{"format":"public-meeting-insights/meeting","format_version":"1.0","meeting_id":"phoenix-city-council/2026-10-07-formal-meeting","status":"published","version":1,"body":{"slug":"phoenix-city-council","name":"Phoenix City Council","city":"Phoenix","state":"AZ"},"meeting":{"date":"2026-10-07","type":"Formal Meeting","type_slug":"formal-meeting","scheduled_time":"2:30 PM","duration_s":7007.668},"notices":{"independence":"An independent project by GOOD|GOAT. Not affiliated with or endorsed by the City of Phoenix.","machine":"Machine transcript, corrected by the public. Not the official record: the City's minutes are.","official_record_url":"https://phoenix.legistar.com/Calendar.aspx"},"licence":{"data":"CC-BY-4.0","attribution":"GOOD|GOAT, Public Meeting Insights (https://goodgoat.net)"},"policy":{"names":"on-record","on_record_window_s":180.0},"agenda":{"system":"legistar","client":"phoenix","event_id":2600,"body_id":138,"body_name":"City Council Formal Meeting","minutes_status":"Tentative","agenda_status":"Final-revised","event_url":"https://phoenix.legistar.com/MeetingDetail.aspx?LEGID=2600&GID=485&G=3F9B5896-D56F-4AD3-85AD-A8E5E58DD74C"},"video":{"platform":"youtube","id":"pqbrBtnsN7U","url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pqbrBtnsN7U","embed_url":"https://www.youtube-nocookie.com/embed/pqbrBtnsN7U","offset_s":880.0,"offset_source":"measured against the video's own captions (12367 matching passages, within 0.03 s)"},"recordings":[{"part":1,"of":1,"source":"speakr_db","source_ref":"part 1 of 1","duration_s":7023.974,"meeting_offset_s":0.0,"content_sha256":"f7cabe546cd28bc7464a2ee569b15166431d2485ca85af041e00f53efb1610ea"}],"speakers":[{"id":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138"},{"id":"harry-sexton","role":"official","name":"Harry Sexton","title":"Police Chaplain","name_basis":"roster: Introduced on the record by the Mayor, e.g. 2026-10-07 L00003: 'Police Chaplain Harry Sexton will provide an invocation'; identified by jthacker (moderator) 2026-10-20. Start date is the first meeting built, not his start"},{"id":"v01","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"kevin-robinson","role":"member","name":"Kevin Robinson","title":"Councilman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138"},{"id":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17"},{"id":"mario-barajas","role":"official","name":"Mario Barajas","title":"Spanish interpreter","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07: 'Mayor Gallego acknowledged the presence of Mario Barajas and Elsie Duarte, Spanish interpreters.' Introduced at each meeting."},{"id":"julie-kriegh","role":"staff","name":"Julie Kriegh","title":"City Attorney","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2022-11-15 (first titled mention); still titled City Attorney 2026-09-09"},{"id":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138"},{"id":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January"},{"id":"v02","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v03","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"debra-stark","role":"member","name":"Debra Stark","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138"},{"id":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138"},{"id":"v04","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v05","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v06","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v07","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v08","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v09","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v10","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v11","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v12","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v13","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v14","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v15","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v16","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v17","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v18","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v19","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v20","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v21","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v22","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v23","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v24","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v25","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null}],"chapters":[{"id":"C001","kind":"opening","agenda_numbers":[],"event_item_ids":[],"title":"Opening","start_line":"L00001","start_s":12.805,"end_s":378.929,"confidence":"high","basis":"start of recording"},{"id":"C002","kind":"section","agenda_numbers":[],"event_item_ids":[65490],"title":"BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS","start_line":"L00078","start_s":378.929,"end_s":516.255,"confidence":"medium","basis":"L00078: title read aloud: \"Item two, boards and commissions, vice mayor.\""},{"id":"C003","kind":"block","agenda_numbers":["3","4","5","6","7","8","9","10","11","12","13","14","15","16"],"event_item_ids":[65498,65506,65501,65500,65496,65495,65504,65502,65503,65493,65505,65497,65499,65494],"title":"Items 3–16 voted together","start_line":"L00101","start_s":516.255,"end_s":542.224,"confidence":"low","basis":"L00101: \"Motion to approve items 3 through 16.\""},{"id":"C004","kind":"block","agenda_numbers":["17","18","19","20","21","22","24","26","27","28","29","30","31","33","34","36","37","38","39","40","41","42","43","44","45","49","50","51","52","53","54","55","56","58","59","60","61","64","66","67","68","69","71","72","73","77","78","79"],"event_item_ids":[65513,65511,65512,65568,65508,65509,65515,65517,65518,65519,65520,65521,65522,65526,65525,65583,65528,65529,65530,65531,65532,65533,65534,65536,65581,65544,65547,65548,65546,65542,65543,65545,65549,65550,65552,65556,65557,65558,65559,65582,65562,65561,65579,65572,65577,65571,65570,65580],"title":"Items 17–79 voted together","start_line":"L00112","start_s":542.224,"end_s":627.97,"confidence":"low","basis":"L00112: \"Motion to approve items 17 through 79 except for the following items 23, 32, 35, 46, 48, 57, 62,\" (exceptions listed; the list may continue on the next line)"},{"id":"C005","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["62"],"event_item_ids":[65554],"title":"Joan Ganz Cooney Way Ceremonial Street Name Signage - District 8","start_line":"L00142","start_s":627.97,"end_s":1018.73,"confidence":"high","basis":"L00142: \"We'll begin with item 62, the Joan Gantz Cooney Way ceremonial street name.\""},{"id":"C006","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["63"],"event_item_ids":[65553],"title":"Mel Martin Mile Ceremonial Street Name Signage - District 1","start_line":"L00215","start_s":1018.73,"end_s":1249.359,"confidence":"high","basis":"L00215: \"Item 63 is the Mel Martin Mile Ceremonial Street name signage.\""},{"id":"C007","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["65"],"event_item_ids":[65555],"title":"Serbian Heritage Way Ceremonial Street Name Signage - District 8","start_line":"L00259","start_s":1249.359,"end_s":1400.437,"confidence":"high","basis":"L00259: \"Next we go to item 65, Serbian Heritage Way Ceremonial Street Name, Vice Mayor.\""},{"id":"C008","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["23"],"event_item_ids":[65510],"title":"Settlement of Claim(s) Jadran v. City of Phoenix","start_line":"L00302","start_s":1400.437,"end_s":1506.88,"confidence":"high","basis":"L00302: \"We next go to item 23, settlement of claim.\""},{"id":"C009","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["25"],"event_item_ids":[65516],"title":"Request to Enter into Partner Site Agreements with Northern Arizona University - Center for Service and Volunteerism, Arizona Health Corps and Environmental Literacy Corps AmeriCorps Programs (Ordinance S-53247) - Citywide","start_line":"L00337","start_s":1506.88,"end_s":1591.744,"confidence":"high","basis":"L00337: \"We next go to item 25, which is an agreement with NAU related to the Center for Service and Volunteerism, Arizona Health Corps, and Environmental Literacy Corps\""},{"id":"C010","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["32"],"event_item_ids":[65523],"title":"Outside Legal Counsel for the City Ethics Commission - Amendment (Ordinance S-53226) - Citywide","start_line":"L00375","start_s":1591.744,"end_s":2602.224,"confidence":"high","basis":"L00375: \"Item 32 is next.\""},{"id":"C011","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["35"],"event_item_ids":[65527],"title":"Request Retroactive Authorization to Apply for, Accept and Enter into an Agreement for Fiscal Year 2027 State Housing Trust Fund Housing Solutions Grant Funds (Ordinance S-53246) - Citywide","start_line":"L00522","start_s":2602.224,"end_s":2742.673,"confidence":"high","basis":"L00522: \"We next go to item 35 related to the State Housing Trust Fund.\""},{"id":"C012","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["46"],"event_item_ids":[65537],"title":"Contract with the Los Angeles Organizing Committee for the 2028 Olympic and Paralympic Games to host Olympic Torch Relay and Related Events (Ordinance S-53249) - Citywide","start_line":"L00551","start_s":2742.673,"end_s":2933.345,"confidence":"high","basis":"L00551: \"Next is item 46, contract with the Los Angeles Organizing Committee for the 2028 Olympic and Paralympic Games to host Olympic torch relay and related events.\""},{"id":"C013","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["47"],"event_item_ids":[65539],"title":"Authorization to Enter into Agreements with the Drug Enforcement Administration for Reimbursement for Police Services (Ordinance S-53229) - Citywide","start_line":"L00595","start_s":2933.345,"end_s":3067.369,"confidence":"high","basis":"L00595: \"Next is item 47, authorization to enter into agreements with the DEA for reimbursement for police services, Vice Mayor.\""},{"id":"C014","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["48"],"event_item_ids":[65540],"title":"CovertTrack Global Positioning Units - RFA-18-017 - Amendment (Ordinance S-53231) - Citywide","start_line":"L00635","start_s":3067.369,"end_s":3631.53,"confidence":"high","basis":"L00635: \"Next is item 48, covert track global positioning system units.\""},{"id":"C015","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["57"],"event_item_ids":[65551],"title":"Backflow Assembly Testing, Repair and Replacement Services - Amendment (Ordinance S-53226) - Citywide","start_line":"L00745","start_s":3631.53,"end_s":3751.409,"confidence":"high","basis":"L00745: \"Item 57 is Backflow Assembly Testing Repair and Replacement Services.\""},{"id":"C016","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["70"],"event_item_ids":[65560],"title":"Water Services Department Water Facilities General Engineering On-Call Service (Ordinance S-53230) - Citywide","start_line":"L00781","start_s":3751.409,"end_s":3821.037,"confidence":"high","basis":"L00781: \"Item 70, Water Services Department Engineering On Call.\""},{"id":"C017","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["74"],"event_item_ids":[65576],"title":"Retroactive Approval to Apply for an Arizona State Historic Preservation Office Certified Local Government Pass-Through Grant for Federal Fiscal Year 2025 - Federal Funding (Ordinance S-53238) - District 6","start_line":"L00811","start_s":3821.037,"end_s":4215.777,"confidence":"high","basis":"L00811: \"Next we go to item 74, retroactive approval to apply for an Arizona State Historic Preservation Office certified local government pass through grant for federal\""},{"id":"C018","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["75"],"event_item_ids":[65574],"title":"Approval of a Phil Gordon Threatened Building Grant - 330 N 18th Avenue - Oakland Historic District (Ordinance S-53240) - District 7","start_line":"L00897","start_s":4215.777,"end_s":4481.67,"confidence":"high","basis":"L00897: \"Item 75 is next, approve of a Phil Gordon threatened building grant for 330 North 18th Avenue in the Oakland Historic District in D7.\""},{"id":"C019","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["76"],"event_item_ids":[65575],"title":"Approval of a Phil Gordon Threatened Building Grant - Leopoldo & Isabel Dominguez House, 927 North 8th Street (Ordinance S-53239) - District 8","start_line":"L00964","start_s":4481.67,"end_s":5159.171,"confidence":"high","basis":"L00964: \"Next up, we have item 76.\""},{"id":"C020","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["000"],"event_item_ids":[65565],"title":"000 CITIZEN COMMENTS","start_line":"L01076","start_s":5159.171,"end_s":null,"confidence":"high","basis":"L01076: city cue: \"During citizen comment, members of the public may speak to the city council for up to three minutes on issues of interest or concern.\""}],"turns":[{"id":"T00001","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00001","last_line":"L00006","start_s":12.805,"end_s":26.086},{"id":"T00002","speaker":"harry-sexton","role":"official","name":"Harry Sexton","title":"Police Chaplain","name_basis":"roster: Introduced on the record by the Mayor, e.g. 2026-10-07 L00003: 'Police Chaplain Harry Sexton will provide an invocation'; identified by jthacker (moderator) 2026-10-20. Start date is the first meeting built, not his start","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00007","last_line":"L00022","start_s":33.698,"end_s":110.532},{"id":"T00003","speaker":"v01","role":"public","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00023","last_line":"L00023","start_s":112.655,"end_s":113.957},{"id":"T00004","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00024","last_line":"L00024","start_s":114.338,"end_s":117.943},{"id":"T00005","speaker":"kevin-robinson","role":"member","name":"Kevin Robinson","title":"Councilman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00025","last_line":"L00025","start_s":117.963,"end_s":122.31},{"id":"T00006","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00026","last_line":"L00029","start_s":127.488,"end_s":147.34},{"id":"T00007","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00030","last_line":"L00030","start_s":148.562,"end_s":149.564},{"id":"T00008","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00031","last_line":"L00031","start_s":149.724,"end_s":149.945},{"id":"T00009","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00032","last_line":"L00032","start_s":150.525,"end_s":151.467},{"id":"T00010","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00033","last_line":"L00033","start_s":152.108,"end_s":152.308},{"id":"T00011","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00034","last_line":"L00035","start_s":152.889,"end_s":165.831},{"id":"T00012","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00036","last_line":"L00037","start_s":169.102,"end_s":173.449},{"id":"T00013","speaker":"mario-barajas","role":"official","name":"Mario Barajas","title":"Spanish interpreter","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07: 'Mayor Gallego acknowledged the presence of Mario Barajas and Elsie Duarte, Spanish interpreters.' Introduced at each meeting.","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00038","last_line":"L00049","start_s":174.031,"end_s":233.55},{"id":"T00014","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00050","last_line":"L00051","start_s":234.104,"end_s":254.621},{"id":"T00015","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00052","last_line":"L00052","start_s":256.123,"end_s":257.944},{"id":"T00016","speaker":"julie-kriegh","role":"staff","name":"Julie Kriegh","title":"City Attorney","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2022-11-15 (first titled mention); still titled City Attorney 2026-09-09","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00053","last_line":"L00065","start_s":258.665,"end_s":312.863},{"id":"T00017","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00066","last_line":"L00071","start_s":313.619,"end_s":366.417},{"id":"T00018","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00072","last_line":"L00073","start_s":366.759,"end_s":372.28},{"id":"T00019","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00074","last_line":"L00077","start_s":373.88,"end_s":378.468},{"id":"T00020","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C002","first_line":"L00078","last_line":"L00078","start_s":378.929,"end_s":380.452},{"id":"T00021","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C002","first_line":"L00079","last_line":"L00080","start_s":381.033,"end_s":385.301},{"id":"T00022","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C002","first_line":"L00081","last_line":"L00092","start_s":385.762,"end_s":452.196},{"id":"T00023","speaker":"v02","role":"public","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C002","first_line":"L00093","last_line":"L00093","start_s":454.342,"end_s":454.964},{"id":"T00024","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C002","first_line":"L00094","last_line":"L00100","start_s":458.212,"end_s":515.374},{"id":"T00025","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C003","first_line":"L00101","last_line":"L00102","start_s":516.255,"end_s":519.6},{"id":"T00026","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C003","first_line":"L00103","last_line":"L00109","start_s":520.782,"end_s":538.88},{"id":"T00027","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C003","first_line":"L00110","last_line":"L00110","start_s":539.32,"end_s":539.701},{"id":"T00028","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C003","first_line":"L00111","last_line":"L00111","start_s":541.122,"end_s":541.583},{"id":"T00029","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C004","first_line":"L00112","last_line":"L00112","start_s":542.224,"end_s":554.698},{"id":"T00030","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C004","first_line":"L00113","last_line":"L00122","start_s":554.965,"end_s":598.501},{"id":"T00031","speaker":"v03","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C004","first_line":"L00123","last_line":"L00123","start_s":598.982,"end_s":599.202},{"id":"T00032","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C004","first_line":"L00124","last_line":"L00124","start_s":599.723,"end_s":600.103},{"id":"T00033","speaker":"debra-stark","role":"member","name":"Debra Stark","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C004","first_line":"L00125","last_line":"L00125","start_s":600.744,"end_s":600.984},{"id":"T00034","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C004","first_line":"L00126","last_line":"L00131","start_s":601.444,"end_s":605.809},{"id":"T00035","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C004","first_line":"L00132","last_line":"L00134","start_s":606.129,"end_s":612.175},{"id":"T00036","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C004","first_line":"L00135","last_line":"L00136","start_s":612.813,"end_s":619.841},{"id":"T00037","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C004","first_line":"L00137","last_line":"L00137","start_s":620.201,"end_s":620.542},{"id":"T00038","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C004","first_line":"L00138","last_line":"L00141","start_s":621.423,"end_s":625.647},{"id":"T00039","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00142","last_line":"L00143","start_s":627.97,"end_s":638.842},{"id":"T00040","speaker":"debra-stark","role":"member","name":"Debra Stark","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00144","last_line":"L00161","start_s":638.862,"end_s":791.32},{"id":"T00041","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00162","last_line":"L00169","start_s":791.485,"end_s":845.705},{"id":"T00042","speaker":"v04","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00170","last_line":"L00190","start_s":847.727,"end_s":968.17},{"id":"T00043","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00191","last_line":"L00197","start_s":969.871,"end_s":1002.472},{"id":"T00044","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00198","last_line":"L00202","start_s":1003.533,"end_s":1006.917},{"id":"T00045","speaker":"v05","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00203","last_line":"L00203","start_s":1009.16,"end_s":1010.141},{"id":"T00046","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00204","last_line":"L00211","start_s":1010.161,"end_s":1015.262},{"id":"T00047","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00212","last_line":"L00214","start_s":1015.903,"end_s":1018.63},{"id":"T00048","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C006","first_line":"L00215","last_line":"L00216","start_s":1018.73,"end_s":1026.169},{"id":"T00049","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C006","first_line":"L00217","last_line":"L00235","start_s":1026.402,"end_s":1182.313},{"id":"T00050","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C006","first_line":"L00236","last_line":"L00240","start_s":1185.297,"end_s":1220.454},{"id":"T00051","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C006","first_line":"L00241","last_line":"L00248","start_s":1230.245,"end_s":1241.021},{"id":"T00052","speaker":"harry-sexton","role":"official","name":"Harry Sexton","title":"Police Chaplain","name_basis":"roster: Introduced on the record by the Mayor, e.g. 2026-10-07 L00003: 'Police Chaplain Harry Sexton will provide an invocation'; identified by jthacker (moderator) 2026-10-20. Start date is the first meeting built, not his start","public_id":null,"chapter":"C006","first_line":"L00249","last_line":"L00249","start_s":1241.201,"end_s":1241.482},{"id":"T00053","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C006","first_line":"L00250","last_line":"L00256","start_s":1241.923,"end_s":1246.273},{"id":"T00054","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C006","first_line":"L00257","last_line":"L00258","start_s":1247.255,"end_s":1248.317},{"id":"T00055","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00259","last_line":"L00259","start_s":1249.359,"end_s":1253.99},{"id":"T00056","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00260","last_line":"L00261","start_s":1254.29,"end_s":1257.217},{"id":"T00057","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00262","last_line":"L00264","start_s":1257.577,"end_s":1259.702},{"id":"T00058","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00265","last_line":"L00274","start_s":1259.75,"end_s":1325.202},{"id":"T00059","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00275","last_line":"L00275","start_s":1326.424,"end_s":1327.827},{"id":"T00060","speaker":"v06","role":"public","name":"Leonard Clark","title":null,"name_basis":"named by a moderator","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00276","last_line":"L00278","start_s":1334.0,"end_s":1353.898},{"id":"T00061","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00279","last_line":"L00284","start_s":1355.549,"end_s":1383.362},{"id":"T00062","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00285","last_line":"L00291","start_s":1384.237,"end_s":1391.662},{"id":"T00063","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00292","last_line":"L00292","start_s":1391.803,"end_s":1392.064},{"id":"T00064","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00293","last_line":"L00299","start_s":1392.525,"end_s":1397.332},{"id":"T00065","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00300","last_line":"L00301","start_s":1397.773,"end_s":1399.396},{"id":"T00066","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C008","first_line":"L00302","last_line":"L00302","start_s":1400.437,"end_s":1403.262},{"id":"T00067","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C008","first_line":"L00303","last_line":"L00305","start_s":1403.943,"end_s":1407.449},{"id":"T00068","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C008","first_line":"L00306","last_line":"L00306","start_s":1408.09,"end_s":1408.872},{"id":"T00069","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C008","first_line":"L00307","last_line":"L00319","start_s":1409.413,"end_s":1491.121},{"id":"T00070","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C008","first_line":"L00320","last_line":"L00326","start_s":1492.022,"end_s":1499.189},{"id":"T00071","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C008","first_line":"L00327","last_line":"L00327","start_s":1499.429,"end_s":1499.67},{"id":"T00072","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C008","first_line":"L00328","last_line":"L00336","start_s":1500.17,"end_s":1506.179},{"id":"T00073","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C009","first_line":"L00337","last_line":"L00338","start_s":1506.88,"end_s":1517.922},{"id":"T00074","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C009","first_line":"L00339","last_line":"L00340","start_s":1518.382,"end_s":1520.727},{"id":"T00075","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C009","first_line":"L00341","last_line":"L00342","start_s":1521.308,"end_s":1522.851},{"id":"T00076","speaker":"v06","role":"public","name":"Leonard Clark","title":null,"name_basis":"named by a moderator","public_id":null,"chapter":"C009","first_line":"L00343","last_line":"L00350","start_s":1527.505,"end_s":1559.872},{"id":"T00077","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C009","first_line":"L00351","last_line":"L00351","start_s":1562.196,"end_s":1563.037},{"id":"T00078","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C009","first_line":"L00352","last_line":"L00366","start_s":1564.619,"end_s":1584.697},{"id":"T00079","speaker":"debra-stark","role":"member","name":"Debra Stark","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C009","first_line":"L00367","last_line":"L00367","start_s":1585.057,"end_s":1585.718},{"id":"T00080","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C009","first_line":"L00368","last_line":"L00371","start_s":1585.738,"end_s":1588.28},{"id":"T00081","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C009","first_line":"L00372","last_line":"L00374","start_s":1588.301,"end_s":1590.002},{"id":"T00082","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00375","last_line":"L00376","start_s":1591.744,"end_s":1594.867},{"id":"T00083","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00377","last_line":"L00378","start_s":1595.588,"end_s":1597.85},{"id":"T00084","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00379","last_line":"L00381","start_s":1598.25,"end_s":1602.855},{"id":"T00085","speaker":"v07","role":"public","name":"Jeremy Thacker","title":null,"name_basis":"named by a moderator","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00382","last_line":"L00407","start_s":1616.588,"end_s":1736.493},{"id":"T00086","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00408","last_line":"L00408","start_s":1739.236,"end_s":1739.897},{"id":"T00087","speaker":"v02","role":"public","name":"Kristin Lisson","title":null,"name_basis":"named by a moderator","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00409","last_line":"L00432","start_s":1745.864,"end_s":1871.006},{"id":"T00088","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00433","last_line":"L00434","start_s":1871.727,"end_s":1874.266},{"id":"T00089","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00435","last_line":"L00437","start_s":1875.129,"end_s":1884.263},{"id":"T00090","speaker":"v08","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00438","last_line":"L00438","start_s":1897.962,"end_s":1925.995},{"id":"T00091","speaker":"v09","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00439","last_line":"L00442","start_s":1928.962,"end_s":1966.309},{"id":"T00092","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00443","last_line":"L00446","start_s":1966.407,"end_s":1981.26},{"id":"T00093","speaker":"v08","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00447","last_line":"L00448","start_s":1983.147,"end_s":2029.708},{"id":"T00094","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00449","last_line":"L00450","start_s":2031.342,"end_s":2035.528},{"id":"T00095","speaker":"v09","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00451","last_line":"L00453","start_s":2040.916,"end_s":2061.265},{"id":"T00096","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00454","last_line":"L00454","start_s":2061.498,"end_s":2080.165},{"id":"T00097","speaker":"v09","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00455","last_line":"L00463","start_s":2082.17,"end_s":2132.06},{"id":"T00098","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00464","last_line":"L00470","start_s":2132.301,"end_s":2233.626},{"id":"T00099","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00471","last_line":"L00471","start_s":2233.994,"end_s":2263.478},{"id":"T00100","speaker":"v09","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00472","last_line":"L00476","start_s":2268.335,"end_s":2310.492},{"id":"T00101","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00477","last_line":"L00477","start_s":2311.754,"end_s":2338.234},{"id":"T00102","speaker":"v09","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00478","last_line":"L00481","start_s":2341.319,"end_s":2369.47},{"id":"T00103","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00482","last_line":"L00482","start_s":2369.77,"end_s":2379.06},{"id":"T00104","speaker":"v08","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00483","last_line":"L00483","start_s":2380.441,"end_s":2389.05},{"id":"T00105","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00484","last_line":"L00484","start_s":2389.251,"end_s":2399.001},{"id":"T00106","speaker":"v08","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00485","last_line":"L00485","start_s":2401.58,"end_s":2427.891},{"id":"T00107","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00486","last_line":"L00486","start_s":2427.871,"end_s":2453.153},{"id":"T00108","speaker":"v08","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00487","last_line":"L00488","start_s":2453.521,"end_s":2459.504},{"id":"T00109","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00489","last_line":"L00489","start_s":2459.524,"end_s":2460.569},{"id":"T00110","speaker":"v08","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00490","last_line":"L00491","start_s":2461.111,"end_s":2483.899},{"id":"T00111","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00492","last_line":"L00492","start_s":2484.335,"end_s":2507.524},{"id":"T00112","speaker":"v09","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00493","last_line":"L00493","start_s":2509.124,"end_s":2529.681},{"id":"T00113","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00494","last_line":"L00494","start_s":2529.83,"end_s":2554.048},{"id":"T00114","speaker":"v08","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00495","last_line":"L00496","start_s":2554.872,"end_s":2565.767},{"id":"T00115","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00497","last_line":"L00502","start_s":2566.028,"end_s":2580.167},{"id":"T00116","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00503","last_line":"L00503","start_s":2580.207,"end_s":2581.169},{"id":"T00117","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00504","last_line":"L00504","start_s":2581.329,"end_s":2581.71},{"id":"T00118","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00505","last_line":"L00511","start_s":2582.431,"end_s":2593.351},{"id":"T00119","speaker":"julie-kriegh","role":"staff","name":"Julie Kriegh","title":"City Attorney","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2022-11-15 (first titled mention); still titled City Attorney 2026-09-09","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00512","last_line":"L00512","start_s":2593.592,"end_s":2593.812},{"id":"T00120","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00513","last_line":"L00521","start_s":2594.413,"end_s":2600.561},{"id":"T00121","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00522","last_line":"L00523","start_s":2602.224,"end_s":2607.311},{"id":"T00122","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00524","last_line":"L00527","start_s":2607.831,"end_s":2613.741},{"id":"T00123","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00528","last_line":"L00528","start_s":2613.781,"end_s":2615.366},{"id":"T00124","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00529","last_line":"L00530","start_s":2615.386,"end_s":2618.477},{"id":"T00125","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00531","last_line":"L00539","start_s":2621.663,"end_s":2730.73},{"id":"T00126","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00540","last_line":"L00546","start_s":2732.498,"end_s":2738.066},{"id":"T00127","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00547","last_line":"L00548","start_s":2738.206,"end_s":2739.248},{"id":"T00128","speaker":"debra-stark","role":"member","name":"Debra Stark","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00549","last_line":"L00549","start_s":2739.689,"end_s":2740.31},{"id":"T00129","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00550","last_line":"L00550","start_s":2740.33,"end_s":2741.071},{"id":"T00130","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C012","first_line":"L00551","last_line":"L00552","start_s":2742.673,"end_s":2752.327},{"id":"T00131","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C012","first_line":"L00553","last_line":"L00554","start_s":2752.868,"end_s":2755.452},{"id":"T00132","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C012","first_line":"L00555","last_line":"L00560","start_s":2757.153,"end_s":2800.322},{"id":"T00133","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C012","first_line":"L00561","last_line":"L00571","start_s":2800.724,"end_s":2852.01},{"id":"T00134","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C012","first_line":"L00572","last_line":"L00573","start_s":2852.834,"end_s":2855.718},{"id":"T00135","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C012","first_line":"L00574","last_line":"L00585","start_s":2856.139,"end_s":2914.973},{"id":"T00136","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C012","first_line":"L00586","last_line":"L00587","start_s":2916.376,"end_s":2917.318},{"id":"T00137","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C012","first_line":"L00588","last_line":"L00593","start_s":2918.12,"end_s":2931.363},{"id":"T00138","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C012","first_line":"L00594","last_line":"L00594","start_s":2931.763,"end_s":2932.304},{"id":"T00139","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C013","first_line":"L00595","last_line":"L00595","start_s":2933.345,"end_s":2941.073},{"id":"T00140","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C013","first_line":"L00596","last_line":"L00597","start_s":2941.534,"end_s":2943.356},{"id":"T00141","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C013","first_line":"L00598","last_line":"L00599","start_s":2944.557,"end_s":2946.139},{"id":"T00142","speaker":"v06","role":"public","name":"Leonard Clark","title":null,"name_basis":"named by a moderator","public_id":null,"chapter":"C013","first_line":"L00600","last_line":"L00615","start_s":2952.869,"end_s":3046.931},{"id":"T00143","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C013","first_line":"L00616","last_line":"L00616","start_s":3048.934,"end_s":3049.294},{"id":"T00144","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C013","first_line":"L00617","last_line":"L00622","start_s":3051.918,"end_s":3056.503},{"id":"T00145","speaker":"v05","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C013","first_line":"L00623","last_line":"L00623","start_s":3058.386,"end_s":3058.746},{"id":"T00146","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C013","first_line":"L00624","last_line":"L00631","start_s":3059.249,"end_s":3064.281},{"id":"T00147","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C013","first_line":"L00632","last_line":"L00632","start_s":3064.662,"end_s":3065.063},{"id":"T00148","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C013","first_line":"L00633","last_line":"L00633","start_s":3065.404,"end_s":3065.604},{"id":"T00149","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C013","first_line":"L00634","last_line":"L00634","start_s":3065.945,"end_s":3066.827},{"id":"T00150","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L00635","last_line":"L00639","start_s":3067.369,"end_s":3076.33},{"id":"T00151","speaker":"v06","role":"public","name":"Leonard Clark","title":null,"name_basis":"named by a moderator","public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L00640","last_line":"L00653","start_s":3080.663,"end_s":3166.036},{"id":"T00152","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L00654","last_line":"L00655","start_s":3167.817,"end_s":3168.938},{"id":"T00153","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L00656","last_line":"L00657","start_s":3171.181,"end_s":3175.465},{"id":"T00154","speaker":"v10","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L00658","last_line":"L00658","start_s":3177.687,"end_s":3183.914},{"id":"T00155","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L00659","last_line":"L00662","start_s":3184.194,"end_s":3214.221},{"id":"T00156","speaker":"v11","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L00663","last_line":"L00668","start_s":3217.431,"end_s":3242.725},{"id":"T00157","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L00669","last_line":"L00675","start_s":3243.226,"end_s":3254.369},{"id":"T00158","speaker":"v12","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L00676","last_line":"L00679","start_s":3254.389,"end_s":3269.975},{"id":"T00159","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L00680","last_line":"L00682","start_s":3270.536,"end_s":3293.815},{"id":"T00160","speaker":"v11","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L00683","last_line":"L00685","start_s":3295.027,"end_s":3323.127},{"id":"T00161","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L00686","last_line":"L00687","start_s":3323.242,"end_s":3334.403},{"id":"T00162","speaker":"v11","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L00688","last_line":"L00691","start_s":3337.469,"end_s":3361.095},{"id":"T00163","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L00692","last_line":"L00699","start_s":3361.531,"end_s":3425.242},{"id":"T00164","speaker":"v12","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L00700","last_line":"L00709","start_s":3425.262,"end_s":3465.332},{"id":"T00165","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L00710","last_line":"L00714","start_s":3465.464,"end_s":3472.622},{"id":"T00166","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L00715","last_line":"L00715","start_s":3474.121,"end_s":3475.183},{"id":"T00167","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L00716","last_line":"L00720","start_s":3475.203,"end_s":3506.47},{"id":"T00168","speaker":"v12","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L00721","last_line":"L00722","start_s":3509.159,"end_s":3515.62},{"id":"T00169","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L00723","last_line":"L00728","start_s":3515.903,"end_s":3560.322},{"id":"T00170","speaker":"v12","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L00729","last_line":"L00729","start_s":3560.943,"end_s":3568.436},{"id":"T00171","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L00730","last_line":"L00732","start_s":3568.676,"end_s":3577.993},{"id":"T00172","speaker":"v12","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L00733","last_line":"L00733","start_s":3578.754,"end_s":3581.719},{"id":"T00173","speaker":"v11","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L00734","last_line":"L00734","start_s":3582.678,"end_s":3594.122},{"id":"T00174","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L00735","last_line":"L00735","start_s":3594.44,"end_s":3623.451},{"id":"T00175","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L00736","last_line":"L00744","start_s":3623.971,"end_s":3630.287},{"id":"T00176","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C015","first_line":"L00745","last_line":"L00746","start_s":3631.53,"end_s":3635.981},{"id":"T00177","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C015","first_line":"L00747","last_line":"L00749","start_s":3636.342,"end_s":3640.292},{"id":"T00178","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C015","first_line":"L00750","last_line":"L00751","start_s":3647.714,"end_s":3654.349},{"id":"T00179","speaker":"v01","role":"public","name":"Tammy Weaver","title":null,"name_basis":"named by a moderator","public_id":null,"chapter":"C015","first_line":"L00752","last_line":"L00761","start_s":3656.152,"end_s":3718.261},{"id":"T00180","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C015","first_line":"L00762","last_line":"L00763","start_s":3720.964,"end_s":3730.596},{"id":"T00181","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C015","first_line":"L00764","last_line":"L00780","start_s":3732.538,"end_s":3746.904},{"id":"T00182","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C016","first_line":"L00781","last_line":"L00782","start_s":3751.409,"end_s":3755.515},{"id":"T00183","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C016","first_line":"L00783","last_line":"L00784","start_s":3757.217,"end_s":3761.463},{"id":"T00184","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C016","first_line":"L00785","last_line":"L00786","start_s":3763.125,"end_s":3764.847},{"id":"T00185","speaker":"v01","role":"public","name":"Tammy Weaver","title":null,"name_basis":"named by a moderator","public_id":null,"chapter":"C016","first_line":"L00787","last_line":"L00792","start_s":3769.113,"end_s":3802.173},{"id":"T00186","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C016","first_line":"L00793","last_line":"L00802","start_s":3802.313,"end_s":3812.405},{"id":"T00187","speaker":"debra-stark","role":"member","name":"Debra Stark","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C016","first_line":"L00803","last_line":"L00803","start_s":3812.786,"end_s":3813.487},{"id":"T00188","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C016","first_line":"L00804","last_line":"L00810","start_s":3813.507,"end_s":3818.593},{"id":"T00189","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C017","first_line":"L00811","last_line":"L00812","start_s":3821.037,"end_s":3831.701},{"id":"T00190","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C017","first_line":"L00813","last_line":"L00814","start_s":3832.242,"end_s":3834.547},{"id":"T00191","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C017","first_line":"L00815","last_line":"L00817","start_s":3835.089,"end_s":3840.16},{"id":"T00192","speaker":"v02","role":"public","name":"Kristin Lisson","title":null,"name_basis":"named by a moderator","public_id":null,"chapter":"C017","first_line":"L00818","last_line":"L00846","start_s":3851.092,"end_s":3983.611},{"id":"T00193","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C017","first_line":"L00847","last_line":"L00847","start_s":3986.015,"end_s":3986.736},{"id":"T00194","speaker":"v07","role":"public","name":"Jeremy Thacker","title":null,"name_basis":"named by a moderator","public_id":null,"chapter":"C017","first_line":"L00848","last_line":"L00864","start_s":3994.985,"end_s":4085.308},{"id":"T00195","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C017","first_line":"L00865","last_line":"L00866","start_s":4087.678,"end_s":4089.285},{"id":"T00196","speaker":"kevin-robinson","role":"member","name":"Kevin Robinson","title":"Councilman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C017","first_line":"L00867","last_line":"L00879","start_s":4090.447,"end_s":4178.537},{"id":"T00197","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C017","first_line":"L00880","last_line":"L00883","start_s":4179.682,"end_s":4194.677},{"id":"T00198","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C017","first_line":"L00884","last_line":"L00889","start_s":4194.977,"end_s":4199.521},{"id":"T00199","speaker":"harry-sexton","role":"official","name":"Harry Sexton","title":"Police Chaplain","name_basis":"roster: Introduced on the record by the Mayor, e.g. 2026-10-07 L00003: 'Police Chaplain Harry Sexton will provide an invocation'; identified by jthacker (moderator) 2026-10-20. Start date is the first meeting built, not his start","public_id":null,"chapter":"C017","first_line":"L00890","last_line":"L00890","start_s":4203.305,"end_s":4203.445},{"id":"T00200","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C017","first_line":"L00891","last_line":"L00891","start_s":4204.686,"end_s":4205.127},{"id":"T00201","speaker":"harry-sexton","role":"official","name":"Harry Sexton","title":"Police Chaplain","name_basis":"roster: Introduced on the record by the Mayor, e.g. 2026-10-07 L00003: 'Police Chaplain Harry Sexton will provide an invocation'; identified by jthacker (moderator) 2026-10-20. Start date is the first meeting built, not his start","public_id":null,"chapter":"C017","first_line":"L00892","last_line":"L00892","start_s":4205.307,"end_s":4205.567},{"id":"T00202","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C017","first_line":"L00893","last_line":"L00894","start_s":4206.028,"end_s":4211.038},{"id":"T00203","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C017","first_line":"L00895","last_line":"L00896","start_s":4212.246,"end_s":4213.857},{"id":"T00204","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C018","first_line":"L00897","last_line":"L00904","start_s":4215.777,"end_s":4242.072},{"id":"T00205","speaker":"v02","role":"public","name":"Kristin Lisson","title":null,"name_basis":"named by a moderator","public_id":null,"chapter":"C018","first_line":"L00905","last_line":"L00923","start_s":4252.987,"end_s":4353.2},{"id":"T00206","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C018","first_line":"L00924","last_line":"L00925","start_s":4353.26,"end_s":4358.244},{"id":"T00207","speaker":"v07","role":"public","name":"Jeremy Thacker","title":null,"name_basis":"named by a moderator","public_id":null,"chapter":"C018","first_line":"L00926","last_line":"L00939","start_s":4359.506,"end_s":4449.022},{"id":"T00208","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C018","first_line":"L00940","last_line":"L00942","start_s":4452.405,"end_s":4455.628},{"id":"T00209","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C018","first_line":"L00943","last_line":"L00943","start_s":4455.648,"end_s":4455.849},{"id":"T00210","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C018","first_line":"L00944","last_line":"L00944","start_s":4457.57,"end_s":4458.291},{"id":"T00211","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C018","first_line":"L00945","last_line":"L00946","start_s":4458.997,"end_s":4461.24},{"id":"T00212","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C018","first_line":"L00947","last_line":"L00948","start_s":4461.26,"end_s":4464.525},{"id":"T00213","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C018","first_line":"L00949","last_line":"L00949","start_s":4464.545,"end_s":4464.926},{"id":"T00214","speaker":"debra-stark","role":"member","name":"Debra Stark","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C018","first_line":"L00950","last_line":"L00950","start_s":4465.567,"end_s":4466.348},{"id":"T00215","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C018","first_line":"L00951","last_line":"L00963","start_s":4466.368,"end_s":4478.225},{"id":"T00216","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C019","first_line":"L00964","last_line":"L00971","start_s":4481.67,"end_s":4515.682},{"id":"T00217","speaker":"v13","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C019","first_line":"L00972","last_line":"L00973","start_s":4531.117,"end_s":4541.367},{"id":"T00218","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C019","first_line":"L00974","last_line":"L00975","start_s":4542.089,"end_s":4545.974},{"id":"T00219","speaker":"v02","role":"public","name":"Kristin Lisson","title":null,"name_basis":"named by a moderator","public_id":null,"chapter":"C019","first_line":"L00976","last_line":"L01000","start_s":4549.979,"end_s":4666.83},{"id":"T00220","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C019","first_line":"L01001","last_line":"L01002","start_s":4667.33,"end_s":4670.935},{"id":"T00221","speaker":"v07","role":"public","name":"Jeremy Thacker","title":null,"name_basis":"named by a moderator","public_id":null,"chapter":"C019","first_line":"L01003","last_line":"L01020","start_s":4672.557,"end_s":4748.709},{"id":"T00222","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C019","first_line":"L01021","last_line":"L01026","start_s":4749.39,"end_s":4797.192},{"id":"T00223","speaker":"v14","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C019","first_line":"L01027","last_line":"L01034","start_s":4800.192,"end_s":4909.393},{"id":"T00224","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C019","first_line":"L01035","last_line":"L01036","start_s":4910.639,"end_s":4951.429},{"id":"T00225","speaker":"v14","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C019","first_line":"L01037","last_line":"L01040","start_s":4951.882,"end_s":5026.378},{"id":"T00226","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C019","first_line":"L01041","last_line":"L01042","start_s":5026.398,"end_s":5031.269},{"id":"T00227","speaker":"debra-stark","role":"member","name":"Debra Stark","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C019","first_line":"L01043","last_line":"L01044","start_s":5031.79,"end_s":5042.352},{"id":"T00228","speaker":"v14","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C019","first_line":"L01045","last_line":"L01050","start_s":5042.905,"end_s":5096.419},{"id":"T00229","speaker":"debra-stark","role":"member","name":"Debra Stark","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C019","first_line":"L01051","last_line":"L01051","start_s":5097.412,"end_s":5105.52},{"id":"T00230","speaker":"v14","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C019","first_line":"L01052","last_line":"L01054","start_s":5105.74,"end_s":5116.812},{"id":"T00231","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C019","first_line":"L01055","last_line":"L01058","start_s":5118.393,"end_s":5126.001},{"id":"T00232","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C019","first_line":"L01059","last_line":"L01059","start_s":5126.723,"end_s":5128.125},{"id":"T00233","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C019","first_line":"L01060","last_line":"L01060","start_s":5128.145,"end_s":5128.365},{"id":"T00234","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C019","first_line":"L01061","last_line":"L01065","start_s":5129.146,"end_s":5134.493},{"id":"T00235","speaker":"debra-stark","role":"member","name":"Debra Stark","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C019","first_line":"L01066","last_line":"L01066","start_s":5134.734,"end_s":5134.974},{"id":"T00236","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C019","first_line":"L01067","last_line":"L01067","start_s":5135.515,"end_s":5136.095},{"id":"T00237","speaker":"debra-stark","role":"member","name":"Debra Stark","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C019","first_line":"L01068","last_line":"L01068","start_s":5136.115,"end_s":5136.376},{"id":"T00238","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C019","first_line":"L01069","last_line":"L01072","start_s":5137.057,"end_s":5142.324},{"id":"T00239","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C019","first_line":"L01073","last_line":"L01074","start_s":5149.653,"end_s":5157.585},{"id":"T00240","speaker":"julie-kriegh","role":"staff","name":"Julie Kriegh","title":"City Attorney","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2022-11-15 (first titled mention); still titled City Attorney 2026-09-09","public_id":null,"chapter":"C019","first_line":"L01075","last_line":"L01075","start_s":5158.228,"end_s":5158.629},{"id":"T00241","speaker":"julie-kriegh","role":"staff","name":"Julie Kriegh","title":"City Attorney","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2022-11-15 (first titled mention); still titled City Attorney 2026-09-09","public_id":null,"chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01076","last_line":"L01081","start_s":5159.171,"end_s":5185.697},{"id":"T00242","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01082","last_line":"L01083","start_s":5187.499,"end_s":5193.805},{"id":"T00243","speaker":"v15","role":"public","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":"pc-000-001","chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01084","last_line":"L01093","start_s":5209.428,"end_s":5281.05},{"id":"T00244","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01094","last_line":"L01095","start_s":5283.953,"end_s":5289.199},{"id":"T00245","speaker":"v03","role":"public","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":"pc-000-002","chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01096","last_line":"L01108","start_s":5290.073,"end_s":5388.041},{"id":"T00246","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01109","last_line":"L01111","start_s":5389.224,"end_s":5408.59},{"id":"T00247","speaker":"v16","role":"public","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":"pc-000-003","chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01112","last_line":"L01130","start_s":5413.055,"end_s":5529.668},{"id":"T00248","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01131","last_line":"L01133","start_s":5530.424,"end_s":5554.39},{"id":"T00249","speaker":"v17","role":"public","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":"pc-000-004","chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01134","last_line":"L01139","start_s":5562.588,"end_s":5609.132},{"id":"T00250","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01140","last_line":"L01141","start_s":5611.863,"end_s":5618.932},{"id":"T00251","speaker":"v18","role":"public","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":"pc-000-005","chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01142","last_line":"L01142","start_s":5628.824,"end_s":5631.187},{"id":"T00252","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01143","last_line":"L01143","start_s":5631.827,"end_s":5632.528},{"id":"T00253","speaker":"v18","role":"public","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":"pc-000-005","chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01144","last_line":"L01153","start_s":5632.969,"end_s":5686.951},{"id":"T00254","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01154","last_line":"L01155","start_s":5687.732,"end_s":5693.558},{"id":"T00255","speaker":"v19","role":"public","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":"pc-000-006","chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01156","last_line":"L01181","start_s":5704.979,"end_s":5886.716},{"id":"T00256","speaker":"debra-stark","role":"member","name":"Debra Stark","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01182","last_line":"L01183","start_s":5887.297,"end_s":5891.502},{"id":"T00257","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01184","last_line":"L01184","start_s":5895.886,"end_s":5900.17},{"id":"T00258","speaker":"v20","role":"public","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":"pc-000-007","chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01185","last_line":"L01233","start_s":5906.777,"end_s":6062.715},{"id":"T00259","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01234","last_line":"L01234","start_s":6073.883,"end_s":6075.766},{"id":"T00260","speaker":"v21","role":"public","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":"pc-000-008","chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01235","last_line":"L01247","start_s":6078.169,"end_s":6147.664},{"id":"T00261","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01248","last_line":"L01249","start_s":6148.724,"end_s":6154.684},{"id":"T00262","speaker":"v22","role":"public","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":"pc-000-009","chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01250","last_line":"L01282","start_s":6163.186,"end_s":6346.165},{"id":"T00263","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01283","last_line":"L01284","start_s":6347.107,"end_s":6351.713},{"id":"T00264","speaker":"v23","role":"public","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":"pc-000-010","chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01285","last_line":"L01300","start_s":6357.12,"end_s":6436.615},{"id":"T00265","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01301","last_line":"L01302","start_s":6436.763,"end_s":6440.967},{"id":"T00266","speaker":"v24","role":"public","name":"Jerry Van Gasse","title":null,"name_basis":"named by a moderator","public_id":"pc-000-011","chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01303","last_line":"L01321","start_s":6447.434,"end_s":6607.002},{"id":"T00267","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01322","last_line":"L01323","start_s":6609.192,"end_s":6617.001},{"id":"T00268","speaker":"v07","role":"public","name":"Jeremy Thacker","title":null,"name_basis":"named by a moderator","public_id":"pc-000-012","chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01324","last_line":"L01361","start_s":6622.929,"end_s":6800.912},{"id":"T00269","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01362","last_line":"L01365","start_s":6802.411,"end_s":6813.726},{"id":"T00270","speaker":"v25","role":"public","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":"pc-000-013","chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01366","last_line":"L01368","start_s":6817.271,"end_s":6833.215},{"id":"T00271","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01369","last_line":"L01371","start_s":6836.9,"end_s":6842.266},{"id":"T00272","speaker":"v06","role":"public","name":"Leonard Clark","title":null,"name_basis":"named by a moderator","public_id":"pc-000-014","chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01372","last_line":"L01381","start_s":6848.713,"end_s":6968.987},{"id":"T00273","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01382","last_line":"L01382","start_s":6969.423,"end_s":6994.62},{"id":"T00274","speaker":"v05","role":"public","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":"pc-000-015","chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01383","last_line":"L01385","start_s":7004.219,"end_s":7020.473}],"lines":[{"id":"L00001","start_s":12.805,"end_s":13.386,"video_s":892.805,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00001","chapter":"C001","text":"Good afternoon.","fingerprint":"f01e727e7b79","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00002","start_s":13.406,"end_s":14.508,"video_s":893.406,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00001","chapter":"C001","text":"Thank you for joining us.","fingerprint":"d05900a28222","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00003","start_s":15.089,"end_s":20.016,"video_s":895.089,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00001","chapter":"C001","text":"Police Chaplain Harry Sexton will provide an invocation in keeping with the tradition of a legislative prayer for the council.","fingerprint":"4b91744f5d11","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00004","start_s":20.497,"end_s":22.38,"video_s":900.497,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00001","chapter":"C001","text":"Participation is entirely voluntary.","fingerprint":"97fff558758c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00005","start_s":22.42,"end_s":24.964,"video_s":902.42,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00001","chapter":"C001","text":"Anyone may step outside or remain seated.","fingerprint":"d834644087cf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00006","start_s":25.324,"end_s":26.086,"video_s":905.324,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00001","chapter":"C001","text":"Chaplain Sexton.","fingerprint":"22cadf400716","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00007","start_s":33.698,"end_s":37.243,"video_s":913.698,"speaker":"harry-sexton","turn":"T00002","chapter":"C001","text":"Madam Mayor, honorable council members, ladies and gentlemen,","fingerprint":"48086aa27666","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00008","start_s":38.168,"end_s":45.335,"video_s":918.168,"speaker":"harry-sexton","turn":"T00002","chapter":"C001","text":"My prayer today is based upon 1 Samuel 2, verses 1 and 2, which reads, My heart rejoices in the Lord.","fingerprint":"00f1b7131e6a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00009","start_s":45.375,"end_s":47.297,"video_s":925.375,"speaker":"harry-sexton","turn":"T00002","chapter":"C001","text":"My horn is lifted up by the Lord.","fingerprint":"15c98bf7c134","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00010","start_s":47.838,"end_s":52.222,"video_s":927.838,"speaker":"harry-sexton","turn":"T00002","chapter":"C001","text":"My mouth boasts over my enemies because I rejoice in your salvation.","fingerprint":"a9b21864f39a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00011","start_s":53.003,"end_s":54.745,"video_s":933.003,"speaker":"harry-sexton","turn":"T00002","chapter":"C001","text":"There is no one holy like the Lord.","fingerprint":"974fae1dee18","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00012","start_s":55.005,"end_s":56.267,"video_s":935.005,"speaker":"harry-sexton","turn":"T00002","chapter":"C001","text":"There is no one beside you.","fingerprint":"6b6ebadf76a9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00013","start_s":56.967,"end_s":59.09,"video_s":936.967,"speaker":"harry-sexton","turn":"T00002","chapter":"C001","text":"And there is no rock like our God.","fingerprint":"06f599f2c134","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00014","start_s":59.33,"end_s":59.95,"video_s":939.33,"speaker":"harry-sexton","turn":"T00002","chapter":"C001","text":"Let us pray.","fingerprint":"cbc716bdc78e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00015","start_s":61.472,"end_s":67.298,"video_s":941.472,"speaker":"harry-sexton","turn":"T00002","chapter":"C001","text":"O God, our Father, our hearts do rejoice in the honor that you have bestowed upon us to enter your presence.","fingerprint":"0a25f779a719","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00016","start_s":68.425,"end_s":72.909,"video_s":948.425,"speaker":"harry-sexton","turn":"T00002","chapter":"C001","text":"We are truly grateful for all that your loving mercy has brought upon this place.","fingerprint":"bf7217182666","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00017","start_s":73.329,"end_s":84.279,"video_s":953.329,"speaker":"harry-sexton","turn":"T00002","chapter":"C001","text":"We thank you for the wisdom that you have imparted to this council, and we ask that you continue to pour forth your wisdom as they seek to take care of all that has been entrusted to their care.","fingerprint":"13fe7bee4115","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00018","start_s":85.581,"end_s":93.568,"video_s":965.581,"speaker":"harry-sexton","turn":"T00002","chapter":"C001","text":"Father, bless all those who work here at the City of Phoenix as they work for the safety, security, and well-being of their fellow people.","fingerprint":"233f47b5c192","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00019","start_s":94.869,"end_s":98.112,"video_s":974.869,"speaker":"harry-sexton","turn":"T00002","chapter":"C001","text":"Endow them with the strength to do what needs to be done","fingerprint":"987764165c9d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00020","start_s":98.513,"end_s":103.1,"video_s":978.513,"speaker":"harry-sexton","turn":"T00002","chapter":"C001","text":"so that this section of the earth may flourish under their care.","fingerprint":"eb59b93068ae","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00021","start_s":104.362,"end_s":109.51,"video_s":984.362,"speaker":"harry-sexton","turn":"T00002","chapter":"C001","text":"Father, we humbly come before you with both our petitions and our praise.","fingerprint":"f0c42512257d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00022","start_s":110.211,"end_s":110.532,"video_s":990.211,"speaker":"harry-sexton","turn":"T00002","chapter":"C001","text":"Amen.","fingerprint":"9fdea7d457b5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00023","start_s":112.655,"end_s":113.957,"video_s":992.655,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00003","chapter":"C001","text":"Thank you, Chaplain Sexton.","fingerprint":"2f38255f8fdb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00024","start_s":114.338,"end_s":117.943,"video_s":994.338,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00004","chapter":"C001","text":"I will now ask Councilman Robinson to lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance.","fingerprint":"68f34088381a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00025","start_s":117.963,"end_s":122.31,"video_s":997.963,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00005","chapter":"C001","text":"I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America,","fingerprint":"b534f39e5e90","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00026","start_s":127.488,"end_s":141.791,"video_s":1007.488,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00006","chapter":"C001","text":"Thank you, Councilman Robinson and Chaplain Sexton.","fingerprint":"1f22a5939589","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00027","start_s":141.851,"end_s":144.476,"video_s":1021.851,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00006","chapter":"C001","text":"I'll now call to order the meeting of the Phoenix City Council.","fingerprint":"08edecee7c11","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00028","start_s":144.836,"end_s":145.738,"video_s":1024.836,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00006","chapter":"C001","text":"Will the clerk call the roll?","fingerprint":"89bb0df24607","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00029","start_s":146.479,"end_s":147.34,"video_s":1026.479,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00006","chapter":"C001","text":"Councilwoman Guardado.","fingerprint":"725cada514c9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00030","start_s":148.562,"end_s":149.564,"video_s":1028.562,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00007","chapter":"C001","text":"Councilwoman Hernandez.","fingerprint":"be943e39201c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00031","start_s":149.724,"end_s":149.945,"video_s":1029.724,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00008","chapter":"C001","text":"Here.","fingerprint":"fcec91509759","evidence":[{"kind":"agenda-record","source":"roll call on 'CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL'","recorded":"Present","result":"matches"}],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00032","start_s":150.525,"end_s":151.467,"video_s":1030.525,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00009","chapter":"C001","text":"Councilwoman O'Brien.","fingerprint":"003ed429bc6f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00033","start_s":152.108,"end_s":152.308,"video_s":1032.108,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00010","chapter":"C001","text":"Here.","fingerprint":"fcec91509759","evidence":[{"kind":"agenda-record","source":"roll call on 'CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL'","recorded":"Present","result":"matches"}],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00034","start_s":152.889,"end_s":153.951,"video_s":1032.889,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00011","chapter":"C001","text":"Councilwoman Pastor.","fingerprint":"dbcef12e9415","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00035","start_s":155.686,"end_s":165.831,"video_s":1035.686,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00011","chapter":"C001","text":"Councilman Robinson, Councilwoman Stark, Councilman Waring, Vice Mayor Hodge Washington, Mayor Gallego.","fingerprint":"fa1baa0e891c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00036","start_s":169.102,"end_s":172.287,"video_s":1049.102,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00012","chapter":"C001","text":"Mario Barajas and Elsie Duarte are with us to provide Spanish interpretation.","fingerprint":"3fe98f436d96","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00037","start_s":172.388,"end_s":173.449,"video_s":1052.388,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00012","chapter":"C001","text":"Mario, would you introduce your team?","fingerprint":"f1c3c980359f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00038","start_s":174.031,"end_s":174.511,"video_s":1054.031,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00013","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes, Mayor.","fingerprint":"f16b9e8eb094","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00039","start_s":174.531,"end_s":174.912,"video_s":1054.531,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00013","chapter":"C001","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00040","start_s":175.533,"end_s":176.134,"video_s":1055.533,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00013","chapter":"C001","text":"Good afternoon.","fingerprint":"f01e727e7b79","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00041","start_s":176.254,"end_s":178.498,"video_s":1056.254,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00013","chapter":"C001","text":"As I already mentioned, my name is Mario Barajas.","fingerprint":"9eccd721dd83","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00042","start_s":178.518,"end_s":182.225,"video_s":1058.518,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00013","chapter":"C001","text":"I'll be working today with Elsie Duarte as Spanish interpreters.","fingerprint":"57f75acd6bc7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00043","start_s":182.846,"end_s":187.093,"video_s":1062.846,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00013","chapter":"C001","text":"I'll now take a moment to introduce ourselves to our Spanish speaking residents.","fingerprint":"20cc63988a7b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00044","start_s":187.073,"end_s":194.806,"video_s":1067.073,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00013","chapter":"C001","text":"Buenas tardes, yo soy Mario Barajas y voy a estar trabajando hoy con Elsie Duarte como intérpretes a los de habla hispana.","fingerprint":"00b0db19e245","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"language","detail":"Spanish speech, transcribed as said"}]},{"id":"L00045","start_s":194.846,"end_s":204.982,"video_s":1074.846,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00013","chapter":"C001","text":"Primeramente, quisiéramos repasar un par de pautas que podrá beneficiarles a ustedes para que podamos interpretarles de la mejor manera posible.","fingerprint":"64d47a2ae4ea","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"possible-translation","detail":"this speaker also spoke Spanish here; this English line may be a machine translation, not their words"}]},{"id":"L00046","start_s":205.563,"end_s":210.972,"video_s":1085.563,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00013","chapter":"C001","text":"Primeramente, se les sugiere que, si acaso van a estar dando un comentario público,","fingerprint":"f100cd38eaec","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"language","detail":"Spanish speech, transcribed as said"}]},{"id":"L00047","start_s":210.952,"end_s":218.224,"video_s":1090.952,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00013","chapter":"C001","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"possible-translation","detail":"this speaker also spoke Spanish here; this English line may be a machine translation, not their words"}]},{"id":"L00048","start_s":218.685,"end_s":222.171,"video_s":1098.685,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00013","chapter":"C001","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"possible-translation","detail":"this speaker also spoke Spanish here; this English line may be a machine translation, not their words"}]},{"id":"L00049","start_s":222.932,"end_s":233.55,"video_s":1102.932,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00013","chapter":"C001","text":"Will the City Clerk read the 24-hour paragraph?","fingerprint":"a89968a90ab6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00050","start_s":234.104,"end_s":242.031,"video_s":1114.104,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00014","chapter":"C001","text":"the titles of the following ordinance and resolution numbers on the agenda were available to the public at least 24 hours prior to this council meeting and therefore may be read by title or agenda item only.","fingerprint":"1563ae4bf111","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00051","start_s":242.391,"end_s":254.621,"video_s":1122.391,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00014","chapter":"C001","text":"Ordinances number G7549 through 7551, S53190 and 53225 through 53252 and resolutions 22396 through 22397.","fingerprint":"06bfa6cc7173","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00052","start_s":256.123,"end_s":257.944,"video_s":1136.123,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00015","chapter":"C001","text":"Will the city attorney explain the role of public comment?","fingerprint":"0492d3ec79fa","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00053","start_s":258.665,"end_s":259.365,"video_s":1138.665,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00016","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes, thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"810f7bb9ebdf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00054","start_s":259.806,"end_s":263.689,"video_s":1139.806,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00016","chapter":"C001","text":"Members of the public may speak for up to two minutes to comment on agenda items.","fingerprint":"fc6d2876d22d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00055","start_s":263.821,"end_s":267.949,"video_s":1143.821,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00016","chapter":"C001","text":"Comments must be related to the agenda item in the action being considered by the council.","fingerprint":"07b1dc1378a3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00056","start_s":268.47,"end_s":274.621,"video_s":1148.47,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00016","chapter":"C001","text":"General comments that go beyond the scope of the agenda item should be made during the citizen comment session at the end of the agenda.","fingerprint":"59d83a08d310","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00057","start_s":275.102,"end_s":281.374,"video_s":1155.102,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00016","chapter":"C001","text":"The city council and staff cannot discuss or comment on matters related to pending investigations, claims, or litigation.","fingerprint":"cd361cdf5e3c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00058","start_s":281.894,"end_s":287.044,"video_s":1161.894,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00016","chapter":"C001","text":"Additionally, any member of the public who appears before the council in their capacity as a lobbyist","fingerprint":"5641ace27465","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00059","start_s":287.024,"end_s":291.351,"video_s":1167.024,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00016","chapter":"C001","text":"must, as required by Phoenix City Code, disclose this fact before addressing the Council.","fingerprint":"ad3e381cf44b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00060","start_s":292.072,"end_s":296.338,"video_s":1172.072,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00016","chapter":"C001","text":"The City Code states that speakers must express their comments respectfully and courteously.","fingerprint":"bc64226bce55","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00061","start_s":296.378,"end_s":302.167,"video_s":1176.378,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00016","chapter":"C001","text":"Use of profane language, threats, or personal attacks on members of the public, Council members, or staff are not allowed.","fingerprint":"8b37bacb6b7f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00062","start_s":302.768,"end_s":305.832,"video_s":1182.768,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00016","chapter":"C001","text":"Such comments are disruptive and unrelated to the Council's business.","fingerprint":"77ffc08a1538","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00063","start_s":306.373,"end_s":310.379,"video_s":1186.373,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00016","chapter":"C001","text":"Any person who violates these rules may lose their opportunity to speak further and could be asked to leave.","fingerprint":"a37c4a3765dc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00064","start_s":310.459,"end_s":311.02,"video_s":1190.459,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00016","chapter":"C001","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00065","start_s":311.501,"end_s":312.863,"video_s":1191.501,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00016","chapter":"C001","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00066","start_s":313.619,"end_s":320.738,"video_s":1193.619,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00017","chapter":"C001","text":"Before we begin the approval of the meeting minutes, we have an important retirement of our retirement administrator this week.","fingerprint":"f58b0abe18a4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00067","start_s":320.758,"end_s":322.543,"video_s":1200.758,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00017","chapter":"C001","text":"If Scott could please stand up.","fingerprint":"30205ff7bdda","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00068","start_s":323.406,"end_s":329.502,"video_s":1203.406,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00017","chapter":"C001","text":"Nearly 32 years of service, including with the-","fingerprint":"01922df12aad","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00069","start_s":335.978,"end_s":353.802,"video_s":1215.978,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00017","chapter":"C001","text":"several positions at the city including roles in police city manager's office city clerk's office and retirement we are so thankful that among other things so many people have been able to retire thanks to your excellent good work on our behalf and we wish you an incredible retirement well deserved thank you for your service","fingerprint":"162925de95fa","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00070","start_s":362.0,"end_s":365.012,"video_s":1242.0,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00017","chapter":"C001","text":"And now we go to item number one, approval of the meeting minutes.","fingerprint":"2b548668da52","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00071","start_s":365.072,"end_s":366.417,"video_s":1245.072,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00017","chapter":"C001","text":"Councilwoman Hernandez, do you have a motion?","fingerprint":"0b7d35e9c027","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00072","start_s":366.759,"end_s":367.281,"video_s":1246.759,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00018","chapter":"C001","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00073","start_s":367.481,"end_s":372.28,"video_s":1247.481,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00018","chapter":"C001","text":"I move to approve the minutes of the formal meeting on December 17, 2025.","fingerprint":"3c943c854d2c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00074","start_s":373.88,"end_s":374.902,"video_s":1253.88,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00019","chapter":"C001","text":"All those in favor say aye.","fingerprint":"a4221bb84d8e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00075","start_s":375.283,"end_s":375.964,"video_s":1255.283,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00019","chapter":"C001","text":"Aye.","fingerprint":"4707c4fdc04e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00076","start_s":375.984,"end_s":376.705,"video_s":1255.984,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00019","chapter":"C001","text":"Any opposed nay?","fingerprint":"f7daaedf3626","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00077","start_s":377.567,"end_s":378.468,"video_s":1257.567,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00019","chapter":"C001","text":"Passes unanimously.","fingerprint":"a967da129bf4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00078","start_s":378.929,"end_s":380.452,"video_s":1258.929,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00020","chapter":"C002","text":"Item two, boards and commissions, vice mayor.","fingerprint":"0c1fce4736de","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00079","start_s":381.033,"end_s":384.6,"video_s":1261.033,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00021","chapter":"C002","text":"Motion to approve the mayor and city council boards and commission nominations.","fingerprint":"d057834a5c5c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00080","start_s":384.94,"end_s":385.301,"video_s":1264.94,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00021","chapter":"C002","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00081","start_s":385.762,"end_s":387.205,"video_s":1265.762,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00022","chapter":"C002","text":"We have a motion and a second.","fingerprint":"7451ba811637","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00082","start_s":387.245,"end_s":388.487,"video_s":1267.245,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00022","chapter":"C002","text":"All those in favor, please say aye.","fingerprint":"80a7b6856cc0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00083","start_s":389.108,"end_s":389.188,"video_s":1269.108,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00022","chapter":"C002","text":"Aye.","fingerprint":"4707c4fdc04e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00084","start_s":389.529,"end_s":390.23,"video_s":1269.529,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00022","chapter":"C002","text":"Any opposed nay?","fingerprint":"f7daaedf3626","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00085","start_s":390.491,"end_s":391.192,"video_s":1270.491,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00022","chapter":"C002","text":"Aye.","fingerprint":"4707c4fdc04e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00086","start_s":391.212,"end_s":392.094,"video_s":1271.212,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00022","chapter":"C002","text":"Passes unanimously.","fingerprint":"a967da129bf4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00087","start_s":392.114,"end_s":394.238,"video_s":1272.114,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00022","chapter":"C002","text":"We will now conduct a swearing in ceremony.","fingerprint":"087de52cb841","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00088","start_s":394.258,"end_s":397.744,"video_s":1274.258,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00022","chapter":"C002","text":"Congratulations to our commissioners on your unanimous approval.","fingerprint":"a282084be768","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00089","start_s":419.189,"end_s":420.03,"video_s":1299.189,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00022","chapter":"C002","text":"Please raise your right hand.","fingerprint":"a5659d528c68","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00090","start_s":421.352,"end_s":422.033,"video_s":1301.352,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00022","chapter":"C002","text":"I state your name.","fingerprint":"2c5eb3b50815","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00091","start_s":424.456,"end_s":448.926,"video_s":1304.456,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00022","chapter":"C002","text":"Do solemnly swear that I will support the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution of the laws of the state of Arizona, that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same and defend them against all enemies, foreign and domestic, and that I will faithfully and impartially","fingerprint":"a1cc40529424","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00092","start_s":451.133,"end_s":452.196,"video_s":1331.133,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00022","chapter":"C002","text":"Discharge the duties of?","fingerprint":"6bcf75b38307","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00093","start_s":454.342,"end_s":454.964,"video_s":1334.342,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00023","chapter":"C002","text":"State your office.","fingerprint":"eaca3f35de5e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00094","start_s":458.212,"end_s":459.195,"video_s":1338.212,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00024","chapter":"C002","text":"According to the best of my ability.","fingerprint":"9b029dfa7161","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00095","start_s":461.221,"end_s":461.782,"video_s":1341.221,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00024","chapter":"C002","text":"So help me God.","fingerprint":"856b3c045092","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00096","start_s":462.604,"end_s":465.733,"video_s":1342.604,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00024","chapter":"C002","text":"Congratulations and thank you for serving our city yet again.","fingerprint":"ad209e62b44a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00097","start_s":498.13,"end_s":503.197,"video_s":1378.13,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00024","chapter":"C002","text":"We're excited to thank our commissioners who are serving on Arts and Culture and the Development Advisory Board.","fingerprint":"6aa95231b132","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00098","start_s":503.277,"end_s":508.184,"video_s":1383.277,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00024","chapter":"C002","text":"Again, congratulations and thank you for serving our city.","fingerprint":"d8e45265484c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00099","start_s":509.666,"end_s":514.713,"video_s":1389.666,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00024","chapter":"C002","text":"We provide an advisory role to the state of Arizona on liquor licenses and we'll turn to that portion of our agenda next.","fingerprint":"537d4556277b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00100","start_s":514.853,"end_s":515.374,"video_s":1394.853,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00024","chapter":"C002","text":"Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"9a95bf6095c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00101","start_s":516.255,"end_s":518.879,"video_s":1396.255,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00025","chapter":"C003","text":"Motion to approve items 3 through 16.","fingerprint":"c8fc8b1e6d79","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00102","start_s":519.219,"end_s":519.6,"video_s":1399.219,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00025","chapter":"C003","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00103","start_s":520.782,"end_s":521.563,"video_s":1400.782,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00026","chapter":"C003","text":"Motion and a second.","fingerprint":"9b5eb76aa224","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00104","start_s":521.623,"end_s":522.844,"video_s":1401.623,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00026","chapter":"C003","text":"All those in favor say aye.","fingerprint":"a4221bb84d8e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00105","start_s":523.545,"end_s":523.625,"video_s":1403.545,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00026","chapter":"C003","text":"Aye.","fingerprint":"4707c4fdc04e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00106","start_s":523.966,"end_s":524.587,"video_s":1403.966,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00026","chapter":"C003","text":"Any opposed?","fingerprint":"912fd592ea04","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00107","start_s":526.089,"end_s":527.631,"video_s":1406.089,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00026","chapter":"C003","text":"Passes unanimously.","fingerprint":"a967da129bf4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00108","start_s":527.847,"end_s":535.796,"video_s":1407.847,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00026","chapter":"C003","text":"included today were several special events and Cosina Madrigal.","fingerprint":"b39ec6823102","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00109","start_s":535.816,"end_s":538.88,"video_s":1415.816,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00026","chapter":"C003","text":"City Clerk, are you ready for ordinances, resolution, new business planning and zoning?","fingerprint":"b20e05e08edf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00110","start_s":539.32,"end_s":539.701,"video_s":1419.32,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00027","chapter":"C003","text":"Yes, Mayor.","fingerprint":"f16b9e8eb094","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00111","start_s":541.122,"end_s":541.583,"video_s":1421.122,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00028","chapter":"C003","text":"Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"9a95bf6095c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00112","start_s":542.224,"end_s":554.698,"video_s":1422.224,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00029","chapter":"C004","text":"Motion to approve items 17 through 79 except for the following items 23, 32, 35, 46, 48, 57, 62,","fingerprint":"7f218515c3fa","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00113","start_s":554.965,"end_s":584.044,"video_s":1434.965,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00030","chapter":"C004","text":"63 70 and 74 noting that item 41 is withdrawn and item 47 is as revised and can the clerk confirm if there are any other items that should be excluded for in-person public comments yes mayor and vice mayor also excluding items 25 47 65 75 and 76 that's items 25 47 65 75 and 76 second","fingerprint":"82e5d9eb4dea","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00114","start_s":584.868,"end_s":587.23,"video_s":1464.868,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00030","chapter":"C004","text":"We have a motion and a second.","fingerprint":"7451ba811637","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00115","start_s":587.931,"end_s":589.853,"video_s":1467.931,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00030","chapter":"C004","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00116","start_s":589.873,"end_s":590.373,"video_s":1469.873,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00030","chapter":"C004","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00117","start_s":591.074,"end_s":591.755,"video_s":1471.074,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00030","chapter":"C004","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00118","start_s":591.775,"end_s":592.235,"video_s":1471.775,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00030","chapter":"C004","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00119","start_s":592.636,"end_s":592.916,"video_s":1472.636,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00030","chapter":"C004","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00120","start_s":593.376,"end_s":593.877,"video_s":1473.376,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00030","chapter":"C004","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00121","start_s":596.92,"end_s":597.961,"video_s":1476.92,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00030","chapter":"C004","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00122","start_s":597.981,"end_s":598.501,"video_s":1477.981,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00030","chapter":"C004","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00123","start_s":598.982,"end_s":599.202,"video_s":1478.982,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00031","chapter":"C004","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00124","start_s":599.723,"end_s":600.103,"video_s":1479.723,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00032","chapter":"C004","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00125","start_s":600.744,"end_s":600.984,"video_s":1480.744,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00033","chapter":"C004","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00126","start_s":601.444,"end_s":601.805,"video_s":1481.444,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00034","chapter":"C004","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00127","start_s":602.566,"end_s":602.646,"video_s":1482.566,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00034","chapter":"C004","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00128","start_s":602.666,"end_s":603.326,"video_s":1482.666,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00034","chapter":"C004","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00129","start_s":603.506,"end_s":603.767,"video_s":1483.506,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00034","chapter":"C004","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00130","start_s":604.207,"end_s":605.548,"video_s":1484.207,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00034","chapter":"C004","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00131","start_s":605.568,"end_s":605.809,"video_s":1485.568,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00034","chapter":"C004","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00132","start_s":606.129,"end_s":607.07,"video_s":1486.129,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00035","chapter":"C004","text":"Passes 8-0.","fingerprint":"f9a0ca3f6107","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00133","start_s":608.471,"end_s":611.434,"video_s":1488.471,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00035","chapter":"C004","text":"Vice Mayor, do you have a motion to suspend the rules and take items out of order?","fingerprint":"d5d9c0d4626a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00134","start_s":612.095,"end_s":612.175,"video_s":1492.095,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00035","chapter":"C004","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00135","start_s":612.813,"end_s":613.334,"video_s":1492.813,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00036","chapter":"C004","text":"Yes, Mayor.","fingerprint":"f16b9e8eb094","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00136","start_s":613.414,"end_s":619.841,"video_s":1493.414,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00036","chapter":"C004","text":"I would move that we suspend the rules and take items 62, 63, and 65 out of order.","fingerprint":"0e39fcec5166","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00137","start_s":620.201,"end_s":620.542,"video_s":1500.201,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00037","chapter":"C004","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00138","start_s":621.423,"end_s":622.524,"video_s":1501.423,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00038","chapter":"C004","text":"We have a motion and a second.","fingerprint":"7451ba811637","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00139","start_s":622.584,"end_s":623.565,"video_s":1502.584,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00038","chapter":"C004","text":"All those in favor, say aye.","fingerprint":"a4221bb84d8e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00140","start_s":624.186,"end_s":624.286,"video_s":1504.186,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00038","chapter":"C004","text":"Aye.","fingerprint":"4707c4fdc04e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00141","start_s":624.646,"end_s":625.647,"video_s":1504.646,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00038","chapter":"C004","text":"Any opposed, nay.","fingerprint":"f7daaedf3626","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00142","start_s":627.97,"end_s":633.216,"video_s":1507.97,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00039","chapter":"C005","text":"We'll begin with item 62, the Joan Gantz Cooney Way ceremonial street name.","fingerprint":"1c0451f3d707","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00143","start_s":633.736,"end_s":638.842,"video_s":1513.736,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00039","chapter":"C005","text":"And I'll turn to Councilwoman Stark.","fingerprint":"0e86fd608359","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00144","start_s":638.862,"end_s":639.423,"video_s":1518.862,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00040","chapter":"C005","text":"Thank you, Mary.","fingerprint":"44f80aad999c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00145","start_s":639.523,"end_s":641.605,"video_s":1519.523,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00040","chapter":"C005","text":"I'd like to move approval.","fingerprint":"1d06d015b6cd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00146","start_s":642.158,"end_s":643.3,"video_s":1522.158,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00040","chapter":"C005","text":"and then I have some comments.","fingerprint":"67efc5b6e61a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00147","start_s":643.961,"end_s":644.622,"video_s":1523.961,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00040","chapter":"C005","text":"Second?","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00148","start_s":644.642,"end_s":644.843,"video_s":1524.642,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00040","chapter":"C005","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00149","start_s":645.444,"end_s":645.844,"video_s":1525.444,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00040","chapter":"C005","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00150","start_s":646.225,"end_s":655.261,"video_s":1526.225,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00040","chapter":"C005","text":"About two or three years ago, I had a constituent come forth and talk about Joan Ganz Cooney and he had done some research.","fingerprint":"55a93f10c514","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00151","start_s":655.301,"end_s":663.475,"video_s":1535.301,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00040","chapter":"C005","text":"He was an elementary school teacher and he had done some research with his students and they found out that she was born and raised in the city of Phoenix.","fingerprint":"8d66db5a08b0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00152","start_s":663.455,"end_s":683.91,"video_s":1543.455,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00040","chapter":"C005","text":"and that was quite exciting and he asked us to do some things to celebrate that and we worked with our public library and we did celebrate Sesame Street and had some events but then along came Julia Taggart and she decided no we need to do more and so now we are doing a street night a street name to","fingerprint":"d73f41059fab","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00153","start_s":683.89,"end_s":695.751,"video_s":1563.89,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00040","chapter":"C005","text":"honor her in the significance of value she's brought to the entire country with Big Bird and Oscar the Grouch and the Cookie Monster and everything that's wonderful about Sesame Street.","fingerprint":"acfc8cbf1407","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00154","start_s":695.771,"end_s":698.436,"video_s":1575.771,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00040","chapter":"C005","text":"My kids certainly grew up with it as did my brothers.","fingerprint":"7444a2a19f58","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00155","start_s":698.937,"end_s":700.92,"video_s":1578.937,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00040","chapter":"C005","text":"It was a little before my time.","fingerprint":"0d23ef52af8f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00156","start_s":700.9,"end_s":719.77,"video_s":1580.9,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00040","chapter":"C005","text":"but what's also interesting about Joan Cooney is her grandfather was mayor of the city of Phoenix and we're celebrating 140 years of our fire department he was elected in 1885 and Emil Gantz","fingerprint":"f82a08c68d1d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00157","start_s":719.75,"end_s":745.707,"video_s":1599.75,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00040","chapter":"C005","text":"actually created the fire department which was pretty significant and it actually occurred because we had a major fire in downtown Phoenix and so he ran a bond election and sure enough we created our fire department we're so lucky we have a professional fire department probably the best in the country and certainly I think we can um attribute that to uh Mayor Gantz","fingerprint":"3e594d3d57c8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00158","start_s":745.687,"end_s":752.46,"video_s":1625.687,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00040","chapter":"C005","text":"He also was the first Jewish mayor of the city of Phoenix and so that has some significance as well.","fingerprint":"a2088e5015b5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00159","start_s":752.961,"end_s":756.427,"video_s":1632.961,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00040","chapter":"C005","text":"You know, it is quite an honor to say that Joan grew up here.","fingerprint":"7d6c1e0ac0c3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00160","start_s":756.467,"end_s":763.24,"video_s":1636.467,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00040","chapter":"C005","text":"Again, Sesame Street is a part of the American fabric and I'm very excited that we're doing this.","fingerprint":"076e24ad2fe1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00161","start_s":763.22,"end_s":791.32,"video_s":1643.22,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00040","chapter":"C005","text":"a little jealous that it's in district 8 but I know why I mean obviously it's by the children's museum and so someday I hope we actually have a corner that honors Sesame Street and Joan at the children's museum thank you mayor thank you so much I will go to the vice mayor and Julia if you would mind coming coming down we will recognize you shortly thank you mayor I echo the sentiments of councilwoman stark","fingerprint":"445e1a2ff1c0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00162","start_s":791.485,"end_s":799.87,"video_s":1671.485,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00041","chapter":"C005","text":"I am proud to support this item because I think it's a true opportunity to recognize someone from Phoenix whose impact reached children and families across the world.","fingerprint":"39d953b04fc4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00163","start_s":801.274,"end_s":806.068,"video_s":1681.274,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00041","chapter":"C005","text":"Having Joan born and raised here in Phoenix and through her creation of Sesame Street,","fingerprint":"a482ea78a3b6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00164","start_s":806.47,"end_s":829.93,"video_s":1686.47,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00041","chapter":"C005","text":"she made learning more accessible more engaging more joyful for many of generations of children including myself she understood the power of education and media to teach children who may otherwise may not have had access to these type of opportunities I think there's something special about having her name recognized right here in District 8 because it reminds us that extraordinary things from our own neighborhoods are possible","fingerprint":"d325ab367da0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00165","start_s":829.91,"end_s":833.633,"video_s":1709.91,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00041","chapter":"C005","text":"Her story tells our young people that you don't have to leave Phoenix to dream big.","fingerprint":"af15f8e72891","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00166","start_s":834.094,"end_s":837.837,"video_s":1714.094,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00041","chapter":"C005","text":"And the work that you do can have an impact far beyond our city.","fingerprint":"2c92d621cb78","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00167","start_s":838.358,"end_s":841.601,"video_s":1718.358,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00041","chapter":"C005","text":"This is exactly the type of history we should preserve and make more visible.","fingerprint":"8da6647a4016","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00168","start_s":842.021,"end_s":844.904,"video_s":1722.021,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00041","chapter":"C005","text":"I'm proud to support Joan Gantz Coney's way.","fingerprint":"17265477f375","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00169","start_s":845.224,"end_s":845.705,"video_s":1725.224,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00041","chapter":"C005","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00170","start_s":847.727,"end_s":848.027,"video_s":1727.727,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00042","chapter":"C005","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00171","start_s":848.067,"end_s":850.809,"video_s":1728.067,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00042","chapter":"C005","text":"We'll recognize Julia Taggart.","fingerprint":"e40e01f0f239","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00172","start_s":850.869,"end_s":852.231,"video_s":1730.869,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00042","chapter":"C005","text":"Thank you guys so much for this.","fingerprint":"8cc5a7c438ff","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00173","start_s":853.051,"end_s":854.833,"video_s":1733.051,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00042","chapter":"C005","text":"Joan and her team have been wonderful in this.","fingerprint":"d31941cad18c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00174","start_s":854.873,"end_s":855.934,"video_s":1734.873,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00042","chapter":"C005","text":"Her family supports this.","fingerprint":"ac7b4bc331ff","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00175","start_s":855.994,"end_s":857.976,"video_s":1735.994,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00042","chapter":"C005","text":"They thank the council.","fingerprint":"eb9a37ff1979","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00176","start_s":858.226,"end_s":861.369,"video_s":1738.226,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00042","chapter":"C005","text":"It's wonderful to have Joan B. from Phoenix, Arizona.","fingerprint":"0d690da7f146","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00177","start_s":861.429,"end_s":863.211,"video_s":1741.429,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00042","chapter":"C005","text":"She was actually growing up in District 4.","fingerprint":"097f21b75f1f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00178","start_s":864.212,"end_s":866.495,"video_s":1744.212,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00042","chapter":"C005","text":"But the Children's Museum is the perfect fit for the sign.","fingerprint":"7f1008144a58","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00179","start_s":866.655,"end_s":873.182,"video_s":1746.655,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00042","chapter":"C005","text":"If you look at the location, you have the University of Arizona building, which was her alma mater, and then you have the Phoenix Children's Museum.","fingerprint":"9abdacf16758","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00180","start_s":873.542,"end_s":876.746,"video_s":1753.542,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00042","chapter":"C005","text":"So that way when people drive by, they get to recognize all that she did for children.","fingerprint":"d9976913ee2f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00181","start_s":877.186,"end_s":880.77,"video_s":1757.186,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00042","chapter":"C005","text":"She was a co-creator of Sesame Street, which I'm sure many people remember the show.","fingerprint":"8f6a93f2222b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00182","start_s":881.41,"end_s":885.735,"video_s":1761.41,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00042","chapter":"C005","text":"Before I came, my dad said, I remember in 1996 the Tickle Me Elmo craze.","fingerprint":"2b2563904558","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00183","start_s":885.715,"end_s":909.647,"video_s":1765.715,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00042","chapter":"C005","text":"and we had to go and all these stores to find one for your cousin in Canada because they needed it in Canada so everybody has a connection to Sesame Street and they love it so much and it's just a wonderful thing that she did and she still lives in New York she supports this and once we figure out that with the New York team and the immediate family here the sign unveiling I will make sure that you guys are all invited but I appreciate you considering this request because","fingerprint":"11fa427919b9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00184","start_s":909.627,"end_s":932.209,"video_s":1789.627,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00042","chapter":"C005","text":"I really want more people to know about what Joan did with Sesame Street and that there's amazing people from Arizona that maybe they still don't live here but they've done amazing work for the country and especially with America 250 this is a great way to honor Sesame Street as well as Joan because we've done so much here in Phoenix so we've had so many great wonderful people come and don't worry Councilman Debra Stark I have some ceremonial street signs coming for your district too","fingerprint":"5a8c88d3ebbb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00185","start_s":932.189,"end_s":948.477,"video_s":1812.189,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00042","chapter":"C005","text":"Yes not this year because I don't want to you know kill the streets team with multiple ceremony signs but no it's going to be a great honor and I know the family is very appreciative of all that you guys have done to support this with the Phoenix Public Library recognizing her and now ceremonial street sign.","fingerprint":"fb8a4ec38850","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00186","start_s":948.517,"end_s":953.185,"video_s":1828.517,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00042","chapter":"C005","text":"I will be nominating her for the Arizona Women's Hall of Fame so that will be another fun nomination for her.","fingerprint":"ec28a84949cf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00187","start_s":953.165,"end_s":959.115,"video_s":1833.165,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00042","chapter":"C005","text":"But thank you again for all the wonderful words that you said, Vice Mayor Kesha Hodge Washington and Councilwoman Debra Stark.","fingerprint":"ad257a88bc59","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00188","start_s":959.175,"end_s":960.077,"video_s":1839.175,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00042","chapter":"C005","text":"It really means a lot.","fingerprint":"9fb7ca21f071","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00189","start_s":960.457,"end_s":967.349,"video_s":1840.457,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00042","chapter":"C005","text":"I think this is going to really inspire young women that they can be like Joan and create something that lasts decades and changes lives all across the globe.","fingerprint":"c1e9d631afa2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00190","start_s":967.549,"end_s":968.17,"video_s":1847.549,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00042","chapter":"C005","text":"So thank you.","fingerprint":"dd9ed184b6d2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00191","start_s":969.871,"end_s":970.272,"video_s":1849.871,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00043","chapter":"C005","text":"Wonderful.","fingerprint":"ee04228c5c6d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00192","start_s":970.352,"end_s":974.964,"video_s":1850.352,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00043","chapter":"C005","text":"Thank you, Julia, and thank you to the Councilwoman for bringing this forward.","fingerprint":"4f17ac520e83","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00193","start_s":975.244,"end_s":978.292,"video_s":1855.244,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00043","chapter":"C005","text":"The Gantz family has had an incredible legacy in our city.","fingerprint":"cf8704464ef4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00194","start_s":978.332,"end_s":985.45,"video_s":1858.332,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00043","chapter":"C005","text":"Because of Joan, we have tested Sesame Street, so our kids got to be consultants.","fingerprint":"26f3ccac42d3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00195","start_s":985.43,"end_s":991.618,"video_s":1865.43,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00043","chapter":"C005","text":"for the show and there are many people who see references to Phoenix as well.","fingerprint":"7a9080bb201b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00196","start_s":991.958,"end_s":1001.43,"video_s":1871.958,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00043","chapter":"C005","text":"I was a Sesame Street kid and as a mom, I'm excited this will move forward and it's such a special location near one of the best spots for kids in Phoenix.","fingerprint":"125af4ab4175","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00197","start_s":1002.071,"end_s":1002.472,"video_s":1882.071,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00043","chapter":"C005","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00198","start_s":1003.533,"end_s":1004.454,"video_s":1883.533,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00044","chapter":"C005","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00199","start_s":1004.474,"end_s":1004.694,"video_s":1884.474,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00044","chapter":"C005","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00200","start_s":1005.255,"end_s":1005.816,"video_s":1885.255,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00044","chapter":"C005","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00201","start_s":1005.836,"end_s":1006.477,"video_s":1885.836,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00044","chapter":"C005","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00202","start_s":1006.497,"end_s":1006.917,"video_s":1886.497,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00044","chapter":"C005","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00203","start_s":1009.16,"end_s":1010.141,"video_s":1889.16,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00045","chapter":"C005","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00204","start_s":1010.161,"end_s":1010.662,"video_s":1890.161,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00046","chapter":"C005","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00205","start_s":1010.842,"end_s":1011.103,"video_s":1890.842,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00046","chapter":"C005","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00206","start_s":1011.563,"end_s":1011.904,"video_s":1891.563,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00046","chapter":"C005","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00207","start_s":1012.184,"end_s":1012.464,"video_s":1892.184,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00046","chapter":"C005","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00208","start_s":1012.905,"end_s":1013.225,"video_s":1892.905,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00046","chapter":"C005","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00209","start_s":1013.886,"end_s":1013.966,"video_s":1893.886,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00046","chapter":"C005","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00210","start_s":1013.986,"end_s":1014.627,"video_s":1893.986,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00046","chapter":"C005","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00211","start_s":1014.961,"end_s":1015.262,"video_s":1894.961,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00046","chapter":"C005","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00212","start_s":1015.903,"end_s":1016.244,"video_s":1895.903,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00047","chapter":"C005","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00213","start_s":1016.264,"end_s":1016.926,"video_s":1896.264,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00047","chapter":"C005","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00214","start_s":1016.946,"end_s":1018.63,"video_s":1896.946,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00047","chapter":"C005","text":"Passes 8-0.","fingerprint":"f9a0ca3f6107","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00215","start_s":1018.73,"end_s":1024.445,"video_s":1898.73,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00048","chapter":"C006","text":"Item 63 is the Mel Martin Mile Ceremonial Street name signage.","fingerprint":"f4e43564c0d9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00216","start_s":1024.525,"end_s":1026.169,"video_s":1904.525,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00048","chapter":"C006","text":"Councilwoman O'Brien.","fingerprint":"003ed429bc6f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00217","start_s":1026.402,"end_s":1027.023,"video_s":1906.402,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00049","chapter":"C006","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00218","start_s":1027.043,"end_s":1031.612,"video_s":1907.043,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00049","chapter":"C006","text":"I approve, I move to approve item 63 and then I have comments.","fingerprint":"db53f0a9f2f5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00219","start_s":1031.952,"end_s":1032.153,"video_s":1911.952,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00049","chapter":"C006","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00220","start_s":1032.994,"end_s":1033.495,"video_s":1912.994,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00049","chapter":"C006","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00221","start_s":1033.916,"end_s":1049.946,"video_s":1913.916,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00049","chapter":"C006","text":"So I have to, I'm so honored to be able to get to do this and just want to share a little bit that Mel Martin is the first business person I met at a chamber event after being elected but before being officially elected.","fingerprint":"2d3e50cf66a5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00222","start_s":1049.926,"end_s":1071.58,"video_s":1929.926,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00049","chapter":"C006","text":"Inaugurated into office and we both showed up to a meeting very early and and had a lot of time to to chat and he's just such an incredible one a man with great stories and so I learned quickly that he had an auto museum in my district that he was in the process of moving and","fingerprint":"153fe8b1c6f9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00223","start_s":1071.56,"end_s":1076.947,"video_s":1951.56,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00049","chapter":"C006","text":"We've, I think, become good friends, but I have a few things that I've written down so I don't forget them all.","fingerprint":"23205f37d7f6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00224","start_s":1078.008,"end_s":1079.99,"video_s":1958.008,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00049","chapter":"C006","text":"We're so thrilled that you're here with us today.","fingerprint":"c00306fbd076","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00225","start_s":1080.03,"end_s":1085.857,"video_s":1960.03,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00049","chapter":"C006","text":"Your, Mel's contributions to Phoenix have been cultural, historical, and educational.","fingerprint":"16f9f0931cc8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00226","start_s":1086.598,"end_s":1094.648,"video_s":1966.598,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00049","chapter":"C006","text":"He has spent a lifetime preserving and sharing the story of the automobile and making that history accessible to our community.","fingerprint":"c30962bfb86f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00227","start_s":1094.948,"end_s":1100.373,"video_s":1974.948,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00049","chapter":"C006","text":"Mel's lifelong dedication started when he was just 17 years old with his first Douglas truck.","fingerprint":"5a5f1204d1a6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00228","start_s":1100.393,"end_s":1113.605,"video_s":1980.393,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00049","chapter":"C006","text":"From there, he became a mechanic, a garage owner, towing business operator, auctioneer, collector, and ultimately the founder of Martin Auto Museum, which is located at 43rd Avenue and Thunderbird Road.","fingerprint":"4a271109c112","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00229","start_s":1114.245,"end_s":1123.774,"video_s":1994.245,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00049","chapter":"C006","text":"Today, Martin Auto Museum has more than 170 vehicles, along with extraordinary collection of automotive memorabilia and antique gas pumps,","fingerprint":"6ea0b49e11ce","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00230","start_s":1123.754,"end_s":1142.961,"video_s":2003.754,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00049","chapter":"C006","text":"I visited the museum several times.","fingerprint":"535479a500c6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00231","start_s":1143.481,"end_s":1151.452,"video_s":2023.481,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00049","chapter":"C006","text":"and I've seen firsthand the passion Mel has for preserving these pieces of our history and sharing them with others.","fingerprint":"7ddcfaf7ab7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00232","start_s":1151.733,"end_s":1156.62,"video_s":2031.733,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00049","chapter":"C006","text":"My husband has actually disappeared for hours of time with Mel to learn about those cars.","fingerprint":"f662f164e989","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00233","start_s":1157.501,"end_s":1168.577,"video_s":2037.501,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00049","chapter":"C006","text":"He made his mark in the automotive history world and I'm proud that we can make his contributions a little bit more visible here in Phoenix by literally putting his name on the map.","fingerprint":"c0f3057c5c32","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00234","start_s":1168.557,"end_s":1174.312,"video_s":2048.557,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00049","chapter":"C006","text":"Mel, thank you for your lifetime of dedication to automobiles history and our community.","fingerprint":"aafd69a1074b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00235","start_s":1174.332,"end_s":1182.313,"video_s":2054.332,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00049","chapter":"C006","text":"I look forward to soon celebrating the installation of ceremonial street signs designating Mel Martin Mile.","fingerprint":"285901877135","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00236","start_s":1185.297,"end_s":1187.941,"video_s":2065.297,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00050","chapter":"C006","text":"Thank you Councilwoman, thank you for recognizing Mel.","fingerprint":"c368a34fe119","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00237","start_s":1187.961,"end_s":1207.191,"video_s":2067.961,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00050","chapter":"C006","text":"Mel thank you for what you've done for our city and our region whether it be your philanthropic investments or just making sure that when we have parades such as Veterans Day that we have the wonderful cars to celebrate our history and we're very very thankful for your investments.","fingerprint":"447ea06fb10f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00238","start_s":1207.271,"end_s":1211.237,"video_s":2087.271,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00050","chapter":"C006","text":"My son is particularly thankful for the transformer that you have at the","fingerprint":"a2ae2e1beb77","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00239","start_s":1211.605,"end_s":1217.892,"video_s":2091.605,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00050","chapter":"C006","text":"Mel Martin Auto Museum, but from multiple generations of my family, thank you for your investment.","fingerprint":"65b477e727ac","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00240","start_s":1217.932,"end_s":1220.454,"video_s":2097.932,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00050","chapter":"C006","text":"And Mel, why don't you stand since we're starting a bit of a tradition.","fingerprint":"5787b0c3335c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00241","start_s":1230.245,"end_s":1234.509,"video_s":2110.245,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00051","chapter":"C006","text":"And with that, roll call.","fingerprint":"bf7ed32ff9a2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00242","start_s":1234.529,"end_s":1234.89,"video_s":2114.529,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00051","chapter":"C006","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00243","start_s":1235.33,"end_s":1235.55,"video_s":2115.33,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00051","chapter":"C006","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00244","start_s":1236.071,"end_s":1236.471,"video_s":2116.071,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00051","chapter":"C006","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00245","start_s":1236.732,"end_s":1237.012,"video_s":2116.732,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00051","chapter":"C006","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00246","start_s":1237.412,"end_s":1237.933,"video_s":2117.412,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00051","chapter":"C006","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00247","start_s":1239.618,"end_s":1240.54,"video_s":2119.618,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00051","chapter":"C006","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00248","start_s":1240.56,"end_s":1241.021,"video_s":2120.56,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00051","chapter":"C006","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00249","start_s":1241.201,"end_s":1241.482,"video_s":2121.201,"speaker":"harry-sexton","turn":"T00052","chapter":"C006","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00250","start_s":1241.923,"end_s":1242.524,"video_s":2121.923,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00053","chapter":"C006","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00251","start_s":1242.544,"end_s":1243.226,"video_s":2122.544,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00053","chapter":"C006","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00252","start_s":1243.246,"end_s":1243.567,"video_s":2123.246,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00053","chapter":"C006","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00253","start_s":1244.308,"end_s":1244.388,"video_s":2124.308,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00053","chapter":"C006","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00254","start_s":1244.409,"end_s":1245.05,"video_s":2124.409,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00053","chapter":"C006","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00255","start_s":1245.21,"end_s":1245.451,"video_s":2125.21,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00053","chapter":"C006","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00256","start_s":1245.872,"end_s":1246.273,"video_s":2125.872,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00053","chapter":"C006","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00257","start_s":1247.255,"end_s":1247.475,"video_s":2127.255,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00054","chapter":"C006","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00258","start_s":1247.796,"end_s":1248.317,"video_s":2127.796,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00054","chapter":"C006","text":"Passes 8-0.","fingerprint":"f9a0ca3f6107","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00259","start_s":1249.359,"end_s":1253.99,"video_s":2129.359,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00055","chapter":"C007","text":"Next we go to item 65, Serbian Heritage Way Ceremonial Street Name, Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"6f1ceee91f2b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00260","start_s":1254.29,"end_s":1254.791,"video_s":2134.29,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00056","chapter":"C007","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00261","start_s":1254.811,"end_s":1257.217,"video_s":2134.811,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00056","chapter":"C007","text":"I move to approve item 65 and then I'll get comments.","fingerprint":"b2a2c13ada3f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00262","start_s":1257.577,"end_s":1257.918,"video_s":2137.577,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00057","chapter":"C007","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00263","start_s":1258.219,"end_s":1258.6,"video_s":2138.219,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00057","chapter":"C007","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00264","start_s":1258.76,"end_s":1259.702,"video_s":2138.76,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00057","chapter":"C007","text":"Recognized for comments.","fingerprint":"3446961602f4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00265","start_s":1259.75,"end_s":1260.391,"video_s":2139.75,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00058","chapter":"C007","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00266","start_s":1260.531,"end_s":1269.724,"video_s":2140.531,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00058","chapter":"C007","text":"I am very pleased to support item 65 because recognizing our history means recognizing the many communities and institutions that helped make Phoenix the city it is today.","fingerprint":"d4008514ace7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00267","start_s":1269.744,"end_s":1275.912,"video_s":2149.744,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00058","chapter":"C007","text":"St. Sava Serbian Orthodox Church has been an anchor in this Phoenix neighborhood since 1958.","fingerprint":"9b5daa740bb3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00268","start_s":1275.992,"end_s":1287.748,"video_s":2155.992,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00058","chapter":"C007","text":"For nearly seven decades, it has provided cultural, spiritual, educational, charitable, and community support while preserving Serbian American heritage for generations.","fingerprint":"ad1e81261e7f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00269","start_s":1289.045,"end_s":1294.291,"video_s":2169.045,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00058","chapter":"C007","text":"What I particularly appreciate is that this recognition also celebrates the way culture can bring people together.","fingerprint":"06c40145db4c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00270","start_s":1294.931,"end_s":1306.424,"video_s":2174.931,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00058","chapter":"C007","text":"ServFest gives thousands of people an opportunity to experience Serbian food, music, dance, history, and traditions while creating opportunities for cultural exchange through our broader community.","fingerprint":"04d42d50d189","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00271","start_s":1307.365,"end_s":1312.791,"video_s":2187.365,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00058","chapter":"C007","text":"A ceremonial sign may seem simple, but these signs tell a story about who we are as a city,","fingerprint":"ddfbd9c7d9ca","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00272","start_s":1313.159,"end_s":1315.544,"video_s":2193.159,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00058","chapter":"C007","text":"and the communities that helped build Phoenix.","fingerprint":"79e61ad2525e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00273","start_s":1315.564,"end_s":1324.32,"video_s":2195.564,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00058","chapter":"C007","text":"I'm proud to support Serbian Heritage Way and to recognize the lasting contributions of the Serbian American community in District 8 and across Phoenix.","fingerprint":"4e774f76104b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00274","start_s":1324.761,"end_s":1325.202,"video_s":2204.761,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00058","chapter":"C007","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00275","start_s":1326.424,"end_s":1327.827,"video_s":2206.424,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00059","chapter":"C007","text":"Thank you so much, Leonard Clark.","fingerprint":"a0fffb6f2bb7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00276","start_s":1334.0,"end_s":1334.601,"video_s":2214.0,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00060","chapter":"C007","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00277","start_s":1334.621,"end_s":1338.749,"video_s":2214.621,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00060","chapter":"C007","text":"I'm just very happy to hear that we're preserving our cultural heritage in the city of Phoenix.","fingerprint":"af194b6ddfff","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00278","start_s":1338.929,"end_s":1353.898,"video_s":2218.929,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00060","chapter":"C007","text":"I grew up with a Ukrainian friend, and I know that's not the same as Serbian, but I know different Serbian people, and all I have to say is I'm so glad you're doing this, and thank you to the Serbian people for enriching our city and its culture and its history, and zi veli, zi veli, cheers!","fingerprint":"b61f26a693b4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00279","start_s":1355.549,"end_s":1356.03,"video_s":2235.549,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00061","chapter":"C007","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00280","start_s":1356.05,"end_s":1358.232,"video_s":2236.05,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00061","chapter":"C007","text":"I'm looking forward to supporting this item.","fingerprint":"130b42ccfc03","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00281","start_s":1358.272,"end_s":1361.156,"video_s":2238.272,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00061","chapter":"C007","text":"We have a wonderful Serbian community here.","fingerprint":"3d1dd19dc7d6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00282","start_s":1361.516,"end_s":1376.994,"video_s":2241.516,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00061","chapter":"C007","text":"If you have not had a chance to visit this location, it has several very impressive and beautiful buildings, including stained glass and other artwork that has come from Serbia, a real gem and a jewel for our city.","fingerprint":"5bdbf789b803","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00283","start_s":1377.555,"end_s":1382.201,"video_s":2257.555,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00061","chapter":"C007","text":"And again, Serb Fest, incredible food, culture, and dancing.","fingerprint":"acdcad218daf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00284","start_s":1382.601,"end_s":1383.362,"video_s":2262.601,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00061","chapter":"C007","text":"All right, roll call.","fingerprint":"5d88818c1d17","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00285","start_s":1384.237,"end_s":1384.98,"video_s":2264.237,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00062","chapter":"C007","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00286","start_s":1385.0,"end_s":1385.822,"video_s":2265.0,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00062","chapter":"C007","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00287","start_s":1385.843,"end_s":1386.244,"video_s":2265.843,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00062","chapter":"C007","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00288","start_s":1386.425,"end_s":1387.047,"video_s":2266.425,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00062","chapter":"C007","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00289","start_s":1387.067,"end_s":1387.508,"video_s":2267.067,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00062","chapter":"C007","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00290","start_s":1390.218,"end_s":1390.458,"video_s":2270.218,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00062","chapter":"C007","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00291","start_s":1391.161,"end_s":1391.662,"video_s":2271.161,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00062","chapter":"C007","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00292","start_s":1391.803,"end_s":1392.064,"video_s":2271.803,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00063","chapter":"C007","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00293","start_s":1392.525,"end_s":1392.867,"video_s":2272.525,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00064","chapter":"C007","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00294","start_s":1393.348,"end_s":1393.589,"video_s":2273.348,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00064","chapter":"C007","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00295","start_s":1393.99,"end_s":1394.312,"video_s":2273.99,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00064","chapter":"C007","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00296","start_s":1395.114,"end_s":1395.195,"video_s":2275.114,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00064","chapter":"C007","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00297","start_s":1395.215,"end_s":1395.917,"video_s":2275.215,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00064","chapter":"C007","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00298","start_s":1396.15,"end_s":1396.471,"video_s":2276.15,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00064","chapter":"C007","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00299","start_s":1396.971,"end_s":1397.332,"video_s":2276.971,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00064","chapter":"C007","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00300","start_s":1397.773,"end_s":1398.033,"video_s":2277.773,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00065","chapter":"C007","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00301","start_s":1398.554,"end_s":1399.396,"video_s":2278.554,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00065","chapter":"C007","text":"Passes 8-0.","fingerprint":"f9a0ca3f6107","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00302","start_s":1400.437,"end_s":1403.262,"video_s":2280.437,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00066","chapter":"C008","text":"We next go to item 23, settlement of claim.","fingerprint":"470cbd271b94","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00303","start_s":1403.943,"end_s":1404.364,"video_s":2283.943,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00067","chapter":"C008","text":"Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"9a95bf6095c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00304","start_s":1404.845,"end_s":1406.227,"video_s":2284.845,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00067","chapter":"C008","text":"Motion to approve item 23.","fingerprint":"68f5964d5316","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00305","start_s":1407.049,"end_s":1407.449,"video_s":2287.049,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00067","chapter":"C008","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00306","start_s":1408.09,"end_s":1408.872,"video_s":2288.09,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00068","chapter":"C008","text":"Councilman Hernandez.","fingerprint":"3bb873cefabf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00307","start_s":1409.413,"end_s":1409.893,"video_s":2289.413,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00069","chapter":"C008","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00308","start_s":1409.913,"end_s":1411.536,"video_s":2289.913,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00069","chapter":"C008","text":"Just have a couple comments on this.","fingerprint":"c25b5597acbc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00309","start_s":1411.616,"end_s":1415.543,"video_s":2291.616,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00069","chapter":"C008","text":"You know, I just want to acknowledge that this is one of two settlements that puts us as roughly","fingerprint":"5fb241002070","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00310","start_s":1415.523,"end_s":1431.878,"video_s":2295.523,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00069","chapter":"C008","text":"$600,000 in settlements that the city is being asked to approve for accidents involving on-duty police officers who were driving their vehicles you know that's $600,000 in public dollars that could otherwise be invested in youth programs and housing into human services","fingerprint":"c22fd3a820b0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00311","start_s":1431.858,"end_s":1434.843,"video_s":2311.858,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00069","chapter":"C008","text":"and other resources our communities really need right now.","fingerprint":"d14da0b32310","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00312","start_s":1435.645,"end_s":1440.694,"video_s":2315.645,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00069","chapter":"C008","text":"I am going to be voting yes on this because when residents are harmed they deserve repair and accountability.","fingerprint":"e7345ca26227","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00313","start_s":1440.734,"end_s":1451.773,"video_s":2320.734,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00069","chapter":"C008","text":"At the same time I do believe that we have to take seriously how we are using our public dollars and ask what we can do differently to prevent these incidents from continuing to happen.","fingerprint":"01d2ed00c7b9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00314","start_s":1451.753,"end_s":1471.483,"video_s":2331.753,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00069","chapter":"C008","text":"there are other cities across the country that have taken steps to create stronger financial accountability and transparency around police related settlements I would love to see us as a city as a fifth largest city in the country explore similar policies to see what would work for Phoenix including more accessible public information about these cases and","fingerprint":"e2a5198d77e2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00315","start_s":1471.463,"end_s":1476.087,"video_s":2351.463,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00069","chapter":"C008","text":"clear understanding of what accountability measures are put in place when the city pays a settlement.","fingerprint":"81d5dba46d2a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00316","start_s":1476.728,"end_s":1486.877,"video_s":2356.728,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00069","chapter":"C008","text":"We have a responsibility not only to repair harm after it happens, but to really learn from these cases and make sure we are doing everything in our power to prevent the harm from happening again.","fingerprint":"3850a2be8833","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00317","start_s":1487.658,"end_s":1488.319,"video_s":2367.658,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00069","chapter":"C008","text":"Thank you so much, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d116fbf480ee","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00318","start_s":1489.92,"end_s":1490.641,"video_s":2369.92,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00069","chapter":"C008","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00319","start_s":1490.761,"end_s":1491.121,"video_s":2370.761,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00069","chapter":"C008","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00320","start_s":1492.022,"end_s":1492.463,"video_s":2372.022,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00070","chapter":"C008","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00321","start_s":1492.923,"end_s":1493.123,"video_s":2372.923,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00070","chapter":"C008","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00322","start_s":1493.624,"end_s":1494.024,"video_s":2373.624,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00070","chapter":"C008","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00323","start_s":1494.685,"end_s":1494.945,"video_s":2374.685,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00070","chapter":"C008","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00324","start_s":1495.365,"end_s":1495.786,"video_s":2375.365,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00070","chapter":"C008","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00325","start_s":1497.808,"end_s":1498.028,"video_s":2377.808,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00070","chapter":"C008","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00326","start_s":1498.689,"end_s":1499.189,"video_s":2378.689,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00070","chapter":"C008","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00327","start_s":1499.429,"end_s":1499.67,"video_s":2379.429,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00071","chapter":"C008","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00328","start_s":1500.17,"end_s":1500.51,"video_s":2380.17,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00072","chapter":"C008","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00329","start_s":1501.171,"end_s":1501.251,"video_s":2381.171,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00072","chapter":"C008","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00330","start_s":1501.45,"end_s":1501.69,"video_s":2381.45,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00072","chapter":"C008","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00331","start_s":1501.71,"end_s":1501.851,"video_s":2381.71,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00072","chapter":"C008","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00332","start_s":1502.652,"end_s":1503.273,"video_s":2382.652,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00072","chapter":"C008","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00333","start_s":1503.434,"end_s":1503.674,"video_s":2383.434,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00072","chapter":"C008","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00334","start_s":1504.095,"end_s":1504.516,"video_s":2384.095,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00072","chapter":"C008","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00335","start_s":1504.756,"end_s":1504.957,"video_s":2384.756,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00072","chapter":"C008","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00336","start_s":1505.357,"end_s":1506.179,"video_s":2385.357,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00072","chapter":"C008","text":"Passes 8-0.","fingerprint":"f9a0ca3f6107","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00337","start_s":1506.88,"end_s":1516.799,"video_s":2386.88,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00073","chapter":"C009","text":"We next go to item 25, which is an agreement with NAU related to the Center for Service and Volunteerism, Arizona Health Corps, and Environmental Literacy Corps, AmeriCorps.","fingerprint":"f2e5deb0a957","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00338","start_s":1517.521,"end_s":1517.922,"video_s":2397.521,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00073","chapter":"C009","text":"Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"9a95bf6095c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00339","start_s":1518.382,"end_s":1519.705,"video_s":2398.382,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00074","chapter":"C009","text":"Motion to approve item 25.","fingerprint":"dd4adebc4045","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00340","start_s":1520.046,"end_s":1520.727,"video_s":2400.046,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00074","chapter":"C009","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00341","start_s":1521.308,"end_s":1522.15,"video_s":2401.308,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00075","chapter":"C009","text":"Motion and a second.","fingerprint":"9b5eb76aa224","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00342","start_s":1522.21,"end_s":1522.851,"video_s":2402.21,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00075","chapter":"C009","text":"Leonard Clark.","fingerprint":"7eb3b62b23e1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00343","start_s":1527.505,"end_s":1528.247,"video_s":2407.505,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00076","chapter":"C009","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00344","start_s":1528.267,"end_s":1532.658,"video_s":2408.267,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00076","chapter":"C009","text":"I just wanted to also say again to the Mayor and Council, I think this is an excellent program.","fingerprint":"475d103046ea","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00345","start_s":1533.981,"end_s":1540.558,"video_s":2413.981,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00076","chapter":"C009","text":"We do need these outreach programs for public health, for conservation, and these types of things.","fingerprint":"e5684f40b062","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00346","start_s":1541.38,"end_s":1543.405,"video_s":2421.38,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00076","chapter":"C009","text":"This is what gives our city its heart.","fingerprint":"14598da3a8fe","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00347","start_s":1543.385,"end_s":1550.156,"video_s":2423.385,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00076","chapter":"C009","text":"It doesn't have to be just cold, you know, basically people not connecting with each other.","fingerprint":"fb4ba133c32e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00348","start_s":1550.176,"end_s":1558.249,"video_s":2430.176,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00076","chapter":"C009","text":"This teaches people to, you know, conserve our environment and do all kinds of things like that with Northern Arizona University.","fingerprint":"2da7a9a8e300","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00349","start_s":1558.269,"end_s":1559.531,"video_s":2438.269,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00076","chapter":"C009","text":"So thank you for partnering for this.","fingerprint":"720eb9fce454","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00350","start_s":1559.571,"end_s":1559.872,"video_s":2439.571,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00076","chapter":"C009","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00351","start_s":1562.196,"end_s":1563.037,"video_s":2442.196,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00077","chapter":"C009","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00352","start_s":1564.619,"end_s":1564.98,"video_s":2444.619,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00078","chapter":"C009","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00353","start_s":1567.083,"end_s":1567.644,"video_s":2447.083,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00078","chapter":"C009","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00354","start_s":1567.664,"end_s":1568.606,"video_s":2447.664,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00078","chapter":"C009","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00355","start_s":1568.626,"end_s":1568.987,"video_s":2448.626,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00078","chapter":"C009","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00356","start_s":1569.207,"end_s":1569.427,"video_s":2449.207,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00078","chapter":"C009","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00357","start_s":1570.028,"end_s":1570.489,"video_s":2450.028,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00078","chapter":"C009","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00358","start_s":1575.768,"end_s":1576.208,"video_s":2455.768,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00078","chapter":"C009","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00359","start_s":1576.409,"end_s":1576.589,"video_s":2456.409,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00078","chapter":"C009","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00360","start_s":1579.752,"end_s":1580.212,"video_s":2459.752,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00078","chapter":"C009","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00361","start_s":1580.232,"end_s":1580.573,"video_s":2460.232,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00078","chapter":"C009","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00362","start_s":1580.673,"end_s":1581.113,"video_s":2460.673,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00078","chapter":"C009","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00363","start_s":1581.434,"end_s":1582.295,"video_s":2461.434,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00078","chapter":"C009","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00364","start_s":1583.215,"end_s":1583.416,"video_s":2463.215,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00078","chapter":"C009","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00365","start_s":1583.476,"end_s":1583.796,"video_s":2463.476,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00078","chapter":"C009","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00366","start_s":1584.377,"end_s":1584.697,"video_s":2464.377,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00078","chapter":"C009","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00367","start_s":1585.057,"end_s":1585.718,"video_s":2465.057,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00079","chapter":"C009","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00368","start_s":1585.738,"end_s":1586.038,"video_s":2465.738,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00080","chapter":"C009","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00369","start_s":1586.779,"end_s":1586.859,"video_s":2466.779,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00080","chapter":"C009","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00370","start_s":1586.879,"end_s":1587.46,"video_s":2466.879,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00080","chapter":"C009","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00371","start_s":1587.7,"end_s":1588.28,"video_s":2467.7,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00080","chapter":"C009","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00372","start_s":1588.301,"end_s":1588.661,"video_s":2468.301,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00081","chapter":"C009","text":"Diego?","fingerprint":"00e48a815525","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00373","start_s":1588.841,"end_s":1589.041,"video_s":2468.841,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00081","chapter":"C009","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00374","start_s":1589.382,"end_s":1590.002,"video_s":2469.382,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00081","chapter":"C009","text":"Passes 8-0.","fingerprint":"f9a0ca3f6107","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00375","start_s":1591.744,"end_s":1593.225,"video_s":2471.744,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00082","chapter":"C010","text":"Item 32 is next.","fingerprint":"1d5c5ae7bcce","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00376","start_s":1593.245,"end_s":1594.867,"video_s":2473.245,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00082","chapter":"C010","text":"Outside legal counsel, Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"1d6581344a65","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00377","start_s":1595.588,"end_s":1596.809,"video_s":2475.588,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00083","chapter":"C010","text":"Motion to approve item 32.","fingerprint":"462eba7da202","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00378","start_s":1597.51,"end_s":1597.85,"video_s":2477.51,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00083","chapter":"C010","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00379","start_s":1598.25,"end_s":1598.951,"video_s":2478.25,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00084","chapter":"C010","text":"Motion is second.","fingerprint":"c27652cd98f4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00380","start_s":1598.991,"end_s":1600.473,"video_s":2478.991,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00084","chapter":"C010","text":"We'll begin with public comment.","fingerprint":"cc22f179cbdd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00381","start_s":1600.693,"end_s":1602.855,"video_s":2480.693,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00084","chapter":"C010","text":"Jeremy Thacker followed by Kristen Lisson.","fingerprint":"dc959a2ca40a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00382","start_s":1616.588,"end_s":1617.229,"video_s":2496.588,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C010","text":"Mayor and Council.","fingerprint":"53386485e931","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00383","start_s":1619.633,"end_s":1632.933,"video_s":2499.633,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C010","text":"Spending $300,000 so far on the illusion of an ethics commission and accountability was acceptable when there was some hope attached to it at the beginning that it was actually going to turn into the real thing.","fingerprint":"eb56c7c2f7ae","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00384","start_s":1635.137,"end_s":1636.579,"video_s":2515.137,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C010","text":"Unfortunately, that has not happened.","fingerprint":"b4ef817f8e8f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00385","start_s":1637.059,"end_s":1645.212,"video_s":2517.059,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C010","text":"So spending another $150,000 on the wizard, when we've all seen behind the curtain already,","fingerprint":"ca774a5f9cb5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00386","start_s":1645.63,"end_s":1646.791,"video_s":2525.63,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C010","text":"is unacceptable.","fingerprint":"fc509027cf91","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00387","start_s":1649.114,"end_s":1651.778,"video_s":2529.114,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C010","text":"Before you vote today, I ask you for four questions.","fingerprint":"13fa0b11e2d4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00388","start_s":1651.798,"end_s":1653.2,"video_s":2531.798,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C010","text":"I might not get to all of them.","fingerprint":"68bc344deb7e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00389","start_s":1653.22,"end_s":1663.753,"video_s":2533.22,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C010","text":"First one is, does the city trust that the city is being more ethical, the citizens, I'm sorry, trust that the city is being more ethical or transparent?","fingerprint":"2163877f9525","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00390","start_s":1664.935,"end_s":1670.862,"video_s":2544.935,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C010","text":"Well, ethics complaints before we had the ethics commission were public records.","fingerprint":"3f3a15ecdd6f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00391","start_s":1671.989,"end_s":1676.494,"video_s":2551.989,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C010","text":"We could also at least fight with the attorney who was putting them in the desk drawer.","fingerprint":"f71b2708a77a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00392","start_s":1676.534,"end_s":1678.937,"video_s":2556.534,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C010","text":"We knew who it was, and we could talk with them.","fingerprint":"8ac20152da6d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00393","start_s":1678.957,"end_s":1680.138,"video_s":2558.957,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C010","text":"Now we can't do either of those.","fingerprint":"fbb6646c120f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00394","start_s":1680.559,"end_s":1683.382,"video_s":2560.559,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C010","text":"Ethics complaints are completely in the dark.","fingerprint":"c7df8c5bf657","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00395","start_s":1684.824,"end_s":1691.351,"video_s":2564.824,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C010","text":"So the Ethics Commission has had 27 ethics complaints filed since it was started.","fingerprint":"51ab8b28226f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00396","start_s":1693.834,"end_s":1695.556,"video_s":2573.834,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C010","text":"Not one of them has come before this council.","fingerprint":"10cb658da855","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00397","start_s":1696.096,"end_s":1701.102,"video_s":2576.096,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C010","text":"Not a single ethics complaint has made it here.","fingerprint":"51636d3b2bb8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00398","start_s":1702.617,"end_s":1711.671,"video_s":2582.617,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C010","text":"So clearly, we're either the most ethical city in the world and we don't need it, or we're wasting money, lots of money and time.","fingerprint":"621dfe2a5369","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00399","start_s":1711.951,"end_s":1712.933,"video_s":2591.951,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C010","text":"And this is not against Beth.","fingerprint":"26dc412ceeff","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00400","start_s":1712.973,"end_s":1714.395,"video_s":2592.973,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C010","text":"I think she's a very good attorney.","fingerprint":"ab60fe61080c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00401","start_s":1715.978,"end_s":1718.462,"video_s":2595.978,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C010","text":"This is about the Ethics Commission.","fingerprint":"e5023703bb12","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00402","start_s":1719.103,"end_s":1721.887,"video_s":2599.103,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C010","text":"It's a foundation.","fingerprint":"6f8aee427c6f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00403","start_s":1722.187,"end_s":1723.069,"video_s":2602.187,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C010","text":"It's never going to work.","fingerprint":"6e51a2a740f2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00404","start_s":1724.491,"end_s":1726.093,"video_s":2604.491,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C010","text":"It doesn't follow any best practices.","fingerprint":"8ce2c75eee60","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00405","start_s":1727.235,"end_s":1731.021,"video_s":2607.235,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C010","text":"It's clear that it's a waste of time.","fingerprint":"0b430450a5fa","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00406","start_s":1731.507,"end_s":1734.05,"video_s":2611.507,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C010","text":"and it's just trying to pull the wool over our eyes.","fingerprint":"48c6b42c6e06","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00407","start_s":1734.11,"end_s":1736.493,"video_s":2614.11,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C010","text":"So I ask that you spend this money in a better way.","fingerprint":"57080d71a1c4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00408","start_s":1739.236,"end_s":1739.897,"video_s":2619.236,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00086","chapter":"C010","text":"Kristen is next.","fingerprint":"8cf134efe2ab","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00409","start_s":1745.864,"end_s":1746.465,"video_s":2625.864,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00087","chapter":"C010","text":"Hi, council.","fingerprint":"eb455453d156","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00410","start_s":1747.847,"end_s":1753.854,"video_s":2627.847,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00087","chapter":"C010","text":"So you created this commission in 2017 and you appointed no one for six years.","fingerprint":"e0dd21d89c18","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00411","start_s":1754.535,"end_s":1759.641,"video_s":2634.535,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00087","chapter":"C010","text":"In its first meeting, March of 2024, that meeting was an orientation.","fingerprint":"3a8047e65c81","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00412","start_s":1759.874,"end_s":1766.262,"video_s":2639.874,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00087","chapter":"C010","text":"Since then, it has canceled 11 of its 31 scheduled meetings, so that's more than one in three.","fingerprint":"7e06d7c05bc2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00413","start_s":1766.802,"end_s":1773.09,"video_s":2646.802,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00087","chapter":"C010","text":"It has not met in 83 days, and the next meeting is October 22nd after today's vote.","fingerprint":"01aed619f8a4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00414","start_s":1774.071,"end_s":1783.042,"video_s":2654.071,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00087","chapter":"C010","text":"It holds four of five seats, and as its own rules require four votes to do anything, so every decision must be unanimous.","fingerprint":"50e65249cdf4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00415","start_s":1783.402,"end_s":1789.189,"video_s":2663.402,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00087","chapter":"C010","text":"So that means one absence on the commission and this body, it can't act at all.","fingerprint":"da7127121026","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00416","start_s":1790.367,"end_s":1791.648,"video_s":2670.367,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00087","chapter":"C010","text":"That's not theoretical.","fingerprint":"d9108518c326","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00417","start_s":1792.509,"end_s":1797.755,"video_s":2672.509,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00087","chapter":"C010","text":"Back in June, complaint died on a two-to-two vote, and it closed for good.","fingerprint":"5c6dcf5fac68","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00418","start_s":1797.975,"end_s":1798.315,"video_s":2677.975,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00087","chapter":"C010","text":"That's it.","fingerprint":"57e338d22031","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00419","start_s":1799.597,"end_s":1804.482,"video_s":2679.597,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00087","chapter":"C010","text":"Last December, you gave this commission an assignment, a residence petition on the inquiry process.","fingerprint":"043cbd3bf736","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00420","start_s":1804.522,"end_s":1806.504,"video_s":2684.522,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00087","chapter":"C010","text":"So Councilwoman Stark moved it.","fingerprint":"4d547306bf5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00421","start_s":1806.584,"end_s":1808.726,"video_s":2686.584,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00087","chapter":"C010","text":"Councilman Robinson seconded it.","fingerprint":"46a47db9a996","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00422","start_s":1808.746,"end_s":1809.908,"video_s":2688.746,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00087","chapter":"C010","text":"It passed.","fingerprint":"5611aaf60b86","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00423","start_s":1809.928,"end_s":1811.93,"video_s":2689.928,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00087","chapter":"C010","text":"That was 294 days ago.","fingerprint":"ddf166dc3bc4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00424","start_s":1812.751,"end_s":1818.737,"video_s":2692.751,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00087","chapter":"C010","text":"They discussed it four times, then voted to bring you draft amendments by August 20th.","fingerprint":"14b177dbf7b0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00425","start_s":1819.527,"end_s":1820.789,"video_s":2699.527,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00087","chapter":"C010","text":"They canceled August.","fingerprint":"bb809dce2520","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00426","start_s":1821.57,"end_s":1822.631,"video_s":2701.57,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00087","chapter":"C010","text":"They canceled September.","fingerprint":"cf7ea3ae1c6f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00427","start_s":1822.691,"end_s":1825.354,"video_s":2702.691,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00087","chapter":"C010","text":"Nothing has come back to you.","fingerprint":"a08e8e143637","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00428","start_s":1826.216,"end_s":1833.004,"video_s":2706.216,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00087","chapter":"C010","text":"So that's, Jeremy mentioned, 29 complaints appear in this commission's own minutes and not one has ever reached council.","fingerprint":"eae2d9fde879","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00429","start_s":1833.825,"end_s":1844.539,"video_s":2713.825,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00087","chapter":"C010","text":"We checked the legislative record and in two and a half years, the only ethics items to reach you are that citizen's petition and this contract today.","fingerprint":"d13066d375c1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00430","start_s":1844.519,"end_s":1851.566,"video_s":2724.519,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00087","chapter":"C010","text":"It's never produced an annual report and staff confirmed it back in April that none exists and that none is required.","fingerprint":"e3f16977dcdc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00431","start_s":1851.987,"end_s":1861.236,"video_s":2731.987,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00087","chapter":"C010","text":"So $300,000 and you are asked tonight for $150,000 more justified in one sentence with no scope of work.","fingerprint":"be330081ba68","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00432","start_s":1861.336,"end_s":1871.006,"video_s":2741.336,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00087","chapter":"C010","text":"So please fill the vacant seat, fix the vote threshold, require an annual report, publish the pending complaints, and then you can fund it.","fingerprint":"98cf3f87cc9f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00433","start_s":1871.727,"end_s":1871.927,"video_s":2751.727,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00088","chapter":"C010","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00434","start_s":1873.443,"end_s":1874.266,"video_s":2753.443,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00088","chapter":"C010","text":"Councilman Hernandez.","fingerprint":"3bb873cefabf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00435","start_s":1875.129,"end_s":1875.691,"video_s":2755.129,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00089","chapter":"C010","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00436","start_s":1875.711,"end_s":1877.94,"video_s":2755.711,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00089","chapter":"C010","text":"Just have a couple of questions on this item.","fingerprint":"5dcd61acc594","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00437","start_s":1878.783,"end_s":1884.263,"video_s":2758.783,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00089","chapter":"C010","text":"As the newest member to the council, just trying to understand and for the public,","fingerprint":"dad72b054394","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00438","start_s":1897.962,"end_s":1925.995,"video_s":2777.962,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00090","chapter":"C010","text":"my first question is um can you elaborate a little bit on what the purpose of the ethics commission is and how folk how people selected to join are selected to join the ethics commission good afternoon mayor members of council the purpose of the ethics commission is to review ethical concerns brought forward regarding elected officials boards commission and committee members i'm gonna let david benton speak to the process of appointing members","fingerprint":"1c71f8c46028","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00439","start_s":1928.962,"end_s":1947.325,"video_s":2808.962,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00091","chapter":"C010","text":"Mayor and members of council, the Ethics Commission is created by this body, but the commissioners are appointed through the judicial, let me see, get the exact name for you.","fingerprint":"254d11db101f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00440","start_s":1948.199,"end_s":1950.082,"video_s":2828.199,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00091","chapter":"C010","text":"the Judicial Selection Advisory Board.","fingerprint":"e61d892402ad","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00441","start_s":1950.643,"end_s":1957.695,"video_s":2830.643,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00091","chapter":"C010","text":"They're the ones who, once the applicant is chosen, that applicant goes before the Judicial Selection Advisory Board.","fingerprint":"f97c2a600df3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00442","start_s":1958.095,"end_s":1966.309,"video_s":2838.095,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00091","chapter":"C010","text":"There's some interviews that are conducted, kind of a triage process, and then those recommendations are made and before you.","fingerprint":"11b8cb38466c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00443","start_s":1966.407,"end_s":1967.409,"video_s":2846.407,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00092","chapter":"C010","text":"Okay, thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f3e96a907f4b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00444","start_s":1968.051,"end_s":1977.051,"video_s":2848.051,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00092","chapter":"C010","text":"And who does, when those reports come in, those complaints come in, they only go to the, I mean, obviously they go to the Ethics Commission.","fingerprint":"3b69c9dbb7c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00445","start_s":1977.071,"end_s":1978.674,"video_s":2857.071,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00092","chapter":"C010","text":"And then who do they report?","fingerprint":"21007af9af7a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00446","start_s":1978.734,"end_s":1981.26,"video_s":2858.734,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00092","chapter":"C010","text":"I guess, where's the reporting hierarchy there?","fingerprint":"dca11dfc66a7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00447","start_s":1983.147,"end_s":2003.67,"video_s":2863.147,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00093","chapter":"C010","text":"good afternoon mayor members of council so when the ethics commission comes in and goes through the city clerk's office it then gets forwarded to the ethics commission who conducts per city code and their rules their review and they choose you know whether to look into it further close it dismiss it there's several different actions they could take","fingerprint":"5aba48f6ebcc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00448","start_s":2003.65,"end_s":2029.708,"video_s":2883.65,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00093","chapter":"C010","text":"it continues to go on that path until it's finalized if recommendations were to be made it would eventually come to council but if it's dismissed or closed it ends there once the complaint is dismissed or closed they are made public on the website but while they're under review they are confidential okay thank you so much and what are if there's ethics violations found","fingerprint":"be43c3b21e6f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00449","start_s":2031.342,"end_s":2032.363,"video_s":2911.342,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00094","chapter":"C010","text":"are substantiated.","fingerprint":"1e74800cd860","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00450","start_s":2032.404,"end_s":2035.528,"video_s":2912.404,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00094","chapter":"C010","text":"What are the consequences there and who determines that?","fingerprint":"8ff6a9c39a2f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00451","start_s":2040.916,"end_s":2047.265,"video_s":2920.916,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00095","chapter":"C010","text":"Mayor, members of council, all recommendations from the commission ultimately come before you.","fingerprint":"8772ff6a70ac","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00452","start_s":2047.906,"end_s":2052.072,"video_s":2927.906,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00095","chapter":"C010","text":"You're the ones who make the decisions that a violation has been found.","fingerprint":"b8c48ae33a95","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00453","start_s":2052.913,"end_s":2061.265,"video_s":2932.913,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00095","chapter":"C010","text":"And then under that, there could be sanctions, there could be reprimands, there could be anything, but what actually happens comes before you in the end.","fingerprint":"229064fd8504","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00454","start_s":2061.498,"end_s":2080.165,"video_s":2941.498,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00096","chapter":"C010","text":"okay thank you so much um and then my final question is really um around this the amount on this item is there anything we can provide to answer to one of some of the questions that we just heard in public comment on what the expansion of this contract will is looking to really focus on","fingerprint":"845a9953a6ee","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00455","start_s":2082.17,"end_s":2088.105,"video_s":2962.17,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00097","chapter":"C010","text":"Mayor, members of council, this contract was originally approved by you in 2024 in March.","fingerprint":"e2f4ac962786","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00456","start_s":2088.146,"end_s":2097.951,"video_s":2968.146,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00097","chapter":"C010","text":"And basically what this contract does is provide outside counsel because there's a conflict of interest that the city's attorney's office cannot provide","fingerprint":"b86e9de0ab8c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00457","start_s":2098.184,"end_s":2099.926,"video_s":2978.184,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00097","chapter":"C010","text":"all of those entities.","fingerprint":"8943499e3e56","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00458","start_s":2106.793,"end_s":2112.999,"video_s":2986.793,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00097","chapter":"C010","text":"And so this takes care of that conflict or the appearance of impropriety that occurs.","fingerprint":"799af89488de","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00459","start_s":2113.099,"end_s":2115.281,"video_s":2993.099,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00097","chapter":"C010","text":"So that was originally done in 2024.","fingerprint":"6c734890401c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00460","start_s":2115.322,"end_s":2118.345,"video_s":2995.322,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00097","chapter":"C010","text":"It was extended in 2025 out to 2027.","fingerprint":"17c24b9e2f23","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00461","start_s":2118.985,"end_s":2125.592,"video_s":2998.985,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00097","chapter":"C010","text":"And what this does here is add additional money to have that outside counsel continue with their","fingerprint":"eb4e3a4b7763","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00462","start_s":2125.572,"end_s":2128.055,"video_s":3005.572,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00097","chapter":"C010","text":"with their inquiries and their advice to the commission.","fingerprint":"18b3fc3e3112","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00463","start_s":2128.075,"end_s":2132.06,"video_s":3008.075,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00097","chapter":"C010","text":"There's actually two additional complaints that have been filed from what I understand.","fingerprint":"cbfc0eabe1d5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00464","start_s":2132.301,"end_s":2133.302,"video_s":3012.301,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00098","chapter":"C010","text":"Okay, thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f3e96a907f4b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00465","start_s":2135.104,"end_s":2144.957,"video_s":3015.104,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00098","chapter":"C010","text":"You know, I think optically and for the public, right, there exist concerns when we're talking about ethics commission and I don't think that exists just to Phoenix.","fingerprint":"898291fd321b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00466","start_s":2145.378,"end_s":2155.09,"video_s":3025.378,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00098","chapter":"C010","text":"This was the same structure that is modeled at the state legislature where ethics complaints for elected members go through the committees that are","fingerprint":"54fd94ace968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00467","start_s":2155.07,"end_s":2158.435,"video_s":3035.07,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00098","chapter":"C010","text":"all served by the elected members, right?","fingerprint":"e9f03961d438","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00468","start_s":2158.475,"end_s":2176.302,"video_s":3038.475,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00098","chapter":"C010","text":"So I think there's an opportunity across different jurisdictions to really look at how we structure ethics committees to ensure that our residents are seeing those bodies as independent and actually to provide accountability and that if they're submitting things that","fingerprint":"c238d9c2d9fd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00469","start_s":2176.282,"end_s":2203.842,"video_s":3056.282,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00098","chapter":"C010","text":"they feel we are we stepped out of line on that that's truly investigated so I think I have some concerns around the structure we currently have I kind of liken this to you know policing investigating the police themselves ultimately like they are responsible to look into their own policy violations and so this is a little akin to that and it's not like I said it's not just isolated to the city of Phoenix that is also true at the state level and","fingerprint":"204ac594b0ed","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00470","start_s":2203.822,"end_s":2233.626,"video_s":3083.822,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00098","chapter":"C010","text":"I don't know if fiscally this is the right move at this time when it seems like there are some there's a path to correct the structure we have and if we correct that structure the current funding that's allotted for that maybe that would be more effective so like I would like to see us look at the structure and maybe correct that where we can instill some confidence in the public that that body is moving truly independently before we add additional monies to it","fingerprint":"e7467caf7817","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00471","start_s":2233.994,"end_s":2263.478,"video_s":3113.994,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00099","chapter":"C010","text":"that is a wrap on my comments thank you mayor thank you vice mayor thank you I have a couple questions also is it without talking about the actual substance of the work that's being done I think so this is a contract or amendment of a contract to provide additional resources for legal services is it possible to give us high level about some of the work that the corporate the ethics commission has been doing that has resulted in the need for this additional legal services","fingerprint":"56725f71c83d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00472","start_s":2268.335,"end_s":2271.682,"video_s":3148.335,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00100","chapter":"C010","text":"Madam Chair, members of the Council, there's a number of things.","fingerprint":"ecb043812801","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00473","start_s":2272.444,"end_s":2285.112,"video_s":3152.444,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00100","chapter":"C010","text":"Let me start off that outside Council provides advice and counsel to all the members on whatever inquiry comes before them, process, procedure,","fingerprint":"cac06b32f858","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00474","start_s":2285.092,"end_s":2296.43,"video_s":3165.092,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00100","chapter":"C010","text":"In fact, this particular outside counsel can conduct investigations, look into the inquiries specifically, provide advice on those.","fingerprint":"b7f09724e3c6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00475","start_s":2296.51,"end_s":2302.139,"video_s":3176.51,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00100","chapter":"C010","text":"And this is just from my experience because this is all done in executive session.","fingerprint":"aa82b34e6111","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00476","start_s":2302.64,"end_s":2310.492,"video_s":3182.64,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00100","chapter":"C010","text":"So I don't sit in these and I'm just looking at how the contracts are drafted.","fingerprint":"7f3ec5cec0ce","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00477","start_s":2311.754,"end_s":2338.234,"video_s":3191.754,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00101","chapter":"C010","text":"from what I gathered from what you said is I feel like the ethics commission this is my summary so you can tell me if I'm incorrect I feel like the ethics commission given the newness of the role the newness of the procedural structure the newness of what they're being asked I got the impression that they have been asking counsel to make sure that they are going down the right path and have the right procedure in place is that kind of what you are saying in this in this instance","fingerprint":"d0dd9e026cc7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00478","start_s":2341.319,"end_s":2344.903,"video_s":3221.319,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00102","chapter":"C010","text":"Mayor, members of the council, yes and no.","fingerprint":"f4c60a0d6daf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00479","start_s":2344.963,"end_s":2348.267,"video_s":3224.963,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00102","chapter":"C010","text":"They do have to get some direction depending on what the inquiry says.","fingerprint":"cca0263bb00a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00480","start_s":2349.248,"end_s":2362.002,"video_s":3229.248,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00102","chapter":"C010","text":"A lot of this is driven by the procedures they've adopted for themselves, the bylaws they've adopted themselves, which is all drawn from city code, which this body approved quite some time ago.","fingerprint":"78c123e34c30","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00481","start_s":2362.562,"end_s":2369.47,"video_s":3242.562,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00102","chapter":"C010","text":"So there are guidelines, there are processes in place to make sure that everything's done appropriately.","fingerprint":"99daf7cb2e8e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00482","start_s":2369.77,"end_s":2379.06,"video_s":3249.77,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00103","chapter":"C010","text":"And is legal counsel assisting the commission with the actual investigation of these 27 or 29 complaints?","fingerprint":"d6fb3214bdd6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00483","start_s":2380.441,"end_s":2389.05,"video_s":3260.441,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00104","chapter":"C010","text":"Mayor, members of council, if the commission were to vote to move something forward to investigation, then this contract is capable of conducting those investigations.","fingerprint":"0e3ac56473a1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00484","start_s":2389.251,"end_s":2399.001,"video_s":3269.251,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00105","chapter":"C010","text":"And if the determination was made to move something towards an investigation, would that instruction, that direction, be public notice?","fingerprint":"bf5106e8d930","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00485","start_s":2401.58,"end_s":2427.891,"video_s":3281.58,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00106","chapter":"C010","text":"Mayor, members of council the complaints that come in are confidential until they are finalized so once the final determination is made is when they become public and are made public so the the 25 or so that have been reviewed and have come to some form of completion are posted on the website right now okay so I guess I was trying to fill in some blanks for members of the public and and for some for myself also that part of the","fingerprint":"9a0d48c591ec","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00486","start_s":2427.871,"end_s":2453.153,"video_s":3307.871,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00107","chapter":"C010","text":"the services being provided by outside counsel is actually to assist in the investigation to determine whether or not there is validity or no validity to the complaints that have been raised and given the amount of petitions or complaints that we have and the circumstances of each petition that may necessitate the urgency of having additional funds to complete that process","fingerprint":"94ccbfccf0ab","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00487","start_s":2453.521,"end_s":2455.047,"video_s":3333.521,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C010","text":"Mayor, members of council, vice mayor.","fingerprint":"51ae8d1c9e82","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00488","start_s":2455.107,"end_s":2459.504,"video_s":3335.107,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C010","text":"Also, I'd like, if we look currently right now, this outside legal counsel is assisting.","fingerprint":"9e8f9cdad971","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00489","start_s":2459.524,"end_s":2460.569,"video_s":3339.524,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00109","chapter":"C010","text":"But was I correct before you go?","fingerprint":"996d2db9ebde","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00490","start_s":2461.111,"end_s":2461.472,"video_s":3341.111,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00110","chapter":"C010","text":"What was that?","fingerprint":"583bdb214a39","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00491","start_s":2461.638,"end_s":2483.899,"video_s":3341.638,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00110","chapter":"C010","text":"but I was correct you were not in but I don't think you said yes yes okay the one thing I want to add is currently the commission as was mentioned is looking based on that citizen petition at the current rules that they follow and this outside legal counsel is giving advice input feedback to the commission while they're exploring these rules that will eventually come back to this body","fingerprint":"0703af465154","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00492","start_s":2484.335,"end_s":2507.524,"video_s":3364.335,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00111","chapter":"C010","text":"so it's fair to say that outside counsel in essence is also helping the ethics commission in carrying out their responsibilities to be able to investigate more efficiently and independently yes that's correct okay and can you talk a little bit about how the additional hundred and fifty thousand dollars was determined and why this level of funding was appropriate for the needs from the commission through the end of the contract","fingerprint":"44d902ad7d94","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00493","start_s":2509.124,"end_s":2529.681,"video_s":3389.124,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00112","chapter":"C010","text":"Mayor, members of the council, we had reached the maximum amount we were going to spend on this particular contract and we needed some additional funding to continue with not only as Mr. Matthews mentioned the review of the procedures as well as the bylaws but we have a couple of complaints that have come in so they're going to need assistance with those things too.","fingerprint":"d77d19539e86","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00494","start_s":2529.83,"end_s":2554.048,"video_s":3409.83,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00113","chapter":"C010","text":"okay so is it fair to say one of the outcomes that the council and the public can expect if this motion carries with the additional availability of legal counsel is at a minimum some recommendations on the from the response of the citizens petition at a minimum the rule considerations as well as hopefully to resolve the petitions that or the complaints that are pending","fingerprint":"3540f84f9c28","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00495","start_s":2554.872,"end_s":2563.644,"video_s":3434.872,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00114","chapter":"C010","text":"Mayor, members of council, vice mayor, I will say that if the commission determines that they want to make recommendations on rules, those would come forward.","fingerprint":"a789983aa11c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00496","start_s":2563.744,"end_s":2565.767,"video_s":3443.744,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00114","chapter":"C010","text":"That determination has not been made at this time.","fingerprint":"252b7c1b5c86","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00497","start_s":2566.028,"end_s":2577.083,"video_s":3446.028,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00115","chapter":"C010","text":"That's a fair distinction, but the goal is to at least be able to help them to vet and review that information and have council opine to the commission confidentially as to what their recommendation is.","fingerprint":"a3957b929796","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00498","start_s":2577.323,"end_s":2578.265,"video_s":3457.323,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00115","chapter":"C010","text":"That's correct.","fingerprint":"b09e054ee29f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00499","start_s":2578.285,"end_s":2578.385,"video_s":3458.285,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00115","chapter":"C010","text":"Okay.","fingerprint":"6a581ee90118","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00500","start_s":2578.405,"end_s":2578.946,"video_s":3458.405,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00115","chapter":"C010","text":"Thank you, mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00501","start_s":2578.966,"end_s":2579.647,"video_s":3458.966,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00115","chapter":"C010","text":"Those are my questions.","fingerprint":"7407f9a3f5d4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00502","start_s":2579.667,"end_s":2580.167,"video_s":3459.667,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00115","chapter":"C010","text":"Thank you both.","fingerprint":"02f1b7e238f7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00503","start_s":2580.207,"end_s":2581.169,"video_s":3460.207,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00116","chapter":"C010","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00504","start_s":2581.329,"end_s":2581.71,"video_s":3461.329,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00117","chapter":"C010","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00505","start_s":2582.431,"end_s":2582.811,"video_s":3462.431,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00118","chapter":"C010","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00506","start_s":2583.432,"end_s":2584.153,"video_s":3463.432,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00118","chapter":"C010","text":"No.","fingerprint":"9390298f3fb0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00507","start_s":2584.319,"end_s":2584.84,"video_s":3464.319,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00118","chapter":"C010","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00508","start_s":2585.14,"end_s":2585.4,"video_s":3465.14,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00118","chapter":"C010","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00509","start_s":2585.961,"end_s":2586.422,"video_s":3465.961,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00118","chapter":"C010","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00510","start_s":2591.469,"end_s":2592.871,"video_s":3471.469,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00118","chapter":"C010","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00511","start_s":2592.891,"end_s":2593.351,"video_s":3472.891,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00118","chapter":"C010","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00512","start_s":2593.592,"end_s":2593.812,"video_s":3473.592,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00119","chapter":"C010","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00513","start_s":2594.413,"end_s":2594.994,"video_s":3474.413,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00120","chapter":"C010","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00514","start_s":2595.014,"end_s":2595.234,"video_s":3475.014,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00120","chapter":"C010","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00515","start_s":2595.715,"end_s":2596.055,"video_s":3475.715,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00120","chapter":"C010","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00516","start_s":2596.816,"end_s":2596.896,"video_s":3476.816,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00120","chapter":"C010","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00517","start_s":2596.916,"end_s":2597.577,"video_s":3476.916,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00120","chapter":"C010","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00518","start_s":2597.797,"end_s":2598.038,"video_s":3477.797,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00120","chapter":"C010","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00519","start_s":2598.458,"end_s":2598.959,"video_s":3478.458,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00120","chapter":"C010","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00520","start_s":2599.32,"end_s":2599.52,"video_s":3479.32,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00120","chapter":"C010","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00521","start_s":2599.92,"end_s":2600.561,"video_s":3479.92,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00120","chapter":"C010","text":"Passes 7-1.","fingerprint":"f48d99f43c7a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00522","start_s":2602.224,"end_s":2605.708,"video_s":3482.224,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00121","chapter":"C011","text":"We next go to item 35 related to the State Housing Trust Fund.","fingerprint":"8298e141d7bc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00523","start_s":2606.85,"end_s":2607.311,"video_s":3486.85,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00121","chapter":"C011","text":"Vice Mayor?","fingerprint":"9a95bf6095c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00524","start_s":2607.831,"end_s":2609.854,"video_s":3487.831,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00122","chapter":"C011","text":"Motion to approve item 37.","fingerprint":"f8efddf0e2cd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00525","start_s":2611.252,"end_s":2611.754,"video_s":3491.252,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00122","chapter":"C011","text":"Five.","fingerprint":"222b0bd51fce","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00526","start_s":2612.155,"end_s":2612.215,"video_s":3492.155,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00122","chapter":"C011","text":"35.","fingerprint":"9f14025af006","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00527","start_s":2612.235,"end_s":2613.741,"video_s":3492.235,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00122","chapter":"C011","text":"Oh, I'm sorry, 35.","fingerprint":"c459ed72bbaa","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00528","start_s":2613.781,"end_s":2615.366,"video_s":3493.781,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00123","chapter":"C011","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00529","start_s":2615.386,"end_s":2618.136,"video_s":3495.386,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00124","chapter":"C011","text":"Motion to end a second.","fingerprint":"a28656bc57d6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00530","start_s":2618.156,"end_s":2618.477,"video_s":3498.156,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00124","chapter":"C011","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00531","start_s":2621.663,"end_s":2622.144,"video_s":3501.663,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00125","chapter":"C011","text":"Hernandez.","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00532","start_s":2623.065,"end_s":2624.827,"video_s":3503.065,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00125","chapter":"C011","text":"Mayor may I explain my vote?","fingerprint":"81dee9e71c16","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00533","start_s":2624.847,"end_s":2625.387,"video_s":3504.847,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00125","chapter":"C011","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00534","start_s":2625.407,"end_s":2625.968,"video_s":3505.407,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00125","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00535","start_s":2626.468,"end_s":2641.045,"video_s":3506.468,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00125","chapter":"C011","text":"I just want to take a moment to highlight a really amazing item on the agenda today which is this item the proposed $500,000 grant application to support a workforce readiness program and on-site case management and navigation services at the Phoenix Navigation Center.","fingerprint":"d7d9e4d6853f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00536","start_s":2641.806,"end_s":2649.915,"video_s":3521.806,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00125","chapter":"C011","text":"This program would provide daily employment opportunities through the neighborhood brigade workforce readiness program along with case management","fingerprint":"3a09116948aa","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00537","start_s":2649.895,"end_s":2674.063,"video_s":3529.895,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00125","chapter":"C011","text":"on-site navigation services behavioral health support and assistance with housing placement this is the kind of wraparound services and support that really recognizes people as whole human beings and not just as people experiencing homelessness but as people who have goals who have skills who have responsibilities and a real desire to move forward and while I absolutely support","fingerprint":"a579d6252c9d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00538","start_s":2674.043,"end_s":2702.16,"video_s":3554.043,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00125","chapter":"C011","text":"you know us pursuing this grant I also want us to think beyond the grant because this work is continuous and will be continuous until we really solve the issue of homelessness investing into programs like this shows our residents that we are serious about moving people out of homelessness and into a path of stability but more importantly I think it shows the residents that we are putting our money where our mouth is when it comes to this issue so I really want to thank Rachel the entire OHS team","fingerprint":"a1fa82dc79b1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00539","start_s":2702.14,"end_s":2730.73,"video_s":3582.14,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00125","chapter":"C011","text":"for bringing this forward and I want to thank Fund for Empowerment and the many community organizations that really advocate for our unsheltered residents and who continue to come and engage with us in our good in really good partners advocating for dignity for the well-being and for the futures of all of our community thank you so much mayor oh with that I vote yes thank you O'Brien yes Pastor","fingerprint":"25907af52eee","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00540","start_s":2732.498,"end_s":2733.94,"video_s":3612.498,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00126","chapter":"C011","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00541","start_s":2734.04,"end_s":2734.741,"video_s":3614.04,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00126","chapter":"C011","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00542","start_s":2734.761,"end_s":2735.362,"video_s":3614.761,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00126","chapter":"C011","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00543","start_s":2735.382,"end_s":2735.623,"video_s":3615.382,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00126","chapter":"C011","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00544","start_s":2736.103,"end_s":2736.444,"video_s":3616.103,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00126","chapter":"C011","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00545","start_s":2737.325,"end_s":2737.405,"video_s":3617.325,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00126","chapter":"C011","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00546","start_s":2737.425,"end_s":2738.066,"video_s":3617.425,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00126","chapter":"C011","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00547","start_s":2738.206,"end_s":2738.487,"video_s":3618.206,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00127","chapter":"C011","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00548","start_s":2738.908,"end_s":2739.248,"video_s":3618.908,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00127","chapter":"C011","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00549","start_s":2739.689,"end_s":2740.31,"video_s":3619.689,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00128","chapter":"C011","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00550","start_s":2740.33,"end_s":2741.071,"video_s":3620.33,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00129","chapter":"C011","text":"Passes 8-0.","fingerprint":"f9a0ca3f6107","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00551","start_s":2742.673,"end_s":2751.767,"video_s":3622.673,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00130","chapter":"C012","text":"Next is item 46, contract with the Los Angeles Organizing Committee for the 2028 Olympic and Paralympic Games to host Olympic torch relay and related events.","fingerprint":"6700c347dc6d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00552","start_s":2751.887,"end_s":2752.327,"video_s":3631.887,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00130","chapter":"C012","text":"Vice Mayor?","fingerprint":"9a95bf6095c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00553","start_s":2752.868,"end_s":2754.25,"video_s":3632.868,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00131","chapter":"C012","text":"Motion to approve item 46.","fingerprint":"2e00c9cf9653","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00554","start_s":2754.33,"end_s":2755.452,"video_s":3634.33,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00131","chapter":"C012","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00555","start_s":2757.153,"end_s":2766.34,"video_s":3637.153,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00132","chapter":"C012","text":"The United States will host our next Summer Olympics and the city is thrilled about the prospect of participating in LA 28's historic torch relay.","fingerprint":"9b9be6040f61","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00556","start_s":2766.922,"end_s":2771.415,"video_s":3646.922,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00132","chapter":"C012","text":"We're currently working directly with LA 28 regarding the next steps in the consideration process.","fingerprint":"83490ade4c58","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00557","start_s":2772.256,"end_s":2777.761,"video_s":3652.256,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00132","chapter":"C012","text":"This builds on my efforts to make sure Phoenix remains connected with all possibilities for the 2028 Olympics.","fingerprint":"6609db906e20","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00558","start_s":2779.062,"end_s":2787.89,"video_s":3659.062,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00132","chapter":"C012","text":"I have convened a statewide committee to examine opportunities including hosting qualifying events or international teams to train in our market given our close proximity to Los Angeles.","fingerprint":"563758ebdbae","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00559","start_s":2788.391,"end_s":2794.677,"video_s":3668.391,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00132","chapter":"C012","text":"The entire nation can be proud of the games and Phoenix will be honored to play its role in showcasing our community to the world.","fingerprint":"155ab653f102","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00560","start_s":2795.177,"end_s":2800.322,"video_s":3675.177,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00132","chapter":"C012","text":"I've had the pleasure of partnering with Vice Mayor Hodge Washington on these and I'll turn to her for comments.","fingerprint":"f0362dbb5029","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00561","start_s":2800.724,"end_s":2801.406,"video_s":3680.724,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00133","chapter":"C012","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00562","start_s":2801.686,"end_s":2802.208,"video_s":3681.686,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00133","chapter":"C012","text":"I am too.","fingerprint":"b9c49c1d0e5c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00563","start_s":2802.248,"end_s":2812.374,"video_s":3682.248,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00133","chapter":"C012","text":"I'm also very excited to support this item because just having the opportunity to potentially bring the Olympics torch relay to Phoenix would be a tremendous win for our city, especially.","fingerprint":"f029e595847e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00564","start_s":2812.454,"end_s":2816.083,"video_s":3692.454,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00133","chapter":"C012","text":"I know the mayor, as mentioned, has been working very hard on this for some time.","fingerprint":"b7e58ef06f84","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00565","start_s":2816.063,"end_s":2818.968,"video_s":3696.063,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00133","chapter":"C012","text":"and the Olympics represent so much more than competition.","fingerprint":"d221f8b4bb6f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00566","start_s":2819.469,"end_s":2823.677,"video_s":3699.469,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00133","chapter":"C012","text":"It is a recognition of individual and team excellence.","fingerprint":"ad42b76b2db8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00567","start_s":2824.218,"end_s":2828.566,"video_s":3704.218,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00133","chapter":"C012","text":"It also represents perseverance, friendship and the ability to bring people together.","fingerprint":"e4c35f49b741","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00568","start_s":2828.586,"end_s":2832.073,"video_s":3708.586,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00133","chapter":"C012","text":"And I think those are values that we should continue to celebrate here in Phoenix.","fingerprint":"32d7522b8325","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00569","start_s":2832.714,"end_s":2839.827,"video_s":3712.714,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00133","chapter":"C012","text":"I also appreciate as this will potentially give our residents an opportunity to experience a piece of the Olympic games right here in our community.","fingerprint":"6df1e266fd1a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00570","start_s":2839.807,"end_s":2851.308,"video_s":3719.807,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00133","chapter":"C012","text":"So fingers crossed that the torch will one day pass through our Phoenix streets and the associated community celebration will give us a chance to showcase our city once again on a national and international stage.","fingerprint":"827f170a3c07","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00571","start_s":2851.468,"end_s":2852.01,"video_s":3731.468,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00133","chapter":"C012","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00572","start_s":2852.834,"end_s":2854.336,"video_s":3732.834,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00134","chapter":"C012","text":"Thank you, roll call.","fingerprint":"8d1c66eb1cd1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00573","start_s":2854.356,"end_s":2855.718,"video_s":3734.356,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00134","chapter":"C012","text":"Oh, I'm sorry, Councilwoman O'Brien.","fingerprint":"5099387452ee","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00574","start_s":2856.139,"end_s":2856.72,"video_s":3736.139,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00135","chapter":"C012","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00575","start_s":2856.9,"end_s":2862.188,"video_s":3736.9,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00135","chapter":"C012","text":"I am excited to support Phoenix's opportunity to be part of the 2028 Olympic torch relay.","fingerprint":"54b982827977","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00576","start_s":2862.889,"end_s":2871.382,"video_s":3742.889,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00135","chapter":"C012","text":"After the Olympic flame is lit in Olympia, Greece, the birthplace of the games, the flame will travel through all 50 US states for the first time ever.","fingerprint":"378fc0bb0dda","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00577","start_s":2871.442,"end_s":2879.314,"video_s":3751.442,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00135","chapter":"C012","text":"The full route will be announced next year, but with the council's approval today, we know Phoenix will help carry the spirit of friendship across Arizona","fingerprint":"218864ddcc67","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00578","start_s":2879.294,"end_s":2882.677,"video_s":3759.294,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00135","chapter":"C012","text":"and ultimately to Los Angeles for the summer games in 2028.","fingerprint":"0b74fb95bedc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00579","start_s":2884.058,"end_s":2885.74,"video_s":3764.058,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00135","chapter":"C012","text":"Phoenix knows how to welcome the world.","fingerprint":"93fa76a7c662","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00580","start_s":2886.2,"end_s":2890.844,"video_s":3766.2,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00135","chapter":"C012","text":"We've hosted multiple final fours and NBA all-star games along with Super Bowl events.","fingerprint":"3d677554dbe4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00581","start_s":2891.405,"end_s":2896.069,"video_s":3771.405,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00135","chapter":"C012","text":"And every year we attract national and international baseball fans for spring training.","fingerprint":"26c1efe683d3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00582","start_s":2896.749,"end_s":2900.032,"video_s":3776.749,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00135","chapter":"C012","text":"It's fitting for Phoenix to participate in the Olympic torch relay.","fingerprint":"2055157dc362","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00583","start_s":2900.192,"end_s":2909.2,"video_s":3780.192,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00135","chapter":"C012","text":"I'm excited we'll see Phoenix residents line our streets, our kids experience the Olympic flame up close and our community come together for this history making moment.","fingerprint":"26dafa04e4f7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00584","start_s":2909.18,"end_s":2914.031,"video_s":3789.18,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00135","chapter":"C012","text":"When the Olympic flame comes to Phoenix, it will be a new chance for our city to shine on the world stage.","fingerprint":"3e7f3e89edfd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00585","start_s":2914.472,"end_s":2914.973,"video_s":3794.472,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00135","chapter":"C012","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00586","start_s":2916.376,"end_s":2916.797,"video_s":3796.376,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00136","chapter":"C012","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00587","start_s":2916.957,"end_s":2917.318,"video_s":3796.957,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00136","chapter":"C012","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00588","start_s":2918.12,"end_s":2918.5,"video_s":3798.12,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00137","chapter":"C012","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00589","start_s":2918.761,"end_s":2919.803,"video_s":3798.761,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00137","chapter":"C012","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00590","start_s":2919.823,"end_s":2920.184,"video_s":3799.823,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00137","chapter":"C012","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00591","start_s":2920.765,"end_s":2920.986,"video_s":3800.765,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00137","chapter":"C012","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00592","start_s":2921.447,"end_s":2922.008,"video_s":3801.447,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00137","chapter":"C012","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00593","start_s":2923.574,"end_s":2931.363,"video_s":3803.574,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00137","chapter":"C012","text":"Robinson, Stark, Waring, Hodge Washington, Gallego.","fingerprint":"da731b96e197","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00594","start_s":2931.763,"end_s":2932.304,"video_s":3811.763,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00138","chapter":"C012","text":"Passes 8-0.","fingerprint":"f9a0ca3f6107","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00595","start_s":2933.345,"end_s":2941.073,"video_s":3813.345,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00139","chapter":"C013","text":"Next is item 47, authorization to enter into agreements with the DEA for reimbursement for police services, Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"c10c4b280274","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00596","start_s":2941.534,"end_s":2942.935,"video_s":3821.534,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00140","chapter":"C013","text":"Motion to approve item 47.","fingerprint":"6113236eb0aa","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00597","start_s":2942.996,"end_s":2943.356,"video_s":3822.996,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00140","chapter":"C013","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00598","start_s":2944.557,"end_s":2945.578,"video_s":3824.557,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00141","chapter":"C013","text":"We have a motion and a second.","fingerprint":"7451ba811637","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00599","start_s":2945.598,"end_s":2946.139,"video_s":3825.598,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00141","chapter":"C013","text":"Leonard Clark.","fingerprint":"7eb3b62b23e1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00600","start_s":2952.869,"end_s":2954.332,"video_s":3832.869,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00142","chapter":"C013","text":"Thank you, Mayor and Council Members.","fingerprint":"f75bdb69f012","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00601","start_s":2955.414,"end_s":2964.09,"video_s":3835.414,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00142","chapter":"C013","text":"Yes, I do believe in reform of our police department, but I also believe in those officers who have lost their lives defending our citizens.","fingerprint":"52b6627f8999","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00602","start_s":2964.892,"end_s":2966.034,"video_s":3844.892,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00142","chapter":"C013","text":"But we need reform.","fingerprint":"74156bd49eb7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00603","start_s":2966.054,"end_s":2972.987,"video_s":3846.054,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00142","chapter":"C013","text":"But what I'm here to say about right now is I have deep concern because the current federal administration, and I'm not going to say his name,","fingerprint":"c5fbacc081f3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00604","start_s":2973.288,"end_s":2976.052,"video_s":3853.288,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00142","chapter":"C013","text":"We all know who the, we all know who that is.","fingerprint":"601b3b550e0f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00605","start_s":2977.955,"end_s":2986.848,"video_s":3857.955,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00142","chapter":"C013","text":"The federal government's made it official that they're going to use the, they're going to expand the Department of Justice, the Department of, you know, the drug agency here.","fingerprint":"8649bb19545c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00606","start_s":2986.868,"end_s":2989.212,"video_s":3866.868,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00142","chapter":"C013","text":"They're going to expand and work with ICE.","fingerprint":"600165e36b6a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00607","start_s":2990.274,"end_s":3001.27,"video_s":3870.274,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00142","chapter":"C013","text":"Now I understand if ICE happens to meet somebody who's undocumented and doing these illicit drug activities, but what concerns me now with their lawlessness coming from Washington, D.C.,","fingerprint":"88dc89177d18","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00608","start_s":3001.537,"end_s":3031.172,"video_s":3881.537,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00142","chapter":"C013","text":"I do approve this but in the future I am highly concerned about our Phoenix police officers who must keep their constitutional oaths with working with ICE who do not keep their constitutional oaths because DEA it is official has expanded look it up it's right there Department of Justice is now working officially with ICE so I would strongly caution that our officers take stay on the law side enforcing our laws these courageous officers okay and I know we need reforms but","fingerprint":"91f9068258a6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00609","start_s":3031.152,"end_s":3033.174,"video_s":3911.152,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00142","chapter":"C013","text":"We should not be working with ICE.","fingerprint":"4b94273bb242","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00610","start_s":3033.275,"end_s":3039.943,"video_s":3913.275,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00142","chapter":"C013","text":"They are unconstitutional and they are out against the citizens of Phoenix and the American people.","fingerprint":"702fef214c51","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00611","start_s":3040.023,"end_s":3041.525,"video_s":3920.023,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00142","chapter":"C013","text":"So please, no more.","fingerprint":"5a760dc92fb8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00612","start_s":3042.166,"end_s":3044.208,"video_s":3922.166,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00142","chapter":"C013","text":"I think that we need to be highly concerned about that.","fingerprint":"0e18c4743ab8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00613","start_s":3044.308,"end_s":3045.89,"video_s":3924.308,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00142","chapter":"C013","text":"DEA is working with ICE.","fingerprint":"6d414cd29557","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00614","start_s":3045.99,"end_s":3046.571,"video_s":3925.99,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00142","chapter":"C013","text":"It is official.","fingerprint":"efc1fd5fe7eb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00615","start_s":3046.631,"end_s":3046.931,"video_s":3926.631,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00142","chapter":"C013","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00616","start_s":3048.934,"end_s":3049.294,"video_s":3928.934,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00143","chapter":"C013","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00617","start_s":3051.918,"end_s":3053.239,"video_s":3931.918,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00144","chapter":"C013","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00618","start_s":3053.259,"end_s":3053.66,"video_s":3933.259,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00144","chapter":"C013","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00619","start_s":3054.16,"end_s":3054.361,"video_s":3934.16,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00144","chapter":"C013","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00620","start_s":3054.841,"end_s":3055.202,"video_s":3934.841,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00144","chapter":"C013","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00621","start_s":3055.442,"end_s":3056.043,"video_s":3935.442,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00144","chapter":"C013","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00622","start_s":3056.063,"end_s":3056.503,"video_s":3936.063,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00144","chapter":"C013","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00623","start_s":3058.386,"end_s":3058.746,"video_s":3938.386,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00145","chapter":"C013","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00624","start_s":3059.249,"end_s":3059.81,"video_s":3939.249,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00146","chapter":"C013","text":"Robinson.","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00625","start_s":3059.931,"end_s":3060.652,"video_s":3939.931,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00146","chapter":"C013","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00626","start_s":3060.672,"end_s":3061.013,"video_s":3940.672,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00146","chapter":"C013","text":"Stark.","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00627","start_s":3061.414,"end_s":3061.575,"video_s":3941.414,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00146","chapter":"C013","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00628","start_s":3061.996,"end_s":3062.336,"video_s":3941.996,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00146","chapter":"C013","text":"Waring.","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00629","start_s":3063.038,"end_s":3063.118,"video_s":3943.038,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00146","chapter":"C013","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00630","start_s":3063.138,"end_s":3063.84,"video_s":3943.138,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00146","chapter":"C013","text":"Hodge Washington.","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00631","start_s":3064.0,"end_s":3064.281,"video_s":3944.0,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00146","chapter":"C013","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00632","start_s":3064.662,"end_s":3065.063,"video_s":3944.662,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00147","chapter":"C013","text":"Gallego.","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00633","start_s":3065.404,"end_s":3065.604,"video_s":3945.404,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00148","chapter":"C013","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00634","start_s":3065.945,"end_s":3066.827,"video_s":3945.945,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00149","chapter":"C013","text":"Passes 8-0.","fingerprint":"f9a0ca3f6107","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00635","start_s":3067.369,"end_s":3071.298,"video_s":3947.369,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00150","chapter":"C014","text":"Next is item 48, covert track global positioning system units.","fingerprint":"b80bf718e656","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00636","start_s":3071.679,"end_s":3072.06,"video_s":3951.679,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00150","chapter":"C014","text":"Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"9a95bf6095c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00637","start_s":3072.621,"end_s":3074.125,"video_s":3952.621,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00150","chapter":"C014","text":"Motion to approve item 48.","fingerprint":"16a4505d6389","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00638","start_s":3074.806,"end_s":3075.167,"video_s":3954.806,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00150","chapter":"C014","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00639","start_s":3075.809,"end_s":3076.33,"video_s":3955.809,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00150","chapter":"C014","text":"Leonard Clark.","fingerprint":"7eb3b62b23e1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00640","start_s":3080.663,"end_s":3081.044,"video_s":3960.663,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00151","chapter":"C014","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00641","start_s":3081.625,"end_s":3084.25,"video_s":3961.625,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00151","chapter":"C014","text":"Should be my last time speaking except on non-agenda items.","fingerprint":"b193b96d2879","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00642","start_s":3084.49,"end_s":3090.541,"video_s":3964.49,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00151","chapter":"C014","text":"As a former citizen of Phoenix, I understand we need to have tools for our law enforcement to catch the bad hombres.","fingerprint":"5f31b0e66abf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00643","start_s":3092.284,"end_s":3099.297,"video_s":3972.284,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00151","chapter":"C014","text":"But I am concerned now, as we all know about, we all know about what's going on with flock cameras and Peter Thiel","fingerprint":"b4825d0cb53b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00644","start_s":3099.547,"end_s":3119.428,"video_s":3979.547,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00151","chapter":"C014","text":"and Americans being spied on like it's some kind of time out of Romania but this GPS positioning system it says go after suspects so I hope that there are actual judicial warrants that are being used so for example I know you know I've had some investigations by some of your folks in law enforcement come to find out about that","fingerprint":"18c5a998b155","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00645","start_s":3120.556,"end_s":3136.101,"video_s":4000.556,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00151","chapter":"C014","text":"that American citizens such as myself are not without judicial warrant being tracked with these GPS tracking systems and people can roll their eyes but you see it's not a problem until it happens to you and that is what's going on so I am against this I was neutral","fingerprint":"0487e6484e2e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00646","start_s":3136.081,"end_s":3143.995,"video_s":4016.081,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00151","chapter":"C014","text":"I am highly against GPS systems right now because we have a federal government that is out of control spying on American citizens.","fingerprint":"91766ca0eccf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00647","start_s":3144.056,"end_s":3147.422,"video_s":4024.056,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00151","chapter":"C014","text":"It's like something out of the old Romania dictatorship.","fingerprint":"1ff88fde8877","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00648","start_s":3147.442,"end_s":3149.526,"video_s":4027.442,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00151","chapter":"C014","text":"So please, I would vote no on this.","fingerprint":"253251a57bc6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00649","start_s":3149.726,"end_s":3150.347,"video_s":4029.726,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00151","chapter":"C014","text":"I don't like it.","fingerprint":"3025092de6ae","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00650","start_s":3150.427,"end_s":3153.152,"video_s":4030.427,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00151","chapter":"C014","text":"I don't like that American citizens can be tracked unless I can be assured.","fingerprint":"cd4b8005fcc4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00651","start_s":3153.192,"end_s":3160.165,"video_s":4033.192,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00151","chapter":"C014","text":"If you can ask your police people that they must get judicial warrants to get actual suspects, not just who...","fingerprint":"1e2bf7d9f0b1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00652","start_s":3160.55,"end_s":3165.655,"video_s":4040.55,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00151","chapter":"C014","text":"people who are targeted because the federal government doesn't like people like me criticizing you-know-who in Washington, D.C.","fingerprint":"6aee2c5b11f3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00653","start_s":3165.735,"end_s":3166.036,"video_s":4045.735,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00151","chapter":"C014","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00654","start_s":3167.817,"end_s":3168.138,"video_s":4047.817,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00152","chapter":"C014","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00655","start_s":3168.158,"end_s":3168.938,"video_s":4048.158,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00152","chapter":"C014","text":"Councilwoman Hernandez.","fingerprint":"be943e39201c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00656","start_s":3171.181,"end_s":3172.162,"video_s":4051.181,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00153","chapter":"C014","text":"Thank you so much, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d116fbf480ee","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00657","start_s":3172.923,"end_s":3175.465,"video_s":4052.923,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00153","chapter":"C014","text":"Just have a couple questions on this item.","fingerprint":"0fa50e904a3a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00658","start_s":3177.687,"end_s":3183.914,"video_s":4057.687,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00154","chapter":"C014","text":"Mayor, Councilwoman Hernandez, members of the council, Assistant Chief Ed DeCastro, and Commander Saffler are here to answer those questions.","fingerprint":"7194d691b9d3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00659","start_s":3184.194,"end_s":3184.494,"video_s":4064.194,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00155","chapter":"C014","text":"Perfect.","fingerprint":"fafe97f7def3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00660","start_s":3184.514,"end_s":3185.275,"video_s":4064.514,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00155","chapter":"C014","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00661","start_s":3208.222,"end_s":3209.326,"video_s":4088.222,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00155","chapter":"C014","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00662","start_s":3209.687,"end_s":3214.221,"video_s":4089.687,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00155","chapter":"C014","text":"My first question around this is how is the tracking currently being used?","fingerprint":"0b966bf8ed8c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00663","start_s":3217.431,"end_s":3221.083,"video_s":4097.431,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00156","chapter":"C014","text":"Council Member Hernandez.","fingerprint":"dcd25c090e3e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00664","start_s":3221.435,"end_s":3230.788,"video_s":4101.435,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00156","chapter":"C014","text":"What we do right now is every time we place a tracking device, one of these GPS devices, there's an extensive method to do so.","fingerprint":"c62010415c36","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00665","start_s":3231.289,"end_s":3232.971,"video_s":4111.289,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00156","chapter":"C014","text":"There's an affidavit that's filled out.","fingerprint":"112646184e9f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00666","start_s":3233.472,"end_s":3234.433,"video_s":4113.472,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00156","chapter":"C014","text":"It goes before a judge.","fingerprint":"9b73978b83ef","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00667","start_s":3234.493,"end_s":3240.161,"video_s":4114.493,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00156","chapter":"C014","text":"A judge issues a court order on that that establishes there is probable cause that crime has been committed.","fingerprint":"b3792d0cac21","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00668","start_s":3240.762,"end_s":3242.725,"video_s":4120.762,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00156","chapter":"C014","text":"At that point, we will place a tracker.","fingerprint":"27546506a6eb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00669","start_s":3243.226,"end_s":3243.846,"video_s":4123.226,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00157","chapter":"C014","text":"Okay, thank you.","fingerprint":"21d63267fca8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00670","start_s":3243.866,"end_s":3246.67,"video_s":4123.866,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00157","chapter":"C014","text":"And where is that information stored?","fingerprint":"185df02aa402","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00671","start_s":3246.69,"end_s":3250.075,"video_s":4126.69,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00157","chapter":"C014","text":"That's all with the court.","fingerprint":"a5b75d810b3c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00672","start_s":3250.095,"end_s":3250.716,"video_s":4130.095,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00157","chapter":"C014","text":"Okay.","fingerprint":"6a581ee90118","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00673","start_s":3251.084,"end_s":3252.667,"video_s":4131.084,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00157","chapter":"C014","text":"And it only lives with the court?","fingerprint":"078e6f935292","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00674","start_s":3252.687,"end_s":3252.887,"video_s":4132.687,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00157","chapter":"C014","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00675","start_s":3254.089,"end_s":3254.369,"video_s":4134.089,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00157","chapter":"C014","text":"Okay.","fingerprint":"6a581ee90118","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00676","start_s":3254.389,"end_s":3259.698,"video_s":4134.389,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00158","chapter":"C014","text":"And I guess because it lives there, how are we... Councilwoman Hernandez, I'm sorry.","fingerprint":"f3cb4c21abe9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00677","start_s":3261.321,"end_s":3263.284,"video_s":4141.321,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00158","chapter":"C014","text":"It also lives within our RMS system.","fingerprint":"c32e0812a880","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00678","start_s":3263.304,"end_s":3265.768,"video_s":4143.304,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00158","chapter":"C014","text":"So reports are done by us, by the detectives.","fingerprint":"48913c383a80","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00679","start_s":3266.409,"end_s":3269.975,"video_s":4146.409,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00158","chapter":"C014","text":"So it's part of the case report for whatever that crime may be.","fingerprint":"99c42fffea9d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00680","start_s":3270.536,"end_s":3271.457,"video_s":4150.536,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00159","chapter":"C014","text":"Okay.","fingerprint":"6a581ee90118","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00681","start_s":3271.477,"end_s":3271.978,"video_s":4151.477,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00159","chapter":"C014","text":"And...","fingerprint":"6201111b83a0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00682","start_s":3272.633,"end_s":3293.815,"video_s":4152.633,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00159","chapter":"C014","text":"What auditing mechanism do we have around the use of this technology to ensure that access is not being abused to this tool?","fingerprint":"0625e7855e6f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00683","start_s":3295.027,"end_s":3296.95,"video_s":4175.027,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00160","chapter":"C014","text":"Mayor, Council, Council Member Hernandez.","fingerprint":"644a1386a7f1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00684","start_s":3297.491,"end_s":3311.551,"video_s":4177.491,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00160","chapter":"C014","text":"Basically what we do is every time that a detective determines this is an appropriate method of investigation for the case, he writes the affidavit, he or she writes the affidavit, it then goes to the supervisor as well as the lieutenant for the unit.","fingerprint":"d3da177a8851","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00685","start_s":3312.292,"end_s":3323.127,"video_s":4192.292,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00160","chapter":"C014","text":"Depending upon what it is, it can go all the way up the chain to the chiefs and at that point, but basically everybody has a look at this before we make any of those moves.","fingerprint":"2aa15592e25e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00686","start_s":3323.242,"end_s":3323.923,"video_s":4203.242,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00161","chapter":"C014","text":"Okay, thank you.","fingerprint":"21d63267fca8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00687","start_s":3323.963,"end_s":3334.403,"video_s":4203.963,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00161","chapter":"C014","text":"And if there's any misuse there or any gaps in that process that you just walked us through, what measures of accountability are there in place?","fingerprint":"8791d80ae334","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00688","start_s":3337.469,"end_s":3344.322,"video_s":4217.469,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00162","chapter":"C014","text":"Mayor, Council, and Councilwoman Hernandez, essentially what it is is if they're violating policy or the law,","fingerprint":"5659d00dee3c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00689","start_s":3344.403,"end_s":3347.168,"video_s":4224.403,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00162","chapter":"C014","text":"We've got methods to deal with that.","fingerprint":"bb0b5ab888e2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00690","start_s":3347.85,"end_s":3354.222,"video_s":4227.85,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00162","chapter":"C014","text":"We've got our Professional Standards Bureau that deals with any possible internal policy violations.","fingerprint":"7550e612f628","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00691","start_s":3354.663,"end_s":3361.095,"video_s":4234.663,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00162","chapter":"C014","text":"We've also got detectives that if they're breaking the law, we're going to investigate them like we would anyone else.","fingerprint":"6399d1afabd6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00692","start_s":3361.531,"end_s":3362.112,"video_s":4241.531,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00163","chapter":"C014","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00693","start_s":3362.132,"end_s":3379.962,"video_s":4242.132,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00163","chapter":"C014","text":"I just have a lot of concerns around any tool of mass surveillance, especially right now when our communities are calling on us for more accountability and transparency in our police department and with use of all of the surveillance equipment that law enforcement has at their disposal.","fingerprint":"9ea767b0c09c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00694","start_s":3380.844,"end_s":3386.914,"video_s":4260.844,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00163","chapter":"C014","text":"Because what we've seen in a lot of different areas is that there's no proper parameters","fingerprint":"b46c665b8190","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00695","start_s":3386.894,"end_s":3416.547,"video_s":4266.894,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00163","chapter":"C014","text":"that we have been able to put in place to absolutely protect our residents from privacy data breaches and I have a lot of concerns supporting this item for a lot of those reasons right there we're seeing some of our neighboring cities like Chandler like Tempe who are being more bold on their approach and their stance to protect residents with tools of surveillance really of mass surveillance in our communities so just have a lot of concerns on","fingerprint":"dfc7d4e87b22","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00696","start_s":3416.527,"end_s":3419.452,"video_s":4296.527,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00163","chapter":"C014","text":"all of these items without those proper mechanisms in place.","fingerprint":"7027efb3b9bf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00697","start_s":3420.654,"end_s":3423.198,"video_s":4300.654,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00163","chapter":"C014","text":"So I will not be able to support this item today.","fingerprint":"e98cc881504f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00698","start_s":3423.92,"end_s":3424.46,"video_s":4303.92,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00163","chapter":"C014","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00699","start_s":3424.741,"end_s":3425.242,"video_s":4304.741,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00163","chapter":"C014","text":"And thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"8b2076e456c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00700","start_s":3425.262,"end_s":3428.728,"video_s":4305.262,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00164","chapter":"C014","text":"Mayor, Councilwoman Hernandez, I just want to go back to the question.","fingerprint":"9b23e3ad7f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00701","start_s":3428.748,"end_s":3429.609,"video_s":4308.748,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00164","chapter":"C014","text":"I think I understood it now.","fingerprint":"e0c92538b0cf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00702","start_s":3430.09,"end_s":3431.753,"video_s":4310.09,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00164","chapter":"C014","text":"So this is a self-contained system.","fingerprint":"ed86048c999d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00703","start_s":3431.853,"end_s":3436.02,"video_s":4311.853,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00164","chapter":"C014","text":"The only people that have access to the information from these","fingerprint":"4483f6126676","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00704","start_s":3436.0,"end_s":3439.584,"video_s":4316.0,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00164","chapter":"C014","text":"and the other GPS tools that we have are us, the detectives.","fingerprint":"3e7c05e17feb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00705","start_s":3440.084,"end_s":3443.648,"video_s":4320.084,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00164","chapter":"C014","text":"So this doesn't go out, nobody can log in, it's simply us.","fingerprint":"aeb7945e17be","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00706","start_s":3443.768,"end_s":3448.293,"video_s":4323.768,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00164","chapter":"C014","text":"And this is not a mass surveillance tool, this is a very targeted surveillance tool.","fingerprint":"ca725fcf45f5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00707","start_s":3448.694,"end_s":3458.685,"video_s":4328.694,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00164","chapter":"C014","text":"So we go and we get warrants to be able to put it on very specific suspects that we're looking for that are part of homicides, robberies, human trafficking, drug trafficking.","fingerprint":"c869a357040b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00708","start_s":3459.305,"end_s":3462.889,"video_s":4339.305,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00164","chapter":"C014","text":"And when we get the permission from the judge, we put it on those specific vehicles.","fingerprint":"faecb6e784c2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00709","start_s":3462.909,"end_s":3465.332,"video_s":4342.909,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00164","chapter":"C014","text":"So it goes to nobody else but us.","fingerprint":"1356f117f14b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00710","start_s":3465.464,"end_s":3466.047,"video_s":4345.464,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00165","chapter":"C014","text":"Okay, thank you.","fingerprint":"21d63267fca8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00711","start_s":3466.067,"end_s":3466.751,"video_s":4346.067,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00165","chapter":"C014","text":"I appreciate that.","fingerprint":"71662770e13c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00712","start_s":3467.294,"end_s":3469.807,"video_s":4347.294,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00165","chapter":"C014","text":"But it's still a tool of the surveillance state.","fingerprint":"5cd5a0e1f727","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00713","start_s":3470.29,"end_s":3471.898,"video_s":4350.29,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00165","chapter":"C014","text":"And so my concerns still exist.","fingerprint":"12bb6daffd02","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00714","start_s":3472.26,"end_s":3472.622,"video_s":4352.26,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00165","chapter":"C014","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00715","start_s":3474.121,"end_s":3475.183,"video_s":4354.121,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00166","chapter":"C014","text":"Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"9a95bf6095c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00716","start_s":3475.203,"end_s":3475.723,"video_s":4355.203,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00167","chapter":"C014","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00717","start_s":3475.884,"end_s":3484.997,"video_s":4355.884,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00167","chapter":"C014","text":"I was going to ask that question because I was my understanding that this is not like a it's not like flock cameras where you're surveilling every vehicle that passes through intersection.","fingerprint":"eabe440b217e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00718","start_s":3485.418,"end_s":3495.233,"video_s":4365.418,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00167","chapter":"C014","text":"My understanding of this is it's more similar to like a micro tracker, similar to vehicles that have been, for example, leased and have not been fully paid off.","fingerprint":"b570ad22205c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00719","start_s":3495.694,"end_s":3501.883,"video_s":4375.694,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00167","chapter":"C014","text":"Sometimes the owner of the vehicle will put a tracking device on that vehicle so they know where that vehicle is at that time.","fingerprint":"d777bbf993f1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00720","start_s":3502.336,"end_s":3506.47,"video_s":4382.336,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00167","chapter":"C014","text":"So it's an actual physical apparatus that is attached to a specific vehicle, is that correct?","fingerprint":"b8e71c66b09f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00721","start_s":3509.159,"end_s":3512.47,"video_s":4389.159,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00168","chapter":"C014","text":"Mayor, Councilwoman Hodge-Washington, yes, correct.","fingerprint":"be94b3be712a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00722","start_s":3512.49,"end_s":3515.62,"video_s":4392.49,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00168","chapter":"C014","text":"It is a physical that is specific to that particular vehicle.","fingerprint":"7ab200fd3848","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00723","start_s":3515.903,"end_s":3523.694,"video_s":4395.903,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00169","chapter":"C014","text":"And before that tracker is affixed to a vehicle, you file a petition with the courts.","fingerprint":"3793294b9d7b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00724","start_s":3523.734,"end_s":3543.542,"video_s":4403.734,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00169","chapter":"C014","text":"You outline the probable cause as to why you believe not only that a crime has occurred or is in progress, but you also identify why you believe that specific vehicle is involved and why you believe that tracking is necessary in order to apprehend or to document the criminal activity that's suspected, correct?","fingerprint":"8ad7317328a5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00725","start_s":3543.562,"end_s":3543.902,"video_s":4423.562,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00169","chapter":"C014","text":"That is correct.","fingerprint":"a388af4f4e99","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00726","start_s":3543.882,"end_s":3555.49,"video_s":4423.882,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00169","chapter":"C014","text":"Okay, and it's only after a judicial officer has issued, you called it a court order or a warrant, is at that juncture when the microtracker is attached to the vehicle, correct?","fingerprint":"0e98b58525e7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00727","start_s":3555.51,"end_s":3555.691,"video_s":4435.51,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00169","chapter":"C014","text":"Correct.","fingerprint":"15a596e3c98c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00728","start_s":3556.372,"end_s":3560.322,"video_s":4436.372,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00169","chapter":"C014","text":"And what happens if a judge says you don't have enough probable cause?","fingerprint":"2e0263d3d8a6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00729","start_s":3560.943,"end_s":3568.436,"video_s":4440.943,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00170","chapter":"C014","text":"then we go back and we do more investigating to see if we can find it or we find other avenues to be able to try to find the suspect.","fingerprint":"0a83be51c92f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00730","start_s":3568.676,"end_s":3568.977,"video_s":4448.676,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00171","chapter":"C014","text":"Okay.","fingerprint":"6a581ee90118","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00731","start_s":3569.318,"end_s":3576.53,"video_s":4449.318,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00171","chapter":"C014","text":"And it's also my understanding that these trackers have a certain shelf life for lack of a better word.","fingerprint":"7eba227f9837","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00732","start_s":3576.55,"end_s":3577.993,"video_s":4456.55,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00171","chapter":"C014","text":"Can you tell me what the shelf life is for that?","fingerprint":"7294e3291e4a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00733","start_s":3578.754,"end_s":3581.719,"video_s":4458.754,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00172","chapter":"C014","text":"That I will hand over to Commander Saffler.","fingerprint":"18cb35e28a80","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00734","start_s":3582.678,"end_s":3594.122,"video_s":4462.678,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00173","chapter":"C014","text":"Mayor, Councilwoman, basically what it is is they're a battery operated device and so depending upon how far it goes, how long it goes,","fingerprint":"1b21d755d909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00735","start_s":3594.44,"end_s":3623.451,"video_s":4474.44,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00174","chapter":"C014","text":"but there's a there is a shelf life it could be anywhere from three days to about 30 days so it's not an indefinite tracker that last okay that's what I wanted to make sure I understood as well okay thank you for those clarifications I appreciate that thank you mayor thank you so much roll call Hernandez no O'Brien yes Pastor yes Robinson yes","fingerprint":"5fb89bcd4222","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00736","start_s":3623.971,"end_s":3624.613,"video_s":4503.971,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00175","chapter":"C014","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00737","start_s":3624.633,"end_s":3625.375,"video_s":4504.633,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00175","chapter":"C014","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00738","start_s":3625.395,"end_s":3625.675,"video_s":4505.395,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00175","chapter":"C014","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00739","start_s":3626.658,"end_s":3626.738,"video_s":4506.658,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00175","chapter":"C014","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00740","start_s":3626.758,"end_s":3627.4,"video_s":4506.758,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00175","chapter":"C014","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00741","start_s":3627.56,"end_s":3627.801,"video_s":4507.56,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00175","chapter":"C014","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00742","start_s":3628.282,"end_s":3628.723,"video_s":4508.282,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00175","chapter":"C014","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00743","start_s":3628.903,"end_s":3629.084,"video_s":4508.903,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00175","chapter":"C014","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00744","start_s":3629.565,"end_s":3630.287,"video_s":4509.565,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00175","chapter":"C014","text":"Passes 7-1.","fingerprint":"f48d99f43c7a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00745","start_s":3631.53,"end_s":3635.44,"video_s":4511.53,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00176","chapter":"C015","text":"Item 57 is Backflow Assembly Testing Repair and Replacement Services.","fingerprint":"7426f89d3bed","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00746","start_s":3635.58,"end_s":3635.981,"video_s":4515.58,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00176","chapter":"C015","text":"Vice Mayor?","fingerprint":"9a95bf6095c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00747","start_s":3636.342,"end_s":3637.786,"video_s":4516.342,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00177","chapter":"C015","text":"Motion to approve item 57.","fingerprint":"8ad0a42f904a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00748","start_s":3638.427,"end_s":3638.808,"video_s":4518.427,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00177","chapter":"C015","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00749","start_s":3639.43,"end_s":3640.292,"video_s":4519.43,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00177","chapter":"C015","text":"Tammy Weaver?","fingerprint":"188dd0cc0ba0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00750","start_s":3647.714,"end_s":3651.655,"video_s":4527.714,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00178","chapter":"C015","text":"Tammy, so I'm speaking on item number, can you hear me?","fingerprint":"c20b1688dac2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00751","start_s":3652.097,"end_s":3654.349,"video_s":4532.097,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00178","chapter":"C015","text":"Yes, it's the backflow assembly testing.","fingerprint":"ef1faa2e8a9a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00752","start_s":3656.152,"end_s":3656.733,"video_s":4536.152,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00179","chapter":"C015","text":"Okay, thank you.","fingerprint":"21d63267fca8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00753","start_s":3657.293,"end_s":3658.435,"video_s":4537.293,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00179","chapter":"C015","text":"It's very difficult to hear.","fingerprint":"28dc3dc23f80","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00754","start_s":3658.475,"end_s":3660.597,"video_s":4538.475,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00179","chapter":"C015","text":"I support the city testing.","fingerprint":"02376516b1db","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00755","start_s":3660.958,"end_s":3665.023,"video_s":4540.958,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00179","chapter":"C015","text":"I'm a resident of North Phoenix and I'm speaking on my own behalf.","fingerprint":"0242b3887d27","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00756","start_s":3665.143,"end_s":3667.405,"video_s":4545.143,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00179","chapter":"C015","text":"I support the city testing its own backload devices.","fingerprint":"1b3e10b40a0d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00757","start_s":3668.126,"end_s":3672.532,"video_s":4548.126,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00179","chapter":"C015","text":"It's the second increase this year and it shows how much testing is needed to keep the water supply safe.","fingerprint":"ce4faacc6899","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00758","start_s":3673.172,"end_s":3675.395,"video_s":4553.172,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00179","chapter":"C015","text":"But the city only pays to test its own devices.","fingerprint":"0b4b6bbeef27","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00759","start_s":3675.896,"end_s":3681.282,"video_s":4555.896,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00179","chapter":"C015","text":"Where I love making sure backload devices actually get tested falls largely on volunteer residents.","fingerprint":"96662cfa5ead","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00760","start_s":3681.262,"end_s":3709.53,"video_s":4561.262,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00179","chapter":"C015","text":"backflow prevention protects everyone's drinking water not just one property with heavy industry like tsmc now connected to the same system the city should take ownership i'd ask for three three three things first a city-run record of every required backflow device and its test date second direct notice to owners who are overdue third an annual public report on compliance with industrial and high hazard connections listed separately water quality shouldn't depend on volunteers","fingerprint":"2f3b205dfb12","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00761","start_s":3709.51,"end_s":3718.261,"video_s":4589.51,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00179","chapter":"C015","text":"and lastly I did sign up to speak on the item earlier about ethics but I was not called on to speak during my my time.","fingerprint":"f982bf10e3be","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00762","start_s":3720.964,"end_s":3729.595,"video_s":4600.964,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00180","chapter":"C015","text":"Thank you if you sign up available to speak if necessary then we call on you if people have questions.","fingerprint":"84dbc778ffe3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00763","start_s":3729.615,"end_s":3730.596,"video_s":4609.615,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00180","chapter":"C015","text":"All right roll call.","fingerprint":"5d88818c1d17","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00764","start_s":3732.538,"end_s":3733.339,"video_s":4612.538,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C015","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00765","start_s":3733.359,"end_s":3734.12,"video_s":4613.359,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C015","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00766","start_s":3734.14,"end_s":3735.062,"video_s":4614.14,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C015","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00767","start_s":3735.082,"end_s":3735.302,"video_s":4615.082,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C015","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00768","start_s":3735.802,"end_s":3736.243,"video_s":4615.802,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C015","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00769","start_s":3738.012,"end_s":3738.933,"video_s":4618.012,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C015","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00770","start_s":3738.953,"end_s":3739.454,"video_s":4618.953,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C015","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00771","start_s":3739.594,"end_s":3739.854,"video_s":4619.594,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C015","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00772","start_s":3740.335,"end_s":3740.675,"video_s":4620.335,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C015","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00773","start_s":3741.857,"end_s":3741.977,"video_s":4621.857,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C015","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00774","start_s":3741.997,"end_s":3742.157,"video_s":4621.997,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C015","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00775","start_s":3742.818,"end_s":3742.898,"video_s":4622.818,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C015","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00776","start_s":3742.918,"end_s":3743.639,"video_s":4622.918,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C015","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00777","start_s":3743.8,"end_s":3744.06,"video_s":4623.8,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C015","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00778","start_s":3744.4,"end_s":3744.861,"video_s":4624.4,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C015","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00779","start_s":3745.522,"end_s":3745.722,"video_s":4625.522,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C015","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00780","start_s":3746.063,"end_s":3746.904,"video_s":4626.063,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C015","text":"Passes 8-0.","fingerprint":"f9a0ca3f6107","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00781","start_s":3751.409,"end_s":3754.574,"video_s":4631.409,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00182","chapter":"C016","text":"Item 70, Water Services Department Engineering On Call.","fingerprint":"b947fdad82a2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00782","start_s":3755.074,"end_s":3755.515,"video_s":4635.074,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00182","chapter":"C016","text":"Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"9a95bf6095c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00783","start_s":3757.217,"end_s":3760.722,"video_s":4637.217,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00183","chapter":"C016","text":"Motion to approve item 70.","fingerprint":"845294417f22","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00784","start_s":3761.082,"end_s":3761.463,"video_s":4641.082,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00183","chapter":"C016","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00785","start_s":3763.125,"end_s":3764.406,"video_s":4643.125,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00184","chapter":"C016","text":"We have a motion and a second.","fingerprint":"7451ba811637","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00786","start_s":3764.447,"end_s":3764.847,"video_s":4644.447,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00184","chapter":"C016","text":"Tammy?","fingerprint":"9d31047cacc8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00787","start_s":3769.113,"end_s":3777.06,"video_s":4649.113,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00185","chapter":"C016","text":"Up to $100 million in engineering contracts paid for the water services capital budget, which my water and sewer rates will help fund.","fingerprint":"0304a0c97ff4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00788","start_s":3777.661,"end_s":3786.649,"video_s":4657.661,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00185","chapter":"C016","text":"The rate process starts in November, but before then, I'd ask staff to say publicly how much of this work is for North Gateway and TSMC-related infrastructure.","fingerprint":"e88a9a74b844","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00789","start_s":3787.189,"end_s":3797.398,"video_s":4667.189,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00185","chapter":"C016","text":"I'd also ask how the North Gateway purification plant's remaining balance, about $586 million after the federal grant, will be split between existing ratepayers, impact fees, and partners.","fingerprint":"490b66bea690","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00790","start_s":3797.767,"end_s":3799.91,"video_s":4677.767,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00185","chapter":"C016","text":"I shouldn't have to learn the answer from my water bill.","fingerprint":"3a7b6e63da08","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00791","start_s":3800.15,"end_s":3800.49,"video_s":4680.15,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00185","chapter":"C016","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00792","start_s":3801.832,"end_s":3802.173,"video_s":4681.832,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00185","chapter":"C016","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00793","start_s":3802.313,"end_s":3803.534,"video_s":4682.313,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00186","chapter":"C016","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00794","start_s":3803.554,"end_s":3803.935,"video_s":4683.554,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00186","chapter":"C016","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00795","start_s":3804.555,"end_s":3804.776,"video_s":4684.555,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00186","chapter":"C016","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00796","start_s":3805.356,"end_s":3805.757,"video_s":4685.356,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00186","chapter":"C016","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00797","start_s":3805.997,"end_s":3806.258,"video_s":4685.997,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00186","chapter":"C016","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00798","start_s":3806.738,"end_s":3807.159,"video_s":4686.738,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00186","chapter":"C016","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00799","start_s":3809.902,"end_s":3810.723,"video_s":4689.902,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00186","chapter":"C016","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00800","start_s":3810.743,"end_s":3811.324,"video_s":4690.743,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00186","chapter":"C016","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00801","start_s":3811.344,"end_s":3811.584,"video_s":4691.344,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00186","chapter":"C016","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00802","start_s":3812.045,"end_s":3812.405,"video_s":4692.045,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00186","chapter":"C016","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00803","start_s":3812.786,"end_s":3813.487,"video_s":4692.786,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00187","chapter":"C016","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00804","start_s":3813.507,"end_s":3814.528,"video_s":4693.507,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00188","chapter":"C016","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00805","start_s":3814.548,"end_s":3814.628,"video_s":4694.548,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00188","chapter":"C016","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00806","start_s":3814.648,"end_s":3815.269,"video_s":4694.648,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00188","chapter":"C016","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00807","start_s":3815.489,"end_s":3815.709,"video_s":4695.489,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00188","chapter":"C016","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00808","start_s":3816.17,"end_s":3816.55,"video_s":4696.17,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00188","chapter":"C016","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00809","start_s":3816.991,"end_s":3817.231,"video_s":4696.991,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00188","chapter":"C016","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00810","start_s":3817.692,"end_s":3818.593,"video_s":4697.692,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00188","chapter":"C016","text":"Passes 8-0.","fingerprint":"f9a0ca3f6107","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00811","start_s":3821.037,"end_s":3829.797,"video_s":4701.037,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00189","chapter":"C017","text":"Next we go to item 74, retroactive approval to apply for an Arizona State Historic Preservation Office certified local government pass through grant for federal fiscal year.","fingerprint":"8d2214a28a30","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00812","start_s":3831.3,"end_s":3831.701,"video_s":4711.3,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00189","chapter":"C017","text":"Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"9a95bf6095c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00813","start_s":3832.242,"end_s":3833.605,"video_s":4712.242,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00190","chapter":"C017","text":"Motion to approve item 74.","fingerprint":"3d5b767199fe","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00814","start_s":3834.147,"end_s":3834.547,"video_s":4714.147,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00190","chapter":"C017","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00815","start_s":3835.089,"end_s":3836.392,"video_s":4715.089,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00191","chapter":"C017","text":"Motion and a second.","fingerprint":"9b5eb76aa224","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00816","start_s":3837.394,"end_s":3838.336,"video_s":4717.394,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00191","chapter":"C017","text":"We have two comments.","fingerprint":"84ceaed0c4f1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00817","start_s":3838.356,"end_s":3840.16,"video_s":4718.356,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00191","chapter":"C017","text":"We'll start with Kristen followed by Jeremy.","fingerprint":"57e7fa7378fe","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00818","start_s":3851.092,"end_s":3868.324,"video_s":4731.092,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C017","text":"So item 74 reads as if you're applying for a $20,000 federal grant, but if you look at the number beside it, the city is putting in $175,000.","fingerprint":"71553fea4ff7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00819","start_s":3868.743,"end_s":3870.347,"video_s":4748.743,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C017","text":"You are not receiving money on this item.","fingerprint":"7f84d3ac7ece","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00820","start_s":3870.387,"end_s":3872.01,"video_s":4750.387,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C017","text":"You are spending it 9 to 1.","fingerprint":"eab031c53dae","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00821","start_s":3872.071,"end_s":3874.376,"video_s":4752.071,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C017","text":"That match is not required.","fingerprint":"5211bee6a3db","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00822","start_s":3874.416,"end_s":3876.941,"video_s":4754.416,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C017","text":"These pass-throughs run 60-40.","fingerprint":"0cba94a148ee","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00823","start_s":3876.982,"end_s":3882.113,"video_s":4756.982,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C017","text":"So a $20,000 federal share requires about $13,000 from the city.","fingerprint":"1111117835a7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00824","start_s":3882.855,"end_s":3885.621,"video_s":4762.855,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C017","text":"You are volunteering 13 times that.","fingerprint":"d83f0e61830e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00825","start_s":3886.023,"end_s":3895.621,"video_s":4766.023,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C017","text":"To put it bluntly, $75,000 per mile for a report about a dirt path, not the repair, a report.","fingerprint":"991ed597763c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00826","start_s":3896.462,"end_s":3897.364,"video_s":4776.462,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C017","text":"So now for the dates.","fingerprint":"8d690b51414b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00827","start_s":3897.444,"end_s":3904.236,"video_s":4777.444,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C017","text":"The application deadline was October 17 of last year, and the final extended deadline was June 30 of this year.","fingerprint":"a1138cdff7a4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00828","start_s":3904.657,"end_s":3908.925,"video_s":4784.657,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C017","text":"So you're being asked to authorize the application today.","fingerprint":"f932bff2b16e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00829","start_s":3908.905,"end_s":3913.209,"video_s":4788.905,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C017","text":"So either it went in without your authorization or it never went in.","fingerprint":"d25b57bd21dd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00830","start_s":3913.589,"end_s":3915.611,"video_s":4793.589,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C017","text":"So the report does not say which.","fingerprint":"ee5273cb72da","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00831","start_s":3916.251,"end_s":3920.035,"video_s":4796.251,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C017","text":"So I ask that you please ask that before you vote.","fingerprint":"ccbe6f64434d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00832","start_s":3920.615,"end_s":3931.985,"video_s":4800.615,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C017","text":"One fact that's not in your packet, the neighborhood association whose support letter you were given is a registered lobbying principal before the city represented by a paid government affairs firm.","fingerprint":"1562e7b5cd15","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00833","start_s":3932.005,"end_s":3934.327,"video_s":4812.005,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C017","text":"So it's in your own clerk's registry.","fingerprint":"59d62bc6fda2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00834","start_s":3934.527,"end_s":3937.41,"video_s":4814.527,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C017","text":"One line in the report would have told you that.","fingerprint":"46bb64ef0628","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00835","start_s":3937.576,"end_s":3940.06,"video_s":4817.576,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C017","text":"Lastly, nine homes front that path.","fingerprint":"ac850fb9b829","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00836","start_s":3940.762,"end_s":3949.276,"video_s":4820.762,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C017","text":"Every one of those is a historic property class, so they're already assessed at half the ordinary rate, so they avoid $64,600 in a tax year.","fingerprint":"fd1d2ce7a669","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00837","start_s":3950.659,"end_s":3953.684,"video_s":4830.659,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C017","text":"Phoenix's share of that across 15 years is roughly $156,000.","fingerprint":"078ad8dfed2b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00838","start_s":3954.024,"end_s":3960.175,"video_s":4834.024,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C017","text":"So item 74 asks for $175,000.","fingerprint":"2c280f78c42d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00839","start_s":3960.678,"end_s":3968.029,"video_s":4840.678,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C017","text":"You would spend more studying that corridor than this city has ever given up in tax for the nine owners who front that path.","fingerprint":"458cd4b8fb65","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00840","start_s":3968.87,"end_s":3969.271,"video_s":4848.87,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C017","text":"Twice.","fingerprint":"dc8ffdbf2736","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00841","start_s":3969.751,"end_s":3971.013,"video_s":4849.751,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C017","text":"The same street, same object.","fingerprint":"7c9f9c88dbdd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00842","start_s":3972.255,"end_s":3974.358,"video_s":4852.255,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C017","text":"That's what preservation has become.","fingerprint":"528a700d78d4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00843","start_s":3974.598,"end_s":3975.88,"video_s":4854.598,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C017","text":"We're not saving buildings.","fingerprint":"493c3e4fe403","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00844","start_s":3976.481,"end_s":3981.128,"video_s":4856.481,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C017","text":"It is a transfer upward to the most protected property on the block.","fingerprint":"c00f5a1f2e34","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00845","start_s":3981.528,"end_s":3983.131,"video_s":4861.528,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C017","text":"Please vote no on 74.","fingerprint":"7b3c1134b968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00846","start_s":3983.171,"end_s":3983.611,"video_s":4863.171,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C017","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00847","start_s":3986.015,"end_s":3986.736,"video_s":4866.015,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00193","chapter":"C017","text":"Jeremy is next.","fingerprint":"29ca4e719ae0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00848","start_s":3994.985,"end_s":4007.161,"video_s":4874.985,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00194","chapter":"C017","text":"There's nothing illegal going on here, but spending $175,000 on a study for a problem that doesn't exist in one of the richest neighborhoods in Phoenix doesn't make any sense.","fingerprint":"1016e00b532c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00849","start_s":4009.404,"end_s":4012.428,"video_s":4889.404,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00194","chapter":"C017","text":"What Kristen said was that we've got nine historic homes.","fingerprint":"5142b425e389","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00850","start_s":4012.488,"end_s":4013.689,"video_s":4892.488,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00194","chapter":"C017","text":"We've got more than that, by the way.","fingerprint":"e14679605e3a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00851","start_s":4014.07,"end_s":4015.512,"video_s":4894.07,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00194","chapter":"C017","text":"We just measured nine.","fingerprint":"8c32e6c27ea7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00852","start_s":4016.173,"end_s":4021.92,"video_s":4896.173,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00194","chapter":"C017","text":"The average home that abuts the bridal path is $1.9 million.","fingerprint":"bc5cc700bbec","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00853","start_s":4023.622,"end_s":4050.118,"video_s":4903.622,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00194","chapter":"C017","text":"they pay half the property tax of everyone else the 99 percent of people that own homes in this city why are we subsidizing those people why are we subsidizing people with two million one of the homes is 4.4 million dollars they pay half the property tax if we just collected the property tax which the reason they pay half is to protect their homes for maintenance","fingerprint":"827b13f22949","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00854","start_s":4052.073,"end_s":4053.374,"video_s":4932.073,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00194","chapter":"C017","text":"What the hell are we doing with the dirt path?","fingerprint":"259c53523c3f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00855","start_s":4053.535,"end_s":4053.935,"video_s":4933.535,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00194","chapter":"C017","text":"Maintenance?","fingerprint":"8589c63b0943","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00856","start_s":4055.156,"end_s":4056.057,"video_s":4935.156,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00194","chapter":"C017","text":"So we're paying double?","fingerprint":"874f29bfef3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00857","start_s":4056.177,"end_s":4058.52,"video_s":4936.177,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00194","chapter":"C017","text":"We're discounting it and we're paying for it?","fingerprint":"3473a6110fa4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00858","start_s":4059.701,"end_s":4060.522,"video_s":4939.701,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00194","chapter":"C017","text":"What's the point of this?","fingerprint":"68501f1320c0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00859","start_s":4061.083,"end_s":4063.525,"video_s":4941.083,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00194","chapter":"C017","text":"This money could be used so much better.","fingerprint":"54f4ff01c723","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00860","start_s":4065.287,"end_s":4071.173,"video_s":4945.287,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00194","chapter":"C017","text":"Take it, divide it, make first time down payments for people that actually need protection.","fingerprint":"229ec8d96093","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00861","start_s":4072.435,"end_s":4075.898,"video_s":4952.435,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00194","chapter":"C017","text":"Not people with $4 million houses that don't.","fingerprint":"c259495d1233","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00862","start_s":4076.619,"end_s":4081.084,"video_s":4956.619,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00194","chapter":"C017","text":"The bridal path is a luxury and those people can afford to pay for it.","fingerprint":"b095c1a9a68b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00863","start_s":4081.25,"end_s":4084.665,"video_s":4961.25,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00194","chapter":"C017","text":"or at least pay their share of what they should be to start.","fingerprint":"adb65546c69e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00864","start_s":4085.067,"end_s":4085.308,"video_s":4965.067,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00194","chapter":"C017","text":"Thanks.","fingerprint":"a6a2729cbf6b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00865","start_s":4087.678,"end_s":4088.04,"video_s":4967.678,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00195","chapter":"C017","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00866","start_s":4088.401,"end_s":4089.285,"video_s":4968.401,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00195","chapter":"C017","text":"Councilman Robinson.","fingerprint":"bd39baebf63f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00867","start_s":4090.447,"end_s":4091.088,"video_s":4970.447,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00196","chapter":"C017","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00868","start_s":4092.109,"end_s":4100.461,"video_s":4972.109,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00196","chapter":"C017","text":"You know, I'm pleased to support this grant request because it helps us take the first steps toward its long-term preservation of the Murphy Bridal Path.","fingerprint":"6d039abed9c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00869","start_s":4100.901,"end_s":4104.306,"video_s":4980.901,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00196","chapter":"C017","text":"The funding gives us the ability to address some very practical needs.","fingerprint":"b9f3eb78cf01","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00870","start_s":4104.987,"end_s":4113.619,"video_s":4984.987,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00196","chapter":"C017","text":"The Murphy Bridal Path is a valued asset for Central Phoenix and for our entire city, but like any outstanding or long-standing public space,","fingerprint":"28906963f042","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00871","start_s":4113.599,"end_s":4115.544,"video_s":4993.599,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00196","chapter":"C017","text":"It faces real maintenance challenges.","fingerprint":"41c53a7099d5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00872","start_s":4116.125,"end_s":4129.718,"video_s":4996.125,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00196","chapter":"C017","text":"The grant will allow the city to study existing conditions and provide thoughtful recommendations that protect the past historic character while enhancing safety and usability for everyone to enjoy it.","fingerprint":"ba4c99ef41dd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00873","start_s":4129.698,"end_s":4131.782,"video_s":5009.698,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00196","chapter":"C017","text":"These will not be cosmetic upgrades.","fingerprint":"01896ac10cfc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00874","start_s":4132.022,"end_s":4138.995,"video_s":5012.022,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00196","chapter":"C017","text":"They're essential steps to ensure that the path remains safe, accessible, and functional for the community.","fingerprint":"3de8b2ee98dc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00875","start_s":4139.796,"end_s":4149.934,"video_s":5019.796,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00196","chapter":"C017","text":"This study will give us a clear roadmap as we continue working together to ensure the bridal path remains a safe, beautiful, and well-maintained resource for generations to come.","fingerprint":"f0a0cf6cd26d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00876","start_s":4150.336,"end_s":4165.218,"video_s":5030.336,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00196","chapter":"C017","text":"Now I want to thank the community leaders, and there were a ton of them, as well as community leaders and their neighbors who have been strong champions for this effort and submitted letters of support to help move this project further, or move the project forward.","fingerprint":"7036ae30dd0b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00877","start_s":4165.538,"end_s":4171.507,"video_s":5045.538,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00196","chapter":"C017","text":"I look forward to seeing the results of the study and to continue the work of protecting this important community resource.","fingerprint":"3453539f72b4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00878","start_s":4172.188,"end_s":4177.035,"video_s":5052.188,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00196","chapter":"C017","text":"With that, Mayor, I would like to move approval of item 74, which it already has, but I will be voting yes.","fingerprint":"c7b6aca3d0a1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00879","start_s":4177.435,"end_s":4178.537,"video_s":5057.435,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00196","chapter":"C017","text":"Thank you for the time.","fingerprint":"6467cdd004ea","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00880","start_s":4179.682,"end_s":4180.803,"video_s":5059.682,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00197","chapter":"C017","text":"Thank you, Councilman.","fingerprint":"0a193942ce6f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00881","start_s":4180.823,"end_s":4183.726,"video_s":5060.823,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00197","chapter":"C017","text":"I certainly consider the Murphy Bridal Path to be a citywide amenity.","fingerprint":"93574041a1d7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00882","start_s":4184.086,"end_s":4186.489,"video_s":5064.086,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00197","chapter":"C017","text":"People come from all over our community to enjoy it.","fingerprint":"a8f60063c1be","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00883","start_s":4186.969,"end_s":4194.677,"video_s":5066.969,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00197","chapter":"C017","text":"When we talk about what we'd like to see in terms of shade and walkability, it is often one of the most cited examples in Phoenix.","fingerprint":"955c9415cd8e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00884","start_s":4194.977,"end_s":4195.317,"video_s":5074.977,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00198","chapter":"C017","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00885","start_s":4196.258,"end_s":4196.699,"video_s":5076.258,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00198","chapter":"C017","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00886","start_s":4197.079,"end_s":4197.339,"video_s":5077.079,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00198","chapter":"C017","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00887","start_s":4197.82,"end_s":4198.2,"video_s":5077.82,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00198","chapter":"C017","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00888","start_s":4198.42,"end_s":4198.66,"video_s":5078.42,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00198","chapter":"C017","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00889","start_s":4199.061,"end_s":4199.521,"video_s":5079.061,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00198","chapter":"C017","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00890","start_s":4203.305,"end_s":4203.445,"video_s":5083.305,"speaker":"harry-sexton","turn":"T00199","chapter":"C017","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00891","start_s":4204.686,"end_s":4205.127,"video_s":5084.686,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00200","chapter":"C017","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00892","start_s":4205.307,"end_s":4205.567,"video_s":5085.307,"speaker":"harry-sexton","turn":"T00201","chapter":"C017","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00893","start_s":4206.028,"end_s":4206.448,"video_s":5086.028,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00202","chapter":"C017","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00894","start_s":4207.897,"end_s":4211.038,"video_s":5087.897,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00202","chapter":"C017","text":"Warren, Hodge Washington, Gallego.","fingerprint":"e6a7895e5e94","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00895","start_s":4212.246,"end_s":4212.448,"video_s":5092.246,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00203","chapter":"C017","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00896","start_s":4213.011,"end_s":4213.857,"video_s":5093.011,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00203","chapter":"C017","text":"Passes 8-0.","fingerprint":"f9a0ca3f6107","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00897","start_s":4215.777,"end_s":4224.569,"video_s":5095.777,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00204","chapter":"C018","text":"Item 75 is next, approve of a Phil Gordon threatened building grant for 330 North 18th Avenue in the Oakland Historic District in D7.","fingerprint":"676690cbf44f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00898","start_s":4224.589,"end_s":4225.59,"video_s":5104.589,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00204","chapter":"C018","text":"Do we have a motion?","fingerprint":"ea97412996cb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00899","start_s":4225.971,"end_s":4227.252,"video_s":5105.971,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00204","chapter":"C018","text":"Motion to approve item 75.","fingerprint":"ff35df218b21","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00900","start_s":4227.953,"end_s":4228.294,"video_s":5107.953,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00204","chapter":"C018","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00901","start_s":4228.614,"end_s":4229.896,"video_s":5108.614,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00204","chapter":"C018","text":"We have a motion and a second.","fingerprint":"7451ba811637","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00902","start_s":4230.356,"end_s":4238.447,"video_s":5110.356,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00204","chapter":"C018","text":"We named these grants for our former mayor, Phil Gordon, who was such an advocate for historic preservation and protecting the city of Phoenix's history.","fingerprint":"df38b50b0404","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00903","start_s":4238.808,"end_s":4240.39,"video_s":5118.808,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00204","chapter":"C018","text":"We do have public comment on this.","fingerprint":"9a4d2568a8b5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00904","start_s":4240.41,"end_s":4242.072,"video_s":5120.41,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00204","chapter":"C018","text":"We'll begin with Kristen, followed by Jeremy.","fingerprint":"ab79c6dfe50f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00905","start_s":4252.987,"end_s":4253.988,"video_s":5132.987,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00205","chapter":"C018","text":"again.","fingerprint":"b4c9e14061c2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00906","start_s":4255.329,"end_s":4261.896,"video_s":5135.329,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00205","chapter":"C018","text":"So item 75 hands $84,600 of public money to Oakland Financial LLC.","fingerprint":"a889e9ba7c21","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00907","start_s":4263.778,"end_s":4266.821,"video_s":5143.778,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00205","chapter":"C018","text":"Quick summary of the law before the policy.","fingerprint":"6978c1188f3a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00908","start_s":4266.861,"end_s":4274.689,"video_s":5146.861,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00205","chapter":"C018","text":"Article 9, Section 7 of the Arizona Constitution bars the city from making a grant by subsidy or otherwise to any corporation.","fingerprint":"5b089cbc0542","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00909","start_s":4274.909,"end_s":4282.757,"video_s":5154.909,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00205","chapter":"C018","text":"It survives only if what the public gets back is not grossly disproportionate to what it pays.","fingerprint":"8d8b599373dd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00910","start_s":4282.872,"end_s":4286.897,"video_s":5162.872,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00205","chapter":"C018","text":"Neighborhood character and district integrity are indirect benefits that don't count.","fingerprint":"b5a8f3ecebea","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00911","start_s":4287.017,"end_s":4290.081,"video_s":5167.017,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00205","chapter":"C018","text":"So a court sets the fair market value.","fingerprint":"354dfdbc1ed3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00912","start_s":4290.101,"end_s":4291.863,"video_s":5170.101,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00205","chapter":"C018","text":"So the whole question is one number.","fingerprint":"dd490dadd1bd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00913","start_s":4292.704,"end_s":4296.549,"video_s":5172.704,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00205","chapter":"C018","text":"What is a 25 year easement on this house worth?","fingerprint":"f49602d881c3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00914","start_s":4297.89,"end_s":4299.432,"video_s":5177.89,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00205","chapter":"C018","text":"Nothing in the report answers that.","fingerprint":"36494924707c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00915","start_s":4299.452,"end_s":4300.433,"video_s":5179.452,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00205","chapter":"C018","text":"There's no appraisal.","fingerprint":"517be40c3823","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00916","start_s":4300.914,"end_s":4301.775,"video_s":5180.914,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00205","chapter":"C018","text":"There's no method.","fingerprint":"8985cbdade6e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00917","start_s":4301.815,"end_s":4303.497,"video_s":5181.815,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00205","chapter":"C018","text":"There's no range.","fingerprint":"cf7f119b6e31","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00918","start_s":4304.607,"end_s":4321.097,"video_s":5184.607,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00205","chapter":"C018","text":"Oakfield bought that house in July of last year for $154,000 cash from an unrelated seller, and you are being asked to pay $84,600, so more than half of the price of the whole property for a partial interest that expires.","fingerprint":"053eba165da1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00919","start_s":4322.478,"end_s":4324.902,"video_s":5202.478,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00205","chapter":"C018","text":"And here is the part I ask you to sit with.","fingerprint":"70c264be4f89","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00920","start_s":4325.583,"end_s":4338.943,"video_s":5205.583,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00205","chapter":"C018","text":"The city denied the demolition, so that denial drove the price down, meaning Oakland bought at a lower price and the city now proposes to essentially hand that discount back with public money.","fingerprint":"95f538d31ad2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00921","start_s":4339.423,"end_s":4345.212,"video_s":5219.423,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00205","chapter":"C018","text":"So I ask that you please make the city attorney state the easement's value on the record","fingerprint":"906b1b5d9a64","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00922","start_s":4345.192,"end_s":4351.678,"video_s":5225.192,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00205","chapter":"C018","text":"and until he does, you cannot make the finding that the constitution requires.","fingerprint":"e30e7a4620dd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00923","start_s":4352.039,"end_s":4353.2,"video_s":5232.039,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00205","chapter":"C018","text":"Please vote no on 75.","fingerprint":"bea6228f4fa1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00924","start_s":4353.26,"end_s":4356.623,"video_s":5233.26,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00206","chapter":"C018","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00925","start_s":4356.983,"end_s":4358.244,"video_s":5236.983,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00206","chapter":"C018","text":"Next up we have Jeremy Thacker.","fingerprint":"3288eb019963","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00926","start_s":4359.506,"end_s":4368.154,"video_s":5239.506,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00207","chapter":"C018","text":"So the last one I said wasn't illegal.","fingerprint":"880017de18ab","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00927","start_s":4368.734,"end_s":4372.498,"video_s":5248.734,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00207","chapter":"C018","text":"I am fairly certain this is.","fingerprint":"a47617452c71","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00928","start_s":4373.103,"end_s":4383.595,"video_s":5253.103,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00207","chapter":"C018","text":"The gift clause of the state of Arizona requires a even give and take when the city gives money away.","fingerprint":"9501a5aa671a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00929","start_s":4383.975,"end_s":4389.041,"video_s":5263.975,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00207","chapter":"C018","text":"In this case, this is already historic property that already has conditions set on it.","fingerprint":"6270eb5a2ac6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00930","start_s":4391.063,"end_s":4396.629,"video_s":5271.063,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00207","chapter":"C018","text":"What benefit would the citizens of Phoenix get for the $80,000 that we're giving away?","fingerprint":"4d41768442f2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00931","start_s":4397.33,"end_s":4398.691,"video_s":5277.33,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00207","chapter":"C018","text":"Not to a homeowner, by the way.","fingerprint":"ef70c4240ef7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00932","start_s":4399.873,"end_s":4401.034,"video_s":5279.873,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00207","chapter":"C018","text":"This is a","fingerprint":"46c17b9343c8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00933","start_s":4401.571,"end_s":4428.253,"video_s":5281.571,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00207","chapter":"C018","text":"landlord who has 10 properties several of them on the same street who just bought the home at a discount why are we subsidizing this once again we've got people that are paying extravagant rents and apartments we've got people that don't have homes and we're subsidizing the people who are causing that increase in rates this is insane this is illegal you can't give this money away","fingerprint":"6626eac01197","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00934","start_s":4428.841,"end_s":4430.583,"video_s":5308.841,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00207","chapter":"C018","text":"You have to get a return on your investment.","fingerprint":"21cc4f3d88d2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00935","start_s":4431.023,"end_s":4438.511,"video_s":5311.023,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00207","chapter":"C018","text":"And I'd love for one of you to explain to me what the return on investment is for giving $80,000 to a historic home.","fingerprint":"1769baf40fbe","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00936","start_s":4439.292,"end_s":4440.393,"video_s":5319.292,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00207","chapter":"C018","text":"How does the city get its money back?","fingerprint":"bd87369aaf0d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00937","start_s":4442.835,"end_s":4443.176,"video_s":5322.835,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00207","chapter":"C018","text":"You don't.","fingerprint":"37d1e72444b7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00938","start_s":4444.617,"end_s":4445.878,"video_s":5324.617,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00207","chapter":"C018","text":"So this is a problem.","fingerprint":"e86769e98a5f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00939","start_s":4447.38,"end_s":4449.022,"video_s":5327.38,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00207","chapter":"C018","text":"And it's going to be a problem on the next one too.","fingerprint":"f4a5697d578a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00940","start_s":4452.405,"end_s":4452.545,"video_s":5332.405,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00208","chapter":"C018","text":"Thanks.","fingerprint":"a6a2729cbf6b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00941","start_s":4452.565,"end_s":4452.986,"video_s":5332.565,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00208","chapter":"C018","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00942","start_s":4453.506,"end_s":4455.628,"video_s":5333.506,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00208","chapter":"C018","text":"Any questions from the panel?","fingerprint":"ac1b04b1f948","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00943","start_s":4455.648,"end_s":4455.849,"video_s":5335.648,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00209","chapter":"C018","text":"All right.","fingerprint":"dfbdd9492bec","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00944","start_s":4457.57,"end_s":4458.291,"video_s":5337.57,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00210","chapter":"C018","text":"Councilman Stark?","fingerprint":"8578f4ef93a6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00945","start_s":4458.997,"end_s":4460.199,"video_s":5338.997,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00211","chapter":"C018","text":"No, I don't have any questions.","fingerprint":"6d8a20f5bbad","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00946","start_s":4460.219,"end_s":4461.24,"video_s":5340.219,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00211","chapter":"C018","text":"I apologize.","fingerprint":"2c77a47f05b2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00947","start_s":4461.26,"end_s":4462.001,"video_s":5341.26,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C018","text":"Oh, no worries.","fingerprint":"f0920cf01f9f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00948","start_s":4462.682,"end_s":4464.525,"video_s":5342.682,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C018","text":"Go ahead and do roll call.","fingerprint":"29e5e0dcc733","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00949","start_s":4464.545,"end_s":4464.926,"video_s":5344.545,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00213","chapter":"C018","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00950","start_s":4465.567,"end_s":4466.348,"video_s":5345.567,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00214","chapter":"C018","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[{"kind":"agenda-record","source":"vote on item 75","recorded":"Yes","result":"matches"}],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00951","start_s":4466.368,"end_s":4466.808,"video_s":5346.368,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00215","chapter":"C018","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00952","start_s":4466.969,"end_s":4467.209,"video_s":5346.969,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00215","chapter":"C018","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00953","start_s":4467.67,"end_s":4468.11,"video_s":5347.67,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00215","chapter":"C018","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00954","start_s":4470.834,"end_s":4470.955,"video_s":5350.834,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00215","chapter":"C018","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00955","start_s":4471.836,"end_s":4472.337,"video_s":5351.836,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00215","chapter":"C018","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00956","start_s":4472.417,"end_s":4472.657,"video_s":5352.417,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00215","chapter":"C018","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00957","start_s":4473.178,"end_s":4473.538,"video_s":5353.178,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00215","chapter":"C018","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00958","start_s":4473.739,"end_s":4474.52,"video_s":5353.739,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00215","chapter":"C018","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00959","start_s":4474.54,"end_s":4474.88,"video_s":5354.54,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00215","chapter":"C018","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00960","start_s":4475.762,"end_s":4475.842,"video_s":5355.762,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00215","chapter":"C018","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00961","start_s":4475.862,"end_s":4476.483,"video_s":5355.862,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00215","chapter":"C018","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00962","start_s":4476.723,"end_s":4476.963,"video_s":5356.723,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00215","chapter":"C018","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00963","start_s":4477.404,"end_s":4478.225,"video_s":5357.404,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00215","chapter":"C018","text":"Passes 7-0.","fingerprint":"32c0c3561a2c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00964","start_s":4481.67,"end_s":4484.194,"video_s":5361.67,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00216","chapter":"C019","text":"Next up, we have item 76.","fingerprint":"1ca0846774e2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00965","start_s":4485.676,"end_s":4494.128,"video_s":5365.676,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00216","chapter":"C019","text":"which is the approval of a Phil Gordon threatened building grant in District 8 at 927 North 8th Street.","fingerprint":"68b1f46089e4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00966","start_s":4494.769,"end_s":4495.63,"video_s":5374.769,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00216","chapter":"C019","text":"Can I get a motion, please?","fingerprint":"98bb6c7acca8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00967","start_s":4495.65,"end_s":4497.172,"video_s":5375.65,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00216","chapter":"C019","text":"I move to approve.","fingerprint":"58031e242348","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00968","start_s":4497.192,"end_s":4497.333,"video_s":5377.192,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00216","chapter":"C019","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00969","start_s":4497.353,"end_s":4497.733,"video_s":5377.353,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00216","chapter":"C019","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00970","start_s":4502.861,"end_s":4512.274,"video_s":5382.861,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00216","chapter":"C019","text":"For that, we have two speakers, Michael Buchbacher and Kristin Lyson.","fingerprint":"699b8ae224fe","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00971","start_s":4514.701,"end_s":4515.682,"video_s":5394.701,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00216","chapter":"C019","text":"and Jeremy Thacker.","fingerprint":"05fd20171b0a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00972","start_s":4531.117,"end_s":4535.301,"video_s":5411.117,"speaker":"v13","turn":"T00217","chapter":"C019","text":"Mike Buschbacher, 3101 North Central, Suite 1000.","fingerprint":"7715ccb7fb1d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00973","start_s":4536.482,"end_s":4541.367,"video_s":5416.482,"speaker":"v13","turn":"T00217","chapter":"C019","text":"Just wanted to say I'm in support of the funding and the grant and that's it.","fingerprint":"1a8a3dcb019c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00974","start_s":4542.089,"end_s":4542.93,"video_s":5422.089,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00218","chapter":"C019","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00975","start_s":4543.491,"end_s":4545.974,"video_s":5423.491,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00218","chapter":"C019","text":"Next up, Kristen Liza.","fingerprint":"142cdf997e82","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00976","start_s":4549.979,"end_s":4551.461,"video_s":5429.979,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C019","text":"Thank you, Council and Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"4f4b55de1fdf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00977","start_s":4552.222,"end_s":4556.307,"video_s":5432.222,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C019","text":"To introduce myself, I'm Kristen List and I'm on the Board of Directors of Good Goat.","fingerprint":"d7d27df11948","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00978","start_s":4556.507,"end_s":4558.63,"video_s":5436.507,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C019","text":"Item 76 is a fun one.","fingerprint":"81bef756ff24","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00979","start_s":4558.79,"end_s":4563.456,"video_s":5438.79,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C019","text":"It's $250,000 to Rann Holdings LLP.","fingerprint":"0e120e18f68f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00980","start_s":4563.638,"end_s":4568.837,"video_s":5443.638,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C019","text":"It is the larger of your two preservation grants today and there's less behind it than the last one.","fingerprint":"830ef1f2fea9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00981","start_s":4569.54,"end_s":4571.366,"video_s":5449.54,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C019","text":"Starting with the property, what the property costs.","fingerprint":"4f69a4bb9256","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00982","start_s":4571.888,"end_s":4573.193,"video_s":5451.888,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C019","text":"Does anybody know?","fingerprint":"69f9bf1d287e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00983","start_s":4573.477,"end_s":4575.219,"video_s":5453.477,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C019","text":"I don't think you do because nobody does.","fingerprint":"848abd2b2394","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00984","start_s":4575.279,"end_s":4586.755,"video_s":5455.279,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C019","text":"The deed is dated December 27, 2024 from Rann LLC to Rann Holdings LLP signed by the same man as president of the company conveying the property to his own partnership.","fingerprint":"98f39366e408","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00985","start_s":4587.275,"end_s":4588.497,"video_s":5467.275,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C019","text":"It is a courtesy recording.","fingerprint":"34b98ae63798","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00986","start_s":4588.557,"end_s":4598.37,"video_s":5468.557,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C019","text":"There's no escrow, no title insurance, marked affidavit exempt under ARS 11-1134B.","fingerprint":"10ed7a6b55f2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00987","start_s":4598.35,"end_s":4601.493,"video_s":5478.35,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C019","text":"the exemption for transfers among commonly controlled entities.","fingerprint":"cbaba9e6442b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00988","start_s":4601.533,"end_s":4606.898,"video_s":5481.533,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C019","text":"So no price was ever recorded and your report calls this the current owner.","fingerprint":"c2e75986b6e9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00989","start_s":4608.279,"end_s":4611.762,"video_s":5488.279,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C019","text":"Basically the deed shows one operator moving a parcel between his own entities.","fingerprint":"73e6c2ae55fa","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00990","start_s":4612.603,"end_s":4614.765,"video_s":5492.603,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C019","text":"There's no appraisal of the easement.","fingerprint":"a088768a5cf4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00991","start_s":4614.825,"end_s":4618.629,"video_s":5494.825,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C019","text":"There's no valuation method and no identified funding source.","fingerprint":"cb1544e2ec5e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00992","start_s":4618.709,"end_s":4625.455,"video_s":5498.709,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C019","text":"The report states the amount goes, the report states the amount and goes straight to the terms.","fingerprint":"869f3561ec5c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00993","start_s":4626.278,"end_s":4636.574,"video_s":5506.278,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C019","text":"Under Turkin and Shires, you must find that the $250,000 that you're granting is not grossly disproportionate to a 30-year easement.","fingerprint":"9e37e0b5c1bf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00994","start_s":4637.475,"end_s":4643.003,"video_s":5517.475,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C019","text":"You cannot make that finding today because you have neither the easement's value nor the property's basis.","fingerprint":"bd7d490c18d7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00995","start_s":4644.025,"end_s":4650.835,"video_s":5524.025,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C019","text":"You are putting a quarter of a million dollars into the anchor parcel of a block one landlord is assembling.","fingerprint":"7e2c0493947a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00996","start_s":4651.27,"end_s":4657.858,"video_s":5531.27,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C019","text":"So these preservation items today, not one of those items contains a number showing what the public receives.","fingerprint":"c12cab5df4fc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00997","start_s":4658.719,"end_s":4659.901,"video_s":5538.719,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C019","text":"Not a paperwork problem.","fingerprint":"9d1bb08d7ab5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00998","start_s":4659.941,"end_s":4663.806,"video_s":5539.941,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C019","text":"This is a program that has stopped measuring altogether.","fingerprint":"c0014930c76b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00999","start_s":4663.906,"end_s":4665.968,"video_s":5543.906,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C019","text":"So please vote no on item number 76.","fingerprint":"3e6bdb99e40e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01000","start_s":4666.028,"end_s":4666.83,"video_s":5546.028,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C019","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01001","start_s":4667.33,"end_s":4668.051,"video_s":5547.33,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00220","chapter":"C019","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01002","start_s":4670.294,"end_s":4670.935,"video_s":5550.294,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00220","chapter":"C019","text":"Thank you, Jeremy.","fingerprint":"af0daaa6f746","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01003","start_s":4672.557,"end_s":4676.822,"video_s":5552.557,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C019","text":"I recommend that you vote yes on this one, because this is the exact","fingerprint":"7526273714e8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01004","start_s":4677.258,"end_s":4680.842,"video_s":5557.258,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C019","text":"legal case that I would like to take against the historic property tax discount.","fingerprint":"d07bde10fdc0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01005","start_s":4682.803,"end_s":4693.254,"video_s":5562.803,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C019","text":"This is going to a landlord who owns 45 properties, the entire block, the entire block he owns.","fingerprint":"332e5422dbb1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01006","start_s":4694.555,"end_s":4696.156,"video_s":5574.555,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C019","text":"We're giving him $250,000.","fingerprint":"9799760fde78","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01007","start_s":4696.657,"end_s":4701.302,"video_s":5576.657,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C019","text":"The report says that a new owner took possession.","fingerprint":"43ea24c2bac0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01008","start_s":4701.542,"end_s":4704.885,"video_s":5581.542,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C019","text":"It's the same owner from one of his entities to the other.","fingerprint":"7d5227a1e1cd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01009","start_s":4708.493,"end_s":4711.998,"video_s":5588.493,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C019","text":"If this is not a violation of the gift clause, I don't know what possibly could be.","fingerprint":"d601e64fd79f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01010","start_s":4714.241,"end_s":4715.603,"video_s":5594.241,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C019","text":"We're giving more than the value of the house.","fingerprint":"2520d7ee1406","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01011","start_s":4716.304,"end_s":4716.724,"video_s":5596.304,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C019","text":"And for what?","fingerprint":"db9b78eb767a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01012","start_s":4717.024,"end_s":4717.445,"video_s":5597.024,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C019","text":"And to who?","fingerprint":"894524842fa0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01013","start_s":4720.209,"end_s":4726.117,"video_s":5600.209,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C019","text":"Can anyone explain to me how this is a good use of money of the taxpayers?","fingerprint":"d5127b42e451","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01014","start_s":4726.397,"end_s":4729.862,"video_s":5606.397,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C019","text":"How this benefits anyone except that person?","fingerprint":"353bcbdcd56d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01015","start_s":4730.082,"end_s":4735.77,"video_s":5610.082,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C019","text":"In fact, it negatively benefits the rest of the people that are looking to rent, that are looking to buy.","fingerprint":"9f351aa5b31a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01016","start_s":4736.351,"end_s":4738.213,"video_s":5616.351,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C019","text":"Because we've got one person taking all of it.","fingerprint":"598516dcf88d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01017","start_s":4739.915,"end_s":4743.581,"video_s":5619.915,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C019","text":"So if you're going to vote yes, please explain it.","fingerprint":"14780f56e60f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01018","start_s":4744.643,"end_s":4745.644,"video_s":5624.643,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C019","text":"I'd love to understand why.","fingerprint":"e46c80287dbc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01019","start_s":4747.307,"end_s":4748.409,"video_s":5627.307,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C019","text":"Or just sit there silent.","fingerprint":"73ee644693dd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01020","start_s":4748.429,"end_s":4748.709,"video_s":5628.429,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C019","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01021","start_s":4749.39,"end_s":4749.811,"video_s":5629.39,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00222","chapter":"C019","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01022","start_s":4750.873,"end_s":4753.157,"video_s":5630.873,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00222","chapter":"C019","text":"There was a lot of our speakers on that item.","fingerprint":"f294a17ebaac","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01023","start_s":4753.898,"end_s":4762.632,"video_s":5633.898,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00222","chapter":"C019","text":"I will ask Josh Bednarek and Helena Rutter to come forward to answer a couple questions for me, please.","fingerprint":"ac1d57cd1d79","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01024","start_s":4781.326,"end_s":4781.747,"video_s":5661.326,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00222","chapter":"C019","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01025","start_s":4784.01,"end_s":4785.994,"video_s":5664.01,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00222","chapter":"C019","text":"I thought it might be helpful to give you an opportunity.","fingerprint":"e13c1f92fa3a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01026","start_s":4786.214,"end_s":4797.192,"video_s":5666.214,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00222","chapter":"C019","text":"My question, I guess, in simplistic terms would be, can you articulate the public benefit that the residents of Phoenix would receive as a result of this item?","fingerprint":"3a7656a6132e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01027","start_s":4800.192,"end_s":4802.155,"video_s":5680.192,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C019","text":"Thank you, Vice Mayor, members of council.","fingerprint":"7a955c9b68a8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01028","start_s":4802.875,"end_s":4811.567,"video_s":5682.875,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C019","text":"Yes, under the current zoning ordinance, there is a one-year stay of demolition in place for historic properties.","fingerprint":"c188eb7030f8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01029","start_s":4812.848,"end_s":4824.023,"video_s":5692.848,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C019","text":"And in this case, with a conservation easement, basically what changes is that that demolition restraint extends to that","fingerprint":"29748c3f0c15","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01030","start_s":4824.34,"end_s":4839.582,"video_s":5704.34,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C019","text":"and many more.","fingerprint":"9f7a5303e3d4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01031","start_s":4840.253,"end_s":4864.236,"video_s":5720.253,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C019","text":"which include both contributing resources and non-contributing resources there's kind of a threshold of about 50 percent that we're looking to maintain at least to maintain a historic district so when we lose a resource completely then we have a non-contributing lot so really the goal of our office is to maintain our historic districts to maintain contributing resources","fingerprint":"1ded2a810e9f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01032","start_s":4864.216,"end_s":4877.099,"video_s":5744.216,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C019","text":"So the grant funds allow us both to save sort of the historic resource, a contributing resource, and then we also have that additional protection that we don't have currently under the zoning ordinance.","fingerprint":"dee0d94a6979","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01033","start_s":4877.68,"end_s":4886.916,"video_s":5757.68,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C019","text":"We are also able to have higher kind of standards of things that we review on the property during the period of the easement.","fingerprint":"3561a0486a5f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01034","start_s":4886.896,"end_s":4909.393,"video_s":5766.896,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C019","text":"in that currently you know it basically has to be a building permit to trigger our review but there are things in terms of materials when the city invests in those things obviously we don't want to see those removed so this also kind of enhances the enforcement of the office to maintain contributing properties","fingerprint":"d06b30fc7391","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01035","start_s":4910.639,"end_s":4939.92,"video_s":5790.639,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00224","chapter":"C019","text":"thank you so much for that and I just want to make sure I'm clear because you you mentioned it you said from the initial um one year period the demolition to the duration of the conservation easement and just to make sure it's clear the duration of the proposed conservation easement is 25 sorry 30 years in this case correct sorry vice mayor uh h2 h2 uh yes that is correct thank you vice mayor members of council","fingerprint":"7fba2b6d7d48","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01036","start_s":4940.137,"end_s":4951.429,"video_s":5820.137,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00224","chapter":"C019","text":"Okay so that takes it from a conservation easement from having it from one year to for up to 30 well not up to but 30 years addition so there is some","fingerprint":"75f158c37d1d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01037","start_s":4951.882,"end_s":4977.147,"video_s":5831.882,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00225","chapter":"C019","text":"there is definitely impacting you also talked about a little bit of enhanced enforcement can you expound a little bit more on that yes thanks thank you vice mayor members of council um so when the city invests public funds into the exterior and I should say that these uh the the goal of these and historic preservation is broader seen as a public benefit uh that's sort of the model behind the adoption of the ordinance is that historic preservation is a public benefit","fingerprint":"5d61c783f888","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01038","start_s":4977.127,"end_s":4996.08,"video_s":5857.127,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00225","chapter":"C019","text":"and so the funds that we use as grant funds are really focused on the exterior of the building and you know obviously bringing it back to so in this case there's you know fire damage to the roof so roof would be reconstructed everything keeping with the original character of the home","fingerprint":"89d459c35f99","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01039","start_s":4996.06,"end_s":5024.835,"video_s":5876.06,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00225","chapter":"C019","text":"and so if we were to say you know provide funding for historic windows that we wouldn't normally be able to regulate because if it doesn't need a building permit we're not we don't regulate those things if public funds are going for those materials even if we can't normally regulate it with a conservation easement we can it gives us that additional mechanism because again if public funds are being invested in a property we want to make sure those materials","fingerprint":"abefa5ebb66f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01040","start_s":5024.815,"end_s":5026.378,"video_s":5904.815,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00225","chapter":"C019","text":"are staying with the property.","fingerprint":"b28e68823528","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01041","start_s":5026.398,"end_s":5029.505,"video_s":5906.398,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00226","chapter":"C019","text":"Thank you so much for the clarification.","fingerprint":"08cfe671b271","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01042","start_s":5029.525,"end_s":5031.269,"video_s":5909.525,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00226","chapter":"C019","text":"A question for Councilman Stark.","fingerprint":"c42e6b179c00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01043","start_s":5031.79,"end_s":5040.428,"video_s":5911.79,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00227","chapter":"C019","text":"And just quickly, as far as the tax break, it's for 10 years for commercial, 15 for residential?","fingerprint":"69bf882e6c3c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01044","start_s":5040.468,"end_s":5042.352,"video_s":5920.468,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00227","chapter":"C019","text":"Isn't there a time limit?","fingerprint":"44dc78d12ce6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01045","start_s":5042.905,"end_s":5046.809,"video_s":5922.905,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00228","chapter":"C019","text":"Yes, Vice Mayor, Councilwoman Stark, members of the council.","fingerprint":"77d6d44ac97f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01046","start_s":5047.29,"end_s":5055.478,"video_s":5927.29,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00228","chapter":"C019","text":"The property tax reduction is managed in partnership with the State Historic Preservation Office and the county assessors.","fingerprint":"43ab7538bacb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01047","start_s":5055.879,"end_s":5060.083,"video_s":5935.879,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00228","chapter":"C019","text":"And so those are for, it's properties that are listed in the National Register of Historic Places.","fingerprint":"233436cebc24","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01048","start_s":5060.143,"end_s":5063.186,"video_s":5940.143,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00228","chapter":"C019","text":"It's not actually a program that's administered by the City of Phoenix.","fingerprint":"354655f68064","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01049","start_s":5064.508,"end_s":5070.634,"video_s":5944.508,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00228","chapter":"C019","text":"For commercial properties that are eligible for that, basically what they do,","fingerprint":"62e27a1ae6f1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01050","start_s":5070.614,"end_s":5096.419,"video_s":5950.614,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00228","chapter":"C019","text":"so commercial rental basically any income producing properties under that state program they evaluate your property before you make improvements they evaluate it after you make improvements and then you are charged one percent of the value of the improvements over 10 years so again that's not a city program that's that's a program in partnership with the state and county assessors","fingerprint":"a34f0c9581e4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01051","start_s":5097.412,"end_s":5105.52,"video_s":5977.412,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00229","chapter":"C019","text":"But long term, we do benefit by an increase in valuation after the tax break is taken away, correct?","fingerprint":"75d046d4cdf6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01052","start_s":5105.74,"end_s":5106.862,"video_s":5985.74,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00230","chapter":"C019","text":"Yes, Councilwoman Stark.","fingerprint":"f17648542553","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01053","start_s":5106.922,"end_s":5109.785,"video_s":5986.922,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00230","chapter":"C019","text":"It is in place for 10 years.","fingerprint":"cb5b544416a8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01054","start_s":5109.865,"end_s":5116.812,"video_s":5989.865,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00230","chapter":"C019","text":"And obviously, they say typically to benefit from it, it needs to be a substantial investment into the property.","fingerprint":"5cb4cdbfbccd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01055","start_s":5118.393,"end_s":5119.054,"video_s":5998.393,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00231","chapter":"C019","text":"OK, thank you.","fingerprint":"26935da7c73d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01056","start_s":5119.074,"end_s":5119.815,"video_s":5999.074,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00231","chapter":"C019","text":"Thank you, Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"8ac1fd1753f1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01057","start_s":5120.936,"end_s":5122.257,"video_s":6000.936,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00231","chapter":"C019","text":"Thank you so much, Councilwoman Stark.","fingerprint":"1b1075b5e2da","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01058","start_s":5122.978,"end_s":5126.001,"video_s":6002.978,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00231","chapter":"C019","text":"Seeing there are no further questions, I'll go ahead and proceed with the roll call vote.","fingerprint":"8e995430e8b1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01059","start_s":5126.723,"end_s":5128.125,"video_s":6006.723,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00232","chapter":"C019","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01060","start_s":5128.145,"end_s":5128.365,"video_s":6008.145,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00233","chapter":"C019","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01061","start_s":5129.146,"end_s":5129.567,"video_s":6009.146,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00234","chapter":"C019","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01062","start_s":5129.747,"end_s":5130.027,"video_s":6009.747,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00234","chapter":"C019","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01063","start_s":5130.868,"end_s":5131.329,"video_s":6010.868,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00234","chapter":"C019","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01064","start_s":5133.051,"end_s":5133.292,"video_s":6013.051,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00234","chapter":"C019","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01065","start_s":5134.033,"end_s":5134.493,"video_s":6014.033,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00234","chapter":"C019","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01066","start_s":5134.734,"end_s":5134.974,"video_s":6014.734,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00235","chapter":"C019","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01067","start_s":5135.515,"end_s":5136.095,"video_s":6015.515,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00236","chapter":"C019","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01068","start_s":5136.115,"end_s":5136.376,"video_s":6016.115,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00237","chapter":"C019","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01069","start_s":5137.057,"end_s":5137.397,"video_s":6017.057,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00238","chapter":"C019","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01070","start_s":5140.121,"end_s":5140.761,"video_s":6020.121,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00238","chapter":"C019","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01071","start_s":5141.022,"end_s":5141.262,"video_s":6021.022,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00238","chapter":"C019","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01072","start_s":5141.823,"end_s":5142.324,"video_s":6021.823,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00238","chapter":"C019","text":"Passes 6-0.","fingerprint":"b1f073e43aaf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01073","start_s":5149.653,"end_s":5153.338,"video_s":6029.653,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00239","chapter":"C019","text":"Next we will proceed to our citizens comment.","fingerprint":"dfbc74f47487","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01074","start_s":5154.213,"end_s":5157.585,"video_s":6034.213,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00239","chapter":"C019","text":"and I will turn to the city manager to provide statement.","fingerprint":"a82b559d278c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01075","start_s":5158.228,"end_s":5158.629,"video_s":6038.228,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00240","chapter":"C019","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01076","start_s":5159.171,"end_s":5165.033,"video_s":6039.171,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00241","chapter":"C020","text":"During citizen comment, members of the public may speak to the city council for up to three minutes on issues of interest or concern.","fingerprint":"4d4713206cdf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01077","start_s":5165.418,"end_s":5171.784,"video_s":6045.418,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00241","chapter":"C020","text":"However, the matters addressed must be within the jurisdiction of the Phoenix City Council and on which the council has the authority to act.","fingerprint":"604f59ebdbba","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01078","start_s":5172.325,"end_s":5175.047,"video_s":6052.325,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00241","chapter":"C020","text":"The citizen comment session is limited to 30 minutes.","fingerprint":"4b4641b48602","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01079","start_s":5175.548,"end_s":5182.534,"video_s":6055.548,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00241","chapter":"C020","text":"The Arizona Open Meeting Law allows the city council to listen to comments but prohibits council members from discussing or acting on the issues presented.","fingerprint":"8a816930936b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01080","start_s":5182.975,"end_s":5185.177,"video_s":6062.975,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00241","chapter":"C020","text":"However, council members may respond to criticism.","fingerprint":"73272def6458","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01081","start_s":5185.337,"end_s":5185.697,"video_s":6065.337,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00241","chapter":"C020","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01082","start_s":5187.499,"end_s":5187.899,"video_s":6067.499,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00242","chapter":"C020","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01083","start_s":5188.64,"end_s":5193.805,"video_s":6068.64,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00242","chapter":"C020","text":"We will start with our first speaker is Faith Kearns followed by Frank Urban.","fingerprint":"873fa4271acd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01084","start_s":5209.428,"end_s":5210.469,"video_s":6089.428,"speaker":"v15","turn":"T00243","chapter":"C020","text":"Thank you, council.","fingerprint":"c0a53982bdd7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01085","start_s":5213.413,"end_s":5221.945,"video_s":6093.413,"speaker":"v15","turn":"T00243","chapter":"C020","text":"I feel that there needs to be more effort for the handicapped people that are here in Phoenix.","fingerprint":"19112a8869f3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01086","start_s":5224.468,"end_s":5228.934,"video_s":6104.468,"speaker":"v15","turn":"T00243","chapter":"C020","text":"We aren't getting what we would like and we're not getting what we need.","fingerprint":"50ec54b1bae5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01087","start_s":5228.974,"end_s":5235.503,"video_s":6108.974,"speaker":"v15","turn":"T00243","chapter":"C020","text":"And what we need is a place where we can go,","fingerprint":"4c27f2b3bbc8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01088","start_s":5236.411,"end_s":5237.473,"video_s":6116.411,"speaker":"v15","turn":"T00243","chapter":"C020","text":"and be accepted.","fingerprint":"7078927074ad","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01089","start_s":5237.573,"end_s":5254.477,"video_s":6117.573,"speaker":"v15","turn":"T00243","chapter":"C020","text":"Right now, even though I've got a place, there's a lot of handicapped people out there that don't because of the rules of them saying, oh, well, if you can't take care of yourself, you can't come in.","fingerprint":"67bec4491fa3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01090","start_s":5257.201,"end_s":5263.87,"video_s":6137.201,"speaker":"v15","turn":"T00243","chapter":"C020","text":"We need a place where there's somebody there to help.","fingerprint":"10d32c297691","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01091","start_s":5265.773,"end_s":5267.735,"video_s":6145.773,"speaker":"v15","turn":"T00243","chapter":"C020","text":"because right now we're not getting it.","fingerprint":"df284665f99d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01092","start_s":5270.979,"end_s":5279.909,"video_s":6150.979,"speaker":"v15","turn":"T00243","chapter":"C020","text":"And as far as the shelters, they still need work, a lot of work.","fingerprint":"b2329e5e204e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01093","start_s":5279.929,"end_s":5281.05,"video_s":6159.929,"speaker":"v15","turn":"T00243","chapter":"C020","text":"And with that, I'll close.","fingerprint":"184874e26ec0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01094","start_s":5283.953,"end_s":5284.854,"video_s":6163.953,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00244","chapter":"C020","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01095","start_s":5285.855,"end_s":5289.199,"video_s":6165.855,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00244","chapter":"C020","text":"Next speaker is Frank, followed by Clarissa Peterson.","fingerprint":"c782b87ac007","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01096","start_s":5290.073,"end_s":5291.215,"video_s":6170.073,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00245","chapter":"C020","text":"Hello, City Council.","fingerprint":"b9eca2381224","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01097","start_s":5291.775,"end_s":5292.937,"video_s":6171.775,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00245","chapter":"C020","text":"My name is Frank Urban.","fingerprint":"f915981ecc95","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01098","start_s":5292.957,"end_s":5295.0,"video_s":6172.957,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00245","chapter":"C020","text":"I'm with Fund for Empowerment.","fingerprint":"7ae4a6a80a6c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01099","start_s":5295.02,"end_s":5298.865,"video_s":6175.02,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00245","chapter":"C020","text":"I would also like to comment on the shelters.","fingerprint":"44fbc1ff2406","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01100","start_s":5299.426,"end_s":5310.481,"video_s":6179.426,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00245","chapter":"C020","text":"There are a lot of people there that are working there that say they would like to help the homeless, but actually they don't care at all.","fingerprint":"e36bd8385342","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01101","start_s":5310.561,"end_s":5317.33,"video_s":6190.561,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00245","chapter":"C020","text":"They will throw you out on the streets","fingerprint":"022acca37222","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01102","start_s":5319.267,"end_s":5326.456,"video_s":6199.267,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00245","chapter":"C020","text":"without your stuff for no reason whatsoever, for the smallest infraction of that shelter's rules.","fingerprint":"f7990491b076","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01103","start_s":5331.302,"end_s":5335.808,"video_s":6211.302,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00245","chapter":"C020","text":"I myself have been a victim of that very thing more than once.","fingerprint":"7cc487e68340","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01104","start_s":5338.311,"end_s":5348.143,"video_s":6218.311,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00245","chapter":"C020","text":"And there needs to be a lot more heat relief","fingerprint":"2e2f2b043ee9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01105","start_s":5349.203,"end_s":5375.346,"video_s":6229.203,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00245","chapter":"C020","text":"um even in uh now there needs to be heat relief during the summer summer months like july and august that's that's a given but also um all year round because it still gets hot even outside of july and august","fingerprint":"4e00a0526c04","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01106","start_s":5376.372,"end_s":5384.151,"video_s":6256.372,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00245","chapter":"C020","text":"and the homeless population is still at risk from heat related deaths outside of July and August.","fingerprint":"120b5d8abe6e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01107","start_s":5384.873,"end_s":5387.5,"video_s":6264.873,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00245","chapter":"C020","text":"And with that, that's all I have to say.","fingerprint":"e1ae7cedf776","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01108","start_s":5387.68,"end_s":5388.041,"video_s":6267.68,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00245","chapter":"C020","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01109","start_s":5389.224,"end_s":5390.166,"video_s":6269.224,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00246","chapter":"C020","text":"Thank you so much, Frank.","fingerprint":"142970dbef4e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01110","start_s":5390.607,"end_s":5393.655,"video_s":6270.607,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00246","chapter":"C020","text":"Our next speaker is Clarissa, followed by Eric Richardson.","fingerprint":"f4124b5942cf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01111","start_s":5404.705,"end_s":5408.59,"video_s":6284.705,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00246","chapter":"C020","text":"Moving on to Eric Richardson, followed by Lauren Carrasso.","fingerprint":"53cb5542b1a1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01112","start_s":5413.055,"end_s":5414.757,"video_s":6293.055,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00247","chapter":"C020","text":"Hello, I'm Eric Richardson.","fingerprint":"90dda5dacbc4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01113","start_s":5415.158,"end_s":5419.684,"video_s":6295.158,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00247","chapter":"C020","text":"I represent Funds for Empowerment, and I'm also a current resident at SOS.","fingerprint":"aced2f56ffe4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01114","start_s":5420.825,"end_s":5424.77,"video_s":6300.825,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00247","chapter":"C020","text":"And basically, I want to talk about, I guess, the heat reliefs.","fingerprint":"8825633e924c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01115","start_s":5425.07,"end_s":5429.376,"video_s":6305.07,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00247","chapter":"C020","text":"One of the things I want to talk about is the heat relief, maybe getting extended.","fingerprint":"2d5c8904bfaa","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01116","start_s":5429.636,"end_s":5433.801,"video_s":6309.636,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00247","chapter":"C020","text":"I mean, of those most heat reliefs, they closed at the beginning of this month.","fingerprint":"fcc9870d0517","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01117","start_s":5434.287,"end_s":5458.303,"video_s":6314.287,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00247","chapter":"C020","text":"and I guess I can understand because the weather is getting cooler or whatever and everything but still at the same time it still gets hot you know I mean I can't believe it's October I'm not I'm not from here or whatever so I'm not from the Midwest so it kind of throws me off you know it being still like 90 degrees and it's October you know I'm still trying to get used to that but but no","fingerprint":"3ce2de30c097","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01118","start_s":5458.283,"end_s":5473.879,"video_s":6338.283,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00247","chapter":"C020","text":"but I mean maybe not as many heat reliefs as it is like back in July, August but at least maybe get it like maybe some type of extension to some basically or at least have them open when the weather is extreme temperatures and everything.","fingerprint":"427c44f65f4f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01119","start_s":5473.859,"end_s":5481.413,"video_s":6353.859,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00247","chapter":"C020","text":"And also, as far as with SOS, I know most of the times I talk about SOS, it's about the improvements it needs.","fingerprint":"7ba361fd780b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01120","start_s":5481.433,"end_s":5489.809,"video_s":6361.433,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00247","chapter":"C020","text":"There's nothing in general that I want to talk about, but that always needs improvement.","fingerprint":"302b8d54f434","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01121","start_s":5489.789,"end_s":5492.574,"video_s":6369.789,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00247","chapter":"C020","text":"For us, the staff, more staff accountability.","fingerprint":"08562153092f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01122","start_s":5492.614,"end_s":5494.818,"video_s":6372.614,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00247","chapter":"C020","text":"I don't think there's no accountability for the staff.","fingerprint":"0e801033fdae","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01123","start_s":5496.582,"end_s":5501.932,"video_s":6376.582,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00247","chapter":"C020","text":"It seems like they can get away with anything or do anything they would want, but mainly with security, too.","fingerprint":"cab925156b37","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01124","start_s":5501.952,"end_s":5505.418,"video_s":6381.952,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00247","chapter":"C020","text":"I think we need, like,","fingerprint":"8a8bdfb74c70","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01125","start_s":5506.192,"end_s":5507.995,"video_s":6386.192,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00247","chapter":"C020","text":"Be honest with you, that's security, basically.","fingerprint":"717414d04b78","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01126","start_s":5508.015,"end_s":5516.247,"video_s":6388.015,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00247","chapter":"C020","text":"It seems like all they really do is just make sure rules are more enforced, basically.","fingerprint":"007ba905b2c6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01127","start_s":5516.328,"end_s":5523.919,"video_s":6396.328,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00247","chapter":"C020","text":"I mean, they're more secure for the employees, basically.","fingerprint":"aed1fc2d3416","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01128","start_s":5524.099,"end_s":5527.104,"video_s":6404.099,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00247","chapter":"C020","text":"They're not securing us, basically, as far as the residents.","fingerprint":"2dae383d12dd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01129","start_s":5527.925,"end_s":5529.067,"video_s":6407.925,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00247","chapter":"C020","text":"And that's all I got to say.","fingerprint":"90e8b2854688","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01130","start_s":5529.247,"end_s":5529.668,"video_s":6409.247,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00247","chapter":"C020","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01131","start_s":5530.424,"end_s":5531.425,"video_s":6410.424,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00248","chapter":"C020","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01132","start_s":5532.506,"end_s":5536.431,"video_s":6412.506,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00248","chapter":"C020","text":"Next is Lauren followed by Christopher Carrazzo.","fingerprint":"f9eda1cbd86f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01133","start_s":5551.867,"end_s":5554.39,"video_s":6431.867,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00248","chapter":"C020","text":"And then Clarissa could go next if she's back.","fingerprint":"5708c1a87622","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01134","start_s":5562.588,"end_s":5562.928,"video_s":6442.588,"speaker":"v17","turn":"T00249","chapter":"C020","text":"Hello.","fingerprint":"2cf24dba5fb0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01135","start_s":5565.151,"end_s":5571.119,"video_s":6445.151,"speaker":"v17","turn":"T00249","chapter":"C020","text":"I just had to say at SOS they don't have any dentistry or anything like that.","fingerprint":"ea7264bdf960","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01136","start_s":5571.539,"end_s":5576.045,"video_s":6451.539,"speaker":"v17","turn":"T00249","chapter":"C020","text":"It would be nice if somebody came like once or twice a month.","fingerprint":"ee35fb417d44","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01137","start_s":5576.065,"end_s":5580.391,"video_s":6456.065,"speaker":"v17","turn":"T00249","chapter":"C020","text":"And the heat relief should be open in the wintertime, I think.","fingerprint":"9617d95fc2f6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01138","start_s":5581.112,"end_s":5583.094,"video_s":6461.112,"speaker":"v17","turn":"T00249","chapter":"C020","text":"So it's like a warming station.","fingerprint":"405dbf1c075a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01139","start_s":5584.357,"end_s":5609.132,"video_s":6464.357,"speaker":"v17","turn":"T00249","chapter":"C020","text":"and that's all I really wanted to say oh and diabetes my husband has diabetes and they don't have anything for food at SOS for him like that like he eats the food every once in a while but it doesn't do any good for him thank you okay thank you and are you Lauren or Christopher I'm Lauren thank you","fingerprint":"3078d12a02c9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01140","start_s":5611.863,"end_s":5615.387,"video_s":6491.863,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00250","chapter":"C020","text":"Christopher, followed by Clarissa if she's back.","fingerprint":"3d787af95d13","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01141","start_s":5616.108,"end_s":5618.932,"video_s":6496.108,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00250","chapter":"C020","text":"And if Clarissa is not back, we're going to go to Antonio Harris.","fingerprint":"f5f61dd0f04f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01142","start_s":5628.824,"end_s":5631.187,"video_s":6508.824,"speaker":"v18","turn":"T00251","chapter":"C020","text":"Yes, I'm with the Fund for Empowerment.","fingerprint":"c475421c73a2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01143","start_s":5631.827,"end_s":5632.528,"video_s":6511.827,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00252","chapter":"C020","text":"And you're Antonio?","fingerprint":"19a91722820e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01144","start_s":5632.969,"end_s":5633.449,"video_s":6512.969,"speaker":"v18","turn":"T00253","chapter":"C020","text":"Antonio.","fingerprint":"4ee3679892e6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01145","start_s":5633.61,"end_s":5633.97,"video_s":6513.61,"speaker":"v18","turn":"T00253","chapter":"C020","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01146","start_s":5635.172,"end_s":5641.279,"video_s":6515.172,"speaker":"v18","turn":"T00253","chapter":"C020","text":"And with regard to the cooling centers,","fingerprint":"a13d4890636f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01147","start_s":5642.879,"end_s":5645.762,"video_s":6522.879,"speaker":"v18","turn":"T00253","chapter":"C020","text":"that are possibly running out of funding.","fingerprint":"56b4094ae955","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01148","start_s":5648.004,"end_s":5664.541,"video_s":6528.004,"speaker":"v18","turn":"T00253","chapter":"C020","text":"So there's a way we can find funding for that because a lot of homeless people that are at these centers, they're able to get housing from the staff that's working there.","fingerprint":"373ba3fa70e7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01149","start_s":5665.722,"end_s":5668.465,"video_s":6545.722,"speaker":"v18","turn":"T00253","chapter":"C020","text":"And if they qualify, they're able to process them","fingerprint":"878a446b886a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01150","start_s":5670.132,"end_s":5672.635,"video_s":6550.132,"speaker":"v18","turn":"T00253","chapter":"C020","text":"are able to get them housing vouchers.","fingerprint":"186c1120e151","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01151","start_s":5673.456,"end_s":5675.838,"video_s":6553.456,"speaker":"v18","turn":"T00253","chapter":"C020","text":"I know a few people that happen to.","fingerprint":"98f0b8171b5c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01152","start_s":5675.858,"end_s":5684.308,"video_s":6555.858,"speaker":"v18","turn":"T00253","chapter":"C020","text":"So hopefully there's a way that can be put in the budget somehow or whatever.","fingerprint":"42bb7f93a079","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01153","start_s":5686.59,"end_s":5686.951,"video_s":6566.59,"speaker":"v18","turn":"T00253","chapter":"C020","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01154","start_s":5687.732,"end_s":5688.733,"video_s":6567.732,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00254","chapter":"C020","text":"Thank you so much, sir.","fingerprint":"e8614896687a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01155","start_s":5690.154,"end_s":5693.558,"video_s":6570.154,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00254","chapter":"C020","text":"Next up, we have Elizabeth Venable, followed by David Morgan.","fingerprint":"de9c614e3247","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01156","start_s":5704.979,"end_s":5707.265,"video_s":6584.979,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00255","chapter":"C020","text":"Okay, so I have another citizen petition.","fingerprint":"792302812401","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01157","start_s":5707.305,"end_s":5709.089,"video_s":6587.305,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00255","chapter":"C020","text":"It's more specific this time.","fingerprint":"dbbf7b6cd422","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01158","start_s":5709.149,"end_s":5715.765,"video_s":6589.149,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00255","chapter":"C020","text":"It does concern the Americans with Disabilities Act, but it's also about code violations.","fingerprint":"799c168e3836","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01159","start_s":5716.471,"end_s":5724.642,"video_s":6596.471,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00255","chapter":"C020","text":"building code violations, which is what the ADA refers to when it doesn't have a specific standard.","fingerprint":"66636dc164d8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01160","start_s":5725.563,"end_s":5725.924,"video_s":6605.563,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00255","chapter":"C020","text":"Okay.","fingerprint":"6a581ee90118","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01161","start_s":5726.004,"end_s":5739.542,"video_s":6606.004,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00255","chapter":"C020","text":"So with the showers, we've had multiple people testify that they couldn't use the showers until the middle of the night because the temperature was too hot and this is a problem that could probably be rectified very cheaply.","fingerprint":"e5fa39339863","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01162","start_s":5739.522,"end_s":5751.077,"video_s":6619.522,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00255","chapter":"C020","text":"I would imagine somebody suggested to me it might be valves or pipes, you know, to fix the temperature of the water.","fingerprint":"63b923abe50d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01163","start_s":5751.958,"end_s":5768.078,"video_s":6631.958,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00255","chapter":"C020","text":"So, you know, under federal standards it says, well, we say, based on those federal standards, the city should test a new shard, the SOS law, to make sure the temperature of the water never exceeds the guidelines of the American Society of Sanitary Engineering.","fingerprint":"67b1337062fd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01164","start_s":5768.058,"end_s":5770.12,"video_s":6648.058,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00255","chapter":"C020","text":"and Consumer Product Safety Commission.","fingerprint":"ccc53b53aa5e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01165","start_s":5770.16,"end_s":5791.163,"video_s":6650.16,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00255","chapter":"C020","text":"If the temperature ever exceeds the guidelines of plumbing codes and anti-scald regulations which limit hot water delivered to accessible fixtures to 120 degrees Fahrenheit at the outlet to prevent burns and ensure safety for all users, including those with reduced mobility or sensation, who are more likely to get burns.","fingerprint":"385c0f3b2d08","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01166","start_s":5791.143,"end_s":5793.466,"video_s":6671.143,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00255","chapter":"C020","text":"if you have reduced mobility or sensation.","fingerprint":"026687c54ae7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01167","start_s":5794.868,"end_s":5804.963,"video_s":6674.868,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00255","chapter":"C020","text":"If the temperature exceeds 120 degrees the city ever okay the city should correct the temperature through means recommended by professionals in this area again it's probably very cheap.","fingerprint":"867582d1ff19","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01168","start_s":5806.826,"end_s":5816.34,"video_s":6686.826,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00255","chapter":"C020","text":"Background multiple people from the SOS are happy and we've been taking this route where we go in and we sort of present issues as opposed to","fingerprint":"102c40e9e589","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01169","start_s":5817.569,"end_s":5820.813,"video_s":6697.569,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00255","chapter":"C020","text":"It's not actually that hard to file ADA complaints.","fingerprint":"385a76f444c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01170","start_s":5821.654,"end_s":5826.741,"video_s":6701.654,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00255","chapter":"C020","text":"You don't need and I don't need an attorney to file an ADA complaint.","fingerprint":"ea02e0c0b1d7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01171","start_s":5827.082,"end_s":5834.832,"video_s":6707.082,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00255","chapter":"C020","text":"But we go and we bring this in front of you in a respectful way and people are very grateful for these showers.","fingerprint":"694355aef4d8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01172","start_s":5834.992,"end_s":5842.142,"video_s":6714.992,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00255","chapter":"C020","text":"And so it shouldn't actually be taken as an affront if we say that we want these facilities to be better.","fingerprint":"422695620fbd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01173","start_s":5842.122,"end_s":5849.499,"video_s":6722.122,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00255","chapter":"C020","text":"So people have said, thank you, thank you, thank you, but I can't take a shower because it was too hot.","fingerprint":"e7876c24ae9b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01174","start_s":5850.12,"end_s":5850.741,"video_s":6730.12,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00255","chapter":"C020","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01175","start_s":5850.762,"end_s":5852.706,"video_s":6730.762,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00255","chapter":"C020","text":"I can't use it.","fingerprint":"87fec303c8de","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01176","start_s":5853.488,"end_s":5860.283,"video_s":6733.488,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00255","chapter":"C020","text":"So, you know, going back to the statement,","fingerprint":"e4dd058f733b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01177","start_s":5862.085,"end_s":5871.697,"video_s":6742.085,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00255","chapter":"C020","text":"Most plumbing calls and safety precautions set the maximum hot water temperature at 120 degrees Fahrenheit for plumbing fixtures like sinks, showers, and bathtubs to prevent scalping.","fingerprint":"6ef1bdcfe806","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01178","start_s":5871.737,"end_s":5874.501,"video_s":6751.737,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00255","chapter":"C020","text":"At 120 degrees, it takes about five minutes to burn.","fingerprint":"c761bce17cfe","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01179","start_s":5874.921,"end_s":5878.906,"video_s":6754.921,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00255","chapter":"C020","text":"Higher temperatures such as 140 degrees can cause severe burns in seconds.","fingerprint":"c76409be8bb0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01180","start_s":5878.966,"end_s":5885.334,"video_s":6758.966,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00255","chapter":"C020","text":"Therefore, limiting the temperature to follow the ASSC and CPSC guidelines is important to prevent scalping injuries.","fingerprint":"497d526886b3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01181","start_s":5885.414,"end_s":5886.716,"video_s":6765.414,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00255","chapter":"C020","text":"And I can't read the last part.","fingerprint":"02c606224048","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01182","start_s":5887.297,"end_s":5890.481,"video_s":6767.297,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00256","chapter":"C020","text":"But ADA goes back to these plumbing guidelines.","fingerprint":"ae84b8912320","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01183","start_s":5890.501,"end_s":5891.502,"video_s":6770.501,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00256","chapter":"C020","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01184","start_s":5895.886,"end_s":5900.17,"video_s":6775.886,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00257","chapter":"C020","text":"Our next speaker is David Morgan followed by Lee Ellis II.","fingerprint":"9eed1a0c0a08","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01185","start_s":5906.777,"end_s":5907.658,"video_s":6786.777,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"Hi, I'm David Morgan.","fingerprint":"7527e7f6099a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01186","start_s":5907.678,"end_s":5908.739,"video_s":6787.678,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"I'm with Funds for Empowerment.","fingerprint":"a3f8450d3453","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01187","start_s":5909.66,"end_s":5911.221,"video_s":6789.66,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"I also live at the SOS still.","fingerprint":"1ab135811a6a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01188","start_s":5911.822,"end_s":5912.683,"video_s":6791.822,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"I've been there two years.","fingerprint":"a91585fb4aff","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01189","start_s":5913.804,"end_s":5920.611,"video_s":6793.804,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"The system at the shelter, the whole housing system, the whole way everything is structured, it dehumanizes.","fingerprint":"04230d163b3f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01190","start_s":5921.832,"end_s":5923.834,"video_s":6801.832,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"If that isn't bad enough,","fingerprint":"ef9dbfe1797b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01191","start_s":5924.911,"end_s":5925.612,"video_s":6804.911,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"It doesn't work.","fingerprint":"7a24f4ad6b05","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01192","start_s":5926.113,"end_s":5926.594,"video_s":6806.113,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"It's broken.","fingerprint":"acf9f60672f7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01193","start_s":5927.876,"end_s":5929.899,"video_s":6807.876,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"I've been coming in here and saying there's no accountability.","fingerprint":"d0cd8c302b5b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01194","start_s":5929.919,"end_s":5938.532,"video_s":6809.919,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"I've been coming in here and saying we need to get companies that actually care about us to start running it, to start being transparent, accountable.","fingerprint":"dba118575c49","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01195","start_s":5938.552,"end_s":5940.796,"video_s":6818.552,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"I've tried to talk to the Office of Homeless Solutions.","fingerprint":"92906f8c7e54","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01196","start_s":5941.797,"end_s":5942.418,"video_s":6821.797,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"They got nothing.","fingerprint":"aa50948519f9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01197","start_s":5943.019,"end_s":5945.683,"video_s":6823.019,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"They would rather see me as an adversary than an asset.","fingerprint":"180eac8a8d82","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01198","start_s":5946.625,"end_s":5951.172,"video_s":6826.625,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"They don't understand that I have a brain too, that I can come here.","fingerprint":"c054f94f03da","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01199","start_s":5952.097,"end_s":5955.3,"video_s":6832.097,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"They get mad when the city comes down on them, as if it's my fault.","fingerprint":"ea9630015e63","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01200","start_s":5956.261,"end_s":5957.362,"video_s":6836.261,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"I didn't break this system.","fingerprint":"e5019694ed33","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01201","start_s":5957.942,"end_s":5959.544,"video_s":6837.942,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"I'm pointing out the problems that are in it.","fingerprint":"27b05e433679","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01202","start_s":5960.345,"end_s":5961.626,"video_s":6840.345,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"I have probable solutions.","fingerprint":"3591bef94118","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01203","start_s":5962.166,"end_s":5962.707,"video_s":6842.166,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"I have a brain.","fingerprint":"6556a46412f8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01204","start_s":5963.348,"end_s":5964.048,"video_s":6843.348,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"I don't want to listen.","fingerprint":"45a6899f5eed","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01205","start_s":5965.089,"end_s":5968.412,"video_s":6845.089,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"Please, you guys have been listening and I appreciate you so much.","fingerprint":"2502461aff75","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01206","start_s":5969.974,"end_s":5970.374,"video_s":6849.974,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01207","start_s":5974.458,"end_s":5979.162,"video_s":6854.458,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"This ride has been amazing for me, coming in here and making the changes that we've been making.","fingerprint":"8f95475b4ddf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01208","start_s":5979.683,"end_s":5981.985,"video_s":6859.683,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"But the retaliation has been ridiculous.","fingerprint":"a40594949e05","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01209","start_s":5983.383,"end_s":5985.446,"video_s":6863.383,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"It's non-stop.","fingerprint":"2c3e9a1b9e29","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01210","start_s":5987.51,"end_s":5991.577,"video_s":6867.51,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"Somebody was just commenting that they were able to see people get housing.","fingerprint":"1abf99e0bb49","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01211","start_s":5991.837,"end_s":5993.38,"video_s":6871.837,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"They only got housing because they have money.","fingerprint":"37f8309944a1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01212","start_s":5994.401,"end_s":5997.186,"video_s":6874.401,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"Those of us that don't have any income, that can't get an income.","fingerprint":"f11b8e18a104","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01213","start_s":5999.39,"end_s":6000.471,"video_s":6879.39,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"Two years in the shelter.","fingerprint":"24ceaf2f288b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01214","start_s":6001.713,"end_s":6002.475,"video_s":6881.713,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"That's acceptable?","fingerprint":"f41d998c9c7a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01215","start_s":6003.416,"end_s":6006.501,"video_s":6883.416,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"When a shelter is worse than a prison or a jail?","fingerprint":"c8ef227d95fd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01216","start_s":6007.343,"end_s":6009.026,"video_s":6887.343,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"I'm glad you find that amusing, Warren.","fingerprint":"f117a63eea47","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01217","start_s":6009.206,"end_s":6009.947,"video_s":6889.206,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"I really am.","fingerprint":"fafb5a7f4d8e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01218","start_s":6010.248,"end_s":6018.44,"video_s":6890.248,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"To me, it's a shame that your heart is so hard and that you don't see me as a human being.","fingerprint":"1afeabdaec48","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01219","start_s":6019.822,"end_s":6020.623,"video_s":6899.822,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"I see you as one.","fingerprint":"6a2acb29f019","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01220","start_s":6021.784,"end_s":6022.886,"video_s":6901.784,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"It's amazing.","fingerprint":"b2c49bc09a5c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01221","start_s":6022.906,"end_s":6028.234,"video_s":6902.906,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"Anyway, I'm working hard to try to make the changes in the shelter for a reason.","fingerprint":"55026047533f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01222","start_s":6028.854,"end_s":6031.779,"video_s":6908.854,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"I'm not going to be in it forever, but other people are going to be moving into it.","fingerprint":"18704930eccd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01223","start_s":6032.94,"end_s":6034.402,"video_s":6912.94,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"And these changes need to be made.","fingerprint":"325f28ec8e8b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01224","start_s":6034.462,"end_s":6036.405,"video_s":6914.462,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"We need to fix the system.","fingerprint":"2153146d45b7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01225","start_s":6036.425,"end_s":6039.85,"video_s":6916.425,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"We need more funding for that, not for landlords.","fingerprint":"a63edb107c66","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01226","start_s":6041.078,"end_s":6042.821,"video_s":6921.078,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"We need funding for housing.","fingerprint":"ac57a16b320d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01227","start_s":6043.803,"end_s":6049.092,"video_s":6923.803,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"We need to help the people who are incapable of doing that for themselves.","fingerprint":"f3be4e51ed72","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01228","start_s":6049.693,"end_s":6052.938,"video_s":6929.693,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"Those that are handicapped, those that are like me, that are broken.","fingerprint":"9041e8f02e7a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01229","start_s":6053.64,"end_s":6055.182,"video_s":6933.64,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"We can't work like we used to.","fingerprint":"03c69d3d1311","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01230","start_s":6055.202,"end_s":6056.144,"video_s":6935.202,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"We can't do labor.","fingerprint":"cdeecb422642","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01231","start_s":6058.087,"end_s":6059.67,"video_s":6938.087,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"Why should I work for minimum wage anyway?","fingerprint":"4408bdc55fe2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01232","start_s":6059.81,"end_s":6061.894,"video_s":6939.81,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"You're smarter than you have to be.","fingerprint":"423ce62f20dc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01233","start_s":6061.914,"end_s":6062.715,"video_s":6941.914,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"It's fucking horrible.","fingerprint":"fda2e3e068e2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01234","start_s":6073.883,"end_s":6075.766,"video_s":6953.883,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00259","chapter":"C020","text":"The next, okay, there we go.","fingerprint":"9cb08c83cdea","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01235","start_s":6078.169,"end_s":6079.03,"video_s":6958.169,"speaker":"v21","turn":"T00260","chapter":"C020","text":"I thank you for your time.","fingerprint":"3fc6c925816d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01236","start_s":6079.611,"end_s":6082.215,"video_s":6959.611,"speaker":"v21","turn":"T00260","chapter":"C020","text":"I'm Lee Allen Ellis II, I'm with Funds for Empowerment.","fingerprint":"d00be8cecb28","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01237","start_s":6082.435,"end_s":6083.918,"video_s":6962.435,"speaker":"v21","turn":"T00260","chapter":"C020","text":"I currently reside at the SOS.","fingerprint":"d5d1df7fee35","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01238","start_s":6084.619,"end_s":6089.205,"video_s":6964.619,"speaker":"v21","turn":"T00260","chapter":"C020","text":"I'd like to take the time to thank you for our new ADA bathrooms, and I was hoping that we can make some more changes.","fingerprint":"f53eb5193260","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01239","start_s":6090.147,"end_s":6094.553,"video_s":6970.147,"speaker":"v21","turn":"T00260","chapter":"C020","text":"For instance, on our job search log, I, unlike some others, can go to the library.","fingerprint":"af7796a47b6d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01240","start_s":6095.394,"end_s":6098.659,"video_s":6975.394,"speaker":"v21","turn":"T00260","chapter":"C020","text":"They can't, so I'm hoping maybe we can get a computer in the office.","fingerprint":"dd1d12383cc7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01241","start_s":6098.808,"end_s":6123.145,"video_s":6978.808,"speaker":"v21","turn":"T00260","chapter":"C020","text":"you figure out uh finish your meeting with your case manager you can sit down on the computer give you an hour down at the library so give you an hour there um i also did want to see about the solutions we can make on permanent housing i was told section 8 was reopened and i heard hud housing might be able to help us maybe reaching out some of these other programs it would be very beneficial for us","fingerprint":"c07ddbd9a241","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01242","start_s":6124.205,"end_s":6128.111,"video_s":7004.205,"speaker":"v21","turn":"T00260","chapter":"C020","text":"A lot of the participants, like I said, they can't get down to do some of the things that I can.","fingerprint":"3e891e250a55","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01243","start_s":6128.212,"end_s":6137.567,"video_s":7008.212,"speaker":"v21","turn":"T00260","chapter":"C020","text":"But I just feel the more resources that we bring to the SOS would help us for a more positive exit and wouldn't have us to be returning.","fingerprint":"45bb9e327fee","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01244","start_s":6138.569,"end_s":6143.016,"video_s":7018.569,"speaker":"v21","turn":"T00260","chapter":"C020","text":"You'll have a very successful, or a chance for successful ending.","fingerprint":"9fc0c4c20a7b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01245","start_s":6143.437,"end_s":6145.701,"video_s":7023.437,"speaker":"v21","turn":"T00260","chapter":"C020","text":"I had some more comments here, but they've already been covered.","fingerprint":"ff5aa0340381","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01246","start_s":6145.821,"end_s":6146.923,"video_s":7025.821,"speaker":"v21","turn":"T00260","chapter":"C020","text":"So thank you guys for your time.","fingerprint":"a105d70e5480","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01247","start_s":6146.963,"end_s":6147.664,"video_s":7026.963,"speaker":"v21","turn":"T00260","chapter":"C020","text":"Have a beautiful night.","fingerprint":"2863678fcb12","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01248","start_s":6148.724,"end_s":6149.187,"video_s":7028.724,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00261","chapter":"C020","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01249","start_s":6149.67,"end_s":6154.684,"video_s":7029.67,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00261","chapter":"C020","text":"Next speaker is Natalie Miller, followed by Charles Whiteside.","fingerprint":"8aa77a8603dd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01250","start_s":6163.186,"end_s":6180.346,"video_s":7043.186,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C020","text":"Hello, I live at the SOS shelter and they have recently stopped holding our belongings and stated that they have changed rules such as perfume in plastic containers, body products.","fingerprint":"59cd36cbde43","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01251","start_s":6180.626,"end_s":6184.49,"video_s":7060.626,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C020","text":"They're basically treating us as infants or if we're in jail.","fingerprint":"7aadc1c9bfbb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01252","start_s":6185.371,"end_s":6188.515,"video_s":7065.371,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C020","text":"We have cars with fuel in the parking lot.","fingerprint":"74c73a54a68c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01253","start_s":6188.735,"end_s":6190.257,"video_s":7068.735,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C020","text":"We're adults.","fingerprint":"c43e7489e26e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01254","start_s":6190.237,"end_s":6217.729,"video_s":7070.237,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C020","text":"I mean so I literally have stayed outside for a couple nights because I'm not willing to give up certain possessions that they were keeping in lockers and have given me no option to put anywhere else expensive things people have had to throw away and then their staff takes them because they just come up all of a sudden with what they held in lockers for us now we cannot have there and we have nowhere else to put it just out of nowhere","fingerprint":"ec7c61002dc1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01255","start_s":6218.755,"end_s":6225.487,"video_s":7098.755,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C020","text":"So I'm not willing to be run over like that, and I've literally slept in the back outside so I can watch my possessions.","fingerprint":"a14c3b25d3d5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01256","start_s":6226.769,"end_s":6231.377,"video_s":7106.769,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C020","text":"Because I just don't, it's the issue of I'm tired of being run over by people for no reason.","fingerprint":"1d991dba60ea","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01257","start_s":6231.498,"end_s":6232.099,"video_s":7111.498,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C020","text":"I'm an adult.","fingerprint":"df60bedf3bd1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01258","start_s":6232.299,"end_s":6236.306,"video_s":7112.299,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C020","text":"If I want to have my perfume, they have a smoking section.","fingerprint":"fc1e733b1aa2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01259","start_s":6236.587,"end_s":6237.168,"video_s":7116.587,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C020","text":"We have cars.","fingerprint":"cd15586eb806","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01260","start_s":6237.268,"end_s":6238.35,"video_s":7117.268,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C020","text":"We have things all around us.","fingerprint":"13ef7bef8516","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01261","start_s":6238.53,"end_s":6239.532,"video_s":7118.53,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C020","text":"They are...","fingerprint":"4f616d6e36d7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01262","start_s":6239.765,"end_s":6242.714,"video_s":7119.765,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C020","text":"nitpicking and being as if we are infants.","fingerprint":"273608e3e8fd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01263","start_s":6244.098,"end_s":6252.242,"video_s":7124.098,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C020","text":"I watched them throw a man out who had just got out of the hospital and he had his paperwork because they stated that he was not medically released.","fingerprint":"ec53d51d00e5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01264","start_s":6252.624,"end_s":6254.449,"video_s":7132.624,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C020","text":"The paperwork stated he was.","fingerprint":"98c213f26229","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01265","start_s":6255.796,"end_s":6260.568,"video_s":7135.796,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C020","text":"So against fact, they put this man who just got back out the door.","fingerprint":"d36172d1ec5d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01266","start_s":6261.19,"end_s":6264.338,"video_s":7141.19,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C020","text":"I stopped an officer on the street and told him what the issue was.","fingerprint":"2eace301e77c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01267","start_s":6264.358,"end_s":6270.835,"video_s":7144.358,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C020","text":"I know that the Vulnerable Adult Arizona Revised Statute","fingerprint":"82df8af3bbb9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01268","start_s":6270.815,"end_s":6288.048,"video_s":7150.815,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C020","text":"states that anyone knowingly allowing someone who is a vulnerable adult to be in danger or be neglected, exploited, and doesn't make a report to a police officer or something like that is in violation of the law.","fingerprint":"75bbdf04128d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01269","start_s":6288.168,"end_s":6288.809,"video_s":7168.168,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C020","text":"It is a crime.","fingerprint":"dc39f04114a9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01270","start_s":6288.85,"end_s":6291.414,"video_s":7168.85,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C020","text":"This officer said there was no crime.","fingerprint":"4f795c601f5e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01271","start_s":6291.455,"end_s":6293.278,"video_s":7171.455,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C020","text":"He was not interested.","fingerprint":"1fb8ccc6d162","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01272","start_s":6294.102,"end_s":6297.508,"video_s":7174.102,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C020","text":"It is a crime according to our law, our Arizona Revised Statutes.","fingerprint":"7031b3c5ea81","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01273","start_s":6297.588,"end_s":6302.516,"video_s":7177.588,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C020","text":"I became one at one point due to Section 8 housing, very ill to where I could not even care for myself.","fingerprint":"8fb236322112","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01274","start_s":6303.337,"end_s":6307.845,"video_s":7183.337,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C020","text":"I was demeaned and told, like I didn't have the energy to clean and do anything.","fingerprint":"e5a86428e952","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01275","start_s":6308.987,"end_s":6311.19,"video_s":7188.987,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C020","text":"They told me they would come over and have someone teach me to clean.","fingerprint":"3b9bf04876ce","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01276","start_s":6311.231,"end_s":6312.633,"video_s":7191.231,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C020","text":"I didn't need to be taught how to clean.","fingerprint":"f92930ff4bb0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01277","start_s":6314.055,"end_s":6317.882,"video_s":7194.055,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C020","text":"I'm very sharp and I've slowly regained my faculties.","fingerprint":"cdc503783e83","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01278","start_s":6317.922,"end_s":6318.743,"video_s":7197.922,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C020","text":"I've just watched","fingerprint":"04b197ec62a8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01279","start_s":6319.887,"end_s":6331.063,"video_s":7199.887,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C020","text":"Too many situations where it seems like the whole purpose of these shelters and fiduciaries is to have job employment for people rather than solutions and lifting people up.","fingerprint":"3255dc8522c2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01280","start_s":6332.645,"end_s":6337.713,"video_s":7212.645,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C020","text":"For a long time I never went to a heat relief because I do not want to be checked in any manner at the door.","fingerprint":"79b5f5a1f384","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01281","start_s":6338.574,"end_s":6344.022,"video_s":7218.574,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C020","text":"Like for my being or what's on me, I just want to go in like I was in a restaurant.","fingerprint":"1e4477ae1cad","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01282","start_s":6345.825,"end_s":6346.165,"video_s":7225.825,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C020","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01283","start_s":6347.107,"end_s":6348.108,"video_s":7227.107,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00263","chapter":"C020","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01284","start_s":6348.649,"end_s":6351.713,"video_s":7228.649,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00263","chapter":"C020","text":"Charles Whiteside is next, followed by Jerry Van Gass.","fingerprint":"3508dec3df64","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01285","start_s":6357.12,"end_s":6359.924,"video_s":7237.12,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00264","chapter":"C020","text":"Good afternoon, Vice Mayor and City Council.","fingerprint":"b397bb444056","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01286","start_s":6360.284,"end_s":6361.366,"video_s":7240.284,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00264","chapter":"C020","text":"My name is Charles Whiteside.","fingerprint":"3315046cabd1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01287","start_s":6361.386,"end_s":6365.471,"video_s":7241.386,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00264","chapter":"C020","text":"I'm here with Fund for Employment and I'm also a participant in SOS.","fingerprint":"7d539b59a969","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01288","start_s":6366.232,"end_s":6370.498,"video_s":7246.232,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00264","chapter":"C020","text":"I just wanted to comment on the lack of accountability with the staff members.","fingerprint":"b13dfdc03873","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01289","start_s":6371.153,"end_s":6397.11,"video_s":7251.153,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00264","chapter":"C020","text":"I had a situation yesterday around lunchtime when me and a participant was eating and one of the staff members had brought her personal issues and she um one of the clients I asked for extra meal because around 12 45 they give out last call and it was probably about 12 55 she told the um participant she had to wait to one so I spoke up on the um","fingerprint":"c77c73fcb3f5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01290","start_s":6397.765,"end_s":6408.754,"video_s":7277.765,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00264","chapter":"C020","text":"the situation and she was upset so it's just like we get retaliation for things we talk about it's like we coming up here and we don't have a mic but you guys have a mic","fingerprint":"43c90d7397d5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01291","start_s":6409.207,"end_s":6410.468,"video_s":7289.207,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00264","chapter":"C020","text":"It's like they want to take our mics away.","fingerprint":"ae4765b0d0d8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01292","start_s":6411.91,"end_s":6415.654,"video_s":7291.91,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00264","chapter":"C020","text":"I also want to talk about what the young lady before me said about the perfume.","fingerprint":"e7cb076cdf0e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01293","start_s":6415.894,"end_s":6417.415,"video_s":7295.894,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00264","chapter":"C020","text":"I had a sleeping bag in the storage.","fingerprint":"c0efdbda7cbd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01294","start_s":6418.737,"end_s":6423.842,"video_s":7298.737,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00264","chapter":"C020","text":"And after I attend one of these meetings, they told me I had to get my sleeping bag and throw it away.","fingerprint":"11a11f89b31d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01295","start_s":6423.962,"end_s":6427.045,"video_s":7303.962,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00264","chapter":"C020","text":"But I asked, could I use it on my own, personal?","fingerprint":"e0833f42aa34","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01296","start_s":6427.105,"end_s":6429.127,"video_s":7307.105,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00264","chapter":"C020","text":"They didn't let me do that.","fingerprint":"bbc9b58b3b54","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01297","start_s":6429.288,"end_s":6430.829,"video_s":7309.288,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00264","chapter":"C020","text":"So it's just a retaliation.","fingerprint":"6be25c4aee81","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01298","start_s":6430.869,"end_s":6434.373,"video_s":7310.869,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00264","chapter":"C020","text":"Every time we speak up, it's like we get spanked for it.","fingerprint":"aa53de23edf5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01299","start_s":6434.393,"end_s":6435.814,"video_s":7314.393,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00264","chapter":"C020","text":"I appreciate you guys for listening.","fingerprint":"3d818036871d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01300","start_s":6435.994,"end_s":6436.615,"video_s":7315.994,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00264","chapter":"C020","text":"Have a good one.","fingerprint":"99c39b3fac92","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01301","start_s":6436.763,"end_s":6437.684,"video_s":7316.763,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00265","chapter":"C020","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01302","start_s":6438.565,"end_s":6440.967,"video_s":7318.565,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00265","chapter":"C020","text":"Jerry Van Gass followed by Jeremy Thacker.","fingerprint":"4f296f88cc26","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01303","start_s":6447.434,"end_s":6449.556,"video_s":7327.434,"speaker":"v24","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C020","text":"Good afternoon, Jerry Van Gass.","fingerprint":"a7ee23ebb2c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01304","start_s":6450.396,"end_s":6454.14,"video_s":7330.396,"speaker":"v24","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C020","text":"I'm a public watchdog for our Phoenix Mount Reserve System.","fingerprint":"09ab0f799d93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01305","start_s":6457.243,"end_s":6461.568,"video_s":7337.243,"speaker":"v24","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C020","text":"Nothing's more iconic in the city of Phoenix than Camelback Mount.","fingerprint":"6fe00d3b85a0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01306","start_s":6462.528,"end_s":6466.112,"video_s":7342.528,"speaker":"v24","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C020","text":"Half a million people from all over the world","fingerprint":"777967dbe36d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01307","start_s":6466.177,"end_s":6468.179,"video_s":7346.177,"speaker":"v24","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C020","text":"I hike that mountain every year.","fingerprint":"a6f70530f9c1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01308","start_s":6469.741,"end_s":6492.049,"video_s":7349.741,"speaker":"v24","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C020","text":"And yet, since the renovation of the trailhead back in 2015, January, I've been going there every day when the gates are opened by the rangers at 4.30 a.m. with a box of bananas and handing those out every day since when I'm in town.","fingerprint":"1e55079a0ae1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01309","start_s":6493.092,"end_s":6504.224,"video_s":7373.092,"speaker":"v24","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C020","text":"This year, August 1st, all of a sudden, the gates were only being open at 5 a.m. We're not sure who pushed for this.","fingerprint":"940ca89db2bd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01310","start_s":6505.465,"end_s":6506.526,"video_s":7385.465,"speaker":"v24","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C020","text":"We will find out.","fingerprint":"14e82dff14b3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01311","start_s":6507.227,"end_s":6522.643,"video_s":7387.227,"speaker":"v24","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C020","text":"And yet the Parks and Rec Department sent out a letter to city departments and others stating that it's always been 5 o'clock, except for a few slip-ups by the janitorial team leaving the gate open.","fingerprint":"ea6d3efe383f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01312","start_s":6523.889,"end_s":6526.473,"video_s":7403.889,"speaker":"v24","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C020","text":"That's a flat-out lie.","fingerprint":"aab37d948ece","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01313","start_s":6527.434,"end_s":6533.584,"video_s":7407.434,"speaker":"v24","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C020","text":"You're telling everybody 500,000 people don't know when they show up to Ike?","fingerprint":"5f1ddcd13e64","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01314","start_s":6534.525,"end_s":6539.353,"video_s":7414.525,"speaker":"v24","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C020","text":"I suggest you have a staff member go out and talk to the early arrivals.","fingerprint":"03643abb845b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01315","start_s":6540.134,"end_s":6546.724,"video_s":7420.134,"speaker":"v24","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C020","text":"They will tell you it's only been since August 1st of this year.","fingerprint":"4a9572b77e00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01316","start_s":6549.1,"end_s":6578.533,"video_s":7429.1,"speaker":"v24","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C020","text":"and then they have the gall after this five o'clock opening to take money from our 3PI voter initiative fund, not to make improvements, but to make changes that nobody was alerted to, nobody had any input on, and yet they were thwarted with another gate they were gonna put in right at the street at McDonald by the city of Paradise Valley.","fingerprint":"45a44caf682a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01317","start_s":6579.458,"end_s":6598.148,"video_s":7459.458,"speaker":"v24","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C020","text":"So you basically, we've got a record request in from our attorneys at the Arizona Center for Law and the Public Interest for the Rangers Law, which has their daily regimen, which will show that they were opening the gates at 4.30 every morning.","fingerprint":"b971b9e1dd98","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01318","start_s":6598.969,"end_s":6601.032,"video_s":7478.969,"speaker":"v24","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C020","text":"So I don't know who concocted these lies.","fingerprint":"fe9f55683d35","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01319","start_s":6601.613,"end_s":6602.254,"video_s":7481.613,"speaker":"v24","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C020","text":"They're out there.","fingerprint":"b1b0b03c2fe5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01320","start_s":6602.956,"end_s":6606.04,"video_s":7482.956,"speaker":"v24","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C020","text":"But we're gonna keep pushing until we get that 4.30 reopening.","fingerprint":"c7ac2d294423","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01321","start_s":6606.661,"end_s":6607.002,"video_s":7486.661,"speaker":"v24","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C020","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01322","start_s":6609.192,"end_s":6610.093,"video_s":7489.192,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00267","chapter":"C020","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01323","start_s":6612.596,"end_s":6617.001,"video_s":7492.596,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00267","chapter":"C020","text":"Jeremy is next, followed by Devonte Stanley.","fingerprint":"06756feda386","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01324","start_s":6622.929,"end_s":6635.824,"video_s":7502.929,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"So we've read the reports about Echo Canyon that have been sent to you by Marty, who claims that the agreement has been sunrise to sunset.","fingerprint":"4058ba2270b9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01325","start_s":6636.277,"end_s":6636.798,"video_s":7516.277,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"That is true.","fingerprint":"9d7061267b67","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01326","start_s":6636.938,"end_s":6643.105,"video_s":7516.938,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"That was the agreement signed when we exchanged land with the Camelback homeowners.","fingerprint":"d77bf912988b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01327","start_s":6644.626,"end_s":6650.633,"video_s":7524.626,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"That's not 5 a.m. Sunrise to sunset is a moving target, not 5 a.m.","fingerprint":"375f6a5c8abe","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01328","start_s":6651.334,"end_s":6653.717,"video_s":7531.334,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"So watch the sleight of hand that's being pulled.","fingerprint":"568031401ce1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01329","start_s":6654.718,"end_s":6656.92,"video_s":7534.718,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"When he's acting like it's one and the same, it's not.","fingerprint":"3be3304dd5a3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01330","start_s":6657.541,"end_s":6659.043,"video_s":7537.541,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"So how did we change it?","fingerprint":"29198f375d99","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01331","start_s":6659.243,"end_s":6663.668,"video_s":7539.243,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"If we've got to get permission and we have an agreement with those homeowners from sunrise to sunset,","fingerprint":"05a97c4f27b7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01332","start_s":6665.875,"end_s":6667.678,"video_s":7545.875,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"Why are we opening at 5 a.m.?","fingerprint":"4e9ec50f4487","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01333","start_s":6667.698,"end_s":6668.859,"video_s":7547.698,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"That's not what was agreed to.","fingerprint":"4217e1e014f4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01334","start_s":6669.5,"end_s":6670.762,"video_s":7549.5,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"We're already violating the agreement.","fingerprint":"fc3a2a691e5b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01335","start_s":6672.244,"end_s":6680.175,"video_s":7552.244,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"So it's blaming it on the cleaning crew is condescending and wrong.","fingerprint":"406ed8efc0b9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01336","start_s":6681.257,"end_s":6687.345,"video_s":7561.257,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"Jerry has been delivering 40 pounds of bananas daily to Echo Canyon for a decade.","fingerprint":"618c3e88ed25","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01337","start_s":6687.365,"end_s":6689.829,"video_s":7567.365,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"I think he knows what time it opens.","fingerprint":"a444c43bdcaa","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01338","start_s":6690.69,"end_s":6692.092,"video_s":7570.69,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"He's got a pretty good feel for it at this point.","fingerprint":"b9d5df5d9f55","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01339","start_s":6692.953,"end_s":6695.697,"video_s":7572.953,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"He's known as Banana Man.","fingerprint":"9888f8d1e82c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01340","start_s":6695.845,"end_s":6724.992,"video_s":7575.845,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"he's out there and if there's one thing about Jerry he shows up on time every time so just be honest if we're moving it to five say we're moving it to five say we didn't do it but stop pissing on our legs and tell us it's raining so we're getting ready to submit a citizen petition about these damn things too","fingerprint":"b1905e8c4a85","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01341","start_s":6725.343,"end_s":6729.128,"video_s":7605.343,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"This is a complete rock.","fingerprint":"99ea9cf9c2a5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01342","start_s":6729.148,"end_s":6742.848,"video_s":7609.148,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"The mayor sat up here and said, changed them last year, and stopped showing the dais so she can leave and not be on camera, or so people can't see who stands up here on camera.","fingerprint":"e42525d8a7cc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01343","start_s":6744.089,"end_s":6748.355,"video_s":7624.089,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"YouTube is perfectly capable of captions in real time.","fingerprint":"011aa54ba8e3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01344","start_s":6749.136,"end_s":6750.078,"video_s":7629.136,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"So why are we showing this?","fingerprint":"30bcd6d9d2b1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01345","start_s":6750.919,"end_s":6755.265,"video_s":7630.919,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"The only place we broadcast this is YouTube, and that technology is completely available and has been.","fingerprint":"8feaba6e0e05","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01346","start_s":6756.832,"end_s":6759.015,"video_s":7636.832,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"So why are we not showing the people?","fingerprint":"471af2ee329e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01347","start_s":6759.335,"end_s":6760.676,"video_s":7639.335,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"The city code requires it.","fingerprint":"3ad67f214af5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01348","start_s":6761.277,"end_s":6763.96,"video_s":7641.277,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"Every meeting of the formal council will be televised.","fingerprint":"3801c318cdaa","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01349","start_s":6764.561,"end_s":6766.643,"video_s":7644.561,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"This is not televised.","fingerprint":"bc5559af335c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01350","start_s":6768.686,"end_s":6769.807,"video_s":7648.686,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"This is an audio recording.","fingerprint":"0149740aa5d1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01351","start_s":6771.629,"end_s":6780.139,"video_s":7651.629,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"This doesn't allow people to see who's speaking, to form groups, to petition our government, to congratulate one another or to support one another.","fingerprint":"863b5827aa4a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01352","start_s":6782.009,"end_s":6784.775,"video_s":7662.009,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"This needs to be live and we're submitting a citizen petition to bring it back.","fingerprint":"ba043ad8cdba","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01353","start_s":6785.276,"end_s":6786.459,"video_s":7665.276,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"And who voted on it?","fingerprint":"592b0bb65406","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01354","start_s":6786.9,"end_s":6787.922,"video_s":7666.9,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"When did that vote take place?","fingerprint":"c75c44af9dab","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01355","start_s":6789.767,"end_s":6790.989,"video_s":7669.767,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"This is a major change.","fingerprint":"501c7c9c64fb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01356","start_s":6792.774,"end_s":6793.395,"video_s":7672.774,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"Who decided this?","fingerprint":"3d2e2303916b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01357","start_s":6793.896,"end_s":6794.377,"video_s":7673.896,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"Was it y'all?","fingerprint":"6aadbd595dfa","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01358","start_s":6794.397,"end_s":6794.938,"video_s":7674.397,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"Was it the mayor?","fingerprint":"389cd7867a51","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01359","start_s":6795.56,"end_s":6796.221,"video_s":7675.56,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"Was it in secret?","fingerprint":"f7ee3317476d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01360","start_s":6797.725,"end_s":6800.451,"video_s":7677.725,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"We'd like to know and we're going to do that right now.","fingerprint":"409f5c5a7534","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01361","start_s":6800.651,"end_s":6800.912,"video_s":7680.651,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C020","text":"Thanks.","fingerprint":"a6a2729cbf6b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01362","start_s":6802.411,"end_s":6802.932,"video_s":7682.411,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00269","chapter":"C020","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01363","start_s":6803.733,"end_s":6806.697,"video_s":7683.733,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00269","chapter":"C020","text":"We are approaching the 30-minute mark.","fingerprint":"ef445e1a8dea","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01364","start_s":6806.717,"end_s":6812.965,"video_s":7686.717,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00269","chapter":"C020","text":"So if we, this may be our last speaker, depending on how long Mr. Devante Stanley takes.","fingerprint":"2c2ebd466e57","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01365","start_s":6813.185,"end_s":6813.726,"video_s":7693.185,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00269","chapter":"C020","text":"Then if you.","fingerprint":"456114190731","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01366","start_s":6817.271,"end_s":6822.418,"video_s":7697.271,"speaker":"v25","turn":"T00270","chapter":"C020","text":"Hello, I'm with Funds for Empowerment and also a member at the SOS program.","fingerprint":"8695ee44633d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01367","start_s":6823.019,"end_s":6827.845,"video_s":7703.019,"speaker":"v25","turn":"T00270","chapter":"C020","text":"I just wanted to say that the plumbing and showers could be a lot better and","fingerprint":"5ec290518e72","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01368","start_s":6828.55,"end_s":6833.215,"video_s":7708.55,"speaker":"v25","turn":"T00270","chapter":"C020","text":"A lot of the staff could do a lot better at their jobs than what they are doing.","fingerprint":"9d9bb7a5ad2b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01369","start_s":6836.9,"end_s":6837.42,"video_s":7716.9,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00271","chapter":"C020","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01370","start_s":6838.241,"end_s":6841.505,"video_s":7718.241,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00271","chapter":"C020","text":"We have one more speaker, Leonard Clark.","fingerprint":"aa3b2b28b29c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01371","start_s":6841.945,"end_s":6842.266,"video_s":7721.945,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00271","chapter":"C020","text":"Go ahead.","fingerprint":"d44fcf731c17","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01372","start_s":6848.713,"end_s":6850.115,"video_s":7728.713,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00272","chapter":"C020","text":"Thank you, Mayor and Councilmembers.","fingerprint":"81f8dc494263","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01373","start_s":6850.555,"end_s":6852.077,"video_s":7730.555,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00272","chapter":"C020","text":"First of all, I want to thank","fingerprint":"1555f5d53801","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01374","start_s":6853.002,"end_s":6882.857,"video_s":7733.002,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00272","chapter":"C020","text":"the beautiful people who are here because I need to come here so I can listen when you're in person that works you know you can hear what's going on so I'm hoping that they we can achieve some accountability on what they're talking about but also I'm here because I'm concerned I believe the midterm elections are 27 days away and I want the citizens of Phoenix to be to know they're safe from intimidation and I'm not talking from a democrat republican because I am an independent although I lean very heavily left","fingerprint":"266b959cebb1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01375","start_s":6882.837,"end_s":6891.126,"video_s":7762.837,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00272","chapter":"C020","text":"but I'm just worried because in 27 days I don't want the city the residents of Phoenix to show up and","fingerprint":"bcbe41c509cb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01376","start_s":6891.73,"end_s":6899.579,"video_s":7771.73,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00272","chapter":"C020","text":"people are standing there demanding their identification, FBI agents that work for Kash Patel, these types of things.","fingerprint":"1ec2daca3411","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01377","start_s":6900.079,"end_s":6911.171,"video_s":7780.079,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00272","chapter":"C020","text":"And I know that the other authorities are going to be working on that, but I'm just wondering, I'm hoping our law enforcement will remember their constitutional oaths and the laws of Arizona that these things are not allowed.","fingerprint":"49d05031ec7a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01378","start_s":6911.532,"end_s":6917.138,"video_s":7791.532,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00272","chapter":"C020","text":"Also, I want to send a shout out to the truck drivers of Arizona, the ones in Phoenix and all around the state of Arizona.","fingerprint":"90b92ce83abb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01379","start_s":6917.158,"end_s":6921.703,"video_s":7797.158,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00272","chapter":"C020","text":"I've had family members because Phoenix is on a very tenuous","fingerprint":"995d42be921a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01380","start_s":6922.173,"end_s":6939.203,"video_s":7802.173,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00272","chapter":"C020","text":"line we are running very close on the diesel and the truck drivers are literally having less food to put on their tables for their children due to you know what going on in Iran so I just want to say thank you to all those truck drivers I know some of you like Trump but despite that","fingerprint":"03adf0f64177","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01381","start_s":6939.183,"end_s":6968.987,"video_s":7819.183,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00272","chapter":"C020","text":"we're Americans and I want to thank you for helping put food on the tables for the citizens of Phoenix because that diesel is going up up and up and it looks like it's going to get worse so I call on the citizens of Phoenix don't do what you know the lawlessness in Washington DC wants I call on the citizens of Phoenix to get along with each other look at the human person before you not at their political party because I can tell you that's what certain political forces want in Washington DC and you know who I'm talking about thank you","fingerprint":"cdc6bdd4c935","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01382","start_s":6969.423,"end_s":6994.62,"video_s":7849.423,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00273","chapter":"C020","text":"thank you so much we've reached the end of public comment in terms of yeah you can bring that to the clerk and you can bring that up to the front of the clerk for to receive that for anyone who is registered to speak for public comment that didn't get called today you're invited to return at our next meeting and your names will be called first during our public comment with that we are adjourned thank you","fingerprint":"c87a824d9ba7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01383","start_s":7004.219,"end_s":7005.021,"video_s":7884.219,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00274","chapter":"C020","text":"Indian School Park.","fingerprint":"c4e284a084ed","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01384","start_s":7005.041,"end_s":7009.169,"video_s":7885.041,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00274","chapter":"C020","text":"My name is Marty Whitfield and I'm the Parks and Recreation Director for the City of Phoenix.","fingerprint":"39edc58107d1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01385","start_s":7009.731,"end_s":7020.473,"video_s":7889.731,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00274","chapter":"C020","text":"It is a privilege to welcome you all here this morning for this special groundbreaking ceremony to commemorate the start of the construction of the USS Phoenix Cold War Monument.","fingerprint":"4ac4a47e4e1f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]}],"items":[{"event_item_id":65487,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Present"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Present"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Present"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Present"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Present"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Present"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Present"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Present"}]},{"event_item_id":65567,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":".","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65660,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":"Councilwoman Pastor attended the meeting virtually. Councilwoman Guardado was absent. Mayor Gallego left the voting body at 3:44 pm.\n\nMayor Gallego acknowledged the presence of Mario Barajas and Elsie Duarte, Spanish interpreters. In Spanish, Mr. Barajas announced their availability to the audience.\n\nThe City Clerk confirmed copies of the titles of Ordinances G-7549 through 7551; S-53190 and 53225 through S-53252 were available to the public in the office of the City Clerk at least 24 hours prior to this Council meeting and, therefore, may be read by title or agenda item only pursuant to the City Code.\n\nReferences to attachments in these minutes relate to documents that were attached to the agenda.\n\nCity Attorney Julie Kriegh stated members of the public may speak for up to two minutes on agenda items and gave direction on appropriate decorum when providing comments.\n\nMayor Gallego announced the retirement of Scott Stevenson and expressed her congratulations.","votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65488,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"MINUTES OF MEETINGS","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65489,"agenda_number":"1","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"For Approval or Correction, the Minutes of the Formal Meeting on December 17, 2025","matter_file":"26-1561","matter_type":"Minutes","action":"approved","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65490,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65491,"agenda_number":"2","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Mayor and Council Appointments to Boards and Commissions","matter_file":"26-2168","matter_type":"Board & Commission","action":"approved","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"The following individuals were recommended for appointment by Mayor Gallego, City Manager Ed Zuercher and Councilmembers:\n\nDevelopment Advisory Board\nAppoint Harry Curtin, will serve a second term, to expire October 7, 2029, as recommended by Mayor Gallego.\n\nAppoint Jenifer Weskalnies, will serve a second term, to expire October 7, 2029, Recommended by Mayor Gallego\n\nPhoenix Arts and Culture Commission\nAppoint Gaby Cardenas, filling a vacancy, for a term to expire September 30, 2029, as recommended by Mayor Gallego.\n\nPhoenix Deferred Compensation/Post Employment Health Plan Boards\nAppoint Mayra Baquera, replaces Scott Steventon as the City of Phoenix Employees' Retirement , as recommended by Mayor Gallego and City Manager Ed Zuercher.\n\nPublic Safety Personnel Retirement System Local Fire Pension Board\nAppoint Mayra Baquera is the City of Phoenix Retirement Programs Director and replaces Scott Steventon as Chair recommended by Mayor Gallego.\n\nPublic Safety Personnel Retirement System Local Police Pension Board\nAppoint Mayra Baquera is the City of Phoenix Retirement Programs Director and replaces Scott Steventon as Chair recommended by Mayor Gallego.\n\nVision Zero Community Advisory Committee\nAppoint Ann Edington, fills a vacancy, for a term to expire October 7, 2028, as recommended by Councilwoman O'Brien.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65661,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":"Mayor Gallego administered the oath of office to the following appointees:\n- Harry Curtin and Jenifer Weskalnies, Development Advisory Board; and\n- Gaby Cardenas, Phoenix Arts and Culture Commission.\n\nMayor Gallego invited the appointees to approach the dais so Council would extend their appreciation.","votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65492,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"LIQUOR LICENSES, BINGO, AND OFF-TRACK BETTING LICENSE APPLICATIONS","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65662,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":"Mayor Gallego requested a motion on the remaining agenda items. A motion was made, as appears below.","votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65622,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":"approved and/or adopted as part of an omnibus motion","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65498,"agenda_number":"3","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - 7-Eleven #47406A - District 2","matter_file":"26-2047","matter_type":"License - Liquor","action":"recommended for approval","passed":null,"consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65506,"agenda_number":"4","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Special Event - Free Serbian Orthodox Church St. Nicholas - District 3","matter_file":"26-2095","matter_type":"License - Special Event","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65501,"agenda_number":"5","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Special Event - St. George Antiochian Orthodox Church - District 3","matter_file":"26-2021","matter_type":"License - Special Event","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65500,"agenda_number":"6","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Staybridge Suites Phoenix North I-17 - District 3","matter_file":"26-2053","matter_type":"License - Liquor","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65496,"agenda_number":"7","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Turney Neighborhood Market - District 4","matter_file":"26-2026","matter_type":"License - Liquor","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65495,"agenda_number":"8","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Mariscos Y Sushi El Kora #2 - District 5","matter_file":"26-2000","matter_type":"License - Liquor","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65504,"agenda_number":"9","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Special Event - Arizona Parks and Recreation Association - District 6","matter_file":"26-2054","matter_type":"License - Special Event","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65502,"agenda_number":"10","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Special Event - Shemer Art Center and Museum Association, Inc. - District 6","matter_file":"26-2039","matter_type":"License - Special Event","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65503,"agenda_number":"11","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Special Event - St. Theresa Roman Catholic Parish Phoenix - District 6","matter_file":"26-2049","matter_type":"License - Special Event","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65493,"agenda_number":"12","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Ahwatukee Golf Club - District 6","matter_file":"26-1865","matter_type":"License - Liquor","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65505,"agenda_number":"13","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Special Event - Phoenix Community Alliance, Inc. - District 7","matter_file":"26-2058","matter_type":"License - Special Event","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65497,"agenda_number":"14","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Get It & Go Liquor - District 7","matter_file":"26-2031","matter_type":"License - Liquor","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65499,"agenda_number":"15","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Cocina Madrigal - District 8","matter_file":"26-2052","matter_type":"License - Liquor","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65494,"agenda_number":"16","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Viva Liquors - District 8","matter_file":"26-1916","matter_type":"License - Liquor","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65507,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"ORDINANCES, RESOLUTIONS, AND NEW BUSINESS","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65663,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":"Mayor Gallego requested a motion on the remaining agenda items. A motion was made, as appears below.","votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65623,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":"approved and/or adopted as part of an omnibus motion","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65664,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":"Items 17-79, Ordinance S-53225 was a request to authorize the City Controller to disburse funds, up to amounts indicated, for the purpose of paying vendors, contractors, claimants and others, and providing additional payment authority under certain existing city contracts. This section also requested continuing payment authority, up to amounts indicated below, for the following contracts, contract extensions and/or bids awarded. As indicated below, some items below require payment pursuant to Phoenix City Code Section 42-13.\n\nMayor Gallego asked Vice Mayor if she had a motion to suspend the rules and take items out of order.\n\nA motion was made by Vice Mayor Hodge Washington, seconded by Councilwoman O'Brien to suspend the rules and take item 62, 63, and 65 out of order.","votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65513,"agenda_number":"17","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Arizona Municipal Water Users Association - Annual Payment Authority","matter_file":"26-0645","matter_type":"Payment Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":null,"consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65511,"agenda_number":"18","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Central Arizona Project","matter_file":"26-1871","matter_type":"Payment Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65514,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"ADMINISTRATION","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65512,"agenda_number":"19","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Oliver Industries, LLC","matter_file":"26-1982","matter_type":"Payment Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65568,"agenda_number":"20","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"TesoroVC Management LLC","matter_file":"26-1700","matter_type":"Payment Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65508,"agenda_number":"21","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Settlement of Claim(s) Abakar v. City of Phoenix","matter_file":"26-1971","matter_type":"Payment Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65509,"agenda_number":"22","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Settlement of Claim(s) Englandside v. City of Phoenix","matter_file":"26-1972","matter_type":"Payment Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65515,"agenda_number":"24","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"(CONTINUED FROM SEPTEMBER 23, 2026) - Grant of Three Public Utility Easements for Lift Station 40 (Ordinance S-53190) - District 6","matter_file":"26-2091","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65517,"agenda_number":"26","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Audit Consulting Services Contracts - COOP 24-0072 - Amendment (Ordinance S-53228) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1329","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65518,"agenda_number":"27","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Bloomberg Datalicense Agreement for SAP S4HANA Contract - Request for Award (Ordinance S-53235) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1866","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65519,"agenda_number":"28","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Acceptance and Dedication of Easements for Public Utility Purposes (Ordinance S-53236) - Districts 6 and 8","matter_file":"26-1904","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65520,"agenda_number":"29","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Agreement for Software and Related Services between the City of Phoenix and NAVEX Global, Inc. - 162108 - Amendment (Ordinance S-53226) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1844","matter_type":"Law Dept. Consolidated S-Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65521,"agenda_number":"30","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"On-Line Investment Market Information and News Services - RFA-91-069 - Amendment (Ordinance S -53226) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1949","matter_type":"Law Dept. Consolidated S-Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65524,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"COMMUNITY SERVICES","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65522,"agenda_number":"31","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Public Communication Equipment and Services - COOP-20-077 - Amendment (Ordinance S-53227) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1233","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65526,"agenda_number":"33","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Chiller And Boiler System Maintenance Contracts - IFB FY27-086-03 Request for Award (Ordinance S-53245) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1987","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65525,"agenda_number":"34","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Multi-Family Roofing Replacement Project Contract - IFB FY27-086-04 - Request for Award (Ordinance S-53244) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1986","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65583,"agenda_number":"36","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Request to Amend City Contract 164226 with Senior Bridge, LLC (Ordinance S- 53250)- District 8","matter_file":"26-2082","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65528,"agenda_number":"37","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Phoenix Public Library's Annual Application for Arizona State Library's State Grants-In-Aid Funds (Ordinance S-53243) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1977","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65529,"agenda_number":"38","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Request to Waive Indemnity and Liability Provisions of Phoenix City Code 42-18 to Enter into an Agreement With Gannett Media Corp. (Ordinance S-53226) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0427","matter_type":"Law Dept. Consolidated S-Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65530,"agenda_number":"39","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Spanish Language Periodicals Contract - RFA 26-0354 Request for Award (Ordinance S-53226) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1909","matter_type":"Law Dept. Consolidated S-Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65531,"agenda_number":"40","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Mailing Services with Electronic Transfer - Professional Services Agreement 161139 - Amendment (Ordinance S-53226) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-2040","matter_type":"Law Dept. Consolidated S-Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65532,"agenda_number":"41","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Funding Agreement for Valley Youth Theatre General Obligation Bond Project (Ordinance S-53241) - District 7","matter_file":"26-1960","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"withdrawn","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65533,"agenda_number":"42","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Rio Salado Transformation Site Mural Agreement -  Request for Award (Ordinance S-53226) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-2012","matter_type":"Law Dept. Consolidated S-Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65534,"agenda_number":"43","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Basketball Backboard Systems Repair and Preventive Maintenance - PKS-IFB-26-0337- Request for Award (Ordinance S -53233) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1843","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65535,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65536,"agenda_number":"44","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Growth Projections and Land Use Assumptions Update - Amendment (Ordinance S-53226) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1328","matter_type":"Law Dept. Consolidated S-Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65581,"agenda_number":"45","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Rapid Reskill Employment Recovery National Dislocated Worker Grants (Ordinance S-53251) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1790","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65544,"agenda_number":"49","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"American Airlines Cargo Transfer Point Land Lease (Ordinance S-53226) - District 8","matter_file":"26-1674","matter_type":"Law Dept. Consolidated S-Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65547,"agenda_number":"50","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Amend Real Property Commercial Lease with Almond Brothers, L.L.C. (Ordinance S-53226) - District 8","matter_file":"26-2004","matter_type":"Law Dept. Consolidated S-Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65538,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"PUBLIC SAFETY","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65548,"agenda_number":"51","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Baggage Handling Controls System Design, Programming, and Integration Services Contract - RFA 25-025 - Amendment (Ordinance S-53226) - District 8","matter_file":"26-2023","matter_type":"Law Dept. Consolidated S-Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65546,"agenda_number":"52","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Baggage Handling System Operation, Maintenance and Repair Services - RFP 19-008 - Amendment (Ordinance S-53226) - District 8","matter_file":"26-1996","matter_type":"Law Dept. Consolidated S-Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65542,"agenda_number":"53","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Passenger Boarding Bridges Maintenance and Repair Services Contract - AVN RFP 23-035 - Amendment (Ordinance S-53237) - District 8","matter_file":"26-1912","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65541,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"TRANSPORTATION AND INFRASTRUCTURE","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65543,"agenda_number":"54","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Robotic Assistance Purchase and Services Contract - RFA 26-0350 Request for Award (Ordinance S-53226)  - District 8","matter_file":"26-1522","matter_type":"Law Dept. Consolidated S-Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65545,"agenda_number":"55","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Southwest Airlines Cargo Transfer Point Land Lease (Ordinance S-53226) - District 8","matter_file":"26-1687","matter_type":"Law Dept. Consolidated S-Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65549,"agenda_number":"56","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Authorization to Enter Into an Easement Agreement with 701 N. Central Owner, LLC for the use of Real Property for Valley Metro Rail, Inc. (Ordinance S-53234) - District 7","matter_file":"26-1862","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65550,"agenda_number":"58","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Cooling Tower Water Treatment Services, IFB 27-FMD-013, Request for Award (Ordinance S-53226) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1743","matter_type":"Law Dept. Consolidated S-Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65552,"agenda_number":"59","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Fleet Vehicle Accessories and Installation - IFB 24-FSD-014 - Amendment (Ordinance S-53226) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1786","matter_type":"Law Dept. Consolidated S-Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65556,"agenda_number":"60","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Citywide General Construction - Job Order Contracting Services Amendment - 4108JOC209 (Ordinance S-53232)- Districts 1, 3, 4, 7, and 8","matter_file":"26-1832","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65557,"agenda_number":"61","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Fire Alarm Services - Cooperative Use Job Order Contracting Services Amendment (Ordinance S-53242) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1961","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65558,"agenda_number":"64","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Permit, License, Utility, and Land Use Agreement Authorization for Paradise Ridge Flood Control Project (Ordinance S-53248) - District 2","matter_file":"26-2076","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65559,"agenda_number":"66","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Thermoplastic Pavement Marking Raw Material Contract - IFB-26-0348 - Request for Award (Ordinance S-53226) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1634","matter_type":"Law Dept. Consolidated S-Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65582,"agenda_number":"67","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Traffic Signal Visibility; Three Intersections, Phoenix (RSAP/HSIP Traffic Signal Visibility Three Locations) - Design-Bid-Build Services - ST89320171 (Ordinance S-53252) - Districts 2, 3, 4, 7, and 8","matter_file":"26-1924","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65562,"agenda_number":"68","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Chlorination Systems Equipment Parts and Service - IFB-1920-WPP-248 - Amendment (Ordinance S-53226) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1852","matter_type":"Law Dept. Consolidated S-Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65561,"agenda_number":"69","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Copper Pipe Contract - IFB-26-0311 Request for Award (Ordinance S-53226) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1794","matter_type":"Law Dept. Consolidated S-Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65579,"agenda_number":"71","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Abandonment of Right-of-Way - ABND 230053 - 1st Avenue and Riverside Avenue (Resolution 22397) - District 7","matter_file":"26-2027","matter_type":"Resolution","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65572,"agenda_number":"72","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Abandonment of Right-of-Way - ABND 230055 - Harrison Street, between 7th Avenue and 9th Avenue (Resolution 22396) - District 7","matter_file":"26-1931","matter_type":"Resolution","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65577,"agenda_number":"73","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Amend City Code - Official Supplementary Zoning Map 1311 (Ordinance G-7549) - District 2","matter_file":"26-1838","matter_type":"Ordinance-G","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65571,"agenda_number":"77","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Amend City Code - Ordinance Adoption - Rezoning Application Z-80-26-2 - Southwest Corner of 28th Street and Rose Garden Lane (Ordinance G-7550) - District 2","matter_file":"26-1945","matter_type":"Ordinance-G","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65570,"agenda_number":"78","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Formal Action - PCD Major Amendment - Rezoning Application Z-104-L-75-3 - Southeast Corner of Interstate 17 and Grandview Road - District 3","matter_file":"26-1975","matter_type":"Formal Action","action":"approved","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65580,"agenda_number":"79","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Amend City Code - Ordinance Adoption - Rezoning Application PHO-6-26--Z-47-19-7 - Approximately 800 Feet South of the Southwest Corner of 59th Avenue and Baseline Road (Ordinance G-7551) - District 7","matter_file":"26-2008","matter_type":"Ordinance-G","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65554,"agenda_number":"62","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Joan Ganz Cooney Way Ceremonial Street Name Signage - District 8","matter_file":"26-1936","matter_type":"Formal Action","action":"approved","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\n\nMotion was made by Councilwoman Stark to approve this item. The motion was seconded by Councilwoman O'Brien.\n\nCouncilwoman Stark expressed her strong support for the new Joan Ganz Cooney Way street name signage in honor of the creator of Sesame Street. She stated the huge impact Sesame Street had on early childhood development . She expressed pride in recognizing Joan Ganz Cooney who was a Phoenix native and served communities across the world.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington expressed her support for the Joan Ganz Cooney street name signage. She noted the impact Sesame Street had across the world.\n\nJulia Tagert expressed her support for item 62.\n\nMayor Gallego expressed her support for the Joan Ganz Cooney name signage and stated the Ganz family had left an extraordinary legacy in Phoenix. She mentioned she had grown up watching Sesame Street and now as a parent she is excited for the recognition of Joan Ganz Cooney.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65553,"agenda_number":"63","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Mel Martin Mile Ceremonial Street Name Signage - District 1","matter_file":"26-1676","matter_type":"Formal Action","action":"approved","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\n\nMotion was made by Councilwoman O'Brien to approve this item. The motion was seconded by Vice Mayor Hodge Washington.\n\nCouncilwoman O'Brien emphasized Mel Martin's cultural, historical, and educational contribution to Phoenix. She told the history of Martin's life preserving and sharing automotive history. She expressed his significant mark in automotive history and her pride in naming a street after him.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65555,"agenda_number":"65","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Serbian Heritage Way Ceremonial Street Name Signage - District 8","matter_file":"26-1970","matter_type":"Formal Action","action":"approved","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\n\nMotion was made by Vice Mayor Hodge Washington to approve this item. The motion was seconded by Councilwoman O'Brien.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington expressed her support in the recognition of Sava Serbian Orthodox Church street name signage. She noted it was an anchor in Phoenix since 1958 offering community support for nearly seven decades while preserving the Serbian-American heritage. Vice Mayor Hodge Washington was proud to support this item.\n\nLeonard Clark expressed his support for this item.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65510,"agenda_number":"23","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Settlement of Claim(s) Jadran v. City of Phoenix","matter_file":"26-2029","matter_type":"Payment Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\n\nMotion was made by Vice Mayor Hodge Washington to approve this item. The motion was seconded by Councilwoman O'Brien.\n\nCouncilwoman Hernandez expressed her concern with the settlement involving on-duty officers. She stated that the settlement money should have gone towards local community services. She expressed her approval for the item since a harmed resident deserved repair and accountability. She noted the need for the city to look into how public dollars were used and to identify ways to prevent similar incidents. She concluded by saying that the city had a responsibility not only to address harm but to learn from these incidents and take steps to prevent future harm.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65516,"agenda_number":"25","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Request to Enter into Partner Site Agreements with Northern Arizona University - Center for Service and Volunteerism, Arizona Health Corps and Environmental Literacy Corps AmeriCorps Programs (Ordinance S-53247) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-2061","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\n\nMotion was made by Vice Mayor Hodge Washington to approve this item. The motion was seconded by Councilwoman O'Brien.\n\nLeonard Clark expressed his support for this item.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"No"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65523,"agenda_number":"32","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Outside Legal Counsel for the City Ethics Commission - Amendment (Ordinance S-53226) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-2002","matter_type":"Law Dept. Consolidated S-Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\n\nMotion was made by Vice Mayor Hodge Washington to approve this item. The motion was seconded by Councilwoman O'Brien.\n\nJeremy Thacker expressed his opposition for this item.\n\nKriston Lisson expressed her opposition for this item.\n\nCouncilwoman Hernandez requested clarification on the purpose of the Ethics Commission and how members are selected to join.\n\nDeputy City Manager David Mathews stated the purpose of the Ethics Commission was to review ethical concerns brought forward regarding elected officials and committee members.\n\nChief Counsel David Benton stated the members were elected through the Judicial Selection Advisory Board.\n\nCouncilwoman Hernandez inquired about the process that followed the submission of a complaint and clarified who was responsible for receiving it.\n\nMr. Mathews stated the complaint initially is initially sent to the City Clerk's Office, and then forwarded to the Ethics Commission. He explained that the commission, following city code and its established rules, determined the status and final disposition of the complaint.\n\nCouncilwoman Hernandez asked what consequences were imposed if ethics violations were found and who was responsible for determining them.\n\nMr. Benton stated the recommended complaints go through City Council. If a complaint was dismissed or closed, the process ended. Once a complaint was closed or dismissed, it was made public on the city's website, but remained confidential while under review.\n\nCouncilwoman Hernandez asked whether additional information could be provided regarding the amount being funded. She questioned what the contract was intended to focus in response to what was mentioned during public comment.\n\nMr. Benton explained that the contract had been initially approved in March 2024 to hire outside legal counsel due to a conflict of interest within the City Attorney’s Office. The contract ensured independent legal guidance and prevented any appearance of impropriety. He further noted that the action added additional funding so outside counsel could continue their investigative work and advisory responsibilities.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"No"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65563,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"PLANNING AND ZONING MATTERS","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65527,"agenda_number":"35","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Request Retroactive Authorization to Apply for, Accept and Enter into an Agreement for Fiscal Year 2027 State Housing Trust Fund Housing Solutions Grant Funds (Ordinance S-53246) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1991","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\n\nMotion was made by Vice Mayor Hodge Washington to approve this item. The motion was seconded by Councilwoman O'Brien.\n\nCouncilwoman Hernandez expressed strong support for the proposed $500,000 grant application which supported workforce readiness. She noted that the program would provide daily employment opportunities, behavioral health services, and assistance with housing placement. She thanked the Office of Homeless Solutions, Fund for Empowerment and the many community organizations that advocated for the unsheltered residents. She expressed her anticipation to see the project move forward.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65537,"agenda_number":"46","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Contract with the Los Angeles Organizing Committee for the 2028 Olympic and Paralympic Games to host Olympic Torch Relay and Related Events (Ordinance S-53249) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-2118","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\n\nMotion was made by Vice Mayor Hodge Washington to approve this item. The motion was seconded by Councilwoman O'Brien.\n\nMayor Gallego stated the United States would host the 2028 Summer Olympics and she expressed excitement of the possibility of participating in the LA28 torch relay. She emphasized that the nation could take pride in the upcoming Olympics and that Phoenix would be honored to help showcase the community.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington expressed her excitement in support of the item. She noted it would give residents an opportunity to experience a piece of the Olympic Games right here in our community.\n\nCouncilwoman O'Brien conveyed her enthusiasm for the possibility of Phoenix participating the 2028 Summer Olympics torch relay. Councilwoman O'Brien highlighted hosting other major sporting events noting that the 2028 Summer Olympics would be a historic moment for Phoenix.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65539,"agenda_number":"47","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Authorization to Enter into Agreements with the Drug Enforcement Administration for Reimbursement for Police Services (Ordinance S-53229) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1507","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted as amended","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\n\nMotion was made by Vice Mayor Hodge Washington to approve this item. The motion was seconded by Councilwoman O'Brien.\n\nLeonard Clark voiced his approval for item 47 and his concerns related to item 47.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65540,"agenda_number":"48","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"CovertTrack Global Positioning Units - RFA-18-017 - Amendment (Ordinance S-53231) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1739","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\n\nMotion was made by Vice Mayor Hodge Washington to approve this item. The motion was seconded by Councilwoman O'Brien.\n\nLeonard Clark expressed his disapproval for item 48.\n\nCouncilwoman Hernandez","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"No"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65551,"agenda_number":"57","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Backflow Assembly Testing, Repair and Replacement Services - Amendment (Ordinance S-53226) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1774","matter_type":"Law Dept. Consolidated S-Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\n\nMotion was made by Vice Mayor Hodge Washington to approve this item. The motion was seconded by Councilwoman O'Brien.\n\nTammy Weaver expressed her support for this item. She provided Council with concerns and request for future compliance ideas.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65560,"agenda_number":"70","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Water Services Department Water Facilities General Engineering On-Call Service (Ordinance S-53230) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1578","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\n\nMotion was made by Vice Mayor Hodge Washington to approve this item. The motion was seconded by Councilwoman O'Brien.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65576,"agenda_number":"74","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Retroactive Approval to Apply for an Arizona State Historic Preservation Office Certified Local Government Pass-Through Grant for Federal Fiscal Year 2025 - Federal Funding (Ordinance S-53238) - District 6","matter_file":"26-1920","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\n\nMotion was made by Vice Mayor Hodge Washington to approve this item. The motion was seconded by Councilwoman O'Brien.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65574,"agenda_number":"75","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Approval of a Phil Gordon Threatened Building Grant - 330 N 18th Avenue - Oakland Historic District (Ordinance S-53240) - District 7","matter_file":"26-1923","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\n\nMotion was made by Vice Mayor Hodge Washington to approve this item. The motion was seconded by Councilwoman O'Brien.\n\nMayor Gallego described the item and explained that it is named after former Mayor Phil Gordon, who was an advocate for historic preservation.\n\nMayor Gallego noted there were community members present to speak on the item.\n\nNote: Mayor Gallego left the dais during public comment.\n\nKriston Lisson expressed her opposition to this item.\n\nJeremy Thacker expressed his opposition to this item.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Absent"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65575,"agenda_number":"76","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Approval of a Phil Gordon Threatened Building Grant - Leopoldo & Isabel Dominguez House, 927 North 8th Street (Ordinance S-53239) - District 8","matter_file":"26-1922","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\n\nMotion was made by Councilwoman O'Brien to approve this item. The motion was seconded by Councilwoman Stark.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington noted there were residents present to speak on the item.\n\nMichael Bushbacher expressed his support for this item.\n\nKriston Lisson conveyed her opposition for this item.\n\nJeremy Thacker voiced his support for this item.\n\nCouncilwoman 1:34:00","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":null},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Absent"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65564,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"REPORTS FROM CITY MANAGER, COMMITTEES OR CITY OFFICIALS","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65565,"agenda_number":"000","agenda_number_source":"title-rule","title":"000 CITIZEN COMMENTS","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":"NOTE: Councilwoman O'Brien temporarily left the voting body.\n\nCity Attorney Julie Kriegh stated during Citizen Comment, members of the public may address the City Council for up to three minutes on issues of interest or concern to them. She advised the Arizona Open Meeting Law permits the City Council to listen to the comment, but prohibits council members from discussing or acting on the matters presented.\n\nAlex Johnson expressed his concern that Ahwatukee residents felt under-represented in District 6 and suggested splitting the district to better reflect its geography and demographics. He expressed frustration that the district had not publicly addressed community opposition to the proposed data center. He urged the Council to acknowledge potential health impacts of industrial development near homes and to respond to residents’ emails and concerns.\n\nNOTE: Councilwoman O'Brien returned to the voting body during Mr. Johnson's comments.\n\nDavid Morgan expressed his appreciation for the changes made to the SOS shelter in response to his previous stated concerns, highlighting that many of them had been addressed. He expressed his concerns for how disciplinary action was conducted at the facility, stating there was no oversight or formal process.\n\nNOTE: Mayor Gallego temporarily left the voting body during Mr. Morgan's comments. Vice Mayor Hodge Washington assumed the Chair\n\nClarissa Peterson expressed her appreciation for the sanitation efforts being made on the SOS lot. She expressed concern for how disciplinary action was conducted at the facility and behaviors from staff members.\n\nNOTE: Mayor Gallego returned to the voting body during Ms. Peterson's comments and assumed the Chair.\n\nFrank Urban expressed his concern for a bill he believed passed by Council that an ordinance limited aid to the homeless population to two times a month per park site.\n\nKarla Kendall expressed her concern for limited access to their mail while being a resident of the SOS facility and emphasized her well-being was dependent on receiving important letters. She expressed frustration with outages of electricity at the facility and noted the negative effects as a result.\n\nFaith Kearns expressed her concern for the environment of homeless shelters and urged the Council to provide more support\n\nWilliam Lockwood expressed his concern for an experience he had at the SOS shelter.\n\nJeremy Thacker expressed his support for the fair and intentional renaming of public parks and emphasized the need for names to be inspirational. He highlighted the importance of farmworker history and Jesse Owen.\n\nNOTE: Councilwoman Hernandez temporarily left the voting body.\n\nElsia Greer expressed her appreciation for the efforts made to improve the SOS facility. she expressed concern over the availability of adequate charging space for their wheelchair.\n\nElizabeth Venable expressed her concern for the availability of Americans with Disabilities Act compliant amenities at the SOS facility and the training of contractors present at the facility, including training material, culture, and relationship building with residents of the facility.\n\nNOTE: Councilwoman Hernandez returned to the voting body during Ms. Venable's comments.\n\nLee Ellis II noted the positive improvements made to the SOS facility but emphasized the need for more programs for its residents.\n\nDorian Vrenden emphasized the importance of heat relief during the summer months. He noted concern for the increase of ticketing and arrests of the homeless population and the effects of building of data centers.\n\nWilliam Kirkland expressed his concern for outages during hot summers. He expressed strong appreciation for the positive improvements to the SOS facility and noted the issues SOS residents face for receiving mail.\n\nDavid Benefiel expressed belief that God was responsible for the positive improvements seen recently in the City of Phoenix and read a scripture.\n\nMayor Gallego reminded speakers to comment on matters under the jurisdiction of the Council.","votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65566,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"ADJOURN","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":"There being no further business to come before the Council, Mayor Gallego declared the meeting adjourned at 12:30 p.m.\n\n___________________________\nMAYOR\n\nATTEST:\n\n__________________________\nCITY CLERK\n\nCH\n\nCERTIFICATION\n\nI hereby certify that the foregoing minutes are a true and correct copy of the minutes of the formal session of the City Council of the City of Phoenix held on the 7th day of October, 2026. I further certify that the meeting was duly called and held and that a quorum was present.\n\nDated this 7th day of October, 2026.\n\n__________________________\nCITY CLERK","votes":[],"roll_call":[]}],"coverage":{"lines":1385,"speaking_seconds":6498.9,"seconds_by_role":{"member":2380.7,"staff":357.6,"official":137.0,"public":2728.2,"unclassified":895.4},"named_seconds":4510.6,"named_share":0.6941,"chapters_found":16,"agenda_items_acted_on":79},"build":{"builder_version":"0.1.0","built_at":"2026-10-20T19:15:45Z","problems":[],"inputs":{"recordings":[{"source_ref":"part 1 of 1","content_sha256":"f7cabe546cd28bc7464a2ee569b15166431d2485ca85af041e00f53efb1610ea"}],"agenda_file_sha256":"79262a57932102412f4a196817702ce4ec21e49ddb4806884de37e1328a89e22","config_pack_sha256":"5056771490d823a6d33bdb79169e991d17ffc31da27d800ac79d9d7b7a82bfeb"},"checks":{"chapter_announcements_skipped":1,"roll_call_suggestions":3,"name_suggestions_from_minutes":5,"captions":null,"lines_flagged_language":5,"video_offset_check":{"source":"the video's own captions","shift_s":879.97,"anchors":12367,"spread_s":0.11,"recorded_offset_s":880.0,"difference_s":-0.03,"agrees":true}},"freeze":{"approved_by":"jthacker 2026-10-20","frozen_at":"2026-10-20T19:24:10Z","previous_version":null}},"publication":{"exported_at":"2026-10-22T05:49:19Z","from_version":1,"from_sha256":"d4c88c867b89043c12ea7c1ac489a43bf09cedf56123ba9bb92ebd63a1e6210c","fixes_applied":3}}