{"format":"public-meeting-insights/meeting","format_version":"1.0","meeting_id":"phoenix-city-council/2026-06-17-formal-meeting","status":"published","version":1,"body":{"slug":"phoenix-city-council","name":"Phoenix City Council","city":"Phoenix","state":"AZ"},"meeting":{"date":"2026-06-17","type":"Formal Meeting","type_slug":"formal-meeting","scheduled_time":"2:30 PM","duration_s":10697.42},"notices":{"independence":"An independent project by GOOD|GOAT. Not affiliated with or endorsed by the City of Phoenix.","machine":"Machine transcript, corrected by the public. Not the official record: the City's minutes are.","official_record_url":"https://phoenix.legistar.com/Calendar.aspx"},"licence":{"data":"CC-BY-4.0","attribution":"GOOD|GOAT, Public Meeting Insights (https://goodgoat.net)"},"policy":{"names":"on-record","on_record_window_s":180.0},"agenda":{"system":"legistar","client":"phoenix","event_id":2595,"body_id":138,"body_name":"City Council Formal Meeting","minutes_status":"Tentative","agenda_status":"Final-revised","event_url":"https://phoenix.legistar.com/MeetingDetail.aspx?LEGID=2595&GID=485&G=3F9B5896-D56F-4AD3-85AD-A8E5E58DD74C"},"video":{"platform":"youtube","id":"1gRr-WKyRLs","url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1gRr-WKyRLs","embed_url":"https://www.youtube-nocookie.com/embed/1gRr-WKyRLs","offset_s":1860.0,"offset_source":"measured against the video's own captions (17797 matching passages, within 0.18 s)"},"recordings":[{"part":1,"of":1,"source":"speakr_db","source_ref":"part 1 of 1","duration_s":10706.152,"meeting_offset_s":0.0,"content_sha256":"02b2434966cb392f1f8c7e25b5326413b3230966f4f174adeaa7861cc65a6258"}],"speakers":[{"id":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138"},{"id":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17"},{"id":"v01","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"ed-zuercher","role":"staff","name":"Ed Zuercher","title":"City Manager","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes: City Manager Ed Zuercher from 2025-11-19 (after Jeff Barton, 2023 to about Nov 2025); still titled 2026-08-26. See gg_phx-cc-data config/officials.csv"},{"id":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January"},{"id":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138"},{"id":"v02","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"laura-pastor","role":"member","name":"Laura Pastor","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138"},{"id":"v03","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"mario-barajas","role":"official","name":"Mario Barajas","title":"Spanish interpreter","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07: 'Mayor Gallego acknowledged the presence of Mario Barajas and Elsie Duarte, Spanish interpreters.' Introduced at each meeting."},{"id":"julie-kriegh","role":"staff","name":"Julie Kriegh","title":"City Attorney","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2022-11-15 (first titled mention); still titled City Attorney 2026-09-09"},{"id":"v04","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"jim-waring","role":"member","name":"Jim Waring","title":"Councilman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138"},{"id":"v05","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"kevin-robinson","role":"member","name":"Kevin Robinson","title":"Councilman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138"},{"id":"debra-stark","role":"member","name":"Debra Stark","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138"},{"id":"v06","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v07","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v08","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v09","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v10","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v11","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v12","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v13","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v14","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"betty-guardado","role":"member","name":"Betty Guardado","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138"},{"id":"v15","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v16","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v17","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v18","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v19","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v20","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v21","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v22","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"lori-bays","role":"staff","name":"Lori Bays","title":"Assistant City Manager","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2021-12-01 item 45 (first titled mention); still titled 2026-04-08"},{"id":"v23","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v24","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v25","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v26","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v27","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v28","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v29","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v30","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v31","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v32","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v33","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v34","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v35","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v36","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v37","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v38","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v39","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v40","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v41","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v42","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v43","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138"}],"chapters":[{"id":"C001","kind":"opening","agenda_numbers":[],"event_item_ids":[],"title":"Opening","start_line":"L00001","start_s":2.005,"end_s":567.662,"confidence":"high","basis":"start of recording"},{"id":"C002","kind":"block","agenda_numbers":["3","4","5","6","7","8","9","10","11","12","13","14","15","16","17","18","19","20","21","22"],"event_item_ids":[64463,64450,64462,64458,64457,64460,64456,64455,64464,64459,64465,64453,64466,64467,64468,64452,64454,64461,64451,64449],"title":"Items 3–22 voted together","start_line":"L00275","start_s":567.662,"end_s":596.287,"confidence":"low","basis":"L00275: \"Motion to approve items 3 through 22.\""},{"id":"C003","kind":"block","agenda_numbers":["23","24","25","26","27","28","29","30","31","32","33","34","35","36","37","38","39","40","41","42","43","45","52","55","56","57","58","61","62","63","64","66","67","68","69","70","71","72","73","74","75","76","77","78","79","82","83","84","85","86","87","88","92","93","94","97","98","99","100","102","103","104","105","107","108","109","110","112","113","114","115","116","117","118","119","120","121","122","123","125","126","127","130","131","132","133","134","135","136","137","138","139","140","141","142","143","144","145","146","147","148","149","150","151"],"event_item_ids":[64473,64479,64481,64482,64610,64484,64485,64478,64616,64486,64487,64488,64489,64490,64491,64492,64477,64480,64475,64476,64483,64494,64520,64611,64503,64504,64505,64508,64509,64518,64510,64615,64511,64513,64514,64515,64516,64517,64519,64521,64522,64523,64524,64525,64526,64530,64531,64532,64533,64534,64535,64537,64618,64617,64541,64544,64546,64547,64548,64550,64551,64552,64553,64555,64556,64557,64558,64560,64562,64563,64564,64565,64566,64567,64568,64569,64570,64571,64572,64574,64575,64576,64580,64581,64582,64583,64584,64585,64586,64587,64588,64589,64592,64593,64594,64595,64596,64612,64613,64614,64597,64598,64599,64620],"title":"Items 23–154 voted together","start_line":"L00301","start_s":596.287,"end_s":683.502,"confidence":"low","basis":"L00301: \"Motion to approve items 23 through 154, except for the following.\""},{"id":"C004","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["44"],"event_item_ids":[64470],"title":"Public Hearing on Proposed Property Tax Levy, Truth in Taxation and Adoption of the Final 2026-27 Annual Budget - Citywide","start_line":"L00333","start_s":683.502,"end_s":743.402,"confidence":"high","basis":"L00333: \"We'll begin with item 44, which is a public hearing on the adoption of the proposed property tax levy, truth in taxation and adoption of the final 2026-2027 ann\""},{"id":"C005","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["46"],"event_item_ids":[64497],"title":"Adoption of the Final 2026-27 Operating Funds Budget (Ordinance S-52969) - Citywide","start_line":"L00348","start_s":743.402,"end_s":976.856,"confidence":"high","basis":"L00348: \"Item 46 is the adoption of the final 26-27 operating funds budget.\""},{"id":"C006","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["47"],"event_item_ids":[64499],"title":"Adoption of the Final 2026-27 Capital Funds Budget (Ordinance S-53015) - Citywide","start_line":"L00402","start_s":976.856,"end_s":1010.119,"confidence":"high","basis":"L00402: \"Item 47 is the adoption of the final 26-27 capital funds budget.\""},{"id":"C007","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["48"],"event_item_ids":[64498],"title":"Adoption of the Final 2026-27 Reappropriated Funds Budget (Ordinance S-52970) - Citywide","start_line":"L00426","start_s":1010.119,"end_s":1091.163,"confidence":"high","basis":"L00426: \"Item 48 is the adoption of the final 2026-27 reappropriated funds budget.\""},{"id":"C008","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["49"],"event_item_ids":[64495],"title":"Amend Ordinance S-52048 Adopting the 2025-26 Annual Budget for Operating Funds (Ordinance S-52967) - Citywide","start_line":"L00465","start_s":1091.163,"end_s":1132.188,"confidence":"high","basis":"L00465: \"Item 49 amends the 25-26 annual operating funds budget to authorize reallocating appropriations.\""},{"id":"C009","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["50"],"event_item_ids":[64500],"title":"Amend Ordinance S-52074 Adopting the 2025-26 Capital Funds Budget (Ordinance S-53016) - Citywide","start_line":"L00491","start_s":1132.188,"end_s":1168.102,"confidence":"high","basis":"L00491: \"Item 50 amends the 2526 annual capital funds budget to authorize reallocating appropriations.\""},{"id":"C010","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["51"],"event_item_ids":[64496],"title":"Amend Ordinance S-52049 Adopting the 2025-26 Final Reappropriation Budget (Ordinance S-52968) - Citywide","start_line":"L00516","start_s":1168.102,"end_s":1219.657,"confidence":"high","basis":"L00516: \"Item 51 amends the 25-26 annual reappropriation funds budget to authorize reallocating appropriations.\""},{"id":"C011","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["54"],"event_item_ids":[64502],"title":"Request to Amend City Code - Chapter 8 Animals - Section 8-3.08 (Ordinance G-7524) - Citywide","start_line":"L00543","start_s":1219.657,"end_s":2807.514,"confidence":"high","basis":"L00543: \"We next go to item 54.\""},{"id":"C012","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["59"],"event_item_ids":[64506],"title":"Authorization to Adopt Public Safety Personnel Retirement System Pension Funding Policy (Ordinance S-52997) - Citywide","start_line":"L00868","start_s":2807.514,"end_s":2845.395,"confidence":"high","basis":"L00868: \"We next go to item 59.\""},{"id":"C013","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["60"],"event_item_ids":[64507],"title":"Authorization to Adopt City of Phoenix Employee Retirement System Pension Funding Policy (Ordinance S-52999) - Citywide","start_line":"L00892","start_s":2845.395,"end_s":3027.134,"confidence":"high","basis":"L00892: \"Item 60 is the authorization to opt the City of Phoenix employee retirement pension system funding policy.\""},{"id":"C014","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["80"],"event_item_ids":[64527],"title":"Request Seeking Council Authorization to Exceed the 8-Hour Rule to Research and Develop Options for Minimum Wage - Citywide","start_line":"L00943","start_s":3027.134,"end_s":3916.111,"confidence":"high","basis":"L00943: \"We next go to item 80, which is a request to seek council authorization to extend, to exceed the eight-hour rule to research and develop options for minimum wag\""},{"id":"C015","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["81"],"event_item_ids":[64528],"title":"Request Seeking Council Authorization to Exceed the 8-Hour Rule to Research and Develop a Potential Worker Retention Policy - Citywide","start_line":"L01091","start_s":3916.111,"end_s":5110.974,"confidence":"high","basis":"L01091: \"Item 81 is a related item on eight hour rule research on a potential worker retention policy.\""},{"id":"C016","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["89"],"event_item_ids":[64538],"title":"Funding for The Moreland Phase II Affordable Housing Development (Ordinance S-53026) - District 8","start_line":"L01278","start_s":5110.974,"end_s":5187.541,"confidence":"medium","basis":"L01278: \"We'll go next to item 89, funding for Moreland Phase II affordable housing development.\""},{"id":"C017","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["90"],"event_item_ids":[64539],"title":"Additional Funding for Choice Neighborhoods Housing Developments (Ordinance S-53034) - District 8","start_line":"L01290","start_s":5187.541,"end_s":5221.397,"confidence":"medium","basis":"L01290: \"With respect to item 90, this supports the Edison Eastlake Choice Neighborhood Initiative, one of the most transformative housing and neighborhood revitalizatio\""},{"id":"C018","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["91"],"event_item_ids":[64540],"title":"Approval to Submit Housing and Urban Development, Section 18 Disposition Application (Ordinance S-53036) - Citywide","start_line":"L01294","start_s":5221.397,"end_s":5273.217,"confidence":"medium","basis":"L01294: \"And lastly item 91 it allows the housing department to seek federal approval to convert 57 sites of single-family housing into affordable for sale single-family\""},{"id":"C019","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["95"],"event_item_ids":[64542],"title":"Authorization to Enter Into Contract with The Arizona Community Action Association dba Wildfire (Ordinance S-53023) - Citywide","start_line":"L01318","start_s":5273.217,"end_s":5359.301,"confidence":"high","basis":"L01318: \"Item 95 is a contract with the Arizona Community Action Association, better known as Wildfire.\""},{"id":"C020","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["101"],"event_item_ids":[64549],"title":"Annual Review and Updates to the Neighborhood Services Department's Code Enforcement Policy - Citywide","start_line":"L01333","start_s":5359.301,"end_s":5597.432,"confidence":"high","basis":"L01333: \"Item 101 is the Annual Review and Updates to the Neighborhood Services Code Enforcement Policy.\""},{"id":"C021","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["106"],"event_item_ids":[64619],"title":"Authorization to Accept 10 Acres of Vacant Land From CACH Holdings, LLC, and to Designate as Mountain Preserve (Ordinance S-53064) - District 6","start_line":"L01381","start_s":5597.432,"end_s":5706.935,"confidence":"high","basis":"L01381: \"Next is item 106, which is an authorization to accept vacant land from cash holdings and to designate it as mountain preserve.\""},{"id":"C022","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["111"],"event_item_ids":[64559],"title":"An Ordinance Amending Phoenix City Code Chapter 10A Regarding Mutual Indemnification Provisions for Certain Facility Use Agreements - Phoenix Convention Center (Ordinance G-7523) - Citywide","start_line":"L01400","start_s":5706.935,"end_s":5746.522,"confidence":"high","basis":"L01400: \"Item 111, I will ask the city clerk to read the title.\""},{"id":"C023","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["124"],"event_item_ids":[64573],"title":"NVLS (LEARN) Database Subscription Services - RFA 18-011 - Amendment (Ordinance S-52981) - Citywide","start_line":"L01423","start_s":5746.522,"end_s":6541.69,"confidence":"high","basis":"L01423: \"Item 124 is next.\""},{"id":"C024","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["128"],"event_item_ids":[64577],"title":"Youth Engagement Training Service - RFA-26-0226 Request for Award (Ordinance S-53012) - Citywide","start_line":"L01567","start_s":6541.69,"end_s":7265.01,"confidence":"high","basis":"L01567: \"Item 128 is the Youth Engagement Training Service.\""},{"id":"C025","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["129"],"event_item_ids":[64578],"title":"Approval to Enter into Agreements with Various Schools and School Districts for School Resource Officer Services (Ordinance S-53058) - Citywide","start_line":"L01675","start_s":7265.01,"end_s":7336.854,"confidence":"high","basis":"L01675: \"We next go to item 129, the approval to enter into agreements with various schools and school districts for school resource officer services, Vice Mayor.\""},{"id":"C026","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["152"],"event_item_ids":[64471],"title":"Public Hearing - Abandonment Appeal of Hearing Officer Decision - ABND 250049 - 5440 E. Calle Camelia - District 6","start_line":"L01716","start_s":7336.854,"end_s":9149.571,"confidence":"high","basis":"L01716: \"Item 152 is the appeal of the hearing officer decision\""},{"id":"C027","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["153"],"event_item_ids":[64590],"title":"Consideration of a Citizen Petition Submitted by Mr. Gregg Turner - District 3","start_line":"L02069","start_s":9149.571,"end_s":9354.54,"confidence":"high","basis":"L02069: \"All right, we next move to item 153, which is consideration of a citizen petition, and we will welcome up Greg Turner, who provided the petition.\""},{"id":"C028","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["000"],"event_item_ids":[64605],"title":"000 CITIZEN COMMENTS","start_line":"L02125","start_s":9354.54,"end_s":null,"confidence":"high","basis":"L02125: city cue: \"We'll now go to the final portion of our meeting, citizen public comment, and I'll turn to our city attorney to introduce this portion.\""}],"turns":[{"id":"T00001","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00001","last_line":"L00006","start_s":2.005,"end_s":13.478},{"id":"T00002","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00007","last_line":"L00011","start_s":14.279,"end_s":19.064},{"id":"T00003","speaker":"v01","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00012","last_line":"L00012","start_s":20.766,"end_s":20.986},{"id":"T00004","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00013","last_line":"L00017","start_s":22.127,"end_s":27.193},{"id":"T00005","speaker":"ed-zuercher","role":"staff","name":"Ed Zuercher","title":"City Manager","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes: City Manager Ed Zuercher from 2025-11-19 (after Jeff Barton, 2023 to about Nov 2025); still titled 2026-08-26. See gg_phx-cc-data config/officials.csv","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00018","last_line":"L00018","start_s":27.493,"end_s":27.713},{"id":"T00006","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00019","last_line":"L00024","start_s":28.214,"end_s":34.58},{"id":"T00007","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00025","last_line":"L00027","start_s":35.061,"end_s":45.052},{"id":"T00008","speaker":"v01","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00028","last_line":"L00029","start_s":46.553,"end_s":49.937},{"id":"T00009","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00030","last_line":"L00033","start_s":50.898,"end_s":60.729},{"id":"T00010","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00034","last_line":"L00043","start_s":60.749,"end_s":71.807},{"id":"T00011","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00044","last_line":"L00044","start_s":72.047,"end_s":72.327},{"id":"T00012","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00045","last_line":"L00049","start_s":72.808,"end_s":75.751},{"id":"T00013","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00050","last_line":"L00050","start_s":75.811,"end_s":76.111},{"id":"T00014","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00051","last_line":"L00051","start_s":76.452,"end_s":76.852},{"id":"T00015","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00052","last_line":"L00052","start_s":77.012,"end_s":77.272},{"id":"T00016","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00053","last_line":"L00053","start_s":77.573,"end_s":78.554},{"id":"T00017","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00054","last_line":"L00055","start_s":79.395,"end_s":84.58},{"id":"T00018","speaker":"v01","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00056","last_line":"L00057","start_s":85.841,"end_s":90.366},{"id":"T00019","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00058","last_line":"L00058","start_s":90.937,"end_s":91.397},{"id":"T00020","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00059","last_line":"L00074","start_s":92.639,"end_s":103.929},{"id":"T00021","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00075","last_line":"L00080","start_s":104.109,"end_s":115.62},{"id":"T00022","speaker":"v01","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00081","last_line":"L00082","start_s":116.881,"end_s":120.825},{"id":"T00023","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00083","last_line":"L00084","start_s":121.919,"end_s":123.461},{"id":"T00024","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00085","last_line":"L00095","start_s":124.182,"end_s":131.79},{"id":"T00025","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00096","last_line":"L00096","start_s":131.991,"end_s":132.611},{"id":"T00026","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00097","last_line":"L00105","start_s":132.631,"end_s":139.019},{"id":"T00027","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00106","last_line":"L00107","start_s":140.22,"end_s":148.99},{"id":"T00028","speaker":"v01","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00108","last_line":"L00110","start_s":149.527,"end_s":155.503},{"id":"T00029","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00111","last_line":"L00113","start_s":156.277,"end_s":158.299},{"id":"T00030","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00114","last_line":"L00114","start_s":158.319,"end_s":159.0},{"id":"T00031","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00115","last_line":"L00121","start_s":159.02,"end_s":164.206},{"id":"T00032","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00122","last_line":"L00122","start_s":164.447,"end_s":164.687},{"id":"T00033","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00123","last_line":"L00125","start_s":165.147,"end_s":166.809},{"id":"T00034","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00126","last_line":"L00126","start_s":167.55,"end_s":167.63},{"id":"T00035","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00127","last_line":"L00127","start_s":167.65,"end_s":168.291},{"id":"T00036","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00128","last_line":"L00133","start_s":168.411,"end_s":181.947},{"id":"T00037","speaker":"v01","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00134","last_line":"L00137","start_s":182.467,"end_s":190.356},{"id":"T00038","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00138","last_line":"L00148","start_s":190.376,"end_s":198.365},{"id":"T00039","speaker":"v02","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00149","last_line":"L00149","start_s":198.425,"end_s":198.685},{"id":"T00040","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00150","last_line":"L00158","start_s":199.346,"end_s":205.993},{"id":"T00041","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00159","last_line":"L00160","start_s":207.188,"end_s":213.517},{"id":"T00042","speaker":"laura-pastor","role":"member","name":"Laura Pastor","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00161","last_line":"L00162","start_s":213.557,"end_s":215.74},{"id":"T00043","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00163","last_line":"L00164","start_s":215.78,"end_s":219.726},{"id":"T00044","speaker":"v01","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00165","last_line":"L00166","start_s":227.156,"end_s":231.242},{"id":"T00045","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00167","last_line":"L00168","start_s":231.883,"end_s":233.385},{"id":"T00046","speaker":"v01","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00169","last_line":"L00171","start_s":233.405,"end_s":235.367},{"id":"T00047","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00172","last_line":"L00179","start_s":235.387,"end_s":243.6},{"id":"T00048","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00180","last_line":"L00180","start_s":243.76,"end_s":244.04},{"id":"T00049","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00181","last_line":"L00188","start_s":244.361,"end_s":248.827},{"id":"T00050","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00189","last_line":"L00191","start_s":250.168,"end_s":258.679},{"id":"T00051","speaker":"v03","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00192","last_line":"L00202","start_s":263.666,"end_s":325.28},{"id":"T00052","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00203","last_line":"L00207","start_s":325.3,"end_s":355.678},{"id":"T00053","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00208","last_line":"L00208","start_s":356.839,"end_s":357.84},{"id":"T00054","speaker":"betty-guardado","role":"member","name":"Betty Guardado","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00209","last_line":"L00209","start_s":357.981,"end_s":358.241},{"id":"T00055","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00210","last_line":"L00210","start_s":358.742,"end_s":359.723},{"id":"T00056","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00211","last_line":"L00211","start_s":359.823,"end_s":360.063},{"id":"T00057","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00212","last_line":"L00212","start_s":360.664,"end_s":361.585},{"id":"T00058","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00213","last_line":"L00213","start_s":361.705,"end_s":361.886},{"id":"T00059","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00214","last_line":"L00214","start_s":362.346,"end_s":363.327},{"id":"T00060","speaker":"laura-pastor","role":"member","name":"Laura Pastor","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00215","last_line":"L00215","start_s":364.128,"end_s":364.329},{"id":"T00061","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00216","last_line":"L00216","start_s":364.889,"end_s":365.891},{"id":"T00062","speaker":"kevin-robinson","role":"member","name":"Kevin Robinson","title":"Councilman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00217","last_line":"L00217","start_s":365.911,"end_s":366.091},{"id":"T00063","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00218","last_line":"L00218","start_s":366.531,"end_s":367.373},{"id":"T00064","speaker":"debra-stark","role":"member","name":"Debra Stark","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00219","last_line":"L00219","start_s":367.533,"end_s":367.733},{"id":"T00065","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00220","last_line":"L00220","start_s":368.174,"end_s":368.874},{"id":"T00066","speaker":"jim-waring","role":"member","name":"Jim Waring","title":"Councilman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00221","last_line":"L00221","start_s":369.756,"end_s":369.856},{"id":"T00067","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00222","last_line":"L00222","start_s":369.876,"end_s":370.837},{"id":"T00068","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00223","last_line":"L00223","start_s":370.977,"end_s":371.157},{"id":"T00069","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00224","last_line":"L00224","start_s":371.598,"end_s":372.499},{"id":"T00070","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00225","last_line":"L00227","start_s":372.817,"end_s":378.611},{"id":"T00071","speaker":"mario-barajas","role":"official","name":"Mario Barajas","title":"Spanish interpreter","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07: 'Mayor Gallego acknowledged the presence of Mario Barajas and Elsie Duarte, Spanish interpreters.' Introduced at each meeting.","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00228","last_line":"L00237","start_s":379.092,"end_s":431.3},{"id":"T00072","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00238","last_line":"L00238","start_s":431.32,"end_s":433.283},{"id":"T00073","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00239","last_line":"L00240","start_s":434.258,"end_s":449.439},{"id":"T00074","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00241","last_line":"L00241","start_s":451.962,"end_s":454.225},{"id":"T00075","speaker":"julie-kriegh","role":"staff","name":"Julie Kriegh","title":"City Attorney","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2022-11-15 (first titled mention); still titled City Attorney 2026-09-09","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00242","last_line":"L00252","start_s":454.576,"end_s":506.892},{"id":"T00076","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00253","last_line":"L00255","start_s":508.947,"end_s":515.844},{"id":"T00077","speaker":"laura-pastor","role":"member","name":"Laura Pastor","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00256","last_line":"L00257","start_s":517.508,"end_s":523.703},{"id":"T00078","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00258","last_line":"L00258","start_s":524.304,"end_s":524.745},{"id":"T00079","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00259","last_line":"L00259","start_s":525.873,"end_s":527.075},{"id":"T00080","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00260","last_line":"L00260","start_s":527.415,"end_s":527.756},{"id":"T00081","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00261","last_line":"L00264","start_s":527.796,"end_s":535.368},{"id":"T00082","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00265","last_line":"L00266","start_s":535.648,"end_s":543.02},{"id":"T00083","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00267","last_line":"L00274","start_s":543.741,"end_s":567.221},{"id":"T00084","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C002","first_line":"L00275","last_line":"L00276","start_s":567.662,"end_s":570.668},{"id":"T00085","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C002","first_line":"L00277","last_line":"L00279","start_s":571.811,"end_s":574.797},{"id":"T00086","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C002","first_line":"L00280","last_line":"L00288","start_s":576.481,"end_s":582.309},{"id":"T00087","speaker":"v04","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C002","first_line":"L00289","last_line":"L00289","start_s":582.609,"end_s":583.25},{"id":"T00088","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C002","first_line":"L00290","last_line":"L00297","start_s":583.27,"end_s":589.678},{"id":"T00089","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C002","first_line":"L00298","last_line":"L00298","start_s":590.459,"end_s":593.643},{"id":"T00090","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C002","first_line":"L00299","last_line":"L00299","start_s":594.004,"end_s":594.444},{"id":"T00091","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C002","first_line":"L00300","last_line":"L00300","start_s":595.105,"end_s":596.066},{"id":"T00092","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C003","first_line":"L00301","last_line":"L00304","start_s":596.287,"end_s":630.518},{"id":"T00093","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C003","first_line":"L00305","last_line":"L00326","start_s":631.105,"end_s":665.295},{"id":"T00094","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C003","first_line":"L00327","last_line":"L00332","start_s":665.756,"end_s":682.881},{"id":"T00095","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C004","first_line":"L00333","last_line":"L00340","start_s":683.502,"end_s":721.574},{"id":"T00096","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C004","first_line":"L00341","last_line":"L00342","start_s":723.437,"end_s":733.371},{"id":"T00097","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C004","first_line":"L00343","last_line":"L00347","start_s":734.988,"end_s":741.739},{"id":"T00098","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00348","last_line":"L00349","start_s":743.402,"end_s":748.57},{"id":"T00099","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00350","last_line":"L00351","start_s":748.991,"end_s":759.308},{"id":"T00100","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00352","last_line":"L00354","start_s":760.3,"end_s":767.745},{"id":"T00101","speaker":"jim-waring","role":"member","name":"Jim Waring","title":"Councilman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00355","last_line":"L00361","start_s":770.054,"end_s":807.334},{"id":"T00102","speaker":"ed-zuercher","role":"staff","name":"Ed Zuercher","title":"City Manager","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes: City Manager Ed Zuercher from 2025-11-19 (after Jeff Barton, 2023 to about Nov 2025); still titled 2026-08-26. See gg_phx-cc-data config/officials.csv","public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00362","last_line":"L00365","start_s":807.787,"end_s":823.635},{"id":"T00103","speaker":"jim-waring","role":"member","name":"Jim Waring","title":"Councilman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00366","last_line":"L00372","start_s":823.615,"end_s":882.287},{"id":"T00104","speaker":"ed-zuercher","role":"staff","name":"Ed Zuercher","title":"City Manager","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes: City Manager Ed Zuercher from 2025-11-19 (after Jeff Barton, 2023 to about Nov 2025); still titled 2026-08-26. See gg_phx-cc-data config/officials.csv","public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00373","last_line":"L00375","start_s":883.087,"end_s":905.631},{"id":"T00105","speaker":"jim-waring","role":"member","name":"Jim Waring","title":"Councilman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00376","last_line":"L00379","start_s":905.611,"end_s":926.438},{"id":"T00106","speaker":"ed-zuercher","role":"staff","name":"Ed Zuercher","title":"City Manager","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes: City Manager Ed Zuercher from 2025-11-19 (after Jeff Barton, 2023 to about Nov 2025); still titled 2026-08-26. See gg_phx-cc-data config/officials.csv","public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00380","last_line":"L00380","start_s":927.16,"end_s":956.83},{"id":"T00107","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00381","last_line":"L00381","start_s":959.898,"end_s":960.579},{"id":"T00108","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00382","last_line":"L00401","start_s":961.42,"end_s":976.035},{"id":"T00109","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C006","first_line":"L00402","last_line":"L00403","start_s":976.856,"end_s":981.401},{"id":"T00110","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C006","first_line":"L00404","last_line":"L00405","start_s":981.921,"end_s":992.871},{"id":"T00111","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C006","first_line":"L00406","last_line":"L00417","start_s":993.151,"end_s":1003.236},{"id":"T00112","speaker":"v05","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C006","first_line":"L00418","last_line":"L00418","start_s":1003.557,"end_s":1003.838},{"id":"T00113","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C006","first_line":"L00419","last_line":"L00423","start_s":1004.319,"end_s":1008.676},{"id":"T00114","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C006","first_line":"L00424","last_line":"L00424","start_s":1008.877,"end_s":1009.498},{"id":"T00115","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C006","first_line":"L00425","last_line":"L00425","start_s":1009.518,"end_s":1009.999},{"id":"T00116","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00426","last_line":"L00427","start_s":1010.119,"end_s":1015.869},{"id":"T00117","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00428","last_line":"L00430","start_s":1016.209,"end_s":1027.148},{"id":"T00118","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00431","last_line":"L00432","start_s":1028.191,"end_s":1030.253},{"id":"T00119","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00433","last_line":"L00447","start_s":1030.274,"end_s":1041.247},{"id":"T00120","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00448","last_line":"L00448","start_s":1041.988,"end_s":1042.208},{"id":"T00121","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00449","last_line":"L00451","start_s":1042.668,"end_s":1044.931},{"id":"T00122","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00452","last_line":"L00454","start_s":1046.093,"end_s":1050.638},{"id":"T00123","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00455","last_line":"L00457","start_s":1051.732,"end_s":1055.576},{"id":"T00124","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00458","last_line":"L00458","start_s":1056.257,"end_s":1056.377},{"id":"T00125","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00459","last_line":"L00464","start_s":1056.898,"end_s":1090.562},{"id":"T00126","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C008","first_line":"L00465","last_line":"L00466","start_s":1091.163,"end_s":1099.335},{"id":"T00127","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C008","first_line":"L00467","last_line":"L00469","start_s":1099.816,"end_s":1111.16},{"id":"T00128","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C008","first_line":"L00470","last_line":"L00470","start_s":1112.343,"end_s":1112.724},{"id":"T00129","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C008","first_line":"L00471","last_line":"L00471","start_s":1113.365,"end_s":1114.328},{"id":"T00130","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C008","first_line":"L00472","last_line":"L00486","start_s":1115.15,"end_s":1127.683},{"id":"T00131","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C008","first_line":"L00487","last_line":"L00487","start_s":1128.404,"end_s":1129.224},{"id":"T00132","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C008","first_line":"L00488","last_line":"L00488","start_s":1129.245,"end_s":1129.725},{"id":"T00133","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C008","first_line":"L00489","last_line":"L00489","start_s":1130.045,"end_s":1130.266},{"id":"T00134","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C008","first_line":"L00490","last_line":"L00490","start_s":1130.626,"end_s":1131.187},{"id":"T00135","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C009","first_line":"L00491","last_line":"L00492","start_s":1132.188,"end_s":1138.595},{"id":"T00136","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C009","first_line":"L00493","last_line":"L00496","start_s":1139.076,"end_s":1151.484},{"id":"T00137","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C009","first_line":"L00497","last_line":"L00505","start_s":1152.766,"end_s":1158.817},{"id":"T00138","speaker":"v04","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C009","first_line":"L00506","last_line":"L00506","start_s":1159.038,"end_s":1159.258},{"id":"T00139","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C009","first_line":"L00507","last_line":"L00513","start_s":1159.759,"end_s":1164.688},{"id":"T00140","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C009","first_line":"L00514","last_line":"L00514","start_s":1164.969,"end_s":1165.209},{"id":"T00141","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C009","first_line":"L00515","last_line":"L00515","start_s":1165.77,"end_s":1166.772},{"id":"T00142","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00516","last_line":"L00517","start_s":1168.102,"end_s":1175.069},{"id":"T00143","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00518","last_line":"L00520","start_s":1175.83,"end_s":1190.045},{"id":"T00144","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00521","last_line":"L00529","start_s":1191.407,"end_s":1198.211},{"id":"T00145","speaker":"kevin-robinson","role":"member","name":"Kevin Robinson","title":"Councilman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00530","last_line":"L00530","start_s":1198.431,"end_s":1198.671},{"id":"T00146","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00531","last_line":"L00537","start_s":1199.172,"end_s":1203.958},{"id":"T00147","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00538","last_line":"L00538","start_s":1204.458,"end_s":1204.679},{"id":"T00148","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00539","last_line":"L00539","start_s":1205.099,"end_s":1206.08},{"id":"T00149","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00540","last_line":"L00542","start_s":1206.861,"end_s":1218.296},{"id":"T00150","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00543","last_line":"L00544","start_s":1219.657,"end_s":1223.522},{"id":"T00151","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00545","last_line":"L00545","start_s":1224.464,"end_s":1234.98},{"id":"T00152","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00546","last_line":"L00547","start_s":1236.817,"end_s":1238.54},{"id":"T00153","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00548","last_line":"L00549","start_s":1239.061,"end_s":1241.805},{"id":"T00154","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00550","last_line":"L00554","start_s":1242.226,"end_s":1261.238},{"id":"T00155","speaker":"debra-stark","role":"member","name":"Debra Stark","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00555","last_line":"L00555","start_s":1267.816,"end_s":1268.958},{"id":"T00156","speaker":"v06","role":"unclassified","name":"Coco Garcia","title":null,"name_basis":"said aloud at L00553","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00556","last_line":"L00577","start_s":1270.52,"end_s":1391.209},{"id":"T00157","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00578","last_line":"L00578","start_s":1391.999,"end_s":1394.262},{"id":"T00158","speaker":"v07","role":"unclassified","name":"Don Bentley","title":null,"name_basis":"minutes note for item 54","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00579","last_line":"L00589","start_s":1401.01,"end_s":1478.543},{"id":"T00159","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00590","last_line":"L00592","start_s":1481.807,"end_s":1485.692},{"id":"T00160","speaker":"v08","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00593","last_line":"L00611","start_s":1494.7,"end_s":1610.05},{"id":"T00161","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00612","last_line":"L00612","start_s":1613.699,"end_s":1616.625},{"id":"T00162","speaker":"v09","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00613","last_line":"L00634","start_s":1623.085,"end_s":1714.139},{"id":"T00163","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00635","last_line":"L00636","start_s":1715.822,"end_s":1719.73},{"id":"T00164","speaker":"mario-barajas","role":"official","name":"Mario Barajas","title":"Spanish interpreter","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07: 'Mayor Gallego acknowledged the presence of Mario Barajas and Elsie Duarte, Spanish interpreters.' Introduced at each meeting.","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00637","last_line":"L00637","start_s":1724.719,"end_s":1726.121},{"id":"T00165","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00638","last_line":"L00638","start_s":1726.462,"end_s":1729.688},{"id":"T00166","speaker":"mario-barajas","role":"official","name":"Mario Barajas","title":"Spanish interpreter","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07: 'Mayor Gallego acknowledged the presence of Mario Barajas and Elsie Duarte, Spanish interpreters.' Introduced at each meeting.","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00639","last_line":"L00661","start_s":1732.503,"end_s":1828.734},{"id":"T00167","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00662","last_line":"L00663","start_s":1830.298,"end_s":1832.203},{"id":"T00168","speaker":"v10","role":"unclassified","name":"Poverty's Pets","title":null,"name_basis":"said aloud at L00665","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00664","last_line":"L00681","start_s":1835.069,"end_s":1934.206},{"id":"T00169","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00682","last_line":"L00683","start_s":1935.988,"end_s":1938.33},{"id":"T00170","speaker":"v11","role":"unclassified","name":"Bill Ross","title":null,"name_basis":"minutes note for item 54","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00684","last_line":"L00698","start_s":1943.693,"end_s":2056.599},{"id":"T00171","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00699","last_line":"L00700","start_s":2057.661,"end_s":2061.147},{"id":"T00172","speaker":"v12","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00701","last_line":"L00722","start_s":2069.952,"end_s":2195.151},{"id":"T00173","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00723","last_line":"L00728","start_s":2197.493,"end_s":2212.178},{"id":"T00174","speaker":"v13","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00729","last_line":"L00742","start_s":2213.44,"end_s":2296.313},{"id":"T00175","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00743","last_line":"L00745","start_s":2297.134,"end_s":2303.961},{"id":"T00176","speaker":"laura-pastor","role":"member","name":"Laura Pastor","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00746","last_line":"L00763","start_s":2305.763,"end_s":2412.526},{"id":"T00177","speaker":"v14","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00764","last_line":"L00764","start_s":2413.489,"end_s":2414.492},{"id":"T00178","speaker":"laura-pastor","role":"member","name":"Laura Pastor","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00765","last_line":"L00778","start_s":2414.692,"end_s":2501.28},{"id":"T00179","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00779","last_line":"L00788","start_s":2503.252,"end_s":2547.717},{"id":"T00180","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00789","last_line":"L00789","start_s":2549.359,"end_s":2550.42},{"id":"T00181","speaker":"betty-guardado","role":"member","name":"Betty Guardado","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00790","last_line":"L00807","start_s":2551.835,"end_s":2621.796},{"id":"T00182","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00808","last_line":"L00809","start_s":2622.517,"end_s":2624.839},{"id":"T00183","speaker":"jim-waring","role":"member","name":"Jim Waring","title":"Councilman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00810","last_line":"L00830","start_s":2625.747,"end_s":2695.526},{"id":"T00184","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00831","last_line":"L00831","start_s":2695.546,"end_s":2698.009},{"id":"T00185","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00832","last_line":"L00840","start_s":2698.478,"end_s":2747.569},{"id":"T00186","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00841","last_line":"L00846","start_s":2749.832,"end_s":2777.743},{"id":"T00187","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00847","last_line":"L00855","start_s":2778.584,"end_s":2785.196},{"id":"T00188","speaker":"v15","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00856","last_line":"L00856","start_s":2785.316,"end_s":2785.557},{"id":"T00189","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00857","last_line":"L00866","start_s":2786.098,"end_s":2795.395},{"id":"T00190","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00867","last_line":"L00867","start_s":2805.972,"end_s":2806.813},{"id":"T00191","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C012","first_line":"L00868","last_line":"L00868","start_s":2807.514,"end_s":2809.417},{"id":"T00192","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C012","first_line":"L00869","last_line":"L00872","start_s":2809.437,"end_s":2824.72},{"id":"T00193","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C012","first_line":"L00873","last_line":"L00873","start_s":2825.22,"end_s":2829.426},{"id":"T00194","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C012","first_line":"L00874","last_line":"L00889","start_s":2830.047,"end_s":2842.611},{"id":"T00195","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C012","first_line":"L00890","last_line":"L00891","start_s":2842.952,"end_s":2844.494},{"id":"T00196","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C013","first_line":"L00892","last_line":"L00893","start_s":2845.395,"end_s":2852.145},{"id":"T00197","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C013","first_line":"L00894","last_line":"L00895","start_s":2852.125,"end_s":2861.536},{"id":"T00198","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C013","first_line":"L00896","last_line":"L00897","start_s":2862.116,"end_s":2866.341},{"id":"T00199","speaker":"jim-waring","role":"member","name":"Jim Waring","title":"Councilman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C013","first_line":"L00898","last_line":"L00908","start_s":2866.641,"end_s":2957.031},{"id":"T00200","speaker":"ed-zuercher","role":"staff","name":"Ed Zuercher","title":"City Manager","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes: City Manager Ed Zuercher from 2025-11-19 (after Jeff Barton, 2023 to about Nov 2025); still titled 2026-08-26. See gg_phx-cc-data config/officials.csv","public_id":null,"chapter":"C013","first_line":"L00909","last_line":"L00918","start_s":2958.533,"end_s":3000.653},{"id":"T00201","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C013","first_line":"L00919","last_line":"L00921","start_s":3000.673,"end_s":3008.205},{"id":"T00202","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C013","first_line":"L00922","last_line":"L00930","start_s":3008.725,"end_s":3015.055},{"id":"T00203","speaker":"kevin-robinson","role":"member","name":"Kevin Robinson","title":"Councilman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C013","first_line":"L00931","last_line":"L00931","start_s":3015.355,"end_s":3015.596},{"id":"T00204","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C013","first_line":"L00932","last_line":"L00940","start_s":3016.157,"end_s":3024.27},{"id":"T00205","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C013","first_line":"L00941","last_line":"L00942","start_s":3024.57,"end_s":3026.213},{"id":"T00206","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L00943","last_line":"L00948","start_s":3027.134,"end_s":3045.966},{"id":"T00207","speaker":"betty-guardado","role":"member","name":"Betty Guardado","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L00949","last_line":"L00950","start_s":3046.307,"end_s":3048.192},{"id":"T00208","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L00951","last_line":"L00952","start_s":3049.114,"end_s":3052.823},{"id":"T00209","speaker":"v16","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L00953","last_line":"L00977","start_s":3067.349,"end_s":3178.305},{"id":"T00210","speaker":"v17","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L00978","last_line":"L00996","start_s":3192.511,"end_s":3316.107},{"id":"T00211","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L00997","last_line":"L01009","start_s":3321.52,"end_s":3414.42},{"id":"T00212","speaker":"betty-guardado","role":"member","name":"Betty Guardado","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L01010","last_line":"L01038","start_s":3415.784,"end_s":3668.725},{"id":"T00213","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L01039","last_line":"L01048","start_s":3668.745,"end_s":3748.459},{"id":"T00214","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L01049","last_line":"L01049","start_s":3750.364,"end_s":3752.95},{"id":"T00215","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L01050","last_line":"L01058","start_s":3753.453,"end_s":3815.591},{"id":"T00216","speaker":"laura-pastor","role":"member","name":"Laura Pastor","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L01059","last_line":"L01071","start_s":3817.033,"end_s":3891.737},{"id":"T00217","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C014","first_line":"L01072","last_line":"L01090","start_s":3893.479,"end_s":3906.58},{"id":"T00218","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C015","first_line":"L01091","last_line":"L01098","start_s":3916.111,"end_s":3949.324},{"id":"T00219","speaker":"v18","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C015","first_line":"L01099","last_line":"L01115","start_s":3969.487,"end_s":4103.546},{"id":"T00220","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C015","first_line":"L01116","last_line":"L01117","start_s":4103.827,"end_s":4114.667},{"id":"T00221","speaker":"v14","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C015","first_line":"L01118","last_line":"L01124","start_s":4121.7,"end_s":4182.908},{"id":"T00222","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C015","first_line":"L01125","last_line":"L01125","start_s":4189.402,"end_s":4191.144},{"id":"T00223","speaker":"v19","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C015","first_line":"L01126","last_line":"L01151","start_s":4209.788,"end_s":4308.762},{"id":"T00224","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C015","first_line":"L01152","last_line":"L01152","start_s":4317.28,"end_s":4319.422},{"id":"T00225","speaker":"v02","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C015","first_line":"L01153","last_line":"L01171","start_s":4327.83,"end_s":4452.283},{"id":"T00226","speaker":"mario-barajas","role":"official","name":"Mario Barajas","title":"Spanish interpreter","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07: 'Mayor Gallego acknowledged the presence of Mario Barajas and Elsie Duarte, Spanish interpreters.' Introduced at each meeting.","public_id":null,"chapter":"C015","first_line":"L01172","last_line":"L01188","start_s":4458.997,"end_s":4577.783},{"id":"T00227","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C015","first_line":"L01189","last_line":"L01190","start_s":4588.951,"end_s":4591.587},{"id":"T00228","speaker":"v20","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C015","first_line":"L01191","last_line":"L01205","start_s":4629.485,"end_s":4775.473},{"id":"T00229","speaker":"v21","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C015","first_line":"L01206","last_line":"L01226","start_s":4777.259,"end_s":4938.75},{"id":"T00230","speaker":"betty-guardado","role":"member","name":"Betty Guardado","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C015","first_line":"L01227","last_line":"L01227","start_s":4944.488,"end_s":4944.87},{"id":"T00231","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C015","first_line":"L01228","last_line":"L01228","start_s":4945.411,"end_s":4946.535},{"id":"T00232","speaker":"betty-guardado","role":"member","name":"Betty Guardado","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C015","first_line":"L01229","last_line":"L01245","start_s":4947.798,"end_s":5028.548},{"id":"T00233","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C015","first_line":"L01246","last_line":"L01255","start_s":5028.788,"end_s":5085.126},{"id":"T00234","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C015","first_line":"L01256","last_line":"L01256","start_s":5085.667,"end_s":5086.087},{"id":"T00235","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C015","first_line":"L01257","last_line":"L01257","start_s":5086.288,"end_s":5086.648},{"id":"T00236","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C015","first_line":"L01258","last_line":"L01264","start_s":5087.168,"end_s":5091.921},{"id":"T00237","speaker":"laura-pastor","role":"member","name":"Laura Pastor","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C015","first_line":"L01265","last_line":"L01265","start_s":5092.242,"end_s":5092.603},{"id":"T00238","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C015","first_line":"L01266","last_line":"L01266","start_s":5093.184,"end_s":5093.666},{"id":"T00239","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C015","first_line":"L01267","last_line":"L01267","start_s":5093.826,"end_s":5094.067},{"id":"T00240","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C015","first_line":"L01268","last_line":"L01272","start_s":5094.548,"end_s":5097.817},{"id":"T00241","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C015","first_line":"L01273","last_line":"L01273","start_s":5098.158,"end_s":5098.398},{"id":"T00242","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C015","first_line":"L01274","last_line":"L01276","start_s":5098.799,"end_s":5101.667},{"id":"T00243","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C015","first_line":"L01277","last_line":"L01277","start_s":5110.473,"end_s":5110.934},{"id":"T00244","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C016","first_line":"L01278","last_line":"L01282","start_s":5110.974,"end_s":5122.71},{"id":"T00245","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C016","first_line":"L01283","last_line":"L01289","start_s":5123.01,"end_s":5186.532},{"id":"T00246","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C017","first_line":"L01290","last_line":"L01293","start_s":5187.541,"end_s":5220.696},{"id":"T00247","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C018","first_line":"L01294","last_line":"L01298","start_s":5221.397,"end_s":5255.102},{"id":"T00248","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C018","first_line":"L01299","last_line":"L01299","start_s":5256.243,"end_s":5256.623},{"id":"T00249","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C018","first_line":"L01300","last_line":"L01315","start_s":5256.744,"end_s":5270.312},{"id":"T00250","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C018","first_line":"L01316","last_line":"L01317","start_s":5270.572,"end_s":5272.155},{"id":"T00251","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C019","first_line":"L01318","last_line":"L01322","start_s":5273.217,"end_s":5283.212},{"id":"T00252","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C019","first_line":"L01323","last_line":"L01330","start_s":5283.392,"end_s":5342.423},{"id":"T00253","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C019","first_line":"L01331","last_line":"L01331","start_s":5343.162,"end_s":5357.278},{"id":"T00254","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C019","first_line":"L01332","last_line":"L01332","start_s":5358.58,"end_s":5359.281},{"id":"T00255","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01333","last_line":"L01334","start_s":5359.301,"end_s":5366.169},{"id":"T00256","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01335","last_line":"L01336","start_s":5366.329,"end_s":5368.491},{"id":"T00257","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01337","last_line":"L01338","start_s":5368.772,"end_s":5370.874},{"id":"T00258","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01339","last_line":"L01344","start_s":5371.158,"end_s":5401.873},{"id":"T00259","speaker":"v22","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01345","last_line":"L01352","start_s":5401.853,"end_s":5472.36},{"id":"T00260","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01353","last_line":"L01364","start_s":5472.34,"end_s":5581.153},{"id":"T00261","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01365","last_line":"L01365","start_s":5582.348,"end_s":5582.99},{"id":"T00262","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01366","last_line":"L01366","start_s":5583.411,"end_s":5583.592},{"id":"T00263","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01367","last_line":"L01371","start_s":5584.354,"end_s":5588.185},{"id":"T00264","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01372","last_line":"L01372","start_s":5588.285,"end_s":5588.566},{"id":"T00265","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C020","first_line":"L01373","last_line":"L01380","start_s":5589.188,"end_s":5596.189},{"id":"T00266","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C021","first_line":"L01381","last_line":"L01398","start_s":5597.432,"end_s":5688.833},{"id":"T00267","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C021","first_line":"L01399","last_line":"L01399","start_s":5690.028,"end_s":5705.753},{"id":"T00268","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C022","first_line":"L01400","last_line":"L01400","start_s":5706.935,"end_s":5709.96},{"id":"T00269","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C022","first_line":"L01401","last_line":"L01401","start_s":5711.408,"end_s":5723.58},{"id":"T00270","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C022","first_line":"L01402","last_line":"L01403","start_s":5726.683,"end_s":5728.685},{"id":"T00271","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C022","first_line":"L01404","last_line":"L01414","start_s":5729.446,"end_s":5738.015},{"id":"T00272","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C022","first_line":"L01415","last_line":"L01415","start_s":5738.275,"end_s":5738.515},{"id":"T00273","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C022","first_line":"L01416","last_line":"L01420","start_s":5738.956,"end_s":5743.499},{"id":"T00274","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C022","first_line":"L01421","last_line":"L01422","start_s":5744.159,"end_s":5745.701},{"id":"T00275","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C023","first_line":"L01423","last_line":"L01425","start_s":5746.522,"end_s":5753.55},{"id":"T00276","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C023","first_line":"L01426","last_line":"L01426","start_s":5753.79,"end_s":5754.511},{"id":"T00277","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C023","first_line":"L01427","last_line":"L01428","start_s":5754.591,"end_s":5756.193},{"id":"T00278","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C023","first_line":"L01429","last_line":"L01429","start_s":5756.634,"end_s":5757.394},{"id":"T00279","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C023","first_line":"L01430","last_line":"L01432","start_s":5758.235,"end_s":5765.023},{"id":"T00280","speaker":"lori-bays","role":"staff","name":"Lori Bays","title":"Assistant City Manager","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2021-12-01 item 45 (first titled mention); still titled 2026-04-08","public_id":null,"chapter":"C023","first_line":"L01433","last_line":"L01433","start_s":5771.821,"end_s":5778.407},{"id":"T00281","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C023","first_line":"L01434","last_line":"L01441","start_s":5779.488,"end_s":5842.8},{"id":"T00282","speaker":"v05","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C023","first_line":"L01442","last_line":"L01451","start_s":5845.548,"end_s":5923.354},{"id":"T00283","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C023","first_line":"L01452","last_line":"L01456","start_s":5923.374,"end_s":5944.573},{"id":"T00284","speaker":"v05","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C023","first_line":"L01457","last_line":"L01461","start_s":5945.954,"end_s":5978.96},{"id":"T00285","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C023","first_line":"L01462","last_line":"L01465","start_s":5978.98,"end_s":5994.596},{"id":"T00286","speaker":"v05","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C023","first_line":"L01466","last_line":"L01472","start_s":5995.858,"end_s":6038.894},{"id":"T00287","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C023","first_line":"L01473","last_line":"L01476","start_s":6039.275,"end_s":6095.183},{"id":"T00288","speaker":"v05","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C023","first_line":"L01477","last_line":"L01486","start_s":6095.669,"end_s":6131.668},{"id":"T00289","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C023","first_line":"L01487","last_line":"L01499","start_s":6131.688,"end_s":6202.917},{"id":"T00290","speaker":"betty-guardado","role":"member","name":"Betty Guardado","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C023","first_line":"L01500","last_line":"L01503","start_s":6203.538,"end_s":6221.543},{"id":"T00291","speaker":"v05","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C023","first_line":"L01504","last_line":"L01516","start_s":6222.637,"end_s":6318.135},{"id":"T00292","speaker":"betty-guardado","role":"member","name":"Betty Guardado","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C023","first_line":"L01517","last_line":"L01538","start_s":6319.06,"end_s":6484.706},{"id":"T00293","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C023","first_line":"L01539","last_line":"L01547","start_s":6487.169,"end_s":6495.029},{"id":"T00294","speaker":"laura-pastor","role":"member","name":"Laura Pastor","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C023","first_line":"L01548","last_line":"L01555","start_s":6496.131,"end_s":6531.587},{"id":"T00295","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C023","first_line":"L01556","last_line":"L01562","start_s":6532.883,"end_s":6537.959},{"id":"T00296","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C023","first_line":"L01563","last_line":"L01566","start_s":6538.139,"end_s":6540.527},{"id":"T00297","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C024","first_line":"L01567","last_line":"L01568","start_s":6541.69,"end_s":6547.663},{"id":"T00298","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C024","first_line":"L01569","last_line":"L01571","start_s":6547.683,"end_s":6551.388},{"id":"T00299","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C024","first_line":"L01572","last_line":"L01597","start_s":6552.149,"end_s":6708.212},{"id":"T00300","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C024","first_line":"L01598","last_line":"L01599","start_s":6709.294,"end_s":6711.998},{"id":"T00301","speaker":"lori-bays","role":"staff","name":"Lori Bays","title":"Assistant City Manager","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2021-12-01 item 45 (first titled mention); still titled 2026-04-08","public_id":null,"chapter":"C024","first_line":"L01600","last_line":"L01602","start_s":6712.038,"end_s":6728.502},{"id":"T00302","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C024","first_line":"L01603","last_line":"L01604","start_s":6737.138,"end_s":6748.043},{"id":"T00303","speaker":"v23","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C024","first_line":"L01605","last_line":"L01612","start_s":6755.161,"end_s":6833.532},{"id":"T00304","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C024","first_line":"L01613","last_line":"L01615","start_s":6833.512,"end_s":6866.877},{"id":"T00305","speaker":"v23","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C024","first_line":"L01616","last_line":"L01622","start_s":6869.371,"end_s":6933.378},{"id":"T00306","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C024","first_line":"L01623","last_line":"L01624","start_s":6934.64,"end_s":6947.421},{"id":"T00307","speaker":"v24","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C024","first_line":"L01625","last_line":"L01632","start_s":6948.16,"end_s":6987.273},{"id":"T00308","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C024","first_line":"L01633","last_line":"L01634","start_s":6990.337,"end_s":6995.403},{"id":"T00309","speaker":"betty-guardado","role":"member","name":"Betty Guardado","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C024","first_line":"L01635","last_line":"L01635","start_s":6996.965,"end_s":6997.245},{"id":"T00310","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C024","first_line":"L01636","last_line":"L01636","start_s":6997.946,"end_s":6998.687},{"id":"T00311","speaker":"betty-guardado","role":"member","name":"Betty Guardado","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C024","first_line":"L01637","last_line":"L01645","start_s":6999.055,"end_s":7065.389},{"id":"T00312","speaker":"v24","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C024","first_line":"L01646","last_line":"L01646","start_s":7066.992,"end_s":7071.52},{"id":"T00313","speaker":"v23","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C024","first_line":"L01647","last_line":"L01655","start_s":7085.489,"end_s":7175.284},{"id":"T00314","speaker":"betty-guardado","role":"member","name":"Betty Guardado","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C024","first_line":"L01656","last_line":"L01667","start_s":7175.956,"end_s":7257.01},{"id":"T00315","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C024","first_line":"L01668","last_line":"L01674","start_s":7258.323,"end_s":7263.488},{"id":"T00316","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C025","first_line":"L01675","last_line":"L01678","start_s":7265.01,"end_s":7280.766},{"id":"T00317","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C025","first_line":"L01679","last_line":"L01689","start_s":7280.786,"end_s":7294.716},{"id":"T00318","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C025","first_line":"L01690","last_line":"L01691","start_s":7296.138,"end_s":7304.57},{"id":"T00319","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C025","first_line":"L01692","last_line":"L01693","start_s":7309.157,"end_s":7313.062},{"id":"T00320","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C025","first_line":"L01694","last_line":"L01697","start_s":7313.643,"end_s":7319.661},{"id":"T00321","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C025","first_line":"L01698","last_line":"L01701","start_s":7319.962,"end_s":7323.268},{"id":"T00322","speaker":"v05","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C025","first_line":"L01702","last_line":"L01702","start_s":7323.528,"end_s":7323.749},{"id":"T00323","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C025","first_line":"L01703","last_line":"L01705","start_s":7324.611,"end_s":7326.875},{"id":"T00324","speaker":"v05","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C025","first_line":"L01706","last_line":"L01706","start_s":7326.915,"end_s":7327.155},{"id":"T00325","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C025","first_line":"L01707","last_line":"L01711","start_s":7328.077,"end_s":7332.225},{"id":"T00326","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C025","first_line":"L01712","last_line":"L01712","start_s":7332.426,"end_s":7333.427},{"id":"T00327","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C025","first_line":"L01713","last_line":"L01715","start_s":7333.448,"end_s":7335.652},{"id":"T00328","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L01716","last_line":"L01721","start_s":7336.854,"end_s":7367.288},{"id":"T00329","speaker":"v15","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L01722","last_line":"L01727","start_s":7367.673,"end_s":7379.672},{"id":"T00330","speaker":"v25","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L01728","last_line":"L01757","start_s":7383.258,"end_s":7628.625},{"id":"T00331","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L01758","last_line":"L01761","start_s":7628.645,"end_s":7645.405},{"id":"T00332","speaker":"v26","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L01762","last_line":"L01822","start_s":7653.62,"end_s":7961.226},{"id":"T00333","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L01823","last_line":"L01824","start_s":7963.249,"end_s":7967.295},{"id":"T00334","speaker":"v27","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L01825","last_line":"L01868","start_s":7988.96,"end_s":8280.445},{"id":"T00335","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L01869","last_line":"L01873","start_s":8281.336,"end_s":8306.77},{"id":"T00336","speaker":"v28","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L01874","last_line":"L01875","start_s":8307.577,"end_s":8309.6},{"id":"T00337","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L01876","last_line":"L01876","start_s":8309.92,"end_s":8310.461},{"id":"T00338","speaker":"v28","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L01877","last_line":"L01908","start_s":8310.481,"end_s":8428.523},{"id":"T00339","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L01909","last_line":"L01910","start_s":8430.815,"end_s":8439.276},{"id":"T00340","speaker":"v29","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L01911","last_line":"L01930","start_s":8439.296,"end_s":8540.819},{"id":"T00341","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L01931","last_line":"L01932","start_s":8542.381,"end_s":8546.087},{"id":"T00342","speaker":"v30","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L01933","last_line":"L01939","start_s":8548.391,"end_s":8588.422},{"id":"T00343","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L01940","last_line":"L01942","start_s":8589.344,"end_s":8595.535},{"id":"T00344","speaker":"kevin-robinson","role":"member","name":"Kevin Robinson","title":"Councilman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L01943","last_line":"L01945","start_s":8596.878,"end_s":8601.306},{"id":"T00345","speaker":"v26","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L01946","last_line":"L01946","start_s":8604.661,"end_s":8605.482},{"id":"T00346","speaker":"kevin-robinson","role":"member","name":"Kevin Robinson","title":"Councilman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L01947","last_line":"L01962","start_s":8606.363,"end_s":8690.628},{"id":"T00347","speaker":"ed-zuercher","role":"staff","name":"Ed Zuercher","title":"City Manager","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes: City Manager Ed Zuercher from 2025-11-19 (after Jeff Barton, 2023 to about Nov 2025); still titled 2026-08-26. See gg_phx-cc-data config/officials.csv","public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L01963","last_line":"L01963","start_s":8690.648,"end_s":8697.78},{"id":"T00348","speaker":"kevin-robinson","role":"member","name":"Kevin Robinson","title":"Councilman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L01964","last_line":"L01964","start_s":8697.8,"end_s":8703.67},{"id":"T00349","speaker":"v26","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L01965","last_line":"L01969","start_s":8703.818,"end_s":8724.841},{"id":"T00350","speaker":"v31","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L01970","last_line":"L01971","start_s":8730.146,"end_s":8731.868},{"id":"T00351","speaker":"kevin-robinson","role":"member","name":"Kevin Robinson","title":"Councilman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L01972","last_line":"L01975","start_s":8732.287,"end_s":8755.729},{"id":"T00352","speaker":"v26","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L01976","last_line":"L01978","start_s":8756.502,"end_s":8777.072},{"id":"T00353","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L01979","last_line":"L01979","start_s":8780.137,"end_s":8783.942},{"id":"T00354","speaker":"kevin-robinson","role":"member","name":"Kevin Robinson","title":"Councilman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L01980","last_line":"L01982","start_s":8784.263,"end_s":8789.417},{"id":"T00355","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L01983","last_line":"L01983","start_s":8791.279,"end_s":8792.02},{"id":"T00356","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L01984","last_line":"L01989","start_s":8792.04,"end_s":8810.583},{"id":"T00357","speaker":"v26","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L01990","last_line":"L02002","start_s":8810.603,"end_s":8891.269},{"id":"T00358","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L02003","last_line":"L02009","start_s":8891.249,"end_s":8937.979},{"id":"T00359","speaker":"v26","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L02010","last_line":"L02016","start_s":8938.567,"end_s":9004.014},{"id":"T00360","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L02017","last_line":"L02021","start_s":9004.794,"end_s":9015.385},{"id":"T00361","speaker":"kevin-robinson","role":"member","name":"Kevin Robinson","title":"Councilman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L02022","last_line":"L02030","start_s":9015.635,"end_s":9046.406},{"id":"T00362","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L02031","last_line":"L02035","start_s":9046.627,"end_s":9054.358},{"id":"T00363","speaker":"debra-stark","role":"member","name":"Debra Stark","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L02036","last_line":"L02039","start_s":9055.159,"end_s":9071.375},{"id":"T00364","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L02040","last_line":"L02040","start_s":9072.897,"end_s":9073.958},{"id":"T00365","speaker":"laura-pastor","role":"member","name":"Laura Pastor","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L02041","last_line":"L02045","start_s":9074.512,"end_s":9122.463},{"id":"T00366","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L02046","last_line":"L02049","start_s":9123.445,"end_s":9127.613},{"id":"T00367","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L02050","last_line":"L02054","start_s":9127.633,"end_s":9137.712},{"id":"T00368","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L02055","last_line":"L02058","start_s":9138.147,"end_s":9140.873},{"id":"T00369","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L02059","last_line":"L02059","start_s":9141.053,"end_s":9141.334},{"id":"T00370","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L02060","last_line":"L02066","start_s":9141.835,"end_s":9146.244},{"id":"T00371","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L02067","last_line":"L02067","start_s":9146.905,"end_s":9147.106},{"id":"T00372","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C026","first_line":"L02068","last_line":"L02068","start_s":9147.466,"end_s":9148.007},{"id":"T00373","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C027","first_line":"L02069","last_line":"L02069","start_s":9149.571,"end_s":9156.966},{"id":"T00374","speaker":"v32","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C027","first_line":"L02070","last_line":"L02089","start_s":9164.827,"end_s":9293.681},{"id":"T00375","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C027","first_line":"L02090","last_line":"L02091","start_s":9293.701,"end_s":9297.347},{"id":"T00376","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C027","first_line":"L02092","last_line":"L02093","start_s":9299.51,"end_s":9303.697},{"id":"T00377","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C027","first_line":"L02094","last_line":"L02095","start_s":9304.318,"end_s":9307.103},{"id":"T00378","speaker":"debra-stark","role":"member","name":"Debra Stark","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C027","first_line":"L02096","last_line":"L02100","start_s":9308.804,"end_s":9326.378},{"id":"T00379","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C027","first_line":"L02101","last_line":"L02102","start_s":9326.458,"end_s":9330.846},{"id":"T00380","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C027","first_line":"L02103","last_line":"L02113","start_s":9331.197,"end_s":9339.485},{"id":"T00381","speaker":"debra-stark","role":"member","name":"Debra Stark","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C027","first_line":"L02114","last_line":"L02116","start_s":9340.246,"end_s":9344.61},{"id":"T00382","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C027","first_line":"L02117","last_line":"L02121","start_s":9345.491,"end_s":9349.194},{"id":"T00383","speaker":"debra-stark","role":"member","name":"Debra Stark","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C027","first_line":"L02122","last_line":"L02122","start_s":9349.475,"end_s":9349.655},{"id":"T00384","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C027","first_line":"L02123","last_line":"L02123","start_s":9350.075,"end_s":9351.016},{"id":"T00385","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C027","first_line":"L02124","last_line":"L02124","start_s":9352.858,"end_s":9353.258},{"id":"T00386","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C028","first_line":"L02125","last_line":"L02125","start_s":9354.54,"end_s":9360.225},{"id":"T00387","speaker":"julie-kriegh","role":"staff","name":"Julie Kriegh","title":"City Attorney","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2022-11-15 (first titled mention); still titled City Attorney 2026-09-09","public_id":null,"chapter":"C028","first_line":"L02126","last_line":"L02132","start_s":9361.015,"end_s":9389.166},{"id":"T00388","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C028","first_line":"L02133","last_line":"L02134","start_s":9390.412,"end_s":9395.224},{"id":"T00389","speaker":"v33","role":"public","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":"pc-000-001","chapter":"C028","first_line":"L02135","last_line":"L02139","start_s":9410.527,"end_s":9485.404},{"id":"T00390","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C028","first_line":"L02140","last_line":"L02141","start_s":9487.46,"end_s":9493.672},{"id":"T00391","speaker":"v04","role":"public","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":"pc-000-002","chapter":"C028","first_line":"L02142","last_line":"L02159","start_s":9500.184,"end_s":9592.615},{"id":"T00392","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C028","first_line":"L02160","last_line":"L02161","start_s":9592.635,"end_s":9598.102},{"id":"T00393","speaker":"v34","role":"public","name":"Jerry Van Gasse","title":null,"name_basis":"named by a moderator","public_id":"pc-000-003","chapter":"C028","first_line":"L02162","last_line":"L02181","start_s":9602.627,"end_s":9748.369},{"id":"T00394","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C028","first_line":"L02182","last_line":"L02183","start_s":9748.389,"end_s":9751.793},{"id":"T00395","speaker":"v35","role":"public","name":"Tim Sierakowski","title":null,"name_basis":"said aloud at L02161","public_id":"pc-000-004","chapter":"C028","first_line":"L02184","last_line":"L02193","start_s":9755.114,"end_s":9826.221},{"id":"T00396","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C028","first_line":"L02194","last_line":"L02194","start_s":9828.504,"end_s":9830.987},{"id":"T00397","speaker":"v36","role":"public","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":"pc-000-005","chapter":"C028","first_line":"L02195","last_line":"L02213","start_s":9838.392,"end_s":10019.346},{"id":"T00398","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C028","first_line":"L02214","last_line":"L02215","start_s":10020.946,"end_s":10026.155},{"id":"T00399","speaker":"v31","role":"public","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":"pc-000-006","chapter":"C028","first_line":"L02216","last_line":"L02223","start_s":10030.722,"end_s":10075.455},{"id":"T00400","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C028","first_line":"L02224","last_line":"L02224","start_s":10084.143,"end_s":10085.926},{"id":"T00401","speaker":"v37","role":"public","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":"pc-000-007","chapter":"C028","first_line":"L02225","last_line":"L02229","start_s":10086.387,"end_s":10137.471},{"id":"T00402","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C028","first_line":"L02230","last_line":"L02231","start_s":10138.112,"end_s":10142.803},{"id":"T00403","speaker":"v38","role":"public","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":"pc-000-008","chapter":"C028","first_line":"L02232","last_line":"L02250","start_s":10151.491,"end_s":10264.624},{"id":"T00404","speaker":"v39","role":"public","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":"pc-000-009","chapter":"C028","first_line":"L02251","last_line":"L02257","start_s":10266.798,"end_s":10297.17},{"id":"T00405","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C028","first_line":"L02258","last_line":"L02260","start_s":10298.472,"end_s":10308.465},{"id":"T00406","speaker":"v40","role":"public","name":"Jeremy Thacker","title":null,"name_basis":"named by a moderator","public_id":"pc-000-010","chapter":"C028","first_line":"L02261","last_line":"L02273","start_s":10320.072,"end_s":10398.153},{"id":"T00407","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C028","first_line":"L02274","last_line":"L02275","start_s":10398.173,"end_s":10401.497},{"id":"T00408","speaker":"v41","role":"public","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":"pc-000-011","chapter":"C028","first_line":"L02276","last_line":"L02285","start_s":10407.282,"end_s":10438.389},{"id":"T00409","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C028","first_line":"L02286","last_line":"L02291","start_s":10440.792,"end_s":10456.711},{"id":"T00410","speaker":"v25","role":"public","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":"pc-000-012","chapter":"C028","first_line":"L02292","last_line":"L02292","start_s":10458.053,"end_s":10459.315},{"id":"T00411","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C028","first_line":"L02293","last_line":"L02294","start_s":10462.619,"end_s":10470.797},{"id":"T00412","speaker":"v42","role":"public","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":"pc-000-013","chapter":"C028","first_line":"L02295","last_line":"L02308","start_s":10479.564,"end_s":10656.809},{"id":"T00413","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C028","first_line":"L02309","last_line":"L02313","start_s":10659.953,"end_s":10682.382},{"id":"T00414","speaker":"v43","role":"public","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":"pc-000-014","chapter":"C028","first_line":"L02314","last_line":"L02314","start_s":10696.25,"end_s":10699.425}],"lines":[{"id":"L00001","start_s":2.005,"end_s":2.966,"video_s":1862.005,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00001","chapter":"C001","text":"Good afternoon.","fingerprint":"f01e727e7b79","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00002","start_s":3.006,"end_s":4.167,"video_s":1863.006,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00001","chapter":"C001","text":"Thank you for joining us.","fingerprint":"d05900a28222","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00003","start_s":4.668,"end_s":8.352,"video_s":1864.668,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00001","chapter":"C001","text":"It is Wednesday, June 17th before the formal City Council meeting begins.","fingerprint":"4e14f89c9e79","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00004","start_s":8.712,"end_s":10.875,"video_s":1868.712,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00001","chapter":"C001","text":"We'll convene the Assisted Housing Governing Board.","fingerprint":"9d57fcbde667","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00005","start_s":10.915,"end_s":12.096,"video_s":1870.915,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00001","chapter":"C001","text":"I'll call that meeting to order.","fingerprint":"45305a20d74a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00006","start_s":12.557,"end_s":13.478,"video_s":1872.557,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00001","chapter":"C001","text":"Will the clerk call the roll?","fingerprint":"89bb0df24607","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00007","start_s":14.279,"end_s":15.18,"video_s":1874.279,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00002","chapter":"C001","text":"Board Member Guardado?","fingerprint":"8b706b52ba6d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00008","start_s":15.5,"end_s":15.72,"video_s":1875.5,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00002","chapter":"C001","text":"Here.","fingerprint":"fcec91509759","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00009","start_s":16.141,"end_s":17.202,"video_s":1876.141,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00002","chapter":"C001","text":"Board Member Hernandez?","fingerprint":"93cce1970fe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00010","start_s":17.322,"end_s":17.542,"video_s":1877.322,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00002","chapter":"C001","text":"Here.","fingerprint":"fcec91509759","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00011","start_s":18.163,"end_s":19.064,"video_s":1878.163,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00002","chapter":"C001","text":"Board Member Maggard?","fingerprint":"5c414dec72dc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00012","start_s":20.766,"end_s":20.986,"video_s":1880.766,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00003","chapter":"C001","text":"Here.","fingerprint":"fcec91509759","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00013","start_s":22.127,"end_s":23.429,"video_s":1882.127,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00004","chapter":"C001","text":"Board Member O'Brien?","fingerprint":"1181dea6f5d8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00014","start_s":23.449,"end_s":23.669,"video_s":1883.449,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00004","chapter":"C001","text":"Here.","fingerprint":"fcec91509759","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00015","start_s":24.23,"end_s":25.111,"video_s":1884.23,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00004","chapter":"C001","text":"Board Member Pastor?","fingerprint":"cf1c52443939","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00016","start_s":25.471,"end_s":25.691,"video_s":1885.471,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00004","chapter":"C001","text":"Here.","fingerprint":"fcec91509759","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00017","start_s":26.192,"end_s":27.193,"video_s":1886.192,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00004","chapter":"C001","text":"Board Member Robinson?","fingerprint":"9d32e3e62eca","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00018","start_s":27.493,"end_s":27.713,"video_s":1887.493,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00005","chapter":"C001","text":"Here.","fingerprint":"fcec91509759","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00019","start_s":28.214,"end_s":28.995,"video_s":1888.214,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00006","chapter":"C001","text":"Board Member Stark?","fingerprint":"e5afe27d599a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00020","start_s":29.275,"end_s":29.475,"video_s":1889.275,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00006","chapter":"C001","text":"Here.","fingerprint":"fcec91509759","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00021","start_s":29.996,"end_s":31.017,"video_s":1889.996,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00006","chapter":"C001","text":"Board Member Waring?","fingerprint":"c78d5b285371","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00022","start_s":31.857,"end_s":33.018,"video_s":1891.857,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00006","chapter":"C001","text":"Vice Chair Hodge Washington.","fingerprint":"cd8f629b6963","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00023","start_s":33.078,"end_s":33.299,"video_s":1893.078,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00006","chapter":"C001","text":"Here.","fingerprint":"fcec91509759","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00024","start_s":33.759,"end_s":34.58,"video_s":1893.759,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00006","chapter":"C001","text":"Chairwoman Gallego.","fingerprint":"7d3954d25719","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00025","start_s":35.061,"end_s":35.241,"video_s":1895.061,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00007","chapter":"C001","text":"Here.","fingerprint":"fcec91509759","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00026","start_s":38.164,"end_s":42.609,"video_s":1898.164,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00007","chapter":"C001","text":"Item number three is resolution number 233.","fingerprint":"2120844591c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00027","start_s":43.13,"end_s":45.052,"video_s":1903.13,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00007","chapter":"C001","text":"Do we have a motion on that resolution?","fingerprint":"867aa6603112","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00028","start_s":46.553,"end_s":49.337,"video_s":1906.553,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00008","chapter":"C001","text":"I move to approve resolution 233.","fingerprint":"2a1a114afdb8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00029","start_s":49.457,"end_s":49.937,"video_s":1909.457,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00008","chapter":"C001","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00030","start_s":50.898,"end_s":51.519,"video_s":1910.898,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00009","chapter":"C001","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00031","start_s":52.16,"end_s":53.281,"video_s":1912.16,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00009","chapter":"C001","text":"We have a motion and a second.","fingerprint":"7451ba811637","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00032","start_s":53.321,"end_s":57.185,"video_s":1913.321,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00009","chapter":"C001","text":"This is related to project vouchers for Moreland phase two.","fingerprint":"1001a9d1f394","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00033","start_s":58.086,"end_s":60.729,"video_s":1918.086,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00009","chapter":"C001","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00034","start_s":60.749,"end_s":61.29,"video_s":1920.749,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00010","chapter":"C001","text":"Guardado.","fingerprint":"0344b48c3f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00035","start_s":61.456,"end_s":64.239,"video_s":1921.456,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00010","chapter":"C001","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00036","start_s":64.719,"end_s":65.76,"video_s":1924.719,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00010","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00037","start_s":65.78,"end_s":66.181,"video_s":1925.78,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00010","chapter":"C001","text":"Maggard?","fingerprint":"98fd3e273d77","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00038","start_s":67.602,"end_s":67.823,"video_s":1927.602,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00010","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00039","start_s":68.563,"end_s":68.984,"video_s":1928.563,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00010","chapter":"C001","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00040","start_s":69.264,"end_s":69.845,"video_s":1929.264,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00010","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00041","start_s":69.865,"end_s":70.365,"video_s":1929.865,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00010","chapter":"C001","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00042","start_s":70.606,"end_s":70.846,"video_s":1930.606,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00010","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00043","start_s":71.326,"end_s":71.807,"video_s":1931.326,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00010","chapter":"C001","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00044","start_s":72.047,"end_s":72.327,"video_s":1932.047,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00011","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00045","start_s":72.808,"end_s":73.168,"video_s":1932.808,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00012","chapter":"C001","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00046","start_s":73.428,"end_s":73.649,"video_s":1933.428,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00012","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00047","start_s":74.069,"end_s":74.409,"video_s":1934.069,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00012","chapter":"C001","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00048","start_s":75.01,"end_s":75.09,"video_s":1935.01,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00012","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00049","start_s":75.11,"end_s":75.751,"video_s":1935.11,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00012","chapter":"C001","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00050","start_s":75.811,"end_s":76.111,"video_s":1935.811,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00013","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00051","start_s":76.452,"end_s":76.852,"video_s":1936.452,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00014","chapter":"C001","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00052","start_s":77.012,"end_s":77.272,"video_s":1937.012,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00015","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00053","start_s":77.573,"end_s":78.554,"video_s":1937.573,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00016","chapter":"C001","text":"Passes 10-0.","fingerprint":"55830666fff8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00054","start_s":79.395,"end_s":82.958,"video_s":1939.395,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00017","chapter":"C001","text":"Resolution number 234 is related to scattered site development.","fingerprint":"1e4c0af82661","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00055","start_s":83.319,"end_s":84.58,"video_s":1943.319,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00017","chapter":"C001","text":"Board Member Maggard, do you have a motion?","fingerprint":"6a7382a9d38d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00056","start_s":85.841,"end_s":88.464,"video_s":1945.841,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00018","chapter":"C001","text":"I move to approve resolution 234.","fingerprint":"9308ae28a7fa","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00057","start_s":88.544,"end_s":90.366,"video_s":1948.544,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00018","chapter":"C001","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00058","start_s":90.937,"end_s":91.397,"video_s":1950.937,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00019","chapter":"C001","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00059","start_s":92.639,"end_s":93.279,"video_s":1952.639,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00020","chapter":"C001","text":"Guardado.","fingerprint":"0344b48c3f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00060","start_s":93.299,"end_s":93.92,"video_s":1953.299,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00020","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00061","start_s":93.94,"end_s":94.44,"video_s":1953.94,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00020","chapter":"C001","text":"Hernandez.","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00062","start_s":94.58,"end_s":94.781,"video_s":1954.58,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00020","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00063","start_s":95.221,"end_s":95.621,"video_s":1955.221,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00020","chapter":"C001","text":"Maggard.","fingerprint":"98fd3e273d77","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00064","start_s":96.122,"end_s":96.362,"video_s":1956.122,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00020","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00065","start_s":96.843,"end_s":97.323,"video_s":1956.843,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00020","chapter":"C001","text":"O'Brien.","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00066","start_s":97.503,"end_s":97.763,"video_s":1957.503,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00020","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00067","start_s":98.164,"end_s":98.604,"video_s":1958.164,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00020","chapter":"C001","text":"Pastor.","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00068","start_s":98.924,"end_s":99.565,"video_s":1958.924,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00020","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00069","start_s":99.585,"end_s":100.086,"video_s":1959.585,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00020","chapter":"C001","text":"Robinson.","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00070","start_s":100.246,"end_s":100.486,"video_s":1960.246,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00020","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00071","start_s":100.926,"end_s":101.247,"video_s":1960.926,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00020","chapter":"C001","text":"Stark.","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00072","start_s":101.487,"end_s":101.707,"video_s":1961.487,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00020","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00073","start_s":102.087,"end_s":102.428,"video_s":1962.087,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00020","chapter":"C001","text":"Waring.","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00074","start_s":103.209,"end_s":103.929,"video_s":1963.209,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00020","chapter":"C001","text":"Hodge Washington.","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00075","start_s":104.109,"end_s":104.37,"video_s":1964.109,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00021","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00076","start_s":104.75,"end_s":105.27,"video_s":1964.75,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00021","chapter":"C001","text":"Gallego.","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00077","start_s":105.29,"end_s":105.511,"video_s":1965.29,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00021","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00078","start_s":105.911,"end_s":106.492,"video_s":1965.911,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00021","chapter":"C001","text":"Passes 10-0.","fingerprint":"55830666fff8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00079","start_s":107.553,"end_s":114.499,"video_s":1967.553,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00021","chapter":"C001","text":"Item five is resolution number 235, a resolution related to Edison Eastlake Choice Neighborhoods Mixed Income Housing Developments.","fingerprint":"590b20c5b0e0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00080","start_s":114.859,"end_s":115.62,"video_s":1974.859,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00021","chapter":"C001","text":"Do we have a motion?","fingerprint":"ea97412996cb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00081","start_s":116.881,"end_s":119.944,"video_s":1976.881,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00022","chapter":"C001","text":"I move to approve resolution 235.","fingerprint":"862b5537bb6c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00082","start_s":120.325,"end_s":120.825,"video_s":1980.325,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00022","chapter":"C001","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00083","start_s":121.919,"end_s":123.0,"video_s":1981.919,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00023","chapter":"C001","text":"We have a motion and a second.","fingerprint":"7451ba811637","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00084","start_s":123.02,"end_s":123.461,"video_s":1983.02,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00023","chapter":"C001","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00085","start_s":124.182,"end_s":124.702,"video_s":1984.182,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00024","chapter":"C001","text":"Guardado?","fingerprint":"0344b48c3f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00086","start_s":124.862,"end_s":125.543,"video_s":1984.862,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00024","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00087","start_s":125.683,"end_s":125.924,"video_s":1985.683,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00024","chapter":"C001","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00088","start_s":126.024,"end_s":126.664,"video_s":1986.024,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00024","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00089","start_s":126.684,"end_s":127.505,"video_s":1986.684,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00024","chapter":"C001","text":"Maggard?","fingerprint":"98fd3e273d77","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00090","start_s":127.525,"end_s":128.266,"video_s":1987.525,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00024","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00091","start_s":128.286,"end_s":128.767,"video_s":1988.286,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00024","chapter":"C001","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00092","start_s":129.388,"end_s":129.648,"video_s":1989.388,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00024","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00093","start_s":130.048,"end_s":130.509,"video_s":1990.048,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00024","chapter":"C001","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00094","start_s":130.649,"end_s":130.889,"video_s":1990.649,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00024","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00095","start_s":131.27,"end_s":131.79,"video_s":1991.27,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00024","chapter":"C001","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00096","start_s":131.991,"end_s":132.611,"video_s":1991.991,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00025","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00097","start_s":132.631,"end_s":133.352,"video_s":1992.631,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00026","chapter":"C001","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00098","start_s":133.372,"end_s":133.532,"video_s":1993.372,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00026","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00099","start_s":134.313,"end_s":134.654,"video_s":1994.313,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00026","chapter":"C001","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00100","start_s":135.434,"end_s":135.515,"video_s":1995.434,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00026","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00101","start_s":135.535,"end_s":136.175,"video_s":1995.535,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00026","chapter":"C001","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00102","start_s":136.275,"end_s":136.956,"video_s":1996.275,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00026","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00103","start_s":136.976,"end_s":137.377,"video_s":1996.976,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00026","chapter":"C001","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00104","start_s":137.657,"end_s":138.278,"video_s":1997.657,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00026","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00105","start_s":138.298,"end_s":139.019,"video_s":1998.298,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00026","chapter":"C001","text":"Passes 10-0.","fingerprint":"55830666fff8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00106","start_s":140.22,"end_s":147.388,"video_s":2000.22,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00027","chapter":"C001","text":"Item number six is resolution 236 related to the HUD rental assistance demonstration or RAD program.","fingerprint":"04ea6debc649","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00107","start_s":147.809,"end_s":148.99,"video_s":2007.809,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00027","chapter":"C001","text":"Do we have a motion?","fingerprint":"ea97412996cb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00108","start_s":149.527,"end_s":152.445,"video_s":2009.527,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00028","chapter":"C001","text":"I move to approve resolution 236.","fingerprint":"ffa54547a18e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00109","start_s":152.505,"end_s":153.954,"video_s":2012.505,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00028","chapter":"C001","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00110","start_s":155.161,"end_s":155.503,"video_s":2015.161,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00028","chapter":"C001","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00111","start_s":156.277,"end_s":156.818,"video_s":2016.277,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00029","chapter":"C001","text":"Guardado?","fingerprint":"0344b48c3f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00112","start_s":157.058,"end_s":157.278,"video_s":2017.058,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00029","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00113","start_s":157.759,"end_s":158.299,"video_s":2017.759,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00029","chapter":"C001","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00114","start_s":158.319,"end_s":159.0,"video_s":2018.319,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00030","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00115","start_s":159.02,"end_s":159.461,"video_s":2019.02,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00031","chapter":"C001","text":"Maggard?","fingerprint":"98fd3e273d77","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00116","start_s":160.162,"end_s":160.402,"video_s":2020.162,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00031","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00117","start_s":160.942,"end_s":161.443,"video_s":2020.942,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00031","chapter":"C001","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00118","start_s":161.623,"end_s":161.864,"video_s":2021.623,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00031","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00119","start_s":162.244,"end_s":162.785,"video_s":2022.244,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00031","chapter":"C001","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00120","start_s":162.885,"end_s":163.646,"video_s":2022.885,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00031","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00121","start_s":163.666,"end_s":164.206,"video_s":2023.666,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00031","chapter":"C001","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00122","start_s":164.447,"end_s":164.687,"video_s":2024.447,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00032","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00123","start_s":165.147,"end_s":165.508,"video_s":2025.147,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00033","chapter":"C001","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00124","start_s":165.768,"end_s":166.409,"video_s":2025.768,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00033","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00125","start_s":166.429,"end_s":166.809,"video_s":2026.429,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00033","chapter":"C001","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00126","start_s":167.55,"end_s":167.63,"video_s":2027.55,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00034","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00127","start_s":167.65,"end_s":168.291,"video_s":2027.65,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00035","chapter":"C001","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00128","start_s":168.411,"end_s":168.671,"video_s":2028.411,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00036","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00129","start_s":169.072,"end_s":169.753,"video_s":2029.072,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00036","chapter":"C001","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00130","start_s":169.773,"end_s":169.913,"video_s":2029.773,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00036","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00131","start_s":170.434,"end_s":171.355,"video_s":2030.434,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00036","chapter":"C001","text":"Passes 10-0.","fingerprint":"55830666fff8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00132","start_s":172.236,"end_s":180.425,"video_s":2032.236,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00036","chapter":"C001","text":"Item number seven is resolution number 237 related to housing choice voucher section eight project based vouchers for Central and Columbus.","fingerprint":"01c5aa7a47dd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00133","start_s":180.806,"end_s":181.947,"video_s":2040.806,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00036","chapter":"C001","text":"Do we have a motion?","fingerprint":"ea97412996cb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00134","start_s":182.467,"end_s":185.27,"video_s":2042.467,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00037","chapter":"C001","text":"I move to approve resolution 237.","fingerprint":"dfe3460937a3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00135","start_s":185.31,"end_s":186.271,"video_s":2045.31,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00037","chapter":"C001","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00136","start_s":187.973,"end_s":189.114,"video_s":2047.973,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00037","chapter":"C001","text":"We have a motion and a second.","fingerprint":"7451ba811637","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00137","start_s":189.174,"end_s":190.356,"video_s":2049.174,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00037","chapter":"C001","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00138","start_s":190.376,"end_s":190.896,"video_s":2050.376,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00038","chapter":"C001","text":"Guardado?","fingerprint":"0344b48c3f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00139","start_s":191.197,"end_s":191.397,"video_s":2051.197,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00038","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00140","start_s":191.957,"end_s":192.358,"video_s":2051.957,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00038","chapter":"C001","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00141","start_s":192.538,"end_s":193.279,"video_s":2052.538,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00038","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00142","start_s":193.299,"end_s":193.719,"video_s":2053.299,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00038","chapter":"C001","text":"Maggard?","fingerprint":"98fd3e273d77","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00143","start_s":194.06,"end_s":194.28,"video_s":2054.06,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00038","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00144","start_s":194.841,"end_s":195.321,"video_s":2054.841,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00038","chapter":"C001","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00145","start_s":195.461,"end_s":196.242,"video_s":2055.461,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00038","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00146","start_s":196.262,"end_s":196.783,"video_s":2056.262,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00038","chapter":"C001","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00147","start_s":196.963,"end_s":197.243,"video_s":2056.963,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00038","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00148","start_s":197.844,"end_s":198.365,"video_s":2057.844,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00038","chapter":"C001","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00149","start_s":198.425,"end_s":198.685,"video_s":2058.425,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00039","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00150","start_s":199.346,"end_s":199.686,"video_s":2059.346,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00040","chapter":"C001","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00151","start_s":200.046,"end_s":200.767,"video_s":2060.046,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00040","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00152","start_s":200.787,"end_s":201.148,"video_s":2060.787,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00040","chapter":"C001","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00153","start_s":202.009,"end_s":202.089,"video_s":2062.009,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00040","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00154","start_s":202.109,"end_s":202.789,"video_s":2062.109,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00040","chapter":"C001","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00155","start_s":202.95,"end_s":203.69,"video_s":2062.95,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00040","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00156","start_s":203.71,"end_s":204.131,"video_s":2063.71,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00040","chapter":"C001","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00157","start_s":204.331,"end_s":204.571,"video_s":2064.331,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00040","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00158","start_s":204.992,"end_s":205.993,"video_s":2064.992,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00040","chapter":"C001","text":"Passes 10-0.","fingerprint":"55830666fff8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00159","start_s":207.188,"end_s":208.109,"video_s":2067.188,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00041","chapter":"C001","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00160","start_s":208.149,"end_s":213.517,"video_s":2068.149,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00041","chapter":"C001","text":"Thank you to board member Donna Maggard for your service to our city and housing authority.","fingerprint":"e9d434c2a7e2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00161","start_s":213.557,"end_s":214.879,"video_s":2073.557,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00042","chapter":"C001","text":"With that, we are adjourned.","fingerprint":"e9ba3e61d7a9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00162","start_s":215.059,"end_s":215.74,"video_s":2075.059,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00042","chapter":"C001","text":"No, 238?","fingerprint":"2c9f0063fcaf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00163","start_s":215.78,"end_s":218.083,"video_s":2075.78,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00043","chapter":"C001","text":"All right.","fingerprint":"dfbdd9492bec","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00164","start_s":218.123,"end_s":219.726,"video_s":2078.123,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00043","chapter":"C001","text":"Do a motion on number 8, 238.","fingerprint":"4989652151ca","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00165","start_s":227.156,"end_s":230.16,"video_s":2087.156,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00044","chapter":"C001","text":"I move to approve resolution 238.","fingerprint":"5874f8f65351","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00166","start_s":230.861,"end_s":231.242,"video_s":2090.861,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00044","chapter":"C001","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00167","start_s":231.883,"end_s":232.664,"video_s":2091.883,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00045","chapter":"C001","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00168","start_s":232.684,"end_s":233.385,"video_s":2092.684,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00045","chapter":"C001","text":"Bernardo?","fingerprint":"ab2a0d5e0f4b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00169","start_s":233.405,"end_s":234.186,"video_s":2093.405,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00046","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00170","start_s":234.206,"end_s":234.787,"video_s":2094.206,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00046","chapter":"C001","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00171","start_s":234.807,"end_s":235.367,"video_s":2094.807,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00046","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00172","start_s":235.387,"end_s":235.728,"video_s":2095.387,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00047","chapter":"C001","text":"Maggard?","fingerprint":"98fd3e273d77","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00173","start_s":235.748,"end_s":235.828,"video_s":2095.748,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00047","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00174","start_s":239.234,"end_s":240.476,"video_s":2099.234,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00047","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00175","start_s":240.496,"end_s":240.896,"video_s":2100.496,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00047","chapter":"C001","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00176","start_s":241.116,"end_s":241.357,"video_s":2101.116,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00047","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00177","start_s":241.717,"end_s":242.158,"video_s":2101.717,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00047","chapter":"C001","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00178","start_s":242.398,"end_s":242.699,"video_s":2102.398,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00047","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00179","start_s":243.099,"end_s":243.6,"video_s":2103.099,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00047","chapter":"C001","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00180","start_s":243.76,"end_s":244.04,"video_s":2103.76,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00048","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00181","start_s":244.361,"end_s":244.721,"video_s":2104.361,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00049","chapter":"C001","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00182","start_s":245.062,"end_s":245.302,"video_s":2105.062,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00049","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00183","start_s":245.662,"end_s":246.023,"video_s":2105.662,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00049","chapter":"C001","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00184","start_s":246.604,"end_s":246.684,"video_s":2106.604,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00049","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00185","start_s":246.704,"end_s":247.385,"video_s":2106.704,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00049","chapter":"C001","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00186","start_s":247.525,"end_s":247.785,"video_s":2107.525,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00049","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00187","start_s":248.066,"end_s":248.486,"video_s":2108.066,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00049","chapter":"C001","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00188","start_s":248.606,"end_s":248.827,"video_s":2108.606,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00049","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00189","start_s":250.168,"end_s":251.23,"video_s":2110.168,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00050","chapter":"C001","text":"All right, now we are adjourned.","fingerprint":"d034e9ef9f0d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00190","start_s":251.27,"end_s":253.152,"video_s":2111.27,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00050","chapter":"C001","text":"Thank you so much to our board member.","fingerprint":"70703f4acd0a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00191","start_s":253.853,"end_s":258.679,"video_s":2113.853,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00050","chapter":"C001","text":"We'll next move to the invocation, and I invite Fire Chaplain Tim Martinell forward.","fingerprint":"32478c4d6116","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00192","start_s":263.666,"end_s":264.567,"video_s":2123.666,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00051","chapter":"C001","text":"Good afternoon.","fingerprint":"f01e727e7b79","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00193","start_s":265.12,"end_s":273.09,"video_s":2125.12,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00051","chapter":"C001","text":"Madam Mayor, I would like to thank you, the City Council, and the staff for the opportunity to be here today to open up this meeting with the invocation.","fingerprint":"e66d8140ed72","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00194","start_s":274.171,"end_s":275.513,"video_s":2134.171,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00051","chapter":"C001","text":"Please bow your heads and pray with me.","fingerprint":"ba00e6178116","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00195","start_s":277.295,"end_s":282.962,"video_s":2137.295,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00051","chapter":"C001","text":"Gracious God, we thank you for this day and for the privilege of serving the residents of Phoenix.","fingerprint":"b85e5965467d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00196","start_s":283.783,"end_s":289.39,"video_s":2143.783,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00051","chapter":"C001","text":"We are grateful for the members of the City Council and for their commitment to our community.","fingerprint":"7ef87d0950ad","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00197","start_s":289.943,"end_s":296.796,"video_s":2149.943,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00051","chapter":"C001","text":"As they gather to conduct the city's business, grant them wisdom, discernment, and clarity of thought.","fingerprint":"8aafa81eb0f2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00198","start_s":297.978,"end_s":304.009,"video_s":2157.978,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00051","chapter":"C001","text":"Help them work together with respect and understanding as they consider the needs of those that they serve.","fingerprint":"0a1e1bff3499","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00199","start_s":305.512,"end_s":313.487,"video_s":2165.512,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00051","chapter":"C001","text":"We also give thanks for the residents of Phoenix and for all who contribute to making this city a vibrant and caring community.","fingerprint":"db927c3d1ea9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00200","start_s":314.362,"end_s":319.591,"video_s":2174.362,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00051","chapter":"C001","text":"May this meeting be productive, thoughtful, and focused on the common good.","fingerprint":"c69fbb9e5dc9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00201","start_s":320.492,"end_s":322.555,"video_s":2180.492,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00051","chapter":"C001","text":"And I ask this in Jesus' name.","fingerprint":"cef6c2407756","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00202","start_s":322.575,"end_s":325.28,"video_s":2182.575,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00051","chapter":"C001","text":"Amen.","fingerprint":"9fdea7d457b5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00203","start_s":325.3,"end_s":325.5,"video_s":2185.3,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00052","chapter":"C001","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00204","start_s":325.52,"end_s":326.302,"video_s":2185.52,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00052","chapter":"C001","text":"Thank you, Chaplain.","fingerprint":"3804daada558","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00205","start_s":326.402,"end_s":329.687,"video_s":2186.402,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00052","chapter":"C001","text":"And now I'll ask Councilwoman Ann O'Brien to lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance.","fingerprint":"3955eddca853","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00206","start_s":351.132,"end_s":354.496,"video_s":2211.132,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00052","chapter":"C001","text":"I'll call to order the formal meeting of the Phoenix City Council.","fingerprint":"bb42a0d01973","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00207","start_s":354.516,"end_s":355.678,"video_s":2214.516,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00052","chapter":"C001","text":"Will the clerk call the roll?","fingerprint":"89bb0df24607","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00208","start_s":356.839,"end_s":357.84,"video_s":2216.839,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00053","chapter":"C001","text":"Councilwoman Guardado?","fingerprint":"725cada514c9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00209","start_s":357.981,"end_s":358.241,"video_s":2217.981,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00054","chapter":"C001","text":"Here.","fingerprint":"fcec91509759","evidence":[{"kind":"agenda-record","source":"roll call on 'CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL'","recorded":"Present","result":"matches"}],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00210","start_s":358.742,"end_s":359.723,"video_s":2218.742,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00055","chapter":"C001","text":"Councilwoman Hernandez?","fingerprint":"be943e39201c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00211","start_s":359.823,"end_s":360.063,"video_s":2219.823,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00056","chapter":"C001","text":"Here.","fingerprint":"fcec91509759","evidence":[{"kind":"agenda-record","source":"roll call on 'CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL'","recorded":"Present","result":"matches"}],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00212","start_s":360.664,"end_s":361.585,"video_s":2220.664,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00057","chapter":"C001","text":"Councilwoman O'Brien?","fingerprint":"003ed429bc6f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00213","start_s":361.705,"end_s":361.886,"video_s":2221.705,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00058","chapter":"C001","text":"Here.","fingerprint":"fcec91509759","evidence":[{"kind":"agenda-record","source":"roll call on 'CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL'","recorded":"Present","result":"matches"}],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00214","start_s":362.346,"end_s":363.327,"video_s":2222.346,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00059","chapter":"C001","text":"Councilwoman Pastor?","fingerprint":"dbcef12e9415","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00215","start_s":364.128,"end_s":364.329,"video_s":2224.128,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00060","chapter":"C001","text":"Here.","fingerprint":"fcec91509759","evidence":[{"kind":"agenda-record","source":"roll call on 'CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL'","recorded":"Present","result":"matches"}],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00216","start_s":364.889,"end_s":365.891,"video_s":2224.889,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00061","chapter":"C001","text":"Councilman Robinson?","fingerprint":"bd39baebf63f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00217","start_s":365.911,"end_s":366.091,"video_s":2225.911,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00062","chapter":"C001","text":"Here.","fingerprint":"fcec91509759","evidence":[{"kind":"agenda-record","source":"roll call on 'CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL'","recorded":"Present","result":"matches"}],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00218","start_s":366.531,"end_s":367.373,"video_s":2226.531,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00063","chapter":"C001","text":"Councilwoman Stark?","fingerprint":"f15b3cd9b019","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00219","start_s":367.533,"end_s":367.733,"video_s":2227.533,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00064","chapter":"C001","text":"Here.","fingerprint":"fcec91509759","evidence":[{"kind":"agenda-record","source":"roll call on 'CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL'","recorded":"Present","result":"matches"}],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00220","start_s":368.174,"end_s":368.874,"video_s":2228.174,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00065","chapter":"C001","text":"Councilman Waring?","fingerprint":"7cf533a8b87c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00221","start_s":369.756,"end_s":369.856,"video_s":2229.756,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00066","chapter":"C001","text":"Here.","fingerprint":"fcec91509759","evidence":[{"kind":"agenda-record","source":"roll call on 'CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL'","recorded":"Present","result":"matches"}],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00222","start_s":369.876,"end_s":370.837,"video_s":2229.876,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00067","chapter":"C001","text":"Vice Mayor Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"92c6a882f2f0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00223","start_s":370.977,"end_s":371.157,"video_s":2230.977,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00068","chapter":"C001","text":"Here.","fingerprint":"fcec91509759","evidence":[{"kind":"agenda-record","source":"roll call on 'CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL'","recorded":"Present","result":"matches"}],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00224","start_s":371.598,"end_s":372.499,"video_s":2231.598,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00069","chapter":"C001","text":"Mayor Gallego?","fingerprint":"d86fc0848ea6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00225","start_s":372.817,"end_s":373.058,"video_s":2232.817,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00070","chapter":"C001","text":"Here.","fingerprint":"fcec91509759","evidence":[{"kind":"agenda-record","source":"roll call on 'CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL'","recorded":"Present","result":"matches"}],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00226","start_s":374.26,"end_s":377.328,"video_s":2234.26,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00070","chapter":"C001","text":"Mario Barajas and Elsie Duarte are with us to provide interpretation.","fingerprint":"a7888de6ffac","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00227","start_s":377.408,"end_s":378.611,"video_s":2237.408,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00070","chapter":"C001","text":"Mario, would you introduce your team?","fingerprint":"f1c3c980359f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00228","start_s":379.092,"end_s":379.553,"video_s":2239.092,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00071","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes, Mayor.","fingerprint":"f16b9e8eb094","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00229","start_s":379.593,"end_s":379.974,"video_s":2239.593,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00071","chapter":"C001","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00230","start_s":380.495,"end_s":381.017,"video_s":2240.495,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00071","chapter":"C001","text":"Good afternoon.","fingerprint":"f01e727e7b79","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00231","start_s":381.057,"end_s":384.645,"video_s":2241.057,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00071","chapter":"C001","text":"As already mentioned, my name is Mario Barajas.","fingerprint":"c7f330665db8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00232","start_s":384.665,"end_s":391.281,"video_s":2244.665,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00071","chapter":"C001","text":"I'll be working together with Elsie Duarte as our Spanish interpreters for our Spanish-speaking residents.","fingerprint":"955f67271e5b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00233","start_s":391.261,"end_s":395.046,"video_s":2251.261,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00071","chapter":"C001","text":"I'll now take a moment to introduce ourselves to our Spanish speaking residents.","fingerprint":"20cc63988a7b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00234","start_s":395.707,"end_s":404.1,"video_s":2255.707,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00071","chapter":"C001","text":"Buenas tardes, yo soy Mario Barajas y junto conmigo va a estar trabajando Elsie Duarte y vamos a ser intérpretes a los de habla hispana.","fingerprint":"7c79394a1cb0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00235","start_s":404.58,"end_s":412.712,"video_s":2264.58,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00071","chapter":"C001","text":"Quisiéramos repasar brevemente de que si acaso van a estar dando un comentario público, favor de hablar de una manera lenta","fingerprint":"8db923d1b71a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00236","start_s":412.692,"end_s":426.192,"video_s":2272.692,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00071","chapter":"C001","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00237","start_s":430.339,"end_s":431.3,"video_s":2290.339,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00071","chapter":"C001","text":"Thank you so much, Mario.","fingerprint":"408ccfa35ecd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00238","start_s":431.32,"end_s":433.283,"video_s":2291.32,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00072","chapter":"C001","text":"Will the City Clerk read the 24-hour paragraph?","fingerprint":"a89968a90ab6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00239","start_s":434.258,"end_s":442.569,"video_s":2294.258,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00073","chapter":"C001","text":"The titles of the following ordinance and resolution numbers on the agenda were available to the public at least 24 hours prior to this council meeting and therefore may be read by title or agenda item only.","fingerprint":"1563ae4bf111","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00240","start_s":442.95,"end_s":449.439,"video_s":2302.95,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00073","chapter":"C001","text":"Ordinance is number G7523 through 7524 and S52964 through 53064.","fingerprint":"27bb78d39aae","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00241","start_s":451.962,"end_s":454.225,"video_s":2311.962,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00074","chapter":"C001","text":"Will the city attorney please explain public comment?","fingerprint":"e94693e1161d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00242","start_s":454.576,"end_s":455.478,"video_s":2314.576,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00075","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes, thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"810f7bb9ebdf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00243","start_s":455.858,"end_s":459.585,"video_s":2315.858,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00075","chapter":"C001","text":"Members of the public may speak for up to two minutes to comment on agenda items.","fingerprint":"fc6d2876d22d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00244","start_s":459.966,"end_s":464.213,"video_s":2319.966,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00075","chapter":"C001","text":"Comments must be related to the agenda item in the action being considered by the Council.","fingerprint":"07b1dc1378a3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00245","start_s":464.714,"end_s":470.805,"video_s":2324.714,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00075","chapter":"C001","text":"General comments that go beyond the scope of the agenda item should be made during the citizen comment session at the end of the agenda.","fingerprint":"59d83a08d310","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00246","start_s":471.306,"end_s":477.276,"video_s":2331.306,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00075","chapter":"C001","text":"The City Council and staff cannot discuss or comment on matters related to pending investigations, claims, or litigation.","fingerprint":"cd361cdf5e3c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00247","start_s":477.256,"end_s":486.687,"video_s":2337.256,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00075","chapter":"C001","text":"Additionally, any member of the public who appears before the council in their capacity as a lobbyist must, as required by Phoenix City Code, disclose this fact before addressing the council.","fingerprint":"ec3f694263b6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00248","start_s":487.368,"end_s":491.493,"video_s":2347.368,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00075","chapter":"C001","text":"The City Code states that speakers must express their comments respectfully and courteously.","fingerprint":"bc64226bce55","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00249","start_s":492.094,"end_s":497.4,"video_s":2352.094,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00075","chapter":"C001","text":"Use of profane language, threats, or personal attacks on members of the public, council members, or staff are not allowed.","fingerprint":"8b37bacb6b7f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00250","start_s":498.001,"end_s":501.085,"video_s":2358.001,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00075","chapter":"C001","text":"Such comments are disruptive and unrelated to the council's business.","fingerprint":"77ffc08a1538","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00251","start_s":501.726,"end_s":506.111,"video_s":2361.726,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00075","chapter":"C001","text":"Any person who violates these rules may lose their opportunity to speak further and could be asked to leave.","fingerprint":"a37c4a3765dc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00252","start_s":506.391,"end_s":506.892,"video_s":2366.391,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00075","chapter":"C001","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00253","start_s":508.947,"end_s":511.032,"video_s":2368.947,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00076","chapter":"C001","text":"Thank you so much to our city attorney.","fingerprint":"bbf857dc3bd9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00254","start_s":512.135,"end_s":514.42,"video_s":2372.135,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00076","chapter":"C001","text":"Agenda item number one, formal meeting minutes.","fingerprint":"d3396e0d38da","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00255","start_s":514.44,"end_s":515.844,"video_s":2374.44,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00076","chapter":"C001","text":"Councilwoman Pastor, do you have a motion?","fingerprint":"cf6c7d7a543e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00256","start_s":517.508,"end_s":522.359,"video_s":2377.508,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00077","chapter":"C001","text":"I move to approve the formal meeting minutes of 11-5-2025.","fingerprint":"78a8c8da6e24","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00257","start_s":522.64,"end_s":523.703,"video_s":2382.64,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00077","chapter":"C001","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00258","start_s":524.304,"end_s":524.745,"video_s":2384.304,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00078","chapter":"C001","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00259","start_s":525.873,"end_s":527.075,"video_s":2385.873,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00079","chapter":"C001","text":"All those in favor, please say aye.","fingerprint":"80a7b6856cc0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00260","start_s":527.415,"end_s":527.756,"video_s":2387.415,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00080","chapter":"C001","text":"Aye.","fingerprint":"4707c4fdc04e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00261","start_s":527.796,"end_s":528.757,"video_s":2387.796,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00081","chapter":"C001","text":"Any opposed?","fingerprint":"912fd592ea04","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00262","start_s":529.378,"end_s":530.32,"video_s":2389.378,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00081","chapter":"C001","text":"Passes unanimously.","fingerprint":"a967da129bf4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00263","start_s":530.961,"end_s":534.186,"video_s":2390.961,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00081","chapter":"C001","text":"Item number two is appointing of municipal court judges.","fingerprint":"fb857bd21882","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00264","start_s":534.406,"end_s":535.368,"video_s":2394.406,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00081","chapter":"C001","text":"Vice Mayor, do you have a motion?","fingerprint":"ecd9515b01d8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00265","start_s":535.648,"end_s":542.539,"video_s":2395.648,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00082","chapter":"C001","text":"Motion to approve the reappointments of Judge Laura E. Lowry and Judge Tina Solomon as Phoenix Municipal Court judges.","fingerprint":"9bda4649eb4f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00266","start_s":542.639,"end_s":543.02,"video_s":2402.639,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00082","chapter":"C001","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00267","start_s":543.741,"end_s":544.963,"video_s":2403.741,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00083","chapter":"C001","text":"Motion and a second.","fingerprint":"9b5eb76aa224","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00268","start_s":545.083,"end_s":545.684,"video_s":2405.083,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00083","chapter":"C001","text":"Any comments?","fingerprint":"9cdeefcc2f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00269","start_s":548.168,"end_s":549.309,"video_s":2408.168,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00083","chapter":"C001","text":"All those in favor, say aye.","fingerprint":"a4221bb84d8e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00270","start_s":550.111,"end_s":550.191,"video_s":2410.111,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00083","chapter":"C001","text":"Aye.","fingerprint":"4707c4fdc04e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00271","start_s":550.231,"end_s":551.453,"video_s":2410.231,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00083","chapter":"C001","text":"Any opposed, nay.","fingerprint":"f7daaedf3626","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00272","start_s":552.414,"end_s":554.277,"video_s":2412.414,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00083","chapter":"C001","text":"Welcome back to our judges.","fingerprint":"d3cd79445b1c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00273","start_s":555.657,"end_s":565.598,"video_s":2415.657,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00083","chapter":"C001","text":"The city of Phoenix provides an advisory role to the state of Arizona on liquor license and we'll turn to that portion of our agenda as well as off-track betting and bingo.","fingerprint":"20d0765cfe8f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00274","start_s":566.239,"end_s":567.221,"video_s":2426.239,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00083","chapter":"C001","text":"Vice Mayor, do we have a motion?","fingerprint":"fb76ba8f4bfa","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00275","start_s":567.662,"end_s":570.248,"video_s":2427.662,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00084","chapter":"C002","text":"Motion to approve items 3 through 22.","fingerprint":"63d8c1c03f19","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00276","start_s":570.268,"end_s":570.668,"video_s":2430.268,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00084","chapter":"C002","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00277","start_s":571.811,"end_s":572.993,"video_s":2431.811,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C002","text":"Motion and a second.","fingerprint":"9b5eb76aa224","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00278","start_s":573.174,"end_s":574.336,"video_s":2433.174,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C002","text":"Any comments?","fingerprint":"9cdeefcc2f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00279","start_s":574.356,"end_s":574.797,"video_s":2434.356,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C002","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00280","start_s":576.481,"end_s":577.002,"video_s":2436.481,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00086","chapter":"C002","text":"Guardado?","fingerprint":"0344b48c3f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00281","start_s":577.242,"end_s":577.883,"video_s":2437.242,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00086","chapter":"C002","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00282","start_s":577.903,"end_s":578.484,"video_s":2437.903,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00086","chapter":"C002","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00283","start_s":578.504,"end_s":578.724,"video_s":2438.504,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00086","chapter":"C002","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00284","start_s":579.104,"end_s":579.545,"video_s":2439.104,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00086","chapter":"C002","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00285","start_s":579.705,"end_s":580.306,"video_s":2439.705,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00086","chapter":"C002","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00286","start_s":580.326,"end_s":580.767,"video_s":2440.326,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00086","chapter":"C002","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00287","start_s":581.187,"end_s":581.407,"video_s":2441.187,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00086","chapter":"C002","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00288","start_s":581.788,"end_s":582.309,"video_s":2441.788,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00086","chapter":"C002","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00289","start_s":582.609,"end_s":583.25,"video_s":2442.609,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00087","chapter":"C002","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00290","start_s":583.27,"end_s":583.63,"video_s":2443.27,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00088","chapter":"C002","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00291","start_s":584.071,"end_s":584.351,"video_s":2444.071,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00088","chapter":"C002","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00292","start_s":584.832,"end_s":585.172,"video_s":2444.832,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00088","chapter":"C002","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00293","start_s":585.953,"end_s":586.694,"video_s":2445.953,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00088","chapter":"C002","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00294","start_s":586.915,"end_s":587.595,"video_s":2446.915,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00088","chapter":"C002","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00295","start_s":587.615,"end_s":587.936,"video_s":2447.615,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00088","chapter":"C002","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00296","start_s":588.256,"end_s":588.477,"video_s":2448.256,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00088","chapter":"C002","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00297","start_s":588.817,"end_s":589.678,"video_s":2448.817,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00088","chapter":"C002","text":"Passes 9-0.","fingerprint":"f7c37e75fd84","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00298","start_s":590.459,"end_s":593.643,"video_s":2450.459,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00089","chapter":"C002","text":"City Clerk, are we ready for Ordinances Resolution, New Business Planning and Zoning?","fingerprint":"1092ab6f73b0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00299","start_s":594.004,"end_s":594.444,"video_s":2454.004,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00090","chapter":"C002","text":"Yes, Mayor.","fingerprint":"f16b9e8eb094","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00300","start_s":595.105,"end_s":596.066,"video_s":2455.105,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00091","chapter":"C002","text":"Vice Mayor, do we have a motion?","fingerprint":"fb76ba8f4bfa","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00301","start_s":596.287,"end_s":600.833,"video_s":2456.287,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00092","chapter":"C003","text":"Motion to approve items 23 through 154, except for the following.","fingerprint":"e0f73e48dadc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00302","start_s":601.273,"end_s":605.779,"video_s":2461.273,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00092","chapter":"C003","text":"Items 44 through 51, 54, 59, 60...","fingerprint":"5459f07f1309","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00303","start_s":606.417,"end_s":615.973,"video_s":2466.417,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00092","chapter":"C003","text":"89, 95, 101, 106, 111, 124, 128, 129, 135, and 152.","fingerprint":"301c3591aee8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00304","start_s":616.234,"end_s":630.518,"video_s":2476.234,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00092","chapter":"C003","text":"Noting that items 53 and 65 are as revised, item 96 is withdrawn, item 154 is an add-on item, and can the clerk confirm if there are any other items that should be excluded for in-person public comment?","fingerprint":"1c7b56330295","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00305","start_s":631.105,"end_s":632.226,"video_s":2491.105,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00093","chapter":"C003","text":"Yes, Mayor, Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"03d669af740a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00306","start_s":632.347,"end_s":638.214,"video_s":2492.347,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00093","chapter":"C003","text":"Also items 80, 81, 133, and 153.","fingerprint":"eba7a950a092","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00307","start_s":638.574,"end_s":644.081,"video_s":2498.574,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00093","chapter":"C003","text":"That's items 80, 81, 133, and 153.","fingerprint":"d4bd8c2d0c80","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00308","start_s":644.562,"end_s":644.922,"video_s":2504.562,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00093","chapter":"C003","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00309","start_s":647.365,"end_s":649.087,"video_s":2507.365,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00093","chapter":"C003","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00310","start_s":649.107,"end_s":649.668,"video_s":2509.107,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00093","chapter":"C003","text":"Guardado?","fingerprint":"0344b48c3f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00311","start_s":649.688,"end_s":649.948,"video_s":2509.688,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00093","chapter":"C003","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00312","start_s":650.749,"end_s":651.35,"video_s":2510.749,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00093","chapter":"C003","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00313","start_s":651.37,"end_s":652.211,"video_s":2511.37,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00093","chapter":"C003","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00314","start_s":652.231,"end_s":652.672,"video_s":2512.231,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00093","chapter":"C003","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00315","start_s":652.832,"end_s":653.713,"video_s":2512.832,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00093","chapter":"C003","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00316","start_s":653.733,"end_s":654.214,"video_s":2513.733,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00093","chapter":"C003","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00317","start_s":654.514,"end_s":655.475,"video_s":2514.514,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00093","chapter":"C003","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00318","start_s":655.495,"end_s":656.016,"video_s":2515.495,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00093","chapter":"C003","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00319","start_s":656.276,"end_s":657.137,"video_s":2516.276,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00093","chapter":"C003","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00320","start_s":657.157,"end_s":657.518,"video_s":2517.157,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00093","chapter":"C003","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00321","start_s":657.958,"end_s":658.759,"video_s":2517.958,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00093","chapter":"C003","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00322","start_s":658.779,"end_s":659.24,"video_s":2518.779,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00093","chapter":"C003","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00323","start_s":659.26,"end_s":659.34,"video_s":2519.26,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00093","chapter":"C003","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00324","start_s":663.252,"end_s":663.933,"video_s":2523.252,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00093","chapter":"C003","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00325","start_s":664.153,"end_s":664.414,"video_s":2524.153,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00093","chapter":"C003","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00326","start_s":664.854,"end_s":665.295,"video_s":2524.854,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00093","chapter":"C003","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00327","start_s":665.756,"end_s":665.976,"video_s":2525.756,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00094","chapter":"C003","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00328","start_s":666.397,"end_s":667.258,"video_s":2526.397,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00094","chapter":"C003","text":"Passes 8-0.","fingerprint":"f9a0ca3f6107","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00329","start_s":669.682,"end_s":670.483,"video_s":2529.682,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00094","chapter":"C003","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00330","start_s":671.264,"end_s":675.17,"video_s":2531.264,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00094","chapter":"C003","text":"Now we go to the budget portion of our city council meeting.","fingerprint":"1aa0f92c7581","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00331","start_s":675.51,"end_s":679.897,"video_s":2535.51,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00094","chapter":"C003","text":"The city council has months of hearings on this and then votes three times.","fingerprint":"4f10231d0941","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00332","start_s":679.937,"end_s":682.881,"video_s":2539.937,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00094","chapter":"C003","text":"This is the third, so final vote.","fingerprint":"bd60b4dffbd0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00333","start_s":683.502,"end_s":695.034,"video_s":2543.502,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00095","chapter":"C004","text":"We'll begin with item 44, which is a public hearing on the adoption of the proposed property tax levy, truth in taxation and adoption of the final 2026-2027 annual budget.","fingerprint":"7500065da7cb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00334","start_s":696.856,"end_s":697.958,"video_s":2556.856,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00095","chapter":"C004","text":"Declare the hearing open.","fingerprint":"c8aa4750890f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00335","start_s":699.139,"end_s":700.24,"video_s":2559.139,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00095","chapter":"C004","text":"Are there any comments?","fingerprint":"0cebb137ad47","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00336","start_s":702.182,"end_s":703.484,"video_s":2562.182,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00095","chapter":"C004","text":"Do not have any comments on this.","fingerprint":"639256bcfd6e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00337","start_s":704.244,"end_s":706.607,"video_s":2564.244,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00095","chapter":"C004","text":"So I will close the public hearing.","fingerprint":"ed456dfb3470","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00338","start_s":707.313,"end_s":714.103,"video_s":2567.313,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00095","chapter":"C004","text":"and I want to thank the thousands of people who participated in our budget and the many hearings we've been having for months.","fingerprint":"4d51486ced7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00339","start_s":714.684,"end_s":720.993,"video_s":2574.684,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00095","chapter":"C004","text":"Item 44 is a convening of a special meeting of the Phoenix City Council to consider the adoption of the 26-27 budget.","fingerprint":"a313a3507dc7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00340","start_s":721.053,"end_s":721.574,"video_s":2581.053,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00095","chapter":"C004","text":"Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"9a95bf6095c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00341","start_s":723.437,"end_s":732.37,"video_s":2583.437,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00096","chapter":"C004","text":"Mayor, in accordance with state statute, I move that the regular meeting of the City Council be recessed and the City Council convene a special meeting to consider adoption of the budget.","fingerprint":"234916abb80a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00342","start_s":732.81,"end_s":733.371,"video_s":2592.81,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00096","chapter":"C004","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00343","start_s":734.988,"end_s":736.03,"video_s":2594.988,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00097","chapter":"C004","text":"I have a motion and a second.","fingerprint":"fefb382e214a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00344","start_s":736.11,"end_s":736.791,"video_s":2596.11,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00097","chapter":"C004","text":"Any discussion?","fingerprint":"b8f5fff823de","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00345","start_s":737.692,"end_s":738.934,"video_s":2597.692,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00097","chapter":"C004","text":"All those in favor, please say aye.","fingerprint":"80a7b6856cc0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00346","start_s":739.556,"end_s":739.676,"video_s":2599.556,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00097","chapter":"C004","text":"Aye.","fingerprint":"4707c4fdc04e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00347","start_s":741.018,"end_s":741.739,"video_s":2601.018,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00097","chapter":"C004","text":"Any opposed nay?","fingerprint":"f7daaedf3626","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00348","start_s":743.402,"end_s":747.469,"video_s":2603.402,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00098","chapter":"C005","text":"Item 46 is the adoption of the final 26-27 operating funds budget.","fingerprint":"88e0a76f974e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00349","start_s":748.13,"end_s":748.57,"video_s":2608.13,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00098","chapter":"C005","text":"Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"9a95bf6095c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00350","start_s":748.991,"end_s":758.687,"video_s":2608.991,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00099","chapter":"C005","text":"Mayor, I move that item 46 be in ordinance S-52969, the final 2026-27 operating funds budget be adopted.","fingerprint":"1e8ec5b3b1c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00351","start_s":758.727,"end_s":759.308,"video_s":2618.727,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00099","chapter":"C005","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00352","start_s":760.3,"end_s":761.986,"video_s":2620.3,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00100","chapter":"C005","text":"We have a motion and a second.","fingerprint":"7451ba811637","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00353","start_s":763.19,"end_s":765.598,"video_s":2623.19,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00100","chapter":"C005","text":"Do we have any council questions or comments?","fingerprint":"6109386bbeca","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00354","start_s":766.421,"end_s":767.745,"video_s":2626.421,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00100","chapter":"C005","text":"Councilman Waring, no?","fingerprint":"64aabcae01e8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00355","start_s":770.054,"end_s":771.156,"video_s":2630.054,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00101","chapter":"C005","text":"Sorry, I apologize.","fingerprint":"b45803d4c7b3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00356","start_s":771.196,"end_s":774.283,"video_s":2631.196,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00101","chapter":"C005","text":"Yes, I did have a couple questions for Ed.","fingerprint":"7081b3cea764","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00357","start_s":774.403,"end_s":777.349,"video_s":2634.403,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00101","chapter":"C005","text":"First, I am supportive of this budget.","fingerprint":"89ef82901413","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00358","start_s":777.53,"end_s":790.898,"video_s":2637.53,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00101","chapter":"C005","text":"This will help to explain why in 2008, 2009, the inflation adjusted, I just want to check these numbers are correct, per capita spending per citizen was $1,268.","fingerprint":"0d97ae63c7d4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00359","start_s":791.08,"end_s":798.776,"video_s":2651.08,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00101","chapter":"C005","text":"In this budget, the 2026-2027 budget, the per capita spending per citizen is only $1,222.","fingerprint":"4a5cbd3cf818","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00360","start_s":798.856,"end_s":806.232,"video_s":2658.856,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00101","chapter":"C005","text":"Over almost 20 years, the per capita expenditure when you adjust for inflation has actually gone down.","fingerprint":"9bb10fb19576","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00361","start_s":806.572,"end_s":807.334,"video_s":2666.572,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00101","chapter":"C005","text":"Is that correct?","fingerprint":"bad86010d563","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00362","start_s":807.787,"end_s":810.412,"video_s":2667.787,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00102","chapter":"C005","text":"Councilman Waring, that has been a conversation we've had.","fingerprint":"7a6a8099c5c4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00363","start_s":810.432,"end_s":814.399,"video_s":2670.432,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00102","chapter":"C005","text":"I'm looking at Aaron, and he is nodding because he has done the math.","fingerprint":"784332acc42a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00364","start_s":814.419,"end_s":815.28,"video_s":2674.419,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00102","chapter":"C005","text":"That is correct.","fingerprint":"a388af4f4e99","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00365","start_s":815.34,"end_s":823.635,"video_s":2675.34,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00102","chapter":"C005","text":"When you adjusted for inflation from our high water mark in 2008 before the Great Recession to now, your numbers are correct.","fingerprint":"a8529287fca5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00366","start_s":823.615,"end_s":824.516,"video_s":2683.615,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00103","chapter":"C005","text":"OK, thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"4bfa0064eebf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00367","start_s":824.536,"end_s":829.523,"video_s":2684.536,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00103","chapter":"C005","text":"I just want to point out, obviously, you were city manager for a lot of that time, but you obviously had a lot of staffers helping and so forth.","fingerprint":"ca02cf2e7f84","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00368","start_s":829.543,"end_s":838.115,"video_s":2689.543,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00103","chapter":"C005","text":"I just want to say, as a fiscal conservative and someone who lives in Phoenix, I appreciate the fact that spending per citizen has actually declined.","fingerprint":"03090256b119","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00369","start_s":838.796,"end_s":851.935,"video_s":2698.796,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00103","chapter":"C005","text":"The number of employees, because of our use of technology and so forth, the deployment of different new technologies that didn't exist in 2007 and 2008, we actually have, what, like 3,000 fewer employees.","fingerprint":"76509ad85b26","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00370","start_s":851.915,"end_s":876.1,"video_s":2711.915,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00103","chapter":"C005","text":"but I wanted to get to that as a percentage of the budget in 2007-2008 and I picked that because that is the kind of the high watermark in some ways of city spending then the great recession happened and things changed 59 of the general fund operating budget was for public safety but in this budget it's 63 so not only has spending per capita gone down","fingerprint":"512a95bbd943","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00371","start_s":876.08,"end_s":881.205,"video_s":2736.08,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00103","chapter":"C005","text":"But the percentage spent on public safety of the whole budget has gone up.","fingerprint":"527046035545","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00372","start_s":881.446,"end_s":882.287,"video_s":2741.446,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00103","chapter":"C005","text":"Is that a correct statement?","fingerprint":"1d1f7ceb9677","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00373","start_s":883.087,"end_s":888.633,"video_s":2743.087,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00104","chapter":"C005","text":"I believe that's correct when we're talking about the general funds budget, yes, which is what this vote is about.","fingerprint":"9c3c8dfe2ba5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00374","start_s":889.274,"end_s":900.966,"video_s":2749.274,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00104","chapter":"C005","text":"That's attributed to a couple things, which is the council has expanded the fire department in the last several years to meet growing demand, as well as the pension costs for police and fire.","fingerprint":"9db0ceb74b12","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00375","start_s":901.306,"end_s":905.631,"video_s":2761.306,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00104","chapter":"C005","text":"But yes, I think from our conversation, those numbers sound to me to be correct.","fingerprint":"c1df24c31690","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00376","start_s":905.611,"end_s":908.114,"video_s":2765.611,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00105","chapter":"C005","text":"and a number of full-time FTEs.","fingerprint":"9002121c054e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00377","start_s":908.975,"end_s":914.623,"video_s":2768.975,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00105","chapter":"C005","text":"In 2007, 2008, 38% of the workforce was police and fire.","fingerprint":"38f2a5793c00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00378","start_s":915.243,"end_s":918.988,"video_s":2775.243,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00105","chapter":"C005","text":"With this budget, it's 44%, according to the charts you provided.","fingerprint":"75a0658c44d4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00379","start_s":919.088,"end_s":926.438,"video_s":2779.088,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00105","chapter":"C005","text":"So the percentage of people who work for the city, it's more concentrated in police and fire than it was in the past.","fingerprint":"1b91371bf65d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00380","start_s":927.16,"end_s":956.83,"video_s":2787.16,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00106","chapter":"C005","text":"correct that would be a higher percentage again the expansion that the council has done with our fire department to meet growing demand for emergency services and also increase in civilian positions in the police department account for that but our public safety percentage of employment has gone up and this is the high water mark as you look at the charts year over year 44 is the high water mark so again just those are a couple things I wanted to point out I thought some citizens might be interested in that and I appreciate your efforts Ed thank you","fingerprint":"18b65dcace41","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00381","start_s":959.898,"end_s":960.579,"video_s":2819.898,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00107","chapter":"C005","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00382","start_s":961.42,"end_s":961.84,"video_s":2821.42,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C005","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00383","start_s":962.601,"end_s":963.061,"video_s":2822.601,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C005","text":"Guardado.","fingerprint":"0344b48c3f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00384","start_s":963.542,"end_s":964.243,"video_s":2823.542,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C005","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00385","start_s":964.263,"end_s":964.643,"video_s":2824.263,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C005","text":"Hernandez.","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00386","start_s":964.883,"end_s":965.103,"video_s":2824.883,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C005","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00387","start_s":965.584,"end_s":966.024,"video_s":2825.584,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C005","text":"O'Brien.","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00388","start_s":966.145,"end_s":966.865,"video_s":2826.145,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C005","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00389","start_s":966.885,"end_s":967.346,"video_s":2826.885,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C005","text":"Pastor.","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00390","start_s":967.686,"end_s":968.407,"video_s":2827.686,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C005","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00391","start_s":968.427,"end_s":968.948,"video_s":2828.427,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C005","text":"Robinson.","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00392","start_s":969.088,"end_s":969.348,"video_s":2829.088,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C005","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00393","start_s":969.869,"end_s":970.209,"video_s":2829.869,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C005","text":"Stark.","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00394","start_s":970.549,"end_s":971.45,"video_s":2830.549,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C005","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00395","start_s":971.47,"end_s":971.811,"video_s":2831.47,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C005","text":"Waring.","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00396","start_s":972.691,"end_s":972.772,"video_s":2832.691,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C005","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00397","start_s":972.792,"end_s":973.432,"video_s":2832.792,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C005","text":"Hodge Washington.","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00398","start_s":973.552,"end_s":973.793,"video_s":2833.552,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C005","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00399","start_s":974.233,"end_s":974.874,"video_s":2834.233,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C005","text":"Gallego.","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00400","start_s":974.894,"end_s":975.474,"video_s":2834.894,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C005","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00401","start_s":975.494,"end_s":976.035,"video_s":2835.494,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C005","text":"Passes 9-0.","fingerprint":"f7c37e75fd84","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00402","start_s":976.856,"end_s":980.92,"video_s":2836.856,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00109","chapter":"C006","text":"Item 47 is the adoption of the final 26-27 capital funds budget.","fingerprint":"362edf1d2fae","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00403","start_s":980.96,"end_s":981.401,"video_s":2840.96,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00109","chapter":"C006","text":"Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"9a95bf6095c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00404","start_s":981.921,"end_s":987.407,"video_s":2841.921,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00110","chapter":"C006","text":"Mayor, I move that item 47 be in ordinance S-53015,","fingerprint":"719e9dfcbed0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00405","start_s":987.758,"end_s":992.871,"video_s":2847.758,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00110","chapter":"C006","text":"The final 2026-2027 capital fund budget be adopted.","fingerprint":"8821246a1375","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00406","start_s":993.151,"end_s":993.492,"video_s":2853.151,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00111","chapter":"C006","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00407","start_s":994.735,"end_s":995.377,"video_s":2854.735,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00111","chapter":"C006","text":"Any comments?","fingerprint":"9cdeefcc2f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00408","start_s":995.898,"end_s":997.562,"video_s":2855.898,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00111","chapter":"C006","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00409","start_s":997.582,"end_s":998.043,"video_s":2857.582,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00111","chapter":"C006","text":"Guardado?","fingerprint":"0344b48c3f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00410","start_s":998.304,"end_s":999.006,"video_s":2858.304,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00111","chapter":"C006","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00411","start_s":999.026,"end_s":999.607,"video_s":2859.026,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00111","chapter":"C006","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00412","start_s":999.627,"end_s":1000.249,"video_s":2859.627,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00111","chapter":"C006","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00413","start_s":1000.269,"end_s":1000.67,"video_s":2860.269,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00111","chapter":"C006","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00414","start_s":1000.79,"end_s":1001.371,"video_s":2860.79,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00111","chapter":"C006","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00415","start_s":1001.392,"end_s":1001.853,"video_s":2861.392,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00111","chapter":"C006","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00416","start_s":1002.053,"end_s":1002.695,"video_s":2862.053,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00111","chapter":"C006","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00417","start_s":1002.715,"end_s":1003.236,"video_s":2862.715,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00111","chapter":"C006","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00418","start_s":1003.557,"end_s":1003.838,"video_s":2863.557,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00112","chapter":"C006","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00419","start_s":1004.319,"end_s":1004.66,"video_s":2864.319,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00113","chapter":"C006","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00420","start_s":1004.92,"end_s":1005.261,"video_s":2864.92,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00113","chapter":"C006","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00421","start_s":1005.511,"end_s":1007.294,"video_s":2865.511,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00113","chapter":"C006","text":"Waring, Hodge Washington.","fingerprint":"df7a73d085ed","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00422","start_s":1007.534,"end_s":1008.196,"video_s":2867.534,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00113","chapter":"C006","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00423","start_s":1008.216,"end_s":1008.676,"video_s":2868.216,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00113","chapter":"C006","text":"Gallego.","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00424","start_s":1008.877,"end_s":1009.498,"video_s":2868.877,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00114","chapter":"C006","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00425","start_s":1009.518,"end_s":1009.999,"video_s":2869.518,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00115","chapter":"C006","text":"Passes 9-0.","fingerprint":"f7c37e75fd84","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00426","start_s":1010.119,"end_s":1015.388,"video_s":2870.119,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00116","chapter":"C007","text":"Item 48 is the adoption of the final 2026-27 reappropriated funds budget.","fingerprint":"1937a4bfd4fa","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00427","start_s":1015.468,"end_s":1015.869,"video_s":2875.468,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00116","chapter":"C007","text":"Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"9a95bf6095c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00428","start_s":1016.209,"end_s":1026.387,"video_s":2876.209,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00117","chapter":"C007","text":"Mayor, I move that item 48 be in ordinance S-52970, the final 2026-27 reapportioned funds budget be adopted.","fingerprint":"33107debb788","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00429","start_s":1026.647,"end_s":1026.787,"video_s":2886.647,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00117","chapter":"C007","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00430","start_s":1026.807,"end_s":1027.148,"video_s":2886.807,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00117","chapter":"C007","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00431","start_s":1028.191,"end_s":1029.232,"video_s":2888.191,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00118","chapter":"C007","text":"We have a motion and a second.","fingerprint":"7451ba811637","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00432","start_s":1029.292,"end_s":1030.253,"video_s":2889.292,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00118","chapter":"C007","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00433","start_s":1030.274,"end_s":1030.754,"video_s":2890.274,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00119","chapter":"C007","text":"Guardado?","fingerprint":"0344b48c3f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00434","start_s":1031.014,"end_s":1031.655,"video_s":2891.014,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00119","chapter":"C007","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00435","start_s":1031.675,"end_s":1032.316,"video_s":2891.675,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00119","chapter":"C007","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00436","start_s":1032.336,"end_s":1032.997,"video_s":2892.336,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00119","chapter":"C007","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00437","start_s":1033.017,"end_s":1033.577,"video_s":2893.017,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00119","chapter":"C007","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00438","start_s":1033.598,"end_s":1033.818,"video_s":2893.598,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00119","chapter":"C007","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00439","start_s":1034.278,"end_s":1034.719,"video_s":2894.278,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00119","chapter":"C007","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00440","start_s":1035.64,"end_s":1036.441,"video_s":2895.64,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00119","chapter":"C007","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00441","start_s":1036.461,"end_s":1036.982,"video_s":2896.461,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00119","chapter":"C007","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00442","start_s":1037.182,"end_s":1037.442,"video_s":2897.182,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00119","chapter":"C007","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00443","start_s":1037.923,"end_s":1038.263,"video_s":2897.923,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00119","chapter":"C007","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00444","start_s":1038.563,"end_s":1039.224,"video_s":2898.563,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00119","chapter":"C007","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00445","start_s":1039.244,"end_s":1040.446,"video_s":2899.244,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00119","chapter":"C007","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00446","start_s":1040.466,"end_s":1040.546,"video_s":2900.466,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00119","chapter":"C007","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00447","start_s":1040.566,"end_s":1041.247,"video_s":2900.566,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00119","chapter":"C007","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00448","start_s":1041.988,"end_s":1042.208,"video_s":2901.988,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00120","chapter":"C007","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00449","start_s":1042.668,"end_s":1043.509,"video_s":2902.668,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00121","chapter":"C007","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00450","start_s":1043.529,"end_s":1043.75,"video_s":2903.529,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00121","chapter":"C007","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00451","start_s":1044.15,"end_s":1044.931,"video_s":2904.15,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00121","chapter":"C007","text":"Passes 9-0.","fingerprint":"f7c37e75fd84","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00452","start_s":1046.093,"end_s":1047.014,"video_s":2906.093,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00122","chapter":"C007","text":"Vice Mayor?","fingerprint":"9a95bf6095c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00453","start_s":1047.034,"end_s":1049.777,"video_s":2907.034,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00122","chapter":"C007","text":"May I move the City Council adjourn the special meeting?","fingerprint":"478cf93fe554","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00454","start_s":1050.057,"end_s":1050.638,"video_s":2910.057,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00122","chapter":"C007","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00455","start_s":1051.732,"end_s":1052.753,"video_s":2911.732,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00123","chapter":"C007","text":"I have a motion and a second.","fingerprint":"fefb382e214a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00456","start_s":1052.873,"end_s":1053.534,"video_s":2912.873,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00123","chapter":"C007","text":"Any discussion?","fingerprint":"b8f5fff823de","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00457","start_s":1053.574,"end_s":1055.576,"video_s":2913.574,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00123","chapter":"C007","text":"All those in favor, please say aye.","fingerprint":"80a7b6856cc0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00458","start_s":1056.257,"end_s":1056.377,"video_s":2916.257,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00124","chapter":"C007","text":"Aye.","fingerprint":"4707c4fdc04e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00459","start_s":1056.898,"end_s":1057.459,"video_s":2916.898,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00125","chapter":"C007","text":"Any opposed?","fingerprint":"912fd592ea04","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00460","start_s":1057.959,"end_s":1059.241,"video_s":2917.959,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00125","chapter":"C007","text":"The special meeting is adjourned.","fingerprint":"a73ee09ef855","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00461","start_s":1059.361,"end_s":1064.727,"video_s":2919.361,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00125","chapter":"C007","text":"I hereby declare that the special meeting is concluded and I reconvene the regular city council meeting.","fingerprint":"73f6f5a4a99b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00462","start_s":1065.408,"end_s":1074.338,"video_s":2925.408,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00125","chapter":"C007","text":"And really remarkable, we are a very diverse city council, but we have come together to move forward unanimously on a budget and I hope our residents see some confidence in that.","fingerprint":"ef6bc73c7aea","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00463","start_s":1074.399,"end_s":1077.402,"video_s":2934.399,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00125","chapter":"C007","text":"A lot of diverse needs being met by this budget.","fingerprint":"4df40661ca0e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00464","start_s":1077.382,"end_s":1090.562,"video_s":2937.382,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00125","chapter":"C007","text":"Items 49, 50, and 51 are legally required amendments to the current 25-26 operating capital and reappropriated funds budget, allowing the city to close out the current fiscal year budgetary accounts and proceed with the annual independent audit.","fingerprint":"d55a16c66ef2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00465","start_s":1091.163,"end_s":1098.534,"video_s":2951.163,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00126","chapter":"C008","text":"Item 49 amends the 25-26 annual operating funds budget to authorize reallocating appropriations.","fingerprint":"12702be0ba97","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00466","start_s":1098.915,"end_s":1099.335,"video_s":2958.915,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00126","chapter":"C008","text":"Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"9a95bf6095c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00467","start_s":1099.816,"end_s":1104.503,"video_s":2959.816,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00127","chapter":"C008","text":"Mayor, I move that item 49 be in ordinance S-52967,","fingerprint":"8805926c98b2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00468","start_s":1104.483,"end_s":1110.598,"video_s":2964.483,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00127","chapter":"C008","text":"the required reallocation of the 2025-26 operating funds budget appropriations be adopted.","fingerprint":"102b8f588575","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00469","start_s":1110.658,"end_s":1111.16,"video_s":2970.658,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00127","chapter":"C008","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00470","start_s":1112.343,"end_s":1112.724,"video_s":2972.343,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00128","chapter":"C008","text":"Comments?","fingerprint":"2b4244fb2663","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00471","start_s":1113.365,"end_s":1114.328,"video_s":2973.365,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00129","chapter":"C008","text":"Will the clerk call the roll?","fingerprint":"89bb0df24607","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00472","start_s":1115.15,"end_s":1115.571,"video_s":2975.15,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00130","chapter":"C008","text":"Guardado?","fingerprint":"0344b48c3f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00473","start_s":1115.992,"end_s":1116.974,"video_s":2975.992,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00130","chapter":"C008","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00474","start_s":1116.994,"end_s":1117.596,"video_s":2976.994,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00130","chapter":"C008","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00475","start_s":1117.616,"end_s":1118.478,"video_s":2977.616,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00130","chapter":"C008","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00476","start_s":1118.498,"end_s":1118.959,"video_s":2978.498,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00130","chapter":"C008","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00477","start_s":1119.099,"end_s":1119.741,"video_s":2979.099,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00130","chapter":"C008","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00478","start_s":1119.974,"end_s":1120.535,"video_s":2979.974,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00130","chapter":"C008","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00479","start_s":1121.536,"end_s":1121.776,"video_s":2981.536,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00130","chapter":"C008","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00480","start_s":1122.657,"end_s":1123.158,"video_s":2982.657,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00130","chapter":"C008","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00481","start_s":1123.398,"end_s":1124.219,"video_s":2983.398,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00130","chapter":"C008","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00482","start_s":1124.239,"end_s":1124.599,"video_s":2984.239,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00130","chapter":"C008","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00483","start_s":1124.9,"end_s":1125.6,"video_s":2984.9,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00130","chapter":"C008","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00484","start_s":1125.62,"end_s":1125.981,"video_s":2985.62,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00130","chapter":"C008","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00485","start_s":1126.922,"end_s":1127.002,"video_s":2986.922,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00130","chapter":"C008","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00486","start_s":1127.022,"end_s":1127.683,"video_s":2987.022,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00130","chapter":"C008","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00487","start_s":1128.404,"end_s":1129.224,"video_s":2988.404,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00131","chapter":"C008","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00488","start_s":1129.245,"end_s":1129.725,"video_s":2989.245,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00132","chapter":"C008","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00489","start_s":1130.045,"end_s":1130.266,"video_s":2990.045,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00133","chapter":"C008","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00490","start_s":1130.626,"end_s":1131.187,"video_s":2990.626,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00134","chapter":"C008","text":"Passes 9-0.","fingerprint":"f7c37e75fd84","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00491","start_s":1132.188,"end_s":1137.994,"video_s":2992.188,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00135","chapter":"C009","text":"Item 50 amends the 2526 annual capital funds budget to authorize reallocating appropriations.","fingerprint":"867fb187f578","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00492","start_s":1138.255,"end_s":1138.595,"video_s":2998.255,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00135","chapter":"C009","text":"Vice Mayor?","fingerprint":"9a95bf6095c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00493","start_s":1139.076,"end_s":1144.682,"video_s":2999.076,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00136","chapter":"C009","text":"Mayor, I move that item 50 be an ordinance S53016, the required reallocation","fingerprint":"e76ad985410c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00494","start_s":1144.932,"end_s":1149.3,"video_s":3004.932,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00136","chapter":"C009","text":"of the 2025-26 capital funds budget appropriations be adopted.","fingerprint":"3cf31f538a6d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00495","start_s":1149.34,"end_s":1149.881,"video_s":3009.34,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00136","chapter":"C009","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00496","start_s":1150.562,"end_s":1151.484,"video_s":3010.562,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00136","chapter":"C009","text":"Will the clerk call the roll?","fingerprint":"89bb0df24607","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00497","start_s":1152.766,"end_s":1153.227,"video_s":3012.766,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00137","chapter":"C009","text":"Guardado?","fingerprint":"0344b48c3f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00498","start_s":1153.488,"end_s":1154.249,"video_s":3013.488,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00137","chapter":"C009","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00499","start_s":1154.269,"end_s":1154.71,"video_s":3014.269,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00137","chapter":"C009","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00500","start_s":1154.89,"end_s":1155.572,"video_s":3014.89,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00137","chapter":"C009","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00501","start_s":1155.592,"end_s":1156.072,"video_s":3015.592,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00137","chapter":"C009","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00502","start_s":1156.213,"end_s":1156.473,"video_s":3016.213,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00137","chapter":"C009","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00503","start_s":1156.974,"end_s":1157.415,"video_s":3016.974,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00137","chapter":"C009","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00504","start_s":1157.575,"end_s":1157.776,"video_s":3017.575,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00137","chapter":"C009","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00505","start_s":1158.337,"end_s":1158.817,"video_s":3018.337,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00137","chapter":"C009","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00506","start_s":1159.038,"end_s":1159.258,"video_s":3019.038,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00138","chapter":"C009","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00507","start_s":1159.759,"end_s":1160.34,"video_s":3019.759,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00139","chapter":"C009","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00508","start_s":1160.36,"end_s":1161.322,"video_s":3020.36,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00139","chapter":"C009","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00509","start_s":1161.342,"end_s":1161.683,"video_s":3021.342,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00139","chapter":"C009","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00510","start_s":1162.604,"end_s":1162.685,"video_s":3022.604,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00139","chapter":"C009","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00511","start_s":1162.705,"end_s":1163.406,"video_s":3022.705,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00139","chapter":"C009","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00512","start_s":1163.506,"end_s":1164.147,"video_s":3023.506,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00139","chapter":"C009","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00513","start_s":1164.167,"end_s":1164.688,"video_s":3024.167,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00139","chapter":"C009","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00514","start_s":1164.969,"end_s":1165.209,"video_s":3024.969,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00140","chapter":"C009","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00515","start_s":1165.77,"end_s":1166.772,"video_s":3025.77,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00141","chapter":"C009","text":"Passes 9-0.","fingerprint":"f7c37e75fd84","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00516","start_s":1168.102,"end_s":1174.589,"video_s":3028.102,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00142","chapter":"C010","text":"Item 51 amends the 25-26 annual reappropriation funds budget to authorize reallocating appropriations.","fingerprint":"9f51e4b9d3e4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00517","start_s":1174.629,"end_s":1175.069,"video_s":3034.629,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00142","chapter":"C010","text":"Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"9a95bf6095c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00518","start_s":1175.83,"end_s":1188.083,"video_s":3035.83,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00143","chapter":"C010","text":"Mayor, I move that item 51 be in ordinance S52968, the required reallocation of the 2025-26 reappropriation funds budget reappropriations be adopted.","fingerprint":"52dd2a967b25","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00519","start_s":1188.484,"end_s":1188.864,"video_s":3048.484,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00143","chapter":"C010","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00520","start_s":1189.645,"end_s":1190.045,"video_s":3049.645,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00143","chapter":"C010","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00521","start_s":1191.407,"end_s":1191.827,"video_s":3051.407,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00144","chapter":"C010","text":"Guardado?","fingerprint":"0344b48c3f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00522","start_s":1192.148,"end_s":1192.828,"video_s":3052.148,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00144","chapter":"C010","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00523","start_s":1192.848,"end_s":1193.289,"video_s":3052.848,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00144","chapter":"C010","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00524","start_s":1193.91,"end_s":1194.13,"video_s":3053.91,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00144","chapter":"C010","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00525","start_s":1194.65,"end_s":1195.091,"video_s":3054.65,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00144","chapter":"C010","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00526","start_s":1195.331,"end_s":1195.591,"video_s":3055.331,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00144","chapter":"C010","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00527","start_s":1196.152,"end_s":1196.592,"video_s":3056.152,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00144","chapter":"C010","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00528","start_s":1197.033,"end_s":1197.113,"video_s":3057.033,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00144","chapter":"C010","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00529","start_s":1197.65,"end_s":1198.211,"video_s":3057.65,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00144","chapter":"C010","text":"Robinson.","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00530","start_s":1198.431,"end_s":1198.671,"video_s":3058.431,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00145","chapter":"C010","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00531","start_s":1199.172,"end_s":1199.532,"video_s":3059.172,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00146","chapter":"C010","text":"Stark.","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00532","start_s":1200.594,"end_s":1200.714,"video_s":3060.594,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00146","chapter":"C010","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00533","start_s":1200.734,"end_s":1201.014,"video_s":3060.734,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00146","chapter":"C010","text":"Waring.","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00534","start_s":1201.855,"end_s":1201.935,"video_s":3061.855,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00146","chapter":"C010","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00535","start_s":1201.955,"end_s":1202.656,"video_s":3061.955,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00146","chapter":"C010","text":"Hodge Washington.","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00536","start_s":1202.816,"end_s":1203.057,"video_s":3062.816,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00146","chapter":"C010","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00537","start_s":1203.477,"end_s":1203.958,"video_s":3063.477,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00146","chapter":"C010","text":"Gallego.","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00538","start_s":1204.458,"end_s":1204.679,"video_s":3064.458,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00147","chapter":"C010","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00539","start_s":1205.099,"end_s":1206.08,"video_s":3065.099,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00148","chapter":"C010","text":"Passes nine zero.","fingerprint":"4028571107a8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00540","start_s":1206.861,"end_s":1207.222,"video_s":3066.861,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00149","chapter":"C010","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00541","start_s":1207.242,"end_s":1210.626,"video_s":3067.242,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00149","chapter":"C010","text":"That concludes our budget process for today.","fingerprint":"2a83459f46aa","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00542","start_s":1210.686,"end_s":1218.296,"video_s":3070.686,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00149","chapter":"C010","text":"We will be back on the first meeting in July and we'll have a property tax related vote where the property tax will be notching downward a bit.","fingerprint":"8aea73143f11","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00543","start_s":1219.657,"end_s":1221.78,"video_s":3079.657,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00150","chapter":"C011","text":"We next go to item 54.","fingerprint":"9f4b5a81da6d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00544","start_s":1222.1,"end_s":1223.522,"video_s":3082.1,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00150","chapter":"C011","text":"Will the city clerk read the title?","fingerprint":"45e2bea4735e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00545","start_s":1224.464,"end_s":1234.98,"video_s":3084.464,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00151","chapter":"C011","text":"Item 54 is for Ordinance G7524, an ordinance amending Chapter 8, Article 1, Phoenix City Code Section 8-3.08, relating to the unlawful restraint of a dog.","fingerprint":"2ca05d364c32","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00546","start_s":1236.817,"end_s":1237.238,"video_s":3096.817,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00152","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00547","start_s":1237.398,"end_s":1238.54,"video_s":3097.398,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00152","chapter":"C011","text":"Vice Mayor, do we have a motion?","fingerprint":"fb76ba8f4bfa","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00548","start_s":1239.061,"end_s":1240.804,"video_s":3099.061,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00153","chapter":"C011","text":"Motion to approve item 54.","fingerprint":"3c226eabfa24","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00549","start_s":1241.445,"end_s":1241.805,"video_s":3101.445,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00153","chapter":"C011","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00550","start_s":1242.226,"end_s":1243.228,"video_s":3102.226,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00154","chapter":"C011","text":"We have a motion and a second.","fingerprint":"7451ba811637","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00551","start_s":1243.268,"end_s":1246.613,"video_s":3103.268,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00154","chapter":"C011","text":"I know a lot of council members have been working on this, but maybe we'll start.","fingerprint":"c2615c452dd0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00552","start_s":1246.894,"end_s":1250.36,"video_s":3106.894,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00154","chapter":"C011","text":"We have nine members of the public here to testify.","fingerprint":"47e55263063f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00553","start_s":1250.4,"end_s":1255.328,"video_s":3110.4,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00154","chapter":"C011","text":"We will begin with Coco Garcia, followed by Don Bentley.","fingerprint":"5f0634545362","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00554","start_s":1258.033,"end_s":1261.238,"video_s":3118.033,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00154","chapter":"C011","text":"Thanks to members of the public who've been working on this with us.","fingerprint":"df14ab3e2e82","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00555","start_s":1267.816,"end_s":1268.958,"video_s":3127.816,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00155","chapter":"C011","text":"Hello, council members.","fingerprint":"e0641b245c08","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00556","start_s":1270.52,"end_s":1271.642,"video_s":3130.52,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00156","chapter":"C011","text":"My name is Coco Garcia.","fingerprint":"f033fce3f9bc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00557","start_s":1271.702,"end_s":1273.404,"video_s":3131.702,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00156","chapter":"C011","text":"I'm the founder of Handover Rover.","fingerprint":"2436a67deae9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00558","start_s":1273.444,"end_s":1276.369,"video_s":3133.444,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00156","chapter":"C011","text":"We're a small rescue here in the Phoenix, Scottsdale area.","fingerprint":"444cb2c9ee53","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00559","start_s":1276.91,"end_s":1283.82,"video_s":3136.91,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00156","chapter":"C011","text":"We spend a tremendous amount of time, money, and resources negotiating animals off tiebacks when we learn that this is how they live.","fingerprint":"d392bbcfe36b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00560","start_s":1283.88,"end_s":1286.584,"video_s":3143.88,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00156","chapter":"C011","text":"The suffering that takes place","fingerprint":"479b7c8c4b30","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00561","start_s":1286.564,"end_s":1289.468,"video_s":3146.564,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00156","chapter":"C011","text":"In the desert heat is just too much to look away from.","fingerprint":"ff768c33683a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00562","start_s":1289.528,"end_s":1296.116,"video_s":3149.528,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00156","chapter":"C011","text":"Last winter, we worked on a case that involved a female doodle living on a rope with one of her puppies and a 3x3 cage.","fingerprint":"4901cc612186","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00563","start_s":1296.697,"end_s":1301.423,"video_s":3156.697,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00156","chapter":"C011","text":"There was also a tiny chihuahua that was attached to the doodle, so they were both on the same rope.","fingerprint":"917ad45edb1b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00564","start_s":1302.224,"end_s":1307.971,"video_s":3162.224,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00156","chapter":"C011","text":"Poverty's pets had already been met with hostility, so I knocked on the door to see if I could possibly hit them with a different angle.","fingerprint":"9593ad0cf707","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00565","start_s":1308.551,"end_s":1309.312,"video_s":3168.551,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00156","chapter":"C011","text":"I was pretty nervous.","fingerprint":"625ac5b811fc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00566","start_s":1309.372,"end_s":1311.475,"video_s":3169.372,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00156","chapter":"C011","text":"I don't like confrontation.","fingerprint":"59fd6814cb4d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00567","start_s":1311.455,"end_s":1315.801,"video_s":3171.455,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00156","chapter":"C011","text":"and to my surprise I was met with two young men 15 and 17 years old.","fingerprint":"6592df7ce41d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00568","start_s":1315.921,"end_s":1321.669,"video_s":3175.921,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00156","chapter":"C011","text":"They were the primary caretakers and had no problem spilling the tea and letting me know that they breed these dogs for money.","fingerprint":"df61155daa4d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00569","start_s":1322.189,"end_s":1327.136,"video_s":3182.189,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00156","chapter":"C011","text":"It's an easy profit and their parents drive them to the places where puppies were likely to get sold.","fingerprint":"2b8b7a1beb6c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00570","start_s":1327.957,"end_s":1331.041,"video_s":3187.957,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00156","chapter":"C011","text":"These animals lived on three feet of tangled ropes permanently.","fingerprint":"7fd7fb84ef63","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00571","start_s":1331.282,"end_s":1332.664,"video_s":3191.282,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00156","chapter":"C011","text":"They couldn't reach their food or water.","fingerprint":"bd564388f290","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00572","start_s":1332.724,"end_s":1336.669,"video_s":3192.724,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00156","chapter":"C011","text":"We got involved in the winter but this had been going on for well over a year.","fingerprint":"413c9b78d4b1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00573","start_s":1337.527,"end_s":1347.924,"video_s":3197.527,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00156","chapter":"C011","text":"It took us about three weeks of driving an hour back and forth before we were finally able to win over the trust of these young men and get them to agree to rehome these dogs to us and to Poverty's Pets.","fingerprint":"9c720b103341","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00574","start_s":1348.705,"end_s":1352.451,"video_s":3208.705,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00156","chapter":"C011","text":"It was a lot of money, a lot of time, a lot of resources that we put into one case.","fingerprint":"9001c1feca29","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00575","start_s":1353.433,"end_s":1357.099,"video_s":3213.433,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00156","chapter":"C011","text":"This is just one of several, several hundred that we have worked over the years.","fingerprint":"8d78cd810e0f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00576","start_s":1357.68,"end_s":1363.77,"video_s":3217.68,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00156","chapter":"C011","text":"Passing this ordinance today isn't just going to aid in the overpopulation because when people own these animals,","fingerprint":"982c4e3003a6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00577","start_s":1363.75,"end_s":1391.209,"video_s":3223.75,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00156","chapter":"C011","text":"and they have the option to put them on tie backs they will use them for breeding if that's what they're using them for but if that's not allowed they don't have the they're not going to put extra time and money into building and securing a fence so likely they just won't own them but this is also going to change how the future of our youth view these animals passing this law today is indirectly creating better humans we're hopeful that you guys agree thank you thank you so much","fingerprint":"c7e7f9364edf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00578","start_s":1391.999,"end_s":1394.262,"video_s":3251.999,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00157","chapter":"C011","text":"Don is next, followed by Barbara Brackett.","fingerprint":"8a2d7224872c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00579","start_s":1401.01,"end_s":1410.261,"video_s":3261.01,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00158","chapter":"C011","text":"Madam Mayor and members of the council, my name is Don Bentley and I'm here with Poverty's Pets to speak in favor of the proposed changes for the dog tethering ordinance.","fingerprint":"54160e00bb48","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00580","start_s":1411.362,"end_s":1415.307,"video_s":3271.362,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00158","chapter":"C011","text":"These proposed changes fix a major flaw in the current ordinance.","fingerprint":"a5a1c3feeaef","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00581","start_s":1416.012,"end_s":1425.465,"video_s":3276.012,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00158","chapter":"C011","text":"The city currently has a full ban on dog tethering during extreme weather conditions, which means essentially whenever the temperature is over 100 degrees.","fingerprint":"adbdda531827","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00582","start_s":1426.326,"end_s":1430.332,"video_s":3286.326,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00158","chapter":"C011","text":"But there's no ban at all when the temperature is under 100 degrees.","fingerprint":"87347fadbef7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00583","start_s":1431.113,"end_s":1435.759,"video_s":3291.113,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00158","chapter":"C011","text":"So tethering may be legal in the morning, but not legal in the afternoon.","fingerprint":"fe045580572c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00584","start_s":1436.667,"end_s":1443.674,"video_s":3296.667,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00158","chapter":"C011","text":"And tethering may become illegal at a different time each day, depending on when the temperature hits 100 degrees.","fingerprint":"e4c6cb3ebe64","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00585","start_s":1444.375,"end_s":1453.784,"video_s":3304.375,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00158","chapter":"C011","text":"So the current ordinance is confusing for citizens, and it's very difficult for police and cruelty investigators to enforce.","fingerprint":"f772fe5646db","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00586","start_s":1455.065,"end_s":1459.63,"video_s":3315.065,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00158","chapter":"C011","text":"Additionally, dog tethering results in a great deal of animal cruelty.","fingerprint":"0983dfccc120","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00587","start_s":1460.571,"end_s":1465.155,"video_s":3320.571,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00158","chapter":"C011","text":"Outside temperature is an important factor, but it's not the only one.","fingerprint":"d17c3ca71dab","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00588","start_s":1465.726,"end_s":1474.698,"video_s":3325.726,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00158","chapter":"C011","text":"Your proposed changes address the root problem and ban the practice entirely unless it's under direct supervision of the dog owner.","fingerprint":"4dc2ad83b97a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00589","start_s":1475.539,"end_s":1478.543,"video_s":3335.539,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00158","chapter":"C011","text":"So thank you and please support these proposed changes.","fingerprint":"c7ec5fd86b70","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00590","start_s":1481.807,"end_s":1482.288,"video_s":3341.807,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00159","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00591","start_s":1483.049,"end_s":1484.43,"video_s":3343.049,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00159","chapter":"C011","text":"Barbara is next.","fingerprint":"5224e029eaee","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00592","start_s":1484.611,"end_s":1485.692,"video_s":3344.611,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00159","chapter":"C011","text":"Ernestina Proxima.","fingerprint":"dcb774939a20","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00593","start_s":1494.7,"end_s":1499.426,"video_s":3354.7,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00160","chapter":"C011","text":"Hello, my name is Barbara Brackett, and I've been volunteering for Poverty's Pets for about four years.","fingerprint":"1ff3c44f2b44","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00594","start_s":1500.308,"end_s":1504.173,"video_s":3360.308,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00160","chapter":"C011","text":"I first became involved with Poverty's Pets after adopting a dog through them.","fingerprint":"649983ae74e9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00595","start_s":1504.994,"end_s":1514.887,"video_s":3364.994,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00160","chapter":"C011","text":"I wanted to do more, so I started helping to distribute flyers in targeted underserved communities, letting residents know about the free spay and neuter clinics.","fingerprint":"ce4dc5b93ef9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00596","start_s":1514.907,"end_s":1517.13,"video_s":3374.907,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00160","chapter":"C011","text":"And then I volunteered at the clinics themselves.","fingerprint":"820be1cb2b3e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00597","start_s":1518.022,"end_s":1522.008,"video_s":3378.022,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00160","chapter":"C011","text":"Before finding Poverty's Pets, I honestly didn't spend much time in these neighborhoods.","fingerprint":"94702bbb80b9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00598","start_s":1522.769,"end_s":1529.458,"video_s":3382.769,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00160","chapter":"C011","text":"Like most of us, I traveled the same roads and routes and so was completely unaware of the conditions many animals were living in.","fingerprint":"a11359f7f98d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00599","start_s":1529.498,"end_s":1538.511,"video_s":3389.498,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00160","chapter":"C011","text":"Dogs roaming freely, strays struggling to survive, and injured animals with little or probably no care.","fingerprint":"66149aef1555","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00600","start_s":1539.554,"end_s":1547.186,"video_s":3399.554,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00160","chapter":"C011","text":"As I mentioned before, Poverty's Pets volunteers, like myself, prepared for clinics by walking neighborhoods, distributing flyers.","fingerprint":"2c41db43f811","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00601","start_s":1547.847,"end_s":1549.49,"video_s":3407.847,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00160","chapter":"C011","text":"And what we saw was eye-opening.","fingerprint":"36cf7306b42c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00602","start_s":1550.251,"end_s":1553.396,"video_s":3410.251,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00160","chapter":"C011","text":"We saw dogs living on chains and cables.","fingerprint":"8d3e326c432e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00603","start_s":1554.678,"end_s":1564.414,"video_s":3414.678,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00160","chapter":"C011","text":"We saw dogs confined to impossibly small areas, isolated and often without food or water or the ability to get out of the sun.","fingerprint":"4c479d67b8c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00604","start_s":1564.867,"end_s":1571.35,"video_s":3424.867,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00160","chapter":"C011","text":"The suffering was difficult to witness, and often what I saw stayed with me long after I returned home.","fingerprint":"62056f170883","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00605","start_s":1571.87,"end_s":1582.042,"video_s":3431.87,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00160","chapter":"C011","text":"These experiences strengthen my belief that we all have a responsibility to care for animals that depend entirely on us, as well as educate pet owners.","fingerprint":"822d26f663e8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00606","start_s":1582.983,"end_s":1584.605,"video_s":3442.983,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00160","chapter":"C011","text":"That's why I support this ordinance.","fingerprint":"70867bcfe84f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00607","start_s":1584.985,"end_s":1592.314,"video_s":3444.985,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00160","chapter":"C011","text":"It will help protect dogs from prolonged tethering, but it will also send an important message that animals deserve compassion.","fingerprint":"918ad5e6af52","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00608","start_s":1593.355,"end_s":1594.496,"video_s":3453.355,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00160","chapter":"C011","text":"They deserve proper care.","fingerprint":"f7e653515a16","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00609","start_s":1595.097,"end_s":1597.54,"video_s":3455.097,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00160","chapter":"C011","text":"And they deserve a better quality of life.","fingerprint":"ed38c6242a2e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00610","start_s":1597.823,"end_s":1604.518,"video_s":3457.823,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00160","chapter":"C011","text":"Equally as important, it will help educate pet owners and encourage the more humane treatment of animals throughout our community.","fingerprint":"29e57d57817f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00611","start_s":1605.48,"end_s":1610.05,"video_s":3465.48,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00160","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you for your time and for supporting this important step forward for the dogs of Phoenix.","fingerprint":"feff3075727c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00612","start_s":1613.699,"end_s":1616.625,"video_s":3473.699,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00161","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you, Ernestina and then Sherry.","fingerprint":"f41ac3979c77","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00613","start_s":1623.085,"end_s":1627.735,"video_s":3483.085,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00162","chapter":"C011","text":"Hola, mi nombre es Ernestina Briceño y soy voluntaria con Poverty Pets.","fingerprint":"04108a95bd47","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00614","start_s":1628.196,"end_s":1632.245,"video_s":3488.196,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00162","chapter":"C011","text":"Conocía por primera vez hace cuatro años.","fingerprint":"96f78bf528fb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00615","start_s":1632.545,"end_s":1639.019,"video_s":3492.545,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00162","chapter":"C011","text":"Vinieron a mi vecindario y dejaron un volante sobre servicios gratuitos de esterilización y castración.","fingerprint":"27b2306a3f8c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00616","start_s":1639.56,"end_s":1641.364,"video_s":3499.56,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00162","chapter":"C011","text":"Tenía muchos gatos ferales.","fingerprint":"eff8775daa1e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00617","start_s":1641.344,"end_s":1644.571,"video_s":3501.344,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00162","chapter":"C011","text":"Necesitaba ayuda, así que llamé al número del volante.","fingerprint":"ec1308939101","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00618","start_s":1645.172,"end_s":1647.437,"video_s":3505.172,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00162","chapter":"C011","text":"Después de eso me convertí en voluntaria.","fingerprint":"439c2fb1ab6f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"language","detail":"Spanish speech, transcribed as said"}]},{"id":"L00619","start_s":1648.119,"end_s":1649.441,"video_s":3508.119,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00162","chapter":"C011","text":"Ahora ayudo a mi comunidad.","fingerprint":"c00a5299cc8f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"possible-translation","detail":"this speaker also spoke Spanish here; this English line may be a machine translation, not their words"}]},{"id":"L00620","start_s":1650.103,"end_s":1654.112,"video_s":3510.103,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00162","chapter":"C011","text":"Ayudo a traducir y explicar información para familias que hablan mi idioma.","fingerprint":"5568b86958ae","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"possible-translation","detail":"this speaker also spoke Spanish here; this English line may be a machine translation, not their words"}]},{"id":"L00621","start_s":1654.613,"end_s":1658.982,"video_s":3514.613,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00162","chapter":"C011","text":"Muchas personas se sienten más cómodas cuando alguien puede hablar con ellas.","fingerprint":"01b2032732ee","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"language","detail":"Spanish speech, transcribed as said"}]},{"id":"L00622","start_s":1659.94,"end_s":1661.664,"video_s":3519.94,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00162","chapter":"C011","text":"y ayudarlas a entender.","fingerprint":"94ea3e02353b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"possible-translation","detail":"this speaker also spoke Spanish here; this English line may be a machine translation, not their words"}]},{"id":"L00623","start_s":1662.124,"end_s":1673.308,"video_s":3522.124,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00162","chapter":"C011","text":"En mi vecindario veo muchos perros atados viviendo fuera, algunos están atados a cercas, muchos están solos en patios traseros por largos periodos de tiempo.","fingerprint":"bdc98a72035e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"language","detail":"Spanish speech, transcribed as said"}]},{"id":"L00624","start_s":1673.688,"end_s":1677.135,"video_s":3533.688,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00162","chapter":"C011","text":"Mucha gente no entiende que esto puede hacerles daño a los perros.","fingerprint":"af1d762c81cc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"possible-translation","detail":"this speaker also spoke Spanish here; this English line may be a machine translation, not their words"}]},{"id":"L00625","start_s":1677.516,"end_s":1680.362,"video_s":3537.516,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00162","chapter":"C011","text":"Veo mucho insecto, garrapatas en los perros.","fingerprint":"9e044e6568c1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"language","detail":"Spanish speech, transcribed as said"}]},{"id":"L00626","start_s":1681.439,"end_s":1684.083,"video_s":3541.439,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00162","chapter":"C011","text":"Trato de educar a las personas cuando puedo.","fingerprint":"3160df8b2550","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"language","detail":"Spanish speech, transcribed as said"}]},{"id":"L00627","start_s":1684.163,"end_s":1688.35,"video_s":3544.163,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00162","chapter":"C011","text":"Les explico que los perros necesitan cuidado, sombra, agua y cariño.","fingerprint":"8a99061578d4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"language","detail":"Spanish speech, transcribed as said"}]},{"id":"L00628","start_s":1688.851,"end_s":1693.698,"video_s":3548.851,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00162","chapter":"C011","text":"También explico mejores maneras de mantenerlos seguros y como parte de la familia.","fingerprint":"7903d6e08488","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"language","detail":"Spanish speech, transcribed as said"}]},{"id":"L00629","start_s":1694.519,"end_s":1696.402,"video_s":3554.519,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00162","chapter":"C011","text":"Estoy contenta con esta nueva ley.","fingerprint":"fa01553b17a7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"possible-translation","detail":"this speaker also spoke Spanish here; this English line may be a machine translation, not their words"}]},{"id":"L00630","start_s":1696.623,"end_s":1699.888,"video_s":3556.623,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00162","chapter":"C011","text":"Creo que ayudará a proteger los perros en nuestra comunidad.","fingerprint":"29e21ff71f0b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"language","detail":"Spanish speech, transcribed as said"}]},{"id":"L00631","start_s":1700.368,"end_s":1705.877,"video_s":3560.368,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00162","chapter":"C011","text":"También creo que ayudará a enseñarles a la gente compasión y una mejor comprensión.","fingerprint":"45115429cb23","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"language","detail":"Spanish speech, transcribed as said"}]},{"id":"L00632","start_s":1706.465,"end_s":1710.913,"video_s":3566.465,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00162","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you for your time and for caring for the animals in our city.","fingerprint":"5936c70676fe","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"possible-translation","detail":"this speaker also spoke Spanish here; this English line may be a machine translation, not their words"}]},{"id":"L00633","start_s":1711.314,"end_s":1711.795,"video_s":3571.314,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00162","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"possible-translation","detail":"this speaker also spoke Spanish here; this English line may be a machine translation, not their words"}]},{"id":"L00634","start_s":1713.698,"end_s":1714.139,"video_s":3573.698,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00162","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00635","start_s":1715.822,"end_s":1718.547,"video_s":3575.822,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00163","chapter":"C011","text":"Sherry is next, followed by Bill Ross.","fingerprint":"01f9a06566e3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00636","start_s":1719.289,"end_s":1719.73,"video_s":3579.289,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00163","chapter":"C011","text":"Oh, I'm sorry.","fingerprint":"531db447802e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00637","start_s":1724.719,"end_s":1726.121,"video_s":3584.719,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00164","chapter":"C011","text":"Mayor, do you want the translation?","fingerprint":"3a223e188f69","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00638","start_s":1726.462,"end_s":1729.688,"video_s":3586.462,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00165","chapter":"C011","text":"Sorry, I'm sorry, Sherry, we're going to do a translation.","fingerprint":"b71f6f55b07b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00639","start_s":1732.503,"end_s":1734.206,"video_s":3592.503,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00166","chapter":"C011","text":"Hello, my name is Ernestina.","fingerprint":"416b6777b8b7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00640","start_s":1734.226,"end_s":1736.389,"video_s":3594.226,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00166","chapter":"C011","text":"I'm a volunteer.","fingerprint":"b2f93bfaa6d9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00641","start_s":1736.409,"end_s":1747.045,"video_s":3596.409,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00166","chapter":"C011","text":"And I am known for providing services in the area.","fingerprint":"db827d44257d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00642","start_s":1747.065,"end_s":1750.09,"video_s":3607.065,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00166","chapter":"C011","text":"I first met them four years ago.","fingerprint":"5817513b2300","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00643","start_s":1750.15,"end_s":1755.979,"video_s":3610.15,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00166","chapter":"C011","text":"They came to my neighborhood and left a flyer about the free spaying and neutering service.","fingerprint":"e4abe3675168","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00644","start_s":1757.917,"end_s":1762.924,"video_s":3617.917,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00166","chapter":"C011","text":"There was many feral cats that needed help, so I called the number on the flyer.","fingerprint":"f0aa3912451b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00645","start_s":1762.985,"end_s":1765.508,"video_s":3622.985,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00166","chapter":"C011","text":"After that, I became a volunteer.","fingerprint":"67dc4e7f5744","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00646","start_s":1765.548,"end_s":1768.172,"video_s":3625.548,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00166","chapter":"C011","text":"Now, I help my community.","fingerprint":"842a960abd47","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00647","start_s":1768.192,"end_s":1772.639,"video_s":3628.192,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00166","chapter":"C011","text":"I help translate and explain information for families who speak my language.","fingerprint":"b9e80b041dc7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00648","start_s":1773.28,"end_s":1778.187,"video_s":3633.28,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00166","chapter":"C011","text":"Many people feel more comfortable when someone can talk to them and help them understand.","fingerprint":"a40000ec1131","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00649","start_s":1779.709,"end_s":1784.296,"video_s":3639.709,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00166","chapter":"C011","text":"In my neighborhood, I see many dogs that are tied up and living outside.","fingerprint":"4e7ce780021c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00650","start_s":1784.737,"end_s":1786.86,"video_s":3644.737,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00166","chapter":"C011","text":"Some are tied to fences.","fingerprint":"bb24eb6d65c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00651","start_s":1787.043,"end_s":1790.268,"video_s":3647.043,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00166","chapter":"C011","text":"Many are left alone in backyards for long periods of time.","fingerprint":"96e04e5a3474","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00652","start_s":1791.77,"end_s":1795.596,"video_s":3651.77,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00166","chapter":"C011","text":"Many people don't understand that this can harm dogs.","fingerprint":"72e790567466","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00653","start_s":1795.616,"end_s":1797.338,"video_s":3655.616,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00166","chapter":"C011","text":"I see a lot of ticks on dogs.","fingerprint":"7562223ba56a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00654","start_s":1798.92,"end_s":1801.144,"video_s":3658.92,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00166","chapter":"C011","text":"I try to educate people when I can.","fingerprint":"9ffa8ec9bc39","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00655","start_s":1801.925,"end_s":1806.712,"video_s":3661.925,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00166","chapter":"C011","text":"I explain to them that dogs need care, shade, water, and affection.","fingerprint":"1bdf87b51231","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00656","start_s":1807.633,"end_s":1810.017,"video_s":3667.633,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00166","chapter":"C011","text":"I also explain better ways to keep them safe.","fingerprint":"26abe974e6ef","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00657","start_s":1810.437,"end_s":1813.742,"video_s":3670.437,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00166","chapter":"C011","text":"And as part of the family, I'm happy with this new law.","fingerprint":"f81ffa7ce53a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00658","start_s":1814.92,"end_s":1817.386,"video_s":3674.92,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00166","chapter":"C011","text":"I believe it will help protect dogs in our community.","fingerprint":"81e647e04941","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00659","start_s":1818.108,"end_s":1823.1,"video_s":3678.108,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00166","chapter":"C011","text":"I also believe it will help teach people compassion and better understanding.","fingerprint":"06b6404184cb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00660","start_s":1824.143,"end_s":1827.632,"video_s":3684.143,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00166","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you for your time and for caring about the animals in our city.","fingerprint":"31f2638e9175","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00661","start_s":1828.313,"end_s":1828.734,"video_s":3688.313,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00166","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00662","start_s":1830.298,"end_s":1831.201,"video_s":3690.298,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00167","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you, Jerry.","fingerprint":"351cb0b14ddc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00663","start_s":1831.221,"end_s":1832.203,"video_s":3691.221,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00167","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you for your patience.","fingerprint":"aae4a724580e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00664","start_s":1835.069,"end_s":1837.753,"video_s":3695.069,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00168","chapter":"C011","text":"Good afternoon, Mayor and Council Members.","fingerprint":"4cb300cc1756","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00665","start_s":1838.314,"end_s":1845.584,"video_s":3698.314,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00168","chapter":"C011","text":"My name is Sherry Hoffman, and I have been volunteering with Poverty's Pets for over a decade, and I'm currently on the board.","fingerprint":"24f91941b8db","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00666","start_s":1845.624,"end_s":1856.259,"video_s":3705.624,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00168","chapter":"C011","text":"Before each spay and neuter clinic, we canvass the neighborhood, leaving flyers on the doors.","fingerprint":"6ae6c1b5b8a5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00667","start_s":1857.421,"end_s":1861.887,"video_s":3717.421,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00168","chapter":"C011","text":"And we do this probably at least once a month, maybe twice a month.","fingerprint":"2037d155df49","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00668","start_s":1862.71,"end_s":1865.517,"video_s":3722.71,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00168","chapter":"C011","text":"Poverty's Pets dedicated volunteers.","fingerprint":"6fea6e274f2c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00669","start_s":1865.577,"end_s":1866.941,"video_s":3725.577,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00168","chapter":"C011","text":"I'm sorry.","fingerprint":"308815590952","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00670","start_s":1867.382,"end_s":1869.869,"video_s":3727.382,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00168","chapter":"C011","text":"The one flyer initiates a conversation.","fingerprint":"99a131b156f4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00671","start_s":1869.929,"end_s":1874.421,"video_s":3729.929,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00168","chapter":"C011","text":"Once an individual reaches out to us, we feel an obligation to help.","fingerprint":"17d9fa8187ab","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00672","start_s":1875.002,"end_s":1878.07,"video_s":3735.002,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00168","chapter":"C011","text":"By asking them four words, how can we help?","fingerprint":"3ee1edd06f45","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00673","start_s":1880.834,"end_s":1883.436,"video_s":3740.834,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00168","chapter":"C011","text":"opens the door to get them services they need.","fingerprint":"14cb516110ad","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00674","start_s":1883.917,"end_s":1891.824,"video_s":3743.917,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00168","chapter":"C011","text":"Many of these families are rescuing animals because they can't stand to see them suffer on their streets.","fingerprint":"d7d366c817a0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00675","start_s":1892.345,"end_s":1898.851,"video_s":3752.345,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00168","chapter":"C011","text":"Walking the streets in these underserved communities, we witness the horrific effects of tethering.","fingerprint":"44daeb903304","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00676","start_s":1899.591,"end_s":1909.12,"video_s":3759.591,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00168","chapter":"C011","text":"Dogs standing in their own feces and urine, covered in flies, behavioral deterioration, heightened aggression,","fingerprint":"75e84dde55cd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00677","start_s":1909.1,"end_s":1919.351,"video_s":3769.1,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00168","chapter":"C011","text":"Severe psychological distress and vulnerable to extreme weather, which we can see in which we have in Phoenix like today, which is 110 degrees out.","fingerprint":"0a7b93d9a701","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00678","start_s":1919.871,"end_s":1928.14,"video_s":3779.871,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00168","chapter":"C011","text":"Today we are taking a definitive step in the right direction to ensure dogs in Phoenix will no longer suffer on the end of a tether.","fingerprint":"e42eaea7c7d7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00679","start_s":1928.96,"end_s":1931.123,"video_s":3788.96,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00168","chapter":"C011","text":"Please vote in favor of this legislation.","fingerprint":"d8b18f7c4a23","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00680","start_s":1931.563,"end_s":1932.704,"video_s":3791.563,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00168","chapter":"C011","text":"The dogs will thank you.","fingerprint":"b3347a8b3554","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00681","start_s":1933.025,"end_s":1934.206,"video_s":3793.025,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00168","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you very much for your time.","fingerprint":"28e18f02a49b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00682","start_s":1935.988,"end_s":1936.188,"video_s":3795.988,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00169","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00683","start_s":1936.208,"end_s":1938.33,"video_s":3796.208,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00169","chapter":"C011","text":"Bill is next, followed by Kate.","fingerprint":"4de568f48805","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00684","start_s":1943.693,"end_s":1944.274,"video_s":3803.693,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00170","chapter":"C011","text":"Good afternoon.","fingerprint":"f01e727e7b79","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00685","start_s":1944.315,"end_s":1949.006,"video_s":3804.315,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00170","chapter":"C011","text":"My name is Bill Ross and I'm a board member with the Poverty Pets organizations.","fingerprint":"863d07616bb9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00686","start_s":1950.57,"end_s":1958.85,"video_s":3810.57,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00170","chapter":"C011","text":"I'd like to take a moment now to express our gratitude to all the folks in city leadership who have taken the time to meet with us over the past several years.","fingerprint":"56c8d23587f7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00687","start_s":1959.353,"end_s":1966.786,"video_s":3819.353,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00170","chapter":"C011","text":"as we work to better understand animal welfare issues in Phoenix and explore solutions to reduce animal neglect and cruelty.","fingerprint":"78c5220c2a38","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00688","start_s":1967.548,"end_s":1977.025,"video_s":3827.548,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00170","chapter":"C011","text":"We met several times with Maricopa Animal Care and Control where staff helped us better understand the challenges facing animal welfare in our community.","fingerprint":"0ec08a63c4a6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00689","start_s":1977.46,"end_s":1986.256,"video_s":3837.46,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00170","chapter":"C011","text":"We also met with Commander Shane Disatel, who always made himself accessible, answered our questions, and helped us understand enforcement realities.","fingerprint":"7ffe517a8840","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00690","start_s":1986.858,"end_s":1999.401,"video_s":3846.858,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00170","chapter":"C011","text":"We met with Spencer Self as well from Neighborhood Services and had helpful conversations and very productive conversations with council members Pastor, Waring, Robinson, Guardado, as well as former council members.","fingerprint":"bd424727c5e3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00691","start_s":1999.769,"end_s":2003.878,"video_s":3859.769,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00170","chapter":"C011","text":"When we first started this journey, we quickly learned that we didn't know what we didn't know.","fingerprint":"0f70d2dec712","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00692","start_s":2004.479,"end_s":2012.417,"video_s":3864.479,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00170","chapter":"C011","text":"We had to educate ourselves on how animal welfare is managed in the city, who handles what, where complaints go, and how different departments work together.","fingerprint":"20451c216a3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00693","start_s":2012.978,"end_s":2016.546,"video_s":3872.978,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00170","chapter":"C011","text":"What we did know, however, was that there were far too many animals suffering.","fingerprint":"67993d9b7823","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00694","start_s":2017.319,"end_s":2029.956,"video_s":3877.319,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00170","chapter":"C011","text":"As we listened, learned, and met with stakeholders throughout the city, one thing became clear that education, while important, there are situations where stronger protections are needed to prevent ongoing neglect and suffering.","fingerprint":"340e3cd0d863","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00695","start_s":2030.778,"end_s":2037.707,"video_s":3890.778,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00170","chapter":"C011","text":"The proposed anti-tethering ordinance is a result of years of conversations, research, and collaboration.","fingerprint":"f26d129cec9c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00696","start_s":2037.805,"end_s":2046.541,"video_s":3897.805,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00170","chapter":"C011","text":"It is a reasonable measure and a meaningful step to ensure dogs are treated humanely while still allowing responsible pet owners to safely manage their animals.","fingerprint":"6b37140bf1a6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00697","start_s":2047.422,"end_s":2054.555,"video_s":3907.422,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00170","chapter":"C011","text":"We respectfully ask for you to support this ordinance change and for your continued commitment to protecting the welfare of Phoenix animals.","fingerprint":"2743fb79cddd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00698","start_s":2055.156,"end_s":2056.599,"video_s":3915.156,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00170","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you for your time and consideration.","fingerprint":"8ce4ab4f0271","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00699","start_s":2057.661,"end_s":2058.122,"video_s":3917.661,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00171","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00700","start_s":2059.524,"end_s":2061.147,"video_s":3919.524,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00171","chapter":"C011","text":"Kate is next, followed by Lisa.","fingerprint":"9b8642572fda","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00701","start_s":2069.952,"end_s":2072.135,"video_s":3929.952,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00172","chapter":"C011","text":"Good afternoon, Mayor and Council Members.","fingerprint":"4cb300cc1756","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00702","start_s":2072.515,"end_s":2075.739,"video_s":3932.515,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00172","chapter":"C011","text":"My name is Kate Civilella, and I'm the founder of Poverty Pets.","fingerprint":"51ed81ecb5c4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00703","start_s":2076.4,"end_s":2082.988,"video_s":3936.4,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00172","chapter":"C011","text":"For over a decade, we have advocated for strong, clear, anti-tethering legislation in Phoenix.","fingerprint":"96d0064204a0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00704","start_s":2083.569,"end_s":2084.911,"video_s":3943.569,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00172","chapter":"C011","text":"Many of you have met with us.","fingerprint":"384bb168fd8d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00705","start_s":2085.812,"end_s":2089.276,"video_s":3945.812,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00172","chapter":"C011","text":"What we see every week is not abstract.","fingerprint":"53a13bd44846","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00706","start_s":2089.296,"end_s":2098.187,"video_s":3949.296,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00172","chapter":"C011","text":"It is dogs tied 24-7, tangled in ropes, cables, chains, without clean water or shade, and living in deplorable conditions.","fingerprint":"f63541ab7419","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00707","start_s":2098.69,"end_s":2102.317,"video_s":3958.69,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00172","chapter":"C011","text":"Just recently, Poverty Pets reported a tethered dog.","fingerprint":"f02b8baa8491","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00708","start_s":2102.838,"end_s":2107.546,"video_s":3962.838,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00172","chapter":"C011","text":"The dog was tethered by a short rope attached to a cloth collar.","fingerprint":"0866acbcfa55","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00709","start_s":2107.847,"end_s":2109.47,"video_s":3967.847,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00172","chapter":"C011","text":"It was 99 degrees outside.","fingerprint":"e987574d8d50","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00710","start_s":2110.451,"end_s":2116.362,"video_s":3970.451,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00172","chapter":"C011","text":"We were told there was nothing that could be done as the temperature had not yet reached 100 degrees.","fingerprint":"88ad6efaf5eb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00711","start_s":2116.932,"end_s":2119.336,"video_s":3976.932,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00172","chapter":"C011","text":"At 99 degrees, the dog was legal.","fingerprint":"acc45f8ba18b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00712","start_s":2120.137,"end_s":2132.157,"video_s":3980.137,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00172","chapter":"C011","text":"One digit later, that exact same dog, standing in the exact same spot, tethered in the exact same manner, would suddenly become illegal.","fingerprint":"90af9992c5f3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00713","start_s":2132.508,"end_s":2136.734,"video_s":3992.508,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00172","chapter":"C011","text":"The dog's suffering did not change when the temperature moved one degree.","fingerprint":"fd5393429f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00714","start_s":2137.234,"end_s":2139.918,"video_s":3997.234,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00172","chapter":"C011","text":"Cruelty cannot be measured by temperature alone.","fingerprint":"183ec02028fc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00715","start_s":2140.539,"end_s":2146.987,"video_s":4000.539,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00172","chapter":"C011","text":"For too long, discussions have been centered on whether a dog is tethered with a chain, a cable, or a rope.","fingerprint":"e021f6e8b53d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00716","start_s":2147.588,"end_s":2151.634,"video_s":4007.588,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00172","chapter":"C011","text":"But changing the material does not change the reality for a dog.","fingerprint":"9e1cb949c128","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00717","start_s":2152.254,"end_s":2156.44,"video_s":4012.254,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00172","chapter":"C011","text":"A tethered dog is still confined, isolated, and vulnerable.","fingerprint":"867bb8e49ea1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00718","start_s":2156.909,"end_s":2164.824,"video_s":4016.909,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00172","chapter":"C011","text":"This ordinance moves the conversation beyond those loopholes and keeps the focus where it needs to be, on the welfare of the animal.","fingerprint":"10394fa50b4c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00719","start_s":2165.846,"end_s":2170.395,"video_s":4025.846,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00172","chapter":"C011","text":"We are grateful for this council for taking this issue seriously","fingerprint":"d2b59e1791d7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00720","start_s":2170.628,"end_s":2178.415,"video_s":4030.628,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00172","chapter":"C011","text":"I would also like to thank Councilwoman Laura Pastor and your office for your continued support and commitment on this issue.","fingerprint":"99780af5c36f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00721","start_s":2179.176,"end_s":2182.119,"video_s":4039.176,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00172","chapter":"C011","text":"This language moves Phoenix in the right direction.","fingerprint":"a73f2abd8113","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00722","start_s":2182.499,"end_s":2195.151,"video_s":4042.499,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00172","chapter":"C011","text":"It is practical, a step forward, and will help educate both owners and help educate owners and dogs will receive a humane... All right.","fingerprint":"930e9ddd7720","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00723","start_s":2197.493,"end_s":2197.873,"video_s":4057.493,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00173","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00724","start_s":2198.354,"end_s":2199.555,"video_s":4058.354,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00173","chapter":"C011","text":"We got the...","fingerprint":"f090a1789d10","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00725","start_s":2201.543,"end_s":2203.309,"video_s":4061.543,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00173","chapter":"C011","text":"She thinks we should support it, guys.","fingerprint":"b8ac061992c1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00726","start_s":2203.329,"end_s":2205.476,"video_s":4063.329,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00173","chapter":"C011","text":"All right, council member comments.","fingerprint":"803c3adf42ef","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00727","start_s":2207.021,"end_s":2211.436,"video_s":4067.021,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00173","chapter":"C011","text":"Oh, I'm sorry.","fingerprint":"531db447802e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00728","start_s":2211.476,"end_s":2212.178,"video_s":4071.476,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00173","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you, Lisa.","fingerprint":"3f910178ad8b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00729","start_s":2213.44,"end_s":2216.143,"video_s":4073.44,"speaker":"v13","turn":"T00174","chapter":"C011","text":"Good afternoon, and thank you for letting us all talk.","fingerprint":"cf54d55855d6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00730","start_s":2216.544,"end_s":2222.331,"video_s":4076.544,"speaker":"v13","turn":"T00174","chapter":"C011","text":"You've heard from a lot of my colleagues and friends here, and we are all here supporting the same thing.","fingerprint":"01aaf9d2ff1c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00731","start_s":2223.413,"end_s":2232.845,"video_s":4083.413,"speaker":"v13","turn":"T00174","chapter":"C011","text":"I volunteer with Handover Rover Rescue, and we spend countless hours doing trap, neuter, and return work for community cats throughout Phoenix.","fingerprint":"c87c582c1d07","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00732","start_s":2233.566,"end_s":2242.097,"video_s":4093.566,"speaker":"v13","turn":"T00174","chapter":"C011","text":"And rescue work puts you in some places that most people never see, puts you face to face with animals that have been neglected, abandoned, or forgotten.","fingerprint":"5198e4fce132","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00733","start_s":2243.562,"end_s":2248.206,"video_s":4103.562,"speaker":"v13","turn":"T00174","chapter":"C011","text":"I've seen dogs left outside in extreme heat with little human interaction.","fingerprint":"8dc8659f8cec","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00734","start_s":2249.327,"end_s":2253.411,"video_s":4109.327,"speaker":"v13","turn":"T00174","chapter":"C011","text":"We've seen dogs spending day after day tied to a chain or cable tether.","fingerprint":"04f60d9bdc72","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00735","start_s":2254.131,"end_s":2259.356,"video_s":4114.131,"speaker":"v13","turn":"T00174","chapter":"C011","text":"And we've seen the physical and emotional toll that isolation and neglect can take on an animal.","fingerprint":"aae3f8f00398","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00736","start_s":2260.997,"end_s":2269.605,"video_s":4120.997,"speaker":"v13","turn":"T00174","chapter":"C011","text":"In rescue, we often encounter animals that after months and years of neglect, the dogs that spend their lives at the end of a chain, they have no voice of their own.","fingerprint":"56488d2b5815","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00737","start_s":2269.645,"end_s":2273.248,"video_s":4129.645,"speaker":"v13","turn":"T00174","chapter":"C011","text":"And today, we have the opportunity to speak with them.","fingerprint":"26a751130873","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00738","start_s":2274.089,"end_s":2277.312,"video_s":4134.089,"speaker":"v13","turn":"T00174","chapter":"C011","text":"Every animal that we've rescued had really one thing in common.","fingerprint":"a8333dc67f36","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00739","start_s":2278.394,"end_s":2280.496,"video_s":4138.394,"speaker":"v13","turn":"T00174","chapter":"C011","text":"They're waiting for a human to do the right thing.","fingerprint":"b602b2f86e02","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00740","start_s":2280.556,"end_s":2288.665,"video_s":4140.556,"speaker":"v13","turn":"T00174","chapter":"C011","text":"Today, you have the opportunity to do the right thing for countless of animals you may never see or meet.","fingerprint":"56c038a1b307","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00741","start_s":2289.566,"end_s":2294.09,"video_s":4149.566,"speaker":"v13","turn":"T00174","chapter":"C011","text":"I respectfully ask for your support and thank you for your time and consideration.","fingerprint":"96f8be15c500","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00742","start_s":2295.972,"end_s":2296.313,"video_s":4155.972,"speaker":"v13","turn":"T00174","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00743","start_s":2297.134,"end_s":2299.977,"video_s":4157.134,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00175","chapter":"C011","text":"I believe that concludes our testimony.","fingerprint":"0e84e57b750c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00744","start_s":2302.139,"end_s":2302.66,"video_s":4162.139,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00175","chapter":"C011","text":"Any comments?","fingerprint":"9cdeefcc2f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00745","start_s":2303.12,"end_s":2303.961,"video_s":4163.12,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00175","chapter":"C011","text":"Councilwoman Pastor.","fingerprint":"dbcef12e9415","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00746","start_s":2305.763,"end_s":2315.048,"video_s":4165.763,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00176","chapter":"C011","text":"Kate and I have had a I don't know back and forth relationship","fingerprint":"3e68c26427df","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00747","start_s":2315.888,"end_s":2318.112,"video_s":4175.888,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00176","chapter":"C011","text":"for many years.","fingerprint":"72ce782c97f3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00748","start_s":2318.713,"end_s":2319.995,"video_s":4178.713,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00176","chapter":"C011","text":"I'm trying to think back.","fingerprint":"35e477e16949","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00749","start_s":2320.075,"end_s":2324.082,"video_s":4180.075,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00176","chapter":"C011","text":"I want to say five years maybe this has been going, six years.","fingerprint":"eb6970fa41c9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00750","start_s":2325.183,"end_s":2329.07,"video_s":4185.183,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00176","chapter":"C011","text":"And Kate is a constituent of mine in District 4.","fingerprint":"e7f541150d40","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00751","start_s":2329.771,"end_s":2332.195,"video_s":4189.771,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00176","chapter":"C011","text":"And so I see Kate very often.","fingerprint":"92ef92e49b43","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00752","start_s":2332.255,"end_s":2338.826,"video_s":4192.255,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00176","chapter":"C011","text":"And she reminds me at times, like Laura, we still need to work on this ordinance.","fingerprint":"c5475744f387","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00753","start_s":2339.307,"end_s":2342.352,"video_s":4199.307,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00176","chapter":"C011","text":"We still need to do these following things.","fingerprint":"6598f3c08f3f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00754","start_s":2342.332,"end_s":2362.394,"video_s":4202.332,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00176","chapter":"C011","text":"and so I wanna thank Poverty Pets and all of those that are here that are advocates for the pets and regarding the tethering piece because I probably would not be standing here and speaking or speaking about this if it hadn't been for Michael Peterson and Kariah.","fingerprint":"9a33d5e785cc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00755","start_s":2363.996,"end_s":2369.942,"video_s":4223.996,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00176","chapter":"C011","text":"And Michael really took on this ordinance","fingerprint":"7208b49bdec1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00756","start_s":2370.344,"end_s":2375.369,"video_s":4230.344,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00176","chapter":"C011","text":"to make sure that TOGs were not tethered.","fingerprint":"f08d8ca82a30","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00757","start_s":2376.35,"end_s":2380.454,"video_s":4236.35,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00176","chapter":"C011","text":"And so he was the one who said, you need to get involved.","fingerprint":"1f0ef1172f57","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00758","start_s":2380.474,"end_s":2383.978,"video_s":4240.474,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00176","chapter":"C011","text":"I will organize all the meetings.","fingerprint":"1aa2612542fa","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00759","start_s":2384.198,"end_s":2385.159,"video_s":4244.198,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00176","chapter":"C011","text":"We will sit down.","fingerprint":"3ae750f50981","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00760","start_s":2385.179,"end_s":2390.504,"video_s":4245.179,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00176","chapter":"C011","text":"I will go through the process of the legal piece and see what we can and cannot do.","fingerprint":"2ef37ece0f2c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00761","start_s":2390.524,"end_s":2394.288,"video_s":4250.524,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00176","chapter":"C011","text":"And so for me, this is the final piece.","fingerprint":"224c917faa21","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00762","start_s":2395.509,"end_s":2400.334,"video_s":4255.509,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00176","chapter":"C011","text":"And this is also a memory of Michael Peterson and Gervaya.","fingerprint":"a4c0a7409fec","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00763","start_s":2401.208,"end_s":2412.526,"video_s":4261.208,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00176","chapter":"C011","text":"So I wanna thank you for having me and push me to this point to make a really good ordinance that is necessary in our city.","fingerprint":"3429d50b46a7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00764","start_s":2413.489,"end_s":2414.492,"video_s":4273.489,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00177","chapter":"C011","text":"There are many people,","fingerprint":"5252f6191fe2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00765","start_s":2414.692,"end_s":2422.641,"video_s":4274.692,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00178","chapter":"C011","text":"I want to thank Lori Bays, because Lori Bays has been in this process for just as long as us.","fingerprint":"b77e9349bed2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00766","start_s":2423.522,"end_s":2424.904,"video_s":4283.522,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00178","chapter":"C011","text":"I also want to thank legal.","fingerprint":"301b7e17925e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00767","start_s":2424.924,"end_s":2428.148,"video_s":4284.924,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00178","chapter":"C011","text":"I also want to thank public safety.","fingerprint":"277124c1d3b8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00768","start_s":2428.168,"end_s":2437.218,"video_s":4288.168,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00178","chapter":"C011","text":"I also want to thank those that were part of this and have stuck to it and were committed to this piece.","fingerprint":"b8f85e808c53","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00769","start_s":2438.54,"end_s":2443.686,"video_s":4298.54,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00178","chapter":"C011","text":"This final piece wouldn't have happened without Councilman Robinson.","fingerprint":"82641063c6e2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00770","start_s":2443.885,"end_s":2446.775,"video_s":4303.885,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00178","chapter":"C011","text":"because he is the Chair of Public Safety and Justice.","fingerprint":"0ddf217d8309","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00771","start_s":2447.418,"end_s":2452.275,"video_s":4307.418,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00178","chapter":"C011","text":"And so I really want to thank Councilman Robinson for working with me","fingerprint":"d37aa97d38ca","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00772","start_s":2453.437,"end_s":2465.411,"video_s":4313.437,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00178","chapter":"C011","text":"to get this on the Public Justice and Safety Committee and understanding the commitment and his commitment to this because he's the one who determines what's on and what's off on a committee.","fingerprint":"ce2ca1ba8be7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00773","start_s":2466.152,"end_s":2471.438,"video_s":4326.152,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00178","chapter":"C011","text":"And I also wanna thank those that sat on that committee because they voted for it.","fingerprint":"959ef07292f0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00774","start_s":2472.139,"end_s":2480.288,"video_s":4332.139,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00178","chapter":"C011","text":"And it's very important to understand that we can't get anything through any type of policy or ordinance through without a collective.","fingerprint":"9a75ab110605","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00775","start_s":2480.588,"end_s":2485.415,"video_s":4340.588,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00178","chapter":"C011","text":"And so I want to thank those that, everybody that has worked on this to get it to this space.","fingerprint":"17348a5d96a3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00776","start_s":2486.097,"end_s":2492.086,"video_s":4346.097,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00178","chapter":"C011","text":"And I'm just ready to get it to the point to pass it so that Kate will be happy and others will be happy.","fingerprint":"6b79551318f6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00777","start_s":2493.388,"end_s":2500.419,"video_s":4353.388,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00178","chapter":"C011","text":"And when she sees me at Encanto Golf Course, we're not having this conversation, we're having another one.","fingerprint":"14f1dd4b7952","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00778","start_s":2500.779,"end_s":2501.28,"video_s":4360.779,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00178","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00779","start_s":2503.252,"end_s":2504.054,"video_s":4363.252,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00179","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you, Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"8ac1fd1753f1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00780","start_s":2504.334,"end_s":2504.895,"video_s":4364.334,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00179","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00781","start_s":2505.236,"end_s":2514.253,"video_s":4365.236,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00179","chapter":"C011","text":"I just wanted to say I really appreciate bringing forth these common sense solutions and updates that provide more clarity for the enforcement.","fingerprint":"0a933fbc86c9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00782","start_s":2514.353,"end_s":2521.226,"video_s":4374.353,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00179","chapter":"C011","text":"I believe they reflect the best practices when it comes to animal welfare, and I think it reinforces our commitment to humane treatment for animals.","fingerprint":"2fd85f613696","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00783","start_s":2521.566,"end_s":2524.011,"video_s":4381.566,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00179","chapter":"C011","text":"I just wanted to say thank you to staff and the","fingerprint":"db5592d9aa54","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00784","start_s":2523.991,"end_s":2528.276,"video_s":4383.991,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00179","chapter":"C011","text":"Council members and subcommittee for working with the advocacy groups on this effort.","fingerprint":"ca7f11d7979e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00785","start_s":2528.676,"end_s":2537.065,"video_s":4388.676,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00179","chapter":"C011","text":"And I just wanted to encourage that this partnership continues as we educate the community on the new changes to the updated changes to the law.","fingerprint":"d11283136656","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00786","start_s":2537.085,"end_s":2539.148,"video_s":4397.085,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00179","chapter":"C011","text":"And I'm just grateful to be able to support this effort.","fingerprint":"1a4ef42e6a9a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00787","start_s":2539.208,"end_s":2541.55,"video_s":4399.208,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00179","chapter":"C011","text":"So thank you for everyone who was involved in this.","fingerprint":"b8c54c0ba6f1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00788","start_s":2541.57,"end_s":2547.717,"video_s":4401.57,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00179","chapter":"C011","text":"I just wanted to say thank you for, as Lisa said, for allowing this human to do the right thing.","fingerprint":"9dd4b7e10c94","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00789","start_s":2549.359,"end_s":2550.42,"video_s":4409.359,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00180","chapter":"C011","text":"Councilman Guardado.","fingerprint":"aa00302728d8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00790","start_s":2551.835,"end_s":2552.476,"video_s":4411.835,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00791","start_s":2552.537,"end_s":2557.688,"video_s":4412.537,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C011","text":"As well, I want to thank everyone that is here today that spoke on this item.","fingerprint":"f2896ef40bdb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00792","start_s":2558.169,"end_s":2559.111,"video_s":4418.169,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C011","text":"Incredibly important.","fingerprint":"31be660f7188","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00793","start_s":2559.151,"end_s":2563.06,"video_s":4419.151,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C011","text":"As someone that owns two dogs, I understand how important this is.","fingerprint":"db090fd13bcb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00794","start_s":2563.682,"end_s":2568.392,"video_s":4423.682,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C011","text":"And also want to thank staff for all of their hard work and everything that they're doing.","fingerprint":"fce4df30232e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00795","start_s":2568.372,"end_s":2572.558,"video_s":4428.372,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C011","text":"and we continue to expand into our parks and our dog parks.","fingerprint":"ea8cf1aa90e8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00796","start_s":2573.239,"end_s":2575.803,"video_s":4433.239,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C011","text":"I want to thank our city manager, Ed Zuercher.","fingerprint":"74c60e14413c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00797","start_s":2576.524,"end_s":2580.47,"video_s":4436.524,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C011","text":"We are finally getting a dog park in the west side at El Oso Park.","fingerprint":"356dfda88354","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00798","start_s":2580.49,"end_s":2585.077,"video_s":4440.49,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C011","text":"So very thankful for you and to Cynthia and to the staff for making that happen.","fingerprint":"0b1e455869b5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00799","start_s":2586.098,"end_s":2596.894,"video_s":4446.098,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C011","text":"We have so many apartment complexes in that area and so many beautiful dogs and now they're going to have this amazing dog park in that area so they can come out and","fingerprint":"dc5e6b15d6e3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00800","start_s":2596.874,"end_s":2600.177,"video_s":4456.874,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C011","text":"and being able to have a different space.","fingerprint":"eb96eb79901d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00801","start_s":2600.637,"end_s":2602.379,"video_s":4460.637,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C011","text":"We know that's important in the West Side.","fingerprint":"34806e4a5ae0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00802","start_s":2602.459,"end_s":2606.743,"video_s":4462.459,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C011","text":"It's incredibly important that we continue to create these type of spaces.","fingerprint":"898807e2dd34","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00803","start_s":2606.763,"end_s":2609.425,"video_s":4466.763,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C011","text":"So very thankful for everyone's work and advocacy.","fingerprint":"73ddabbd6ece","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00804","start_s":2609.866,"end_s":2617.472,"video_s":4469.866,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C011","text":"I know we've been talking about this for a long time and I'm very grateful that I was able to vote on this in PSJ and being able to vote on this today.","fingerprint":"505ef78b3c4c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00805","start_s":2617.532,"end_s":2618.473,"video_s":4477.532,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C011","text":"So thanks to everyone.","fingerprint":"42cb228b3330","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00806","start_s":2618.593,"end_s":2619.134,"video_s":4478.593,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00807","start_s":2621.416,"end_s":2621.796,"video_s":4481.416,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00808","start_s":2622.517,"end_s":2623.518,"video_s":4482.517,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00182","chapter":"C011","text":"Any additional?","fingerprint":"07328916c680","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00809","start_s":2624.218,"end_s":2624.839,"video_s":4484.218,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00182","chapter":"C011","text":"Councilman Waring.","fingerprint":"7cf533a8b87c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00810","start_s":2625.747,"end_s":2626.268,"video_s":4485.747,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00183","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00811","start_s":2626.288,"end_s":2629.252,"video_s":4486.288,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00183","chapter":"C011","text":"One of the speakers, Mayor, mentioned that they met with me.","fingerprint":"255384a9bb01","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00812","start_s":2630.454,"end_s":2631.335,"video_s":4490.454,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00183","chapter":"C011","text":"We have a lot of meetings.","fingerprint":"35f2ae1b245f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00813","start_s":2631.816,"end_s":2634.559,"video_s":4491.816,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00183","chapter":"C011","text":"That meeting stuck out a couple of weeks ago.","fingerprint":"33b72f857716","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00814","start_s":2634.579,"end_s":2637.684,"video_s":4494.579,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00183","chapter":"C011","text":"I recognize some faces in the audience, even though it had been a while.","fingerprint":"b764363e9e20","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00815","start_s":2637.864,"end_s":2640.107,"video_s":4497.864,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00183","chapter":"C011","text":"As far as I can remember, that was our only meeting.","fingerprint":"cb8e1cefcb9f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00816","start_s":2640.308,"end_s":2643.452,"video_s":4500.308,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00183","chapter":"C011","text":"I wish you guys would give a seminar on how","fingerprint":"a0718bb78889","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00817","start_s":2643.432,"end_s":2644.913,"video_s":4503.432,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00183","chapter":"C011","text":"to have a meeting with an elected official.","fingerprint":"a2af26709819","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00818","start_s":2645.374,"end_s":2648.416,"video_s":4505.374,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00183","chapter":"C011","text":"Now, unbeknownst to you, I was already kind of on your side.","fingerprint":"2631257b928b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00819","start_s":2648.997,"end_s":2654.182,"video_s":4508.997,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00183","chapter":"C011","text":"I have my own dog and love cats and so forth and grew up partially on a farm.","fingerprint":"27f61e9181cf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00820","start_s":2654.242,"end_s":2656.043,"video_s":4514.242,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00183","chapter":"C011","text":"So for me, this was kind of meaningful.","fingerprint":"171f13238fb0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00821","start_s":2656.143,"end_s":2657.545,"video_s":4516.143,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00183","chapter":"C011","text":"And I don't want you to think you wasted your time.","fingerprint":"0e511005e4ba","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00822","start_s":2657.645,"end_s":2659.547,"video_s":4517.645,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00183","chapter":"C011","text":"You probably would have just voted for it anyway.","fingerprint":"d5ca51f86684","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00823","start_s":2659.607,"end_s":2661.608,"video_s":4519.607,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00183","chapter":"C011","text":"But I appreciated the way you handled that meeting.","fingerprint":"0ff48eabe885","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00824","start_s":2662.329,"end_s":2665.152,"video_s":4522.329,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00183","chapter":"C011","text":"Christine from my office, we talked about that afterwards.","fingerprint":"087843ea1e98","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00825","start_s":2665.232,"end_s":2669.896,"video_s":4525.232,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00183","chapter":"C011","text":"Just the tenor of it and everything, I just thought I would be remiss if I didn't compliment you on that.","fingerprint":"5e15561310f4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00826","start_s":2670.396,"end_s":2673.439,"video_s":4530.396,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00183","chapter":"C011","text":"Not every meeting goes that way.","fingerprint":"56356fe8551c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00827","start_s":2673.419,"end_s":2679.567,"video_s":4533.419,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00183","chapter":"C011","text":"I don't even know that I was saying everything that you wanted to hear but I did appreciate that very much the professionalism and the tone.","fingerprint":"f3de34c43078","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00828","start_s":2680.728,"end_s":2689.579,"video_s":4540.728,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00183","chapter":"C011","text":"There were I think about seven of you there and it was a kind of a pretty diverse group and everybody was really collegial and trying to work together towards a solution.","fingerprint":"c7c5d32f865b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00829","start_s":2689.999,"end_s":2692.082,"video_s":4549.999,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00183","chapter":"C011","text":"I appreciated that very much so thank you for that.","fingerprint":"dc24838d7132","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00830","start_s":2692.322,"end_s":2695.526,"video_s":4552.322,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00183","chapter":"C011","text":"I appreciate it.","fingerprint":"910e85234d19","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00831","start_s":2695.546,"end_s":2698.009,"video_s":4555.546,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00184","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you so much Councilwoman Hernandez.","fingerprint":"5648680e0954","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00832","start_s":2698.478,"end_s":2699.039,"video_s":4558.478,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00185","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00833","start_s":2699.319,"end_s":2708.328,"video_s":4559.319,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00185","chapter":"C011","text":"As a dog mom myself, glad to see that we as a city are taking additional steps and actions to protect dogs in Phoenix.","fingerprint":"3f93051ec976","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00834","start_s":2708.809,"end_s":2710.811,"video_s":4568.809,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00185","chapter":"C011","text":"You know, dog abuse can look a lot of different ways.","fingerprint":"9a87ba2d80b2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00835","start_s":2710.951,"end_s":2714.975,"video_s":4570.951,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00185","chapter":"C011","text":"It could be a dog tethered to some sort of structure.","fingerprint":"cfa3d1285252","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00836","start_s":2714.995,"end_s":2726.427,"video_s":4574.995,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00185","chapter":"C011","text":"It could also be a golden doodle in his Knicks jersey celebrating their championship win with their beloved human and then shot by 20 officers that showed up for a noise complaint.","fingerprint":"eb8bd18e74ea","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00837","start_s":2726.407,"end_s":2731.172,"video_s":4586.407,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00185","chapter":"C011","text":"So I, you know, this is a very important topic that we tackle.","fingerprint":"062b3946554d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00838","start_s":2732.133,"end_s":2744.426,"video_s":4592.133,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00185","chapter":"C011","text":"So I also want to see us move to a place where we extend these protections to the dogs that we force into our canine units as well, because I think we should work together as a council and as a city to end all dog abuse.","fingerprint":"4f72a6686b41","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00839","start_s":2744.806,"end_s":2746.868,"video_s":4604.806,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00185","chapter":"C011","text":"And with that, I will be supporting this item today.","fingerprint":"15ecf6d70b71","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00840","start_s":2747.109,"end_s":2747.569,"video_s":4607.109,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00185","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00841","start_s":2749.832,"end_s":2750.272,"video_s":4609.832,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00186","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00842","start_s":2751.333,"end_s":2753.596,"video_s":4611.333,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00186","chapter":"C011","text":"I am also thinking of Zelda Williams today.","fingerprint":"0b5b3007b529","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00843","start_s":2753.916,"end_s":2755.958,"video_s":4613.916,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00186","chapter":"C011","text":"This is an ordinance that updates","fingerprint":"d09dfe57a65a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00844","start_s":2757.001,"end_s":2760.488,"video_s":4617.001,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00186","chapter":"C011","text":"something she worked on very hard probably around 2016.","fingerprint":"74ebb4ad9bee","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00845","start_s":2761.189,"end_s":2769.266,"video_s":4621.189,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00186","chapter":"C011","text":"And she was a member of our city council and a great animal lover and her birthday would be coming up very soon.","fingerprint":"1effbae20503","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00846","start_s":2769.406,"end_s":2777.743,"video_s":4629.406,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00186","chapter":"C011","text":"So just thinking of her and the legacy that she left behind that we can continue to build and improve with that roll call.","fingerprint":"fcd5b4eac5db","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00847","start_s":2778.584,"end_s":2779.546,"video_s":4638.584,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00187","chapter":"C011","text":"Guardado?","fingerprint":"0344b48c3f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00848","start_s":2779.566,"end_s":2779.806,"video_s":4639.566,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00187","chapter":"C011","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00849","start_s":2780.347,"end_s":2780.968,"video_s":4640.347,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00187","chapter":"C011","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00850","start_s":2780.988,"end_s":2781.209,"video_s":4640.988,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00187","chapter":"C011","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00851","start_s":2781.71,"end_s":2782.151,"video_s":4641.71,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00187","chapter":"C011","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00852","start_s":2782.371,"end_s":2783.032,"video_s":4642.371,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00187","chapter":"C011","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00853","start_s":2783.052,"end_s":2783.513,"video_s":4643.052,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00187","chapter":"C011","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00854","start_s":2783.914,"end_s":2784.655,"video_s":4643.914,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00187","chapter":"C011","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00855","start_s":2784.675,"end_s":2785.196,"video_s":4644.675,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00187","chapter":"C011","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00856","start_s":2785.316,"end_s":2785.557,"video_s":4645.316,"speaker":"v15","turn":"T00188","chapter":"C011","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00857","start_s":2786.098,"end_s":2786.459,"video_s":4646.098,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00189","chapter":"C011","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00858","start_s":2786.719,"end_s":2787.841,"video_s":4646.719,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00189","chapter":"C011","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00859","start_s":2787.861,"end_s":2788.202,"video_s":4647.861,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00189","chapter":"C011","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00860","start_s":2789.123,"end_s":2789.204,"video_s":4649.123,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00189","chapter":"C011","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00861","start_s":2789.224,"end_s":2789.985,"video_s":4649.224,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00189","chapter":"C011","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00862","start_s":2790.085,"end_s":2790.346,"video_s":4650.085,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00189","chapter":"C011","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00863","start_s":2790.787,"end_s":2791.949,"video_s":4650.787,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00189","chapter":"C011","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00864","start_s":2791.969,"end_s":2792.61,"video_s":4651.969,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00189","chapter":"C011","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00865","start_s":2792.63,"end_s":2793.512,"video_s":4652.63,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00189","chapter":"C011","text":"Passes nine zero.","fingerprint":"4028571107a8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00866","start_s":2794.113,"end_s":2795.395,"video_s":4654.113,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00189","chapter":"C011","text":"Congratulations.","fingerprint":"e58c1f5c22c1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00867","start_s":2805.972,"end_s":2806.813,"video_s":4665.972,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00190","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00868","start_s":2807.514,"end_s":2809.417,"video_s":4667.514,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00191","chapter":"C012","text":"We next go to item 59.","fingerprint":"251574a9bb77","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00869","start_s":2809.437,"end_s":2810.278,"video_s":4669.437,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C012","text":"59.","fingerprint":"3e1e967e9b79","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00870","start_s":2811.781,"end_s":2813.423,"video_s":4671.781,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C012","text":"Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"9a95bf6095c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00871","start_s":2813.683,"end_s":2823.998,"video_s":4673.683,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C012","text":"Motion to approve per the staff recommendation and adopt the annual PSPRS pension funding policy and acknowledge the assets and liabilities of the PSPRS plan.","fingerprint":"7490e69fe3df","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00872","start_s":2824.359,"end_s":2824.72,"video_s":4684.359,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C012","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00873","start_s":2825.22,"end_s":2829.426,"video_s":4685.22,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00193","chapter":"C012","text":"We have a motion and a second, noting that Councilman Robinson will not participate in this item.","fingerprint":"0402ac9fd872","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00874","start_s":2830.047,"end_s":2830.528,"video_s":4690.047,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00194","chapter":"C012","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00875","start_s":2831.015,"end_s":2832.097,"video_s":4691.015,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00194","chapter":"C012","text":"Guardado?","fingerprint":"0344b48c3f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00876","start_s":2832.117,"end_s":2833.018,"video_s":4692.117,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00194","chapter":"C012","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00877","start_s":2833.038,"end_s":2833.438,"video_s":4693.038,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00194","chapter":"C012","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00878","start_s":2833.579,"end_s":2834.54,"video_s":4693.579,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00194","chapter":"C012","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00879","start_s":2834.56,"end_s":2834.981,"video_s":4694.56,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00194","chapter":"C012","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00880","start_s":2835.181,"end_s":2836.002,"video_s":4695.181,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00194","chapter":"C012","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00881","start_s":2836.022,"end_s":2836.503,"video_s":4696.022,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00194","chapter":"C012","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00882","start_s":2836.803,"end_s":2837.124,"video_s":4696.803,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00194","chapter":"C012","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00883","start_s":2837.705,"end_s":2838.065,"video_s":4697.705,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00194","chapter":"C012","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00884","start_s":2838.486,"end_s":2839.267,"video_s":4698.486,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00194","chapter":"C012","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00885","start_s":2839.287,"end_s":2839.667,"video_s":4699.287,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00194","chapter":"C012","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00886","start_s":2840.488,"end_s":2840.569,"video_s":4700.488,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00194","chapter":"C012","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00887","start_s":2840.589,"end_s":2841.27,"video_s":4700.589,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00194","chapter":"C012","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00888","start_s":2841.39,"end_s":2842.131,"video_s":4701.39,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00194","chapter":"C012","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00889","start_s":2842.151,"end_s":2842.611,"video_s":4702.151,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00194","chapter":"C012","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00890","start_s":2842.952,"end_s":2843.553,"video_s":4702.952,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00195","chapter":"C012","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00891","start_s":2843.573,"end_s":2844.494,"video_s":4703.573,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00195","chapter":"C012","text":"Passes 8-0.","fingerprint":"f9a0ca3f6107","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00892","start_s":2845.395,"end_s":2851.484,"video_s":4705.395,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00196","chapter":"C013","text":"Item 60 is the authorization to opt the City of Phoenix employee retirement pension system funding policy.","fingerprint":"654d4673ed19","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00893","start_s":2851.524,"end_s":2852.145,"video_s":4711.524,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00196","chapter":"C013","text":"Vice Mayor?","fingerprint":"9a95bf6095c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00894","start_s":2852.125,"end_s":2860.815,"video_s":4712.125,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00197","chapter":"C013","text":"Motion to approve per the staff recommendation and adopt the annual COPERS pension funding policy and acknowledge the assets and liabilities of the COPERS plan.","fingerprint":"1195bf47fbb1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00895","start_s":2861.215,"end_s":2861.536,"video_s":4721.215,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00197","chapter":"C013","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00896","start_s":2862.116,"end_s":2865.68,"video_s":4722.116,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00198","chapter":"C013","text":"We have a motion and second, noting Councilwoman Stark will not participate in this item.","fingerprint":"175b71ba489f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00897","start_s":2865.76,"end_s":2866.341,"video_s":4725.76,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00198","chapter":"C013","text":"Councilman Waring.","fingerprint":"7cf533a8b87c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00898","start_s":2866.641,"end_s":2868.443,"video_s":4726.641,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00199","chapter":"C013","text":"Mayor, I just had one thing to say.","fingerprint":"db5282b4d101","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00899","start_s":2868.483,"end_s":2870.606,"video_s":4728.483,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00199","chapter":"C013","text":"Again, compliment the staff.","fingerprint":"ba7bb9dc4e22","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00900","start_s":2870.866,"end_s":2876.192,"video_s":4730.866,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00199","chapter":"C013","text":"I think it's my third positive comment of a meeting, so I'll have to come up with a couple negatives for later just to balance things out.","fingerprint":"086d3b38dd2b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00901","start_s":2876.527,"end_s":2901.403,"video_s":4736.527,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00199","chapter":"C013","text":"but in 2020 or 2019 the unfunded pension liability for cofers was about 1.8 billion and this year we are at about 1.3 roughly by 2038 2039 there will be no unfunded liability Ed is that all correct?","fingerprint":"7bf9c8d45b4b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00902","start_s":2903.105,"end_s":2905.249,"video_s":4763.105,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00199","chapter":"C013","text":"Councilman Waring, that is correct, yes.","fingerprint":"a3cac5c4a94a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00903","start_s":2905.67,"end_s":2911.16,"video_s":4765.67,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00199","chapter":"C013","text":"I mean, that's a remarkable accomplishment when you look at the graph I'm looking at when they briefed me in the office.","fingerprint":"113a3011bc5f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00904","start_s":2911.2,"end_s":2924.826,"video_s":4771.2,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00199","chapter":"C013","text":"In 2013, we sent something to citizens and they passed it and it worked, so really the compliment goes to the citizens of Phoenix, but appreciate Ed and the staff because you were city manager then, if I remember correctly.","fingerprint":"ccae55e8c737","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00905","start_s":2925.683,"end_s":2950.138,"video_s":4785.683,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00199","chapter":"C013","text":"you know it is it does show that working together things can get done and this trajectory is fantastic it is maybe not unprecedented around the country but it's not the norm certainly around the country and I think the city of Phoenix for the I think it's about 35 percent of the workforce that are in COPERS at least that's a dated number but that's sort of what I remember you're nodding but that's basically accurate that's the pension system that we control","fingerprint":"cf486db61749","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00906","start_s":2950.743,"end_s":2951.985,"video_s":4810.743,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00199","chapter":"C013","text":"and we're controlling it very well.","fingerprint":"8cbea0d45320","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00907","start_s":2952.405,"end_s":2953.527,"video_s":4812.405,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00199","chapter":"C013","text":"I guess I'll just put it that way.","fingerprint":"140ad2d5b7bb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00908","start_s":2953.567,"end_s":2957.031,"video_s":4813.567,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00199","chapter":"C013","text":"And so I just wanted to compliment you and your team on a great effort.","fingerprint":"cb722587256f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00909","start_s":2958.533,"end_s":2960.295,"video_s":4818.533,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00200","chapter":"C013","text":"Mayor, Councilman Waring, thank you for that.","fingerprint":"99037b7ef107","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00910","start_s":2960.335,"end_s":2962.058,"video_s":4820.335,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00200","chapter":"C013","text":"For the staff, they do work very hard.","fingerprint":"c9f95c057905","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00911","start_s":2962.098,"end_s":2965.642,"video_s":4822.098,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00200","chapter":"C013","text":"Our finance department and budget and research have collaborated over the years.","fingerprint":"503598964909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00912","start_s":2965.702,"end_s":2967.945,"video_s":4825.702,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00200","chapter":"C013","text":"I'm glad you acknowledged that the voters voted.","fingerprint":"53895e4fb2b2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00913","start_s":2968.005,"end_s":2974.714,"video_s":4828.005,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00200","chapter":"C013","text":"I would also acknowledge that the city council has adopted a series of policies that are not easy, but have been very effective.","fingerprint":"961f63cd4b3d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00914","start_s":2975.155,"end_s":2980.041,"video_s":4835.155,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00200","chapter":"C013","text":"As you mentioned, the city of Phoenix employee retirement system","fingerprint":"d2f2da2403b5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00915","start_s":2980.021,"end_s":2985.229,"video_s":4840.021,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00200","chapter":"C013","text":"among the lowest funded city systems 15 years ago.","fingerprint":"cb4401a9b6a1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00916","start_s":2985.75,"end_s":2990.678,"video_s":4845.75,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00200","chapter":"C013","text":"And today we are among the best funded large city pensions in the United States.","fingerprint":"f731b0de7084","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00917","start_s":2991.018,"end_s":2996.447,"video_s":4851.018,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00200","chapter":"C013","text":"And as you said, that's a team effort, but the council has adopted significant policies to make that the case.","fingerprint":"5d541c4e67f9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00918","start_s":2996.467,"end_s":3000.653,"video_s":4856.467,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00200","chapter":"C013","text":"So thank you for that.","fingerprint":"dc62dd93c0fb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00919","start_s":3000.673,"end_s":3003.698,"video_s":4860.673,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00201","chapter":"C013","text":"Thank you, Councilman, and good recognition for our finance team.","fingerprint":"1183c8448f46","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00920","start_s":3003.718,"end_s":3007.223,"video_s":4863.718,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00201","chapter":"C013","text":"They've had several innovative and important items on today's agenda.","fingerprint":"3c3a100c44bf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00921","start_s":3007.584,"end_s":3008.205,"video_s":4867.584,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00201","chapter":"C013","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00922","start_s":3008.725,"end_s":3009.266,"video_s":4868.725,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00202","chapter":"C013","text":"Guardado?","fingerprint":"0344b48c3f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00923","start_s":3009.707,"end_s":3009.947,"video_s":4869.707,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00202","chapter":"C013","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00924","start_s":3010.448,"end_s":3010.848,"video_s":4870.448,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00202","chapter":"C013","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00925","start_s":3011.049,"end_s":3011.71,"video_s":4871.049,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00202","chapter":"C013","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00926","start_s":3011.73,"end_s":3012.391,"video_s":4871.73,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00202","chapter":"C013","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00927","start_s":3012.411,"end_s":3012.671,"video_s":4872.411,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00202","chapter":"C013","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00928","start_s":3013.032,"end_s":3013.473,"video_s":4873.032,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00202","chapter":"C013","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00929","start_s":3013.493,"end_s":3014.494,"video_s":4873.493,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00202","chapter":"C013","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00930","start_s":3014.514,"end_s":3015.055,"video_s":4874.514,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00202","chapter":"C013","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00931","start_s":3015.355,"end_s":3015.596,"video_s":4875.355,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00203","chapter":"C013","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00932","start_s":3016.157,"end_s":3018.38,"video_s":4876.157,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00204","chapter":"C013","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00933","start_s":3018.4,"end_s":3019.161,"video_s":4878.4,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00204","chapter":"C013","text":"Sorry, I apologize.","fingerprint":"b45803d4c7b3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00934","start_s":3019.562,"end_s":3020.403,"video_s":4879.562,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00204","chapter":"C013","text":"Stark has a conflict.","fingerprint":"6dff7f7d6327","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00935","start_s":3020.423,"end_s":3020.704,"video_s":4880.423,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00204","chapter":"C013","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00936","start_s":3021.946,"end_s":3022.026,"video_s":4881.946,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00204","chapter":"C013","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00937","start_s":3022.046,"end_s":3022.627,"video_s":4882.046,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00204","chapter":"C013","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00938","start_s":3022.867,"end_s":3023.128,"video_s":4882.867,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00204","chapter":"C013","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00939","start_s":3023.408,"end_s":3023.809,"video_s":4883.408,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00204","chapter":"C013","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00940","start_s":3024.069,"end_s":3024.27,"video_s":4884.069,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00204","chapter":"C013","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00941","start_s":3024.57,"end_s":3025.512,"video_s":4884.57,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00205","chapter":"C013","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00942","start_s":3025.532,"end_s":3026.213,"video_s":4885.532,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00205","chapter":"C013","text":"Passes 8-0.","fingerprint":"f9a0ca3f6107","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00943","start_s":3027.134,"end_s":3035.928,"video_s":4887.134,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00206","chapter":"C014","text":"We next go to item 80, which is a request to seek council authorization to extend, to exceed the eight-hour rule to research and develop options for minimum wage.","fingerprint":"9d8580a815b1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00944","start_s":3035.968,"end_s":3036.589,"video_s":4895.968,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00206","chapter":"C014","text":"Vice Mayor?","fingerprint":"9a95bf6095c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00945","start_s":3037.345,"end_s":3038.768,"video_s":4897.345,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00206","chapter":"C014","text":"Motion to approve item 80.","fingerprint":"7ea1a328a43a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00946","start_s":3039.129,"end_s":3039.49,"video_s":4899.129,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00206","chapter":"C014","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00947","start_s":3040.072,"end_s":3042.538,"video_s":4900.072,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00206","chapter":"C014","text":"We have a motion and a second.","fingerprint":"7451ba811637","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00948","start_s":3044.082,"end_s":3045.966,"video_s":4904.082,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00206","chapter":"C014","text":"Does anyone want to speak before public comment?","fingerprint":"462f1bf278d9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00949","start_s":3046.307,"end_s":3047.67,"video_s":4906.307,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00207","chapter":"C014","text":"No, we can go to public comment.","fingerprint":"7ef7a1e2eb17","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00950","start_s":3047.811,"end_s":3048.192,"video_s":4907.811,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00207","chapter":"C014","text":"All right.","fingerprint":"dfbdd9492bec","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00951","start_s":3049.114,"end_s":3050.698,"video_s":4909.114,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00208","chapter":"C014","text":"We do have two speakers on this item.","fingerprint":"4b66c4f146be","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00952","start_s":3050.778,"end_s":3052.823,"video_s":4910.778,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00208","chapter":"C014","text":"We'll begin with Nicole followed by Janae.","fingerprint":"36955a399351","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00953","start_s":3067.349,"end_s":3068.33,"video_s":4927.349,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00209","chapter":"C014","text":"Good afternoon, everyone.","fingerprint":"56b4592a53d0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00954","start_s":3069.351,"end_s":3070.432,"video_s":4929.351,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00209","chapter":"C014","text":"My name is Nicole Ray.","fingerprint":"62119bfd57a1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00955","start_s":3070.472,"end_s":3073.996,"video_s":4930.472,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00209","chapter":"C014","text":"I'm a wheelchair assistant at Sky Harbor International Airport.","fingerprint":"21dce5b8349d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00956","start_s":3074.756,"end_s":3080.422,"video_s":4934.756,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00209","chapter":"C014","text":"I'm speaking in support of increasing the minimum wage for workers at city facilities like Sky Harbor where I work.","fingerprint":"ce7792a0618f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00957","start_s":3081.223,"end_s":3088.59,"video_s":4941.223,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00209","chapter":"C014","text":"I love my job, but I am paid just the minimum wage of $15.15 an hour and rely on tips from passengers to help.","fingerprint":"370e6beb9279","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00958","start_s":3089.491,"end_s":3097.018,"video_s":4949.491,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00209","chapter":"C014","text":"But tips aren't reliable, and we shouldn't depend on the kindness of strangers to supplement our low wages while the major airlines we serve","fingerprint":"fb770407ee5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00959","start_s":3097.538,"end_s":3101.765,"video_s":4957.538,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00209","chapter":"C014","text":"are making record revenue and pay their CEOs tens of millions a year.","fingerprint":"396c30a4538a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00960","start_s":3101.805,"end_s":3103.387,"video_s":4961.805,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00209","chapter":"C014","text":"They have the money.","fingerprint":"8281eba5eb40","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00961","start_s":3103.428,"end_s":3105.891,"video_s":4963.428,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00209","chapter":"C014","text":"They can make sure we're paid fairly, but they aren't.","fingerprint":"b2af6f0d2912","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00962","start_s":3106.673,"end_s":3115.146,"video_s":4966.673,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00209","chapter":"C014","text":"So we need the city to take swift action and set a $25 an hour living wage, which is the bare minimum we need to live as costs keep skyrocketing.","fingerprint":"df5b25bd5a17","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00963","start_s":3115.186,"end_s":3119.213,"video_s":4975.186,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00209","chapter":"C014","text":"It's hard as a single mother of two young boys to make ends meet.","fingerprint":"6980d6eb0b7e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00964","start_s":3119.634,"end_s":3123.58,"video_s":4979.634,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00209","chapter":"C014","text":"I had to stop taking medications I depended on because I couldn't afford them.","fingerprint":"7422cca35a71","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00965","start_s":3124.15,"end_s":3126.692,"video_s":4984.15,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00209","chapter":"C014","text":"It was either medicine or food for my two young sons.","fingerprint":"1ebca3769d45","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00966","start_s":3127.033,"end_s":3128.994,"video_s":4987.033,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00209","chapter":"C014","text":"And as a single mother, the choice was easy.","fingerprint":"80f643ed56a2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00967","start_s":3129.034,"end_s":3139.844,"video_s":4989.034,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00209","chapter":"C014","text":"What's even worse, the major airlines supported the legislation that slashed access to health care for millions of working people like myself.","fingerprint":"57b4313f15dd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00968","start_s":3140.645,"end_s":3143.147,"video_s":5000.645,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00209","chapter":"C014","text":"The airlines are actively working to make my life worse.","fingerprint":"a949e1fe5fa8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00969","start_s":3143.687,"end_s":3150.213,"video_s":5003.687,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00209","chapter":"C014","text":"I live paycheck to paycheck and not a day goes by that I don't worry about how I'll pay for rent, bills, medication, and food.","fingerprint":"04c1394714a1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00970","start_s":3151.094,"end_s":3152.115,"video_s":5011.094,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00209","chapter":"C014","text":"I'm tired of helping them.","fingerprint":"23edd1f5c9b3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00971","start_s":3152.416,"end_s":3156.22,"video_s":5012.416,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00209","chapter":"C014","text":"helping make the airlines and their CEOs richer and richer while I struggle.","fingerprint":"2b4be295dd50","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00972","start_s":3156.721,"end_s":3157.722,"video_s":5016.721,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00209","chapter":"C014","text":"The system is broken.","fingerprint":"8e52ada5ac31","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00973","start_s":3157.782,"end_s":3160.785,"video_s":5017.782,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00209","chapter":"C014","text":"The city can fix it.","fingerprint":"04e1fce6c9df","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00974","start_s":3160.805,"end_s":3165.511,"video_s":5020.805,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00209","chapter":"C014","text":"25 an hour would mean my children don't go hungry and that I can provide for my family.","fingerprint":"7fe1ed88885e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00975","start_s":3165.531,"end_s":3174.601,"video_s":5025.531,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00209","chapter":"C014","text":"It would mean our essential jobs are valued, that the airport has a fully staffed, well-trained, and experienced workforce to keep travelers and the public safe.","fingerprint":"48f637e0ae33","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00976","start_s":3175.202,"end_s":3177.564,"video_s":5035.202,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00209","chapter":"C014","text":"I hope you will all work to make this happen quickly.","fingerprint":"00d520d2b723","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00977","start_s":3177.604,"end_s":3178.305,"video_s":5037.604,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00209","chapter":"C014","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00978","start_s":3192.511,"end_s":3198.056,"video_s":5052.511,"speaker":"v17","turn":"T00210","chapter":"C014","text":"Hello, my name is Janae Vandekerk, and I work at a ticket counter at Sky Harbor International Airport.","fingerprint":"97e6be3efcd9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00979","start_s":3198.777,"end_s":3210.267,"video_s":5058.777,"speaker":"v17","turn":"T00210","chapter":"C014","text":"I'm really happy the mayor and the city council are taking action to address the poverty wage crisis impacting workers in the city of Phoenix and airport service workers who service airlines at Sky Harbor.","fingerprint":"d75bab4a0e8d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00980","start_s":3211.128,"end_s":3213.43,"video_s":5071.128,"speaker":"v17","turn":"T00210","chapter":"C014","text":"Numerous companies contract with the airlines.","fingerprint":"cedbca11d352","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00981","start_s":3213.93,"end_s":3220.416,"video_s":5073.93,"speaker":"v17","turn":"T00210","chapter":"C014","text":"Contractor workers not only help passengers who need wheelchair assistance, but make sure their cabins are clean and safe.","fingerprint":"840bf02f4250","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00982","start_s":3220.616,"end_s":3222.518,"video_s":5080.616,"speaker":"v17","turn":"T00210","chapter":"C014","text":"We load and unload baggage.","fingerprint":"7c2c4eb88245","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00983","start_s":3222.498,"end_s":3225.389,"video_s":5082.498,"speaker":"v17","turn":"T00210","chapter":"C014","text":"We help passengers at the ticket counter and at the gate.","fingerprint":"8e6dfc329606","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00984","start_s":3225.851,"end_s":3232.255,"video_s":5085.851,"speaker":"v17","turn":"T00210","chapter":"C014","text":"Contract workers manage flights and are responsible for the safety of passengers and the airplanes.","fingerprint":"b47fa356c548","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00985","start_s":3232.91,"end_s":3238.756,"video_s":5092.91,"speaker":"v17","turn":"T00210","chapter":"C014","text":"We help airlines make billions every year, but too many of us struggle to afford rent, groceries, and pay bills.","fingerprint":"c9c76bc04364","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00986","start_s":3239.696,"end_s":3250.727,"video_s":5099.696,"speaker":"v17","turn":"T00210","chapter":"C014","text":"Since 2022, airline CEOs have doubled and even tripled their pay, while airport workers like me have not seen our wages budge, while every other cost has skyrocketed.","fingerprint":"5a6a7d24fed1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00987","start_s":3251.728,"end_s":3259.255,"video_s":5111.728,"speaker":"v17","turn":"T00210","chapter":"C014","text":"A single adult with no children in Maricopa County needs to be paid $25 an hour just to make ends meet, according to MIT.","fingerprint":"dd79b8756b77","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00988","start_s":3261.901,"end_s":3263.405,"video_s":5121.901,"speaker":"v17","turn":"T00210","chapter":"C014","text":"Summer travel season is here.","fingerprint":"62e7d5c019ff","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00989","start_s":3263.445,"end_s":3264.908,"video_s":5123.445,"speaker":"v17","turn":"T00210","chapter":"C014","text":"The extreme heat is here.","fingerprint":"4404231bc05e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00990","start_s":3264.969,"end_s":3272.387,"video_s":5124.969,"speaker":"v17","turn":"T00210","chapter":"C014","text":"Workers don't want to risk their health making billions for out-of-state corporations while we can't even keep our AC running.","fingerprint":"7033d294dfc3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00991","start_s":3273.189,"end_s":3279.184,"video_s":5133.189,"speaker":"v17","turn":"T00210","chapter":"C014","text":"I'm glad the city is taking this important first step to setting a fair wage for workers across the city.","fingerprint":"8fb753df1354","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00992","start_s":3279.164,"end_s":3287.219,"video_s":5139.164,"speaker":"v17","turn":"T00210","chapter":"C014","text":"I would like to reshare a report about the impact of a $25 wage standard for airport workers that was conducted by Arizona State University last year.","fingerprint":"dfd27a7a8bcb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00993","start_s":3287.239,"end_s":3293.971,"video_s":5147.239,"speaker":"v17","turn":"T00210","chapter":"C014","text":"It shows that a fair wage for us means better sky harbor for everyone while having no impact on the city budget.","fingerprint":"34ce280bec6c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00994","start_s":3294.392,"end_s":3300.042,"video_s":5154.392,"speaker":"v17","turn":"T00210","chapter":"C014","text":"And it would mean millions and millions of dollars would stay in our community and not go to out-of-state companies.","fingerprint":"60929358b224","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00995","start_s":3301.912,"end_s":3310.613,"video_s":5161.912,"speaker":"v17","turn":"T00210","chapter":"C014","text":"$25 an hour is what we need to keep our airport safe and secure and to build a stable, experienced workforce.","fingerprint":"443b2157c608","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00996","start_s":3311.395,"end_s":3316.107,"video_s":5171.395,"speaker":"v17","turn":"T00210","chapter":"C014","text":"I encourage you to vote yes and take swift action to implement $25 an hour.","fingerprint":"f62245db78cf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00997","start_s":3321.52,"end_s":3322.541,"video_s":5181.52,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00211","chapter":"C014","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00998","start_s":3322.621,"end_s":3324.663,"video_s":5182.621,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00211","chapter":"C014","text":"That concludes comments on item 80.","fingerprint":"b9066690be35","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00999","start_s":3325.024,"end_s":3329.489,"video_s":5185.024,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00211","chapter":"C014","text":"We have two related votes and I'm going to do one comment on both of them.","fingerprint":"2558a9ebc7a4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01000","start_s":3330.29,"end_s":3338.759,"video_s":5190.29,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00211","chapter":"C014","text":"When I was just elected mayor, one of the first things we were able to do was raise the minimum wage for our city employees to $15 an hour.","fingerprint":"dafbf38bed2f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01001","start_s":3338.859,"end_s":3346.127,"video_s":5198.859,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00211","chapter":"C014","text":"It was a great vote, unanimous vote at the Phoenix City Council because we wanted to do right by our city employees.","fingerprint":"c56d35dd74c3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01002","start_s":3346.107,"end_s":3372.283,"video_s":5206.107,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00211","chapter":"C014","text":"however that has not aged incredibly well now the minimum wage for the entire state is above $15 an hour and so I think it's time to take a look at what we're doing as the cost of basic goods rise in our country we want to make sure we're doing our part to ensure those working for the City of Phoenix and at city facilities are able to earn a fair and living wage I'm grateful to have partners including Vice Mayor Hodge Washington and Councilwoman Guardado in that mission","fingerprint":"05ebde4fdfe8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01003","start_s":3373.276,"end_s":3384.288,"video_s":5233.276,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00211","chapter":"C014","text":"This vote gives our staff direction to research how wages are keeping up and what possibilities are open to this council to address any shortcomings that we may have.","fingerprint":"8453318cab64","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01004","start_s":3384.948,"end_s":3394.719,"video_s":5244.948,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00211","chapter":"C014","text":"It's also, in the next item, an opportunity to give staff the opportunity to research how we can keep as many people in their jobs as possible when contractors at a city facility change.","fingerprint":"882890ee29fc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01005","start_s":3395.159,"end_s":3398.963,"video_s":5255.159,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00211","chapter":"C014","text":"That has been an issue for us recently and we want to do what we can.","fingerprint":"ba17325626d0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01006","start_s":3398.943,"end_s":3405.96,"video_s":5258.943,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00211","chapter":"C014","text":"This vote begins a significant stakeholder process to get input from a wide range of people and organizations who do work with the city.","fingerprint":"b82596c55615","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01007","start_s":3406.361,"end_s":3409.308,"video_s":5266.361,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00211","chapter":"C014","text":"If you have any ideas, my office wants to hear from you.","fingerprint":"3223c91242a4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01008","start_s":3410.37,"end_s":3413.398,"video_s":5270.37,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00211","chapter":"C014","text":"We really appreciate people being involved in this stakeholder process.","fingerprint":"6ac38b76cefe","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01009","start_s":3413.578,"end_s":3414.42,"video_s":5273.578,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00211","chapter":"C014","text":"Councilwoman Guardado.","fingerprint":"725cada514c9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01010","start_s":3415.784,"end_s":3416.485,"video_s":5275.784,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C014","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01011","start_s":3416.626,"end_s":3419.612,"video_s":5276.626,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C014","text":"I just want to thank everyone that is here today.","fingerprint":"317eda9ceb9b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01012","start_s":3419.632,"end_s":3436.206,"video_s":5279.632,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C014","text":"A special thank you to Mayor Gallego, to Vice Mayor Hodge Washington, and my colleagues in bringing forward this request to explore options for strengthening wages and workforce stability for the people who serve the City of Phoenix every day.","fingerprint":"d84ecaf905a1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01013","start_s":3436.186,"end_s":3443.158,"video_s":5296.186,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C014","text":"Our employees keep our parks open, maintain our streets, and respond to emergencies, support our residents.","fingerprint":"de6133952632","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01014","start_s":3443.759,"end_s":3448.608,"video_s":5303.759,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C014","text":"And at the airport, we are the friendliest airport in the country, as people have said.","fingerprint":"cd63f20a7e61","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01015","start_s":3449.028,"end_s":3452.895,"video_s":5309.028,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C014","text":"But that is thanks to all of the workers that work in that airport.","fingerprint":"c1ba737d0a2a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01016","start_s":3452.875,"end_s":3466.217,"video_s":5312.875,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C014","text":"that continue to smile to all of our travelers that continue to travel to Phoenix to making sure that the coffee looks right, that the bagels are amazing, that the airplanes are clean, and that the wheelchairs work.","fingerprint":"cb5d6155c72d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01017","start_s":3466.718,"end_s":3472.367,"video_s":5326.718,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C014","text":"And we make sure that we take care of everyone that steps into Sky Harbor Airport.","fingerprint":"59afda30bbe8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01018","start_s":3472.407,"end_s":3479.018,"video_s":5332.407,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C014","text":"So to all of the workers, to everyone, thank you guys all so much for the work that you guys do day in and day out.","fingerprint":"097dbc0e65b2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01019","start_s":3478.998,"end_s":3491.132,"video_s":5338.998,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C014","text":"As the cost of living continues to rise, it is appropriate for us to evaluate whether our compensation policies are keeping pace with the realities facing working families.","fingerprint":"023367d28bf5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01020","start_s":3491.152,"end_s":3493.654,"video_s":5351.152,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C014","text":"This item does not establish a new wage today.","fingerprint":"cfca16d0df6a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01021","start_s":3493.714,"end_s":3507.57,"video_s":5353.714,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C014","text":"It simply asks staff to conduct a thoughtful analysis of options, fiscal impacts and strategies that could improve recruitment, retention and workforce stability while remaining fiscally responsible.","fingerprint":"926ba18e00e8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01022","start_s":3508.04,"end_s":3510.564,"video_s":5368.04,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C014","text":"For me, this issue is not theoretical.","fingerprint":"4fc879d9e71f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01023","start_s":3511.084,"end_s":3530.993,"video_s":5371.084,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C014","text":"I am personally aware of at least four individuals working in positions connected to city operations, three employed by Aramark and one by HMS Holtz working at Phoenix Sky Harbor Airport who are currently experiencing homelessness and staying at St. Vincent de Paul shelter.","fingerprint":"8c82065a76a5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01024","start_s":3531.26,"end_s":3539.652,"video_s":5391.26,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C014","text":"These individuals go to work every day, contribute to our community, and yet still struggle to afford a place to live.","fingerprint":"35b2b36cfebe","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01025","start_s":3540.854,"end_s":3542.877,"video_s":5400.854,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C014","text":"Quite frankly, this is unacceptable.","fingerprint":"eb94da61f61b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01026","start_s":3543.839,"end_s":3552.171,"video_s":5403.839,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C014","text":"No one who works hard and helps keep our city running should have to wonder where they're going to sleep at night.","fingerprint":"b90f62c962b4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01027","start_s":3552.235,"end_s":3566.363,"video_s":5412.235,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C014","text":"While we recognize that housing affordability is a complex challenge, we also have a responsibility to examine whether compensation policies for workers serving city facilities are part of the solution.","fingerprint":"e9e4af3fcbe0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01028","start_s":3566.528,"end_s":3575.001,"video_s":5426.528,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C014","text":"I also appreciate that this request examines ways to support contracted workers when vendor contracts change.","fingerprint":"133c54b2e544","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01029","start_s":3575.101,"end_s":3575.983,"video_s":5435.101,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C014","text":"That is the next item.","fingerprint":"6564aa79a427","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01030","start_s":3576.564,"end_s":3585.718,"video_s":5436.564,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C014","text":"These workers are an important part of delivering services to our residents and workforce continuity benefits both employees and in the public.","fingerprint":"41ef008286da","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01031","start_s":3585.698,"end_s":3615.418,"video_s":5445.698,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C014","text":"we saw a situation that happened last year with with a lot of workers that were displaced some of the workers were able to get jobs and some of those workers continue to be unemployed till this day and we need to make sure that as the city we do the best that we can to keep everyone employed and again I applaud my colleagues our city manager our attorneys everyone that's working incredibly hard on this we've done so much work we did","fingerprint":"5ddfc25a695e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01032","start_s":3615.398,"end_s":3617.462,"video_s":5475.398,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C014","text":"We did the heat ordinance last year.","fingerprint":"665b84ad84a8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01033","start_s":3617.483,"end_s":3632.395,"video_s":5477.483,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C014","text":"We will continue to work with everyone that is affected by this and I'm very grateful to be sitting here in front of all of you as we continue to work on this and we continue to build a better city","fingerprint":"baaecb4ccc61","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01034","start_s":3632.375,"end_s":3651.362,"video_s":5492.375,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C014","text":"It is true that workers are the ones that make our state what it is, make our city what it is, and we are open, my office is open to talking to anyone who wants to talk about this and to making sure that we're being responsible and that we're giving everyone everything that they need.","fingerprint":"8fd1eadcb56f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01035","start_s":3651.342,"end_s":3665.939,"video_s":5511.342,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C014","text":"to making sure that we continue to lead as the fifth largest city in the country and that we continue to compensate our workers in making sure that we keep everyone out of homelessness and that no one is one paycheck away from being homeless.","fingerprint":"db98b7968da3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01036","start_s":3665.96,"end_s":3667.343,"video_s":5525.96,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C014","text":"Thank you so much, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d116fbf480ee","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01037","start_s":3667.323,"end_s":3667.844,"video_s":5527.323,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C014","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01038","start_s":3668.044,"end_s":3668.725,"video_s":5528.044,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C014","text":"Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"9a95bf6095c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01039","start_s":3668.745,"end_s":3669.806,"video_s":5528.745,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00213","chapter":"C014","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01040","start_s":3670.207,"end_s":3677.396,"video_s":5530.207,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00213","chapter":"C014","text":"I also want to just say thank you to Mayor Gallego and Councilman Gallego for allowing me to join you in bringing this item forward.","fingerprint":"aff55c08cb5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01041","start_s":3677.856,"end_s":3688.47,"video_s":5537.856,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00213","chapter":"C014","text":"Over the past several years, Phoenix has made significant progress in strengthening recruitment and retention, but we also know that rising costs continues to place pressures on working families throughout our city.","fingerprint":"5fa8c7e0c37a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01042","start_s":3688.45,"end_s":3695.799,"video_s":5548.45,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00213","chapter":"C014","text":"This request will ensure that we have the information necessary to make thoughtful, data-driven decisions about our workforce.","fingerprint":"e5e6e9bc9c18","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01043","start_s":3695.819,"end_s":3708.754,"video_s":5555.819,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00213","chapter":"C014","text":"This item will allow staff to evaluate our current compensation levels, examine options available to the city, analyze the fiscal impacts, and help us better understand how compensation affects workforce stability, recruitment, and retention.","fingerprint":"1e5c2f08da29","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01044","start_s":3709.495,"end_s":3717.985,"video_s":5569.495,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00213","chapter":"C014","text":"Simultaneously, this item seeks to ensure that any option presented remains fiscally responsible and aligned with what the city can sustainably afford.","fingerprint":"0dd33299535e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01045","start_s":3717.965,"end_s":3725.257,"video_s":5577.965,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00213","chapter":"C014","text":"Our employees and the workers who provide services on behalf of the city are essential to delivering the services residents expect and deserve.","fingerprint":"190b6d5f4958","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01046","start_s":3726.018,"end_s":3741.964,"video_s":5586.018,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00213","chapter":"C014","text":"The intent of this request is not to establish a policy today, rather to help us better understand what options may be available to the city, what legal considerations exist, and what impacts should a policy be implemented have on our workers, contractors, and city operation.","fingerprint":"a8be5691a49d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01047","start_s":3741.944,"end_s":3747.497,"video_s":5601.944,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00213","chapter":"C014","text":"I appreciate my colleagues who've joined this effort and I look forward to reviewing the analysis when it comes back to council.","fingerprint":"b0373860cc7a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01048","start_s":3748.099,"end_s":3748.459,"video_s":5608.099,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00213","chapter":"C014","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01049","start_s":3750.364,"end_s":3752.95,"video_s":5610.364,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00214","chapter":"C014","text":"Thank you so much Councilman Hernandez.","fingerprint":"d8b9ad401c68","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01050","start_s":3753.453,"end_s":3754.034,"video_s":5613.453,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00215","chapter":"C014","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01051","start_s":3754.635,"end_s":3756.258,"video_s":5614.635,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00215","chapter":"C014","text":"First, I just want to thank the speakers.","fingerprint":"a2fb001065b3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01052","start_s":3756.559,"end_s":3764.715,"video_s":5616.559,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00215","chapter":"C014","text":"It's not always easy to be so vulnerable with your experience and your struggles when you come to these meetings.","fingerprint":"8d75c02bd83b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01053","start_s":3764.755,"end_s":3770.246,"video_s":5624.755,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00215","chapter":"C014","text":"So thank you so much for being willing to share your experience and why this item is so important.","fingerprint":"126472eca54b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01054","start_s":3770.967,"end_s":3773.031,"video_s":5630.967,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00215","chapter":"C014","text":"On the retention side, Ray, I think","fingerprint":"a350a208b27c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01055","start_s":3773.011,"end_s":3795.643,"video_s":5633.011,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00215","chapter":"C014","text":"We need to look at that part of that is looking at turnover right like we got to look at this as an investment because as you know we as a city and other other partners look at our retention overall if we continue to see a trend where we're having turnover in our workforce that actually costs us more money right that's more training so","fingerprint":"546d8eb43228","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01056","start_s":3795.623,"end_s":3797.966,"video_s":5655.623,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00215","chapter":"C014","text":"That's why I'm very supportive of this.","fingerprint":"a1b384cb34d4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01057","start_s":3798.367,"end_s":3812.807,"video_s":5658.367,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00215","chapter":"C014","text":"I think this is a step in the right direction to look at how can we make sure that we're doing our part to really tackle and end poverty in the city of Phoenix so that our workers can thrive right in our community.","fingerprint":"541c2efc6132","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01058","start_s":3812.827,"end_s":3815.591,"video_s":5672.827,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00215","chapter":"C014","text":"So thank you so much for everybody that has done so much work on this.","fingerprint":"12ee78f724a9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01059","start_s":3817.033,"end_s":3817.834,"video_s":5677.033,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00216","chapter":"C014","text":"Councilwoman Pastor.","fingerprint":"dbcef12e9415","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01060","start_s":3818.945,"end_s":3825.519,"video_s":5678.945,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00216","chapter":"C014","text":"I would just like to thank the airport workers and those that have been coming in front of us speaking about this.","fingerprint":"93f56f4a5ecb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01061","start_s":3826.401,"end_s":3831.152,"video_s":5686.401,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00216","chapter":"C014","text":"As you can see, we've gotten it to the eight-hour rule.","fingerprint":"28b6a52c913c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01062","start_s":3831.392,"end_s":3833.637,"video_s":5691.392,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00216","chapter":"C014","text":"We just need to keep it moving and do the research.","fingerprint":"996c81753b53","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01063","start_s":3835.04,"end_s":3838.287,"video_s":5695.04,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00216","chapter":"C014","text":"I believe the research and what we will discover","fingerprint":"2f75317e0287","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01064","start_s":3838.267,"end_s":3840.431,"video_s":5698.267,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00216","chapter":"C014","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01065","start_s":3840.952,"end_s":3856.242,"video_s":5700.952,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00216","chapter":"C014","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01066","start_s":3856.222,"end_s":3864.112,"video_s":5716.222,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00216","chapter":"C014","text":"So I want to give voice back to you because you brought it to our attention and you have been consistent in being here.","fingerprint":"e33ffd3c28f2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01067","start_s":3864.152,"end_s":3874.585,"video_s":5724.152,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00216","chapter":"C014","text":"I also want to thank Councilwoman Guardado who has really been leading along with Councilwoman Hodge Washington and the Mayor.","fingerprint":"8c93a1d2b595","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01068","start_s":3875.686,"end_s":3882.094,"video_s":5735.686,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00216","chapter":"C014","text":"She deserves kudos because she is and breathes","fingerprint":"fb531b55a60a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01069","start_s":3883.103,"end_s":3886.969,"video_s":5743.103,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00216","chapter":"C014","text":"the passion of pushing for workers' compensation and rights.","fingerprint":"dfa60e792e73","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01070","start_s":3886.989,"end_s":3889.393,"video_s":5746.989,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00216","chapter":"C014","text":"So thank you, appreciate you.","fingerprint":"4f57675ad99b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01071","start_s":3891.376,"end_s":3891.737,"video_s":5751.376,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00216","chapter":"C014","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01072","start_s":3893.479,"end_s":3893.96,"video_s":5753.479,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00217","chapter":"C014","text":"Guardado?","fingerprint":"0344b48c3f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01073","start_s":3894.241,"end_s":3894.481,"video_s":5754.241,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00217","chapter":"C014","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01074","start_s":3894.902,"end_s":3895.342,"video_s":5754.902,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00217","chapter":"C014","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01075","start_s":3895.563,"end_s":3895.783,"video_s":5755.563,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00217","chapter":"C014","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01076","start_s":3896.264,"end_s":3896.684,"video_s":5756.264,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00217","chapter":"C014","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01077","start_s":3897.025,"end_s":3897.285,"video_s":5757.025,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00217","chapter":"C014","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01078","start_s":3897.666,"end_s":3898.187,"video_s":5757.666,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00217","chapter":"C014","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01079","start_s":3898.407,"end_s":3899.048,"video_s":5758.407,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00217","chapter":"C014","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01080","start_s":3899.068,"end_s":3899.569,"video_s":5759.068,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00217","chapter":"C014","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01081","start_s":3899.689,"end_s":3900.35,"video_s":5759.689,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00217","chapter":"C014","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01082","start_s":3900.37,"end_s":3900.731,"video_s":5760.37,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00217","chapter":"C014","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01083","start_s":3900.991,"end_s":3901.232,"video_s":5760.991,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00217","chapter":"C014","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01084","start_s":3901.632,"end_s":3901.973,"video_s":5761.632,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00217","chapter":"C014","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01085","start_s":3902.634,"end_s":3902.714,"video_s":5762.634,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00217","chapter":"C014","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01086","start_s":3902.734,"end_s":3903.395,"video_s":5762.734,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00217","chapter":"C014","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01087","start_s":3903.515,"end_s":3903.776,"video_s":5763.515,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00217","chapter":"C014","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01088","start_s":3904.176,"end_s":3904.577,"video_s":5764.176,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00217","chapter":"C014","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01089","start_s":3905.198,"end_s":3905.398,"video_s":5765.198,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00217","chapter":"C014","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01090","start_s":3905.679,"end_s":3906.58,"video_s":5765.679,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00217","chapter":"C014","text":"Passes 9-0.","fingerprint":"f7c37e75fd84","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01091","start_s":3916.111,"end_s":3922.743,"video_s":5776.111,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00218","chapter":"C015","text":"Item 81 is a related item on eight hour rule research on a potential worker retention policy.","fingerprint":"d126da937010","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01092","start_s":3923.705,"end_s":3924.146,"video_s":5783.705,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00218","chapter":"C015","text":"Vice mayor.","fingerprint":"9a95bf6095c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01093","start_s":3925.268,"end_s":3926.651,"video_s":5785.268,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00218","chapter":"C015","text":"Motion to approve item 81.","fingerprint":"de974f1a4de8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01094","start_s":3927.432,"end_s":3927.793,"video_s":5787.432,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00218","chapter":"C015","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01095","start_s":3928.274,"end_s":3929.155,"video_s":5788.274,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00218","chapter":"C015","text":"We have a motion and a second.","fingerprint":"7451ba811637","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01096","start_s":3929.175,"end_s":3931.76,"video_s":5789.175,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00218","chapter":"C015","text":"We do have five members of the public here to speak.","fingerprint":"aa4b4b445dfb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01097","start_s":3932.141,"end_s":3935.908,"video_s":5792.141,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00218","chapter":"C015","text":"We'll begin with Lucia followed by Sophia, Sophie, Sophia.","fingerprint":"821a0d18e53f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01098","start_s":3947.954,"end_s":3949.324,"video_s":5807.954,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00218","chapter":"C015","text":"and if you wanna go right back, thanks.","fingerprint":"a17a98ab6207","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01099","start_s":3969.487,"end_s":3971.17,"video_s":5829.487,"speaker":"v18","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C015","text":"Good afternoon, Mayor and Council.","fingerprint":"1a10f4f87093","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01100","start_s":3971.21,"end_s":3978.503,"video_s":5831.21,"speaker":"v18","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C015","text":"My name is Lucia Salinas, and I have been a cook for HMS Holtz at Sky Harbor Airport since 2003.","fingerprint":"01bc78f68194","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01101","start_s":3980.547,"end_s":3991.967,"video_s":5840.547,"speaker":"v18","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C015","text":"I'm proud to be a union leader, and I was part of the effort to organize workers and bring voice to the people who keep the airport running every day.","fingerprint":"fd60742e2993","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01102","start_s":3992.437,"end_s":4002.712,"video_s":5852.437,"speaker":"v18","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C015","text":"For almost two decades, I've seen firsthand what it takes to operate one of the busiest airports in the country.","fingerprint":"5fa6a1ae5949","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01103","start_s":4004.695,"end_s":4010.404,"video_s":5864.695,"speaker":"v18","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C015","text":"The work we do requires skills, experience, and dedication.","fingerprint":"d1e50dbf3267","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01104","start_s":4012.146,"end_s":4020.739,"video_s":5872.146,"speaker":"v18","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C015","text":"When the pandemic hit our industry face in a perceived crisis, passenger traffic collapsed.","fingerprint":"c04787285014","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01105","start_s":4021.715,"end_s":4026.761,"video_s":5881.715,"speaker":"v18","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C015","text":"Flies were canceled and thousands of airport workers lost their jobs.","fingerprint":"09afe7e04139","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01106","start_s":4028.103,"end_s":4038.695,"video_s":5888.103,"speaker":"v18","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C015","text":"The city recognized that when trouble returns, the airport will need experienced workers to come back and help rebuild the industry.","fingerprint":"2cd6e3e35472","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01107","start_s":4040.237,"end_s":4046.625,"video_s":5900.237,"speaker":"v18","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C015","text":"That's why workers retention and recall protection were put in place.","fingerprint":"c3645f9c986b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01108","start_s":4047.112,"end_s":4058.514,"video_s":5907.112,"speaker":"v18","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C015","text":"Those protections gave workers who had been laid off the opportunities to return to their jobs when the war came back.","fingerprint":"a62d95b7fa4e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01109","start_s":4061.94,"end_s":4069.795,"video_s":5921.94,"speaker":"v18","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C015","text":"Today, airport workers can still lose their jobs when contracts change hands, even when the workers themselves continue.","fingerprint":"9bc676209c99","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01110","start_s":4070.264,"end_s":4074.159,"video_s":5930.264,"speaker":"v18","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C015","text":"The airport still needs trained and experienced workers.","fingerprint":"abe22b201913","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01111","start_s":4074.922,"end_s":4078.637,"video_s":5934.922,"speaker":"v18","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C015","text":"What it changed often just the name of the contract.","fingerprint":"7ab39ba26088","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01112","start_s":4081.25,"end_s":4085.797,"video_s":5941.25,"speaker":"v18","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C015","text":"A worker retention ordinance recognizes the experience matters.","fingerprint":"24d481f8e158","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01113","start_s":4086.779,"end_s":4099.379,"video_s":5946.779,"speaker":"v18","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C015","text":"It protects workers who have dedicated years for their lives to serving this airport and help ensure continuity for business travels in the city.","fingerprint":"c762ae6ad299","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01114","start_s":4100.02,"end_s":4101.142,"video_s":5960.02,"speaker":"v18","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C015","text":"I know my time is up.","fingerprint":"28a74c472782","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01115","start_s":4101.162,"end_s":4103.546,"video_s":5961.162,"speaker":"v18","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C015","text":"I didn't finish, but I hope we can.","fingerprint":"d3562c8eb0cd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01116","start_s":4103.827,"end_s":4105.89,"video_s":5963.827,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00220","chapter":"C015","text":"You'd like us to support this, okay.","fingerprint":"ee3906b89e8d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01117","start_s":4112.823,"end_s":4114.667,"video_s":5972.823,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00220","chapter":"C015","text":"Sophia is next, followed by Ansel.","fingerprint":"5c950defe522","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01118","start_s":4121.7,"end_s":4131.76,"video_s":5981.7,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C015","text":"Especially since the Republicans took over the USA in January 2025, prices of everything necessary to live have been going up while we have the same paychecks with low wages.","fingerprint":"d46a77dc074f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01119","start_s":4131.959,"end_s":4136.509,"video_s":5991.959,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C015","text":"This is why I ask you to support worker retention at the airport and increase the minimum wage.","fingerprint":"f28c67019cf8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01120","start_s":4137.03,"end_s":4152.583,"video_s":5997.03,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C015","text":"As a survivor of human trafficking, I was only able to get free by the Bernie campaign providing a union job with a living wage, free housing, free transportation to and from work, and free food for my coworkers who noticed that I was not eating during lunch breaks.","fingerprint":"48aef178153b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01121","start_s":4152.918,"end_s":4171.256,"video_s":6012.918,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C015","text":"I've also helped to successfully pass legislation to increase the minimum wage in Maryland and it took a council such as this to advance economic stability for the people since business owners were focused on hoarding the wealth created by workers to the point that people like me couldn't keep up with the cost of rent, food, and transportation so we became homeless.","fingerprint":"af07aab32115","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01122","start_s":4172.077,"end_s":4175.26,"video_s":6032.077,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C015","text":"You've outlawed feeding and providing care to homeless people in the parks.","fingerprint":"e41c2ea09ec6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01123","start_s":4175.641,"end_s":4182.428,"video_s":6035.641,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C015","text":"If you don't support worker retention, you're supporting the deaths and mass incarceration of the people who have made Phoenix function.","fingerprint":"33481e49c1c9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01124","start_s":4182.528,"end_s":4182.908,"video_s":6042.528,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C015","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01125","start_s":4189.402,"end_s":4191.144,"video_s":6049.402,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00222","chapter":"C015","text":"Anselm is next, followed by Marta.","fingerprint":"05c3e769ae2d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01126","start_s":4209.788,"end_s":4210.429,"video_s":6069.788,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C015","text":"Good afternoon, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d348a72de400","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01127","start_s":4210.469,"end_s":4211.33,"video_s":6070.469,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C015","text":"Good afternoon, Council.","fingerprint":"1fc287373b8a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01128","start_s":4212.411,"end_s":4213.353,"video_s":6072.411,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C015","text":"My name is Anselm Huggins.","fingerprint":"04ff410a65b1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01129","start_s":4213.473,"end_s":4218.379,"video_s":6073.473,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C015","text":"I've worked for RMRC for a little over 10 years, but I've only been over at the Phoenix Convention Center for about two months.","fingerprint":"f545fb0ec242","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01130","start_s":4218.73,"end_s":4225.637,"video_s":6078.73,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C015","text":"I'm here to speak to you on support for looking for potential living wage and worker retention protections for the city employees and city contracted employees.","fingerprint":"154d96551a40","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01131","start_s":4226.258,"end_s":4228.2,"video_s":6086.258,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C015","text":"Phoenix Convention Center welcomes thousands of visitors every year.","fingerprint":"3f8b8754b8b9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01132","start_s":4228.22,"end_s":4229.962,"video_s":6088.22,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C015","text":"It plays a major role in the city's economy.","fingerprint":"7ce16a71b73b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01133","start_s":4230.443,"end_s":4232.185,"video_s":6090.443,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C015","text":"It's a job I choose because I love the work I do.","fingerprint":"73d3cdef4490","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01134","start_s":4232.985,"end_s":4234.707,"video_s":6092.985,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C015","text":"And I love welcoming people to Phoenix as well.","fingerprint":"06e8a0aa2e0f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01135","start_s":4235.568,"end_s":4242.155,"video_s":6095.568,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C015","text":"However, when I hear that my brothers and sisters in the union are losing their jobs and they're losing their homes, it kind of pisses me off.","fingerprint":"764265f62d7e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01136","start_s":4242.416,"end_s":4243.657,"video_s":6102.416,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C015","text":"These are people who work hard every day.","fingerprint":"a2113793717d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01137","start_s":4243.697,"end_s":4246.56,"video_s":6103.697,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C015","text":"These are people who show up every day and put out 110%.","fingerprint":"ac054a786f6d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01138","start_s":4247.317,"end_s":4250.441,"video_s":6107.317,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C015","text":"So what happens to me, what happens to these people when they lose their jobs?","fingerprint":"c9de01314e5b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01139","start_s":4251.382,"end_s":4257.511,"video_s":6111.382,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C015","text":"Even if we have years of experience, even the work we've done, there's no guarantee unless we put in these worker retention laws.","fingerprint":"d05f1dcee5c1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01140","start_s":4258.252,"end_s":4264.861,"video_s":6118.252,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C015","text":"One thing about worker retention policy is that this is something that Phoenix Council has done before for the Phoenix Convention Center, and this also included R-Mark as well.","fingerprint":"c60ba6315ab7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01141","start_s":4266.643,"end_s":4271.69,"video_s":6126.643,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C015","text":"That being said, Phoenix has obligated companies under its contract to retain the existing workers.","fingerprint":"6fe1df26c4f3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01142","start_s":4271.75,"end_s":4274.033,"video_s":6131.75,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C015","text":"I'd like to see this continue in the future.","fingerprint":"5500f29a42a1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01143","start_s":4274.08,"end_s":4281.222,"video_s":6134.08,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C015","text":"But without a policy to make worker retention consistent in all contracts, there's nothing guaranteeing these new contracts that the workers will be retained.","fingerprint":"dc2c249b84b6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01144","start_s":4282.18,"end_s":4283.642,"video_s":6142.18,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C015","text":"Right now, I work three jobs.","fingerprint":"11f82ed5465c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01145","start_s":4284.383,"end_s":4288.37,"video_s":6144.383,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C015","text":"The reason I work three jobs is in the summer, work goes away for the hospitality industry.","fingerprint":"f3a60f2e1b62","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01146","start_s":4289.431,"end_s":4292.056,"video_s":6149.431,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C015","text":"I'm at risk of losing my apartment.","fingerprint":"8dc562abf844","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01147","start_s":4292.096,"end_s":4295.481,"video_s":6152.096,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C015","text":"I'm probably about two months behind on my bills for my energy.","fingerprint":"16f4dfaa0ba3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01148","start_s":4295.882,"end_s":4299.367,"video_s":6155.882,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C015","text":"And I think that these protections would help people in my case.","fingerprint":"b1f1fe1d71ef","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01149","start_s":4300.128,"end_s":4301.671,"video_s":6160.128,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C015","text":"And I'd like to thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"0ce1e2734735","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01150","start_s":4301.831,"end_s":4308.181,"video_s":6161.831,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C015","text":"I'd like to thank you, Councilwoman Hodge Washington and Councilwoman Quadaro for all your hard work on this endeavor.","fingerprint":"8bed117d89cf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01151","start_s":4308.361,"end_s":4308.762,"video_s":6168.361,"speaker":"v19","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C015","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01152","start_s":4317.28,"end_s":4319.422,"video_s":6177.28,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00224","chapter":"C015","text":"Marta Proxima, and then Mohammed.","fingerprint":"6579cfe0a97a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01153","start_s":4327.83,"end_s":4328.611,"video_s":6187.83,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00225","chapter":"C015","text":"MARTA PROXIMA- Buenas tardes.","fingerprint":"b80d6ff6da6a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"language","detail":"Spanish speech, transcribed as said"}]},{"id":"L01154","start_s":4328.651,"end_s":4330.232,"video_s":6188.651,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00225","chapter":"C015","text":"Mi nombre es Marta Martel.","fingerprint":"ba022f8b527c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"possible-translation","detail":"this speaker also spoke Spanish here; this English line may be a machine translation, not their words"}]},{"id":"L01155","start_s":4330.352,"end_s":4338.74,"video_s":6190.352,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00225","chapter":"C015","text":"Trabajo durante dos años para Sky Chef en la preparación de alimentos para la aerolínea del aeropuerto de Sky Harbor.","fingerprint":"9c025ce71dbf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"language","detail":"Spanish speech, transcribed as said"}]},{"id":"L01156","start_s":4338.76,"end_s":4341.302,"video_s":6198.76,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00225","chapter":"C015","text":"Trabajé en el departamento de lavaplatos.","fingerprint":"72fb064bc7b7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"language","detail":"Spanish speech, transcribed as said"}]},{"id":"L01157","start_s":4341.783,"end_s":4346.427,"video_s":6201.783,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00225","chapter":"C015","text":"A finales del 2025, mi vida y la de 200 compañeros de trabajo","fingerprint":"cce421c2c58c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"language","detail":"Spanish speech, transcribed as said"}]},{"id":"L01158","start_s":4346.407,"end_s":4350.896,"video_s":6206.407,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00225","chapter":"C015","text":"They changed forever when Sky Café lost their contract with American Airlines.","fingerprint":"7b204510bba4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"possible-translation","detail":"this speaker also spoke Spanish here; this English line may be a machine translation, not their words"}]},{"id":"L01159","start_s":4350.916,"end_s":4362.019,"video_s":6210.916,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00225","chapter":"C015","text":"In the morning they told us that we could lose our jobs despite having been in contact for years and having done nothing wrong.","fingerprint":"050709229514","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"possible-translation","detail":"this speaker also spoke Spanish here; this English line may be a machine translation, not their words"}]},{"id":"L01160","start_s":4362.117,"end_s":4372.613,"video_s":6222.117,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00225","chapter":"C015","text":"El trabajo no desapareció, los aviones siguen necesitando servicios, todavía tienen que preparar los alimentos para los aviones.","fingerprint":"fcf86a2798d8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"language","detail":"Spanish speech, transcribed as said"}]},{"id":"L01161","start_s":4372.673,"end_s":4376.098,"video_s":6232.673,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00225","chapter":"C015","text":"El aeropuerto sigue necesitando trabajadores experimentados.","fingerprint":"49f15e5ebc8e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"possible-translation","detail":"this speaker also spoke Spanish here; this English line may be a machine translation, not their words"}]},{"id":"L01162","start_s":4376.319,"end_s":4381.086,"video_s":6236.319,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00225","chapter":"C015","text":"Lo único que cambió es la empresa que tenía el contrato.","fingerprint":"2b582b58aa6c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"language","detail":"Spanish speech, transcribed as said"}]},{"id":"L01163","start_s":4382.068,"end_s":4390.2,"video_s":6242.068,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00225","chapter":"C015","text":"Mis compañeros y yo nos enfrentamos a la incertidumbre, la confusión y la...","fingerprint":"0eae255f74f0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"language","detail":"Spanish speech, transcribed as said"}]},{"id":"L01164","start_s":4390.552,"end_s":4392.867,"video_s":6250.552,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00225","chapter":"C015","text":"Thank you very much.","fingerprint":"30ce1a1e9c05","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"possible-translation","detail":"this speaker also spoke Spanish here; this English line may be a machine translation, not their words"}]},{"id":"L01165","start_s":4394.315,"end_s":4396.939,"video_s":6254.315,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00225","chapter":"C015","text":"Sustento sin tener la culpa.","fingerprint":"956da9ebdcf1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"possible-translation","detail":"this speaker also spoke Spanish here; this English line may be a machine translation, not their words"}]},{"id":"L01166","start_s":4397.5,"end_s":4408.396,"video_s":6257.5,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00225","chapter":"C015","text":"No había garantía de los trabajadores como yo que habíamos desempeñado esta labor con éxito funcionando conservando nuestro trabajo.","fingerprint":"60b913d577a8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"language","detail":"Spanish speech, transcribed as said"}]},{"id":"L01167","start_s":4408.416,"end_s":4414.104,"video_s":6268.416,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00225","chapter":"C015","text":"En este tipo de inseguridad provoca estrés, ansiedad y noche de insomnio.","fingerprint":"6d3e26d851a1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"language","detail":"Spanish speech, transcribed as said"}]},{"id":"L01168","start_s":4414.565,"end_s":4416.507,"video_s":6274.565,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00225","chapter":"C015","text":"Afecta a nuestros seres queridos.","fingerprint":"4f337eec7e08","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"possible-translation","detail":"this speaker also spoke Spanish here; this English line may be a machine translation, not their words"}]},{"id":"L01169","start_s":4416.607,"end_s":4418.43,"video_s":6276.607,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00225","chapter":"C015","text":"Afecta a nuestra salud.","fingerprint":"68e33d71e56c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"possible-translation","detail":"this speaker also spoke Spanish here; this English line may be a machine translation, not their words"}]},{"id":"L01170","start_s":4418.45,"end_s":4423.157,"video_s":6278.45,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00225","chapter":"C015","text":"No hace posible planificar el futuro.","fingerprint":"b37a2519e5bc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01171","start_s":4423.39,"end_s":4452.283,"video_s":6283.39,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00225","chapter":"C015","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01172","start_s":4458.997,"end_s":4460.779,"video_s":6318.997,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00226","chapter":"C015","text":"Hello, my name is Marta Martel.","fingerprint":"273e9805bde8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01173","start_s":4461.38,"end_s":4470.512,"video_s":6321.38,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00226","chapter":"C015","text":"I've been working for Sky Chefs for two years as a porter and a dishwasher at the airport.","fingerprint":"61982d2c4b44","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01174","start_s":4471.413,"end_s":4482.827,"video_s":6331.413,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00226","chapter":"C015","text":"In late 2025, my life and the lives of 200 coworkers changed forever when American Airlines lost their contract.","fingerprint":"0f6c54a1cd6a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01175","start_s":4482.807,"end_s":4494.37,"video_s":6342.807,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00226","chapter":"C015","text":"Overnight, we were told that we could lose our jobs, our employment, and despite having years of experience and not having done anything wrong, the job disappeared.","fingerprint":"b3db5e8d7ef7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01176","start_s":4496.476,"end_s":4502.663,"video_s":6356.476,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00226","chapter":"C015","text":"But airliners, they still need services provided to.","fingerprint":"3c7e94155123","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01177","start_s":4503.124,"end_s":4504.525,"video_s":6363.124,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00226","chapter":"C015","text":"But still, it goes on.","fingerprint":"61f00aade81e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01178","start_s":4504.886,"end_s":4506.908,"video_s":6364.886,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00226","chapter":"C015","text":"They have to prepare the food for the airplanes.","fingerprint":"b12b4174458f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01179","start_s":4506.968,"end_s":4510.172,"video_s":6366.968,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00226","chapter":"C015","text":"The airport still needs these experienced workers.","fingerprint":"87ecd0a5f94d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01180","start_s":4510.993,"end_s":4513.976,"video_s":6370.993,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00226","chapter":"C015","text":"The only thing that changed was the company that had the contract.","fingerprint":"ac49f9eb1200","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01181","start_s":4514.717,"end_s":4520.644,"video_s":6374.717,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00226","chapter":"C015","text":"My colleagues and I faced uncertainty, confusion, and the possibility of losing our jobs.","fingerprint":"3554054283cb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01182","start_s":4524.573,"end_s":4540.819,"video_s":6384.573,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00226","chapter":"C015","text":"Support, and without being at fault, there was no guarantee for workers like me who had successfully performed this work, functioning with this type of insecurity, which causes stress, anxiety, and sleepless nights.","fingerprint":"8fcd4da6bfb6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01183","start_s":4542.602,"end_s":4544.045,"video_s":6402.602,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00226","chapter":"C015","text":"Does it affect our loved ones?","fingerprint":"c394295c1b93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01184","start_s":4544.926,"end_s":4545.327,"video_s":6404.926,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00226","chapter":"C015","text":"It does.","fingerprint":"386ef68e8efd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01185","start_s":4545.387,"end_s":4551.677,"video_s":6405.387,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00226","chapter":"C015","text":"It affects our health to the point also making it impossible to plan for the future.","fingerprint":"012181d842d4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01186","start_s":4553.632,"end_s":4569.713,"video_s":6413.632,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00226","chapter":"C015","text":"Then, after getting the job, I was again hired by their flight contractors, but only after Local 11 Union filed a claim in my name to get my job back and receive back wages.","fingerprint":"43bf9a09cfd9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01187","start_s":4572.556,"end_s":4575.5,"video_s":6432.556,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00226","chapter":"C015","text":"Many of my colleagues had the same luck.","fingerprint":"18df8e7f5858","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01188","start_s":4577.182,"end_s":4577.783,"video_s":6437.182,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00226","chapter":"C015","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01189","start_s":4588.951,"end_s":4589.397,"video_s":6448.951,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00227","chapter":"C015","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01190","start_s":4589.945,"end_s":4591.587,"video_s":6449.945,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00227","chapter":"C015","text":"Our final speaker will be Mohammed.","fingerprint":"8677424ee944","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01191","start_s":4629.485,"end_s":4631.008,"video_s":6489.485,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00228","chapter":"C015","text":"Good afternoon.","fingerprint":"f01e727e7b79","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01192","start_s":4631.489,"end_s":4632.832,"video_s":6491.489,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00228","chapter":"C015","text":"My name is Reza.","fingerprint":"883c8d5cae10","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01193","start_s":4636.078,"end_s":4645.116,"video_s":6496.078,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00228","chapter":"C015","text":"May I speak English?","fingerprint":"a02982f383ed","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01194","start_s":4646.559,"end_s":4649.164,"video_s":6506.559,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00228","chapter":"C015","text":"I have an interpreter.","fingerprint":"57cd60720c3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01195","start_s":4653.548,"end_s":4674.207,"video_s":6513.548,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00228","chapter":"C015","text":"Hello, I'm Naiman Reza, and I've been working at Sky Shifts with American Airlines in Phoenix, Sky Harbor, for Sky Shifts.","fingerprint":"8516395ffebd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01196","start_s":4676.684,"end_s":4685.297,"video_s":6536.684,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00228","chapter":"C015","text":"When this happened, many of us found ourselves in a stressful situation.","fingerprint":"9ce40d9ef1f6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01197","start_s":4686.259,"end_s":4700.38,"video_s":6546.259,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00228","chapter":"C015","text":"We were told that the chief would take care of it, but it was never clear what would happen to the workers who were doing this every day.","fingerprint":"63dfa31229e0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01198","start_s":4701.541,"end_s":4705.148,"video_s":6561.541,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00228","chapter":"C015","text":"Some of us have been told that we should request food supplies.","fingerprint":"4a812241684f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01199","start_s":4705.789,"end_s":4708.715,"video_s":6565.789,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00228","chapter":"C015","text":"Others have heard that food will be delivered by R-mark.","fingerprint":"c792d9a68f86","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01200","start_s":4708.735,"end_s":4722.942,"video_s":6568.735,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00228","chapter":"C015","text":"Many of the workers did not know which company to request food from, who uses it, or whether it actually had a job.","fingerprint":"dd4aaacc0ffb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01201","start_s":4723.124,"end_s":4732.847,"video_s":6583.124,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00228","chapter":"C015","text":"I came to this country a few years ago with the hope of having a fresh start and having the opportunity to raise my children here.","fingerprint":"2097c4a48449","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01202","start_s":4733.333,"end_s":4742.847,"video_s":6593.333,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00228","chapter":"C015","text":"I was lucky enough to be able to work in the food production department at R-Mark.","fingerprint":"bbe66299233c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01203","start_s":4743.688,"end_s":4748.395,"video_s":6603.688,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00228","chapter":"C015","text":"But many of my former colleagues were not as lucky as I was.","fingerprint":"b6c3cbf37e16","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01204","start_s":4748.415,"end_s":4753.603,"video_s":6608.415,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00228","chapter":"C015","text":"Some of them applied to the Kafa department and never received any money back.","fingerprint":"5ddcaa03f7a3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01205","start_s":4758.275,"end_s":4775.473,"video_s":6618.275,"speaker":"v20","turn":"T00228","chapter":"C015","text":"Sir, we have only unfortunately two minutes, so if you could translate, that would be great.","fingerprint":"cc0b034726d5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01206","start_s":4777.259,"end_s":4789.26,"video_s":6637.259,"speaker":"v21","turn":"T00229","chapter":"C015","text":"Good afternoon, my name is Reza, and I used to work for Skyship at Phoenix Sky Harbor Airport until the company lost the contract with Air Mar American Airlines.","fingerprint":"2ad9d952e83f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01207","start_s":4789.781,"end_s":4797.053,"video_s":6649.781,"speaker":"v21","turn":"T00229","chapter":"C015","text":"When that happened, many of us suddenly found ourselves in a confusing and stressful situation.","fingerprint":"3d1504ddd56a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01208","start_s":4797.534,"end_s":4802.743,"video_s":6657.534,"speaker":"v21","turn":"T00229","chapter":"C015","text":"We were told that Skyship was losing the contract, but","fingerprint":"89cb6a7e99f4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01209","start_s":4803.095,"end_s":4810.764,"video_s":6663.095,"speaker":"v21","turn":"T00229","chapter":"C015","text":"It was never clear what would happen to the workers who had been doing the job every day.","fingerprint":"63334399f9b1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01210","start_s":4811.345,"end_s":4821.557,"video_s":6671.345,"speaker":"v21","turn":"T00229","chapter":"C015","text":"Some of us were told to apply with Sky Cafe, others heard that food production would be contracted out to Air Mark.","fingerprint":"020e727f1f8e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01211","start_s":4821.577,"end_s":4832.41,"video_s":6681.577,"speaker":"v21","turn":"T00229","chapter":"C015","text":"Many workers didn't know which company they were supposed to apply to, to who was hiring.","fingerprint":"0aa433127988","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01212","start_s":4833.368,"end_s":4844.195,"video_s":6693.368,"speaker":"v21","turn":"T00229","chapter":"C015","text":"I came to this country a few years ago hoping that I would have a fresh start and opportunity to raise my children here.","fingerprint":"f35ef7697443","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01213","start_s":4844.335,"end_s":4846.38,"video_s":6704.335,"speaker":"v21","turn":"T00229","chapter":"C015","text":"I was fortunate.","fingerprint":"b2027848ae80","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01214","start_s":4846.661,"end_s":4851.192,"video_s":6706.661,"speaker":"v21","turn":"T00229","chapter":"C015","text":"I was able to get a job with Airmark doing a","fingerprint":"b381e68ed745","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01215","start_s":4851.965,"end_s":4858.155,"video_s":6711.965,"speaker":"v21","turn":"T00229","chapter":"C015","text":"Food production, but many of my former co-workers were not as lucky.","fingerprint":"85c2dd088bd2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01216","start_s":4858.696,"end_s":4862.883,"video_s":6718.696,"speaker":"v21","turn":"T00229","chapter":"C015","text":"Some applied to Sky Cafe and never received clear answers.","fingerprint":"21af4c7e6b63","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01217","start_s":4863.424,"end_s":4866.208,"video_s":6723.424,"speaker":"v21","turn":"T00229","chapter":"C015","text":"Others applied to Air Mark and never heard back.","fingerprint":"3daf803e9908","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01218","start_s":4867.15,"end_s":4875.964,"video_s":6727.15,"speaker":"v21","turn":"T00229","chapter":"C015","text":"Many experienced workers who had spent years serving this airport were left wondering what happened to the jobs.","fingerprint":"9753e51cd46b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01219","start_s":4876.332,"end_s":4879.816,"video_s":6736.332,"speaker":"v21","turn":"T00229","chapter":"C015","text":"They had worked so hard to earn.","fingerprint":"99a2abcf0c9e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01220","start_s":4880.697,"end_s":4900.34,"video_s":6740.697,"speaker":"v21","turn":"T00229","chapter":"C015","text":"A worker retention ordinance would create a fair and transparent process that is good for workers, good for employers, and good for the traveling public, experienced workers know the job.","fingerprint":"e6e882434a70","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01221","start_s":4900.68,"end_s":4904.685,"video_s":6760.68,"speaker":"v21","turn":"T00229","chapter":"C015","text":"Understand safety and quality standards.","fingerprint":"d4e3bfc7a016","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01222","start_s":4906.015,"end_s":4913.244,"video_s":6766.015,"speaker":"v21","turn":"T00229","chapter":"C015","text":"and help ensure smooth operation at one of the busiest airport in the country.","fingerprint":"bdfd93d79b71","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01223","start_s":4913.765,"end_s":4925.521,"video_s":6773.765,"speaker":"v21","turn":"T00229","chapter":"C015","text":"I support workers retention ordinance because no one should lose their livelihood simply because the name on the contract change.","fingerprint":"a2dc2b20ac6a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01224","start_s":4926.141,"end_s":4934.993,"video_s":6786.141,"speaker":"v21","turn":"T00229","chapter":"C015","text":"Thank you, Mayor Gallego and Councilwoman Guardado and Hodge Washington for getting us on the path","fingerprint":"44436b69a360","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01225","start_s":4935.158,"end_s":4938.328,"video_s":6795.158,"speaker":"v21","turn":"T00229","chapter":"C015","text":"to Worker Retention Policy.","fingerprint":"76b85cab9068","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01226","start_s":4938.348,"end_s":4938.75,"video_s":6798.348,"speaker":"v21","turn":"T00229","chapter":"C015","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01227","start_s":4944.488,"end_s":4944.87,"video_s":6804.488,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00230","chapter":"C015","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01228","start_s":4945.411,"end_s":4946.535,"video_s":6805.411,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00231","chapter":"C015","text":"Councilman.","fingerprint":"817338b594c6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01229","start_s":4947.798,"end_s":4948.439,"video_s":6807.798,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00232","chapter":"C015","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01230","start_s":4949.561,"end_s":4953.007,"video_s":6809.561,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00232","chapter":"C015","text":"So thank you to all the workers that came out and spoke today.","fingerprint":"0f19f92efcb8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01231","start_s":4953.448,"end_s":4958.637,"video_s":6813.448,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00232","chapter":"C015","text":"You could see the diversity at the airport in all of our different workplaces.","fingerprint":"a104a38c0dc6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01232","start_s":4958.777,"end_s":4960.921,"video_s":6818.777,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00232","chapter":"C015","text":"Thank you for your testimony.","fingerprint":"005bb046d69b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01233","start_s":4961.041,"end_s":4964.267,"video_s":6821.041,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00232","chapter":"C015","text":"And yes, worker retention is incredibly important.","fingerprint":"470a389819ac","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01234","start_s":4964.848,"end_s":4970.498,"video_s":6824.848,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00232","chapter":"C015","text":"As a former housekeeper that almost lost her job in December because the company did not want to","fingerprint":"2fb74f19174f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01235","start_s":4970.478,"end_s":4973.723,"video_s":6830.478,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00232","chapter":"C015","text":"respect the worker retention language that we had in our contract.","fingerprint":"fe3b188d047d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01236","start_s":4973.783,"end_s":4977.589,"video_s":6833.783,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00232","chapter":"C015","text":"I understand the uncertainty of almost losing our job.","fingerprint":"dc477afca59f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01237","start_s":4978.169,"end_s":4984.299,"video_s":6838.169,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00232","chapter":"C015","text":"So as a council, we are committed to looking for the best solutions that work for everyone.","fingerprint":"44e9e3eb1675","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01238","start_s":4984.699,"end_s":4990.428,"video_s":6844.699,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00232","chapter":"C015","text":"We saw what happened last year with the Scotchess workers and we continue to hear the horror stories.","fingerprint":"268afc630618","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01239","start_s":4991.069,"end_s":4995.996,"video_s":6851.069,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00232","chapter":"C015","text":"And we also understand that we're also living in some unprecedented times.","fingerprint":"81f9fc097bda","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01240","start_s":4995.976,"end_s":5005.171,"video_s":6855.976,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00232","chapter":"C015","text":"We see the challenges in front of us and we are going to try to make the best that we can of this situation that everyone is in.","fingerprint":"b2cf9b3d0c0b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01241","start_s":5005.231,"end_s":5012.483,"video_s":6865.231,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00232","chapter":"C015","text":"So thank you again to all city management, to our city manager, Ed Zuercher, assistant city manager, Lori Bays,","fingerprint":"183d3d9503e8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01242","start_s":5012.463,"end_s":5024.319,"video_s":6872.463,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00232","chapter":"C015","text":"Assistant City Manager Ginger Spencer, the Human Resources Department, the Budget and Research Department, and all of the staff who will help evaluate these options and bring recommendations back to this council.","fingerprint":"54fc4c3cbf6f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01243","start_s":5024.42,"end_s":5025.363,"video_s":6884.42,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00232","chapter":"C015","text":"Thank you all so much.","fingerprint":"b78254d4c2d8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01244","start_s":5025.543,"end_s":5026.185,"video_s":6885.543,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00232","chapter":"C015","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01245","start_s":5028.207,"end_s":5028.548,"video_s":6888.207,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00232","chapter":"C015","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01246","start_s":5028.788,"end_s":5029.61,"video_s":6888.788,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00233","chapter":"C015","text":"Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"9a95bf6095c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01247","start_s":5029.63,"end_s":5030.152,"video_s":6889.63,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00233","chapter":"C015","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01248","start_s":5030.773,"end_s":5035.886,"video_s":6890.773,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00233","chapter":"C015","text":"I'll be short because this item is closely connected to the workforce discussion we had just a vote earlier.","fingerprint":"36b210843d81","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01249","start_s":5035.946,"end_s":5043.364,"video_s":6895.946,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00233","chapter":"C015","text":"Across the country, many local governments have explored ways to minimize disruption when city services contract change from one vendor to another.","fingerprint":"c15c7c5d3e2a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01250","start_s":5043.344,"end_s":5050.998,"video_s":6903.344,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00233","chapter":"C015","text":"In some cases, workers who have been successfully performing their services can face uncertainty even when the work itself continues.","fingerprint":"df833a60d3df","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01251","start_s":5051.539,"end_s":5060.796,"video_s":6911.539,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00233","chapter":"C015","text":"Again, the intent is not to establish a policy today, but it is again to help us better understand what options may be available to the city, what considerations exist, and what impact it would have.","fingerprint":"0988f9496d9b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01252","start_s":5061.181,"end_s":5069.55,"video_s":6921.181,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00233","chapter":"C015","text":"The individuals who help maintain our facilities, support city functions, and provide services play an important role to the success of our entire organization.","fingerprint":"1fbdb0cb082e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01253","start_s":5069.59,"end_s":5079.581,"video_s":6929.59,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00233","chapter":"C015","text":"I believe it's appropriate for council to ask staff to conduct this research and return with information so we can have a thoughtful discussion based on facts, best practices, and legal guidance.","fingerprint":"f465241ef5cc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01254","start_s":5079.961,"end_s":5084.566,"video_s":6939.961,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00233","chapter":"C015","text":"Again, thank you to everyone who has joined this effort, and I look forward to further conversations.","fingerprint":"d67440b7825e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01255","start_s":5084.626,"end_s":5085.126,"video_s":6944.626,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00233","chapter":"C015","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01256","start_s":5085.667,"end_s":5086.087,"video_s":6945.667,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00234","chapter":"C015","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01257","start_s":5086.288,"end_s":5086.648,"video_s":6946.288,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00235","chapter":"C015","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01258","start_s":5087.168,"end_s":5088.171,"video_s":6947.168,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00236","chapter":"C015","text":"Guardado?","fingerprint":"0344b48c3f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01259","start_s":5088.191,"end_s":5088.431,"video_s":6948.191,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00236","chapter":"C015","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01260","start_s":5088.752,"end_s":5089.534,"video_s":6948.752,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00236","chapter":"C015","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01261","start_s":5089.554,"end_s":5089.775,"video_s":6949.554,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00236","chapter":"C015","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01262","start_s":5090.216,"end_s":5090.637,"video_s":6950.216,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00236","chapter":"C015","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01263","start_s":5090.758,"end_s":5091.379,"video_s":6950.758,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00236","chapter":"C015","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01264","start_s":5091.399,"end_s":5091.921,"video_s":6951.399,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00236","chapter":"C015","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01265","start_s":5092.242,"end_s":5092.603,"video_s":6952.242,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00237","chapter":"C015","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01266","start_s":5093.184,"end_s":5093.666,"video_s":6953.184,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00238","chapter":"C015","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01267","start_s":5093.826,"end_s":5094.067,"video_s":6953.826,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00239","chapter":"C015","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01268","start_s":5094.548,"end_s":5094.889,"video_s":6954.548,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00240","chapter":"C015","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01269","start_s":5095.21,"end_s":5095.912,"video_s":6955.21,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00240","chapter":"C015","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01270","start_s":5095.932,"end_s":5096.273,"video_s":6955.932,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00240","chapter":"C015","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01271","start_s":5097.055,"end_s":5097.135,"video_s":6957.055,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00240","chapter":"C015","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01272","start_s":5097.155,"end_s":5097.817,"video_s":6957.155,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00240","chapter":"C015","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01273","start_s":5098.158,"end_s":5098.398,"video_s":6958.158,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00241","chapter":"C015","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01274","start_s":5098.799,"end_s":5099.261,"video_s":6958.799,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00242","chapter":"C015","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01275","start_s":5099.421,"end_s":5099.622,"video_s":6959.421,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00242","chapter":"C015","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01276","start_s":5099.962,"end_s":5101.667,"video_s":6959.962,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00242","chapter":"C015","text":"Passes 8, sorry, passes 9-0.","fingerprint":"724ab26cf9c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01277","start_s":5110.473,"end_s":5110.934,"video_s":6970.473,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00243","chapter":"C015","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01278","start_s":5110.974,"end_s":5115.7,"video_s":6970.974,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00244","chapter":"C016","text":"We'll go next to item 89, funding for Moreland Phase II affordable housing development.","fingerprint":"d43b5517a94b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01279","start_s":5115.72,"end_s":5116.141,"video_s":6975.72,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00244","chapter":"C016","text":"Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"9a95bf6095c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01280","start_s":5116.541,"end_s":5117.763,"video_s":6976.541,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00244","chapter":"C016","text":"Motion to approve item 89.","fingerprint":"c2e6dddb6f34","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01281","start_s":5117.863,"end_s":5118.043,"video_s":6977.863,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00244","chapter":"C016","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01282","start_s":5120.307,"end_s":5122.71,"video_s":6980.307,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00244","chapter":"C016","text":"We have a motion and a second, and I'll turn to the Vice Mayor for comments.","fingerprint":"d8e466ee59b5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01283","start_s":5123.01,"end_s":5123.591,"video_s":6983.01,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00245","chapter":"C016","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01284","start_s":5123.952,"end_s":5130.0,"video_s":6983.952,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00245","chapter":"C016","text":"I am proud to, I'm going to loop my comments together for 89, 90, and 91, even though 90 and 91 have already passed.","fingerprint":"f57a05d1b9dd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01285","start_s":5130.098,"end_s":5141.974,"video_s":6990.098,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00245","chapter":"C016","text":"I really wanted to just say that items 89 and 90 represent important investments in expanding affordable housing and workforce housing in District 8 and across Phoenix with respect to District, I'm sorry, item 90.","fingerprint":"83e83ee49e63","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01286","start_s":5143.336,"end_s":5156.815,"video_s":7003.336,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00245","chapter":"C016","text":"The Moreland, which is the second phase of the former Deck Park Vista redevelopment, will deliver 105 new affordable units with at least 80% dedicated to seniors and approximately 27 workforce housing units.","fingerprint":"5bc397fac9d0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01287","start_s":5156.997,"end_s":5165.767,"video_s":7016.997,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00245","chapter":"C016","text":"Phoenix continues to face a housing shortage, especially for seniors on fixed income and working families who want to remain close to jobs, transit, and services.","fingerprint":"04db99cc1541","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01288","start_s":5166.388,"end_s":5177.201,"video_s":7026.388,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00245","chapter":"C016","text":"This project responds directly to those needs while leveraging federal resources, tax credit, product-based vouchers, and public-private partnership in a way that minimizes the impact on the general fund.","fingerprint":"a4421d517011","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01289","start_s":5177.641,"end_s":5186.532,"video_s":7037.641,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00245","chapter":"C016","text":"I just want to say I really appreciate and commend the housing department's work and look forward to seeing the Moreland continue to take shape as a strong housing investment in District 8.","fingerprint":"a8c810054dc1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01290","start_s":5187.541,"end_s":5196.415,"video_s":7047.541,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00246","chapter":"C017","text":"With respect to item 90, this supports the Edison Eastlake Choice Neighborhood Initiative, one of the most transformative housing and neighborhood revitalization efforts in the city's history.","fingerprint":"a8fa32ac1a80","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01291","start_s":5197.076,"end_s":5200.101,"video_s":7057.076,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00246","chapter":"C017","text":"This comprehensive strategy goes beyond housing alone.","fingerprint":"472e1b7cee9d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01292","start_s":5200.261,"end_s":5207.372,"video_s":7060.261,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00246","chapter":"C017","text":"It integrates neighborhood improvements, transportation access, economic opportunity, and long-term community investment.","fingerprint":"00bb5b9fe009","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01293","start_s":5207.352,"end_s":5220.696,"video_s":7067.352,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00246","chapter":"C017","text":"The additional funding will help create as our advanced redevelopment that is expected to create 475 new mixed income housing units contributing to a broader vision of more than a thousand units across the choice neighborhood area.","fingerprint":"7c40487bfc36","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01294","start_s":5221.397,"end_s":5231.655,"video_s":7081.397,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00247","chapter":"C018","text":"And lastly item 91 it allows the housing department to seek federal approval to convert 57 sites of single-family housing into affordable for sale single-family residence.","fingerprint":"95b7d106f868","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01295","start_s":5231.635,"end_s":5237.221,"video_s":7091.635,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00247","chapter":"C018","text":"Half of these homes will be sold to owner occupants, converting public housing residents into homeowners.","fingerprint":"c8c4589bbbfa","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01296","start_s":5237.822,"end_s":5248.774,"video_s":7097.822,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00247","chapter":"C018","text":"Together, these items reflect what we can achieve through strong federal, local, and community partnerships, preserving community, expanding opportunity, and making meaningful progress on Phoenix's housing challenge.","fingerprint":"17f6b79ee3d9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01297","start_s":5249.155,"end_s":5254.361,"video_s":7109.155,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00247","chapter":"C018","text":"I just want to again thank the housing department staff, residents, and community partner for their continued commitment to this work.","fingerprint":"9e18c4e927fc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01298","start_s":5254.601,"end_s":5255.102,"video_s":7114.601,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00247","chapter":"C018","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01299","start_s":5256.243,"end_s":5256.623,"video_s":7116.243,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00248","chapter":"C018","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01300","start_s":5256.744,"end_s":5257.204,"video_s":7116.744,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00249","chapter":"C018","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01301","start_s":5257.893,"end_s":5259.916,"video_s":7117.893,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00249","chapter":"C018","text":"Guardado, Hernandez?","fingerprint":"46dc64a63cbc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01302","start_s":5260.257,"end_s":5260.457,"video_s":7120.257,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00249","chapter":"C018","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01303","start_s":5261.038,"end_s":5261.519,"video_s":7121.038,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00249","chapter":"C018","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01304","start_s":5261.779,"end_s":5261.979,"video_s":7121.779,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00249","chapter":"C018","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01305","start_s":5262.44,"end_s":5262.981,"video_s":7122.44,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00249","chapter":"C018","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01306","start_s":5263.081,"end_s":5263.341,"video_s":7123.081,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00249","chapter":"C018","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01307","start_s":5263.922,"end_s":5264.443,"video_s":7123.922,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00249","chapter":"C018","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01308","start_s":5264.543,"end_s":5264.764,"video_s":7124.543,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00249","chapter":"C018","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01309","start_s":5265.324,"end_s":5266.166,"video_s":7125.324,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00249","chapter":"C018","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01310","start_s":5266.186,"end_s":5266.406,"video_s":7126.186,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00249","chapter":"C018","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01311","start_s":5267.067,"end_s":5267.408,"video_s":7127.067,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00249","chapter":"C018","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01312","start_s":5268.289,"end_s":5268.369,"video_s":7128.289,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00249","chapter":"C018","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01313","start_s":5268.389,"end_s":5269.01,"video_s":7128.389,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00249","chapter":"C018","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01314","start_s":5269.15,"end_s":5269.411,"video_s":7129.15,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00249","chapter":"C018","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01315","start_s":5269.831,"end_s":5270.312,"video_s":7129.831,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00249","chapter":"C018","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01316","start_s":5270.572,"end_s":5270.813,"video_s":7130.572,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00250","chapter":"C018","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01317","start_s":5271.153,"end_s":5272.155,"video_s":7131.153,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00250","chapter":"C018","text":"Passes 8-0.","fingerprint":"f9a0ca3f6107","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01318","start_s":5273.217,"end_s":5278.785,"video_s":7133.217,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00251","chapter":"C019","text":"Item 95 is a contract with the Arizona Community Action Association, better known as Wildfire.","fingerprint":"471ddc17f0ec","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01319","start_s":5278.805,"end_s":5279.206,"video_s":7138.805,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00251","chapter":"C019","text":"Vice Mayor?","fingerprint":"9a95bf6095c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01320","start_s":5279.947,"end_s":5282.01,"video_s":7139.947,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00251","chapter":"C019","text":"Motion to approve item 95.","fingerprint":"99b011623dac","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01321","start_s":5281.99,"end_s":5282.731,"video_s":7141.99,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00251","chapter":"C019","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01322","start_s":5282.751,"end_s":5283.212,"video_s":7142.751,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00251","chapter":"C019","text":"Motion.","fingerprint":"305238273bb0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01323","start_s":5283.392,"end_s":5284.995,"video_s":7143.392,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00252","chapter":"C019","text":"In a second, turn to the Vice Mayor for comments.","fingerprint":"c1b884409e29","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01324","start_s":5285.075,"end_s":5286.077,"video_s":7145.075,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00252","chapter":"C019","text":"Thank you so much, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d116fbf480ee","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01325","start_s":5286.097,"end_s":5291.606,"video_s":7146.097,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00252","chapter":"C019","text":"I just really, again, I wanted to support, just state my support for item 95.","fingerprint":"b19c43084813","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01326","start_s":5292.046,"end_s":5299.358,"video_s":7152.046,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00252","chapter":"C019","text":"This investment will provide critical emergency financial assistance to approximately 2,000 low-income households across Phoenix.","fingerprint":"a80f218b48f0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01327","start_s":5299.338,"end_s":5303.666,"video_s":7159.338,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00252","chapter":"C019","text":"helping residents stay current on utility bills and avoid service interruption.","fingerprint":"22b6f7d311a9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01328","start_s":5303.726,"end_s":5308.073,"video_s":7163.726,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00252","chapter":"C019","text":"This funding is a blend of federal utility and program resources.","fingerprint":"3911dcf5e724","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01329","start_s":5308.694,"end_s":5317.65,"video_s":7168.694,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00252","chapter":"C019","text":"At a time when many families are still facing financial strains, these resources play an essential role in stabilizing households and preventing deeper crises.","fingerprint":"67aad9a2828e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01330","start_s":5317.63,"end_s":5342.423,"video_s":7177.63,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00252","chapter":"C019","text":"just this morning I received on my personal call a phone from a call from one individual who was specifically looking for utility assistance it was a reminder that these resources are still needed in our community and I appreciate the human services department and our partners at wildfire for continuing to deliver this support efficiently and at us and at scale and I'm proud to support this item thank you mayor thank you so much roll call","fingerprint":"9de243e06f4b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01331","start_s":5343.162,"end_s":5357.278,"video_s":7203.162,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00253","chapter":"C019","text":"Guardado, Hernandez, O'Brien, Pastor, Robinson, Stark, Waring, Hodge Washington, Gallego.","fingerprint":"3260abd8336d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01332","start_s":5358.58,"end_s":5359.281,"video_s":7218.58,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00254","chapter":"C019","text":"Passes 8-0.","fingerprint":"f9a0ca3f6107","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01333","start_s":5359.301,"end_s":5365.468,"video_s":7219.301,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00255","chapter":"C020","text":"Item 101 is the Annual Review and Updates to the Neighborhood Services Code Enforcement Policy.","fingerprint":"8e40b5647f96","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01334","start_s":5365.748,"end_s":5366.169,"video_s":7225.748,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00255","chapter":"C020","text":"Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"9a95bf6095c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01335","start_s":5366.329,"end_s":5367.851,"video_s":7226.329,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00256","chapter":"C020","text":"Motion to approve item 101.","fingerprint":"d7eaa71c9bcd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01336","start_s":5368.171,"end_s":5368.491,"video_s":7228.171,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00256","chapter":"C020","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01337","start_s":5368.772,"end_s":5369.673,"video_s":7228.772,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00257","chapter":"C020","text":"We have a motion and a second.","fingerprint":"7451ba811637","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01338","start_s":5369.713,"end_s":5370.874,"video_s":7229.713,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00257","chapter":"C020","text":"Councilman Hernandez.","fingerprint":"3bb873cefabf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01339","start_s":5371.158,"end_s":5371.963,"video_s":7231.158,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"Thank you so much, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d116fbf480ee","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01340","start_s":5371.983,"end_s":5376.392,"video_s":7231.983,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"Just have a couple questions for Spencer and NSD on this.","fingerprint":"6953474e19e3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01341","start_s":5385.299,"end_s":5386.542,"video_s":7245.299,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"Thank you so much, Spencer.","fingerprint":"ccdb9f21879a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01342","start_s":5387.864,"end_s":5388.846,"video_s":7247.864,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"Just have a couple questions.","fingerprint":"3ca0258faad8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01343","start_s":5389.167,"end_s":5396.141,"video_s":7249.167,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"What criteria exists that establishes the need for PPD involvement in enforcement of a violation?","fingerprint":"a843b0d26d60","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01344","start_s":5396.181,"end_s":5401.873,"video_s":7256.181,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C020","text":"Or like when and why would we turn over a violation to PPD?","fingerprint":"e2ab97e155ef","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01345","start_s":5401.853,"end_s":5410.086,"video_s":7261.853,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00259","chapter":"C020","text":"Mayor, Councilwoman Hernandez, there's a number of reasons why we may work with the Phoenix Police Department on enforcement efforts.","fingerprint":"4178ba1ed20b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01346","start_s":5411.428,"end_s":5421.263,"video_s":7271.428,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00259","chapter":"C020","text":"Neighborhood Services is responsible for enforcing Chapter 39 of the City Code as well as sections of Chapter 8, 10, and 41.","fingerprint":"107744ced811","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01347","start_s":5421.243,"end_s":5445.698,"video_s":7281.243,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00259","chapter":"C020","text":"if a complaint falls outside of those those areas then we may refer it over to the police department or other departments such as public works vice versa they may refer complaints to us if it falls within our purview and then at times we may coordinate with the police or other city departments for known nuisance properties where there may be violations of codes that","fingerprint":"57dde7bbb753","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01348","start_s":5445.678,"end_s":5447.501,"video_s":7305.678,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00259","chapter":"C020","text":"multiple departments in force.","fingerprint":"b88e50a4809d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01349","start_s":5447.541,"end_s":5451.487,"video_s":7307.541,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00259","chapter":"C020","text":"This is especially true in our community safety plan areas.","fingerprint":"f4243a505d75","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01350","start_s":5452.629,"end_s":5462.725,"video_s":7312.629,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00259","chapter":"C020","text":"And then we also work with the police department to serve administrative warrants if necessary, or to complete an inspection or vehement activities at a property.","fingerprint":"b0380afc3c2a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01351","start_s":5463.446,"end_s":5467.993,"video_s":7323.446,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00259","chapter":"C020","text":"And then the last area is if we have staff who are threatened.","fingerprint":"e29bb7f8e9d4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01352","start_s":5468.033,"end_s":5472.36,"video_s":7328.033,"speaker":"v22","turn":"T00259","chapter":"C020","text":"So for health and safety reasons, we may have police help us in an inspection.","fingerprint":"e49be8cd256f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01353","start_s":5472.34,"end_s":5473.662,"video_s":7332.34,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00260","chapter":"C020","text":"Okay, thank you so much, Spencer.","fingerprint":"8d7ac29a847f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01354","start_s":5473.882,"end_s":5479.169,"video_s":7333.882,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00260","chapter":"C020","text":"I really appreciate just that clarification, right, for the residents and for the community and the audience listening.","fingerprint":"38cdfa70a7c2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01355","start_s":5479.79,"end_s":5482.254,"video_s":7339.79,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00260","chapter":"C020","text":"You know, today I'm not going to be supporting these changes.","fingerprint":"1533ed8160a2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01356","start_s":5482.894,"end_s":5490.585,"video_s":7342.894,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00260","chapter":"C020","text":"First, I just want to flag that, you know, we did raise some concerns on the, specifically the consecutive citation issue in the ordinance.","fingerprint":"cfd7c0f83026","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01357","start_s":5490.565,"end_s":5494.133,"video_s":7350.565,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00260","chapter":"C020","text":"and I don't think those changes or those concerns have been addressed.","fingerprint":"0abec223a5d8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01358","start_s":5494.233,"end_s":5496.818,"video_s":7354.233,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00260","chapter":"C020","text":"So I still have remaining concerns around that.","fingerprint":"6af0c75b9042","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01359","start_s":5497.5,"end_s":5506.018,"video_s":7357.5,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00260","chapter":"C020","text":"Second, I'm still a little unclear on the process under which you as a director can take action to enforce or not enforce a violation.","fingerprint":"94334a1ea75a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01360","start_s":5506.118,"end_s":5507.882,"video_s":7366.118,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00260","chapter":"C020","text":"Third,","fingerprint":"b1e99324505b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01361","start_s":5507.862,"end_s":5516.233,"video_s":7367.862,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00260","chapter":"C020","text":"have a really serious concern around the slippery slope that, you know, how NSD can move forward when it comes to enforcement in particular.","fingerprint":"ad3952bedefa","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01362","start_s":5517.255,"end_s":5529.651,"video_s":7377.255,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00260","chapter":"C020","text":"We give your department a lot of power to really police our lives and the criteria under which they can ticket us and criminalize us are too broad and undefined still for me to support this.","fingerprint":"9fda0c42837c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01363","start_s":5529.631,"end_s":5556.465,"video_s":7389.631,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00260","chapter":"C020","text":"you know I do believe that we are weaponizing enforcement against some of our residents who are just trying to live their lives and I don't want to see NSD become a mini police department I already call you the fun police so I don't want to call you a mini police department right so I know this is likely gonna pass but I do want to continue to work with with you and your in your department to lead make sure we're really leading with more educational","fingerprint":"95cca5234eb2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01364","start_s":5556.445,"end_s":5581.153,"video_s":7416.445,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00260","chapter":"C020","text":"Guardado.","fingerprint":"0344b48c3f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01365","start_s":5582.348,"end_s":5582.99,"video_s":7442.348,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00261","chapter":"C020","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01366","start_s":5583.411,"end_s":5583.592,"video_s":7443.411,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C020","text":"No.","fingerprint":"9390298f3fb0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01367","start_s":5584.354,"end_s":5584.855,"video_s":7444.354,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00263","chapter":"C020","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01368","start_s":5585.116,"end_s":5585.377,"video_s":7445.116,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00263","chapter":"C020","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01369","start_s":5585.958,"end_s":5586.5,"video_s":7445.958,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00263","chapter":"C020","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01370","start_s":5586.761,"end_s":5587.603,"video_s":7446.761,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00263","chapter":"C020","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01371","start_s":5587.623,"end_s":5588.185,"video_s":7447.623,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00263","chapter":"C020","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01372","start_s":5588.285,"end_s":5588.566,"video_s":7448.285,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00264","chapter":"C020","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01373","start_s":5589.188,"end_s":5590.752,"video_s":7449.188,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00265","chapter":"C020","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01374","start_s":5590.772,"end_s":5590.852,"video_s":7450.772,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00265","chapter":"C020","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01375","start_s":5590.872,"end_s":5591.273,"video_s":7450.872,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00265","chapter":"C020","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01376","start_s":5592.016,"end_s":5592.096,"video_s":7452.016,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00265","chapter":"C020","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01377","start_s":5592.116,"end_s":5592.858,"video_s":7452.116,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00265","chapter":"C020","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01378","start_s":5592.978,"end_s":5593.239,"video_s":7452.978,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00265","chapter":"C020","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01379","start_s":5593.7,"end_s":5594.282,"video_s":7453.7,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00265","chapter":"C020","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01380","start_s":5595.528,"end_s":5596.189,"video_s":7455.528,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00265","chapter":"C020","text":"Passes 8-1.","fingerprint":"a7b3afc7a8da","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01381","start_s":5597.432,"end_s":5605.387,"video_s":7457.432,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C021","text":"Next is item 106, which is an authorization to accept vacant land from cash holdings and to designate it as mountain preserve.","fingerprint":"04e29230d1fd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01382","start_s":5605.447,"end_s":5605.928,"video_s":7465.447,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C021","text":"Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"9a95bf6095c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01383","start_s":5606.328,"end_s":5608.032,"video_s":7466.328,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C021","text":"Motion to approve item 106.","fingerprint":"af81f3dc7b55","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01384","start_s":5608.412,"end_s":5608.793,"video_s":7468.412,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C021","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01385","start_s":5609.254,"end_s":5610.436,"video_s":7469.254,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C021","text":"We have a motion and a second.","fingerprint":"7451ba811637","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01386","start_s":5610.977,"end_s":5614.885,"video_s":7470.977,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C021","text":"A big thank you to Councilman Robinson and our Parks Department for working on this item.","fingerprint":"779d63ebc77b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01387","start_s":5614.945,"end_s":5618.852,"video_s":7474.945,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C021","text":"It will help us grow our beloved preserve system.","fingerprint":"8528fadb5a6e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01388","start_s":5618.832,"end_s":5629.326,"video_s":7478.832,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C021","text":"The Center for the Future of Arizona has polled Arizonans and found that one of the things that most unites us is our love for the beautiful open space that we have in our state.","fingerprint":"4c86b8e8ba6e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01389","start_s":5629.987,"end_s":5634.953,"video_s":7489.987,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C021","text":"I am a huge fan of our park system and particularly our wonderful mountains.","fingerprint":"6f9de0a1d23a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01390","start_s":5636.215,"end_s":5641.482,"video_s":7496.215,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C021","text":"Since 2020, Phoenix has acquired more than 2,400 acres of preserve land.","fingerprint":"c20aa6744143","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01391","start_s":5641.462,"end_s":5649.298,"video_s":7501.462,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C021","text":"We are adding acreage to the crown jewel of Phoenix's mountain system, the South Mountain Park and Preserve at more than 16,000 acres.","fingerprint":"f7b102f17ba6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01392","start_s":5649.378,"end_s":5653.126,"video_s":7509.378,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C021","text":"It's one of the largest municipally managed parks in the United States.","fingerprint":"789e4d0a0c55","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01393","start_s":5653.707,"end_s":5657.816,"video_s":7513.707,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C021","text":"One of the things that makes us so unique is that our city has grown up around our mountains.","fingerprint":"b75c2c2d1327","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01394","start_s":5658.437,"end_s":5660.702,"video_s":7518.437,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C021","text":"Many cities","fingerprint":"8fa1729c7113","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01395","start_s":5660.682,"end_s":5667.149,"video_s":7520.682,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C021","text":"grow over the mountains, and we have decided to preserve them, which I think was a wonderful decision.","fingerprint":"960e69e9de4f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01396","start_s":5667.209,"end_s":5675.598,"video_s":7527.209,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C021","text":"While other cities may have erased their natural landscapes, we celebrate them, and they're part of our city's character.","fingerprint":"000d4254406a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01397","start_s":5676.66,"end_s":5686.711,"video_s":7536.66,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C021","text":"So very excited to support this one, and Councilman Robinson, thank you for your work and connection to this wonderful, wonderful opportunity.","fingerprint":"6a7b71c12cb0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01398","start_s":5688.593,"end_s":5688.833,"video_s":7548.593,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C021","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01399","start_s":5690.028,"end_s":5705.753,"video_s":7550.028,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00267","chapter":"C021","text":"Guardado, yes, Hernandez, yes, O'Brien, yes, Pastor, yes, Robinson, yes, Stark, yes, Waring, Hodge Washington, yes, Gallego, yes, passes 9-0.","fingerprint":"7d86a909f56b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01400","start_s":5706.935,"end_s":5709.96,"video_s":7566.935,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C022","text":"Item 111, I will ask the city clerk to read the title.","fingerprint":"8678712c8c3e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01401","start_s":5711.408,"end_s":5723.58,"video_s":7571.408,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00269","chapter":"C022","text":"Item 111 is for Ordinance G7523, an ordinance amending Phoenix City Code Chapter 10A, Sections 10A-1 and 10A-2 related to indemnification provisions in facility use agreements.","fingerprint":"4a8eb736da94","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01402","start_s":5726.683,"end_s":5726.904,"video_s":7586.683,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00270","chapter":"C022","text":"Vice Mayor?","fingerprint":"9a95bf6095c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01403","start_s":5726.924,"end_s":5728.685,"video_s":7586.924,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00270","chapter":"C022","text":"Motion to approve Item 111.","fingerprint":"827f84d687ad","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01404","start_s":5729.446,"end_s":5729.766,"video_s":7589.446,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00271","chapter":"C022","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01405","start_s":5730.307,"end_s":5732.009,"video_s":7590.307,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00271","chapter":"C022","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01406","start_s":5732.029,"end_s":5732.729,"video_s":7592.029,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00271","chapter":"C022","text":"Guardado?","fingerprint":"0344b48c3f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01407","start_s":5732.749,"end_s":5733.49,"video_s":7592.749,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00271","chapter":"C022","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01408","start_s":5733.51,"end_s":5734.111,"video_s":7593.51,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00271","chapter":"C022","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01409","start_s":5734.131,"end_s":5734.812,"video_s":7594.131,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00271","chapter":"C022","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01410","start_s":5734.832,"end_s":5735.272,"video_s":7594.832,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00271","chapter":"C022","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01411","start_s":5735.632,"end_s":5736.193,"video_s":7595.632,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00271","chapter":"C022","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01412","start_s":5736.213,"end_s":5736.713,"video_s":7596.213,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00271","chapter":"C022","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01413","start_s":5736.874,"end_s":5737.514,"video_s":7596.874,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00271","chapter":"C022","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01414","start_s":5737.534,"end_s":5738.015,"video_s":7597.534,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00271","chapter":"C022","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01415","start_s":5738.275,"end_s":5738.515,"video_s":7598.275,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00272","chapter":"C022","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01416","start_s":5738.956,"end_s":5739.636,"video_s":7598.956,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00273","chapter":"C022","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01417","start_s":5739.656,"end_s":5740.217,"video_s":7599.656,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00273","chapter":"C022","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01418","start_s":5740.315,"end_s":5742.197,"video_s":7600.315,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00273","chapter":"C022","text":"Waring, Hodge Washington.","fingerprint":"df7a73d085ed","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01419","start_s":5742.397,"end_s":5742.638,"video_s":7602.397,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00273","chapter":"C022","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01420","start_s":5743.178,"end_s":5743.499,"video_s":7603.178,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00273","chapter":"C022","text":"Gallego.","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01421","start_s":5744.159,"end_s":5744.36,"video_s":7604.159,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00274","chapter":"C022","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01422","start_s":5744.86,"end_s":5745.701,"video_s":7604.86,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00274","chapter":"C022","text":"Passes 9-0.","fingerprint":"f7c37e75fd84","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01423","start_s":5746.522,"end_s":5748.124,"video_s":7606.522,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00275","chapter":"C023","text":"Item 124 is next.","fingerprint":"1044078305a5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01424","start_s":5748.144,"end_s":5752.889,"video_s":7608.144,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00275","chapter":"C023","text":"That is a contract with Motorola for the NVLS database subscription services.","fingerprint":"0027600a57f0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01425","start_s":5753.13,"end_s":5753.55,"video_s":7613.13,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00275","chapter":"C023","text":"Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"9a95bf6095c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01426","start_s":5753.79,"end_s":5754.511,"video_s":7613.79,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00276","chapter":"C023","text":"Motion to approve.","fingerprint":"5a3f6a1d08af","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01427","start_s":5754.591,"end_s":5755.432,"video_s":7614.591,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00277","chapter":"C023","text":"Item 124.","fingerprint":"e769086581cf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01428","start_s":5755.833,"end_s":5756.193,"video_s":7615.833,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00277","chapter":"C023","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01429","start_s":5756.634,"end_s":5757.394,"video_s":7616.634,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00278","chapter":"C023","text":"Councilwoman Hernandez.","fingerprint":"be943e39201c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01430","start_s":5758.235,"end_s":5759.277,"video_s":7618.235,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00279","chapter":"C023","text":"Thank you so much, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d116fbf480ee","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01431","start_s":5759.457,"end_s":5762.941,"video_s":7619.457,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00279","chapter":"C023","text":"I have a couple questions for Phoenix PD.","fingerprint":"9f986cb6f3ca","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01432","start_s":5763.461,"end_s":5765.023,"video_s":7623.461,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00279","chapter":"C023","text":"Not sure who's going to join us at the table.","fingerprint":"ba6dce9147df","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01433","start_s":5771.821,"end_s":5778.407,"video_s":7631.821,"speaker":"lori-bays","turn":"T00280","chapter":"C023","text":"Mayor, members of the council, Councilman Hernandez, coming to the table today, we have Assistant Chief Brian Lee and Commander Bill Mickers.","fingerprint":"a31b54fc38f6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01434","start_s":5779.488,"end_s":5783.832,"video_s":7639.488,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00281","chapter":"C023","text":"Thank you so much, Laurie, and thank you so much, Assistant Chief and Commander, for joining us.","fingerprint":"7924cfd1ec22","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01435","start_s":5784.072,"end_s":5785.934,"video_s":7644.072,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00281","chapter":"C023","text":"Just really quick questions.","fingerprint":"786fee856ca2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01436","start_s":5786.455,"end_s":5798.706,"video_s":7646.455,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00281","chapter":"C023","text":"First, well, I want to start by referencing two articles that dropped this week on interval around license plate readers, and not here in Arizona, but in other states and how they're being used in surveillance.","fingerprint":"c2bfa9fbcba3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01437","start_s":5798.686,"end_s":5811.082,"video_s":7658.686,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00281","chapter":"C023","text":"First, one of the articles mentions reviews of the flock surveillance camera records that showed that at least 18 officers in other cities were using the software to stalk exes and strangers.","fingerprint":"4a5d522be380","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01438","start_s":5811.663,"end_s":5819.533,"video_s":7671.663,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00281","chapter":"C023","text":"One particular officer in Florida ran his ex-girlfriend plates about 69 times, according to what was reported.","fingerprint":"392c9be48df0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01439","start_s":5819.553,"end_s":5826.482,"video_s":7679.553,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00281","chapter":"C023","text":"This is widely unacceptable and cannot be tolerated in any department, and I think","fingerprint":"0cec61018fdd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01440","start_s":5826.462,"end_s":5828.888,"video_s":7686.462,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00281","chapter":"C023","text":"We would all agree that that should not be tolerated here.","fingerprint":"2269bffe2f7f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01441","start_s":5828.948,"end_s":5842.8,"video_s":7688.948,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00281","chapter":"C023","text":"Can either of you review for me what parameters are in place to make sure that we prevent that sort of thing that happened in Florida from the system that we have here from being abused in that manner?","fingerprint":"d8e6ec5651d5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01442","start_s":5845.548,"end_s":5848.676,"video_s":7705.548,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00282","chapter":"C023","text":"Good afternoon, Mayor, members of council, Councilman Hernandez.","fingerprint":"e2542415e805","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01443","start_s":5848.696,"end_s":5849.659,"video_s":7708.696,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00282","chapter":"C023","text":"Yeah, absolutely.","fingerprint":"edfa3194e82a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01444","start_s":5849.679,"end_s":5859.405,"video_s":7709.679,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00282","chapter":"C023","text":"That's one of the areas that was a primary focus for us when we put together our policy, was to make sure that it was in alignment with our current operations orders for the department.","fingerprint":"4e71b8fa3f50","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01445","start_s":5860.347,"end_s":5862.072,"video_s":7720.347,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00282","chapter":"C023","text":"Police officers, when they use","fingerprint":"c3629069c926","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01446","start_s":5862.052,"end_s":5872.609,"video_s":7722.052,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00282","chapter":"C023","text":"Any of the computer systems, software databases, or conduct any research that's related to police activity, they have to follow a very strict policy in terms of identifying what the use is for.","fingerprint":"60174832a2a5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01447","start_s":5872.989,"end_s":5880.942,"video_s":7732.989,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00282","chapter":"C023","text":"Everything they use it for actually creates a record, a city record, for us to be able to go back and conduct audits or look for misuse or abuse.","fingerprint":"1568de838ede","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01448","start_s":5881.543,"end_s":5883.606,"video_s":7741.543,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00282","chapter":"C023","text":"I, too, had seen the same article.","fingerprint":"e5b415774308","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01449","start_s":5883.726,"end_s":5886.27,"video_s":7743.726,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00282","chapter":"C023","text":"I've read through it as well.","fingerprint":"6c9a92ae1c6a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01450","start_s":5886.25,"end_s":5915.312,"video_s":7746.25,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00282","chapter":"C023","text":"although there were some questions I wasn't sure why they ran it so many times but again it certainly would have been one of those items that would have jumped off the table for us if a supervisor doing their their normal monthly reviews if they're looking at that and they see the same person being run by the same individual that many times that would have certainly been a red flag for us for discipline with the police department our officers are actually held to a pretty high standard because not only can they lose their access for certification","fingerprint":"8740c553ecac","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01451","start_s":5915.647,"end_s":5923.354,"video_s":7775.647,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00282","chapter":"C023","text":"but they can also suffer discipline up to and including termination for misuse of those types of city systems.","fingerprint":"87b6c1f6e72a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01452","start_s":5923.374,"end_s":5924.415,"video_s":7783.374,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00283","chapter":"C023","text":"Okay, thank you so much, Chief Lee.","fingerprint":"f1f858d2a91d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01453","start_s":5925.176,"end_s":5935.925,"video_s":7785.176,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00283","chapter":"C023","text":"And I think my next question was gonna be who will have access to the data collected by IRL, I almost went with the acronym, but I'm gonna call them for the audience, the license plate readers.","fingerprint":"120ea7864719","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01454","start_s":5936.546,"end_s":5939.228,"video_s":7796.546,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00283","chapter":"C023","text":"And on the audit, you mentioned the audit piece a little bit.","fingerprint":"415c59167449","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01455","start_s":5939.308,"end_s":5942.711,"video_s":7799.308,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00283","chapter":"C023","text":"How often will those audits be happening?","fingerprint":"ddbc8c2c6f19","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01456","start_s":5942.912,"end_s":5944.573,"video_s":7802.912,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00283","chapter":"C023","text":"I think you mentioned monthly, correct?","fingerprint":"4718ff5b9567","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01457","start_s":5945.954,"end_s":5956.352,"video_s":7805.954,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00284","chapter":"C023","text":"Mayor, members of council, Councilwoman Hernandez, back on November 19th of 25, when we moved forward with the use of this, we established the audit process at that point.","fingerprint":"12852b99db4a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01458","start_s":5956.913,"end_s":5964.807,"video_s":7816.913,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00284","chapter":"C023","text":"During the month of December of 25, we actually conducted a test audit just to check our process, make sure that the information we were collecting was accurate.","fingerprint":"2d4f271746ad","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01459","start_s":5964.787,"end_s":5968.19,"video_s":7824.787,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00284","chapter":"C023","text":"and then we started with the first quarter of 2026.","fingerprint":"eed8d0bed26d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01460","start_s":5968.23,"end_s":5974.096,"video_s":7828.23,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00284","chapter":"C023","text":"That audit has been completed and we're getting ready to start the second quarter which will happen at the end of the month of June.","fingerprint":"4d001bcee066","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01461","start_s":5974.556,"end_s":5978.96,"video_s":7834.556,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00284","chapter":"C023","text":"So we are doing quarterly audits and that was done in consultation with City Audit Department.","fingerprint":"361ca969c372","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01462","start_s":5978.98,"end_s":5979.381,"video_s":7838.98,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00285","chapter":"C023","text":"Okay, perfect.","fingerprint":"88ec2490b428","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01463","start_s":5979.401,"end_s":5980.001,"video_s":7839.401,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00285","chapter":"C023","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01464","start_s":5980.682,"end_s":5993.494,"video_s":7840.682,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00285","chapter":"C023","text":"And as we find, if we find any discrepancies where there will be training that will address that, that could be provided to our officers to make sure that we are preventing any...","fingerprint":"763a541a6f2f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01465","start_s":5993.474,"end_s":5994.596,"video_s":7853.474,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00285","chapter":"C023","text":"for unneeded access.","fingerprint":"c7271a1fa484","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01466","start_s":5995.858,"end_s":5998.764,"video_s":7855.858,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00286","chapter":"C023","text":"Mayor, members of council, Councilwoman Hernandez, yeah, absolutely.","fingerprint":"810248814d62","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01467","start_s":5998.804,"end_s":6007.72,"video_s":7858.804,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00286","chapter":"C023","text":"With that auditing process, once we go through and we look at it, we actually use a 10% auditing percentage that we go through of all the queries that were run.","fingerprint":"c6e50248c719","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01468","start_s":6008.037,"end_s":6014.33,"video_s":7868.037,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00286","chapter":"C023","text":"just to give you an example for the last quarter was roughly 25,000 queries that were run through the system.","fingerprint":"033319b99e17","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01469","start_s":6014.37,"end_s":6016.093,"video_s":7874.37,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00286","chapter":"C023","text":"So we're auditing about 10% of that.","fingerprint":"929a97e9ab21","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01470","start_s":6016.634,"end_s":6019.861,"video_s":7876.634,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00286","chapter":"C023","text":"The national standard according to the audit department is around 3%.","fingerprint":"c4472109637b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01471","start_s":6020.202,"end_s":6024.831,"video_s":7880.202,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00286","chapter":"C023","text":"So we are doing more than the national average.","fingerprint":"13be76d1df78","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01472","start_s":6024.811,"end_s":6038.894,"video_s":7884.811,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00286","chapter":"C023","text":"but if we do find anything in there that is that is suspicious we have systems in place internally within the department as I mentioned earlier the discipline system but we also identify whether or not it is a training need or if somebody just isn't using the system the way it was intended or designed.","fingerprint":"00cf1bdc9f44","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01473","start_s":6039.275,"end_s":6050.413,"video_s":7899.275,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00287","chapter":"C023","text":"Okay thank you Chief Lee and then the second article cited product sheets from a license plate reader manufacturer that includes add-on sensors that can capture phones","fingerprint":"4b300aea4a65","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01474","start_s":6050.393,"end_s":6076.519,"video_s":7910.393,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00287","chapter":"C023","text":"Thank you all for joining us today.","fingerprint":"9482ddb09068","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01475","start_s":6077.984,"end_s":6083.056,"video_s":7937.984,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00287","chapter":"C023","text":"It's just the authority that other law enforcement departments have taken to use those license plate readers.","fingerprint":"7a9ad2219f22","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01476","start_s":6084.218,"end_s":6095.183,"video_s":7944.218,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00287","chapter":"C023","text":"I want to make sure that I understand and the public understands is our department and our license plate readers going to include any of those added on capacities.","fingerprint":"d69192e62e12","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01477","start_s":6095.669,"end_s":6098.514,"video_s":7955.669,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00288","chapter":"C023","text":"Mayor, members of council, Councilwoman Hernandez, that's a great question.","fingerprint":"54c282f42acc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01478","start_s":6098.935,"end_s":6100.679,"video_s":7958.935,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00288","chapter":"C023","text":"That second article I am not familiar with.","fingerprint":"4b15553982b9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01479","start_s":6101.36,"end_s":6102.662,"video_s":7961.36,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00288","chapter":"C023","text":"So I'm hearing that for the first time.","fingerprint":"bd6b1206e907","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01480","start_s":6103.203,"end_s":6108.474,"video_s":7963.203,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00288","chapter":"C023","text":"I can assure you that since we use Motorola products, we do not use Flock.","fingerprint":"cede0bafd1e5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01481","start_s":6108.674,"end_s":6112.902,"video_s":7968.674,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00288","chapter":"C023","text":"So I'm not aware of or familiar with any of those enhanced technology","fingerprint":"1e82ae90e1e3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01482","start_s":6112.882,"end_s":6115.165,"video_s":7972.882,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00288","chapter":"C023","text":"supplemental pieces that could be added on.","fingerprint":"8fb6a69ac07e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01483","start_s":6116.006,"end_s":6122.576,"video_s":7976.006,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00288","chapter":"C023","text":"I can tell you that all within the city of Phoenix, all of our systems, the only thing that we are using is the Motorola and that is the camera only.","fingerprint":"9c0a8809b729","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01484","start_s":6123.257,"end_s":6125.38,"video_s":7983.257,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00288","chapter":"C023","text":"We do not have any additional technology.","fingerprint":"4831818003fe","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01485","start_s":6125.44,"end_s":6130.587,"video_s":7985.44,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00288","chapter":"C023","text":"And if we were looking at any expanded technology, we would have to come back and bring that before the council.","fingerprint":"a108f8c04964","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01486","start_s":6130.567,"end_s":6131.668,"video_s":7990.567,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00288","chapter":"C023","text":"Okay, thank you so much, Chief Lee.","fingerprint":"f1f858d2a91d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01487","start_s":6131.688,"end_s":6139.878,"video_s":7991.688,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00289","chapter":"C023","text":"And I'll send you the article so the team can review it and you are all aware of what is happening to Mother City.","fingerprint":"7888e6e34e9e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01488","start_s":6139.938,"end_s":6141.66,"video_s":7999.938,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00289","chapter":"C023","text":"So thank you for sharing that.","fingerprint":"dca986ec3cfe","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01489","start_s":6141.68,"end_s":6142.961,"video_s":8001.68,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00289","chapter":"C023","text":"I'm glad that's not happening here.","fingerprint":"9b1130ef97c9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01490","start_s":6143.021,"end_s":6145.063,"video_s":8003.021,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00289","chapter":"C023","text":"Those are just my only two questions.","fingerprint":"81efb662023b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01491","start_s":6145.143,"end_s":6155.375,"video_s":8005.143,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00289","chapter":"C023","text":"And I still have a lot of concerns that the automatic license plate readers have more benefit or the benefits outweigh the concerns for me.","fingerprint":"f06240feec5c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01492","start_s":6155.495,"end_s":6157.377,"video_s":8015.495,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00289","chapter":"C023","text":"So I am going to be voting no on that today.","fingerprint":"155db25faa79","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01493","start_s":6157.397,"end_s":6159.78,"video_s":8017.397,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00289","chapter":"C023","text":"I still have a lot of concerns","fingerprint":"d240800500b4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01494","start_s":6159.76,"end_s":6165.674,"video_s":8019.76,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00289","chapter":"C023","text":"I still have some mistrust around how we won't violate our residents First Amendment rights and privacy concerns.","fingerprint":"c184d0f8ebda","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01495","start_s":6166.597,"end_s":6173.212,"video_s":8026.597,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00289","chapter":"C023","text":"So, you know, it's again a slippery slope that we go down with some of this technology and the uses on it.","fingerprint":"b1c4e0720dbb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01496","start_s":6173.754,"end_s":6177.583,"video_s":8033.754,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00289","chapter":"C023","text":"I understand, right, the need to maintain","fingerprint":"ab3da6cfb8b9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01497","start_s":6177.563,"end_s":6182.349,"video_s":8037.563,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00289","chapter":"C023","text":"Thank you so much, Chief Lee.","fingerprint":"9893bf29d0b4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01498","start_s":6182.409,"end_s":6201.411,"video_s":8042.409,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00289","chapter":"C023","text":"Thank you so much, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d116fbf480ee","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01499","start_s":6201.695,"end_s":6202.917,"video_s":8061.695,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00289","chapter":"C023","text":"Thank you, Councilwoman Guardado.","fingerprint":"93733fe85690","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01500","start_s":6203.538,"end_s":6204.158,"video_s":8063.538,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00290","chapter":"C023","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01501","start_s":6204.579,"end_s":6206.922,"video_s":8064.579,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00290","chapter":"C023","text":"Chief, I just had just a question for you.","fingerprint":"3edd3808409d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01502","start_s":6206.942,"end_s":6211.549,"video_s":8066.942,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00290","chapter":"C023","text":"On the license plate readers, I know I was a huge advocate for those.","fingerprint":"56e1b23ecee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01503","start_s":6212.21,"end_s":6221.543,"video_s":8072.21,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00290","chapter":"C023","text":"Can you just tell us a couple of success stories that we've had thanks to license plate readers given all the challenge, especially along 27th Avenue?","fingerprint":"8c2ade6317a9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01504","start_s":6222.637,"end_s":6224.961,"video_s":8082.637,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00291","chapter":"C023","text":"Mayor, members of council, Councilwoman Guardado.","fingerprint":"730e7cc27b42","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01505","start_s":6226.023,"end_s":6232.295,"video_s":8086.023,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00291","chapter":"C023","text":"Yes, fortunately for us, we continue to see at kind of an unprecedented rate the number of successes that are happening every day.","fingerprint":"50ad96a3a2eb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01506","start_s":6233.096,"end_s":6240.27,"video_s":8093.096,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00291","chapter":"C023","text":"And we are able to capture some of those through our current real-time operations centers that we have in the Desert Horizon Precinct as well as the Cactus Park Precinct.","fingerprint":"abb3a44b9076","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01507","start_s":6241.752,"end_s":6245.86,"video_s":8101.752,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00291","chapter":"C023","text":"This technology is supporting patrol-based efforts within each of the precincts.","fingerprint":"956c2e8f7feb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01508","start_s":6246.076,"end_s":6251.611,"video_s":8106.076,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00291","chapter":"C023","text":"and we are looking at ways to continue to expand that to be able to provide greater support citywide.","fingerprint":"f59bfae064bc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01509","start_s":6252.012,"end_s":6255.782,"video_s":8112.012,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00291","chapter":"C023","text":"However, to your point, one of the most recent success stories that we've had","fingerprint":"53bda302e5ed","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01510","start_s":6256.117,"end_s":6258.261,"video_s":8116.117,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00291","chapter":"C023","text":"Only because it just happened a couple of weeks ago.","fingerprint":"1289479d7bf2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01511","start_s":6258.281,"end_s":6269.781,"video_s":8118.281,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00291","chapter":"C023","text":"On June 2nd of this month, we had the incident where it was a homicide of one teen out at Desert Sky Mall, 7611 West Thomas Road.","fingerprint":"ac13ccce15a6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01512","start_s":6271.264,"end_s":6276.353,"video_s":8131.264,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00291","chapter":"C023","text":"When the suspect produced the gun and fired multiple rounds, we did have one victim who was deceased.","fingerprint":"eb82e6a7f510","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01513","start_s":6276.687,"end_s":6285.523,"video_s":8136.687,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00291","chapter":"C023","text":"The investigators on the scene as soon as the officers arrived began searching the nearby cameras based on the description of the vehicle that was provided by witnesses and bystanders at the scene.","fingerprint":"0ebaeb65f15d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01514","start_s":6286.184,"end_s":6294.139,"video_s":8146.184,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00291","chapter":"C023","text":"That information was critical because the license plate readers that are networked throughout that part of the valley were able to pick the vehicle up.","fingerprint":"d538d8f31c42","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01515","start_s":6294.457,"end_s":6303.972,"video_s":8154.457,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00291","chapter":"C023","text":"which was again a start for investigators to be able to conduct their necessary intelligence workup to be able to identify where the vehicle was associated with and then they went from there.","fingerprint":"ca5fcd8b766a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01516","start_s":6304.032,"end_s":6318.135,"video_s":8164.032,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00291","chapter":"C023","text":"Now while this investigation is still ongoing, investigators have shared multiple times that the use of this technology early on in an investigation is critical to developing those first pieces of investigative follow-up.","fingerprint":"636473cdf511","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01517","start_s":6319.06,"end_s":6320.663,"video_s":8179.06,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C023","text":"Thank you so much for that.","fingerprint":"121d87d3fc1f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01518","start_s":6320.684,"end_s":6337.44,"video_s":8180.684,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C023","text":"I just think along 27th Avenue, a few years ago, being called on by residents with all the issues happening with the drugs, with the prostitution, with that one hotel we had that we were able to shut down.","fingerprint":"ab06f9479106","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01519","start_s":6337.42,"end_s":6350.109,"video_s":8197.42,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C023","text":"I see how essential the license plate readers have been and will continue to be until we don't have a full on capacity within the police department that we're able to hire all the police officers that we can.","fingerprint":"a829983d564e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01520","start_s":6350.651,"end_s":6354.72,"video_s":8210.651,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C023","text":"We need all the technology to continue to keep our neighbors safe.","fingerprint":"66af0b6ba821","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01521","start_s":6354.7,"end_s":6363.779,"video_s":8214.7,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C023","text":"and we have a responsibility as council members, at least I feel the responsibility as council members to use all the tools that we have to continue to keep neighbors safe.","fingerprint":"4a805ab86524","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01522","start_s":6363.859,"end_s":6370.633,"video_s":8223.859,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C023","text":"I was just in a meeting last week where neighbors finally told me, we see improvement, Betty.","fingerprint":"ed29484f35e9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01523","start_s":6370.613,"end_s":6375.005,"video_s":8230.613,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C023","text":"We see everything that you guys are doing is working and we're not done.","fingerprint":"210196cfed88","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01524","start_s":6375.045,"end_s":6377.471,"video_s":8235.045,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C023","text":"There's still a lot to be done.","fingerprint":"c0e5245de44f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01525","start_s":6377.491,"end_s":6387.036,"video_s":8237.491,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C023","text":"You know, kudos to Senator Bravo, who was able to pass HB 2720, the prostitution bill, and where there's a lot more work","fingerprint":"45320253b053","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01526","start_s":6387.016,"end_s":6387.878,"video_s":8247.016,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C023","text":"that needs to be done.","fingerprint":"daaf6c9d3789","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01527","start_s":6387.898,"end_s":6403.708,"video_s":8247.898,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C023","text":"But I think that the reason that bill was able to be passed is because of all the work that we're doing as a city, the work that the police department is doing, the real-time operation centers, all of the work, all of the investment that we've put in and we're finally","fingerprint":"f4ec25dcdb46","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01528","start_s":6403.688,"end_s":6416.967,"video_s":8263.688,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C023","text":"Having some luck at the state level and being able to pass a very substantial bill to continue to build on what needs to happen on 27th Avenue and everywhere else throughout the city.","fingerprint":"01f6043411ed","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01529","start_s":6417.027,"end_s":6424.077,"video_s":8277.027,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C023","text":"The incident that happened at Desert Sky Mall was also in my district and my heart goes out to those families and","fingerprint":"230b7b8d4c9a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01530","start_s":6424.057,"end_s":6428.222,"video_s":8284.057,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C023","text":"The challenges and the issues that continue to happen through the district.","fingerprint":"ef83f3dd9be7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01531","start_s":6428.362,"end_s":6440.075,"video_s":8288.362,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C023","text":"I continue to get the text messages every day of all the incidents that continue to happen and I see how essential it is to making sure that we have the license plate readers and everything that we need.","fingerprint":"4e17d029f70c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01532","start_s":6440.616,"end_s":6446.402,"video_s":8300.616,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C023","text":"We also passed CTI not that long ago that I think helps.","fingerprint":"4f07a0bcde1a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01533","start_s":6446.382,"end_s":6463.041,"video_s":8306.382,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C023","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01534","start_s":6463.021,"end_s":6466.745,"video_s":8323.021,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C023","text":"that helps us protect our residents as we continue to do the work that we do.","fingerprint":"4fb1f58b8240","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01535","start_s":6466.825,"end_s":6471.992,"video_s":8326.825,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C023","text":"So thank you for all of your guys' hard work and everything that you guys do out there, out in the streets.","fingerprint":"c5389928064e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01536","start_s":6472.112,"end_s":6473.533,"video_s":8332.112,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C023","text":"And like I said, we're not done.","fingerprint":"0c9c7ad9c623","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01537","start_s":6474.254,"end_s":6483.885,"video_s":8334.254,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C023","text":"There's still a lot of work that needs to be done throughout our city, specifically on 27th Avenue, but definitely we're very thankful for everything that you guys do every day.","fingerprint":"e18c2d0174e9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01538","start_s":6484.166,"end_s":6484.706,"video_s":8344.166,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C023","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01539","start_s":6487.169,"end_s":6487.63,"video_s":8347.169,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00293","chapter":"C023","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01540","start_s":6488.291,"end_s":6488.711,"video_s":8348.291,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00293","chapter":"C023","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01541","start_s":6489.612,"end_s":6489.993,"video_s":8349.612,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00293","chapter":"C023","text":"Guardado?","fingerprint":"0344b48c3f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01542","start_s":6490.293,"end_s":6490.994,"video_s":8350.293,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00293","chapter":"C023","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01543","start_s":6491.014,"end_s":6491.795,"video_s":8351.014,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00293","chapter":"C023","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01544","start_s":6491.815,"end_s":6492.015,"video_s":8351.815,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00293","chapter":"C023","text":"No.","fingerprint":"9390298f3fb0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01545","start_s":6493.025,"end_s":6493.546,"video_s":8353.025,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00293","chapter":"C023","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01546","start_s":6493.767,"end_s":6493.987,"video_s":8353.767,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00293","chapter":"C023","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01547","start_s":6494.548,"end_s":6495.029,"video_s":8354.548,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00293","chapter":"C023","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01548","start_s":6496.131,"end_s":6496.372,"video_s":8356.131,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00294","chapter":"C023","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01549","start_s":6496.392,"end_s":6497.274,"video_s":8356.392,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00294","chapter":"C023","text":"Can I explain my vote?","fingerprint":"e881d2afa8f3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01550","start_s":6498.196,"end_s":6498.376,"video_s":8358.196,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00294","chapter":"C023","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01551","start_s":6499.418,"end_s":6509.92,"video_s":8359.418,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00294","chapter":"C023","text":"I just want to quickly say that it was a license plate readers that helped on several incidences on 27th Avenue and Thomas.","fingerprint":"efb5ae82674d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01552","start_s":6509.9,"end_s":6514.165,"video_s":8369.9,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00294","chapter":"C023","text":"in particular, two murders or homicides, sorry.","fingerprint":"62504671b720","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01553","start_s":6514.626,"end_s":6523.217,"video_s":8374.626,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00294","chapter":"C023","text":"And if it wasn't for that, the license plate readers, we wouldn't have been able to figure out what happened in that space and who did it.","fingerprint":"b93f6c811609","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01554","start_s":6523.737,"end_s":6531.006,"video_s":8383.737,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00294","chapter":"C023","text":"So it does bring value to our community and it helps us solve crime.","fingerprint":"816005a164e4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01555","start_s":6531.046,"end_s":6531.587,"video_s":8391.046,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00294","chapter":"C023","text":"So thank you.","fingerprint":"dd9ed184b6d2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01556","start_s":6532.883,"end_s":6533.405,"video_s":8392.883,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00295","chapter":"C023","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01557","start_s":6533.665,"end_s":6534.388,"video_s":8393.665,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00295","chapter":"C023","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01558","start_s":6534.408,"end_s":6534.749,"video_s":8394.408,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00295","chapter":"C023","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01559","start_s":6535.11,"end_s":6535.812,"video_s":8395.11,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00295","chapter":"C023","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01560","start_s":6535.832,"end_s":6536.173,"video_s":8395.832,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00295","chapter":"C023","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01561","start_s":6537.257,"end_s":6537.337,"video_s":8397.257,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00295","chapter":"C023","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01562","start_s":6537.357,"end_s":6537.959,"video_s":8397.357,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00295","chapter":"C023","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01563","start_s":6538.139,"end_s":6538.4,"video_s":8398.139,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00296","chapter":"C023","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01564","start_s":6538.821,"end_s":6539.243,"video_s":8398.821,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00296","chapter":"C023","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01565","start_s":6539.403,"end_s":6539.624,"video_s":8399.403,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00296","chapter":"C023","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01566","start_s":6539.965,"end_s":6540.527,"video_s":8399.965,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00296","chapter":"C023","text":"Passes 8-1.","fingerprint":"a7b3afc7a8da","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01567","start_s":6541.69,"end_s":6545.442,"video_s":8401.69,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00297","chapter":"C024","text":"Item 128 is the Youth Engagement Training Service.","fingerprint":"16a4788bfd10","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01568","start_s":6545.86,"end_s":6547.663,"video_s":8405.86,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00297","chapter":"C024","text":"Request for award, Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"d4dd3caaa80a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01569","start_s":6547.683,"end_s":6549.185,"video_s":8407.683,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00298","chapter":"C024","text":"Motion to approve item 128.","fingerprint":"dd47224fdbe9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01570","start_s":6549.646,"end_s":6550.026,"video_s":8409.646,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00298","chapter":"C024","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01571","start_s":6550.667,"end_s":6551.388,"video_s":8410.667,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00298","chapter":"C024","text":"Councilman Hernandez.","fingerprint":"3bb873cefabf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01572","start_s":6552.149,"end_s":6552.61,"video_s":8412.149,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C024","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01573","start_s":6552.67,"end_s":6553.792,"video_s":8412.67,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C024","text":"Don't have any questions on this.","fingerprint":"aa4e50186c81","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01574","start_s":6553.812,"end_s":6555.875,"video_s":8413.812,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C024","text":"Just wanted to make a couple of brief comments.","fingerprint":"6e235463fdc7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01575","start_s":6556.776,"end_s":6562.986,"video_s":8416.776,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C024","text":"First, you know, my team flagged that the vendor for this contract, or flagged this vendor for their contract with OAT.","fingerprint":"99b44fa8c306","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01576","start_s":6563.727,"end_s":6567.092,"video_s":8423.727,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C024","text":"Their curriculum simply did not accurately prepare youth","fingerprint":"58b535282221","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01577","start_s":6567.072,"end_s":6568.874,"video_s":8427.072,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C024","text":"for engaging with our police department.","fingerprint":"cfcf6f61f0a6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01578","start_s":6569.475,"end_s":6579.868,"video_s":8429.475,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C024","text":"It teaches you to act right, which really shifts the responsibility off of our trained professional officers and puts it on the teens whose brains are literally still developing.","fingerprint":"d36f9029bd56","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01579","start_s":6580.489,"end_s":6581.891,"video_s":8440.489,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C024","text":"To me, that's really unacceptable.","fingerprint":"42b68665672c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01580","start_s":6581.951,"end_s":6586.056,"video_s":8441.951,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C024","text":"Second, there's no community or parent oversight on this curriculum.","fingerprint":"9d616db3e735","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01581","start_s":6586.777,"end_s":6591.763,"video_s":8446.777,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C024","text":"We actually don't even know what the curriculum will be and, you know, asking","fingerprint":"5b5cba1aeadc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01582","start_s":6591.743,"end_s":6598.274,"video_s":8451.743,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C024","text":"voting to approve a contract of up to $120,000 without knowing exactly where that curriculum will be.","fingerprint":"2c0e6054b2e7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01583","start_s":6598.674,"end_s":6600.157,"video_s":8458.674,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C024","text":"I just, I can't support that.","fingerprint":"28c8c5dad070","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01584","start_s":6601.178,"end_s":6611.355,"video_s":8461.178,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C024","text":"Next, the DOJ flagged, you know, one of the findings in the DOJ investigation was that our police interactions with youth and kids","fingerprint":"b0077af67735","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01585","start_s":6611.335,"end_s":6626.712,"video_s":8471.335,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C024","text":"As disturbing and likely to traumatize our children, instead of continuing to force interactions between our officers and youth, we should be asking caretakers, counselors, and individuals who can offer support to make that contact.","fingerprint":"ed248fe1e09c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01586","start_s":6627.633,"end_s":6631.717,"video_s":8487.633,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C024","text":"Overall, the title says it all, Policing the Teen Brain.","fingerprint":"14f53eaaafc3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01587","start_s":6631.777,"end_s":6635.942,"video_s":8491.777,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C024","text":"Teens don't need policing.","fingerprint":"ded87d6a539f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01588","start_s":6635.922,"end_s":6643.317,"video_s":8495.922,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C024","text":"We cannot fundamentally understand them if the default approach begins and ends with policing.","fingerprint":"6872c2c73e00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01589","start_s":6644.078,"end_s":6651.954,"video_s":8504.078,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C024","text":"Kids need guidance, they need mentorship, they need care, they need investment into resources for them and for their families.","fingerprint":"2706f0e1ed4b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01590","start_s":6652.395,"end_s":6656.142,"video_s":8512.395,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C024","text":"Policing will not solve the challenges that our youth face","fingerprint":"45019350d807","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01591","start_s":6656.999,"end_s":6670.857,"video_s":8516.999,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C024","text":"And today, finally, today is also pretty triggering because yesterday in Mississippi, police shot and killed a one-year-old baby boy, a black boy,","fingerprint":"d428a93679f6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01592","start_s":6671.663,"end_s":6677.33,"video_s":8531.663,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C024","text":"Our children, especially our black and brown children, are being murdered, point blank period.","fingerprint":"d36d4eb46fde","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01593","start_s":6678.071,"end_s":6684.96,"video_s":8538.071,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C024","text":"And I cannot in good conscience vote to approve anything that increases the interaction of police with our kids.","fingerprint":"565faa985685","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01594","start_s":6686.402,"end_s":6698.397,"video_s":8546.402,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C024","text":"Every time our officers interact with our youth, those officers literally carry the possibility of death into that engagement.","fingerprint":"ce36105d21c4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01595","start_s":6699.98,"end_s":6702.343,"video_s":8559.98,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C024","text":"So for me, police shouldn't be nowhere near our kids.","fingerprint":"8e34bbb932f2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01596","start_s":6703.045,"end_s":6703.525,"video_s":8563.045,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C024","text":"Thanks, Mayor.","fingerprint":"477393354163","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01597","start_s":6707.832,"end_s":6708.212,"video_s":8567.832,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C024","text":"Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"9a95bf6095c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01598","start_s":6709.294,"end_s":6709.674,"video_s":8569.294,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00300","chapter":"C024","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01599","start_s":6710.255,"end_s":6711.998,"video_s":8570.255,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00300","chapter":"C024","text":"Can I ask a few questions about the training?","fingerprint":"ebdb59d8d8ca","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01600","start_s":6712.038,"end_s":6726.539,"video_s":8572.038,"speaker":"lori-bays","turn":"T00301","chapter":"C024","text":"Mayor, Vice Mayor, members of the Council, we do have Assistant Chief Jeff Benza and Commander Brian Knuppel, as well as, I know, as well as Deborah Hale.","fingerprint":"91eba277f5be","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01601","start_s":6726.92,"end_s":6727.521,"video_s":8586.92,"speaker":"lori-bays","turn":"T00301","chapter":"C024","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01602","start_s":6728.041,"end_s":6728.502,"video_s":8588.041,"speaker":"lori-bays","turn":"T00301","chapter":"C024","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01603","start_s":6737.138,"end_s":6738.401,"video_s":8597.138,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00302","chapter":"C024","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01604","start_s":6738.421,"end_s":6748.043,"video_s":8598.421,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00302","chapter":"C024","text":"Can you explain the process that the department underwent in determining this training as appropriate to determine the feasibility and the appropriateness of this training?","fingerprint":"2da989205f02","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01605","start_s":6755.161,"end_s":6773.642,"video_s":8615.161,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00303","chapter":"C024","text":"Mayor, members of council, Vice Mayor Hodge Washington, yes, we have been working on this project since 2024, and when we first started it, we went through a gap analysis to see where we had gaps, and training was...","fingerprint":"0ff3fdfbe192","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01606","start_s":6774.382,"end_s":6777.827,"video_s":8634.382,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00303","chapter":"C024","text":"one of the areas that we needed to improve upon.","fingerprint":"c741e191105b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01607","start_s":6778.508,"end_s":6792.129,"video_s":8638.508,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00303","chapter":"C024","text":"So we went through, I went through a nationwide search and spoke to several other agencies across the nation to see what training they had been offering and that's how I came upon this vendor with their curriculum.","fingerprint":"3072fd5fb24c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01608","start_s":6792.85,"end_s":6794.112,"video_s":8652.85,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00303","chapter":"C024","text":"They've trained","fingerprint":"0534d23e1157","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01609","start_s":6794.092,"end_s":6795.715,"video_s":8654.092,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00303","chapter":"C024","text":"agencies in 28 states.","fingerprint":"41c90ca16591","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01610","start_s":6796.316,"end_s":6809.94,"video_s":8656.316,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00303","chapter":"C024","text":"They are certified with the International Association of Director of Law Enforcement Standards of Training, and they are a nonprofit, and their goal is to increase","fingerprint":"b108f7ea693e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01611","start_s":6812.148,"end_s":6815.415,"video_s":8672.148,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00303","chapter":"C024","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01612","start_s":6816.577,"end_s":6833.532,"video_s":8676.577,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00303","chapter":"C024","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01613","start_s":6833.512,"end_s":6844.892,"video_s":8693.512,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00304","chapter":"C024","text":"Thank you because I did a just a quick little research into the into the training as well because it did pique my interest and I did see that it was utilized in a number of cities but I didn't realize it was so extensive to get into 28 states.","fingerprint":"36f2e87d775f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01614","start_s":6844.952,"end_s":6856.532,"video_s":8704.952,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00304","chapter":"C024","text":"I know for example Boston, LA, San Francisco, Baltimore, Washington DC, Fresno, Cleveland, Charlottesville, a number of municipalities have utilized this.","fingerprint":"94a9870e3f51","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01615","start_s":6856.512,"end_s":6866.877,"video_s":8716.512,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00304","chapter":"C024","text":"and one of the things that I don't know if you have any data regarding any metrics of success that other cities and municipalities have seen utilizing this program.","fingerprint":"c12eeb060caa","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01616","start_s":6869.371,"end_s":6872.756,"video_s":8729.371,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00305","chapter":"C024","text":"Mayor, members of council, Vice Hodge Washington.","fingerprint":"28c91797ed5e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01617","start_s":6873.236,"end_s":6883.61,"video_s":8733.236,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00305","chapter":"C024","text":"Yes, I did talk to several agencies to get information on how the training went in their departments with the Baltimore Police Department specifically.","fingerprint":"8e2b1562b96f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01618","start_s":6883.67,"end_s":6888.797,"video_s":8743.67,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00305","chapter":"C024","text":"They said they had a huge reduction in use of force with youth.","fingerprint":"9224c70cecf0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01619","start_s":6888.777,"end_s":6903.055,"video_s":8748.777,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00305","chapter":"C024","text":"and I also spoke with the Salt Lake City SRO Chief of Police for their school districts there and they indicated that they have had a lower number of arrests.","fingerprint":"100fe6e8562a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01620","start_s":6903.075,"end_s":6915.51,"video_s":8763.075,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00305","chapter":"C024","text":"I don't have specific data from those agencies but I also spoke with Chief Gandy in Madison, Alabama who also attended the training when he was a captain","fingerprint":"59800400eb0a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01621","start_s":6915.727,"end_s":6931.255,"video_s":8775.727,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00305","chapter":"C024","text":"At Virginia Beach, and it was so successful there, he brought it to his agency when he became chief and said that it has helped their department tremendously, reducing incidents and helping officers understand how to escalate with youth better.","fingerprint":"9bc6ffa291a9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01622","start_s":6931.235,"end_s":6933.378,"video_s":8791.235,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00305","chapter":"C024","text":"I'm sorry, Dee Escalate with Youth Better.","fingerprint":"05509258734e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01623","start_s":6934.64,"end_s":6935.522,"video_s":8794.64,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00306","chapter":"C024","text":"Thank you for the correction.","fingerprint":"3ebca88146dd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01624","start_s":6935.562,"end_s":6947.421,"video_s":8795.562,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00306","chapter":"C024","text":"And then my last question is, if this is approved, what are some of the metrics of success that the Phoenix Police Department will use in determining whether or not this is a successful program?","fingerprint":"0062aedf48f9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01625","start_s":6948.16,"end_s":6950.263,"video_s":8808.16,"speaker":"v24","turn":"T00307","chapter":"C024","text":"Mayor, members of council, Vice Mayor Hodge Washington.","fingerprint":"f9e424a73422","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01626","start_s":6950.283,"end_s":6956.952,"video_s":8810.283,"speaker":"v24","turn":"T00307","chapter":"C024","text":"One of the metrics we're gonna look at is we already look at officer initiated contacts with people.","fingerprint":"8354d40b3f7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01627","start_s":6956.972,"end_s":6959.876,"video_s":8816.972,"speaker":"v24","turn":"T00307","chapter":"C024","text":"So we're gonna look at those things, the stop searches and arrests that we've talked about.","fingerprint":"d9d1f2fbf577","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01628","start_s":6959.916,"end_s":6962.961,"video_s":8819.916,"speaker":"v24","turn":"T00307","chapter":"C024","text":"We're gonna look at use of force and we're gonna look at youth arrest totals.","fingerprint":"34bc1c23205b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01629","start_s":6963.501,"end_s":6965.084,"video_s":8823.501,"speaker":"v24","turn":"T00307","chapter":"C024","text":"Those are some of the big metrics that we see.","fingerprint":"e76745fb7c93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01630","start_s":6965.104,"end_s":6966.886,"video_s":8825.104,"speaker":"v24","turn":"T00307","chapter":"C024","text":"We wanna see if those increase or decrease.","fingerprint":"c7f63a5823fb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01631","start_s":6967.727,"end_s":6976.159,"video_s":8827.727,"speaker":"v24","turn":"T00307","chapter":"C024","text":"Having sat through a presentation from the vendor, I think that this vendor will be able to provide a lot of education for our staff.","fingerprint":"987be05da09b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01632","start_s":6976.139,"end_s":6987.273,"video_s":8836.139,"speaker":"v24","turn":"T00307","chapter":"C024","text":"We give them a lot more tools that they had not had previously to allow them to deescalate situations and to understand where the kids are coming from as they interact with our officers.","fingerprint":"2776b970fb48","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01633","start_s":6990.337,"end_s":6991.398,"video_s":8850.337,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00308","chapter":"C024","text":"Thank you so much for that.","fingerprint":"121d87d3fc1f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01634","start_s":6993.08,"end_s":6995.403,"video_s":8853.08,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00308","chapter":"C024","text":"Thank you so much for the clarification and the additional information.","fingerprint":"7404592ef228","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01635","start_s":6996.965,"end_s":6997.245,"video_s":8856.965,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00309","chapter":"C024","text":"Mayor.","fingerprint":"dd51a825d06a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01636","start_s":6997.946,"end_s":6998.687,"video_s":8857.946,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00310","chapter":"C024","text":"Councilwoman.","fingerprint":"6362e4737814","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01637","start_s":6999.055,"end_s":6999.516,"video_s":8859.055,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00311","chapter":"C024","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01638","start_s":7000.497,"end_s":7009.732,"video_s":8860.497,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00311","chapter":"C024","text":"Chief, I just had, I know I asked you this question before, because I think part of the reason why we're here is because of the DOJ investigation, right?","fingerprint":"20157e190684","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01639","start_s":7009.772,"end_s":7015.942,"video_s":8869.772,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00311","chapter":"C024","text":"And trying to take a lot more serious the incidents that we have had in the past.","fingerprint":"1ebc5f501562","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01640","start_s":7016.723,"end_s":7026.278,"video_s":8876.723,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00311","chapter":"C024","text":"And those are things that we cannot erase, but I appreciate the work that you guys are doing to move forward and how in tuned you guys are","fingerprint":"3d8801d0d187","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01641","start_s":7026.258,"end_s":7046.697,"video_s":8886.258,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00311","chapter":"C024","text":"Thank you so much for joining us.","fingerprint":"945bc1e42037","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01642","start_s":7046.677,"end_s":7055.011,"video_s":8906.677,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00311","chapter":"C024","text":"With this group, I did a little bit of my own research and I spoke to some of my counterparts in Los Angeles and heard really good things about this.","fingerprint":"de8faa1b7d5b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01643","start_s":7056.013,"end_s":7058.377,"video_s":8916.013,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00311","chapter":"C024","text":"But what about diversity and inclusivity?","fingerprint":"4d7989ab8b13","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01644","start_s":7058.437,"end_s":7060.24,"video_s":8918.437,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00311","chapter":"C024","text":"And we've talked about the different cultures.","fingerprint":"e074987fe616","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01645","start_s":7061.623,"end_s":7065.389,"video_s":8921.623,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00311","chapter":"C024","text":"How much of that is going to be included in the curriculum?","fingerprint":"ec5c12263bad","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01646","start_s":7066.992,"end_s":7071.52,"video_s":8926.992,"speaker":"v24","turn":"T00312","chapter":"C024","text":"Mayor, members of council, Councilman Obrado, I'm going to pass it off to Deb Hale, our project manager for that one.","fingerprint":"ef48ba2c400e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01647","start_s":7085.489,"end_s":7091.517,"video_s":8945.489,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00313","chapter":"C024","text":"Mayor, members of council, and Councilwoman Guardado,","fingerprint":"46c8943137bb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01648","start_s":7091.986,"end_s":7100.698,"video_s":8951.986,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00313","chapter":"C024","text":"have spoken with this vendor over several months because we wanted to make sure that this was appropriate product for us.","fingerprint":"a0a62e2410f5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01649","start_s":7101.519,"end_s":7120.204,"video_s":8961.519,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00313","chapter":"C024","text":"When they come to do the train the trainer, they actually have psychologists that come and teach a portion of the training, a large portion of the training because a large portion of the training focuses on developmental explanation of normative and compromised team behaviors.","fingerprint":"05548e281bd1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01650","start_s":7120.184,"end_s":7131.322,"video_s":8980.184,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00313","chapter":"C024","text":"And so there's going to be a large portion of this training that focuses on the developmental stages of youth, why they are risk takers and that type of thing.","fingerprint":"d5408374b887","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01651","start_s":7131.382,"end_s":7137.272,"video_s":8991.382,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00313","chapter":"C024","text":"And then they will also have partnerships with community to assist in the teaching.","fingerprint":"d9293bdced6d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01652","start_s":7137.332,"end_s":7146.327,"video_s":8997.332,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00313","chapter":"C024","text":"They like to encourage youth from the community to come and do scenario training at the end of the training to use some of the skills that they've learned.","fingerprint":"f27d96b3c748","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01653","start_s":7146.307,"end_s":7151.534,"video_s":9006.307,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00313","chapter":"C024","text":"and then we also have juvenile court probation.","fingerprint":"9bc6f571d7cd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01654","start_s":7151.734,"end_s":7160.025,"video_s":9011.734,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00313","chapter":"C024","text":"Those that are very familiar with like the juvenile diversion programs and things like that, they come and also teach portion of the course.","fingerprint":"2e26723e1e48","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01655","start_s":7160.045,"end_s":7175.284,"video_s":9020.045,"speaker":"v23","turn":"T00313","chapter":"C024","text":"So we have psychologists, clinical psychologists, the juvenile court, we have attorneys and then also we involve the community in the scenario portion of the training at the end.","fingerprint":"7b90e1fd6fcb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01656","start_s":7175.956,"end_s":7176.396,"video_s":9035.956,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00314","chapter":"C024","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01657","start_s":7176.457,"end_s":7177.698,"video_s":9036.457,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00314","chapter":"C024","text":"Thank you so much for that.","fingerprint":"121d87d3fc1f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01658","start_s":7177.818,"end_s":7181.562,"video_s":9037.818,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00314","chapter":"C024","text":"And anything that we can do to be helpful with this, please let me know.","fingerprint":"83905a87ab6c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01659","start_s":7182.122,"end_s":7183.043,"video_s":9042.122,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00314","chapter":"C024","text":"I have a teenager.","fingerprint":"05a42ebe1df1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01660","start_s":7183.063,"end_s":7184.305,"video_s":9043.063,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00314","chapter":"C024","text":"I have a 15-year-old.","fingerprint":"767305e22e5e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01661","start_s":7184.925,"end_s":7194.275,"video_s":9044.925,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00314","chapter":"C024","text":"I go to sleep better every night just knowing that we have SROs in our schools, that we have people that are protecting our children.","fingerprint":"b11f32ad875a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01662","start_s":7194.295,"end_s":7201.002,"video_s":9054.295,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00314","chapter":"C024","text":"We have seen what have happened, what happened in Texas a couple of years ago, what continues to happen throughout the country.","fingerprint":"bdfdd8ba36c1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01663","start_s":7200.982,"end_s":7206.609,"video_s":9060.982,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00314","chapter":"C024","text":"We need to make sure that we keep our children safe when they're in school, when they're out of school.","fingerprint":"62dbd843885c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01664","start_s":7207.13,"end_s":7212.377,"video_s":9067.13,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00314","chapter":"C024","text":"I know there is a commitment on this dais to hold you guys accountable to do it.","fingerprint":"b81f84c33bd8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01665","start_s":7212.718,"end_s":7215.661,"video_s":9072.718,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00314","chapter":"C024","text":"But then I also know that you guys hold yourselves accountable as well.","fingerprint":"176e21e78ac6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01666","start_s":7215.682,"end_s":7227.377,"video_s":9075.682,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00314","chapter":"C024","text":"So I really, really, really appreciate the work that you guys are doing in any way that we can be helpful, that my office can be helpful with the different high schools in my district.","fingerprint":"529d198831c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01667","start_s":7227.357,"end_s":7257.01,"video_s":9087.357,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00314","chapter":"C024","text":"wherever we can help let us know and again thank you everyone thank you Lori as well right for for leading a lot of this charge in helping us on making sure that on all the different that we are complying with all the different demands from the DOJ report thank you guys all so much thank you mayor thank you roll call Guardado yes Hernandez no O'Brien yes Pastor yes Robinson yes Stark","fingerprint":"d85ae444b0d6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01668","start_s":7258.323,"end_s":7258.603,"video_s":9118.323,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00315","chapter":"C024","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01669","start_s":7258.623,"end_s":7258.703,"video_s":9118.623,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00315","chapter":"C024","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01670","start_s":7259.624,"end_s":7260.365,"video_s":9119.624,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00315","chapter":"C024","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01671","start_s":7260.545,"end_s":7260.806,"video_s":9120.545,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00315","chapter":"C024","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01672","start_s":7261.266,"end_s":7261.726,"video_s":9121.266,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00315","chapter":"C024","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01673","start_s":7261.967,"end_s":7262.167,"video_s":9121.967,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00315","chapter":"C024","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01674","start_s":7262.667,"end_s":7263.488,"video_s":9122.667,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00315","chapter":"C024","text":"Passes eight one.","fingerprint":"7c1e3f9d0f50","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01675","start_s":7265.01,"end_s":7272.057,"video_s":9125.01,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00316","chapter":"C025","text":"We next go to item 129, the approval to enter into agreements with various schools and school districts for school resource officer services, Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"f6e06df35253","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01676","start_s":7273.378,"end_s":7274.94,"video_s":9133.378,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00316","chapter":"C025","text":"Motion to approve item 129.","fingerprint":"2418c0fa6465","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01677","start_s":7275.48,"end_s":7275.841,"video_s":9135.48,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00316","chapter":"C025","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01678","start_s":7276.281,"end_s":7280.766,"video_s":9136.281,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00316","chapter":"C025","text":"Noting that Councilman Waring will not participate in this item, roll call.","fingerprint":"0a041436a986","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01679","start_s":7280.786,"end_s":7281.246,"video_s":9140.786,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00317","chapter":"C025","text":"Guardado?","fingerprint":"0344b48c3f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01680","start_s":7281.386,"end_s":7282.307,"video_s":9141.386,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00317","chapter":"C025","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01681","start_s":7282.327,"end_s":7282.868,"video_s":9142.327,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00317","chapter":"C025","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01682","start_s":7283.028,"end_s":7283.268,"video_s":9143.028,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00317","chapter":"C025","text":"No.","fingerprint":"9390298f3fb0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01683","start_s":7284.469,"end_s":7284.95,"video_s":9144.469,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00317","chapter":"C025","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01684","start_s":7285.07,"end_s":7285.951,"video_s":9145.07,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00317","chapter":"C025","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01685","start_s":7285.971,"end_s":7286.451,"video_s":9145.971,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00317","chapter":"C025","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01686","start_s":7286.612,"end_s":7286.832,"video_s":9146.612,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00317","chapter":"C025","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01687","start_s":7287.512,"end_s":7288.093,"video_s":9147.512,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00317","chapter":"C025","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01688","start_s":7288.327,"end_s":7293.595,"video_s":9148.327,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00317","chapter":"C025","text":"Stark, Hodge Washington, Gallego.","fingerprint":"2e58953fb991","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01689","start_s":7294.155,"end_s":7294.716,"video_s":9154.155,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00317","chapter":"C025","text":"Passes 7-1.","fingerprint":"f48d99f43c7a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01690","start_s":7296.138,"end_s":7301.766,"video_s":9156.138,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00318","chapter":"C025","text":"Items 133 and 135 are both related to public transit and we will take them both together.","fingerprint":"bd7bcbfc1796","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01691","start_s":7302.167,"end_s":7304.57,"video_s":9162.167,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00318","chapter":"C025","text":"Vice Mayor, do you have a motion on 133 and 135?","fingerprint":"ae24fb8de8d4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01692","start_s":7309.157,"end_s":7312.101,"video_s":9169.157,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00319","chapter":"C025","text":"Motion to approve item 133 and item 135.","fingerprint":"764d6a21d20c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01693","start_s":7312.702,"end_s":7313.062,"video_s":9172.702,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00319","chapter":"C025","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01694","start_s":7313.643,"end_s":7314.644,"video_s":9173.643,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00320","chapter":"C025","text":"We have a motion and a second.","fingerprint":"7451ba811637","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01695","start_s":7314.665,"end_s":7315.345,"video_s":9174.665,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00320","chapter":"C025","text":"Any comments?","fingerprint":"9cdeefcc2f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01696","start_s":7316.087,"end_s":7316.427,"video_s":9176.087,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00320","chapter":"C025","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01697","start_s":7319.14,"end_s":7319.661,"video_s":9179.14,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00320","chapter":"C025","text":"Guardado?","fingerprint":"0344b48c3f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01698","start_s":7319.962,"end_s":7321.104,"video_s":9179.962,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00321","chapter":"C025","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01699","start_s":7321.124,"end_s":7321.605,"video_s":9181.124,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00321","chapter":"C025","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01700","start_s":7321.805,"end_s":7322.006,"video_s":9181.805,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00321","chapter":"C025","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01701","start_s":7322.847,"end_s":7323.268,"video_s":9182.847,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00321","chapter":"C025","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01702","start_s":7323.528,"end_s":7323.749,"video_s":9183.528,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00322","chapter":"C025","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01703","start_s":7324.611,"end_s":7325.051,"video_s":9184.611,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00323","chapter":"C025","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01704","start_s":7325.212,"end_s":7326.354,"video_s":9185.212,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00323","chapter":"C025","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01705","start_s":7326.374,"end_s":7326.875,"video_s":9186.374,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00323","chapter":"C025","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01706","start_s":7326.915,"end_s":7327.155,"video_s":9186.915,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00324","chapter":"C025","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01707","start_s":7328.077,"end_s":7328.438,"video_s":9188.077,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00325","chapter":"C025","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01708","start_s":7328.859,"end_s":7329.74,"video_s":9188.859,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00325","chapter":"C025","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01709","start_s":7329.76,"end_s":7330.101,"video_s":9189.76,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00325","chapter":"C025","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01710","start_s":7331.464,"end_s":7331.524,"video_s":9191.464,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00325","chapter":"C025","text":"No.","fingerprint":"9390298f3fb0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01711","start_s":7331.544,"end_s":7332.225,"video_s":9191.544,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00325","chapter":"C025","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01712","start_s":7332.426,"end_s":7333.427,"video_s":9192.426,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00326","chapter":"C025","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01713","start_s":7333.448,"end_s":7334.229,"video_s":9193.448,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00327","chapter":"C025","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01714","start_s":7334.249,"end_s":7334.449,"video_s":9194.249,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00327","chapter":"C025","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01715","start_s":7335.131,"end_s":7335.652,"video_s":9195.131,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00327","chapter":"C025","text":"Passes 8-1.","fingerprint":"a7b3afc7a8da","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01716","start_s":7336.854,"end_s":7341.503,"video_s":9196.854,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00328","chapter":"C026","text":"Item 152 is the appeal of the hearing officer decision","fingerprint":"b154c4f8cfeb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01717","start_s":7341.854,"end_s":7345.339,"video_s":9201.854,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00328","chapter":"C026","text":"for abandonment in District 6.","fingerprint":"334b7a9d1ff0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01718","start_s":7346.24,"end_s":7353.81,"video_s":9206.24,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00328","chapter":"C026","text":"We will begin with a staff report and then we'll hear first from the applicant and then the appellant.","fingerprint":"3338cb6d3f70","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01719","start_s":7353.93,"end_s":7357.575,"video_s":9213.93,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00328","chapter":"C026","text":"Each will have five minutes for planning items.","fingerprint":"fc1baf275125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01720","start_s":7357.635,"end_s":7361.62,"video_s":9217.635,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00328","chapter":"C026","text":"There is an opportunity to do a PowerPoint if you wish.","fingerprint":"cdfdd7b61183","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01721","start_s":7363.443,"end_s":7367.288,"video_s":9223.443,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00328","chapter":"C026","text":"Turn it over to our planning and development director, Josh Bednarek.","fingerprint":"7ee4a39877f6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01722","start_s":7367.673,"end_s":7369.195,"video_s":9227.673,"speaker":"v15","turn":"T00329","chapter":"C026","text":"Thank you, Mayor, members of the Council.","fingerprint":"6fac6f2f5b4e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01723","start_s":7369.256,"end_s":7373.963,"video_s":9229.256,"speaker":"v15","turn":"T00329","chapter":"C026","text":"We have a short staff presentation to provide the Council an overview of the request.","fingerprint":"868a3017b57f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01724","start_s":7374.564,"end_s":7376.808,"video_s":9234.564,"speaker":"v15","turn":"T00329","chapter":"C026","text":"To my left is Assistant Director Mike Baxley.","fingerprint":"2680e827b8e4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01725","start_s":7376.828,"end_s":7378.551,"video_s":9236.828,"speaker":"v15","turn":"T00329","chapter":"C026","text":"Mike will provide an overview of the request.","fingerprint":"7263ee23e602","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01726","start_s":7378.571,"end_s":7379.192,"video_s":9238.571,"speaker":"v15","turn":"T00329","chapter":"C026","text":"I'll turn to Mike.","fingerprint":"3f491a5d6630","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01727","start_s":7379.392,"end_s":7379.672,"video_s":9239.392,"speaker":"v15","turn":"T00329","chapter":"C026","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01728","start_s":7383.258,"end_s":7383.859,"video_s":9243.258,"speaker":"v25","turn":"T00330","chapter":"C026","text":"There we go.","fingerprint":"f8285af8ce44","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01729","start_s":7383.879,"end_s":7384.4,"video_s":9243.879,"speaker":"v25","turn":"T00330","chapter":"C026","text":"You got live.","fingerprint":"279df4c546e7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01730","start_s":7384.701,"end_s":7386.183,"video_s":9244.701,"speaker":"v25","turn":"T00330","chapter":"C026","text":"Thank you, Mayor, members of the Council.","fingerprint":"6fac6f2f5b4e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01731","start_s":7387.645,"end_s":7393.535,"video_s":9247.645,"speaker":"v25","turn":"T00330","chapter":"C026","text":"Just a quick overview for you for the appeal here and the application.","fingerprint":"898749916e94","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01732","start_s":7394.096,"end_s":7394.777,"video_s":9254.096,"speaker":"v25","turn":"T00330","chapter":"C026","text":"We have","fingerprint":"311eecafbfec","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01733","start_s":7407.447,"end_s":7410.352,"video_s":9267.447,"speaker":"v25","turn":"T00330","chapter":"C026","text":"There we go, no?","fingerprint":"c1fccbb01615","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01734","start_s":7410.372,"end_s":7422.012,"video_s":9270.372,"speaker":"v25","turn":"T00330","chapter":"C026","text":"Here we go.","fingerprint":"8f03973c6b88","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01735","start_s":7422.032,"end_s":7426.84,"video_s":9282.032,"speaker":"v25","turn":"T00330","chapter":"C026","text":"Okay, we're working now, perfect, thank you.","fingerprint":"bd13c547fed7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01736","start_s":7429.199,"end_s":7435.809,"video_s":9289.199,"speaker":"v25","turn":"T00330","chapter":"C026","text":"So right here, this slide shows the red area of the area that's been applied for for an abandonment.","fingerprint":"b414a947bf42","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01737","start_s":7436.931,"end_s":7443.08,"video_s":9296.931,"speaker":"v25","turn":"T00330","chapter":"C026","text":"And so the application came to us from Jordan Greenman of Greenman Law Firm.","fingerprint":"066e2294c69e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01738","start_s":7443.901,"end_s":7452.835,"video_s":9303.901,"speaker":"v25","turn":"T00330","chapter":"C026","text":"It was for an alley abandonment, and it was located between 5440 East Cali Camellia and 4001 North 54th Place.","fingerprint":"64efc9f7a20f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01739","start_s":7454.077,"end_s":7458.143,"video_s":9314.077,"speaker":"v25","turn":"T00330","chapter":"C026","text":"It was measuring approximately 28 feet by 133 feet in length.","fingerprint":"22f88c2d11f1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01740","start_s":7458.68,"end_s":7465.394,"video_s":9318.68,"speaker":"v25","turn":"T00330","chapter":"C026","text":"and when it was applied for, the applicant asserted that the alley segment was no longer necessary for public use.","fingerprint":"b09ef448d78a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01741","start_s":7467.619,"end_s":7473.732,"video_s":9327.619,"speaker":"v25","turn":"T00330","chapter":"C026","text":"This is a current picture or a recent picture of the alley in question here, just to give you some reference.","fingerprint":"015841b57953","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01742","start_s":7475.516,"end_s":7476.418,"video_s":9335.516,"speaker":"v25","turn":"T00330","chapter":"C026","text":"And then","fingerprint":"819745c14ca2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01743","start_s":7476.685,"end_s":7484.878,"video_s":9336.685,"speaker":"v25","turn":"T00330","chapter":"C026","text":"After the application had been ruled on by the hearing officer, it was appealed by Kate Melendrez.","fingerprint":"14286fa57d3f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01744","start_s":7484.898,"end_s":7489.426,"video_s":9344.898,"speaker":"v25","turn":"T00330","chapter":"C026","text":"She is a resident and neighbor of the applicant.","fingerprint":"5de03f58e87c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01745","start_s":7490.568,"end_s":7493.192,"video_s":9350.568,"speaker":"v25","turn":"T00330","chapter":"C026","text":"She appealed on three different reasons.","fingerprint":"4aa5323ceae5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01746","start_s":7493.358,"end_s":7501.687,"video_s":9353.358,"speaker":"v25","turn":"T00330","chapter":"C026","text":"The first one was stipulation one, which provided the applicant a choice to relocate utilities and retain the public utility easement.","fingerprint":"170f36eeef2f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01747","start_s":7502.608,"end_s":7513.5,"video_s":9362.608,"speaker":"v25","turn":"T00330","chapter":"C026","text":"Stipulation four, which required the applicant to retain a 16-foot easement for public utility easement, refuse collection, pedestrian access, and emergency services.","fingerprint":"7682d317e14d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01748","start_s":7514.381,"end_s":7520.007,"video_s":9374.381,"speaker":"v25","turn":"T00330","chapter":"C026","text":"And then stipulation five, which required the applicant to retain a 28-foot wide sewer easement.","fingerprint":"b7fa70ad1415","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01749","start_s":7521.708,"end_s":7527.636,"video_s":9381.708,"speaker":"v25","turn":"T00330","chapter":"C026","text":"This kind of gives you an overview of the alley in question and how it would sort out with all the easements there.","fingerprint":"40ac81618d85","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01750","start_s":7528.617,"end_s":7536.648,"video_s":9388.617,"speaker":"v25","turn":"T00330","chapter":"C026","text":"From the gray line kind of off center, you'll see that would be where the property line would be divided to, to the property of the south and the property of the north.","fingerprint":"c11eda4c5671","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01751","start_s":7536.668,"end_s":7543.817,"video_s":9396.668,"speaker":"v25","turn":"T00330","chapter":"C026","text":"The red dotted line would be the finished easement that would allow for the access through the alley.","fingerprint":"9736f35234ee","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01752","start_s":7548.168,"end_s":7577.112,"video_s":9408.168,"speaker":"v25","turn":"T00330","chapter":"C026","text":"one of the things that came up in processing this application for appeal is that the city code requires that all appeals must be filed within 15 calendar days of the decision date in this case we wound up accepting that appeal on the 16th day and that was because there was a holiday in between and staff inappropriately assumed that that extended out a day they gave the","fingerprint":"bcfba5d5c541","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01753","start_s":7577.682,"end_s":7590.924,"video_s":9437.682,"speaker":"v25","turn":"T00330","chapter":"C026","text":"The appellant, the date that it was due on, and the appellant did apply on that date, and so it was done in good faith, and everything else was done consistent with what normal circumstances would be.","fingerprint":"400b13574936","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01754","start_s":7591.726,"end_s":7603.285,"video_s":9451.726,"speaker":"v25","turn":"T00330","chapter":"C026","text":"Really what that rule does mean is that the calendar days are extended when the holiday lands on the last day of it, but it did not land on the last day, it landed in the middle.","fingerprint":"94ddce743083","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01755","start_s":7605.982,"end_s":7620.083,"video_s":9465.982,"speaker":"v25","turn":"T00330","chapter":"C026","text":"And options for counsel today would include upholding the hearing officer's conditional approval of the abandonment or a motion to overturn the abandonment hearing officer's decision and deny the request.","fingerprint":"6670ab37ce46","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01756","start_s":7621.185,"end_s":7626.994,"video_s":9481.185,"speaker":"v25","turn":"T00330","chapter":"C026","text":"And with that, I'd be more than happy to answer any questions before we have the applicant and the appellant.","fingerprint":"e52d610f791d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01757","start_s":7627.362,"end_s":7628.625,"video_s":9487.362,"speaker":"v25","turn":"T00330","chapter":"C026","text":"come up and speak.","fingerprint":"31078a98d983","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01758","start_s":7628.645,"end_s":7630.971,"video_s":9488.645,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00331","chapter":"C026","text":"All right, I think we are ready for the applicant and the appellant.","fingerprint":"82aa2561bf4e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01759","start_s":7631.352,"end_s":7632.835,"video_s":9491.352,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00331","chapter":"C026","text":"So each side will have five minutes.","fingerprint":"91bee617b7a5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01760","start_s":7632.875,"end_s":7641.736,"video_s":9492.875,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00331","chapter":"C026","text":"You may have any member of speakers that you wish, but if anyone speaks during the five minute period, we will not call them for two minute public comment later.","fingerprint":"6efe56995f86","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01761","start_s":7642.097,"end_s":7645.405,"video_s":9502.097,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00331","chapter":"C026","text":"And we will begin with Jordan on behalf of the applicant.","fingerprint":"99145a63fe05","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01762","start_s":7653.62,"end_s":7658.005,"video_s":9513.62,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"Good afternoon, honorable mayor, vice mayor, members of city council.","fingerprint":"fd8e72bf606f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01763","start_s":7658.786,"end_s":7660.888,"video_s":9518.786,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"Can you see my, there we go, thank you.","fingerprint":"13e20bf18414","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01764","start_s":7666.535,"end_s":7672.281,"video_s":9526.535,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"Jordan Greenman, Greenman Law Firm, 1621 West Waletta Street, Phoenix, Arizona, 85007.","fingerprint":"6a42cd5fd1d7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01765","start_s":7673.222,"end_s":7678.328,"video_s":9533.222,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"Here on behalf of the appellee, not the appellant, we","fingerprint":"8a0680050a96","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01766","start_s":7678.73,"end_s":7682.115,"video_s":9538.73,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"I represent Garrett Kneifer as well as Sven Johnson who are sitting here.","fingerprint":"2bc56102e4aa","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01767","start_s":7682.656,"end_s":7688.265,"video_s":9542.656,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"We originally applied for this back in February.","fingerprint":"f8cb61887d65","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01768","start_s":7688.765,"end_s":7693.994,"video_s":9548.765,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"We received conditional approval and the appellants, the neighbors, appealed this.","fingerprint":"1621039c5d6a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01769","start_s":7696.197,"end_s":7697.599,"video_s":9556.197,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"Our request is fairly simple.","fingerprint":"d5a9f389973e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01770","start_s":7697.639,"end_s":7705.311,"video_s":9557.639,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"We're asking you to look at this conditional approval and to uphold this request on the merits.","fingerprint":"667ab51638b8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01771","start_s":7706.388,"end_s":7709.571,"video_s":9566.388,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"Our request is done under abandonment 250049.","fingerprint":"ae092992d1db","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01772","start_s":7711.453,"end_s":7713.495,"video_s":9571.453,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"What we're requesting here is fairly straightforward.","fingerprint":"9990882f8f9e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01773","start_s":7714.176,"end_s":7720.022,"video_s":9574.176,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"The neighbors had a series of concerns such as accessibility, public utilities, access, and easement questions.","fingerprint":"6d3453a9efc0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01774","start_s":7720.483,"end_s":7724.086,"video_s":9580.483,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"We believe the city has adhered to all of those through their series of stipulations.","fingerprint":"d5e5ce908a5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01775","start_s":7724.146,"end_s":7735.298,"video_s":9584.146,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"There are four stipulations that address access, utilities, things like trash pickup, and people's ability to use the alley as it were.","fingerprint":"c5f2dc09f8b3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01776","start_s":7735.278,"end_s":7738.682,"video_s":9595.278,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"There is no error in the request.","fingerprint":"2d359089158b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01777","start_s":7738.862,"end_s":7744.348,"video_s":9598.862,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"There is no error in the abandonment hearing officer's stipulations of approval.","fingerprint":"8a3eb37f6583","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01778","start_s":7744.688,"end_s":7746.59,"video_s":9604.688,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"To give you a quick overhead, here's what it looks like.","fingerprint":"4357200d5348","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01779","start_s":7747.071,"end_s":7749.834,"video_s":9607.071,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"So the alley itself is shown highlighted in red.","fingerprint":"4ece83a7fa56","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01780","start_s":7750.134,"end_s":7752.857,"video_s":9610.134,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"My client's properties are shown with the star.","fingerprint":"88b0be8ac61c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01781","start_s":7753.298,"end_s":7758.183,"video_s":9613.298,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"As you can see, this connects roughly to 56th, 54th, and Lafayette to the north here.","fingerprint":"21c0b69d8f4b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01782","start_s":7758.964,"end_s":7764.39,"video_s":9618.964,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"What was approved generally was the 28-foot oversized alley.","fingerprint":"a23e28c4d421","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01783","start_s":7764.59,"end_s":7765.792,"video_s":9624.59,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"It is oversized.","fingerprint":"4cc80d419b80","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01784","start_s":7765.812,"end_s":7767.375,"video_s":9625.812,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"A typical alley is 16 feet.","fingerprint":"1d4290680015","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01785","start_s":7767.716,"end_s":7774.549,"video_s":9627.716,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"This was taken under advisement and was reviewed by the city for an additional month after the hearing itself.","fingerprint":"74b0954b0361","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01786","start_s":7774.99,"end_s":7780.0,"video_s":9634.99,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"The staff recommended approval with conditions and stipulations, and in doing so,","fingerprint":"fea23dd3b209","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01787","start_s":7779.98,"end_s":7782.164,"video_s":9639.98,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"You can see the current alley segment right here.","fingerprint":"91ce4b04a4f1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01788","start_s":7782.745,"end_s":7788.795,"video_s":9642.745,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"In doing so, they applied the applicable standard, which is under 3164, and they determined it was met.","fingerprint":"7a6ea2d9409a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01789","start_s":7789.136,"end_s":7793.924,"video_s":9649.136,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"There's a fairly narrow question whether the right of way is necessary as a public roadway.","fingerprint":"5aaab8981850","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01790","start_s":7794.405,"end_s":7795.967,"video_s":9654.405,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"Staff reviewed this under that standard.","fingerprint":"73ee129a1311","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01791","start_s":7796.268,"end_s":7800.435,"video_s":9656.268,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"The departments and utilities commented, and the staff recommended approval","fingerprint":"c113863e11ec","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01792","start_s":7800.415,"end_s":7802.078,"video_s":9660.415,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"with a series of stipulations.","fingerprint":"393f9f06deae","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01793","start_s":7802.519,"end_s":7806.587,"video_s":9662.519,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"The appeal itself does not address any legal error itself.","fingerprint":"9d7122185e09","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01794","start_s":7807.389,"end_s":7815.144,"video_s":9667.389,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"It in a way confuses what easements are, their ability to protect rights of way and protect people's access.","fingerprint":"eeeaff147b94","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01795","start_s":7815.685,"end_s":7818.39,"video_s":9675.685,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"Now this abandonment makes sense for several reasons.","fingerprint":"c84c627e4dd8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01796","start_s":7818.37,"end_s":7822.558,"video_s":9678.37,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"The alley itself is 28 feet wide, which is nearly double the standard alley.","fingerprint":"10801dc72e87","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01797","start_s":7822.858,"end_s":7830.292,"video_s":9682.858,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"There are two adjacent subdivisions which were dedicated in the 1950s that created a substantially larger right of way than necessary.","fingerprint":"1fd1abe8f5ea","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01798","start_s":7830.693,"end_s":7833.618,"video_s":9690.693,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"So the public uses here can be retained through the easements.","fingerprint":"3c76f4e401a1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01799","start_s":7833.999,"end_s":7836.463,"video_s":9693.999,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"We believe this is a win-win.","fingerprint":"e4cefc0ab25d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01800","start_s":7836.443,"end_s":7856.342,"video_s":9696.443,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"My client as well as his neighbor to the north are both hoping to put ADUs in their backyard and what this effectively does is it gives them an additional 18 and 10 feet respectively to one of them I know will be housing an older family member and the other one will be putting an ADU in there hopefully potentially in the future to help","fingerprint":"1e6676879f39","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01801","start_s":7856.542,"end_s":7868.627,"video_s":9716.542,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"increase the amount of housing in this area this is a very expensive and difficult area to get into so our goal is to increase the housing standard by increasing the setbacks increasing the lot sizes things like that","fingerprint":"b6412fd36601","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01802","start_s":7869.4,"end_s":7872.485,"video_s":9729.4,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"So there are a series of relevant stipulations here that the city requested.","fingerprint":"7cdfaac4baba","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01803","start_s":7872.785,"end_s":7882.58,"video_s":9732.785,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"There are four or five of them, a public utility easement, a refuse collection easement, emergency vehicle easement, a sewer easement, and a pedestrian access easement.","fingerprint":"bd34bea22e69","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01804","start_s":7882.94,"end_s":7890.311,"video_s":9742.94,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"Now what these effectively do is they create a privatized space that has public use tied to it.","fingerprint":"c95065139dea","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01805","start_s":7890.652,"end_s":7892.715,"video_s":9750.652,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"So people will still be able to go through this.","fingerprint":"61662b31ea74","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01806","start_s":7893.035,"end_s":7894.317,"video_s":9753.035,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"This will not be gated off.","fingerprint":"93e59b865e8e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01807","start_s":7894.438,"end_s":7896.1,"video_s":9754.438,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"It will not be walled off.","fingerprint":"6e9851a7d287","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01808","start_s":7896.08,"end_s":7897.662,"video_s":9756.08,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"Refuse will not change.","fingerprint":"0b145750397c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01809","start_s":7897.862,"end_s":7899.304,"video_s":9757.862,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"The bins can still be in the alley.","fingerprint":"d63c4b8e25f4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01810","start_s":7899.624,"end_s":7901.787,"video_s":9759.624,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"There will be no obstructions to this area.","fingerprint":"fc829cc1542d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01811","start_s":7902.168,"end_s":7910.578,"video_s":9762.168,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"We're fairly surprised to see the appeal as we believe the stipulations were addressed and the neighborhood concerns were also addressed.","fingerprint":"4da60cd24696","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01812","start_s":7910.979,"end_s":7914.483,"video_s":9770.979,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"So in all fairness, this will look like an active alley.","fingerprint":"9a92d706dac4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01813","start_s":7914.823,"end_s":7916.385,"video_s":9774.823,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"It will bark like an active alley.","fingerprint":"c4413f06ca44","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01814","start_s":7916.686,"end_s":7918.348,"video_s":9776.686,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"People will still be able to go back there.","fingerprint":"798fccbbf38c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01815","start_s":7918.488,"end_s":7921.632,"video_s":9778.488,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"Trash trucks, utilities will still be able to access that area.","fingerprint":"5ffd59de951c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01816","start_s":7922.05,"end_s":7927.978,"video_s":9782.05,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"The appeal itself, looking at it, raises several concerns such as enforceability, utility access, and permanence.","fingerprint":"a81012da428e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01817","start_s":7928.378,"end_s":7931.602,"video_s":9788.378,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"The appeal does not identify any sort of defect in the decision.","fingerprint":"13c7ce1adef1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01818","start_s":7932.023,"end_s":7936.729,"video_s":9792.023,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"It simply asks you to re-litigate the concerns that were resolved through the stipulations themselves.","fingerprint":"87d781359be9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01819","start_s":7937.49,"end_s":7942.877,"video_s":9797.49,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"As we can see, all of the utility easements will address the concerns from the neighbors","fingerprint":"be49b1164370","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01820","start_s":7942.857,"end_s":7951.07,"video_s":9802.857,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"We believe this should sit as exactly approved or conditionally approved by the hearing officer itself.","fingerprint":"9741522b9207","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01821","start_s":7951.631,"end_s":7960.164,"video_s":9811.631,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"Our request here is to uphold this decision and in doing so uphold the hearing officer's conditional approval.","fingerprint":"a500f2197b0e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01822","start_s":7960.905,"end_s":7961.226,"video_s":9820.905,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00332","chapter":"C026","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01823","start_s":7963.249,"end_s":7964.05,"video_s":9823.249,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00333","chapter":"C026","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01824","start_s":7964.07,"end_s":7967.295,"video_s":9824.07,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00333","chapter":"C026","text":"Next we will hear from Kate Melendres, the appellant.","fingerprint":"49d5abcc35e2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01825","start_s":7988.96,"end_s":7991.583,"video_s":9848.96,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"Just trying to figure out how to get it up on the screen here.","fingerprint":"93f7928e15b0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01826","start_s":7991.803,"end_s":7992.464,"video_s":9851.803,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"Good morning.","fingerprint":"cdf71dea7d77","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01827","start_s":7992.524,"end_s":7993.686,"video_s":9852.524,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"Excuse me.","fingerprint":"e3b4b8e99bda","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01828","start_s":7993.706,"end_s":7996.229,"video_s":9853.706,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"Good afternoon, Mayor Gallego and council members.","fingerprint":"73e3ecc2ca8f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01829","start_s":7997.15,"end_s":8001.415,"video_s":9857.15,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"My name is Kate Melendrez and I am a District 6 resident.","fingerprint":"a1ba9533b2ce","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01830","start_s":8002.296,"end_s":8004.398,"video_s":9862.296,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"Thank you for the opportunity to speak today.","fingerprint":"ec7b5d9d9473","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01831","start_s":8004.458,"end_s":8018.595,"video_s":9864.458,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"While I am speaking as the appellant, I also want council to know that many neighboring residents share the same concerns and also signed a petition requesting that this alley remain public.","fingerprint":"463873721827","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01832","start_s":8022.524,"end_s":8029.292,"video_s":9882.524,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"As you can see on the slide, ongoing public use is a primary concern.","fingerprint":"3a2fee60aa7e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01833","start_s":8030.133,"end_s":8034.918,"video_s":9890.133,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"The alley segment at issue continues to serve multiple public functions.","fingerprint":"44c01186b213","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01834","start_s":8035.859,"end_s":8050.135,"video_s":9895.859,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"And as shown on this map that Mr. Greenman also put up, the alley segment sits at the edge of the alleyway and serves as the only direct public connection from the alley to those neighboring streets behind.","fingerprint":"ec1802f345be","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01835","start_s":8050.874,"end_s":8057.941,"video_s":9910.874,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"Residents regularly use this portion of the alley as a connection point to safely access the adjoining neighborhood.","fingerprint":"7d1da0c34d46","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01836","start_s":8057.961,"end_s":8067.59,"video_s":9917.961,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"The alley segment is also the entry point that supports certain public services, including solid waste collection and utility access.","fingerprint":"0a1de1c61235","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01837","start_s":8068.09,"end_s":8069.752,"video_s":9928.09,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"And you'll see a picture of this later.","fingerprint":"a07d04ced37e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01838","start_s":8071.393,"end_s":8073.856,"video_s":9931.393,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"This is not an abandoned or unused strip of land.","fingerprint":"4a8c398aff6d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01839","start_s":8074.396,"end_s":8080.442,"video_s":9934.396,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"It remains an active public right of way serving both residents and city functions.","fingerprint":"5ff49331f579","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01840","start_s":8083.882,"end_s":8084.523,"video_s":9943.882,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"Safety.","fingerprint":"856e8bd358ec","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01841","start_s":8084.543,"end_s":8088.989,"video_s":9944.543,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"This point is particularly important to the residents in this area.","fingerprint":"7ec8cdd9a2a1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01842","start_s":8089.049,"end_s":8100.003,"video_s":9949.049,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"The alley provides the only practical neighborhood connection that allows many residents, children, and pet owners to avoid walking along portions of 56th Street.","fingerprint":"142dcabdcdbe","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01843","start_s":8101.064,"end_s":8111.678,"video_s":9961.064,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"Of note, portions of 56th Street lack sidewalks and carry significant traffic, which is a safety risk for families with young children and those walking past.","fingerprint":"053220a14f4a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01844","start_s":8113.075,"end_s":8119.244,"video_s":9973.075,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"The issue is not whether another route technically exists, which you can see on the yellow there.","fingerprint":"6740b0cfd4ce","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01845","start_s":8119.644,"end_s":8121.187,"video_s":9979.644,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"Mr. Greenman also showed this.","fingerprint":"c4e340c939f5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01846","start_s":8122.208,"end_s":8126.053,"video_s":9982.208,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"The issue is whether a safe and practical public connection exists today.","fingerprint":"2b6470d28ec8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01847","start_s":8126.114,"end_s":8129.619,"video_s":9986.114,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"And that alley segment at issue provides that connection.","fingerprint":"16ced6bc0b2d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01848","start_s":8129.659,"end_s":8135.887,"video_s":9989.659,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"And let's talk briefly about the stipulations and enforceability concerns.","fingerprint":"577c5c2108b9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01849","start_s":8136.568,"end_s":8140.534,"video_s":9996.568,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"To be clear, I'm not suggesting that the stipulations are unnecessary.","fingerprint":"044bb8c8e8c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01850","start_s":8140.919,"end_s":8143.724,"video_s":10000.919,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"In fact, I believe they are important protections.","fingerprint":"0f406cb88cda","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01851","start_s":8145.286,"end_s":8148.171,"video_s":10005.286,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"Their existence demonstrates the ongoing public need.","fingerprint":"f8526b1615f1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01852","start_s":8148.211,"end_s":8156.464,"video_s":10008.211,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"Numerous conditions were required to preserve access for waste collection, utilities, and other public functions.","fingerprint":"39e184f8cdac","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01853","start_s":8156.883,"end_s":8161.855,"video_s":10016.883,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"If the alley truly had no continuing public value, these protections would not have been necessary.","fingerprint":"ab96d37e1f1e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01854","start_s":8161.915,"end_s":8173.643,"video_s":10021.915,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"Our concern is that once the right of way is abandoned, enforcement of those stipulations become far more difficult and burdensome for neighboring residents and future city staff.","fingerprint":"79c7db39c554","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01855","start_s":8175.918,"end_s":8179.002,"video_s":10035.918,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"And this is that picture of the trash truck coming through the alley.","fingerprint":"434976915e05","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01856","start_s":8179.062,"end_s":8186.532,"video_s":10039.062,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"This is last week and you can see the overgrown vegetation there makes it difficult for the truck to get through.","fingerprint":"1a50d403f7c8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01857","start_s":8186.572,"end_s":8194.643,"video_s":10046.572,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"And again, our question was where is the PUE and pedestrian easement going to be given those conditions?","fingerprint":"ed94c0c0973e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01858","start_s":8199.069,"end_s":8204.997,"video_s":10059.069,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"There's a few more current pictures that demonstrate the overgrown vegetation as well.","fingerprint":"d785ea714a25","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01859","start_s":8208.267,"end_s":8210.449,"video_s":10068.267,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"Public impacts versus private benefits.","fingerprint":"fac462ae0969","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01860","start_s":8210.969,"end_s":8213.692,"video_s":10070.969,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"The applicants receive clear and substantial benefits.","fingerprint":"42abea0446df","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01861","start_s":8214.332,"end_s":8221.158,"video_s":10074.332,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"By contrast, the public loses a right of way that has existed for decades and that continues to be actively used.","fingerprint":"ec4f62e032fe","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01862","start_s":8223.32,"end_s":8230.327,"video_s":10083.32,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"But possibly most importantly is the overwhelming community support that opposes this alley abandonment.","fingerprint":"7c1cc3beec09","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01863","start_s":8230.947,"end_s":8236.452,"video_s":10090.947,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"Many neighboring residents took the time to sign a petition asking that this alley remain public.","fingerprint":"18c2e553e516","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01864","start_s":8236.685,"end_s":8246.768,"video_s":10096.685,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"This demonstrates that the concerns raised in the appeal extend beyond a couple of homeowners and reflect broader neighborhood concerns about the loss of a public right of way.","fingerprint":"149685e51f0b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01865","start_s":8247.811,"end_s":8254.947,"video_s":10107.811,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"As you can see on this map, the circles in red depict homes in opposition of the abandonment,","fingerprint":"028c55b36482","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01866","start_s":8255.821,"end_s":8266.58,"video_s":10115.821,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"The circle in green is the applicant and the blue are unknown opinion or we were unable to contact those and those without a circle were not contacted either.","fingerprint":"e20bb1f097fa","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01867","start_s":8266.62,"end_s":8277.941,"video_s":10126.62,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"Our request to city council for the reasons we stated is we respectfully request that you reverse the approval and deny the abandonment request.","fingerprint":"59fc36490895","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01868","start_s":8278.602,"end_s":8280.445,"video_s":10138.602,"speaker":"v27","turn":"T00334","chapter":"C026","text":"Thank you for your time and consideration.","fingerprint":"8ce4ab4f0271","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01869","start_s":8281.336,"end_s":8283.459,"video_s":10141.336,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00335","chapter":"C026","text":"Thank you, thank you for those presentations.","fingerprint":"7f474b9b7aff","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01870","start_s":8283.479,"end_s":8286.002,"video_s":10143.479,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00335","chapter":"C026","text":"We will now go to public comment.","fingerprint":"73a612f547c4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01871","start_s":8286.863,"end_s":8291.81,"video_s":10146.863,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00335","chapter":"C026","text":"And just to clarify, we have two David Keens who will be participating.","fingerprint":"f614c47a8da2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01872","start_s":8291.87,"end_s":8297.357,"video_s":10151.87,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00335","chapter":"C026","text":"I will first call in-person David Keen and then we will go to virtual David Keen.","fingerprint":"9f8371ab7523","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01873","start_s":8298.199,"end_s":8306.77,"video_s":10158.199,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00335","chapter":"C026","text":"So in-person David Keen, the floor is yours, followed by Annette, and then we will go virtual.","fingerprint":"0f29a2bf0d3f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01874","start_s":8307.577,"end_s":8308.198,"video_s":10167.577,"speaker":"v28","turn":"T00336","chapter":"C026","text":"And thank you.","fingerprint":"51a72e206a25","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01875","start_s":8308.218,"end_s":8309.6,"video_s":10168.218,"speaker":"v28","turn":"T00336","chapter":"C026","text":"Am I standing at the right podium?","fingerprint":"c08a56ca5239","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01876","start_s":8309.92,"end_s":8310.461,"video_s":10169.92,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00337","chapter":"C026","text":"Yes, perfect.","fingerprint":"8b6f5b9597e8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01877","start_s":8310.481,"end_s":8315.247,"video_s":10170.481,"speaker":"v28","turn":"T00338","chapter":"C026","text":"So I'm David Keene, K-E-E-N, and we do not get our mail mixed up for some reason.","fingerprint":"26a99cd88b2e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01878","start_s":8316.288,"end_s":8317.049,"video_s":10176.288,"speaker":"v28","turn":"T00338","chapter":"C026","text":"Incredible.","fingerprint":"6bf67200c289","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01879","start_s":8317.069,"end_s":8317.249,"video_s":10177.069,"speaker":"v28","turn":"T00338","chapter":"C026","text":"Yeah.","fingerprint":"a495a4b86c1e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01880","start_s":8317.47,"end_s":8321.014,"video_s":10177.47,"speaker":"v28","turn":"T00338","chapter":"C026","text":"Mayor and members of council, thank you for my time.","fingerprint":"a185e2ce0ff9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01881","start_s":8321.215,"end_s":8322.236,"video_s":10181.215,"speaker":"v28","turn":"T00338","chapter":"C026","text":"I'm an immediate neighbor.","fingerprint":"339a585b41fc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01882","start_s":8322.276,"end_s":8328.164,"video_s":10182.276,"speaker":"v28","turn":"T00338","chapter":"C026","text":"The council for the applicants brings up a good point.","fingerprint":"c7a7aafafeea","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01883","start_s":8328.184,"end_s":8333.23,"video_s":10188.184,"speaker":"v28","turn":"T00338","chapter":"C026","text":"There are a number of stipulations that should provide for easements on this alley.","fingerprint":"6a596c41d062","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01884","start_s":8333.8,"end_s":8336.763,"video_s":10193.8,"speaker":"v28","turn":"T00338","chapter":"C026","text":"that in theory would protect public use.","fingerprint":"b07d76851cd4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01885","start_s":8337.785,"end_s":8348.297,"video_s":10197.785,"speaker":"v28","turn":"T00338","chapter":"C026","text":"And I want to tell you from my own personal experience, and I feel very uncomfortable talking to you today because I was told by one of the applicants to not speak to the city ever.","fingerprint":"df69b7d3694a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01886","start_s":8350.199,"end_s":8352.842,"video_s":10210.199,"speaker":"v28","turn":"T00338","chapter":"C026","text":"But he wasn't very specific about city council.","fingerprint":"fdcb93309c3e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01887","start_s":8352.882,"end_s":8354.324,"video_s":10212.882,"speaker":"v28","turn":"T00338","chapter":"C026","text":"So I don't think you count.","fingerprint":"df308e46c564","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01888","start_s":8354.424,"end_s":8356.787,"video_s":10214.424,"speaker":"v28","turn":"T00338","chapter":"C026","text":"And he could have just been having a bad day.","fingerprint":"3f8d7b40d72f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01889","start_s":8356.97,"end_s":8365.399,"video_s":10216.97,"speaker":"v28","turn":"T00338","chapter":"C026","text":"But we have on multiple occasions had an issue with trash being dumped in the alley by the contractor of one of the applicants.","fingerprint":"c0c2d275bad2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01890","start_s":8365.519,"end_s":8368.222,"video_s":10225.519,"speaker":"v28","turn":"T00338","chapter":"C026","text":"This has gone on for a while now.","fingerprint":"2366edf5eeef","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01891","start_s":8368.703,"end_s":8371.325,"video_s":10228.703,"speaker":"v28","turn":"T00338","chapter":"C026","text":"And we did, my wife and I did everything by book.","fingerprint":"dda778d80b4f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01892","start_s":8371.946,"end_s":8380.395,"video_s":10231.946,"speaker":"v28","turn":"T00338","chapter":"C026","text":"You nicely knock on the door, tell them to, hey, you may not know this, but they dumped the trash and it's causing a big issue in the alley.","fingerprint":"2a8a56365484","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01893","start_s":8380.595,"end_s":8382.6,"video_s":10240.595,"speaker":"v28","turn":"T00338","chapter":"C026","text":"We were unable to reach him.","fingerprint":"89177ca491f3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01894","start_s":8382.76,"end_s":8393.846,"video_s":10242.76,"speaker":"v28","turn":"T00338","chapter":"C026","text":"We sent him a letter, waited to see if that would clear it up, finally sent communication to the city along with the letter, and it was resolved.","fingerprint":"f9fc519758c0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01895","start_s":8393.866,"end_s":8394.527,"video_s":10253.866,"speaker":"v28","turn":"T00338","chapter":"C026","text":"That was last year.","fingerprint":"048721d753b4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01896","start_s":8394.608,"end_s":8395.991,"video_s":10254.608,"speaker":"v28","turn":"T00338","chapter":"C026","text":"This year we did the same thing.","fingerprint":"2216a849c6f2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01897","start_s":8396.011,"end_s":8398.637,"video_s":10256.011,"speaker":"v28","turn":"T00338","chapter":"C026","text":"I approached to the door, knocked on the door,","fingerprint":"ca79d7c62f73","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01898","start_s":8398.617,"end_s":8401.62,"video_s":10258.617,"speaker":"v28","turn":"T00338","chapter":"C026","text":"I was very agitated and said, you are the person who sent that letter.","fingerprint":"1e02525ce59f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01899","start_s":8401.64,"end_s":8403.922,"video_s":10261.64,"speaker":"v28","turn":"T00338","chapter":"C026","text":"You may never talk to the city on my behalf again.","fingerprint":"8ade056a635f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01900","start_s":8404.822,"end_s":8407.745,"video_s":10264.822,"speaker":"v28","turn":"T00338","chapter":"C026","text":"And I backed away from his door.","fingerprint":"0a1a9fe01bcb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01901","start_s":8407.765,"end_s":8410.467,"video_s":10267.765,"speaker":"v28","turn":"T00338","chapter":"C026","text":"I do not feel comfortable on his property.","fingerprint":"5bc545682b17","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01902","start_s":8410.928,"end_s":8413.55,"video_s":10270.928,"speaker":"v28","turn":"T00338","chapter":"C026","text":"So this alley will be his property in the future.","fingerprint":"482dacb4da40","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01903","start_s":8413.57,"end_s":8415.652,"video_s":10273.57,"speaker":"v28","turn":"T00338","chapter":"C026","text":"I do not feel comfortable being on it.","fingerprint":"7dda03734f28","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01904","start_s":8416.212,"end_s":8419.295,"video_s":10276.212,"speaker":"v28","turn":"T00338","chapter":"C026","text":"Again, it could have been a bad day, but better safe than sorry.","fingerprint":"d726a3082dc3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01905","start_s":8420.016,"end_s":8423.599,"video_s":10280.016,"speaker":"v28","turn":"T00338","chapter":"C026","text":"This enforcement of the easement does not need to be my problem.","fingerprint":"95619935761b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01906","start_s":8423.639,"end_s":8425.981,"video_s":10283.639,"speaker":"v28","turn":"T00338","chapter":"C026","text":"The city has told us that they will not enforce it.","fingerprint":"d82f4e2b4297","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01907","start_s":8426.061,"end_s":8427.302,"video_s":10286.061,"speaker":"v28","turn":"T00338","chapter":"C026","text":"It is our job to police it.","fingerprint":"8967632a1495","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01908","start_s":8427.542,"end_s":8428.523,"video_s":10287.542,"speaker":"v28","turn":"T00338","chapter":"C026","text":"Thank you for your time.","fingerprint":"28036d909db6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01909","start_s":8430.815,"end_s":8431.316,"video_s":10290.815,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00339","chapter":"C026","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01910","start_s":8431.517,"end_s":8439.276,"video_s":10291.517,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00339","chapter":"C026","text":"Annette is next, and then we'll go virtual public comment to David Keene.","fingerprint":"43af9ce50e9a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01911","start_s":8439.296,"end_s":8439.898,"video_s":10299.296,"speaker":"v29","turn":"T00340","chapter":"C026","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01912","start_s":8439.918,"end_s":8440.86,"video_s":10299.918,"speaker":"v29","turn":"T00340","chapter":"C026","text":"I'm Annette Humkeen.","fingerprint":"6a82a928bb2f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01913","start_s":8441.0,"end_s":8444.048,"video_s":10301.0,"speaker":"v29","turn":"T00340","chapter":"C026","text":"I'm also a resident of the area.","fingerprint":"3fefb656b48c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01914","start_s":8444.787,"end_s":8450.116,"video_s":10304.787,"speaker":"v29","turn":"T00340","chapter":"C026","text":"I'm here today to again thank you council and thank you to be here.","fingerprint":"7064ebdef332","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01915","start_s":8450.596,"end_s":8452.86,"video_s":10310.596,"speaker":"v29","turn":"T00340","chapter":"C026","text":"But I'm here today to oppose the alley abandonment.","fingerprint":"2ad423fc4cbd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01916","start_s":8453.721,"end_s":8462.115,"video_s":10313.721,"speaker":"v29","turn":"T00340","chapter":"C026","text":"The abandonment serves two applicants only at the disadvantage of many others as demonstrated by the petition of signatures that Kate put up a few minutes ago.","fingerprint":"67d0ea9626ea","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01917","start_s":8463.457,"end_s":8470.288,"video_s":10323.457,"speaker":"v29","turn":"T00340","chapter":"C026","text":"Signatures by my neighbors who simply ask that existing conditions of the public ownership are retained without change.","fingerprint":"7a6c5d0fa859","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01918","start_s":8470.522,"end_s":8471.844,"video_s":10330.522,"speaker":"v29","turn":"T00340","chapter":"C026","text":"So we all like what's there.","fingerprint":"6191c536bfa1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01919","start_s":8471.904,"end_s":8477.372,"video_s":10331.904,"speaker":"v29","turn":"T00340","chapter":"C026","text":"We don't need change right now for the benefit of two at the expense of many, many others.","fingerprint":"47bb1507723f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01920","start_s":8478.333,"end_s":8484.422,"video_s":10338.333,"speaker":"v29","turn":"T00340","chapter":"C026","text":"My opposition is that the abandonment puts enforcement of the proposed easements in the hands of neighbors.","fingerprint":"2681e2d5fbbd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01921","start_s":8484.803,"end_s":8497.221,"video_s":10344.803,"speaker":"v29","turn":"T00340","chapter":"C026","text":"And we've been told this directly by the city that if there's issues in the alley, the city doesn't have the resource to be there unless we notify them, which means we have to police that alley.","fingerprint":"f5b3885e641f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01922","start_s":8498.095,"end_s":8505.466,"video_s":10358.095,"speaker":"v29","turn":"T00340","chapter":"C026","text":"This idea of the abandonment puts the enforcement, as I said, in our hands, in the neighbors' hands.","fingerprint":"9ef1d32e7fb2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01923","start_s":8505.987,"end_s":8509.793,"video_s":10365.987,"speaker":"v29","turn":"T00340","chapter":"C026","text":"And this really, to me, contradicts the meaning and the spirit of community.","fingerprint":"9f729e129855","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01924","start_s":8510.374,"end_s":8511.616,"video_s":10370.374,"speaker":"v29","turn":"T00340","chapter":"C026","text":"I don't want to police my neighbors.","fingerprint":"23d29ad5b7b5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01925","start_s":8511.756,"end_s":8512.838,"video_s":10371.756,"speaker":"v29","turn":"T00340","chapter":"C026","text":"I don't want them to police me.","fingerprint":"46d44a523d79","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01926","start_s":8513.398,"end_s":8514.781,"video_s":10373.398,"speaker":"v29","turn":"T00340","chapter":"C026","text":"I want us all to live in harmony.","fingerprint":"db1154f9d7bc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01927","start_s":8515.782,"end_s":8524.896,"video_s":10375.782,"speaker":"v29","turn":"T00340","chapter":"C026","text":"So as Dave shared, policing the alley has been ongoing and difficult and threatening to us personally.","fingerprint":"7dfcc58684b7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01928","start_s":8525.315,"end_s":8529.221,"video_s":10385.315,"speaker":"v29","turn":"T00340","chapter":"C026","text":"So we believe that the city should retain ownership.","fingerprint":"b7773bd8f695","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01929","start_s":8530.183,"end_s":8539.898,"video_s":10390.183,"speaker":"v29","turn":"T00340","chapter":"C026","text":"Privatizing the alley to make sure that the easements are followed will be an unfair hardship on neighbors like myself, my husband, and my community as a whole.","fingerprint":"98f988431798","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01930","start_s":8540.378,"end_s":8540.819,"video_s":10400.378,"speaker":"v29","turn":"T00340","chapter":"C026","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01931","start_s":8542.381,"end_s":8542.782,"video_s":10402.381,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00341","chapter":"C026","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01932","start_s":8542.922,"end_s":8546.087,"video_s":10402.922,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00341","chapter":"C026","text":"And now we will go virtual to David Kean with an A.","fingerprint":"2fe01291b161","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01933","start_s":8548.391,"end_s":8549.112,"video_s":10408.391,"speaker":"v30","turn":"T00342","chapter":"C026","text":"Yes, hello.","fingerprint":"c8c3e72bdcae","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01934","start_s":8549.913,"end_s":8552.537,"video_s":10409.913,"speaker":"v30","turn":"T00342","chapter":"C026","text":"My name is David Kean, K-E-A-N.","fingerprint":"cd2691e0e692","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01935","start_s":8553.04,"end_s":8559.071,"video_s":10413.04,"speaker":"v30","turn":"T00342","chapter":"C026","text":"I live at 4011 North 54th Place with my family.","fingerprint":"ca46ca7d23b0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01936","start_s":8560.633,"end_s":8566.063,"video_s":10420.633,"speaker":"v30","turn":"T00342","chapter":"C026","text":"We are and we live directly adjacent to the alleyway.","fingerprint":"b9a9308a4133","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01937","start_s":8566.103,"end_s":8577.343,"video_s":10426.103,"speaker":"v30","turn":"T00342","chapter":"C026","text":"We would be directly and deeply impacted by the","fingerprint":"f4d5c2065188","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01938","start_s":8577.762,"end_s":8585.036,"video_s":10437.762,"speaker":"v30","turn":"T00342","chapter":"C026","text":"by the abandonment and we are opposed to the abandonment and urge the council to vote yes to approve the appeal.","fingerprint":"e51780eac476","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01939","start_s":8586.699,"end_s":8588.422,"video_s":10446.699,"speaker":"v30","turn":"T00342","chapter":"C026","text":"Thank you so much to everybody for your time.","fingerprint":"07b12729dcaf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01940","start_s":8589.344,"end_s":8589.664,"video_s":10449.344,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00343","chapter":"C026","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01941","start_s":8589.704,"end_s":8591.688,"video_s":10449.704,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00343","chapter":"C026","text":"I believe that is all of our speakers.","fingerprint":"bb364af4d144","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01942","start_s":8592.309,"end_s":8595.535,"video_s":10452.309,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00343","chapter":"C026","text":"So I will close the public hearing and turn to Councilman Robinson.","fingerprint":"ae2a39e4ce94","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01943","start_s":8596.878,"end_s":8597.399,"video_s":10456.878,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00344","chapter":"C026","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01944","start_s":8597.699,"end_s":8600.424,"video_s":10457.699,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00344","chapter":"C026","text":"I do have a question before I make a motion or anything.","fingerprint":"c63d2e57d297","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01945","start_s":8600.444,"end_s":8601.306,"video_s":10460.444,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00344","chapter":"C026","text":"Mr. Greenman.","fingerprint":"c18afc164dd3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01946","start_s":8604.661,"end_s":8605.482,"video_s":10464.661,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00345","chapter":"C026","text":"Councilman Robinson.","fingerprint":"bd39baebf63f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01947","start_s":8606.363,"end_s":8607.124,"video_s":10466.363,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00346","chapter":"C026","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01948","start_s":8607.565,"end_s":8613.433,"video_s":10467.565,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00346","chapter":"C026","text":"A couple of pictures that you put up, the two pictures you showed of the alley, there's slides three and four.","fingerprint":"e508426e8a79","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01949","start_s":8613.894,"end_s":8615.456,"video_s":10473.894,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00346","chapter":"C026","text":"Can we get those back up real quick?","fingerprint":"973abbb8b6cb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01950","start_s":8615.836,"end_s":8616.197,"video_s":10475.836,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00346","chapter":"C026","text":"I'd love to.","fingerprint":"3c4da4693f02","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01951","start_s":8616.217,"end_s":8631.478,"video_s":10476.217,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00346","chapter":"C026","text":"I think, yes, that's this one.","fingerprint":"d32125e0757a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01952","start_s":8636.386,"end_s":8643.198,"video_s":10496.386,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00346","chapter":"C026","text":"As I look at these pictures, the stars on, well, you see the stars on the two houses and such.","fingerprint":"07c8e285dd18","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01953","start_s":8645.101,"end_s":8652.133,"video_s":10505.101,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00346","chapter":"C026","text":"The one just to the south on Calle Camellia, is that a true depiction of what the house looks like now?","fingerprint":"eb5f98f6f781","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01954","start_s":8654.51,"end_s":8668.833,"video_s":10514.51,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00346","chapter":"C026","text":"And the reason I ask, before you go too much further, the reason I ask, you look at that one, and then the picture that the city has taken, which wasn't all that long ago, it appears that it was under construction, and it appears there's a structure right up against the wall in the back alley.","fingerprint":"98b898a0ad8c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01955","start_s":8669.534,"end_s":8671.697,"video_s":10529.534,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00346","chapter":"C026","text":"And I walked the alley earlier this week.","fingerprint":"81a6b46410a3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01956","start_s":8671.898,"end_s":8673.08,"video_s":10531.898,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00346","chapter":"C026","text":"I wanted to know more about it.","fingerprint":"223a80994780","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01957","start_s":8673.1,"end_s":8674.221,"video_s":10533.1,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00346","chapter":"C026","text":"I knew this was coming up.","fingerprint":"6a692e09ce12","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01958","start_s":8674.742,"end_s":8676.926,"video_s":10534.742,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00346","chapter":"C026","text":"And it appears that that structure is all finished.","fingerprint":"4c270ad159d0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01959","start_s":8677.386,"end_s":8678.128,"video_s":10537.386,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00346","chapter":"C026","text":"It could be an ADU.","fingerprint":"d580e24ecf4d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01960","start_s":8678.368,"end_s":8680.872,"video_s":10538.368,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00346","chapter":"C026","text":"I didn't want to peer over the wall or anything like that.","fingerprint":"b1cce17f15ac","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01961","start_s":8680.852,"end_s":8683.597,"video_s":10540.852,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00346","chapter":"C026","text":"but there's a, it's right up against the wall.","fingerprint":"95626e6b1ea9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01962","start_s":8684.017,"end_s":8690.628,"video_s":10544.017,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00346","chapter":"C026","text":"So I'm curious, you're showing one picture, the city has another picture, it appears that the house is finished.","fingerprint":"61eb832c3f03","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01963","start_s":8690.648,"end_s":8697.78,"video_s":10550.648,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00347","chapter":"C026","text":"So is the house at 5401 East Chi Camellia, is that, is it being occupied, am I giving the right address?","fingerprint":"018977d4425a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01964","start_s":8697.8,"end_s":8703.67,"video_s":10557.8,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00348","chapter":"C026","text":"5440 East Chi Camellia, is it being occupied or is it occupied at the moment?","fingerprint":"23921f62663a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01965","start_s":8703.818,"end_s":8708.243,"video_s":10563.818,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00349","chapter":"C026","text":"Mayor, members of council, Councilman Robinson, I can bring my client up.","fingerprint":"f527b4d87238","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01966","start_s":8708.263,"end_s":8710.485,"video_s":10568.263,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00349","chapter":"C026","text":"I believe he lives there currently with his family.","fingerprint":"a47ed13597b9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01967","start_s":8710.505,"end_s":8711.546,"video_s":10570.505,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00349","chapter":"C026","text":"That is correct.","fingerprint":"a388af4f4e99","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01968","start_s":8711.566,"end_s":8720.035,"video_s":10571.566,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00349","chapter":"C026","text":"Now, if your question is regarding the setbacks themselves, Councilman, doing an abandonment also allows you to increase your lot coverage effectively.","fingerprint":"4a250562565c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01969","start_s":8720.416,"end_s":8724.841,"video_s":10580.416,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00349","chapter":"C026","text":"So it would allow other portions of that property to be built out with something like an ADU as well.","fingerprint":"80fffff62a21","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01970","start_s":8730.146,"end_s":8730.947,"video_s":10590.146,"speaker":"v31","turn":"T00350","chapter":"C026","text":"Okay.","fingerprint":"6a581ee90118","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01971","start_s":8730.967,"end_s":8731.868,"video_s":10590.967,"speaker":"v31","turn":"T00350","chapter":"C026","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01972","start_s":8732.287,"end_s":8736.655,"video_s":10592.287,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00351","chapter":"C026","text":"It's just, it's curious to me, it appears that that has already been done.","fingerprint":"b105c8e32716","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01973","start_s":8736.695,"end_s":8739.26,"video_s":10596.695,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00351","chapter":"C026","text":"To me, I'm asking the question.","fingerprint":"1999c5626de8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01974","start_s":8739.66,"end_s":8745.491,"video_s":10599.66,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00351","chapter":"C026","text":"It appears that additional coverage of a lot has already been accomplished.","fingerprint":"1f878a8a7314","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01975","start_s":8746.633,"end_s":8755.729,"video_s":10606.633,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00351","chapter":"C026","text":"And based on the pictures, I'm just curious as to why... Mayor, members of council, Councilman Robinson.","fingerprint":"270d70c44820","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01976","start_s":8756.502,"end_s":8769.221,"video_s":10616.502,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00352","chapter":"C026","text":"Respectfully, the standard we should be applying here is 3164, whether this is necessary as a public right-of-way, not whether my client has built an accessory structure at this point in time.","fingerprint":"ce8996493e9e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01977","start_s":8769.261,"end_s":8770.543,"video_s":10629.261,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00352","chapter":"C026","text":"I'd like to be explicitly clear there.","fingerprint":"7a01f39abea6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01978","start_s":8771.144,"end_s":8777.072,"video_s":10631.144,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00352","chapter":"C026","text":"I'd also, Honorable Mayor, if I may, am I able to respond to the concerns from the appellants?","fingerprint":"3cd07c4e8763","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01979","start_s":8780.137,"end_s":8783.942,"video_s":10640.137,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00353","chapter":"C026","text":"We closed the public hearing, so I think at this point we are just council questions.","fingerprint":"b5761abc07e4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01980","start_s":8784.263,"end_s":8785.024,"video_s":10644.263,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00354","chapter":"C026","text":"Understood.","fingerprint":"53501f58f192","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01981","start_s":8785.612,"end_s":8787.254,"video_s":10645.612,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00354","chapter":"C026","text":"Okay, thank you very much.","fingerprint":"04a5a5c62bbd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01982","start_s":8787.534,"end_s":8789.417,"video_s":10647.534,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00354","chapter":"C026","text":"Mayor, I'm ready to make a motion.","fingerprint":"2094e7aed19f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01983","start_s":8791.279,"end_s":8792.02,"video_s":10651.279,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00355","chapter":"C026","text":"All right, Councilman.","fingerprint":"32b3bb515c75","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01984","start_s":8792.04,"end_s":8793.101,"video_s":10652.04,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00356","chapter":"C026","text":"Mayor, may I ask a question?","fingerprint":"9fb3729e51ff","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01985","start_s":8793.702,"end_s":8794.443,"video_s":10653.702,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00356","chapter":"C026","text":"Sure.","fingerprint":"c0cafcf0e2d6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01986","start_s":8794.463,"end_s":8796.125,"video_s":10654.463,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00356","chapter":"C026","text":"Councilwoman Hernandez.","fingerprint":"be943e39201c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01987","start_s":8796.145,"end_s":8796.846,"video_s":10656.145,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00356","chapter":"C026","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01988","start_s":8796.886,"end_s":8806.158,"video_s":10656.886,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00356","chapter":"C026","text":"Actually, I was going to ask, if I could ask Mr. Greenman, because those are some pretty heavy concerns that the residents shared, or a lot of concerns.","fingerprint":"18b5ef24954e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01989","start_s":8806.198,"end_s":8810.583,"video_s":10666.198,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00356","chapter":"C026","text":"Can you address some of the things that were shared in public comment?","fingerprint":"90d9c347f219","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01990","start_s":8810.603,"end_s":8815.129,"video_s":10670.603,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00357","chapter":"C026","text":"Mayor, members of Council, Councilwoman Hernandez, I would absolutely love to address","fingerprint":"38a4bf8cd9eb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01991","start_s":8815.362,"end_s":8821.311,"video_s":10675.362,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00357","chapter":"C026","text":"Importantly, the abandonment hearing officer also addressed these comments themselves with the series of stipulations.","fingerprint":"ca3c77cb6d85","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01992","start_s":8821.731,"end_s":8831.425,"video_s":10681.731,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00357","chapter":"C026","text":"And they created a series of stipulations to leave the alley open, to create a refuse easement, a pedestrian easement, a public utility easement, and a sewer easement.","fingerprint":"d9b544036173","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01993","start_s":8831.505,"end_s":8836.673,"video_s":10691.505,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00357","chapter":"C026","text":"So for all intents and purposes, the alley itself will look exactly as it does now.","fingerprint":"01957494fcad","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01994","start_s":8837.114,"end_s":8840.138,"video_s":10697.114,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00357","chapter":"C026","text":"There were questions about the enforceability of the easements.","fingerprint":"c3e452150d32","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01995","start_s":8840.118,"end_s":8846.083,"video_s":10700.118,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00357","chapter":"C026","text":"The easement holder, which would be the city of Phoenix, would be responsible for any sort of enforceability.","fingerprint":"e9e8b58cf1cb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01996","start_s":8846.103,"end_s":8851.328,"video_s":10706.103,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00357","chapter":"C026","text":"This is exactly how the utilities and how the alleys currently are.","fingerprint":"f20cfd373896","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01997","start_s":8851.808,"end_s":8856.893,"video_s":10711.808,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00357","chapter":"C026","text":"So all of the current enforceability would consistently move forward.","fingerprint":"3c6b6864fd47","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01998","start_s":8856.953,"end_s":8858.775,"video_s":10716.953,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00357","chapter":"C026","text":"And our thought is this is a win-win.","fingerprint":"80f97ab2cf72","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01999","start_s":8859.255,"end_s":8868.083,"video_s":10719.255,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00357","chapter":"C026","text":"In relation to Mr. Keene and a contractor and dumping, I can't speak to that in any way, shape, or form.","fingerprint":"e53371737280","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02000","start_s":8868.063,"end_s":8869.985,"video_s":10728.063,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00357","chapter":"C026","text":"Truth be told, I'm not sure what to make of that.","fingerprint":"bee5981ed1f4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02001","start_s":8870.005,"end_s":8874.911,"video_s":10730.005,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00357","chapter":"C026","text":"This seems a bit unneighborly to be completely flat, Councilwoman.","fingerprint":"7bba6d530726","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02002","start_s":8875.351,"end_s":8891.269,"video_s":10735.351,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00357","chapter":"C026","text":"That being said, our goal was to work with the city and work with the people nearby to create a series of easements that allows us to stay open effectively, as it does right now, while privatizing it and allowing my clients to potentially build ADUs, stuff like that.","fingerprint":"98769ed80be0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02003","start_s":8891.249,"end_s":8892.091,"video_s":10751.249,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00358","chapter":"C026","text":"Okay, thank you.","fingerprint":"21d63267fca8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02004","start_s":8892.111,"end_s":8892.531,"video_s":10752.111,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00358","chapter":"C026","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02005","start_s":8893.553,"end_s":8906.237,"video_s":10753.553,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00358","chapter":"C026","text":"But do you see how that could be a little, I guess, like, how can we guarantee that to the residents that if we move forward with approving this abandonment, that, I guess, what's the, I'm sorry, let me backtrack.","fingerprint":"972c07e16e34","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02006","start_s":8907.179,"end_s":8913.111,"video_s":10767.179,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00358","chapter":"C026","text":"How is your applicant going to address to make sure that alley stays open?","fingerprint":"d0e110e50bcd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02007","start_s":8913.391,"end_s":8919.163,"video_s":10773.391,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00358","chapter":"C026","text":"Because what I'm hearing is that the neighbors want to make sure they still have access there.","fingerprint":"a86b4ca68d06","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02008","start_s":8919.183,"end_s":8928.141,"video_s":10779.183,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00358","chapter":"C026","text":"I mean, looking at some of the maps, the fact that they use that as a way to get out and walk and things like that.","fingerprint":"c3535d7f5e5c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02009","start_s":8928.121,"end_s":8937.979,"video_s":10788.121,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00358","chapter":"C026","text":"so is what I'm hearing that the plan is to if the abandonment is approved the alley would still remain open for the neighbors to use that","fingerprint":"9e652a4170d0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02010","start_s":8938.567,"end_s":8940.05,"video_s":10798.567,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00359","chapter":"C026","text":"Absolutely, Councilman Hernandez.","fingerprint":"7db1e5e78cec","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02011","start_s":8940.07,"end_s":8945.902,"video_s":10800.07,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00359","chapter":"C026","text":"That's exactly what the point of the stipulations are, to leave the alley open exactly as it is right now.","fingerprint":"302505439b8c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02012","start_s":8946.403,"end_s":8960.17,"video_s":10806.403,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00359","chapter":"C026","text":"And importantly, this gives the City of Phoenix the ability to remove this, to pull it if there are issues with it, and those easements are held in trust forever to the easement holders, which are the City of Phoenix.","fingerprint":"206a69b18533","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02013","start_s":8960.15,"end_s":8987.457,"video_s":10820.15,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00359","chapter":"C026","text":"so the city will have the responsibility to work with the neighbors and the the homeowners themselves as they currently do to make sure this area is clean clear and into perpetuity so these easements don't go away they stay there forever and our goal in doing that is to allow the neighbors to have the access to allow the trash vehicles to have the access forever our goal is not to close this to gate it to even move our walls back our goal is to enhance the area","fingerprint":"e6fb15ba423c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02014","start_s":8987.437,"end_s":8993.723,"video_s":10847.437,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00359","chapter":"C026","text":"create a private enforceability where they will be responsible for keeping it clear, just like you would your own neighbor's property.","fingerprint":"d3560420f316","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02015","start_s":8994.184,"end_s":8996.706,"video_s":10854.184,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00359","chapter":"C026","text":"So our goal is to leave this open forever.","fingerprint":"5e04036444f9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02016","start_s":8996.806,"end_s":9004.014,"video_s":10856.806,"speaker":"v26","turn":"T00359","chapter":"C026","text":"And we were looking at this as a win-win with the abandonment hearing officer's decision, as well as the city staff's recommendation.","fingerprint":"534e2aea4d13","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02017","start_s":9004.794,"end_s":9005.155,"video_s":10864.794,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00360","chapter":"C026","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02018","start_s":9005.255,"end_s":9006.536,"video_s":10865.255,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00360","chapter":"C026","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02019","start_s":9007.757,"end_s":9008.858,"video_s":10867.757,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00360","chapter":"C026","text":"Thank you, Councilman Robinson.","fingerprint":"45f502b768cc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02020","start_s":9013.063,"end_s":9014.204,"video_s":10873.063,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00360","chapter":"C026","text":"Okay, why don't we just go for the motion?","fingerprint":"b321274506c8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02021","start_s":9014.224,"end_s":9015.385,"video_s":10874.224,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00360","chapter":"C026","text":"Do you want to just do the motion?","fingerprint":"477d4178fe38","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02022","start_s":9015.635,"end_s":9017.457,"video_s":10875.635,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00361","chapter":"C026","text":"I was going to make a motion, yes.","fingerprint":"9d2161c3261a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02023","start_s":9017.477,"end_s":9017.577,"video_s":10877.477,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00361","chapter":"C026","text":"Okay.","fingerprint":"6a581ee90118","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02024","start_s":9017.598,"end_s":9018.338,"video_s":10877.598,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00361","chapter":"C026","text":"All right.","fingerprint":"dfbdd9492bec","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02025","start_s":9018.358,"end_s":9018.919,"video_s":10878.358,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00361","chapter":"C026","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02026","start_s":9019.74,"end_s":9024.226,"video_s":10879.74,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00361","chapter":"C026","text":"You know, we've obviously heard from several neighbors the petitions, and it's been discussed.","fingerprint":"b08e91dbc365","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02027","start_s":9024.626,"end_s":9035.721,"video_s":10884.626,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00361","chapter":"C026","text":"There are several utilities that use the alleyway, including for current trash collection, and the city has no obligation to approve every alley abandonment application that's received.","fingerprint":"dae92b34dd1b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02028","start_s":9035.761,"end_s":9036.782,"video_s":10895.761,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00361","chapter":"C026","text":"We just don't.","fingerprint":"db080fc4682f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02029","start_s":9036.762,"end_s":9039.409,"video_s":10896.762,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00361","chapter":"C026","text":"and especially when we hear from so many impacted neighbors.","fingerprint":"84f09ac54ea3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02030","start_s":9039.97,"end_s":9046.406,"video_s":10899.97,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00361","chapter":"C026","text":"Therefore, Mayor, I move to overturn the abandonment hearing officer's decision and deny the request for the abandonment.","fingerprint":"4d20783d5c0b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02031","start_s":9046.627,"end_s":9047.228,"video_s":10906.627,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00362","chapter":"C026","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02032","start_s":9048.592,"end_s":9049.653,"video_s":10908.592,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00362","chapter":"C026","text":"Well, I was enthusiastic.","fingerprint":"e565c13c0eb8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02033","start_s":9049.853,"end_s":9050.194,"video_s":10909.853,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00362","chapter":"C026","text":"Okay.","fingerprint":"6a581ee90118","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02034","start_s":9050.314,"end_s":9051.495,"video_s":10910.314,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00362","chapter":"C026","text":"We have a motion and a second.","fingerprint":"7451ba811637","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02035","start_s":9051.795,"end_s":9054.358,"video_s":10911.795,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00362","chapter":"C026","text":"Hearing the motion, do my colleagues still want to speak?","fingerprint":"4d607ede032c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02036","start_s":9055.159,"end_s":9062.046,"video_s":10915.159,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00363","chapter":"C026","text":"I just wanted to make a comment, and I think that probably the better route is to keep it under public domain.","fingerprint":"8bc473e08151","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02037","start_s":9062.566,"end_s":9068.152,"video_s":10922.566,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00363","chapter":"C026","text":"And then if you want to build an ADU, maybe work with your neighborhood and get support for a variance.","fingerprint":"ee0e4b8f7dfe","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02038","start_s":9068.232,"end_s":9070.775,"video_s":10928.232,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00363","chapter":"C026","text":"And I think your hardship would be the argument of the alley.","fingerprint":"17d2472cc151","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02039","start_s":9070.895,"end_s":9071.375,"video_s":10930.895,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00363","chapter":"C026","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02040","start_s":9072.897,"end_s":9073.958,"video_s":10932.897,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00364","chapter":"C026","text":"Councilwoman Pastor.","fingerprint":"dbcef12e9415","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02041","start_s":9074.512,"end_s":9099.658,"video_s":10934.512,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00365","chapter":"C026","text":"I just want to make a comment because right now I am in the middle of dealing with one of these abandonment issues with neighbors and the fact that there was an agreement but now there's not an agreement because the property was sold and there's a lot of dynamics that I'm dealing with right now regarding this and","fingerprint":"8f6a0624721a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02042","start_s":9099.638,"end_s":9115.259,"video_s":10959.638,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00365","chapter":"C026","text":"The people that do get access are the utilities and the city, but it's very difficult for these neighbors to get to their sewer line, their tap line, in order to do the things that they need to do.","fingerprint":"5e29444e996a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02043","start_s":9115.539,"end_s":9118.002,"video_s":10975.539,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00365","chapter":"C026","text":"So I'm just putting it on record.","fingerprint":"50db22b1f90c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02044","start_s":9118.383,"end_s":9119.925,"video_s":10978.383,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00365","chapter":"C026","text":"This is why I'm the second.","fingerprint":"53aa463916e2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02045","start_s":9121.441,"end_s":9122.463,"video_s":10981.441,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00365","chapter":"C026","text":"All right, roll call.","fingerprint":"5d88818c1d17","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02046","start_s":9123.445,"end_s":9123.685,"video_s":10983.445,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00366","chapter":"C026","text":"Guardado?","fingerprint":"0344b48c3f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02047","start_s":9124.046,"end_s":9124.827,"video_s":10984.046,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00366","chapter":"C026","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02048","start_s":9124.847,"end_s":9125.248,"video_s":10984.847,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00366","chapter":"C026","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02049","start_s":9126.05,"end_s":9127.613,"video_s":10986.05,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00366","chapter":"C026","text":"May I explain my vote?","fingerprint":"26d5f810396a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02050","start_s":9127.633,"end_s":9128.114,"video_s":10987.633,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00367","chapter":"C026","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02051","start_s":9128.134,"end_s":9128.514,"video_s":10988.134,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00367","chapter":"C026","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02052","start_s":9128.735,"end_s":9134.145,"video_s":10988.735,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00367","chapter":"C026","text":"I'm going to vote no because I actually would side with staff recommendation with the stipulations.","fingerprint":"5cdcd2178eb6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02053","start_s":9134.766,"end_s":9135.508,"video_s":10994.766,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00367","chapter":"C026","text":"So today I vote no.","fingerprint":"33c1f6a5b054","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02054","start_s":9136.55,"end_s":9137.712,"video_s":10996.55,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00367","chapter":"C026","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02055","start_s":9138.147,"end_s":9138.448,"video_s":10998.147,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00368","chapter":"C026","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02056","start_s":9138.969,"end_s":9139.43,"video_s":10998.969,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00368","chapter":"C026","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02057","start_s":9139.67,"end_s":9139.911,"video_s":10999.67,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00368","chapter":"C026","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02058","start_s":9140.392,"end_s":9140.873,"video_s":11000.392,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00368","chapter":"C026","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02059","start_s":9141.053,"end_s":9141.334,"video_s":11001.053,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00369","chapter":"C026","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02060","start_s":9141.835,"end_s":9142.496,"video_s":11001.835,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00370","chapter":"C026","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02061","start_s":9142.516,"end_s":9143.197,"video_s":11002.516,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00370","chapter":"C026","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02062","start_s":9143.218,"end_s":9143.558,"video_s":11003.218,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00370","chapter":"C026","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02063","start_s":9144.22,"end_s":9144.3,"video_s":11004.22,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00370","chapter":"C026","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02064","start_s":9144.32,"end_s":9144.981,"video_s":11004.32,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00370","chapter":"C026","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02065","start_s":9145.142,"end_s":9145.382,"video_s":11005.142,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00370","chapter":"C026","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02066","start_s":9145.763,"end_s":9146.244,"video_s":11005.763,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00370","chapter":"C026","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02067","start_s":9146.905,"end_s":9147.106,"video_s":11006.905,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00371","chapter":"C026","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02068","start_s":9147.466,"end_s":9148.007,"video_s":11007.466,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00372","chapter":"C026","text":"Passes 8-1.","fingerprint":"a7b3afc7a8da","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02069","start_s":9149.571,"end_s":9156.966,"video_s":11009.571,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00373","chapter":"C027","text":"All right, we next move to item 153, which is consideration of a citizen petition, and we will welcome up Greg Turner, who provided the petition.","fingerprint":"f470c4c6e548","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02070","start_s":9164.827,"end_s":9168.011,"video_s":11024.827,"speaker":"v32","turn":"T00374","chapter":"C027","text":"Good afternoon Madam Mayor, City Council Members.","fingerprint":"c40f0fcb92ac","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02071","start_s":9168.872,"end_s":9177.282,"video_s":11028.872,"speaker":"v32","turn":"T00374","chapter":"C027","text":"My name is Greg Turner and I'm a born and raised resident of Phoenix and thank you for your time and consideration on my citizen petition.","fingerprint":"306166dd844a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02072","start_s":9178.223,"end_s":9188.655,"video_s":11038.223,"speaker":"v32","turn":"T00374","chapter":"C027","text":"I'm here regarding the intersection of 25th Avenue and Greenway where Harriet Diamond lost her life being struck by an unlicensed, unsured driver while crossing the street.","fingerprint":"635f198f617f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02073","start_s":9189.496,"end_s":9190.918,"video_s":11049.496,"speaker":"v32","turn":"T00374","chapter":"C027","text":"That driver was never sighted.","fingerprint":"5f7655a2908c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02074","start_s":9192.13,"end_s":9198.237,"video_s":11052.13,"speaker":"v32","turn":"T00374","chapter":"C027","text":"and I didn't come here today to revisit litigation or sign blame or ask for compensation.","fingerprint":"88deaffed4da","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02075","start_s":9198.297,"end_s":9201.38,"video_s":11058.297,"speaker":"v32","turn":"T00374","chapter":"C027","text":"I came here because some losses deserve acknowledgement.","fingerprint":"487c3ebfe377","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02076","start_s":9202.862,"end_s":9207.026,"video_s":11062.862,"speaker":"v32","turn":"T00374","chapter":"C027","text":"Harriet was a strong, independent woman and one of the kindest people I've ever known.","fingerprint":"1487b373e89a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02077","start_s":9208.367,"end_s":9217.277,"video_s":11068.367,"speaker":"v32","turn":"T00374","chapter":"C027","text":"She was deeply loved by her son and the day that she was killed, had offered to give her a ride, she insisted on taking the bus as she often did.","fingerprint":"55084c748098","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02078","start_s":9217.544,"end_s":9220.528,"video_s":11077.544,"speaker":"v32","turn":"T00374","chapter":"C027","text":"He respected her independence and expected to hear from her later.","fingerprint":"60ba2c7db8c2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02079","start_s":9221.109,"end_s":9222.01,"video_s":11081.109,"speaker":"v32","turn":"T00374","chapter":"C027","text":"That call never came.","fingerprint":"07dc9b5a349a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02080","start_s":9222.05,"end_s":9227.356,"video_s":11082.05,"speaker":"v32","turn":"T00374","chapter":"C027","text":"After her death, my friend endured something I hope most people will never have to experience.","fingerprint":"881c6176ac1f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02081","start_s":9228.157,"end_s":9238.911,"video_s":11088.157,"speaker":"v32","turn":"T00374","chapter":"C027","text":"Over the course of the litigation, he was forced to repeatedly revisit the worst day of his life, including watching the footage of her death of that incident repeatedly.","fingerprint":"55767a59aeb5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02082","start_s":9239.65,"end_s":9242.316,"video_s":11099.65,"speaker":"v32","turn":"T00374","chapter":"C027","text":"What surprised me most was not that the case was lost.","fingerprint":"56e4ccb18ae7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02083","start_s":9242.757,"end_s":9256.41,"video_s":11102.757,"speaker":"v32","turn":"T00374","chapter":"C027","text":"It was hearing the suggestion that the relationship between Harriet and her son was somehow less meaningful than those who knew them and understood it to be, and that his pursuit of the case was primarily out of compensation.","fingerprint":"f59a914345d3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02084","start_s":9256.39,"end_s":9266.101,"video_s":11116.39,"speaker":"v32","turn":"T00374","chapter":"C027","text":"I felt as though a profound mother and son relationship had been reduced to a legal argument and a preventable death reduced to a matter of dollars and cents.","fingerprint":"c443069d8931","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02085","start_s":9266.802,"end_s":9270.306,"video_s":11126.802,"speaker":"v32","turn":"T00374","chapter":"C027","text":"I respectfully disagree with that view.","fingerprint":"3aa7eb767ac8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02086","start_s":9273.65,"end_s":9282.921,"video_s":11133.65,"speaker":"v32","turn":"T00374","chapter":"C027","text":"The City of Phoenix has embraced Vision Zero, the principle that traffic deaths are not inevitable and that every life lost on our streets","fingerprint":"49da088b12ad","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02087","start_s":9283.103,"end_s":9283.544,"video_s":11143.103,"speaker":"v32","turn":"T00374","chapter":"C027","text":"matters.","fingerprint":"3e9ae4c1660e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02088","start_s":9284.205,"end_s":9289.634,"video_s":11144.205,"speaker":"v32","turn":"T00374","chapter":"C027","text":"I want to respectfully address a suggestion that it was been offered that adopt the seat.","fingerprint":"9220058b9aaf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02089","start_s":9290.756,"end_s":9293.681,"video_s":11150.756,"speaker":"v32","turn":"T00374","chapter":"C027","text":"Thank you for your time.","fingerprint":"28036d909db6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02090","start_s":9293.701,"end_s":9296.706,"video_s":11153.701,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00375","chapter":"C027","text":"Thank you so much for that important testimony.","fingerprint":"b0d711a28bcd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02091","start_s":9296.986,"end_s":9297.347,"video_s":11156.986,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00375","chapter":"C027","text":"Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"9a95bf6095c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02092","start_s":9299.51,"end_s":9302.555,"video_s":11159.51,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00376","chapter":"C027","text":"Motion to approve the staff recommendation and deny the petition.","fingerprint":"c17db5abc930","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02093","start_s":9303.357,"end_s":9303.697,"video_s":11163.357,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00376","chapter":"C027","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02094","start_s":9304.318,"end_s":9305.18,"video_s":11164.318,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00377","chapter":"C027","text":"Motion and a second.","fingerprint":"9b5eb76aa224","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02095","start_s":9305.601,"end_s":9307.103,"video_s":11165.601,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00377","chapter":"C027","text":"Any comments?","fingerprint":"9cdeefcc2f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02096","start_s":9308.804,"end_s":9310.708,"video_s":11168.804,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00378","chapter":"C027","text":"Mayor, I would be happy to.","fingerprint":"e2da148f272c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02097","start_s":9310.928,"end_s":9321.388,"video_s":11170.928,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00378","chapter":"C027","text":"I know that the street department has a adopt a street and perhaps we can look at honoring this section of the street maybe by adopting it, the family.","fingerprint":"9d2c17575a91","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02098","start_s":9321.548,"end_s":9323.151,"video_s":11181.548,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00378","chapter":"C027","text":"So I'll be happy to work with them on that.","fingerprint":"c27dd47f4cf7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02099","start_s":9324.474,"end_s":9325.836,"video_s":11184.474,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00378","chapter":"C027","text":"A great suggestion, Councilwoman.","fingerprint":"cbdcc8306775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02100","start_s":9325.997,"end_s":9326.378,"video_s":11185.997,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00378","chapter":"C027","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02101","start_s":9326.458,"end_s":9329.363,"video_s":11186.458,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00379","chapter":"C027","text":"That would be a really nice way to remember.","fingerprint":"069f413c3d66","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02102","start_s":9330.325,"end_s":9330.846,"video_s":11190.325,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00379","chapter":"C027","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02103","start_s":9331.197,"end_s":9331.718,"video_s":11191.197,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00380","chapter":"C027","text":"Guardado?","fingerprint":"0344b48c3f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02104","start_s":9332.218,"end_s":9333.019,"video_s":11192.218,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00380","chapter":"C027","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02105","start_s":9333.039,"end_s":9333.539,"video_s":11193.039,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00380","chapter":"C027","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02106","start_s":9333.779,"end_s":9334.58,"video_s":11193.779,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00380","chapter":"C027","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02107","start_s":9334.6,"end_s":9335.061,"video_s":11194.6,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00380","chapter":"C027","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02108","start_s":9335.241,"end_s":9335.982,"video_s":11195.241,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00380","chapter":"C027","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02109","start_s":9336.002,"end_s":9336.522,"video_s":11196.002,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00380","chapter":"C027","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02110","start_s":9336.782,"end_s":9337.643,"video_s":11196.782,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00380","chapter":"C027","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02111","start_s":9337.663,"end_s":9338.204,"video_s":11197.663,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00380","chapter":"C027","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02112","start_s":9338.224,"end_s":9338.444,"video_s":11198.224,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00380","chapter":"C027","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02113","start_s":9339.125,"end_s":9339.485,"video_s":11199.125,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00380","chapter":"C027","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02114","start_s":9340.246,"end_s":9340.526,"video_s":11200.246,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00381","chapter":"C027","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02115","start_s":9340.686,"end_s":9344.25,"video_s":11200.686,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00381","chapter":"C027","text":"And Mr. Turner, we'll make sure we contact you to set this up.","fingerprint":"b3b58ca3d2bc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02116","start_s":9344.27,"end_s":9344.61,"video_s":11204.27,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00381","chapter":"C027","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02117","start_s":9345.491,"end_s":9345.851,"video_s":11205.491,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00382","chapter":"C027","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02118","start_s":9346.972,"end_s":9347.052,"video_s":11206.972,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00382","chapter":"C027","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02119","start_s":9347.072,"end_s":9347.673,"video_s":11207.072,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00382","chapter":"C027","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02120","start_s":9347.933,"end_s":9348.714,"video_s":11207.933,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00382","chapter":"C027","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02121","start_s":9348.734,"end_s":9349.194,"video_s":11208.734,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00382","chapter":"C027","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02122","start_s":9349.475,"end_s":9349.655,"video_s":11209.475,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00383","chapter":"C027","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02123","start_s":9350.075,"end_s":9351.016,"video_s":11210.075,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00384","chapter":"C027","text":"Passes 9-0.","fingerprint":"f7c37e75fd84","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02124","start_s":9352.858,"end_s":9353.258,"video_s":11212.858,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00385","chapter":"C027","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02125","start_s":9354.54,"end_s":9360.225,"video_s":11214.54,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00386","chapter":"C028","text":"We'll now go to the final portion of our meeting, citizen public comment, and I'll turn to our city attorney to introduce this portion.","fingerprint":"a4775099c25a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02126","start_s":9361.015,"end_s":9361.656,"video_s":11221.015,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00387","chapter":"C028","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02127","start_s":9361.876,"end_s":9367.923,"video_s":11221.876,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00387","chapter":"C028","text":"During citizen comment, members of the public may speak to the City Council for up to three minutes on issues of interest or concern.","fingerprint":"4d4713206cdf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02128","start_s":9368.423,"end_s":9374.67,"video_s":11228.423,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00387","chapter":"C028","text":"However, the matters addressed must be within the jurisdiction of the Phoenix City Council and on which the Council has the authority to act.","fingerprint":"604f59ebdbba","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02129","start_s":9375.211,"end_s":9378.174,"video_s":11235.211,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00387","chapter":"C028","text":"The citizen comment session is limited to 30 minutes.","fingerprint":"4b4641b48602","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02130","start_s":9378.654,"end_s":9385.782,"video_s":11238.654,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00387","chapter":"C028","text":"The Air Zone Open Meeting Law allows the City Council to listen to comments but prohibits Council members from discussing or acting on the issues presented.","fingerprint":"92bdafdc6035","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02131","start_s":9386.263,"end_s":9388.585,"video_s":11246.263,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00387","chapter":"C028","text":"However, Council members may respond to criticism.","fingerprint":"73272def6458","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02132","start_s":9388.726,"end_s":9389.166,"video_s":11248.726,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00387","chapter":"C028","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02133","start_s":9390.412,"end_s":9391.117,"video_s":11250.412,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00388","chapter":"C028","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02134","start_s":9391.157,"end_s":9395.224,"video_s":11251.157,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00388","chapter":"C028","text":"We'll begin with Clarissa Peterson followed by Randy Kelling and Jerry Van Gass.","fingerprint":"690ca3b4fcd3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02135","start_s":9410.527,"end_s":9413.351,"video_s":11270.527,"speaker":"v33","turn":"T00389","chapter":"C028","text":"Good afternoon, mayor, council members.","fingerprint":"4ff9688b0044","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02136","start_s":9414.412,"end_s":9423.304,"video_s":11274.412,"speaker":"v33","turn":"T00389","chapter":"C028","text":"I am with Elizabeth with Fondson Empowerment, and I live at the SOS shelter.","fingerprint":"af4f49c12343","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02137","start_s":9424.826,"end_s":9435.42,"video_s":11284.826,"speaker":"v33","turn":"T00389","chapter":"C028","text":"And I'm going to be talking about the pets that stay there, and they don't have a voice or anyone to talk for them.","fingerprint":"3dac7c33ed55","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02138","start_s":9435.4,"end_s":9455.046,"video_s":11295.4,"speaker":"v33","turn":"T00389","chapter":"C028","text":"It has to do with cleaning their dog yard and it's not sanitized and just hosing it down with water is not clean enough and the cleaning people that does it doesn't know how to do it and it's hot out there and","fingerprint":"1d68850e8521","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02139","start_s":9456.258,"end_s":9485.404,"video_s":11316.258,"speaker":"v33","turn":"T00389","chapter":"C028","text":"and nobody's not even providing no cooling pads for them either to be to cool off in their tents yeah and that and and I'm the one that usually puts up the waste bags for them on the fence and I don't have a pet myself but I do this for volunteering for that shelter and thank you","fingerprint":"2f85b4590b8c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02140","start_s":9487.46,"end_s":9487.921,"video_s":11347.46,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00390","chapter":"C028","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02141","start_s":9489.865,"end_s":9493.672,"video_s":11349.865,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00390","chapter":"C028","text":"Next we have Randy Kellen followed by Jerry Van Gass.","fingerprint":"03292511ca63","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02142","start_s":9500.184,"end_s":9502.228,"video_s":11360.184,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00391","chapter":"C028","text":"Madam Mayor, Madam Vice Mayor,","fingerprint":"0a95af713dcc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02143","start_s":9502.462,"end_s":9505.386,"video_s":11362.462,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00391","chapter":"C028","text":"Thank you for your time to listen to me.","fingerprint":"4640f9186ee0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02144","start_s":9505.626,"end_s":9509.231,"video_s":11365.626,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00391","chapter":"C028","text":"I'm with Elizabeth, Funds for Empowerment.","fingerprint":"7f23c9a6ddf2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02145","start_s":9510.372,"end_s":9515.499,"video_s":11370.372,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00391","chapter":"C028","text":"I want to say thank you very much for the ADA bathrooms for the SOS.","fingerprint":"16df5e62ecd0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02146","start_s":9515.599,"end_s":9517.462,"video_s":11375.599,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00391","chapter":"C028","text":"It was greatly appreciated.","fingerprint":"248e1fa3672c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02147","start_s":9518.122,"end_s":9524.451,"video_s":11378.122,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00391","chapter":"C028","text":"We have started the construction as far as installing them.","fingerprint":"b2ba821c1bb2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02148","start_s":9524.871,"end_s":9531.54,"video_s":11384.871,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00391","chapter":"C028","text":"They are, however, not up to running as of yet, but it is very much greatly appreciated.","fingerprint":"a4c03e52ed1f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02149","start_s":9531.52,"end_s":9545.279,"video_s":11391.52,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00391","chapter":"C028","text":"Another thing I want to bring up, Saturday the 13th, I don't know if you guys are responsible or not, but it was greatly appreciated for the food that was sent over there to the SOS.","fingerprint":"cb1537f42347","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02150","start_s":9546.881,"end_s":9549.445,"video_s":11406.881,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00391","chapter":"C028","text":"Everybody really enjoyed it.","fingerprint":"ffb504d4782b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02151","start_s":9550.42,"end_s":9555.305,"video_s":11410.42,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00391","chapter":"C028","text":"One other issue I want to bring up is the accountability.","fingerprint":"6bfeb6b57455","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02152","start_s":9556.186,"end_s":9558.328,"video_s":11416.186,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00391","chapter":"C028","text":"It's going to be discussed a little bit later.","fingerprint":"c56941dd4593","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02153","start_s":9558.488,"end_s":9561.251,"video_s":11418.488,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00391","chapter":"C028","text":"Right now is probably not the time to do it.","fingerprint":"83abe71eff46","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02154","start_s":9563.072,"end_s":9569.198,"video_s":11423.072,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00391","chapter":"C028","text":"As far as for what is actually needed is carbon copies for accountability.","fingerprint":"7ab844f6d6d6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02155","start_s":9569.819,"end_s":9578.267,"video_s":11429.819,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00391","chapter":"C028","text":"For instance, backup paperwork for things that need to be followed up on, things that are going wrong or things that need to be improved on.","fingerprint":"904637b1971f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02156","start_s":9579.378,"end_s":9581.821,"video_s":11439.378,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00391","chapter":"C028","text":"Either way, I wanted to say thank you for everything.","fingerprint":"10b0c00eee1b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02157","start_s":9581.861,"end_s":9584.885,"video_s":11441.861,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00391","chapter":"C028","text":"As far as for the ADA, it was greatly appreciated.","fingerprint":"ec8e44b81d95","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02158","start_s":9585.926,"end_s":9590.112,"video_s":11445.926,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00391","chapter":"C028","text":"And thank you very much, Madam Mayor, Vice Mayor, and City Council.","fingerprint":"6e2f5d0ade5b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02159","start_s":9590.632,"end_s":9592.615,"video_s":11450.632,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00391","chapter":"C028","text":"Thank you for listening.","fingerprint":"bb122a8274f4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02160","start_s":9592.635,"end_s":9593.135,"video_s":11452.635,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00392","chapter":"C028","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02161","start_s":9593.976,"end_s":9598.102,"video_s":11453.976,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00392","chapter":"C028","text":"Next, Jerry Van Gass, followed by Tim Sierakowski.","fingerprint":"5a1c113f9e16","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02162","start_s":9602.627,"end_s":9603.388,"video_s":11462.627,"speaker":"v34","turn":"T00393","chapter":"C028","text":"Good afternoon.","fingerprint":"f01e727e7b79","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02163","start_s":9605.171,"end_s":9607.073,"video_s":11465.171,"speaker":"v34","turn":"T00393","chapter":"C028","text":"Jerry Van Gass.","fingerprint":"adb398f9d34f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02164","start_s":9607.373,"end_s":9614.682,"video_s":11467.373,"speaker":"v34","turn":"T00393","chapter":"C028","text":"President of Good Goat Government Oversight and Accountability Team.","fingerprint":"09aadcee417a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02165","start_s":9615.743,"end_s":9626.457,"video_s":11475.743,"speaker":"v34","turn":"T00393","chapter":"C028","text":"I'm here today to submit a citizen petition under the city charter chapter four and section 22.","fingerprint":"4a6326909b41","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02166","start_s":9628.079,"end_s":9637.33,"video_s":11488.079,"speaker":"v34","turn":"T00393","chapter":"C028","text":"And it deals with submitting a request to change the name of Cesar Chavez Park","fingerprint":"a5368ce398a3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02167","start_s":9637.732,"end_s":9639.294,"video_s":11497.732,"speaker":"v34","turn":"T00393","chapter":"C028","text":"to honor Jesse Owens.","fingerprint":"5dc4a95078e6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02168","start_s":9643.621,"end_s":9650.832,"video_s":11503.621,"speaker":"v34","turn":"T00393","chapter":"C028","text":"This action has to take place once it's submitted and there's a copy for each of you within 15 days.","fingerprint":"2bcbbabbca5b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02169","start_s":9654.077,"end_s":9660.246,"video_s":11514.077,"speaker":"v34","turn":"T00393","chapter":"C028","text":"One of my favorite words comes to mind and it's convergence.","fingerprint":"88da23c8f380","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02170","start_s":9660.266,"end_s":9664.212,"video_s":11520.266,"speaker":"v34","turn":"T00393","chapter":"C028","text":"And the city of Phoenix now is sitting on an opportunity","fingerprint":"699ea9153c6f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02171","start_s":9665.12,"end_s":9668.084,"video_s":11525.12,"speaker":"v34","turn":"T00393","chapter":"C028","text":"It's our 250th anniversary of this country.","fingerprint":"a4af7b38ae82","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02172","start_s":9668.125,"end_s":9677.018,"video_s":11528.125,"speaker":"v34","turn":"T00393","chapter":"C028","text":"USA Today is doing a vote nationwide on the greatest athlete in various sports.","fingerprint":"b97110814a5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02173","start_s":9677.859,"end_s":9685.611,"video_s":11537.859,"speaker":"v34","turn":"T00393","chapter":"C028","text":"Jesse Owens will undoubtedly be named the greatest track and field athlete ever in 250 years.","fingerprint":"d0e367d0c173","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02174","start_s":9686.252,"end_s":9692.241,"video_s":11546.252,"speaker":"v34","turn":"T00393","chapter":"C028","text":"He's already been named by USA Today as the most important athlete in our history.","fingerprint":"2710d92b5c62","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02175","start_s":9693.588,"end_s":9713.331,"video_s":11553.588,"speaker":"v34","turn":"T00393","chapter":"C028","text":"and we're also the convergence is we have a 40-acre park with a lake that has to be renamed down at Cesar Chavez Park and there's no better an icon a national icon we can name this for.","fingerprint":"c5f218335b3a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02176","start_s":9714.392,"end_s":9723.342,"video_s":11574.392,"speaker":"v34","turn":"T00393","chapter":"C028","text":"Phoenix will look incredible because no other city is going to be able to do anything comparable to name a park","fingerprint":"4c3baf7588e8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02177","start_s":9723.44,"end_s":9737.276,"video_s":11583.44,"speaker":"v34","turn":"T00393","chapter":"C028","text":"on our 250th anniversary on July 4th for a resident of Phoenix who up to date has never been honored with anything named after him in Phoenix by the city.","fingerprint":"be520c63ee75","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02178","start_s":9738.898,"end_s":9743.303,"video_s":11598.898,"speaker":"v34","turn":"T00393","chapter":"C028","text":"I think I wouldn't even blink.","fingerprint":"544728dce6a0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02179","start_s":9743.944,"end_s":9744.945,"video_s":11603.944,"speaker":"v34","turn":"T00393","chapter":"C028","text":"This needs to be done.","fingerprint":"a9350f6924f9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02180","start_s":9745.426,"end_s":9745.786,"video_s":11605.426,"speaker":"v34","turn":"T00393","chapter":"C028","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02181","start_s":9746.967,"end_s":9748.369,"video_s":11606.967,"speaker":"v34","turn":"T00393","chapter":"C028","text":"And here are the copies.","fingerprint":"70a6d5bd9149","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02182","start_s":9748.389,"end_s":9749.751,"video_s":11608.389,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00394","chapter":"C028","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02183","start_s":9749.771,"end_s":9751.793,"video_s":11609.771,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00394","chapter":"C028","text":"Tim is next followed by Christina Tyler.","fingerprint":"76c5a4104e35","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02184","start_s":9755.114,"end_s":9757.016,"video_s":11615.114,"speaker":"v35","turn":"T00395","chapter":"C028","text":"Tim Sierkowski, good afternoon.","fingerprint":"84184a187e96","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02185","start_s":9757.076,"end_s":9760.601,"video_s":11617.076,"speaker":"v35","turn":"T00395","chapter":"C028","text":"And it has been a long afternoon.","fingerprint":"9e0b1ed0bdf8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02186","start_s":9761.642,"end_s":9763.424,"video_s":11621.642,"speaker":"v35","turn":"T00395","chapter":"C028","text":"I won't take up the whole three minutes.","fingerprint":"a3f9fcddf91c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02187","start_s":9763.985,"end_s":9774.117,"video_s":11623.985,"speaker":"v35","turn":"T00395","chapter":"C028","text":"I just want to follow up with Jerry and say it really would be an honor to name something after one of the greatest athletes in American history.","fingerprint":"5b88097dc67b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02188","start_s":9774.918,"end_s":9781.105,"video_s":11634.918,"speaker":"v35","turn":"T00395","chapter":"C028","text":"We have the opportunity here to really show the people","fingerprint":"6ff8a924533f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02189","start_s":9781.237,"end_s":9790.247,"video_s":11641.237,"speaker":"v35","turn":"T00395","chapter":"C028","text":"of America, how much pride we have in one of the greatest sports people and residents of Phoenix, Arizona.","fingerprint":"b23b103a2bce","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02190","start_s":9791.409,"end_s":9807.447,"video_s":11651.409,"speaker":"v35","turn":"T00395","chapter":"C028","text":"I think that we should just go forward, rename the park at this point, and make sure that everyone across the country realizes what respect that the individuals of Phoenix and the City Council have for such a great athlete.","fingerprint":"3ae787081db0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02191","start_s":9808.658,"end_s":9815.647,"video_s":11668.658,"speaker":"v35","turn":"T00395","chapter":"C028","text":"This is going to look great for us for the 4th of July, and I think we should have this done before the 4th of July.","fingerprint":"57752f65f1d3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02192","start_s":9815.667,"end_s":9825.28,"video_s":11675.667,"speaker":"v35","turn":"T00395","chapter":"C028","text":"And I think this is one of the greatest things that this council could do for a citizen that is now dead in the city of Phoenix.","fingerprint":"c8dbef4c35bf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02193","start_s":9825.88,"end_s":9826.221,"video_s":11685.88,"speaker":"v35","turn":"T00395","chapter":"C028","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02194","start_s":9828.504,"end_s":9830.987,"video_s":11688.504,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00396","chapter":"C028","text":"Christina is next, followed by William Kirkland.","fingerprint":"b4157f110126","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02195","start_s":9838.392,"end_s":9841.458,"video_s":11698.392,"speaker":"v36","turn":"T00397","chapter":"C028","text":"Good afternoon, mayor, vice mayor, and council members.","fingerprint":"b0138f3bdd26","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02196","start_s":9841.879,"end_s":9851.338,"video_s":11701.879,"speaker":"v36","turn":"T00397","chapter":"C028","text":"My name is Christina Tyler, and I'm here today regarding the condition of Cesar Chavez Parks and several related public policy concerns.","fingerprint":"0a24c8973f65","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02197","start_s":9851.487,"end_s":9856.854,"video_s":11711.487,"speaker":"v36","turn":"T00397","chapter":"C028","text":"During my visit yesterday, I observed several issues that I believe deserve attention.","fingerprint":"46b2e65ebe4b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02198","start_s":9857.494,"end_s":9861.459,"video_s":11717.494,"speaker":"v36","turn":"T00397","chapter":"C028","text":"I observed significant algae conditions within portions of the lake.","fingerprint":"44d42c131bad","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02199","start_s":9862.1,"end_s":9872.112,"video_s":11722.1,"speaker":"v36","turn":"T00397","chapter":"C028","text":"I also spent time walking around the lake and observing multiple shoreline areas and did not observe any fish.","fingerprint":"99414f7cc0cc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02200","start_s":9876.53,"end_s":9890.159,"video_s":11736.53,"speaker":"v36","turn":"T00397","chapter":"C028","text":"Given that the lake is promoted as a fishing destination, the absence of any visible fish activity during my visit raised concerns regarding water quality, fish habitat conditions, and the overall health of the lake ecosystem.","fingerprint":"0d575973f760","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02201","start_s":9890.66,"end_s":9895.551,"video_s":11750.66,"speaker":"v36","turn":"T00397","chapter":"C028","text":"I also observed that there were no visible fishing line disposal stations around the lake","fingerprint":"5aca385143a0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02202","start_s":9895.531,"end_s":9903.788,"video_s":11755.531,"speaker":"v36","turn":"T00397","chapter":"C028","text":"Discarded fishing line and fishing hooks can create a hazard for wildlife and injure bird, fish, duck, geese, and other animals.","fingerprint":"b6667aaefc5f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02203","start_s":9904.349,"end_s":9916.054,"video_s":11764.349,"speaker":"v36","turn":"T00397","chapter":"C028","text":"I observed damage and uneven pathways, including areas where tree roots have displaced sidewalks and brick walkways, creating accessibility concerns and potential trip hazards.","fingerprint":"1a1746b6ac6d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02204","start_s":9916.034,"end_s":9926.77,"video_s":11776.034,"speaker":"v36","turn":"T00397","chapter":"C028","text":"I also observed drinking fountains that appeared damaged or outdated, restroom stalls without doors, and a missing American flag on a flagpole near the playground area.","fingerprint":"e8ed0f868445","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02205","start_s":9926.918,"end_s":9932.488,"video_s":11786.918,"speaker":"v36","turn":"T00397","chapter":"C028","text":"Overall, I believe the park would benefit from renovation and modernization throughout the property.","fingerprint":"7a6aede9db8a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02206","start_s":9932.508,"end_s":9949.5,"video_s":11792.508,"speaker":"v36","turn":"T00397","chapter":"C028","text":"To support that effort, I have prepared a photo report documenting existing conditions and a comprehensive future vision master plan that identifies opportunities for maintenance, accessibility improvements, wildlife conservation, recreation, sustainability and community engagement.","fingerprint":"4fa0fb5dbfae","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02207","start_s":9950.375,"end_s":9966.465,"video_s":11810.375,"speaker":"v36","turn":"T00397","chapter":"C028","text":"One of the most important immediate needs is a clear written process for wildlife rescue organizations to gain access to injured animals on park property along with designated city contacts and approved response procedures.","fingerprint":"1ea12adb1eae","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02208","start_s":9967.166,"end_s":9971.775,"video_s":11827.166,"speaker":"v36","turn":"T00397","chapter":"C028","text":"I believe the city should consider establishing a partnership program","fingerprint":"1f3200a141fe","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02209","start_s":9971.755,"end_s":9981.694,"video_s":11831.755,"speaker":"v36","turn":"T00397","chapter":"C028","text":"that allows qualified nonprofit wildlife rescue organizations and other authorized volunteers to provide emergency aid to injured wildlife when needed.","fingerprint":"c033d6f3b0e0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02210","start_s":9982.315,"end_s":9993.477,"video_s":11842.315,"speaker":"v36","turn":"T00397","chapter":"C028","text":"Because wildlife emergencies are often time sensitive, I also believe there should be a fair and transparent appeals process for individuals or organizations denied access","fingerprint":"20cd3a8ad4ca","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02211","start_s":9993.457,"end_s":9999.003,"video_s":11853.457,"speaker":"v36","turn":"T00397","chapter":"C028","text":"with expedited review whenever possible, ideally within 24 hours.","fingerprint":"e468c99bdff1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02212","start_s":9999.364,"end_s":10018.185,"video_s":11859.364,"speaker":"v36","turn":"T00397","chapter":"C028","text":"In addition, shoreline and lake cleanup efforts should be expanded through partnerships between city staff, wildlife organizations, fishing groups, environmental organizations, and community volunteers to remove discarded fishing line hooks and debris before they harm wildlife or negatively affect water quality.","fingerprint":"a70f0bbdf386","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02213","start_s":10018.345,"end_s":10019.346,"video_s":11878.345,"speaker":"v36","turn":"T00397","chapter":"C028","text":"Thank you for your time.","fingerprint":"28036d909db6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02214","start_s":10020.946,"end_s":10021.387,"video_s":11880.946,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00398","chapter":"C028","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02215","start_s":10022.308,"end_s":10026.155,"video_s":11882.308,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00398","chapter":"C028","text":"William is next, followed by Elsia Greer-Hurtado.","fingerprint":"52bbebda3905","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02216","start_s":10030.722,"end_s":10031.443,"video_s":11890.722,"speaker":"v31","turn":"T00399","chapter":"C028","text":"Good afternoon, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d348a72de400","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02217","start_s":10031.463,"end_s":10033.026,"video_s":11891.463,"speaker":"v31","turn":"T00399","chapter":"C028","text":"My name is William D. Kirkland.","fingerprint":"6ef366f53a31","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02218","start_s":10033.888,"end_s":10036.031,"video_s":11893.888,"speaker":"v31","turn":"T00399","chapter":"C028","text":"I'm with Ms. Elizabeth.","fingerprint":"43b09ac097b1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02219","start_s":10037.053,"end_s":10038.415,"video_s":11897.053,"speaker":"v31","turn":"T00399","chapter":"C028","text":"I'm just an old vet.","fingerprint":"c520072dbd84","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02220","start_s":10038.615,"end_s":10041.961,"video_s":11898.615,"speaker":"v31","turn":"T00399","chapter":"C028","text":"You know, I ain't about to tell a bean, but I'm going to tell you something.","fingerprint":"b49f5b3b6964","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02221","start_s":10041.981,"end_s":10046.228,"video_s":11901.981,"speaker":"v31","turn":"T00399","chapter":"C028","text":"There's been a big difference out there at SOS where I'm at, and I want to thank everyone of y'all for that.","fingerprint":"dd69f1a87e6a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02222","start_s":10046.63,"end_s":10048.452,"video_s":11906.63,"speaker":"v31","turn":"T00399","chapter":"C028","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02223","start_s":10048.492,"end_s":10075.455,"video_s":11908.492,"speaker":"v31","turn":"T00399","chapter":"C028","text":"Elsia Greer-Hurtado followed by Eric Richardson.","fingerprint":"55abfa5e7423","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02224","start_s":10084.143,"end_s":10085.926,"video_s":11944.143,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00400","chapter":"C028","text":"If you want to use the lower microphone.","fingerprint":"f0856cea9ca9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02225","start_s":10086.387,"end_s":10094.983,"video_s":11946.387,"speaker":"v37","turn":"T00401","chapter":"C028","text":"Okay, my name is Elsia Greer, and I'm currently residing at the SOS and have been for two years, a little over two years.","fingerprint":"22eb09be19d2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02226","start_s":10095.504,"end_s":10107.366,"video_s":11955.504,"speaker":"v37","turn":"T00401","chapter":"C028","text":"And first I want to tell you, Mayor, thank you for the ADA, the extra ADA bathrooms, but I also want to talk about getting them up and running because they're not running yet.","fingerprint":"1060384a4ad7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02227","start_s":10107.852,"end_s":10125.118,"video_s":11967.852,"speaker":"v37","turn":"T00401","chapter":"C028","text":"even the one that we had before and then I also wanted to ask if you could make more ADA available into our x-wings which I'm at but my wheelchair can't go out inside because it's upstairs you climb like three steps to get up it","fingerprint":"26ba6fdca071","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02228","start_s":10125.824,"end_s":10133.401,"video_s":11985.824,"speaker":"v37","turn":"T00401","chapter":"C028","text":"So that's why I wanted to come here and say thank you very much for the extra, but if they could get up and running, I'd appreciate it.","fingerprint":"f6ab73bb9eae","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02229","start_s":10133.442,"end_s":10137.471,"video_s":11993.442,"speaker":"v37","turn":"T00401","chapter":"C028","text":"Wonderful, and I thank you, and I think our staff may be able to offer an update on the timeline for that.","fingerprint":"7d5b1e6d7129","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02230","start_s":10138.112,"end_s":10139.215,"video_s":11998.112,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00402","chapter":"C028","text":"So I appreciate that.","fingerprint":"b2584391de87","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02231","start_s":10139.796,"end_s":10142.803,"video_s":11999.796,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00402","chapter":"C028","text":"Eric is next, followed by Lee Ellis.","fingerprint":"cd5fe5fc6de8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02232","start_s":10151.491,"end_s":10153.094,"video_s":12011.491,"speaker":"v38","turn":"T00403","chapter":"C028","text":"Hello, good afternoon.","fingerprint":"9299d58b1c6b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02233","start_s":10153.695,"end_s":10154.757,"video_s":12013.695,"speaker":"v38","turn":"T00403","chapter":"C028","text":"My name is Eric Richardson.","fingerprint":"e6618c07fabc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02234","start_s":10155.157,"end_s":10159.505,"video_s":12015.157,"speaker":"v38","turn":"T00403","chapter":"C028","text":"I also represent Funds for Empowerment.","fingerprint":"ec28edea5739","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02235","start_s":10159.565,"end_s":10162.069,"video_s":12019.565,"speaker":"v38","turn":"T00403","chapter":"C028","text":"I'm also a current resident at SOS.","fingerprint":"1f43b979f68d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02236","start_s":10163.01,"end_s":10171.224,"video_s":12023.01,"speaker":"v38","turn":"T00403","chapter":"C028","text":"Also, I'd like to thank, I don't know if this was you all, responsibility for the past Saturday about the dinner.","fingerprint":"b6d66bf343fe","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02237","start_s":10171.405,"end_s":10172.807,"video_s":12031.405,"speaker":"v38","turn":"T00403","chapter":"C028","text":"We had some volunteers that...","fingerprint":"98e855053abf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02238","start_s":10173.361,"end_s":10174.503,"video_s":12033.361,"speaker":"v38","turn":"T00403","chapter":"C028","text":"It was a wonderful dinner.","fingerprint":"c9d48fa41d50","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02239","start_s":10174.723,"end_s":10180.071,"video_s":12034.723,"speaker":"v38","turn":"T00403","chapter":"C028","text":"I had like a lasagna dinner and I kind of really appreciated myself personally because it was like the week after my birthday.","fingerprint":"c94aef8bfe4f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02240","start_s":10180.191,"end_s":10184.697,"video_s":12040.191,"speaker":"v38","turn":"T00403","chapter":"C028","text":"My birthday was June 6th, so I took that as a post, I guess, birthday dinner.","fingerprint":"5430bb144b80","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02241","start_s":10185.358,"end_s":10187.261,"video_s":12045.358,"speaker":"v38","turn":"T00403","chapter":"C028","text":"But anyways, though, back to the matter.","fingerprint":"4f7847b6027a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02242","start_s":10187.281,"end_s":10195.333,"video_s":12047.281,"speaker":"v38","turn":"T00403","chapter":"C028","text":"I guess I wanted to also talk about, I guess, accountability at SOS as far as the staff members there, basically.","fingerprint":"3e57a2f0bdbe","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02243","start_s":10196.254,"end_s":10199.679,"video_s":12056.254,"speaker":"v38","turn":"T00403","chapter":"C028","text":"Not saying it's a big issue with the staff members, but it's just the way they handle things.","fingerprint":"40082f3ad9c1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02244","start_s":10200.22,"end_s":10203.064,"video_s":12060.22,"speaker":"v38","turn":"T00403","chapter":"C028","text":"Personally, I've seen people get like exited","fingerprint":"c5432a45d7f8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02245","start_s":10203.5,"end_s":10219.517,"video_s":12063.5,"speaker":"v38","turn":"T00403","chapter":"C028","text":"from the SOS and it's supposed to be a place to keep people off the streets that are homeless and everything like that and I just think there should be a better procedure when people get exited basically because I'm hearing some people saying that they got kicked out","fingerprint":"c8d968147382","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02246","start_s":10220.341,"end_s":10225.386,"video_s":12080.341,"speaker":"v38","turn":"T00403","chapter":"C028","text":"for a little simple stuff that could have been prevented or maybe they didn't even do.","fingerprint":"2bfd6a372424","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02247","start_s":10225.446,"end_s":10237.837,"video_s":12085.446,"speaker":"v38","turn":"T00403","chapter":"C028","text":"I just feel like as residents there, I'm concerned for even myself, even though I don't have any disciplinary problems, but I mean, like, any time I can get exited and can't even fight, that's basically what I'm talking about.","fingerprint":"1143dc3d3e31","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02248","start_s":10237.897,"end_s":10248.627,"video_s":12097.897,"speaker":"v38","turn":"T00403","chapter":"C028","text":"It just could be some procedure where we get to, I guess, if we feel like, what I'm trying to say, if we, like,","fingerprint":"7a04d6ca2bee","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02249","start_s":10249.298,"end_s":10251.382,"video_s":12109.298,"speaker":"v38","turn":"T00403","chapter":"C028","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02250","start_s":10251.562,"end_s":10264.624,"video_s":12111.562,"speaker":"v38","turn":"T00403","chapter":"C028","text":"Lee is next, followed by David Morgan.","fingerprint":"73b504180f21","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02251","start_s":10266.798,"end_s":10267.9,"video_s":12126.798,"speaker":"v39","turn":"T00404","chapter":"C028","text":"Hello, thank you for your time.","fingerprint":"f25ebefd15e4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02252","start_s":10268.221,"end_s":10270.866,"video_s":12128.221,"speaker":"v39","turn":"T00404","chapter":"C028","text":"I stay at SOS, so I'd like to thank you guys for hearing us out.","fingerprint":"5f11c40c2a64","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02253","start_s":10271.507,"end_s":10273.25,"video_s":12131.507,"speaker":"v39","turn":"T00404","chapter":"C028","text":"We still do have a problem with the showers.","fingerprint":"aa3cde1219cf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02254","start_s":10273.31,"end_s":10278.06,"video_s":12133.31,"speaker":"v39","turn":"T00404","chapter":"C028","text":"We're down to three showers out of six, so we could use another shower trailer.","fingerprint":"9474cce0f82e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02255","start_s":10278.961,"end_s":10287.237,"video_s":12138.961,"speaker":"v39","turn":"T00404","chapter":"C028","text":"I'd like to see if you guys can even bring in some more resources for not only housing, but job opportunities like the worker.","fingerprint":"ccdb37b68153","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02256","start_s":10287.217,"end_s":10295.888,"video_s":12147.217,"speaker":"v39","turn":"T00404","chapter":"C028","text":"some of us aren't allowed to go on a cast where the worker is and where DES is so if they can implement a few more of those programs to the SOS shelter it'd be great.","fingerprint":"e56340dfa374","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02257","start_s":10296.389,"end_s":10297.17,"video_s":12156.389,"speaker":"v39","turn":"T00404","chapter":"C028","text":"Thank you for your time.","fingerprint":"28036d909db6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02258","start_s":10298.472,"end_s":10298.852,"video_s":12158.472,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00405","chapter":"C028","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02259","start_s":10299.533,"end_s":10301.296,"video_s":12159.533,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00405","chapter":"C028","text":"David is next followed by Jeremy Thacker.","fingerprint":"294cc565c4fd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02260","start_s":10305.201,"end_s":10308.465,"video_s":12165.201,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00405","chapter":"C028","text":"All right Jeremy is next followed by Victor Sanchez.","fingerprint":"d3e4aff4b127","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02261","start_s":10320.072,"end_s":10321.294,"video_s":12180.072,"speaker":"v40","turn":"T00406","chapter":"C028","text":"Good afternoon, everyone.","fingerprint":"56b4592a53d0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02262","start_s":10322.856,"end_s":10325.701,"video_s":12182.856,"speaker":"v40","turn":"T00406","chapter":"C028","text":"I just wanted to talk about the renaming of the park as well.","fingerprint":"a067e5bc0cda","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02263","start_s":10327.343,"end_s":10336.096,"video_s":12187.343,"speaker":"v40","turn":"T00406","chapter":"C028","text":"When Jerry told me about the survey, I was surprised that we would put out a survey like this that's going to put out illegitimate results no matter what.","fingerprint":"e0e15588463c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02264","start_s":10336.337,"end_s":10347.193,"video_s":12196.337,"speaker":"v40","turn":"T00406","chapter":"C028","text":"When you put out a survey with names on it, then the chance of a response from somebody writing in something other than the names given is 8%.","fingerprint":"b649851cbee4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02265","start_s":10347.528,"end_s":10358.485,"video_s":12207.528,"speaker":"v40","turn":"T00406","chapter":"C028","text":"So whatever write-ins you get for Jesse Owens should be multiplied times 12 or so to get an actual where it would be if we put the name on there to start.","fingerprint":"63c0040fb1d2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02266","start_s":10358.525,"end_s":10363.192,"video_s":12218.525,"speaker":"v40","turn":"T00406","chapter":"C028","text":"So this town doesn't have a, it's not an old town.","fingerprint":"a8fa14d9ba67","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02267","start_s":10363.232,"end_s":10364.654,"video_s":12223.232,"speaker":"v40","turn":"T00406","chapter":"C028","text":"We've got very little history.","fingerprint":"ea8e3d32375f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02268","start_s":10365.295,"end_s":10374.97,"video_s":12225.295,"speaker":"v40","turn":"T00406","chapter":"C028","text":"We had one of the greatest athletes ever, a world hero that went up against and stood in front of Hitler and","fingerprint":"a51cad26b8a1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02269","start_s":10376.789,"end_s":10379.472,"video_s":12236.789,"speaker":"v40","turn":"T00406","chapter":"C028","text":"really challenge that in front of the entire world.","fingerprint":"46b766874dde","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02270","start_s":10380.253,"end_s":10382.035,"video_s":12240.253,"speaker":"v40","turn":"T00406","chapter":"C028","text":"And we can celebrate that.","fingerprint":"82b2dcdc4ebf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02271","start_s":10382.576,"end_s":10386.78,"video_s":12242.576,"speaker":"v40","turn":"T00406","chapter":"C028","text":"Or we can name the park after a cow is the other option, one of the names given.","fingerprint":"21bee4b3a6f4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02272","start_s":10388.082,"end_s":10395.31,"video_s":12248.082,"speaker":"v40","turn":"T00406","chapter":"C028","text":"I recommend we take this opportunity to celebrate one of the biggest names in the city's history.","fingerprint":"cbc9155f54c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02273","start_s":10395.41,"end_s":10398.153,"video_s":12255.41,"speaker":"v40","turn":"T00406","chapter":"C028","text":"So thanks.","fingerprint":"00c8d3b311d1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02274","start_s":10398.173,"end_s":10398.634,"video_s":12258.173,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00407","chapter":"C028","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02275","start_s":10399.495,"end_s":10401.497,"video_s":12259.495,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00407","chapter":"C028","text":"Victor is next, followed by Michael Morris.","fingerprint":"9092b966d18b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02276","start_s":10407.282,"end_s":10407.943,"video_s":12267.282,"speaker":"v41","turn":"T00408","chapter":"C028","text":"Good afternoon.","fingerprint":"f01e727e7b79","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02277","start_s":10407.963,"end_s":10408.984,"video_s":12267.963,"speaker":"v41","turn":"T00408","chapter":"C028","text":"My name is Victor Sanchez.","fingerprint":"a9de3b1aa3d8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02278","start_s":10410.045,"end_s":10412.048,"video_s":12270.045,"speaker":"v41","turn":"T00408","chapter":"C028","text":"Thank you for hearing us.","fingerprint":"49fee162a4ee","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02279","start_s":10412.068,"end_s":10415.452,"video_s":12272.068,"speaker":"v41","turn":"T00408","chapter":"C028","text":"I would like to comment about the transportation.","fingerprint":"013de246187c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02280","start_s":10416.373,"end_s":10419.737,"video_s":12276.373,"speaker":"v41","turn":"T00408","chapter":"C028","text":"There's other cities like Tempe, they have like Dash.","fingerprint":"4ea882700f11","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02281","start_s":10420.258,"end_s":10422.2,"video_s":12280.258,"speaker":"v41","turn":"T00408","chapter":"C028","text":"It's a free bus ride.","fingerprint":"368fe072c54e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02282","start_s":10422.941,"end_s":10426.225,"video_s":12282.941,"speaker":"v41","turn":"T00408","chapter":"C028","text":"If we could have like a couple of more maybe up north or east or south.","fingerprint":"6e7baa1a8776","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02283","start_s":10427.006,"end_s":10432.713,"video_s":12287.006,"speaker":"v41","turn":"T00408","chapter":"C028","text":"I struggle myself getting bus passes, so I got to pay.","fingerprint":"1076c2d6f9f7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02284","start_s":10432.773,"end_s":10436.057,"video_s":12292.773,"speaker":"v41","turn":"T00408","chapter":"C028","text":"We have those transportations in the third largest city.","fingerprint":"e614bbd5aaa1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02285","start_s":10436.847,"end_s":10438.389,"video_s":12296.847,"speaker":"v41","turn":"T00408","chapter":"C028","text":"Maybe we could have an extra buzz or two.","fingerprint":"cd4e58a74900","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02286","start_s":10440.792,"end_s":10440.992,"video_s":12300.792,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00409","chapter":"C028","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02287","start_s":10441.012,"end_s":10442.174,"video_s":12301.012,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00409","chapter":"C028","text":"Thank you so much, Victor.","fingerprint":"b6145773c503","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02288","start_s":10442.874,"end_s":10444.557,"video_s":12302.874,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00409","chapter":"C028","text":"Michael is next, followed by Tina Wright.","fingerprint":"5f4bd049dc31","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02289","start_s":10447.78,"end_s":10450.284,"video_s":12307.78,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00409","chapter":"C028","text":"Michael Morris, if you could indicate if you're present.","fingerprint":"61f1c551812b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02290","start_s":10453.688,"end_s":10455.089,"video_s":12313.688,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00409","chapter":"C028","text":"Wright, I do not see Michael Morris.","fingerprint":"88ea10a7b9ba","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02291","start_s":10455.21,"end_s":10456.711,"video_s":12315.21,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00409","chapter":"C028","text":"Tina Wright, followed by Tony Hill.","fingerprint":"1c057beb1b0e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02292","start_s":10458.053,"end_s":10459.315,"video_s":12318.053,"speaker":"v25","turn":"T00410","chapter":"C028","text":"Tina, could you indicate?","fingerprint":"062ab6c501c9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02293","start_s":10462.619,"end_s":10464.441,"video_s":12322.619,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00411","chapter":"C028","text":"All right, is Tony Hill here?","fingerprint":"d00b89e9b657","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02294","start_s":10466.733,"end_s":10470.797,"video_s":12326.733,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00411","chapter":"C028","text":"Elizabeth Venable, followed by David Benefiel.","fingerprint":"1e309173353e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02295","start_s":10479.564,"end_s":10488.532,"video_s":12339.564,"speaker":"v42","turn":"T00412","chapter":"C028","text":"I also wanted to echo the comments about it's nice that the SOS law... Oh, Elizabeth Venable from From Pomerant.","fingerprint":"463eabb62016","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02296","start_s":10488.632,"end_s":10491.455,"video_s":12348.632,"speaker":"v42","turn":"T00412","chapter":"C028","text":"I don't really get compensated that much, though, so does it count?","fingerprint":"b8579ad564ec","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02297","start_s":10493.637,"end_s":10495.238,"video_s":12353.637,"speaker":"v42","turn":"T00412","chapter":"C028","text":"Anyways...","fingerprint":"adc93c5e38a8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02298","start_s":10496.888,"end_s":10505.497,"video_s":12356.888,"speaker":"v42","turn":"T00412","chapter":"C028","text":"I think that it's important to have that facility be ADA compliant just as much as any other facility in the city of Phoenix.","fingerprint":"8b97d63d08d1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02299","start_s":10505.577,"end_s":10511.963,"video_s":12365.577,"speaker":"v42","turn":"T00412","chapter":"C028","text":"And so I'm glad that you have made those kinds of investments and are making those kinds of investments.","fingerprint":"fa27b0d2b939","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02300","start_s":10512.184,"end_s":10517.189,"video_s":12372.184,"speaker":"v42","turn":"T00412","chapter":"C028","text":"And I'm glad that there's a little bit more dignity in the SOS lot.","fingerprint":"67d14add8891","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02301","start_s":10517.629,"end_s":10520.552,"video_s":12377.629,"speaker":"v42","turn":"T00412","chapter":"C028","text":"I'm glad that people feel listened to.","fingerprint":"0c232153be7e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02302","start_s":10520.612,"end_s":10525.377,"video_s":12380.612,"speaker":"v42","turn":"T00412","chapter":"C028","text":"And that's a wonderful thing.","fingerprint":"9dd39ecd2ab1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02303","start_s":10526.572,"end_s":10550.74,"video_s":12386.572,"speaker":"v42","turn":"T00412","chapter":"C028","text":"I wanted to say something similar that I said last time which is that it's important to think about these spaces being effective and efficient so that you get again the greatest return out of your large investment that you're making out of the general fund","fingerprint":"7783ee30a669","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02304","start_s":10551.277,"end_s":10581.283,"video_s":12411.277,"speaker":"v42","turn":"T00412","chapter":"C028","text":"and I think it's important to look at the exits and the effectiveness of sort of like having capricious kind of exits that set people back over small minor violations in protocols.","fingerprint":"c9d44eaff282","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02305","start_s":10581.263,"end_s":10602.36,"video_s":12441.263,"speaker":"v42","turn":"T00412","chapter":"C028","text":"it's it's sort of like an establishing a new employee once you have a new employee you have to train the employee every single time every integrated into and it's an extra amount of resources to do every new individual that's random but um","fingerprint":"dd60f5a725a8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02306","start_s":10602.897,"end_s":10623.977,"video_s":12462.897,"speaker":"v42","turn":"T00412","chapter":"C028","text":"What I'm saying is that if you can be more successful with the exits you get more of a return and so you know potentially you could look at data gathering to find out you know what is limiting those exits or look at why some of the success rates are not that high.","fingerprint":"550622e38a04","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02307","start_s":10623.957,"end_s":10653.745,"video_s":12483.957,"speaker":"v42","turn":"T00412","chapter":"C028","text":"you know because there's only so much that the individual can be that is the individual's fault for not having a successful exit and the exits in the other programs are I mean the other facilities are higher than in the SOS lot so it's not something that is I mean I think there's some problems with some of the disciplinary stuff but I think that the exits are worse in the SOS lot","fingerprint":"ec4089df2555","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02308","start_s":10653.725,"end_s":10656.809,"video_s":12513.725,"speaker":"v42","turn":"T00412","chapter":"C028","text":"and I think if you gather data on that, it might be more efficient.","fingerprint":"3279ca41f1c4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02309","start_s":10659.953,"end_s":10661.074,"video_s":12519.953,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00413","chapter":"C028","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02310","start_s":10661.876,"end_s":10663.618,"video_s":12521.876,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00413","chapter":"C028","text":"David is next followed by Michelle Combs.","fingerprint":"88fe308a4feb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02311","start_s":10666.622,"end_s":10674.872,"video_s":12526.622,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00413","chapter":"C028","text":"David Benefiel, B-E-N-E-F-I-E-L. All right, Michelle Combs, are you present?","fingerprint":"b66ec6cc85a0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02312","start_s":10677.656,"end_s":10678.898,"video_s":12537.656,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00413","chapter":"C028","text":"All right, did I get everyone?","fingerprint":"14fa7cb3193f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02313","start_s":10680.339,"end_s":10682.382,"video_s":12540.339,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00413","chapter":"C028","text":"All right, we are adjourned, thank you so much.","fingerprint":"b78ec09dbe45","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L02314","start_s":10696.25,"end_s":10699.425,"video_s":12556.25,"speaker":"v43","turn":"T00414","chapter":"C028","text":"Appreciate the opportunity to speak and to share my story.","fingerprint":"5126f5adca85","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]}],"items":[{"event_item_id":64444,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":"The Phoenix City Council convened in formal session on Wednesday, June 17, 2026 at 2:38 p.m. in the Council Chambers.","votes":[],"roll_call":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Present"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Present"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Present"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Present"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Present"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Present"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Present"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Present"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Present"}]},{"event_item_id":64607,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"If viewing this packet electronically in PDF, open and use bookmarks to navigate easily from one item to another.\r\n\r\nOPTIONS TO ACCESS THIS MEETING\r\n\r\nVirtual Request to speak at a meeting: \r\n\r\n- Register online by visiting the City Council Meetings page on phoenix.gov at least 2 hours prior to the start of this meeting. Then, click on this link at the time of the meeting and join the Webex to speak:\r\nhttps://phoenixcitycouncil.webex.com/phoenixcitycouncil/j.php?MTID=me9ee8fc9ec21730afe2a00978722a9c8 \r\n\r\n- Register via telephone at 602-262-6001 at least 2 hours prior to the start of this meeting, noting the item number. Then, use the Call-in phone number and Meeting ID listed below at the time of the meeting to call-in and speak. \r\n\r\nIn-Person Requests to speak at a meeting:\r\n\r\n- Register in person at a kiosk located at the City Council Chambers, 200 W. Jefferson St., Phoenix, Arizona, 85003. Arrive 1 hour prior to the start of this meeting. Depending on seating availability, residents will attend and speak from the Upper Chambers, Lower Chambers or City Hall location.\r\n\r\n- Individuals should arrive early, 1 hour prior to the start of the meeting to submit an in-person request to speak before the item is called. After the item is called, requests to speak for that item will not be accepted.\r\n\r\nAt the time of the meeting:\r\n\r\n- Watch the meeting live streamed on phoenix.gov or Phoenix Channel 11 on Cox Cable, or using the Webex link provided above.\r\n\r\n- Call-in to listen to the meeting. Dial 602-666-0783 and Enter Meeting ID 2553 805 2828# (for English) or 2551 560 2930# (for Spanish). Press # again when prompted for attendee ID.\r\n\r\n- Watch the meeting in-person from the Upper Chambers, Lower Chambers or City Hall depending on seating availability.\r\n\r\n- Members of the public may attend this meeting in person. Physical access to the meeting location will be available starting 1 hour prior to the meeting.\r\n\r\nPara nuestros residentes de habla hispana:\t\r\n\r\n- Para registrarse para hablar en español, llame al 602-262-6001 al menos 2 horas antes del inicio de esta reunión e indique el número del tema. El día de la reunión, llame al 602-666-0783 e ingrese el número de identificación de la reunión 2551 560 2930#. El intérprete le indicará cuando sea su turno de hablar. \r\n\r\n- Para solamente escuchar la reunión en español, llame a este mismo número el día de la reunión (602-666-0783; ingrese el número de identificación de la reunión 2551 560 2930#). Se proporciona interpretación simultánea para nuestros residentes durante todas las reuniones.\r\n\r\n- Para asistir a la reunión en persona, vaya a las Cámaras del Concejo Municipal de Phoenix ubicadas en 200 W. Jefferson Street, Phoenix, AZ 85003. Llegue 1 hora antes del comienzo de la reunión. Si desea hablar, regístrese electrónicamente en uno de los quioscos, antes de que comience el tema. Una vez que se comience a discutir el tema, no se aceptarán nuevas solicitudes para hablar. Dependiendo de cuantos asientos haya disponibles, usted podría ser sentado en la parte superior de las cámaras, en el piso de abajo de las cámaras, o en el edificio municipal.\r\n\r\n- Miembros del público pueden asistir a esta reunión en persona. El acceso físico al lugar de la reunión estará disponible comenzando una hora antes de la reunión.","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64654,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":"Councilman Waring temporarily left the voting body after the vote on liquor licenses items and returned after the omnibus motion for Ordinances, Resolutions and New Business items. Councilwoman Pastor temporarily left and returned to the voting body during discussion of Item 60. Councilwoman Guardado temporarily left the voting body during discussion of Item 89 and returned during discussion of Item 101. Mayor Gallego temporarily left and returned to the voting body during Citizen Comments.\n\nMayor Gallego acknowledged the presence of Mario Barajas and Elsie Duarte, Spanish interpreters. In Spanish, Mr. Barajas announced their availability to the audience.\n\nThe City Clerk confirmed copies of the titles of Ordinances G-7523 and G-7524 and S-52964 through S-53064 were available to the public in the office of the City Clerk at least 24 hours prior to this Council meeting and, therefore, may be read by title or agenda item only pursuant to the City Code.\n\nReferences to the attachments in these minutes relate to documents that were attached to the agenda.\n\nCity Attorney Julie Kriegh stated members of the public may speak for up to two minutes on agenda items and gave direction on appropriate decorum when providing comments.","votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64445,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"MINUTES OF MEETINGS","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64446,"agenda_number":"1","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"For Approval or Correction, the Minutes of the Formal Meeting on November 5, 2025","matter_file":"26-1029","matter_type":"Minutes","action":"approved","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64447,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"JUDGE APPOINTMENTS AND SWEARING-IN","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64529,"agenda_number":"2","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Reappointment of Phoenix Municipal Court Judges - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1382","matter_type":"Formal Action","action":"approved","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64448,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"LIQUOR LICENSES, BINGO, AND OFF-TRACK BETTING LICENSE APPLICATIONS","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65016,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":"Mayor Gallego requested a motion of liquor and bingo license items.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington made a motion seconded by Councilwoman O'Brien, as appears below.","votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64623,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":"approved and/or adopted as part of an omnibus motion","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65018,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":"NOTE: Councilman Waring left to the voting body after the vote on the liquor and bingo items.","votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64463,"agenda_number":"3","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Gill's Food Mart - District 1","matter_file":"26-1325","matter_type":"License - Liquor","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64450,"agenda_number":"4","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Toso's Sports Bar & Grill - District 1","matter_file":"26-1101","matter_type":"License - Liquor","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64462,"agenda_number":"5","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Churrasco De Brasil - District 1","matter_file":"26-1324","matter_type":"License - Liquor","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64458,"agenda_number":"6","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Firebird Wood Fired Grill - District 1","matter_file":"26-1261","matter_type":"License - Liquor","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64457,"agenda_number":"7","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Tofu King - District 1","matter_file":"26-1240","matter_type":"License - Liquor","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64460,"agenda_number":"8","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Barro's Pizza - District 2","matter_file":"26-1269","matter_type":"License - Liquor","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64456,"agenda_number":"9","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Fire N Ice Arena - District 2","matter_file":"26-1239","matter_type":"License - Liquor","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64455,"agenda_number":"10","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Fire N Ice Hotel - District 2","matter_file":"26-1238","matter_type":"License - Liquor","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64464,"agenda_number":"11","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - 7-Eleven #47406H - District 2","matter_file":"26-1356","matter_type":"License - Liquor","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64459,"agenda_number":"12","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Vig PV - District 3","matter_file":"26-1266","matter_type":"License - Liquor","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64465,"agenda_number":"13","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Stop & Shop - District 4","matter_file":"26-1357","matter_type":"License - Liquor","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64453,"agenda_number":"14","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Terrible Herbst - District 5","matter_file":"26-1234","matter_type":"License - Liquor","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64466,"agenda_number":"15","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Special Event - Almost There: A Mom + Pups Rescue (July 11, 2026) - District 6","matter_file":"26-1316","matter_type":"License - Special Event","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64467,"agenda_number":"16","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Special Event - Almost There: A Mom + Pups Rescue (July 25, 2026) - District 6","matter_file":"26-1319","matter_type":"License - Special Event","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64468,"agenda_number":"17","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Special Event - The Walter Hive - District 7","matter_file":"26-1367","matter_type":"License - Special Event","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64452,"agenda_number":"18","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Buffalo Wild Wings - District 7","matter_file":"26-1229","matter_type":"License - Liquor","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64454,"agenda_number":"19","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Aloft Hotel Phoenix Airport - District 8","matter_file":"26-1237","matter_type":"License - Liquor","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64461,"agenda_number":"20","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Calitacos - District 8","matter_file":"26-1274","matter_type":"License - Liquor","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64451,"agenda_number":"21","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Culinary Gangster - District 8","matter_file":"26-1179","matter_type":"License - Liquor","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64449,"agenda_number":"22","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Bingo License - Monfort Post No. 9400, Veterans of Foreign Wars of the United - District 3","matter_file":"26-1025","matter_type":"License - Bingo","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64472,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"ORDINANCES, RESOLUTIONS AND NEW BUSINESS","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65015,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":"Mayor Gallego requested a motion on the remaining agenda items.\n\nThe following electronic comments were submitted for the record:\n- Two in opposition to Item 107;\n- One in opposition to Item 110.\n\nA motion was made by Vice Mayor Hodge Washington seconded by Councilwoman O'Brien, as appears below.","votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64624,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":"approved and/or adopted as part of an omnibus motion","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64653,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":"Items 23-43, Ordinance S-52964 was a request to authorize the City Controller to disburse funds, up to amounts indicated on items 23 through 43, for the purpose of paying vendors, contractors, claimants and others, and providing additional payment authority under certain existing city contracts. This section also requested continuing payment authority, up to amounts indicated below, for the following contracts, contract extensions and/or bids awarded. As indicated below, some items below require payment pursuant to Phoenix City Code section 42-13.\n\nNOTE: Councilman Waring returned to the voting body after the vote on the Ordinances, Resolutions, and New Business items.","votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64473,"agenda_number":"23","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Federal Aviation Administration","matter_file":"26-1273","matter_type":"Payment Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64479,"agenda_number":"24","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Info-Teach Research Group, Inc., dba McLean and Company","matter_file":"26-1246","matter_type":"Payment Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":null,"consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64481,"agenda_number":"25","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"United States Postal Service - Annual Payment Authority","matter_file":"26-1293","matter_type":"Payment Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64482,"agenda_number":"26","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Various Vendors - Annual Utility Charges","matter_file":"26-1294","matter_type":"Payment Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64610,"agenda_number":"27","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Fiberquant, Inc. dba Fiberquant Analytical Services and SGS North America, Inc.","matter_file":"26-1235","matter_type":"Payment Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64484,"agenda_number":"28","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"United Phoenix Firefighters Association","matter_file":"26-1110","matter_type":"Payment Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64485,"agenda_number":"29","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Public Safety Personnel Retirement System","matter_file":"26-1114","matter_type":"Payment Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64478,"agenda_number":"30","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"030530 Uniforms LLC, dba Ace Uniforms of Phoenix and Debra Lynn Ludlow, dba CODB Solutions LLC","matter_file":"26-1188","matter_type":"Payment Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64616,"agenda_number":"31","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Salt River Project","matter_file":"26-1127","matter_type":"Payment Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64486,"agenda_number":"32","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Arizona Courtlines Inc.","matter_file":"26-1222","matter_type":"Payment Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64487,"agenda_number":"33","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Code Studio, Inc.","matter_file":"26-1057","matter_type":"Payment Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64488,"agenda_number":"34","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Salt River Project","matter_file":"26-1019","matter_type":"Payment Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64489,"agenda_number":"35","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Salt River Project","matter_file":"26-1100","matter_type":"Payment Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64490,"agenda_number":"36","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Maricopa County Environmental Services Department","matter_file":"26-0922","matter_type":"Payment Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64491,"agenda_number":"37","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Maricopa County Air Quality Department","matter_file":"26-0923","matter_type":"Payment Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64492,"agenda_number":"38","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"City Treasurer - Annual Payment Authority","matter_file":"26-1291","matter_type":"Payment Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64493,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"ADMINISTRATION","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64477,"agenda_number":"39","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Settlement of Claim(s) Arispe v. City of Phoenix","matter_file":"26-1180","matter_type":"Payment Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64480,"agenda_number":"40","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Settlement of Claim(s) Carbajal v. City of Phoenix","matter_file":"26-1285","matter_type":"Payment Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64475,"agenda_number":"41","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Settlement of Claim(s) East Valley Disaster Services v. City of Phoenix","matter_file":"26-1135","matter_type":"Payment Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64476,"agenda_number":"42","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Settlement of Claim(s) Largo v. City of Phoenix","matter_file":"26-1137","matter_type":"Payment Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64483,"agenda_number":"43","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Settlement of Claim(s) Reischl v. City of Phoenix","matter_file":"26-1313","matter_type":"Payment Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64520,"agenda_number":"52","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Payment Ordinance for Summer Recess (Ordinance S-53052) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1290","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64501,"agenda_number":"*53","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"***ITEM REVISED (SEE ATTACHED MEMO)*** Request to Correct the Name of One Election Voting Precinct (Ordinance S-53063) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1388","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64611,"agenda_number":"55","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Audio Visual (A/V) Services and Live Switching Operator - IFB-24-0206 - Amendment (Ordinance S-52972) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0407","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64503,"agenda_number":"56","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Title Record Search Services Contract - RFQ-26-0186 - Request for Award (Ordinance S-52977) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0579","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64504,"agenda_number":"57","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Purchase of Property and Casualty Insurance Policies for the City of Phoenix (Ordinance S-52990) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0886","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64505,"agenda_number":"58","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Authorization to Grant an Easement to the Arizona Department of Transportation Across City-Owned Property Located at 320 W. Watkins Street (Ordinance S-52991) - District 8","matter_file":"26-0894","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64508,"agenda_number":"61","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Plants, Cacti, Succulents, and Trees - RFQu 23-026 - Amendment (Ordinance S-53001) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1035","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64509,"agenda_number":"62","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Acceptance and Dedication of a Deed and an Easement for Roadway and Sidewalk Purposes (Ordinance S-53008) - Districts 2 & 4","matter_file":"26-1075","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64518,"agenda_number":"63","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Acceptance and Dedication of a Deed and an Easement for Roadway and Public Utility Purposes (Ordinance S-53041) - Districts 4 & 8","matter_file":"26-1245","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64510,"agenda_number":"64","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Acceptance of an Easement for Sewer Purposes (Ordinance S-53009) - District 3","matter_file":"26-1076","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64512,"agenda_number":"*65","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"***ITEM REVISED (SEE ATTACHED MEMO)*** Acceptance of Easements for Water and Sewer Purposes (Ordinance S-53028) - Districts 3 & 8","matter_file":"26-1144","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64615,"agenda_number":"66","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Dedication of an Easement for Sidewalk Purposes Within City-Owned Property Located at 2526 W. Northern Avenue - (Ordinance S-52987) - District 5","matter_file":"26-0871","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64511,"agenda_number":"67","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Playgrounds, Splash Pads, Outdoor Fitness, and Related Equipment - Contract - COOP 26-0072 Request for Award (Ordinance S-53014) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1123","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64513,"agenda_number":"68","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Armored Car Services (Citywide) - RFP 21-097 - Amendment (Ordinance S-53020) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1147","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64514,"agenda_number":"69","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Emergency Response Services and Disaster Recovery - COOP-26-0084 - Request for Award (Ordinance S-53021) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1149","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64515,"agenda_number":"70","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Hazardous Detection Equipment, Accessories and Preventive Maintenance Services Contract - IFB-26-0111 - Request for Award (Ordinance S-53025) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1161","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64516,"agenda_number":"71","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Decorative Pavement Maintenance Contract - RFA-26-0307 - Request for Award (Ordinance S-53035) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1209","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64517,"agenda_number":"72","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Legal Processing, Notary, and Related Services Contract - COOP 26-0051 - Request for Award (Ordinance S-53039) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1228","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64519,"agenda_number":"73","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Communication Tower Inspection, Maintenance, and Repair - IFB 18-112 - Amendment (Ordinance S-53051) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1271","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64521,"agenda_number":"74","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Amend Ordinance S-46390 for Issuance of Excise Tax-Funded Obligations to Include Short-Term and Long-Term Financing and Refunding of Short-Term and Long-Term Obligations (Ordinance S-53054) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1309","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64522,"agenda_number":"75","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Buy-Up Voluntary Vision Plan - RFP HR 20-108 - Amendment (Ordinance S-52965) - Citywide","matter_file":"25-2557","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64523,"agenda_number":"76","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Online Training Authoring Licenses - EXC-HR-21-026 - Amendment (Ordinance S-53004) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1050","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64524,"agenda_number":"77","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"FMLA and PPL Administration Service Contract - RFP PS-26-0173 - Request for Award (Ordinance S-53005) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1051","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64525,"agenda_number":"78","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Repeal Existing Combined Ordinance for Classification Plan and Pay Plan with Pay Rates and Compensation S-51144 and Adopt a New Combined Ordinance for a Classification Plan and Pay Plan with Pay Rates and Compensation (Ordinance S-53059) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1344","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64526,"agenda_number":"79","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Amendments to the City's Combined Classification and Pay Ordinance (S-51144) in Accordance with Human Resources Committee (HRC) 2026-013 Recommendations (Ordinance S-53061) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1375","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64530,"agenda_number":"82","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Technology Agreement for the Regional Wireless Cooperative Network Contract - EXC 23-122 - Amendment (Ordinance S-52986) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0841","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64531,"agenda_number":"83","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Gila River Indian Community 2026 Gaming Grants (Ordinance S-53000) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1033","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64532,"agenda_number":"84","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Fort McDowell Yavapai Nation 2026 Gaming Grants (Ordinance S-53006) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1053","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64533,"agenda_number":"85","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Ak-Chin Indian Community 2026 Gaming Grants (Ordinance S-53007) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1055","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64534,"agenda_number":"86","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Fiscal Year 2026-27 Legal Representation Services Contracts (Ordinance S-53062) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1386","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64535,"agenda_number":"87","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Transfer of Retirement Funds to Arizona State Retirement System (Ordinance S-53019) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1146","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64537,"agenda_number":"88","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Authorization to Apply for, Accept, and Implement a U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development Resident Opportunities and Self Sufficiency Family Self Sufficiency Service Coordinator Grant (Ordinance S-52973) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0434","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64539,"agenda_number":"90","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Additional Funding for Choice Neighborhoods Housing Developments (Ordinance S-53034) - District 8","matter_file":"26-1207","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64540,"agenda_number":"91","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Approval to Submit Housing and Urban Development, Section 18 Disposition Application (Ordinance S-53036) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1214","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64618,"agenda_number":"92","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Administrative Services for Housing Preservation Projects- Contract RFA FY26-086-14 - Request for Award (Ordinance S-53056) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1317","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64617,"agenda_number":"93","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Authorization to Amend Lease Agreement 129426 Located at 1220 and 1224 S. 7th Avenue With Buckeye and 7th Avenue, LLC to Extend Term - (Ordinance S-53017) - District 8","matter_file":"26-1141","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64541,"agenda_number":"94","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Request Retroactive Authorization to Apply for, Accept and Enter Into an Agreement for 2026 Child and Family Advocacy Center Grant Funds (Ordinance S-53022) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1153","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64543,"agenda_number":"*96","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"***REQUEST TO WITHDRAW (SEE ATTACHED MEMO)*** Acquisition of Improved Real Property Located at 1746 W. Fillmore Street (Ordinance S-53032) - District 7","matter_file":"26-1202","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"withdrawn","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64544,"agenda_number":"97","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Request for Proposals for Head Start Birth to Five Classroom Behavior and Education Coaching Services (Ordinance S-53053) - Council Districts 1, 3, 4, 5, 7 & 8","matter_file":"26-1298","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64536,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"COMMUNITY SERVICES","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64546,"agenda_number":"98","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Thomas Klise/Crimson Multimedia Contract - RFA-26-0150 - Request for Award (Ordinance S-52971) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0102","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64547,"agenda_number":"99","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Chinese Language Materials Contract - RFA 26-0301 Request for Award (Ordinance S-52993) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0950","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64548,"agenda_number":"100","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Spanish Language Materials Contract - RFA 26-0296 Request for Award (Ordinance S-52994) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0951","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64550,"agenda_number":"102","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Environmental Review Consulting Services - RFQu-24-003 - Amendment (Ordinance S-53024) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1157","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64551,"agenda_number":"103","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Event Equipment Rental Services - PKS-IFB-26-0175 Amendment (Ordinance S-52974) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0503","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64552,"agenda_number":"104","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Parks and Recreation Event-Related Services - PKS-RFQu-26-0119 - Amendment (Ordinance S-53028) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1191","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64553,"agenda_number":"105","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Recreation Management Equipment Upgrades - Amendment (Ordinance S-53048) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1264","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64555,"agenda_number":"107","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"19th Avenue and Montebello Avenue - Authorization to Issue Disposition and Redevelopment Solicitation - District 4","matter_file":"26-1301","matter_type":"Formal Action","action":"approved","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64556,"agenda_number":"108","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Greater Phoenix Economic Council - Authorization to Add Funding (Ordinance S-53013) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1121","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64557,"agenda_number":"109","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Western Maricopa Coalition Dues for Fiscal Years 2026-2029 (Ordinance S-53027) - Districts 1, 4, 5, 7 & 8","matter_file":"26-1176","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64558,"agenda_number":"110","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Amend Ordinance S-47581 and Development Agreement (City Contract 157059) with Laveen Baseline LLC (Ordinance S-53031) - Districts 7 & 8","matter_file":"26-1201","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64560,"agenda_number":"112","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Test, Inspection and Repair of Fire Suppression and Pre-Action Systems Contract - IFB-24-0285 - Amendment (Ordinance S-52998) - District 7 & 8","matter_file":"26-1013","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64562,"agenda_number":"113","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Acquisition of Real Property for Fire Station 51 Located Southeast of W. Dove Valley Road and N. 43rd Avenue (Ordinance S-52984) - District 1","matter_file":"26-0834","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64563,"agenda_number":"114","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Occupational Medicine Health Staffing and Electronic Health Records Management RFP PS-26-0128 - Request for Award (Ordinance S-53003) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1043","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64564,"agenda_number":"115","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Fitness Equipment with Related Accessories and Services - COOP 26-0254 (Ordinance S-53010) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1083","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64565,"agenda_number":"116","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Back-Up Ambulance Services Agreements (Ordinance S-53033) - Out of City","matter_file":"26-1203","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64566,"agenda_number":"117","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Fire Department Health Services Agreements (Ordinance S-53043) - District 8","matter_file":"26-1257","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64567,"agenda_number":"118","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Fire Service Training Agreements (Ordinance S-53044) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1258","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64568,"agenda_number":"119","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Adopt Fire Department Computer Aided Dispatch Service Fees and Charges for Fiscal Year 2026-27 (Ordinance S-53047) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1263","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64569,"agenda_number":"120","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Enter Into an Agreement with Maricopa County Department of Public Health to Provide Seasonal Influenza Vaccines (Ordinance S-53049) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1265","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64554,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64570,"agenda_number":"121","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Request to Apply for and Accept Federal Fiscal Year 2025 Assistance to Firefighters Grant Program Funds (Ordinance S-53055) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1314","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64571,"agenda_number":"122","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Fire Department Mutual Aid Agreement (Ordinance S-53057) - Out Of City","matter_file":"26-1330","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64572,"agenda_number":"123","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Alco-Sensor Equipment, Parts, and Supplies Contract - IFB-26-0123 Request for Award (Ordinance S-52979) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0667","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64574,"agenda_number":"125","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Versadex Maintenance and Support - Police CAD/911 System - RFP08-0603 - Amendment (Ordinance S-52982) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0741","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64575,"agenda_number":"126","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"TLOxp Online Investigative Services Contract - EXC 23-120 - Amendment (Ordinance S-52989) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0878","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64576,"agenda_number":"127","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"State Fair Towing Services Contract - IFB-26-0294 - Request for Award (Ordinance S-53011) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1087","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64580,"agenda_number":"130","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Amend Facility Lease Agreement 164739 with AGI Ground, Inc., at Phoenix Sky Harbor International Airport (Ordinance S-53037) - District 8","matter_file":"26-1217","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64561,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"PUBLIC SAFETY","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64581,"agenda_number":"131","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Amend Unsubordinated Ground Lease 153414-Lease-001 with United Parcel Service, Inc. at Phoenix Sky Harbor International Airport (Ordinance S-53038) - District 8","matter_file":"26-1219","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64582,"agenda_number":"132","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Automated Vehicle Identification System - Hardware Maintenance - RFA 24-0321 - Amendment (Ordinance S-53040) - District 8","matter_file":"26-1232","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64584,"agenda_number":"134","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Transit Scheduling and Dispatch Software Upgrade and Maintenance Agreement Extension (Ordinance S-52988) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0877","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64586,"agenda_number":"136","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Parking Services for Public Transit Department Building (Ordinance S-53045) - District 7","matter_file":"26-1259","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64587,"agenda_number":"137","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Accessible Mobility Vehicles and Vehicle Conversion Services CO-OP BPM007074 - Request for Award (Ordinance S-53050) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1270","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64588,"agenda_number":"138","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Custodial Services Contract - RFP 25-FMD-007 - Amendment (Ordinance S-52992) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0896","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64589,"agenda_number":"139","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Energy Management Control Systems (EMCS) New Installations and Upgrades, RFA 27-FMD-012 - Request for Award (Ordinance S-53002) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1036","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64592,"agenda_number":"140","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Intergovernmental Agreement with the City of Glendale for Streetlights on Camelback Road between 73rd and 75th Avenue (Ordinance S-52978) - District 5","matter_file":"26-0598","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64593,"agenda_number":"141","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Salt River Project Distribution Design and Construction Contract - ST87500061 (Ordinance S-53029) - District 8","matter_file":"26-1193","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64594,"agenda_number":"142","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Intergovernmental Agreement between Maricopa County and the City of Phoenix for a Traffic Signal at 91st Avenue and Broadway Road (Ordinance S-53046) - District 7","matter_file":"26-1260","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64595,"agenda_number":"143","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Name Change Amendment on Citywide General Construction Job Order Contracting Services - 4108JOC209 (Ordinance S-53060) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1373","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64596,"agenda_number":"144","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Industrial Automation Training Contract - RFA-26-0108 Request for Award (Ordinance S-52966) - Citywide","matter_file":"25-2590","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64612,"agenda_number":"145","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Sweetwater Avenue Sewer Relief - Design-Bid-Build Services - WS90500317 (Ordinance S-52975) - District 3","matter_file":"26-0510","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64613,"agenda_number":"146","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Water Services Department Wastewater Infrastructure Improvements Engineering On-Call Services (Ordinance S-52976) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0512","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64614,"agenda_number":"147","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Lift Station 43 Force Main Rehabilitation - Construction Manager at Risk Services Amendment - WS90501000 (Ordinance S-52980) - District 7","matter_file":"26-0674","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64597,"agenda_number":"148","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Flow Meters - New, Replacement Parts, and Services - IFB-2122-WWT-355 - Amendment (Ordinance S-52985) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0835","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64598,"agenda_number":"149","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"SmartCover Systems - Amendment (Ordinance S-52995) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0984","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64599,"agenda_number":"150","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Repair and Replacement of Meter Vaults Contract - IFB-26-0283 Request for Award (Ordinance S-53042) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1255","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64579,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"TRANSPORTATION AND INFRASTRUCTURE","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64620,"agenda_number":"151","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Customer Flow Management System Contract - RFA-26-0147 Request for Award (Ordinance S-52996) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1004","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64621,"agenda_number":"*154","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"***REQUEST TO ADD-ON (SEE ATTACHED MEMO)*** Recommended New Name for Library in Laveen - District 8","matter_file":"26-1387","matter_type":"Formal Action","action":"approved","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64470,"agenda_number":"44","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Public Hearing on Proposed Property Tax Levy, Truth in Taxation and Adoption of the Final 2026-27 Annual Budget - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0059","matter_type":"Public Hearing (Non-Zoning)","action":"hearing held","passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\nMayor Gallego stated this was a public hearing on adoption of the proposed Property Tax Levy, Truth in Taxation and final 2026-27 Annual Budget.\n\nMayor Gallego declared the public hearing open. Noting there were no citizens wishing to comment, Mayor Gallego closed the public hearing.\n\nMayor Gallego thanked everyone who participated in the City's budget process as well as the many public hearings.","votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64494,"agenda_number":"45","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Convening of Special Meeting of the City Council - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0060","matter_type":"Formal Action","action":"approved","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\nMayor Gallego stated this item convened a special meeting to consider adoption of the 2026-27 budget.\n\nA motion was made by Vice Mayor Hodge Washington seconded by Councilwoman O'Brien, as appears below.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64497,"agenda_number":"46","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Adoption of the Final 2026-27 Operating Funds Budget (Ordinance S-52969) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0061","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\nMayor Gallego introduced this item.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington made a motion to approve Item 46. Councilwoman O'Brien seconded the motion.\n\nCouncilman Waring stated his support for the budget. He noted the budget for Fiscal Year (FY) 2007-08 adjusted for inflation, the per capita spending per citizen was $1,268 and in the current proposed budget, the per capita spending was at $1,222 per citizen. Councilman Waring asked if it was correct that after 20 years and adjusted by inflation, the budget has actually gone down per resident.\n\nCity Manager Ed Zuercher answered yes. He confirmed if adjusted for inflation from 2008 to now, the numbers were correct.\n\nCouncilman Waring stated he appreciated the fact that spending per citizen has actually declined and assumed this decline was likely due to the adoption of new technologies which reduced the need for as many employees. In addition, he compared the percentage of the City’s general fund operating budget that was allocated to public safety in past years versus the current budget. Councilman Waring noted that in FY 2007-08, public safety corresponded to 59 percent of the general fund, and in the current budget 63 percent was allocated to public safety. He opined that even though spending per capita has gone down, the share of the budget devoted to public safety has increased. Councilman Waring asked whether his interpretation was correct.\n\nMr. Zuercher answered yes, the numbers were correct for the general fund budget. He explained the increase in the share of the budget going to public safety was partly due to the Council expanding the Fire Department to meet growing demand as well as the rising police and fire pension costs. They agree that the figures discussed match their understanding.\n\nCouncilman Waring reported in FY 2007-08, 38 percent of the City's workforce was public safety and in the proposed budget that percentage was now 44 percent, which meant a higher percentage of City employees were now more concentraded in Police and Fire than in the past.\n\nMr. Zuercher confirmed that was correct. He stated Council's expansion of the Fire Department to meet growing demand for emergency services, and also an increase in civilian positions in the Police Department accounted for that.\n\nCouncilman Waring noted the share of public safety employees has increased and was now at a high point, 44 percent year over year. He highlight this as information citizens might find useful and thank Mr. Zuercher and staff for their work.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64499,"agenda_number":"47","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Adoption of the Final 2026-27 Capital Funds Budget (Ordinance S-53015) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1128","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\nMayor Gallego introduced this item.\n\nA motion was made by Vice Mayor Hodge Washington seconded by Councilwoman O'Brien, as appears below.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64498,"agenda_number":"48","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Adoption of the Final 2026-27 Reappropriated Funds Budget (Ordinance S-52970) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0062","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\nMayor Gallego introduced this item.\n\nA motion was made by Vice Mayor Hodge Washington seconded by Councilwoman O'Brien, as appears below.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":65019,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":"approved","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\nFollowing the vote, Mayor Gallego declared the special City Council meeting was concluded and reconvened the regular City Council meeting. She opined it was remarkable such a diverse City Council unanimously approved the budget and she emphasized it addressed a wide range of community needs. Mayor Gallego remarked Items 49-51 were legally required amendments to the current 2025-26 operating, capital and reappropriated funds budget, to close out the City's current fiscal year's budgetary accounts and start the annual independent audit.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64495,"agenda_number":"49","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Amend Ordinance S-52048 Adopting the 2025-26 Annual Budget for Operating Funds (Ordinance S-52967) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0057","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\nMayor Gallego introduced this item.\n\nA motion was made by Vice Mayor Hodge Washington seconded by Councilwoman O'Brien, as appears below.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64500,"agenda_number":"50","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Amend Ordinance S-52074 Adopting the 2025-26 Capital Funds Budget (Ordinance S-53016) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1129","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\nMayor Gallego introduced this item.\n\nA motion was made by Vice Mayor Hodge Washington seconded by Councilwoman O'Brien, as appears below.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64496,"agenda_number":"51","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Amend Ordinance S-52049 Adopting the 2025-26 Final Reappropriation Budget (Ordinance S-52968) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0058","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\nMayor Gallego introduced this item.\n\nA motion was made by Vice Mayor Hodge Washington seconded by Councilwoman O'Brien, as appears below.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64502,"agenda_number":"54","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Request to Amend City Code - Chapter 8 Animals - Section 8-3.08 (Ordinance G-7524) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1384","matter_type":"Ordinance-G","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\nMayor Gallego asked City Clerk to read the title of this item.\n\nCity Clerk Denise Archibald read the title of Ordinance G-7524.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington made a motion to approve Item 54. Councilwoman Pastor seconded the motion.\n\nMayor Gallego announced many Councilmembers have been working on this item.\n\nKoco Garcia, founder of Hand Over Rover, spoke in support of this item.\n\nDon Bentley, with Poverty Pets, spoke in support of this item.\n\nBarbara Brackett, volunteer with Poverty Pets, spoke in support of this item.\n\nMario Barajas interpreting for Ernestina Briseno, a volunteer with Poverty Pets who spoke in Spanish, spoke in support of this item.\n\nSherri Hoffmann, Poverty Pets volunteer and board member, spoke in support of this item.\n\nBill Ross, Poverty Pets board member, spoke in support of this item.\n\nKate Sivolella, founder of Poverty Pets, spoke in support of this item.\n\nLisa Spragens, volunteer with Hand Over Rover, spoke in support of this item.\n\nCouncilwoman Pastor described years long efforts to advance a tethering ordinance, driven by reminders from a constituent, Kate, and inspired by the late Michael Peterson, who pushed for action and organized the legal work. She thanked Poverty Pets, colleagues, legal staff, public safety, and Councilman Robinson for helping move the ordinance through the Public Safety and Justice Subcommittee. Councilwoman Pastor emphasized that updating this ordinance required collective commitment and expressed it was ready to be finalized.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge thanked Mayor Gallego, Council Members, staff and advocacy groups for advancing clear, commonsense animal welfare updates and emphasized the importance of humane treatment, continued community education, and strong partnerships.\n\nCouncilwoman Guardado thanked everyone who spoke on this item today as well as the work staff has put on this ordinance. She opined this item was very important to her and noted that a new dog park was coming to El Oso Park and emphasized the importance to continue to create these types of spaces. Councilwoman Guardado expressed she was grateful to support and vote for the ordinance.\n\nCouncilman Waring recalled a recent meeting with advocates on this matter that stood out for their professionalism, respectful tone, and collaborative spirit. He note he was already supportive of the ordinance but genuinely appreciated how the group conducted the meeting and compliment the diverse group’s collegial approach, emphasized how rare such meetings could be, and express gratitude for the way the advocates engaged with them.\n\nCouncilwoman Hernandez expressed support for the City’s efforts to better protect dogs, and noted dog abuse can take many forms, from being improperly tethered to extreme incidents of harm. She referenced a recent tragic case and urged Council to also consider protections for K-9 units and emphasized the need to end all forms of dog abuse. Councilwoman Hernandez stated her support for this item.\n\nMayor Gallego reflected on former Councilmember Telda Williams and noted the updates to the ordinance built on work she championed around 2016. She remember her as a dedicated public servant and animal lover, acknowledged her upcoming birthday, and honored the legacy she left for the City.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64506,"agenda_number":"59","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Authorization to Adopt Public Safety Personnel Retirement System Pension Funding Policy (Ordinance S-52997) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1012","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\nMayor Gallego introduced this item.\n\nA motion was made by Vice Mayor Hodge Washington seconded by Councilwoman O'Brien as appears below.\n\nMayor Gallego noted Councilman Robinson had declared a conflict of interest on this item and would not participate or vote.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Conflict"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64507,"agenda_number":"60","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Authorization to Adopt City of Phoenix Employee Retirement System Pension Funding Policy (Ordinance S-52999) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1014","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\nMayor Gallego introduced this item.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington made a motion to approve this Item per staff recommendation and adopt the Annual COPERS Pension Funding Policy and acknowledge the assets and liabilities of the COPERS Plan. Councilwoman O'Brien seconded the motion.\n\nMayor Gallego noted Councilwoman Stark had declared a conflict of interest on this item and would not participate or vote.\n\nCouncilman Waring noted that in 2019-2020 COPERS unfunded pension liability was about $1.8 billion, and it has since decreased to roughly $1.3 billion. Councilman Waring asked for confirmation that by around 2038-2039 the plan was expected to have no unfunded liability.\n\nNOTE: Councilwoman Pastor temporarily left the voting body.\n\nCity Manager Ed Zuercher answered yes, that was correct.\n\nCouncilman Waring praised the major progress in reducing COPERS’ pension liability, noting the voter-approved changes from 2013 have clearly worked and credited both Phoenix residents and City staff for the results. He highlighted this strong trajectory is uncommon nationally, and reaffirmed the City was managing the pension system well. Councilman Waring commended the team for their excellent work.\n\nMr. Zuercher thanked Councilman Waring for his comments and recognized the hard work of staff, especially in the Finance and Budget departments. He noted voter approval measures and a series of Council adopted policies have been highly effective. Mr. Zuercher highlighted Phoenix’s retirement system went from being one of the lowest funded city pensions 15 years ago to one of the 15 best funded among large U.S. cities today.\n\nMayor Gallego thanked Councilman Waring and noted this was a good recognition for the finance team.\n\nNOTE: Councilwoman Pastor returned to the voting body.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Conflict"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64527,"agenda_number":"80","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Request Seeking Council Authorization to Exceed the 8-Hour Rule to Research and Develop Options for Minimum Wage - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0118","matter_type":"Formal Action","action":"approved","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\nMayor Gallego Introduced this item.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington made a motion to approve Item 80. Councilwoman Guardado seconded the motion.\n\nNicole Ray spoke in support of this item.\n\nJanae Van de Kerk in support of this item.\n\nMayor Gallego reported there were two related votes but she would make one comment for both.\n\nMayor Gallego explained when she first became mayor, the City raised the minimum wage for Phoenix employees to $15 an hour with unanimous council support and since then, the state minimum wage has surpassed $15, and rising costs meant the City must revisit its wage policies to ensure employees earn a fair, livable wage. She said the vote today directs staff to study how wages are keeping up, explore options to address any gaps, and it also initiates research on how to retain workers when contractors at City facilities change, an issue that has arisen recently. Mayor Gallego noted the process would include broad stakeholder involvement, and invited community ideas and participation.\n\nCouncilwoman Guardado thanked City leadership and workers, especially those at Sky Harbor, for their daily contributions. She supported studying options to improve wages and job stability as living costs rise, and noted some contracted airport workers were experiencing homelessness despite working full-time. Councilwoman Guardado explained this item did not set new wages immediately but began an analysis of compensation, fiscal impacts, and ways to retain workers when vendor contracts change. She emphasized that no one working to keep the City running should face homelessness and encouraged continued collaboration to support workers and maintain stability across City facilities.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington thanked colleagues for bringing the item forward and noted Phoenix has improved workforce recruitment and retention but rising living costs still strained families. She stated the request would let staff analyze current compensation, possible options, fiscal impacts, and how pay affects stability and hiring, while ensuring any updates remain financially sustainable. Vice Mayor Hodge Washington said event though It did not set policy now, the purpose was to gather information, understand legal considerations, and assess potential effects on employees, contractors, and City operations and she looked forward to reviewing the findings.\n\nCouncilwoman Hernandez thanked the speakers who shared personal stories and stressed that retention mattered because turnover was costly for the City. She supported analyzing compensation and workforce stability as an investment in reducing poverty and helping workers thrive. Councilwoman Hernandez stated her appreciation for everyone involved in moving the effort forward.\n\nCouncilwoman Pastor thanked airport workers and those who have repeatedly shared their concerns. She urge for continued research on wages, opined it would show that some City and airport employees were living in poverty and needed higher pay. Councilwoman Pastor credit her colleagues for their leading efforts to support worker compensation and rights, and expressed appreciation for everyone involved.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64528,"agenda_number":"81","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Request Seeking Council Authorization to Exceed the 8-Hour Rule to Research and Develop a Potential Worker Retention Policy - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1432","matter_type":"Formal Action","action":"approved","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\nMayor Gallego Introduced this item.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington made a motion to approve Item 81. Councilwoman Guardado seconded the motion.\n\nLucia Salinas Aleman stated she was a union leader and spoke in support of this item.\n\nSophia Marjanovic spoke in support of this item.\n\nAnselm Huggins spoke in support of this item.\n\nMario Barajas, interpreting for Martha Hernandez-Martell, spoke in support of this item.\n\nDari/ Reza , personal translator for Mohammad Haidari, spoke in support of this item.\n\nCouncilwoman Guardado thanked the workers who provided testimony and acknowledged the diversity across airport and City workplaces. She emphasized the importance of worker retention and shared her own experience of nearly losing a job when retention rules were not respected. Councilman Guardado assured Council was committed to finding solutions that support everyone, noted past issues and ongoing challenges in unprecedented times. She expressed gratitude to City management for evaluating options and bringing recommendations to the Council.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington reported this item closely related to the discussion on the previous item. She noted many local governments were examining ways to reduce disruption when city service contracts shifted between vendors, since workers could face uncertainty even when their jobs continued. Vice Mayor Hodge Washington stated the goal today was not to create policy but to understand available options, considerations, and potential impacts on the workers who supported City services and facilities. She stated it was appropriate for the Council to request staff research and return with factual information, best practices, and legal guidance. Vice Mayor Hodge Washington thanked all involved and expressed interest in continued conversations.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64538,"agenda_number":"89","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Funding for The Moreland Phase II Affordable Housing Development (Ordinance S-53026) - District 8","matter_file":"26-1162","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\nMayor Gallego introduced this item.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington made a motion to approve Item 89. Councilwoman O'Brien seconded the motion.\n\nNOTE: Councilwoman Guardado temporarily left the voting body during discussion of Item 89.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington conveyed her comments were related to items 89, 90, and 91, even though items 90-91 had already been approved. She noted items 89 and 90 made significant investments in expanding affordable and workforce housing in District 8 and throughout Phoenix; Item 90, the Moreland redevelopment, would create 105 new affordable units, with 80 percent dedicated to seniors and approximately 27 workforce housing units; the projects leveraged federal resources, tax credits, vouchers, and public-private partnerships to limit impact on the City’s general fund. She noted Item 92 supported the Edison Eastlake Choice Neighborhood Initiative, a major redevelopment effort integrating housing, transportation, economic opportunity, and long term neighborhood improvements, and the added funding would help produce 475 mixed-income units, contributing to a larger plan of more than a thousand units. In addition, Vice Mayor Hodge Washington stated Item 91 authorized staff to seek federal approval to convert 57 single-family housing sites into affordable, for sale homes, with half designated for owner occupants, allowing some public housing residents to become homeowners. She said together, these efforts strengthened partnerships and made meaningful progress on the City’s housing challenges and she thanked City staff, residents, and community partners for their ongoing commitment.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64542,"agenda_number":"95","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Authorization to Enter Into Contract with The Arizona Community Action Association dba Wildfire (Ordinance S-53023) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1154","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\nMayor Gallego introduced this item.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington made a motion to approve Item 95. Councilwoman O'Brien seconded the motion.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington expressed support for this item, which provided emergency financial assistance to about 2,000 low-income Phoenix households to help them stay current on utility bills. She reported funding combined federal and program resources and was crucial as many families continue to face financial hardship and noted a recent call from a resident seeking utility aid underscored the ongoing need. Vice Mayor Hodge Washington thanked City staff and partners for delivering this support effectively.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Absent"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64549,"agenda_number":"101","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Annual Review and Updates to the Neighborhood Services Department's Code Enforcement Policy - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1346","matter_type":"Formal Action","action":"approved","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\nMayor Gallego introduced this item.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington made a motion to approve Item 101. Councilwoman O'Brien seconded the motion.\n\nCouncilwoman Hernandez asked what were the criteria that established the need for the Police Department (PD) to be involved in the enforcement of a violation.\n\nNeighborhood Services Director Spencer Self explained the Neighborhood Services Department (NSD) collaborated with PD when complaints fell outside of the code enforcement authority or when issues involved multiple departments, especially in the City's community safety plan areas. He stated they coordinated with PD on nuisance properties, served administrative warrants, assisted with inspections or abatement, and requested police support when staff safety was at risk.\n\nCouncilwoman Hernandez thanked Mr. Spencer for the clarification and explained she could not support the proposed changes as she still had concerns about consecutive citations, the director’s enforcement authority, and the broad criteria that would allow NSD to over-police residents. She noted her uneasiness that NSD could become overly enforcement focused and wanted more emphasis on education rather than punishment. She committed to continuing collaboration to ensure enforcement was balanced and community centered.\n\nNOTE: Councilwoman Guardado returned to the voting body.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"No"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64619,"agenda_number":"106","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Authorization to Accept 10 Acres of Vacant Land From CACH Holdings, LLC, and to Designate as Mountain Preserve (Ordinance S-53064) - District 6","matter_file":"26-1423","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\n\nMayor Gallego introduced this item.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington made a motion to approve Item 106. Councilwoman O'Brien seconded the motion.\n\nMayor Gallego thanked Councilman Robinson and the Parks and Recreation Department for their work on expanding Phoenix’s preserve system. She noted Arizonans widely value open space and highlighted Phoenix’s commitment to preserving its mountain landscapes. Mayor Gallego stated since 2020, the City has added more than 2,400 acres to the preserve lands, including new acreage for South Mountain Park and Preserve, one of the largest city managed parks in the country. She praised the City’s choice to protect natural landscapes and expressed strong support for the item.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64559,"agenda_number":"111","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"An Ordinance Amending Phoenix City Code Chapter 10A Regarding Mutual Indemnification Provisions for Certain Facility Use Agreements - Phoenix Convention Center (Ordinance G-7523) - Citywide","matter_file":"25-2640","matter_type":"Ordinance-G","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\nMayor Gallego asked City Clerk to read the title of this item.\n\nCity Clerk Denise Archibald read the title of Ordinance G-7523.\n\nA motion was made by Vice Mayor Hodge Washington seconded by Councilwoman O'Brien, as appears below.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64573,"agenda_number":"124","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"NVLS (LEARN) Database Subscription Services - RFA 18-011 - Amendment (Ordinance S-52981) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0724","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\nMayor Gallego introduced this item.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington made a motion to approve Item 124. Councilwoman O'Brien seconded the motion.\n\nCouncilwoman Hernandez cited recent articles about misuse of license plate readers in other states, where officers used the technology for improper surveillance, including stalking. She stressed such abuse was unacceptable and asked what safeguards and parameters existed in Phoenix to prevent similar misuse of the system.\n\nAssistant Police Chief Brian Lee answered the Police Department (PD) had strict policies that govern the use of computer systems, including license plate readers. He explained that every search created a City record that could be audited for misuse and supervisors conducted regular reviews that would flag suspicious activity, such as repeatedly running the same plate. Assistant Police Chief Lee stated misuse would result in discipline, loss of certification access, or termination and PD aligned its policy with existing operations orders to prevent abuse like the cases reported in recent articles.\n\nCouncilwoman Hernandez questioned who would have access to the data collected by license plate readers and asked for clarification on the audit frequency.\n\nAssistant Police Chief Lee answered the audit process for license plate reader use was established in late 2025 and after a test audit in December, the City began quarterly audits starting in early 2026. He stated the first quarter audit was completed, the second was scheduled for the end of June, and noted these audits were conducted in coordination with the City Audit Department.\n\nCouncilwoman Hernandez asked if audits uncovered any discrepancies, would officers received additional training to prevent any improper or unnecessary access to the system.\n\nAssistant Police Chief Lee answered yes, and explained PD audited about 10 percent of all license plate reader queries, which was far above the national standard of roughly three percent. He stated in the last quarter, about 25,000 queries were run, and 10 percent of those were reviewed. He said if audits identified suspicious activity, PD would use internal discipline processes and determine whether additional training was needed to ensure proper system use.\n\nCouncilwoman Hernandez referenced one of the articles described license plate readers equipped with add-on sensors that could capture personal devices and link them to specific vehicles, which she found highly concerning. She asked for clarification on whether Phoenix’s system included any such expanded surveillance features as she wanted to assurance these add-ons were not part of the City’s license plate reader program.\n\nAssistant Police Chief Lee reported he was unfamiliar with the article but assured Phoenix used Motorola's camera only license plate readers and not systems with enhanced surveillance add-ons. He stated PD had no additional technologies installed, and any future expansion would require Council approval.\n\nCouncilwoman Hernandez noted she would share the article so the team could review it and understand what other cites were doing. She expressed relief those surveillance practices were not being utilized in Phoenix.\n\nCouncilwoman Hernandez stated she would vote no on the license plate reader item because privacy and First Amendment concerns still outweigh any benefits. She restated her unease regarding potential misuse and noted she may reconsider in the future if stronger protections were implemented.\n\nCouncilwoman Guardado stated she strongly supported license plate readers, and asked for a few success stories demonstrating how the technology has helped, especially with challenges along 27th Avenue.\n\nAssistant Police Chief Lee stated PD was seeing an unusually high number of daily successes using its real-time operations centers in the Desert Horizon and Cactus Park precincts. He said this technology currently supported patrol work and may be expanded Citywide. Assistant Police Chief Lee spoke about a recent example that occurred on June 2, when a teen was killed in a shooting at Desert Sky Mall, investigators immediately used nearby cameras and information from witnesses to identify the suspect’s vehicle. He said networked license plate readers quickly located the vehicle, giving investigators critical early leads, and although the case remained active, investigators say technology like this was essential for developing the first investigative steps and follow-up work.\n\nCouncilwoman Guardado reflected on past public safety issues along 27th Avenue, including drugs, prostitution, and a problematic hotel that was ultimately shut down. She emphasized how essential license plate readers and other technologies have been for improving safety, especially while PD was still building staffing capacity. Councilwoman Guardado stated neighbors have recently reported seeing real improvement, and ongoing efforts, such as the City’s investments in real-time operations centers and statewide progress like HB 2720, were helping address persistent problems. She opined the recent mall incident in her district underscored the continued need for these tools. Councilwoman Guardado stressed the responsibility, as Councilmembers, to protect residents while maintaining privacy safeguards. She expressed gratitude for the work PD has done, and noted that although progress has being made, substantial work remained, particularly on 27th Avenue.\n\nPrior to her vote, Councilwoman Pastor stated license plate readers have been crucial in solving multiple serious incidents along 27th Avenue and Thomas, including two homicides. She emphasized without this technology, identifying what happened and who was responsible would not have been possible, and stressed license plate readers bring significant value to the community and help solve crimes.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"No"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64577,"agenda_number":"128","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Youth Engagement Training Service - RFA-26-0226 Request for Award (Ordinance S-53012) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1115","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\nMayor Gallego introduced this item.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington made a motion to approve Item 128. Councilwoman O'Brien seconded the motion.\n\nCouncilwoman Hernandez raised concerns about the proposed contract for a youth-focused police and noted the vendor’s existing material placed responsibility on teens rather than trained officers. She objected to the lack of community or parental oversight, and to approving this contract without knowing the curriculum's content. She argued this conflicted with the Department of Justice (DOJ) findings that police interactions can traumatize youth and that teens need support and mentorship, not policing.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington asked for an explanation of the process the Police Department (PD) underwent to determine that this training was appropriate and feasible.\n\nAssistant Police Chief Jeff Benza explained PD has been working on this project since 2024, and in the beginning a gap analysis was conducted to identify any area of need. He said the project team identified significant training gaps and conducted a nationwide search and spoke with several other agencies across the country to see what training was available. Assistant Police Chief Benza reported PD selected a vendor whose curriculum was used in 28 states, was certified by a national law enforcement training association, and aimed to help officers reduce escalation, better understand youth behavior and development, and improve interactions with young people.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington explained after doing a quick research into the training program she was surprised to learn how widely it has been adopted, spanning 28 states and used in numerous major cities such as Boston, Los Angeles, San Francisco, Baltimore, Washington DC, Fresno, Cleveland, and Charlottesville. She asked whether there were any available metrics or data showing how successful the program has been in those municipalities.\n\nAssistant Police Chief Benza answered he had reached out to several agencies about how the training worked in their departments. He stated the Baltimore Police Department reported a significant reduction in use-of-force incidents involving youth; Salt Lake City’s School Resource Officer (SRO) Chief indicated the program corresponded with fewer arrests in their school districts; Madison, Alabama, Police Chief Gandhi, said he first experienced the training as a captain in Virginia Beach and found it so effective there that he implemented it in his own department, where it has greatly helped reduce incidents and improved officers’ ability to de-escalate interactions with youth. Assistant Police Chief Benza noted even though he had spoken with those agencies, he did not have formal data from those agencies.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington asked what specific metrics the PD would use to evaluate the program’s effectiveness if it was approved, and how the department would determine whether the training was successful.\n\nAssistant Police Chief Benza answered PD would evaluate the program by monitoring several existing metrics, including officer initiated contacts, stops, searches, arrests, use-of-force incidents, and overall youth arrest numbers. He explained PD would be looking for changes, whether those numbers rise or fall, as indicators of the program’s impact, and noted the vendor’s presentation suggested the training would give officers new tools and a better understanding of youth behavior, helping them de-escalate situations more effectively.\n\nCouncilwoman Guardado acknowledged past issues highlighted in the DOJ investigation were part of the reason why this training was being considered, and while those incidents could not be undone, she appreciated PD's efforts to move forward and strengthen relationships with youth. She noted neither the City nor PD is perfect, and even a single harmful incident involving a young person was one too many. Councilwoman Guardado stated she personally heard positive feedback from counterparts in Los Angeles, and asked how diversity and inclusivity, particularly cultural awareness, would be incorporated into the training curriculum.\n\nDebra Hale, with PD, answered staff has spent several months vetting the vendor to ensure the training was appropriate for Phoenix. She stated the “train the trainer” sessions would be led largely by psychologists, with a major portion devoted to understanding developmental stages of youth, including normative and compromised teen behaviors and why teens are prone to risk taking. Ms. Hale said the program also incorporated community partnerships, encouraging local youth to participate in scenario based training, additionally, juvenile court probation staff, attorneys, and clinical psychologists teach portions of the course, ensuring a broad mix of expertise and community involvement in the final scenario portion of the training.\n\nCouncilwoman Guardado opined she felt more at ease knowing SROs are present in schools to help keep children safe, especially in light of tragedies like those in Texas and elsewhere. She emphasized the importance of protecting youth both in and out of school, and noted that while the City and PD were not perfect, there was a strong commitment, both from the Council and within PD, to accountability. Councilwoman Guardado expressed appreciation for the work being done and offered her support to help local high schools in any way needed. She thanked everyone involved for leading efforts to meet the DOJ’s requirements.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"No"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64600,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"PLANNING AND ZONING MATTERS","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64578,"agenda_number":"129","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Approval to Enter into Agreements with Various Schools and School Districts for School Resource Officer Services (Ordinance S-53058) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1342","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\nMayor Gallego introduced this item.\n\nCouncilwoman Hodge Washington made a motion to approve Item 129. Councilwoman O'Brien seconded the motion.\n\nMayor Gallego noted Councilman Waring had declared a conflict of interest on this item and would not participate or vote.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"No"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Conflict"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64583,"agenda_number":"133","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Annual Operations Funding Agreement with Valley Metro Rail for Operational Costs for Light Rail Services for Fiscal Year 2026-27  (Ordinance S-52983) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0806","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\nMayor Gallego introduced this item.\n\nMayor Gallego reported Item 133 and Item 135 were related items and would be voted together.\n\nA motion was made by Vice Mayor Hodge Washington seconded by Councilwoman O'Brien, as appears below.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"No"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64585,"agenda_number":"135","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Request to Submit Annual Federal Transit Administration Grant Applications and Enter into Grant Agreements (Ordinance S-53030) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-1195","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\nNOTE: Refer to Item 133 for discussion on this item.\n\nA motion was made by Vice Mayor Hodge Washington seconded by Councilwoman O'Brien, as appears below.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"No"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64471,"agenda_number":"152","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Public Hearing - Abandonment Appeal of Hearing Officer Decision - ABND 250049 - 5440 E. Calle Camelia - District 6","matter_file":"26-0968","matter_type":"Public Hearing (Non-Zoning)","action":"approved","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\nMayor Gallego introduced this item.\n\nMayor Gallego opened the public hearing.\n\nMayor Gallego reported following a staff report, the applicant and appellant would each have five minutes to speak.\n\nPlanning and Development Director Joshua Bednarek introduced Planning and Development Assistant Director Mike Baxley.\n\nMr. Baxley provided a brief overview of the request as well as PowerPoint Presentation slides illustrating the location. He stated the applicant requested an alley abandonment between two properties as he asserted it was no longer needed for public use. Mr. Baxley said a neighbor, Kate Mahindra, appealed the approval based on requirements to maintain several utility and access easements, and communicated staff accepted her appeal a day late due to a mistaken assumption about a holiday affecting the deadline. Mr. Baxley presented Council with two options of actions in this case, it could either uphold the hearing officer’s conditional approval or overturn it and deny the abandonment.\n\nJordan Greenman, on behalf of the applicant, asked Council to uphold the hearing officer’s conditional approval of the alley abandonment. He argued that all neighbor concerns to include access, utilities, easements, trash service, and emergency vehicle access, were fully addressed through four stipulations. Mr. Greenman noted the alley was unusually wide, public needs would still be preserved through easements, and no legal error was raised in the appeal. He also said the abandonment would support future ADUs, expand housing options, and the alley would continue to function normally for public use. Mr. Greenman urged Council to affirm the hearing officer’s decision.\n\nKate Melendres, appellant, explained that many neighbors opposed the alley abandonment and signed a petition to keep it public. She argued the alley segment still served important public functions, as it provided the only safe connection for residents to access the neighborhood without walking along busy, sidewalk lacking portions of 56th Street; it supported solidwaste collection and utility access; and it remained an active, regularly used right-of-way. Ms. Melendrea noted the required stipulations themselves showed the alley still had public value, and she raised concerns about enforcing those conditions if the right-of-way was abandoned, and also pointed out overgrown vegetation that already makes access difficult. Ms. Melendrea stated given the public loss versus private benefits to the applicant, and strong neighborhood opposition, she urged Council to overturn the approval and deny the abandonment.\n\nDavid Keen (Ken) spoke in opposition to the alley abandonment.\n\nTom or Annette Keen spoke in opposition to the alley abandonment.\n\nDavid Keen spoke in opposition to the alley abandonment.\n\nMayor Gallego declared the public hearing closed.\n\nCouncilman Robinson asked the applicant to clarify two photos shown in the presentation and noted one image appeared to show the Camellia property under construction, while a more recent City photo showed a finished structure built right up against the alley wall, possibly an accessory dwelling unit (ADU). He reported he had walked the alley himself earlier in the week and saw the completed structure and asked whether the house on East Camellia was currently occupied.\n\nMr. Greenman answered his client lived with his family at the property. He clarified that, if Councilman Robinson’s question was about setbacks, the alley abandonment would allow increased lot coverage and in turn, could enable additional construction on the property, such as building an ADU.\n\nCouncilman Robinson opined it appeared, based on the photos, additional lot coverage may already have been added on the property, possibly through a completed structure near the alley. He emphasized he was simply trying to clarify this because the images suggest the work may have already been done.\n\nMr. Greenman emphasized the only relevant standard was whether the alley was still needed as a public right-of-way, not whether the applicant has built an accessory structure. He then asked the mayor for permission to respond to the appellant’s concerns.\n\nMayor Gallego stated the public hearing had been closed and at this point only Council questions would be heard.\n\nMr. Greenman affirmed his understanding.\n\nCouncilman Robinson stated he was ready to make a motion.\n\nCouncilwoman Hernandez asked Mr. Greenman to respond directly to the appellant's concerns. She noted residents raised significant issues during the public hearing and requested that he addressed them.\n\nMr. Greenman said the hearing officer already addressed the concerns raised by residents through multiple stipulations ensuring the alley remained open for refuse collection, pedestrian access, utilities, and sewer service. He emphasized the alley would continue to look and function as it did now, and enforcement of these easements would remain the City’s responsibility, just as it was today. He concluded by saying the goal was to preserve public access through easements while allowing the property owners the flexibility to build future ADUs.\n\nCouncilwoman Hernandez asked how the applicant would ensure the alley remained open and accessible if the abandonment was approved and noted neighbors relied on it for walking and safe access to the neighborhood. Councilwoman Hernandez sought confirmation the plan was for the alley to stay open for continued community use.\n\nMr. Greenman explained the stipulations were specifically designed to keep the alley open exactly as it was now; the City of Phoenix would hold and enforce the easements permanently, ensuring continued access for pedestrians, utilities, and trash collection. He emphasized the easements never go away, the alley would remain open indefinitely, and the intent was to maintain public access while allowing the homeowners to responsibly manage the area and potentially build ADUs.\n\nMayor Gallego asked if Councilman Robinson was ready to make a motion.\n\nCouncilman Robinson noted many neighbors have voiced concerns and signed petitions opposing the abandonment. He emphasized the alley was still used by multiple utilities, including for trash collection, and reminded everyone the City was not obligated to approve every abandonment request, especially when many affected residents object.\n\nCouncilman Robinson made a motion to approve to overturn the Abandonment Hearing Officer's decision and deny the abandonment request. Councilwoman Pastor seconded the motion.\n\nCouncilwoman Pastor stated the better approach may be to keep the alley public and, if the homeowner wanted to build an ADU, they would need to work with the neighborhood to pursue a variance instead. She noted the hardship argument could be tied to the existing alley configuration.\n\nMayor Gallego commented she was currently dealing with a similar alley abandonment issue elsewhere, where an earlier agreement fell apart after the property was sold. She noted that, although utilities and the City retained access, neighbors often struggled to reach their own sewer or tap lines once an alley was privatized. She stated she wanted this concern on the record.\n\nNine electronic comments were submitted for the record in opposition to the alley abandonment.\n\nPrior to her vote, Councilwoman Hernandez stated she would vote no, as she agreed with staff's recommendation with the stipulations.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"No"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64604,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"REPORTS FROM CITY MANAGER, COMMITTEES OR CITY OFFICIALS","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64622,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"ADD-ON ITEMS","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64590,"agenda_number":"153","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Consideration of a Citizen Petition Submitted by Mr. Gregg Turner - District 3","matter_file":"26-1435","matter_type":"Formal Action","action":"denied","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\nMayor Gallego Introduced this item.\n\nGregg Turner spoke briefly to honor Harriet Diamond, who was killed at 25th Avenue and Greenway. He emphasized her death deserved acknowledgment. Mr. Turner recalled Phoenix’s Vision Zero commitment to traffic safety and highlighted that every traffic death mattered.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington made a motion to approve staff's recommendation and deny the petition. Councilwoman O'Brien seconded the motion.\n\nCouncilwoman Stark suggested honoring the location where Ms. Diamond died by having the family adopt that section of the street through the City’s Adopt-A-Street program, and offered to help them pursue that option.\n\nMayor Gallego opined that would be a really nice way to remember Ms. Diamond.\n\nAn electronic comment was submitted for the record in support of this item.\n\nFollowing her vote, Councilwoman Stark informed Mr. Turner her office would contact him to set this up.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64605,"agenda_number":"000","agenda_number_source":"title-rule","title":"000 CITIZEN COMMENTS","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":"City Attorney Julie Kriegh stated during Citizen Comment, members of the public may address the City Council for up to three minutes on issues of interest or concern to them. She advised the Arizona Open Meeting Law (OML) permits the City Council to listed to the comment, but prohibits council members from discussion or acting on the matter presented.\n\nNOTE: Mayor Gallego temporarily left the voting body.\n\nElizabeth Johnson, with Funds for Empowerment and a resident of the SOS shelter, spoke about the unsanitary conditions and unsafe heat of the shelters' dog area\n\nNOTE: Mayor Gallego returned to the voting body.\n\nRodney Kellen, with Funds for Empowerment, thanked the Council for the working being done to the ADA bathrooms at the SOS shelter.\n\nJerry Van Gasse submitted a citizen petition under the City Charter to request renaming Cesar Chavez Park in honor of Jesse Owens, a Phoenix Resident. He noted the timing with the nation’s 250th anniversary and Owens’ national recognition provided Phoenix a unique chance to honor him.\n\nTim Sirakowski spoke in support of renaming Cesar Chavez Park in honor of Jesse Owens.\n\nChristina Tyler spoke about the conditions and the lack of upkeep at Cesar Chavez Park.\n\nWilliam Kirkland spoke about his gratitude for the support he has received at SOS, noting the City had made a positive difference there.\n\nElsia Greer Hurtado, a resident at SOS, thanked Mayor Gallego and Councilmembers for the ADA bathrooms and as a wheelchair user, she asked for better ADA access.\n\nErik Richardson, with Funds for Empowerment, thanked Council for the improvements at SOS, and asked for a fair process for residents to contest shelter exits.\n\nLee Ellis thanked Council for listening to their needs and asked for more working showers at SOS plus additional onsite housing and job support resources.\n\nJeremy Thacker spoke about the survey to rename Cesar Chavez Park and expressed support to rename Cesar Chavez Park in honor of Jesse Owens.\n\nVictor Sanchez spoke about the need for more free neighborhood shuttle options to help residents who struggle to get bus passes.\n\nElizabeth Venable, with Funds for Empowerment, thanked the City for ADA improvements at the SOS lot and urged for better data driven policies to reduce unnecessary exits and improve overall program effectiveness.","votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":64606,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"ADJOURN","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":"There being no further business to come before the Council, Mayor Gallego declared the meeting adjourned at 5:43 p.m.\n\n___________________________\nMAYOR\n\nATTEST:\n\n__________________________\nCITY CLERK\n\nMW\n\nCERTIFICATION\n\nI hereby certify that the foregoing minutes are a true and correct copy of the minutes of the formal session of the City Council of the City of Phoenix held on the 17th day of June, 2026. I further certify that the meeting was duly called and held and that a quorum was present.\n\nDated this [NUMBER]th day of [MONTH], [YEAR].\n\n__________________________\nCITY CLERK","votes":[],"roll_call":[]}],"coverage":{"lines":2314,"speaking_seconds":9968.4,"seconds_by_role":{"member":3958.8,"staff":694.7,"official":268.6,"public":1095.3,"unclassified":3951.0},"named_seconds":5627.3,"named_share":0.5645,"chapters_found":25,"agenda_items_acted_on":155},"build":{"builder_version":"0.1.0","built_at":"2026-10-20T19:26:23Z","problems":[],"inputs":{"recordings":[{"source_ref":"part 1 of 1","content_sha256":"02b2434966cb392f1f8c7e25b5326413b3230966f4f174adeaa7861cc65a6258"}],"agenda_file_sha256":"c1bdc83eede1dcdf2650decf10384e5656fbc8e9a2136a19cd692aa6be1c08af","config_pack_sha256":"5056771490d823a6d33bdb79169e991d17ffc31da27d800ac79d9d7b7a82bfeb"},"checks":{"chapter_announcements_skipped":6,"roll_call_suggestions":9,"name_suggestions_from_minutes":3,"captions":null,"lines_flagged_language":33,"video_offset_check":{"source":"the video's own captions","shift_s":1859.82,"anchors":17797,"spread_s":0.09,"recorded_offset_s":1860.0,"difference_s":-0.18,"agrees":true}},"freeze":{"approved_by":"jthacker 2026-10-20","frozen_at":"2026-10-20T19:27:06Z","previous_version":null}},"publication":{"exported_at":"2026-10-22T05:49:18Z","from_version":1,"from_sha256":"3b863110ffbdf7c1653e6056b3d3e88de260f2fbfa07d50f15420f6b14e97a8e","fixes_applied":9}}