{"format":"public-meeting-insights/meeting","format_version":"1.0","meeting_id":"phoenix-city-council/2026-02-18-formal-meeting","status":"published","version":1,"body":{"slug":"phoenix-city-council","name":"Phoenix City Council","city":"Phoenix","state":"AZ"},"meeting":{"date":"2026-02-18","type":"Formal Meeting","type_slug":"formal-meeting","scheduled_time":"2:30 PM","duration_s":6562.505},"notices":{"independence":"An independent project by GOOD|GOAT. Not affiliated with or endorsed by the City of Phoenix.","machine":"Machine transcript, corrected by the public. Not the official record: the City's minutes are.","official_record_url":"https://phoenix.legistar.com/Calendar.aspx"},"licence":{"data":"CC-BY-4.0","attribution":"GOOD|GOAT, Public Meeting Insights (https://goodgoat.net)"},"policy":{"names":"on-record","on_record_window_s":180.0},"agenda":{"system":"legistar","client":"phoenix","event_id":2586,"body_id":138,"body_name":"City Council Formal Meeting","minutes_status":"Tentative","agenda_status":"Final","event_url":"https://phoenix.legistar.com/MeetingDetail.aspx?LEGID=2586&GID=485&G=3F9B5896-D56F-4AD3-85AD-A8E5E58DD74C"},"video":{"platform":"youtube","id":"QygyDM56AYY","url":"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QygyDM56AYY","embed_url":"https://www.youtube-nocookie.com/embed/QygyDM56AYY","offset_s":50.0,"offset_source":"measured against the video's own captions (11397 matching passages, within 0.05 s)"},"recordings":[{"part":1,"of":1,"source":"speakr_db","source_ref":"part 1 of 1","duration_s":6563.368,"meeting_offset_s":0.0,"content_sha256":"d73937f720f815608825c400bb8a4b476f54fc06e0298f52406f2bec0d6f6324"}],"speakers":[{"id":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138"},{"id":"v01","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January"},{"id":"v02","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17"},{"id":"kevin-robinson","role":"member","name":"Kevin Robinson","title":"Councilman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138"},{"id":"mario-barajas","role":"official","name":"Mario Barajas","title":"Spanish interpreter","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07: 'Mayor Gallego acknowledged the presence of Mario Barajas and Elsie Duarte, Spanish interpreters.' Introduced at each meeting."},{"id":"julie-kriegh","role":"staff","name":"Julie Kriegh","title":"City Attorney","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2022-11-15 (first titled mention); still titled City Attorney 2026-09-09"},{"id":"v03","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138"},{"id":"v04","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"laura-pastor","role":"member","name":"Laura Pastor","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138"},{"id":"v05","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v06","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138"},{"id":"debra-stark","role":"member","name":"Debra Stark","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138"},{"id":"v07","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v08","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v09","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"ed-zuercher","role":"staff","name":"Ed Zuercher","title":"City Manager","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes: City Manager Ed Zuercher from 2025-11-19 (after Jeff Barton, 2023 to about Nov 2025); still titled 2026-08-26. See gg_phx-cc-data config/officials.csv"},{"id":"betty-guardado","role":"member","name":"Betty Guardado","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138"},{"id":"v10","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"lori-bays","role":"staff","name":"Lori Bays","title":"Assistant City Manager","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2021-12-01 item 45 (first titled mention); still titled 2026-04-08"},{"id":"v11","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v12","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v13","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"jim-waring","role":"member","name":"Jim Waring","title":"Councilman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138"},{"id":"v14","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v15","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null},{"id":"v16","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null}],"chapters":[{"id":"C001","kind":"opening","agenda_numbers":[],"event_item_ids":[],"title":"Opening","start_line":"L00001","start_s":0.908,"end_s":299.756,"confidence":"high","basis":"start of recording"},{"id":"C002","kind":"section","agenda_numbers":[],"event_item_ids":[62802],"title":"BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS","start_line":"L00069","start_s":299.756,"end_s":440.418,"confidence":"medium","basis":"L00069: title read aloud: \"Item number one is boards and commissions.\""},{"id":"C003","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["12"],"event_item_ids":[62861],"title":"Liquor License - 27th Ave Market - District 1","start_line":"L00108","start_s":440.418,"end_s":656.941,"confidence":"medium","basis":"L00108: \"We next go to agenda item 12, which is in Councilman O'Brien's district.\""},{"id":"C004","kind":"block","agenda_numbers":["14","16","17","18","19","20","22","23","25","27","28","29","31","32","33","34","35","37","38","39","40","41","42","43","44","45","46","47","48"],"event_item_ids":[62822,62827,62825,62826,62828,62829,62857,62832,62866,62835,62837,62838,62823,62864,62842,62843,62844,62845,62846,62847,62848,62849,62850,62851,62852,62853,62854,62821,62863],"title":"Items 13–48 voted together","start_line":"L00174","start_s":656.941,"end_s":702.82,"confidence":"low","basis":"L00174: \"Motion to approve items 13 through 48 except the following.\""},{"id":"C005","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["13"],"event_item_ids":[62819],"title":"Settlement of Claim(s) Perez v. City of Phoenix","start_line":"L00200","start_s":702.82,"end_s":1016.142,"confidence":"high","basis":"L00200: \"Item 13 is a settlement of a claim.\""},{"id":"C006","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["15"],"event_item_ids":[62817],"title":"Proposed 9th Avenue and Alameda Road Annexation - Public Hearing - District 1","start_line":"L00274","start_s":1016.142,"end_s":1209.479,"confidence":"high","basis":"L00274: \"Item 15 is a public hearing for the proposed 19th Avenue and Alameda Road annexation.\""},{"id":"C007","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["21"],"event_item_ids":[62830],"title":"Amendments to the City's Combined Classification and Pay Ordinance (S-51144) in Accordance with Human Resources Committees (HRCs) 2026-004 and 2026-005 Recommendations (Ordinance S-52621) - Citywide","start_line":"L00326","start_s":1209.479,"end_s":4090.038,"confidence":"high","basis":"L00326: \"Item 21 is amendments to our city's combined classification pay ordinance and the 2026.05 recommendations.\""},{"id":"C008","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["24"],"event_item_ids":[62833],"title":"Authorization to Accept Carnegie Corporation of New York $10,000 Commemorative Gift to Phoenix Public Library (Ordinance S-52616) - Citywide","start_line":"L00793","start_s":4090.038,"end_s":4145.136,"confidence":"high","basis":"L00793: \"Next, we go to item 24, which is to accept a gift from the Carnegie Corporation of New York to the Phoenix Public Library, Vice Mayor.\""},{"id":"C009","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["26"],"event_item_ids":[62834],"title":"Artist Design, Fabrication, and Installation Contract for The Sueño Park Public Art Project (Ordinance S-52620) - District 4","start_line":"L00821","start_s":4145.136,"end_s":4238.956,"confidence":"high","basis":"L00821: \"Item 26 is related to Sueño Park Public Art.\""},{"id":"C010","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["30"],"event_item_ids":[62840],"title":"Pilot Simulator Training Contract - RFA 24-0390 - Request for Award (Ordinance S-52618) - Citywide","start_line":"L00857","start_s":4238.956,"end_s":4893.959,"confidence":"high","basis":"L00857: \"Item 30 is related to pilot simulator training contract.\""},{"id":"C011","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["36"],"event_item_ids":[62865],"title":"Gillig, LLC - PTD22-001 - Amendment - Public Transit Department and Aviation Department (Ordinance S-52625) - Citywide","start_line":"L00988","start_s":4893.959,"end_s":5497.038,"confidence":"high","basis":"L00988: \"We next go to item 36, which is related to public transit department and the aviation buying bus.\""},{"id":"C012","kind":"item","agenda_numbers":["000"],"event_item_ids":[62859],"title":"000 CITIZEN COMMENTS","start_line":"L01125","start_s":5497.038,"end_s":null,"confidence":"high","basis":"L01125: city cue: \"During citizen comment, members of the public may speak to the city council for up to three minutes on issues of interest or concern.\""}],"turns":[{"id":"T00001","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00001","last_line":"L00003","start_s":0.908,"end_s":14.127},{"id":"T00002","speaker":"v01","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00004","last_line":"L00015","start_s":16.59,"end_s":110.704},{"id":"T00003","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00016","last_line":"L00017","start_s":113.066,"end_s":117.451},{"id":"T00004","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00018","last_line":"L00018","start_s":118.192,"end_s":119.273},{"id":"T00005","speaker":"v02","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00019","last_line":"L00019","start_s":124.636,"end_s":141.465},{"id":"T00006","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00020","last_line":"L00020","start_s":141.866,"end_s":143.168},{"id":"T00007","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00021","last_line":"L00021","start_s":143.536,"end_s":144.537},{"id":"T00008","speaker":"betty-guardado","role":"member","name":"Betty Guardado","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00022","last_line":"L00022","start_s":144.677,"end_s":144.917},{"id":"T00009","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00023","last_line":"L00023","start_s":145.538,"end_s":146.439},{"id":"T00010","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00024","last_line":"L00024","start_s":146.579,"end_s":146.799},{"id":"T00011","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00025","last_line":"L00025","start_s":147.24,"end_s":148.12},{"id":"T00012","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00026","last_line":"L00026","start_s":148.521,"end_s":148.741},{"id":"T00013","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00027","last_line":"L00027","start_s":149.262,"end_s":150.202},{"id":"T00014","speaker":"laura-pastor","role":"member","name":"Laura Pastor","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00028","last_line":"L00028","start_s":150.423,"end_s":150.623},{"id":"T00015","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00029","last_line":"L00029","start_s":151.384,"end_s":152.244},{"id":"T00016","speaker":"kevin-robinson","role":"member","name":"Kevin Robinson","title":"Councilman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00030","last_line":"L00030","start_s":152.425,"end_s":152.625},{"id":"T00017","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00031","last_line":"L00031","start_s":153.105,"end_s":154.126},{"id":"T00018","speaker":"debra-stark","role":"member","name":"Debra Stark","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00032","last_line":"L00032","start_s":154.146,"end_s":154.326},{"id":"T00019","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00033","last_line":"L00033","start_s":154.847,"end_s":155.568},{"id":"T00020","speaker":"jim-waring","role":"member","name":"Jim Waring","title":"Councilman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00034","last_line":"L00034","start_s":156.449,"end_s":156.549},{"id":"T00021","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00035","last_line":"L00035","start_s":156.569,"end_s":157.89},{"id":"T00022","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00036","last_line":"L00036","start_s":158.07,"end_s":158.25},{"id":"T00023","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00037","last_line":"L00037","start_s":158.891,"end_s":159.491},{"id":"T00024","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00038","last_line":"L00040","start_s":160.112,"end_s":167.199},{"id":"T00025","speaker":"mario-barajas","role":"official","name":"Mario Barajas","title":"Spanish interpreter","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07: 'Mayor Gallego acknowledged the presence of Mario Barajas and Elsie Duarte, Spanish interpreters.' Introduced at each meeting.","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00041","last_line":"L00050","start_s":167.88,"end_s":216.017},{"id":"T00026","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00051","last_line":"L00052","start_s":216.487,"end_s":231.571},{"id":"T00027","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00053","last_line":"L00054","start_s":234.876,"end_s":237.921},{"id":"T00028","speaker":"julie-kriegh","role":"staff","name":"Julie Kriegh","title":"City Attorney","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2022-11-15 (first titled mention); still titled City Attorney 2026-09-09","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00055","last_line":"L00066","start_s":238.205,"end_s":290.386},{"id":"T00029","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C001","first_line":"L00067","last_line":"L00068","start_s":291.287,"end_s":297.173},{"id":"T00030","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C002","first_line":"L00069","last_line":"L00070","start_s":299.756,"end_s":302.599},{"id":"T00031","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C002","first_line":"L00071","last_line":"L00072","start_s":302.819,"end_s":307.885},{"id":"T00032","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C002","first_line":"L00073","last_line":"L00079","start_s":308.135,"end_s":340.229},{"id":"T00033","speaker":"v03","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C002","first_line":"L00080","last_line":"L00081","start_s":340.951,"end_s":359.548},{"id":"T00034","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C002","first_line":"L00082","last_line":"L00082","start_s":359.808,"end_s":361.01},{"id":"T00035","speaker":"v03","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C002","first_line":"L00083","last_line":"L00083","start_s":361.35,"end_s":362.732},{"id":"T00036","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C002","first_line":"L00084","last_line":"L00084","start_s":363.032,"end_s":363.813},{"id":"T00037","speaker":"v03","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C002","first_line":"L00085","last_line":"L00085","start_s":364.114,"end_s":365.055},{"id":"T00038","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C002","first_line":"L00086","last_line":"L00086","start_s":365.375,"end_s":366.697},{"id":"T00039","speaker":"v03","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C002","first_line":"L00087","last_line":"L00089","start_s":367.137,"end_s":372.744},{"id":"T00040","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C002","first_line":"L00090","last_line":"L00090","start_s":373.285,"end_s":375.167},{"id":"T00041","speaker":"v03","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C002","first_line":"L00091","last_line":"L00091","start_s":375.187,"end_s":376.689},{"id":"T00042","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C002","first_line":"L00092","last_line":"L00092","start_s":376.91,"end_s":377.931},{"id":"T00043","speaker":"v03","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C002","first_line":"L00093","last_line":"L00095","start_s":378.211,"end_s":380.915},{"id":"T00044","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C002","first_line":"L00096","last_line":"L00101","start_s":380.995,"end_s":429.068},{"id":"T00045","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C002","first_line":"L00102","last_line":"L00103","start_s":429.629,"end_s":433.536},{"id":"T00046","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C002","first_line":"L00104","last_line":"L00107","start_s":433.916,"end_s":438.885},{"id":"T00047","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C003","first_line":"L00108","last_line":"L00111","start_s":440.418,"end_s":457.257},{"id":"T00048","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C003","first_line":"L00112","last_line":"L00112","start_s":457.957,"end_s":458.959},{"id":"T00049","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C003","first_line":"L00113","last_line":"L00114","start_s":458.979,"end_s":462.983},{"id":"T00050","speaker":"v04","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C003","first_line":"L00115","last_line":"L00131","start_s":467.789,"end_s":590.223},{"id":"T00051","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C003","first_line":"L00132","last_line":"L00141","start_s":591.164,"end_s":611.996},{"id":"T00052","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C003","first_line":"L00142","last_line":"L00143","start_s":612.517,"end_s":622.751},{"id":"T00053","speaker":"laura-pastor","role":"member","name":"Laura Pastor","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C003","first_line":"L00144","last_line":"L00145","start_s":624.554,"end_s":624.894},{"id":"T00054","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C003","first_line":"L00146","last_line":"L00147","start_s":625.315,"end_s":626.717},{"id":"T00055","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C003","first_line":"L00148","last_line":"L00154","start_s":628.159,"end_s":633.387},{"id":"T00056","speaker":"laura-pastor","role":"member","name":"Laura Pastor","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C003","first_line":"L00155","last_line":"L00155","start_s":633.627,"end_s":634.368},{"id":"T00057","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C003","first_line":"L00156","last_line":"L00156","start_s":634.388,"end_s":634.829},{"id":"T00058","speaker":"v05","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C003","first_line":"L00157","last_line":"L00157","start_s":635.109,"end_s":635.329},{"id":"T00059","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C003","first_line":"L00158","last_line":"L00166","start_s":635.85,"end_s":642.639},{"id":"T00060","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C003","first_line":"L00167","last_line":"L00172","start_s":645.084,"end_s":655.965},{"id":"T00061","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C003","first_line":"L00173","last_line":"L00173","start_s":656.3,"end_s":656.58},{"id":"T00062","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C004","first_line":"L00174","last_line":"L00176","start_s":656.941,"end_s":669.997},{"id":"T00063","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C004","first_line":"L00177","last_line":"L00179","start_s":671.739,"end_s":682.392},{"id":"T00064","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C004","first_line":"L00180","last_line":"L00182","start_s":685.139,"end_s":688.803},{"id":"T00065","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C004","first_line":"L00183","last_line":"L00183","start_s":689.044,"end_s":689.684},{"id":"T00066","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C004","first_line":"L00184","last_line":"L00184","start_s":689.704,"end_s":690.385},{"id":"T00067","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C004","first_line":"L00185","last_line":"L00185","start_s":690.405,"end_s":691.106},{"id":"T00068","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C004","first_line":"L00186","last_line":"L00186","start_s":691.126,"end_s":691.567},{"id":"T00069","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C004","first_line":"L00187","last_line":"L00188","start_s":692.067,"end_s":693.168},{"id":"T00070","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C004","first_line":"L00189","last_line":"L00190","start_s":693.469,"end_s":694.63},{"id":"T00071","speaker":"v06","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C004","first_line":"L00191","last_line":"L00191","start_s":694.75,"end_s":695.011},{"id":"T00072","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C004","first_line":"L00192","last_line":"L00195","start_s":695.511,"end_s":698.875},{"id":"T00073","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C004","first_line":"L00196","last_line":"L00196","start_s":699.115,"end_s":699.776},{"id":"T00074","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C004","first_line":"L00197","last_line":"L00199","start_s":699.796,"end_s":701.719},{"id":"T00075","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00200","last_line":"L00203","start_s":702.82,"end_s":713.172},{"id":"T00076","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00204","last_line":"L00204","start_s":713.573,"end_s":714.835},{"id":"T00077","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00205","last_line":"L00215","start_s":714.855,"end_s":755.359},{"id":"T00078","speaker":"v06","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00216","last_line":"L00219","start_s":757.567,"end_s":798.762},{"id":"T00079","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00220","last_line":"L00224","start_s":798.978,"end_s":820.125},{"id":"T00080","speaker":"v06","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00225","last_line":"L00227","start_s":820.426,"end_s":835.231},{"id":"T00081","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00228","last_line":"L00232","start_s":835.251,"end_s":856.018},{"id":"T00082","speaker":"v06","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00233","last_line":"L00236","start_s":859.461,"end_s":901.581},{"id":"T00083","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00237","last_line":"L00239","start_s":902.405,"end_s":919.215},{"id":"T00084","speaker":"v06","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00240","last_line":"L00243","start_s":919.195,"end_s":965.385},{"id":"T00085","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00244","last_line":"L00251","start_s":965.365,"end_s":998.137},{"id":"T00086","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00252","last_line":"L00255","start_s":998.398,"end_s":1002.644},{"id":"T00087","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00256","last_line":"L00258","start_s":1003.004,"end_s":1005.027},{"id":"T00088","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00259","last_line":"L00259","start_s":1005.047,"end_s":1005.467},{"id":"T00089","speaker":"debra-stark","role":"member","name":"Debra Stark","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00260","last_line":"L00260","start_s":1005.648,"end_s":1005.908},{"id":"T00090","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00261","last_line":"L00263","start_s":1006.349,"end_s":1008.131},{"id":"T00091","speaker":"v06","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00264","last_line":"L00264","start_s":1008.311,"end_s":1008.532},{"id":"T00092","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00265","last_line":"L00270","start_s":1009.052,"end_s":1012.777},{"id":"T00093","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00271","last_line":"L00271","start_s":1013.178,"end_s":1013.618},{"id":"T00094","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C005","first_line":"L00272","last_line":"L00273","start_s":1013.799,"end_s":1015.521},{"id":"T00095","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C006","first_line":"L00274","last_line":"L00281","start_s":1016.142,"end_s":1045.716},{"id":"T00096","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C006","first_line":"L00282","last_line":"L00283","start_s":1046.518,"end_s":1048.925},{"id":"T00097","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C006","first_line":"L00284","last_line":"L00285","start_s":1048.945,"end_s":1051.752},{"id":"T00098","speaker":"v07","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C006","first_line":"L00286","last_line":"L00304","start_s":1064.962,"end_s":1188.713},{"id":"T00099","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C006","first_line":"L00305","last_line":"L00305","start_s":1190.476,"end_s":1191.237},{"id":"T00100","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C006","first_line":"L00306","last_line":"L00313","start_s":1192.359,"end_s":1198.428},{"id":"T00101","speaker":"debra-stark","role":"member","name":"Debra Stark","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C006","first_line":"L00314","last_line":"L00314","start_s":1198.649,"end_s":1199.41},{"id":"T00102","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C006","first_line":"L00315","last_line":"L00315","start_s":1199.43,"end_s":1199.911},{"id":"T00103","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C006","first_line":"L00316","last_line":"L00316","start_s":1200.051,"end_s":1200.291},{"id":"T00104","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C006","first_line":"L00317","last_line":"L00325","start_s":1200.872,"end_s":1207.423},{"id":"T00105","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00326","last_line":"L00327","start_s":1209.479,"end_s":1222.219},{"id":"T00106","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00328","last_line":"L00329","start_s":1222.8,"end_s":1225.625},{"id":"T00107","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00330","last_line":"L00333","start_s":1225.645,"end_s":1235.2},{"id":"T00108","speaker":"v08","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00334","last_line":"L00359","start_s":1242.368,"end_s":1365.355},{"id":"T00109","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00360","last_line":"L00361","start_s":1366.576,"end_s":1372.182},{"id":"T00110","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00362","last_line":"L00367","start_s":1372.783,"end_s":1383.854},{"id":"T00111","speaker":"v08","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00368","last_line":"L00371","start_s":1383.874,"end_s":1390.872},{"id":"T00112","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00372","last_line":"L00372","start_s":1393.957,"end_s":1395.139},{"id":"T00113","speaker":"laura-pastor","role":"member","name":"Laura Pastor","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00373","last_line":"L00382","start_s":1395.88,"end_s":1461.974},{"id":"T00114","speaker":"v09","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00383","last_line":"L00389","start_s":1467.102,"end_s":1498.712},{"id":"T00115","speaker":"laura-pastor","role":"member","name":"Laura Pastor","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00390","last_line":"L00394","start_s":1500.315,"end_s":1525.268},{"id":"T00116","speaker":"v09","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00395","last_line":"L00398","start_s":1526.169,"end_s":1543.05},{"id":"T00117","speaker":"laura-pastor","role":"member","name":"Laura Pastor","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00399","last_line":"L00402","start_s":1543.807,"end_s":1566.878},{"id":"T00118","speaker":"v09","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00403","last_line":"L00405","start_s":1569.271,"end_s":1605.58},{"id":"T00119","speaker":"laura-pastor","role":"member","name":"Laura Pastor","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00406","last_line":"L00406","start_s":1607.002,"end_s":1614.132},{"id":"T00120","speaker":"v09","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00407","last_line":"L00407","start_s":1614.833,"end_s":1616.175},{"id":"T00121","speaker":"laura-pastor","role":"member","name":"Laura Pastor","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00408","last_line":"L00408","start_s":1616.195,"end_s":1621.502},{"id":"T00122","speaker":"v09","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00409","last_line":"L00409","start_s":1621.87,"end_s":1624.214},{"id":"T00123","speaker":"laura-pastor","role":"member","name":"Laura Pastor","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00410","last_line":"L00412","start_s":1624.274,"end_s":1625.597},{"id":"T00124","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00413","last_line":"L00414","start_s":1630.486,"end_s":1632.249},{"id":"T00125","speaker":"debra-stark","role":"member","name":"Debra Stark","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00415","last_line":"L00425","start_s":1635.014,"end_s":1671.067},{"id":"T00126","speaker":"v08","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00426","last_line":"L00428","start_s":1671.667,"end_s":1694.082},{"id":"T00127","speaker":"debra-stark","role":"member","name":"Debra Stark","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00429","last_line":"L00439","start_s":1698.517,"end_s":1755.051},{"id":"T00128","speaker":"v09","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00440","last_line":"L00445","start_s":1756.178,"end_s":1784.886},{"id":"T00129","speaker":"debra-stark","role":"member","name":"Debra Stark","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00446","last_line":"L00449","start_s":1788.292,"end_s":1810.047},{"id":"T00130","speaker":"ed-zuercher","role":"staff","name":"Ed Zuercher","title":"City Manager","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes: City Manager Ed Zuercher from 2025-11-19 (after Jeff Barton, 2023 to about Nov 2025); still titled 2026-08-26. See gg_phx-cc-data config/officials.csv","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00450","last_line":"L00455","start_s":1810.027,"end_s":1841.192},{"id":"T00131","speaker":"debra-stark","role":"member","name":"Debra Stark","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00456","last_line":"L00456","start_s":1845.399,"end_s":1847.343},{"id":"T00132","speaker":"betty-guardado","role":"member","name":"Betty Guardado","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00457","last_line":"L00460","start_s":1848.605,"end_s":1876.77},{"id":"T00133","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00461","last_line":"L00461","start_s":1878.64,"end_s":1881.046},{"id":"T00134","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00462","last_line":"L00471","start_s":1881.066,"end_s":1956.42},{"id":"T00135","speaker":"ed-zuercher","role":"staff","name":"Ed Zuercher","title":"City Manager","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes: City Manager Ed Zuercher from 2025-11-19 (after Jeff Barton, 2023 to about Nov 2025); still titled 2026-08-26. See gg_phx-cc-data config/officials.csv","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00472","last_line":"L00473","start_s":1957.295,"end_s":1975.219},{"id":"T00136","speaker":"v09","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00474","last_line":"L00477","start_s":1976.65,"end_s":1999.941},{"id":"T00137","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00478","last_line":"L00478","start_s":2001.625,"end_s":2019.931},{"id":"T00138","speaker":"betty-guardado","role":"member","name":"Betty Guardado","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00479","last_line":"L00485","start_s":2020.772,"end_s":2038.379},{"id":"T00139","speaker":"v09","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00486","last_line":"L00486","start_s":2038.8,"end_s":2046.94},{"id":"T00140","speaker":"betty-guardado","role":"member","name":"Betty Guardado","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00487","last_line":"L00498","start_s":2046.961,"end_s":2101.078},{"id":"T00141","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00499","last_line":"L00500","start_s":2101.098,"end_s":2103.541},{"id":"T00142","speaker":"laura-pastor","role":"member","name":"Laura Pastor","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00501","last_line":"L00511","start_s":2106.044,"end_s":2209.444},{"id":"T00143","speaker":"v09","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00512","last_line":"L00515","start_s":2209.829,"end_s":2236.005},{"id":"T00144","speaker":"laura-pastor","role":"member","name":"Laura Pastor","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00516","last_line":"L00520","start_s":2236.576,"end_s":2280.205},{"id":"T00145","speaker":"ed-zuercher","role":"staff","name":"Ed Zuercher","title":"City Manager","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes: City Manager Ed Zuercher from 2025-11-19 (after Jeff Barton, 2023 to about Nov 2025); still titled 2026-08-26. See gg_phx-cc-data config/officials.csv","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00521","last_line":"L00523","start_s":2280.225,"end_s":2291.377},{"id":"T00146","speaker":"laura-pastor","role":"member","name":"Laura Pastor","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00524","last_line":"L00525","start_s":2291.397,"end_s":2295.489},{"id":"T00147","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00526","last_line":"L00534","start_s":2296.291,"end_s":2331.45},{"id":"T00148","speaker":"v09","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00535","last_line":"L00540","start_s":2332.493,"end_s":2355.16},{"id":"T00149","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00541","last_line":"L00545","start_s":2355.14,"end_s":2392.244},{"id":"T00150","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00546","last_line":"L00552","start_s":2392.264,"end_s":2485.384},{"id":"T00151","speaker":"v09","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00553","last_line":"L00554","start_s":2486.225,"end_s":2503.308},{"id":"T00152","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00555","last_line":"L00555","start_s":2507.174,"end_s":2509.617},{"id":"T00153","speaker":"betty-guardado","role":"member","name":"Betty Guardado","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00556","last_line":"L00562","start_s":2509.9,"end_s":2583.09},{"id":"T00154","speaker":"v09","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00563","last_line":"L00565","start_s":2584.049,"end_s":2592.418},{"id":"T00155","speaker":"betty-guardado","role":"member","name":"Betty Guardado","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00566","last_line":"L00566","start_s":2593.939,"end_s":2596.582},{"id":"T00156","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00567","last_line":"L00567","start_s":2601.407,"end_s":2605.752},{"id":"T00157","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00568","last_line":"L00570","start_s":2605.772,"end_s":2611.918},{"id":"T00158","speaker":"v09","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00571","last_line":"L00571","start_s":2611.938,"end_s":2613.6},{"id":"T00159","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00572","last_line":"L00572","start_s":2614.188,"end_s":2616.47},{"id":"T00160","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00573","last_line":"L00573","start_s":2616.49,"end_s":2617.211},{"id":"T00161","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00574","last_line":"L00575","start_s":2619.753,"end_s":2625.718},{"id":"T00162","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00576","last_line":"L00576","start_s":2625.738,"end_s":2626.739},{"id":"T00163","speaker":"laura-pastor","role":"member","name":"Laura Pastor","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00577","last_line":"L00578","start_s":2628.701,"end_s":2643.013},{"id":"T00164","speaker":"julie-kriegh","role":"staff","name":"Julie Kriegh","title":"City Attorney","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2022-11-15 (first titled mention); still titled City Attorney 2026-09-09","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00579","last_line":"L00580","start_s":2644.529,"end_s":2648.597},{"id":"T00165","speaker":"laura-pastor","role":"member","name":"Laura Pastor","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00581","last_line":"L00583","start_s":2649.459,"end_s":2666.773},{"id":"T00166","speaker":"julie-kriegh","role":"staff","name":"Julie Kriegh","title":"City Attorney","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2022-11-15 (first titled mention); still titled City Attorney 2026-09-09","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00584","last_line":"L00584","start_s":2668.07,"end_s":2684.847},{"id":"T00167","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00585","last_line":"L00586","start_s":2686.379,"end_s":2694.856},{"id":"T00168","speaker":"betty-guardado","role":"member","name":"Betty Guardado","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00587","last_line":"L00588","start_s":2694.876,"end_s":2710.578},{"id":"T00169","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00589","last_line":"L00590","start_s":2711.099,"end_s":2721.959},{"id":"T00170","speaker":"betty-guardado","role":"member","name":"Betty Guardado","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00591","last_line":"L00591","start_s":2722.44,"end_s":2722.68},{"id":"T00171","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00592","last_line":"L00593","start_s":2724.517,"end_s":2730.446},{"id":"T00172","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00594","last_line":"L00595","start_s":2732.109,"end_s":2735.213},{"id":"T00173","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00596","last_line":"L00599","start_s":2735.854,"end_s":2751.418},{"id":"T00174","speaker":"v09","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00600","last_line":"L00601","start_s":2755.921,"end_s":2763.381},{"id":"T00175","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00602","last_line":"L00602","start_s":2764.584,"end_s":2765.627},{"id":"T00176","speaker":"v10","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00603","last_line":"L00603","start_s":2790.447,"end_s":2792.205},{"id":"T00177","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00604","last_line":"L00609","start_s":2792.827,"end_s":2840.291},{"id":"T00178","speaker":"v10","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00610","last_line":"L00620","start_s":2842.214,"end_s":2926.378},{"id":"T00179","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00621","last_line":"L00623","start_s":2928.788,"end_s":2949.714},{"id":"T00180","speaker":"v10","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00624","last_line":"L00624","start_s":2950.935,"end_s":2955.741},{"id":"T00181","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00625","last_line":"L00625","start_s":2957.037,"end_s":2966.001},{"id":"T00182","speaker":"v10","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00626","last_line":"L00626","start_s":2966.2,"end_s":2996.055},{"id":"T00183","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00627","last_line":"L00628","start_s":2997.993,"end_s":3024.333},{"id":"T00184","speaker":"v09","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00629","last_line":"L00629","start_s":3025.395,"end_s":3025.755},{"id":"T00185","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00630","last_line":"L00630","start_s":3026.516,"end_s":3034.306},{"id":"T00186","speaker":"v09","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00631","last_line":"L00631","start_s":3036.449,"end_s":3039.693},{"id":"T00187","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00632","last_line":"L00632","start_s":3039.713,"end_s":3043.137},{"id":"T00188","speaker":"v09","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00633","last_line":"L00633","start_s":3045.783,"end_s":3047.385},{"id":"T00189","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00634","last_line":"L00635","start_s":3047.405,"end_s":3052.113},{"id":"T00190","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00636","last_line":"L00636","start_s":3052.153,"end_s":3053.975},{"id":"T00191","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00637","last_line":"L00644","start_s":3054.015,"end_s":3096.597},{"id":"T00192","speaker":"v10","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00645","last_line":"L00650","start_s":3096.779,"end_s":3133.485},{"id":"T00193","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00651","last_line":"L00652","start_s":3134.568,"end_s":3144.268},{"id":"T00194","speaker":"v09","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00653","last_line":"L00654","start_s":3146.932,"end_s":3176.23},{"id":"T00195","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00655","last_line":"L00655","start_s":3176.665,"end_s":3181.176},{"id":"T00196","speaker":"v09","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00656","last_line":"L00656","start_s":3181.316,"end_s":3183.722},{"id":"T00197","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00657","last_line":"L00657","start_s":3183.782,"end_s":3188.634},{"id":"T00198","speaker":"v09","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00658","last_line":"L00658","start_s":3189.295,"end_s":3192.042},{"id":"T00199","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00659","last_line":"L00660","start_s":3192.022,"end_s":3210.793},{"id":"T00200","speaker":"betty-guardado","role":"member","name":"Betty Guardado","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00661","last_line":"L00663","start_s":3210.813,"end_s":3224.544},{"id":"T00201","speaker":"ed-zuercher","role":"staff","name":"Ed Zuercher","title":"City Manager","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes: City Manager Ed Zuercher from 2025-11-19 (after Jeff Barton, 2023 to about Nov 2025); still titled 2026-08-26. See gg_phx-cc-data config/officials.csv","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00664","last_line":"L00672","start_s":3230.5,"end_s":3285.293},{"id":"T00202","speaker":"debra-stark","role":"member","name":"Debra Stark","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00673","last_line":"L00675","start_s":3285.333,"end_s":3305.475},{"id":"T00203","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00676","last_line":"L00676","start_s":3306.772,"end_s":3310.876},{"id":"T00204","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00677","last_line":"L00682","start_s":3311.716,"end_s":3388.5},{"id":"T00205","speaker":"v10","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00683","last_line":"L00684","start_s":3394.876,"end_s":3439.345},{"id":"T00206","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00685","last_line":"L00685","start_s":3439.797,"end_s":3443.566},{"id":"T00207","speaker":"v09","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00686","last_line":"L00686","start_s":3446.954,"end_s":3452.808},{"id":"T00208","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00687","last_line":"L00701","start_s":3455.715,"end_s":3555.263},{"id":"T00209","speaker":"ed-zuercher","role":"staff","name":"Ed Zuercher","title":"City Manager","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes: City Manager Ed Zuercher from 2025-11-19 (after Jeff Barton, 2023 to about Nov 2025); still titled 2026-08-26. See gg_phx-cc-data config/officials.csv","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00702","last_line":"L00708","start_s":3555.283,"end_s":3605.175},{"id":"T00210","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00709","last_line":"L00711","start_s":3605.678,"end_s":3625.935},{"id":"T00211","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00712","last_line":"L00713","start_s":3626.416,"end_s":3629.121},{"id":"T00212","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00714","last_line":"L00726","start_s":3629.455,"end_s":3696.842},{"id":"T00213","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00727","last_line":"L00734","start_s":3697.263,"end_s":3737.897},{"id":"T00214","speaker":"lori-bays","role":"staff","name":"Lori Bays","title":"Assistant City Manager","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2021-12-01 item 45 (first titled mention); still titled 2026-04-08","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00735","last_line":"L00740","start_s":3738.687,"end_s":3799.002},{"id":"T00215","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00741","last_line":"L00747","start_s":3799.066,"end_s":3816.906},{"id":"T00216","speaker":"lori-bays","role":"staff","name":"Lori Bays","title":"Assistant City Manager","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2021-12-01 item 45 (first titled mention); still titled 2026-04-08","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00748","last_line":"L00755","start_s":3818.928,"end_s":3873.435},{"id":"T00217","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00756","last_line":"L00757","start_s":3874.097,"end_s":3875.78},{"id":"T00218","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00758","last_line":"L00763","start_s":3876.401,"end_s":3910.738},{"id":"T00219","speaker":"betty-guardado","role":"member","name":"Betty Guardado","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00764","last_line":"L00764","start_s":3911.299,"end_s":3911.58},{"id":"T00220","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00765","last_line":"L00766","start_s":3912.602,"end_s":3916.109},{"id":"T00221","speaker":"betty-guardado","role":"member","name":"Betty Guardado","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00767","last_line":"L00777","start_s":3916.61,"end_s":4027.388},{"id":"T00222","speaker":"lori-bays","role":"staff","name":"Lori Bays","title":"Assistant City Manager","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2021-12-01 item 45 (first titled mention); still titled 2026-04-08","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00778","last_line":"L00778","start_s":4027.688,"end_s":4040.986},{"id":"T00223","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00779","last_line":"L00780","start_s":4041.006,"end_s":4044.11},{"id":"T00224","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00781","last_line":"L00787","start_s":4044.13,"end_s":4048.737},{"id":"T00225","speaker":"laura-pastor","role":"member","name":"Laura Pastor","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00788","last_line":"L00791","start_s":4049.037,"end_s":4084.628},{"id":"T00226","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C007","first_line":"L00792","last_line":"L00792","start_s":4089.097,"end_s":4089.497},{"id":"T00227","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C008","first_line":"L00793","last_line":"L00793","start_s":4090.038,"end_s":4097.988},{"id":"T00228","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C008","first_line":"L00794","last_line":"L00795","start_s":4098.509,"end_s":4100.611},{"id":"T00229","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C008","first_line":"L00796","last_line":"L00802","start_s":4101.432,"end_s":4131.839},{"id":"T00230","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C008","first_line":"L00803","last_line":"L00820","start_s":4132.039,"end_s":4143.494},{"id":"T00231","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C009","first_line":"L00821","last_line":"L00826","start_s":4145.136,"end_s":4157.072},{"id":"T00232","speaker":"laura-pastor","role":"member","name":"Laura Pastor","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C009","first_line":"L00827","last_line":"L00836","start_s":4157.288,"end_s":4221.045},{"id":"T00233","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C009","first_line":"L00837","last_line":"L00840","start_s":4222.713,"end_s":4226.018},{"id":"T00234","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C009","first_line":"L00841","last_line":"L00841","start_s":4226.238,"end_s":4226.458},{"id":"T00235","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C009","first_line":"L00842","last_line":"L00842","start_s":4226.959,"end_s":4227.38},{"id":"T00236","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C009","first_line":"L00843","last_line":"L00843","start_s":4227.96,"end_s":4228.221},{"id":"T00237","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C009","first_line":"L00844","last_line":"L00844","start_s":4228.621,"end_s":4229.062},{"id":"T00238","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C009","first_line":"L00845","last_line":"L00845","start_s":4229.342,"end_s":4229.543},{"id":"T00239","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C009","first_line":"L00846","last_line":"L00846","start_s":4229.963,"end_s":4230.464},{"id":"T00240","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C009","first_line":"L00847","last_line":"L00847","start_s":4230.724,"end_s":4230.925},{"id":"T00241","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C009","first_line":"L00848","last_line":"L00848","start_s":4231.425,"end_s":4231.766},{"id":"T00242","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C009","first_line":"L00849","last_line":"L00849","start_s":4232.006,"end_s":4232.727},{"id":"T00243","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C009","first_line":"L00850","last_line":"L00854","start_s":4232.747,"end_s":4235.972},{"id":"T00244","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C009","first_line":"L00855","last_line":"L00855","start_s":4236.152,"end_s":4236.372},{"id":"T00245","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C009","first_line":"L00856","last_line":"L00856","start_s":4236.813,"end_s":4237.354},{"id":"T00246","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00857","last_line":"L00858","start_s":4238.956,"end_s":4244.624},{"id":"T00247","speaker":"kevin-robinson","role":"member","name":"Kevin Robinson","title":"Councilman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00859","last_line":"L00864","start_s":4246.187,"end_s":4276.817},{"id":"T00248","speaker":"v11","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00865","last_line":"L00871","start_s":4278.805,"end_s":4333.635},{"id":"T00249","speaker":"kevin-robinson","role":"member","name":"Kevin Robinson","title":"Councilman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00872","last_line":"L00874","start_s":4335.725,"end_s":4380.109},{"id":"T00250","speaker":"v12","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00875","last_line":"L00886","start_s":4380.663,"end_s":4450.866},{"id":"T00251","speaker":"kevin-robinson","role":"member","name":"Kevin Robinson","title":"Councilman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00887","last_line":"L00900","start_s":4452.483,"end_s":4520.163},{"id":"T00252","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00901","last_line":"L00902","start_s":4520.303,"end_s":4524.188},{"id":"T00253","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00903","last_line":"L00909","start_s":4524.387,"end_s":4561.228},{"id":"T00254","speaker":"v11","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00910","last_line":"L00914","start_s":4562.896,"end_s":4580.968},{"id":"T00255","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00915","last_line":"L00918","start_s":4580.988,"end_s":4595.822},{"id":"T00256","speaker":"v11","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00919","last_line":"L00923","start_s":4598.013,"end_s":4617.591},{"id":"T00257","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00924","last_line":"L00926","start_s":4618.077,"end_s":4631.813},{"id":"T00258","speaker":"v11","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00927","last_line":"L00932","start_s":4631.833,"end_s":4674.595},{"id":"T00259","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00933","last_line":"L00938","start_s":4674.575,"end_s":4702.303},{"id":"T00260","speaker":"v11","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00939","last_line":"L00945","start_s":4703.195,"end_s":4773.837},{"id":"T00261","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00946","last_line":"L00951","start_s":4774.171,"end_s":4801.309},{"id":"T00262","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00952","last_line":"L00953","start_s":4803.955,"end_s":4805.216},{"id":"T00263","speaker":"anna-hernandez","role":"member","name":"Anna Hernandez","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00954","last_line":"L00971","start_s":4806.778,"end_s":4876.026},{"id":"T00264","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00972","last_line":"L00976","start_s":4876.546,"end_s":4879.93},{"id":"T00265","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00977","last_line":"L00977","start_s":4880.264,"end_s":4880.624},{"id":"T00266","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00978","last_line":"L00984","start_s":4881.105,"end_s":4885.89},{"id":"T00267","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00985","last_line":"L00985","start_s":4886.771,"end_s":4887.011},{"id":"T00268","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00986","last_line":"L00986","start_s":4887.272,"end_s":4888.052},{"id":"T00269","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C010","first_line":"L00987","last_line":"L00987","start_s":4891.276,"end_s":4891.937},{"id":"T00270","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00988","last_line":"L00989","start_s":4893.959,"end_s":4901.327},{"id":"T00271","speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","role":"member","name":"Kesha Hodge Washington","title":"Vice Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2026-01-07 item 52: 'to select Councilwoman Hodge Washington as Vice Mayor'. Shown from the next day; Phoenix's Vice Mayor rotates each January","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00990","last_line":"L00991","start_s":4902.047,"end_s":4904.11},{"id":"T00272","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00992","last_line":"L00994","start_s":4904.871,"end_s":4910.265},{"id":"T00273","speaker":"v02","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L00995","last_line":"L01002","start_s":4916.56,"end_s":4959.823},{"id":"T00274","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L01003","last_line":"L01003","start_s":4962.168,"end_s":4964.473},{"id":"T00275","speaker":"v07","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L01004","last_line":"L01013","start_s":4980.721,"end_s":5044.496},{"id":"T00276","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L01014","last_line":"L01014","start_s":5045.417,"end_s":5052.847},{"id":"T00277","speaker":"v07","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L01015","last_line":"L01020","start_s":5052.867,"end_s":5104.047},{"id":"T00278","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L01021","last_line":"L01033","start_s":5105.461,"end_s":5156.991},{"id":"T00279","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L01034","last_line":"L01052","start_s":5157.011,"end_s":5170.063},{"id":"T00280","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L01053","last_line":"L01055","start_s":5172.105,"end_s":5178.111},{"id":"T00281","speaker":"ann-o-brien","role":"member","name":"Ann O'Brien","title":"Councilwoman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L01056","last_line":"L01056","start_s":5179.93,"end_s":5180.451},{"id":"T00282","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L01057","last_line":"L01057","start_s":5182.233,"end_s":5185.719},{"id":"T00283","speaker":"v07","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L01058","last_line":"L01069","start_s":5197.456,"end_s":5275.682},{"id":"T00284","speaker":"v13","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L01070","last_line":"L01070","start_s":5281.737,"end_s":5283.199},{"id":"T00285","speaker":"jim-waring","role":"member","name":"Jim Waring","title":"Councilman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L01071","last_line":"L01073","start_s":5284.12,"end_s":5306.091},{"id":"T00286","speaker":"v02","role":"unclassified","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L01074","last_line":"L01075","start_s":5308.822,"end_s":5329.53},{"id":"T00287","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L01076","last_line":"L01089","start_s":5332.801,"end_s":5401.559},{"id":"T00288","speaker":"jim-waring","role":"member","name":"Jim Waring","title":"Councilman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L01090","last_line":"L01092","start_s":5402.24,"end_s":5418.902},{"id":"T00289","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L01093","last_line":"L01093","start_s":5418.942,"end_s":5420.283},{"id":"T00290","speaker":"jim-waring","role":"member","name":"Jim Waring","title":"Councilman","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L01094","last_line":"L01098","start_s":5420.383,"end_s":5443.167},{"id":"T00291","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L01099","last_line":"L01103","start_s":5443.433,"end_s":5465.786},{"id":"T00292","speaker":"denise-archibald","role":"staff","name":"Denise Archibald","title":"City Clerk","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2019-01-09 item 49 (first titled mention); still titled City Clerk 2026-06-17","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L01104","last_line":"L01120","start_s":5465.806,"end_s":5480.159},{"id":"T00293","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L01121","last_line":"L01123","start_s":5481.58,"end_s":5495.376},{"id":"T00294","speaker":"julie-kriegh","role":"staff","name":"Julie Kriegh","title":"City Attorney","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2022-11-15 (first titled mention); still titled City Attorney 2026-09-09","public_id":null,"chapter":"C011","first_line":"L01124","last_line":"L01124","start_s":5496.177,"end_s":5496.838},{"id":"T00295","speaker":"julie-kriegh","role":"staff","name":"Julie Kriegh","title":"City Attorney","name_basis":"roster: Legistar minutes 2022-11-15 (first titled mention); still titled City Attorney 2026-09-09","public_id":null,"chapter":"C012","first_line":"L01125","last_line":"L01129","start_s":5497.038,"end_s":5524.972},{"id":"T00296","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C012","first_line":"L01130","last_line":"L01134","start_s":5528.357,"end_s":5539.944},{"id":"T00297","speaker":"v07","role":"public","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":"pc-000-001","chapter":"C012","first_line":"L01135","last_line":"L01160","start_s":5543.247,"end_s":5732.353},{"id":"T00298","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C012","first_line":"L01161","last_line":"L01161","start_s":5733.683,"end_s":5735.914},{"id":"T00299","speaker":"v14","role":"public","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":"pc-000-002","chapter":"C012","first_line":"L01162","last_line":"L01176","start_s":5752.347,"end_s":5890.725},{"id":"T00300","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C012","first_line":"L01177","last_line":"L01178","start_s":5893.27,"end_s":5898.695},{"id":"T00301","speaker":"v02","role":"public","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":"pc-000-003","chapter":"C012","first_line":"L01179","last_line":"L01210","start_s":5899.395,"end_s":6085.092},{"id":"T00302","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C012","first_line":"L01211","last_line":"L01212","start_s":6087.89,"end_s":6090.153},{"id":"T00303","speaker":"v13","role":"public","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":"pc-000-004","chapter":"C012","first_line":"L01213","last_line":"L01220","start_s":6090.173,"end_s":6114.69},{"id":"T00304","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C012","first_line":"L01221","last_line":"L01222","start_s":6118.163,"end_s":6120.345},{"id":"T00305","speaker":"v15","role":"public","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":"pc-000-005","chapter":"C012","first_line":"L01223","last_line":"L01228","start_s":6126.511,"end_s":6147.63},{"id":"T00306","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C012","first_line":"L01229","last_line":"L01229","start_s":6148.859,"end_s":6153.715},{"id":"T00307","speaker":"v16","role":"public","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":"pc-000-006","chapter":"C012","first_line":"L01230","last_line":"L01247","start_s":6158.893,"end_s":6333.209},{"id":"T00308","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C012","first_line":"L01248","last_line":"L01249","start_s":6335.552,"end_s":6340.157},{"id":"T00309","speaker":"v05","role":"public","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":"pc-000-007","chapter":"C012","first_line":"L01250","last_line":"L01280","start_s":6342.55,"end_s":6530.371},{"id":"T00310","speaker":"kate-gallego","role":"member","name":"Kate Gallego","title":"Mayor","name_basis":"roster: Legistar office record, body 138","public_id":null,"chapter":"C012","first_line":"L01281","last_line":"L01282","start_s":6530.391,"end_s":6534.557},{"id":"T00311","speaker":"v01","role":"public","name":null,"title":null,"name_basis":null,"public_id":"pc-000-008","chapter":"C012","first_line":"L01283","last_line":"L01283","start_s":6550.417,"end_s":6563.413}],"lines":[{"id":"L00001","start_s":0.908,"end_s":3.331,"video_s":50.908,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00001","chapter":"C001","text":"Good afternoon, it is February 18th.","fingerprint":"2f0debc90d80","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00002","start_s":3.392,"end_s":5.214,"video_s":53.392,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00001","chapter":"C001","text":"Thank you for joining us for formal.","fingerprint":"9738cda0d400","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00003","start_s":5.635,"end_s":14.127,"video_s":55.635,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00001","chapter":"C001","text":"We'll begin today with an invocation and a special recognition for a member of our City of Phoenix employee family from Police Chaplain Jim Williams.","fingerprint":"5c4b0de77806","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00004","start_s":16.59,"end_s":17.211,"video_s":66.59,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00002","chapter":"C001","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00005","start_s":18.994,"end_s":26.224,"video_s":68.994,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00002","chapter":"C001","text":"Would you join me in a moment of silence for Susan Hawkins, the Municipal Court Hearing Officer and her family.","fingerprint":"2d71f9b77755","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00006","start_s":48.226,"end_s":48.687,"video_s":98.226,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00002","chapter":"C001","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00007","start_s":49.51,"end_s":55.167,"video_s":99.51,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00002","chapter":"C001","text":"Now, would you join me in a prayer of invocation, inviting God to join us in our meeting today?","fingerprint":"2dc021062bb0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00008","start_s":55.227,"end_s":61.847,"video_s":105.227,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00002","chapter":"C001","text":"Lord, I come to you reaching out and requesting your participation in our city council meeting today.","fingerprint":"7af7315a0c89","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00009","start_s":62.131,"end_s":66.475,"video_s":112.131,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00002","chapter":"C001","text":"I lift up to you our mayor, our council, and their staff members.","fingerprint":"6f8fb08a1cd6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00010","start_s":67.296,"end_s":74.763,"video_s":117.296,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00002","chapter":"C001","text":"I believe you've selected and anointed each one of these leading leadership people, and for that, Lord, I give you thanks.","fingerprint":"6de42a1c7176","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00011","start_s":75.484,"end_s":81.149,"video_s":125.484,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00002","chapter":"C001","text":"These are precious and willing individuals that constantly share their leadership and talents with us in the city.","fingerprint":"5713f21bd0cb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00012","start_s":81.93,"end_s":91.159,"video_s":131.93,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00002","chapter":"C001","text":"Father, I ask you to draw the mayor and council close to you, granting them favor, washing them in your wisdom and discernment as only you can.","fingerprint":"86414345570e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00013","start_s":91.443,"end_s":98.07,"video_s":141.443,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00002","chapter":"C001","text":"Lord, I ask that you protect all of our city leaders and our city employees, thus keeping them healthy and safe.","fingerprint":"c5a19d45b8be","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00014","start_s":99.091,"end_s":109.643,"video_s":149.091,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00002","chapter":"C001","text":"And Lord, I thank you in advance for your grace, discernment, and love, extending to our mayor, our city council, and to you, Father, we give you all the praise and all the glory.","fingerprint":"b5c064fffc32","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00015","start_s":110.443,"end_s":110.704,"video_s":160.443,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00002","chapter":"C001","text":"Amen.","fingerprint":"9fdea7d457b5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00016","start_s":113.066,"end_s":114.848,"video_s":163.066,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00003","chapter":"C001","text":"Thank you so much, Chaplain Williams.","fingerprint":"c4175b6a69ab","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00017","start_s":115.429,"end_s":117.451,"video_s":165.429,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00003","chapter":"C001","text":"Vice Mayor Hodge Washington will lead us in the pledge.","fingerprint":"11bb49a2876e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00018","start_s":118.192,"end_s":119.273,"video_s":168.192,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00004","chapter":"C001","text":"I pledge allegiance","fingerprint":"eda0dc911924","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00019","start_s":124.636,"end_s":141.465,"video_s":174.636,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00005","chapter":"C001","text":"We'll now call the meeting to order.","fingerprint":"ee911eddb603","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00020","start_s":141.866,"end_s":143.168,"video_s":191.866,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00006","chapter":"C001","text":"Will the clerk call the roll?","fingerprint":"89bb0df24607","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00021","start_s":143.536,"end_s":144.537,"video_s":193.536,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00007","chapter":"C001","text":"Councilwoman Guardado?","fingerprint":"725cada514c9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00022","start_s":144.677,"end_s":144.917,"video_s":194.677,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00008","chapter":"C001","text":"Here.","fingerprint":"fcec91509759","evidence":[{"kind":"agenda-record","source":"roll call on 'CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL'","recorded":"Present","result":"matches"}],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00023","start_s":145.538,"end_s":146.439,"video_s":195.538,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00009","chapter":"C001","text":"Councilwoman Hernandez?","fingerprint":"be943e39201c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00024","start_s":146.579,"end_s":146.799,"video_s":196.579,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00010","chapter":"C001","text":"Here.","fingerprint":"fcec91509759","evidence":[{"kind":"agenda-record","source":"roll call on 'CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL'","recorded":"Present","result":"matches"}],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00025","start_s":147.24,"end_s":148.12,"video_s":197.24,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00011","chapter":"C001","text":"Councilwoman O'Brien?","fingerprint":"003ed429bc6f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00026","start_s":148.521,"end_s":148.741,"video_s":198.521,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00012","chapter":"C001","text":"Here.","fingerprint":"fcec91509759","evidence":[{"kind":"agenda-record","source":"roll call on 'CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL'","recorded":"Present","result":"matches"}],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00027","start_s":149.262,"end_s":150.202,"video_s":199.262,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00013","chapter":"C001","text":"Councilwoman Pastor?","fingerprint":"dbcef12e9415","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00028","start_s":150.423,"end_s":150.623,"video_s":200.423,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00014","chapter":"C001","text":"Here.","fingerprint":"fcec91509759","evidence":[{"kind":"agenda-record","source":"roll call on 'CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL'","recorded":"Present","result":"matches"}],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00029","start_s":151.384,"end_s":152.244,"video_s":201.384,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00015","chapter":"C001","text":"Councilman Robinson?","fingerprint":"bd39baebf63f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00030","start_s":152.425,"end_s":152.625,"video_s":202.425,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00016","chapter":"C001","text":"Here.","fingerprint":"fcec91509759","evidence":[{"kind":"agenda-record","source":"roll call on 'CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL'","recorded":"Present","result":"matches"}],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00031","start_s":153.105,"end_s":154.126,"video_s":203.105,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00017","chapter":"C001","text":"Councilwoman Stark?","fingerprint":"f15b3cd9b019","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00032","start_s":154.146,"end_s":154.326,"video_s":204.146,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00018","chapter":"C001","text":"Here.","fingerprint":"fcec91509759","evidence":[{"kind":"agenda-record","source":"roll call on 'CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL'","recorded":"Present","result":"matches"}],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00033","start_s":154.847,"end_s":155.568,"video_s":204.847,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00019","chapter":"C001","text":"Councilman Waring?","fingerprint":"7cf533a8b87c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00034","start_s":156.449,"end_s":156.549,"video_s":206.449,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00020","chapter":"C001","text":"Here.","fingerprint":"fcec91509759","evidence":[{"kind":"agenda-record","source":"roll call on 'CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL'","recorded":"Present","result":"matches"}],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00035","start_s":156.569,"end_s":157.89,"video_s":206.569,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00021","chapter":"C001","text":"Vice Mayor Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"92c6a882f2f0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00036","start_s":158.07,"end_s":158.25,"video_s":208.07,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00022","chapter":"C001","text":"Here.","fingerprint":"fcec91509759","evidence":[{"kind":"agenda-record","source":"roll call on 'CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL'","recorded":"Present","result":"matches"}],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00037","start_s":158.891,"end_s":159.491,"video_s":208.891,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00023","chapter":"C001","text":"Mayor Gallego?","fingerprint":"d86fc0848ea6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00038","start_s":160.112,"end_s":160.252,"video_s":210.112,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00024","chapter":"C001","text":"Here.","fingerprint":"fcec91509759","evidence":[{"kind":"agenda-record","source":"roll call on 'CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL'","recorded":"Present","result":"matches"}],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00039","start_s":162.635,"end_s":166.038,"video_s":212.635,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00024","chapter":"C001","text":"Mario Barajas and Elsie Duarte are with us to provide Spanish interpretation.","fingerprint":"3fe98f436d96","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00040","start_s":166.058,"end_s":167.199,"video_s":216.058,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00024","chapter":"C001","text":"Mario, would you introduce your team?","fingerprint":"f1c3c980359f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00041","start_s":167.88,"end_s":168.4,"video_s":217.88,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00025","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes, Mayor.","fingerprint":"f16b9e8eb094","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00042","start_s":168.42,"end_s":169.341,"video_s":218.42,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00025","chapter":"C001","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00043","start_s":170.536,"end_s":172.74,"video_s":220.536,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00025","chapter":"C001","text":"As already mentioned, I'm Mario Barajas.","fingerprint":"9b2f82e1ce9a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00044","start_s":172.76,"end_s":177.427,"video_s":222.76,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00025","chapter":"C001","text":"I'll be working with Elsie Duarte as Spanish interpreters for our Spanish speaking residents.","fingerprint":"d51e13f91457","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00045","start_s":178.028,"end_s":183.437,"video_s":228.028,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00025","chapter":"C001","text":"I'll take a moment now to introduce ourselves to our Spanish speaking audience and also review a couple of guidelines.","fingerprint":"40fb2543792a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00046","start_s":184.078,"end_s":185.681,"video_s":234.078,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00025","chapter":"C001","text":"Buenas tardes, yo soy Mario Barajas.","fingerprint":"bdcc5af94a45","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"language","detail":"Spanish speech, transcribed as said"}]},{"id":"L00047","start_s":185.721,"end_s":190.148,"video_s":235.721,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00025","chapter":"C001","text":"Hoy esta trabajando junto con mi colega Elsie Duarte.","fingerprint":"d65f1095d222","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"possible-translation","detail":"this speaker also spoke Spanish here; this English line may be a machine translation, not their words"}]},{"id":"L00048","start_s":190.128,"end_s":196.815,"video_s":240.128,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00025","chapter":"C001","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[],"flags":[{"kind":"possible-translation","detail":"this speaker also spoke Spanish here; this English line may be a machine translation, not their words"}]},{"id":"L00049","start_s":197.336,"end_s":207.788,"video_s":247.336,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00025","chapter":"C001","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00050","start_s":207.808,"end_s":216.017,"video_s":257.808,"speaker":"mario-barajas","turn":"T00025","chapter":"C001","text":"Will the city clerk read the 24-hour paragraph?","fingerprint":"a89968a90ab6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00051","start_s":216.487,"end_s":224.159,"video_s":266.487,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00026","chapter":"C001","text":"The titles of the following ordinance and resolution numbers on the agenda were available to the public at least 24 hours prior to this council meeting and therefore may be read by title or agenda item only.","fingerprint":"1563ae4bf111","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00052","start_s":224.58,"end_s":231.571,"video_s":274.58,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00026","chapter":"C001","text":"Ordinances number G7471 and S52517, 52595 through 52626.","fingerprint":"fae8ab0d6899","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00053","start_s":234.876,"end_s":235.617,"video_s":284.876,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00027","chapter":"C001","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00054","start_s":236.038,"end_s":237.921,"video_s":286.038,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00027","chapter":"C001","text":"Will the city attorney explain the role of public comment?","fingerprint":"0492d3ec79fa","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00055","start_s":238.205,"end_s":239.087,"video_s":288.205,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00028","chapter":"C001","text":"Yes, thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"810f7bb9ebdf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00056","start_s":239.488,"end_s":243.096,"video_s":289.488,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00028","chapter":"C001","text":"Members of the public may speak for up to two minutes to comment on agenda items.","fingerprint":"fc6d2876d22d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00057","start_s":243.356,"end_s":247.986,"video_s":293.356,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00028","chapter":"C001","text":"Comments must be related to the agenda item in the action being considered by the council.","fingerprint":"07b1dc1378a3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00058","start_s":248.487,"end_s":254.741,"video_s":298.487,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00028","chapter":"C001","text":"General comments go beyond the scope of the agenda item should be made during the citizen comment session at the end of the agenda.","fingerprint":"d7ddeb4a29b5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00059","start_s":255.262,"end_s":258.188,"video_s":305.262,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00028","chapter":"C001","text":"The city council and staff cannot discuss or comment","fingerprint":"90613d8cc456","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00060","start_s":258.168,"end_s":261.592,"video_s":308.168,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00028","chapter":"C001","text":"on matters related to pending investigations, claims, or litigation.","fingerprint":"1903fcdff4ea","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00061","start_s":262.133,"end_s":270.924,"video_s":312.133,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00028","chapter":"C001","text":"Additionally, any member of the public who appears before the council in their capacity as a lobbyist must, as required by Phoenix City Code, disclose this fact before addressing the council.","fingerprint":"ec3f694263b6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00062","start_s":271.745,"end_s":275.61,"video_s":321.745,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00028","chapter":"C001","text":"City Code states that speakers must express their comments respectfully and courteously.","fingerprint":"32be1b3b3fcd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00063","start_s":276.151,"end_s":281.277,"video_s":326.151,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00028","chapter":"C001","text":"Use of profane language, threats, or personal attacks on members of the public, council members, or staff are not allowed.","fingerprint":"8b37bacb6b7f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00064","start_s":281.317,"end_s":285.002,"video_s":331.317,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00028","chapter":"C001","text":"Such comments are disruptive and unrelated to the council's business.","fingerprint":"77ffc08a1538","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00065","start_s":285.32,"end_s":289.825,"video_s":335.32,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00028","chapter":"C001","text":"Any person who violates these rules may lose their opportunity to speak further and could be asked to leave.","fingerprint":"a37c4a3765dc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00066","start_s":290.045,"end_s":290.386,"video_s":340.045,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00028","chapter":"C001","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00067","start_s":291.287,"end_s":292.007,"video_s":341.287,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00029","chapter":"C001","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00068","start_s":292.668,"end_s":297.173,"video_s":342.668,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00029","chapter":"C001","text":"And with public comment and at the end of the meeting, Blue Crowley, as promised, will be going first.","fingerprint":"4261b99087bc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00069","start_s":299.756,"end_s":301.398,"video_s":349.756,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00030","chapter":"C002","text":"Item number one is boards and commissions.","fingerprint":"904f60c5597c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00070","start_s":301.458,"end_s":302.599,"video_s":351.458,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00030","chapter":"C002","text":"Vice Mayor, do we have a motion?","fingerprint":"fb76ba8f4bfa","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00071","start_s":302.819,"end_s":306.904,"video_s":352.819,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00031","chapter":"C002","text":"Yes, motion to approve the Mayor and City Council's boards and commission nominations.","fingerprint":"ff1fbc12bcfe","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00072","start_s":307.745,"end_s":307.885,"video_s":357.745,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00031","chapter":"C002","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00073","start_s":308.135,"end_s":309.636,"video_s":358.135,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00032","chapter":"C002","text":"Motion is second, any comments?","fingerprint":"a1627377a599","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00074","start_s":310.197,"end_s":311.859,"video_s":360.197,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00032","chapter":"C002","text":"All those in favor say aye.","fingerprint":"a4221bb84d8e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00075","start_s":311.879,"end_s":312.619,"video_s":361.879,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00032","chapter":"C002","text":"Aye.","fingerprint":"4707c4fdc04e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00076","start_s":312.639,"end_s":313.22,"video_s":362.639,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00032","chapter":"C002","text":"Any opposed?","fingerprint":"912fd592ea04","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00077","start_s":313.94,"end_s":316.583,"video_s":363.94,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00032","chapter":"C002","text":"Passes unanimously and we will now conduct a swearing in ceremony.","fingerprint":"b8c409b38892","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00078","start_s":335.861,"end_s":336.842,"video_s":385.861,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00032","chapter":"C002","text":"Please raise your right hand.","fingerprint":"a5659d528c68","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00079","start_s":339.387,"end_s":340.229,"video_s":389.387,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00032","chapter":"C002","text":"I state your name.","fingerprint":"2c5eb3b50815","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00080","start_s":340.951,"end_s":356.991,"video_s":390.951,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00033","chapter":"C002","text":"I, Ruben Nock, do solemnly swear do solemnly swear that I will support the Constitution of the United States that I will support the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution and laws of the state of Arizona and the Constitution and laws of the state of Arizona that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same","fingerprint":"0a6028077357","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00081","start_s":357.325,"end_s":359.548,"video_s":407.325,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00033","chapter":"C002","text":"that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same.","fingerprint":"fb18a09f633b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00082","start_s":359.808,"end_s":361.01,"video_s":409.808,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00034","chapter":"C002","text":"And defend them against all enemies.","fingerprint":"2f713ab1022d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00083","start_s":361.35,"end_s":362.732,"video_s":411.35,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00035","chapter":"C002","text":"And defend them against all enemies.","fingerprint":"2f713ab1022d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00084","start_s":363.032,"end_s":363.813,"video_s":413.032,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00036","chapter":"C002","text":"Foreign and domestic.","fingerprint":"37668ca4ad5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00085","start_s":364.114,"end_s":365.055,"video_s":414.114,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00037","chapter":"C002","text":"Foreign and domestic.","fingerprint":"37668ca4ad5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00086","start_s":365.375,"end_s":366.697,"video_s":415.375,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00038","chapter":"C002","text":"And that I will faithfully and impartially.","fingerprint":"68e905db79b5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00087","start_s":367.137,"end_s":368.759,"video_s":417.137,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00039","chapter":"C002","text":"And I will faithfully and impartially.","fingerprint":"14b644633160","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00088","start_s":368.94,"end_s":370.461,"video_s":418.94,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00039","chapter":"C002","text":"Discharge the duties of the office of.","fingerprint":"12332ffb349c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00089","start_s":370.882,"end_s":372.744,"video_s":420.882,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00039","chapter":"C002","text":"Discharge the duties of the office of.","fingerprint":"12332ffb349c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00090","start_s":373.285,"end_s":375.167,"video_s":423.285,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00040","chapter":"C002","text":"North Mountain Village Planning Commission.","fingerprint":"481a54ba638c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00091","start_s":375.187,"end_s":376.689,"video_s":425.187,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00041","chapter":"C002","text":"North Mountain Village Planning Commission.","fingerprint":"481a54ba638c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00092","start_s":376.91,"end_s":377.931,"video_s":426.91,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00042","chapter":"C002","text":"According to the best of my ability.","fingerprint":"9b029dfa7161","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00093","start_s":378.211,"end_s":379.613,"video_s":428.211,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00043","chapter":"C002","text":"According to the best of my ability.","fingerprint":"9b029dfa7161","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00094","start_s":379.653,"end_s":380.174,"video_s":429.653,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00043","chapter":"C002","text":"So help me God.","fingerprint":"856b3c045092","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00095","start_s":380.314,"end_s":380.915,"video_s":430.314,"speaker":"v03","turn":"T00043","chapter":"C002","text":"So help me God.","fingerprint":"856b3c045092","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00096","start_s":380.995,"end_s":382.376,"video_s":430.995,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00044","chapter":"C002","text":"Congratulations, Commissioner.","fingerprint":"0f876be81c46","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00097","start_s":382.677,"end_s":382.877,"video_s":432.677,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00044","chapter":"C002","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00098","start_s":418.109,"end_s":420.714,"video_s":468.109,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00044","chapter":"C002","text":"Congratulations, Ruben.","fingerprint":"9acbc5157a69","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00099","start_s":422.396,"end_s":424.801,"video_s":472.396,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00044","chapter":"C002","text":"Next, we go to the liquor license portion of our agenda.","fingerprint":"6c5ed014a2f7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00100","start_s":424.821,"end_s":427.485,"video_s":474.821,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00044","chapter":"C002","text":"We provide an advisory role to the state of Arizona.","fingerprint":"3dc2bc3cb68f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00101","start_s":427.886,"end_s":429.068,"video_s":477.886,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00044","chapter":"C002","text":"Vice Mayor, do we have a motion?","fingerprint":"fb76ba8f4bfa","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00102","start_s":429.629,"end_s":432.955,"video_s":479.629,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00045","chapter":"C002","text":"Motion to approve items two through 12, except for item 12.","fingerprint":"3a29803a49e5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00103","start_s":433.195,"end_s":433.536,"video_s":483.195,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00045","chapter":"C002","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00104","start_s":433.916,"end_s":434.798,"video_s":483.916,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00046","chapter":"C002","text":"We have motion and a second.","fingerprint":"9c9b6c18f655","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00105","start_s":434.838,"end_s":435.92,"video_s":484.838,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00046","chapter":"C002","text":"All those in favor, please say aye.","fingerprint":"80a7b6856cc0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00106","start_s":436.541,"end_s":436.641,"video_s":486.541,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00046","chapter":"C002","text":"Aye.","fingerprint":"4707c4fdc04e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00107","start_s":438.004,"end_s":438.885,"video_s":488.004,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00046","chapter":"C002","text":"Any opposed, nay.","fingerprint":"f7daaedf3626","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00108","start_s":440.418,"end_s":446.044,"video_s":490.418,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00047","chapter":"C003","text":"We next go to agenda item 12, which is in Councilman O'Brien's district.","fingerprint":"8118698c6967","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00109","start_s":446.144,"end_s":447.806,"video_s":496.144,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00047","chapter":"C003","text":"It is the 27th Avenue Market.","fingerprint":"b2aa5456103b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00110","start_s":448.867,"end_s":453.913,"video_s":498.867,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00047","chapter":"C003","text":"Councilwoman, would you like to make a motion or hear a presentation?","fingerprint":"d51e99488ef6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00111","start_s":455.935,"end_s":457.257,"video_s":505.935,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00047","chapter":"C003","text":"Or hear from the public speaker?","fingerprint":"ccb58dc820cd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00112","start_s":457.957,"end_s":458.959,"video_s":507.957,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00048","chapter":"C003","text":"We have one speaker.","fingerprint":"0404a8d886bc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00113","start_s":458.979,"end_s":461.581,"video_s":508.979,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00049","chapter":"C003","text":"All right, Ismael, if you could come forward, please.","fingerprint":"59425cc4edc9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00114","start_s":462.222,"end_s":462.983,"video_s":512.222,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00049","chapter":"C003","text":"Marked in support.","fingerprint":"4ed2a230d398","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00115","start_s":467.789,"end_s":470.372,"video_s":517.789,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00050","chapter":"C003","text":"Good afternoon, mayor, vice mayor, members of the council.","fingerprint":"6e772be1350c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00116","start_s":470.732,"end_s":478.641,"video_s":520.732,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00050","chapter":"C003","text":"My name's Ishmael Abushinab, and I'm the applicant for the Series 10 liquor license for the property located at 8617 North 27th Avenue.","fingerprint":"12b35684939f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00117","start_s":479.622,"end_s":489.352,"video_s":529.622,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00050","chapter":"C003","text":"This location was previously operated under a Series 9 since 1983, and this license continues to be valid till today.","fingerprint":"271af440ffa1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00118","start_s":489.372,"end_s":496.48,"video_s":539.372,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00050","chapter":"C003","text":"A valid license is a license that has not been revoked, suspended, or transferred.","fingerprint":"0b327096f090","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00119","start_s":497.287,"end_s":502.996,"video_s":547.287,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00050","chapter":"C003","text":"and Circle K can activate their liquor license today and start selling hard liquor with no questions asked as of now.","fingerprint":"daee23a7f15d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00120","start_s":503.898,"end_s":511.791,"video_s":553.898,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00050","chapter":"C003","text":"This building has already cost us over half a million dollars and the homeless already vandalized all my HVAC units and compressors for my walk-in coolers.","fingerprint":"7e115cabbfe5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00121","start_s":512.412,"end_s":516.659,"video_s":562.412,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00050","chapter":"C003","text":"Keeping the building vacant will not do any good to the community or to the city.","fingerprint":"52e0a4528105","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00122","start_s":517.621,"end_s":523.21,"video_s":567.621,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00050","chapter":"C003","text":"The street transportation department notified me that we are within 300 feet of a nearby school.","fingerprint":"bc8a1b73bc92","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00123","start_s":523.747,"end_s":538.026,"video_s":573.747,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00050","chapter":"C003","text":"After doing some research, I pulled up the Arizona Revised Statute 4-207 subsection number five that allows a number 10 license if there's a valid license at the location, which it's still valid today.","fingerprint":"2940beb25844","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00124","start_s":538.799,"end_s":542.366,"video_s":588.799,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00050","chapter":"C003","text":"I proactively engaged with key community stakeholders.","fingerprint":"4118fbc27395","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00125","start_s":543.108,"end_s":554.091,"video_s":593.108,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00050","chapter":"C003","text":"I met with community leader, Jeff Spellman, Alta Vista Block Watch community organizer, Carlina Garza, 19 North Community Alliance Security Collaborator, which is Shannon McBride,","fingerprint":"c6bea92fcbe1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00126","start_s":554.071,"end_s":561.018,"video_s":604.071,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00050","chapter":"C003","text":"Phoenix Police Liquor and Abatement Officer, Javon Brown, as well as neighbors and surrounding community members.","fingerprint":"267173ee0044","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00127","start_s":561.819,"end_s":565.523,"video_s":611.819,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00050","chapter":"C003","text":"We even executed a neighborhood agreement to ensure the safety of the community.","fingerprint":"a191e4c84f68","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00128","start_s":566.344,"end_s":572.37,"video_s":616.344,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00050","chapter":"C003","text":"My goal is to operate a responsible, community-oriented business that contributes positively to the area.","fingerprint":"1802d4425b7b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00129","start_s":573.251,"end_s":581.58,"video_s":623.251,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00050","chapter":"C003","text":"I am committed to working closely with law enforcement, neighborhood leaders, and nearby residents to ensure the property is well-managed, safe, and an asset to the corridor.","fingerprint":"35c031ae1007","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00130","start_s":581.813,"end_s":588.0,"video_s":631.813,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00050","chapter":"C003","text":"I respectfully ask the city council to recommend approval of this series 10 license.","fingerprint":"d3989ef39c8c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00131","start_s":588.661,"end_s":590.223,"video_s":638.661,"speaker":"v04","turn":"T00050","chapter":"C003","text":"Thank you for your time and consideration.","fingerprint":"8ce4ab4f0271","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00132","start_s":591.164,"end_s":591.965,"video_s":641.164,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00051","chapter":"C003","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00133","start_s":592.185,"end_s":595.308,"video_s":642.185,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00051","chapter":"C003","text":"And then we have our new commissioners getting to work quickly.","fingerprint":"29a6a4463978","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00134","start_s":596.53,"end_s":598.072,"video_s":646.53,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00051","chapter":"C003","text":"Ruben is available to speak if necessary.","fingerprint":"768f0139d2bf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00135","start_s":598.092,"end_s":600.735,"video_s":648.092,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00051","chapter":"C003","text":"Ruben, would you like to speak?","fingerprint":"c2fc6e44073f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00136","start_s":600.755,"end_s":601.155,"video_s":650.755,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00051","chapter":"C003","text":"Where'd he go?","fingerprint":"45c9d60d6fa8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00137","start_s":604.859,"end_s":605.04,"video_s":654.859,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00051","chapter":"C003","text":"What?","fingerprint":"749ab2c0d06c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00138","start_s":606.541,"end_s":607.262,"video_s":656.541,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00051","chapter":"C003","text":"Okay, you're marked.","fingerprint":"10b0b7fa73af","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00139","start_s":607.442,"end_s":608.884,"video_s":657.442,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00051","chapter":"C003","text":"We should mark you in support.","fingerprint":"d95f7e8c45d4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00140","start_s":609.252,"end_s":610.694,"video_s":659.252,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00051","chapter":"C003","text":"All right, thank you so much.","fingerprint":"7a3586c8b9c1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00141","start_s":610.854,"end_s":611.996,"video_s":660.854,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00051","chapter":"C003","text":"I'll turn it to Councilman O'Brien.","fingerprint":"d42f9e2bd7e5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00142","start_s":612.517,"end_s":616.643,"video_s":662.517,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00052","chapter":"C003","text":"Thank you, Mayor, and I appreciate all the work you have done with the community.","fingerprint":"21b36d7819f0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00143","start_s":616.683,"end_s":622.751,"video_s":666.683,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00052","chapter":"C003","text":"With that understanding, I recommend, or I move to make no recommendation.","fingerprint":"06c49c3438f1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00144","start_s":624.554,"end_s":624.734,"video_s":674.554,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00053","chapter":"C003","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00145","start_s":624.754,"end_s":624.894,"video_s":674.754,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00053","chapter":"C003","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00146","start_s":625.315,"end_s":626.276,"video_s":675.315,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00054","chapter":"C003","text":"We have a motion and a second.","fingerprint":"7451ba811637","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00147","start_s":626.317,"end_s":626.717,"video_s":676.317,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00054","chapter":"C003","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00148","start_s":628.159,"end_s":628.6,"video_s":678.159,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00055","chapter":"C003","text":"Guardado.","fingerprint":"0344b48c3f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00149","start_s":628.86,"end_s":629.782,"video_s":678.86,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00055","chapter":"C003","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00150","start_s":629.802,"end_s":630.262,"video_s":679.802,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00055","chapter":"C003","text":"Hernandez.","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00151","start_s":630.483,"end_s":631.304,"video_s":680.483,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00055","chapter":"C003","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00152","start_s":631.324,"end_s":631.744,"video_s":681.324,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00055","chapter":"C003","text":"O'Brien.","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00153","start_s":632.165,"end_s":632.385,"video_s":682.165,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00055","chapter":"C003","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00154","start_s":632.986,"end_s":633.387,"video_s":682.986,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00055","chapter":"C003","text":"Pastor.","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00155","start_s":633.627,"end_s":634.368,"video_s":683.627,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00056","chapter":"C003","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00156","start_s":634.388,"end_s":634.829,"video_s":684.388,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00057","chapter":"C003","text":"Robinson.","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00157","start_s":635.109,"end_s":635.329,"video_s":685.109,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00058","chapter":"C003","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00158","start_s":635.85,"end_s":636.171,"video_s":685.85,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00059","chapter":"C003","text":"Stark.","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00159","start_s":636.391,"end_s":637.112,"video_s":686.391,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00059","chapter":"C003","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00160","start_s":637.132,"end_s":637.473,"video_s":687.132,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00059","chapter":"C003","text":"Waring.","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00161","start_s":638.314,"end_s":638.394,"video_s":688.314,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00059","chapter":"C003","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00162","start_s":638.414,"end_s":639.175,"video_s":688.414,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00059","chapter":"C003","text":"Hodge Washington.","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00163","start_s":639.273,"end_s":639.554,"video_s":689.273,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00059","chapter":"C003","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00164","start_s":640.014,"end_s":640.355,"video_s":690.014,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00059","chapter":"C003","text":"Gallego.","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00165","start_s":641.197,"end_s":641.417,"video_s":691.197,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00059","chapter":"C003","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00166","start_s":642.159,"end_s":642.639,"video_s":692.159,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00059","chapter":"C003","text":"Passes 9-0.","fingerprint":"f7c37e75fd84","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00167","start_s":645.084,"end_s":645.445,"video_s":695.084,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00060","chapter":"C003","text":"All right.","fingerprint":"dfbdd9492bec","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00168","start_s":645.545,"end_s":646.006,"video_s":695.545,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00060","chapter":"C003","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00169","start_s":646.747,"end_s":648.992,"video_s":696.747,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00060","chapter":"C003","text":"That concludes the liquor license portion of our agenda.","fingerprint":"8b1dcc666fbe","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00170","start_s":649.412,"end_s":653.36,"video_s":699.412,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00060","chapter":"C003","text":"City Clerk, are we ready for ordinances, resolutions, new business, planning, and zoning?","fingerprint":"de696fbf9cc1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00171","start_s":653.721,"end_s":654.142,"video_s":703.721,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00060","chapter":"C003","text":"Yes, Mayor.","fingerprint":"f16b9e8eb094","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00172","start_s":654.863,"end_s":655.965,"video_s":704.863,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00060","chapter":"C003","text":"Vice Mayor, do we have a motion?","fingerprint":"fb76ba8f4bfa","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00173","start_s":656.3,"end_s":656.58,"video_s":706.3,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00061","chapter":"C003","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00174","start_s":656.941,"end_s":660.485,"video_s":706.941,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00062","chapter":"C004","text":"Motion to approve items 13 through 48 except the following.","fingerprint":"daac05804755","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00175","start_s":660.645,"end_s":664.73,"video_s":710.645,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00062","chapter":"C004","text":"Items 13, 15, 21, 24, 26, and 30.","fingerprint":"656019c5b3f2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00176","start_s":665.291,"end_s":669.997,"video_s":715.291,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00062","chapter":"C004","text":"And can the clerk confirm if there are any other items that should be excluded for in-person public comment?","fingerprint":"e9d5cbf9ac45","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00177","start_s":671.739,"end_s":672.6,"video_s":721.739,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00063","chapter":"C004","text":"Yes, Mayor, Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"03d669af740a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00178","start_s":672.62,"end_s":676.265,"video_s":722.62,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00063","chapter":"C004","text":"Also excluding items 19, 36, and 37.","fingerprint":"834f374e9c54","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00179","start_s":676.285,"end_s":682.392,"video_s":726.285,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00063","chapter":"C004","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00180","start_s":685.139,"end_s":686.661,"video_s":735.139,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00064","chapter":"C004","text":"Thank you, we have a motion and a second.","fingerprint":"52138e013d8e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00181","start_s":686.861,"end_s":687.302,"video_s":736.861,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00064","chapter":"C004","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00182","start_s":688.363,"end_s":688.803,"video_s":738.363,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00064","chapter":"C004","text":"Guardado?","fingerprint":"0344b48c3f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00183","start_s":689.044,"end_s":689.684,"video_s":739.044,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00065","chapter":"C004","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00184","start_s":689.704,"end_s":690.385,"video_s":739.704,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00066","chapter":"C004","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00185","start_s":690.405,"end_s":691.106,"video_s":740.405,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00067","chapter":"C004","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00186","start_s":691.126,"end_s":691.567,"video_s":741.126,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00068","chapter":"C004","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00187","start_s":692.067,"end_s":692.748,"video_s":742.067,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00069","chapter":"C004","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00188","start_s":692.768,"end_s":693.168,"video_s":742.768,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00069","chapter":"C004","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00189","start_s":693.469,"end_s":694.15,"video_s":743.469,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00070","chapter":"C004","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00190","start_s":694.17,"end_s":694.63,"video_s":744.17,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00070","chapter":"C004","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00191","start_s":694.75,"end_s":695.011,"video_s":744.75,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00071","chapter":"C004","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00192","start_s":695.511,"end_s":695.852,"video_s":745.511,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00072","chapter":"C004","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00193","start_s":696.973,"end_s":697.313,"video_s":746.973,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00072","chapter":"C004","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00194","start_s":698.134,"end_s":698.214,"video_s":748.134,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00072","chapter":"C004","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00195","start_s":698.234,"end_s":698.875,"video_s":748.234,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00072","chapter":"C004","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00196","start_s":699.115,"end_s":699.776,"video_s":749.115,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00073","chapter":"C004","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00197","start_s":699.796,"end_s":700.117,"video_s":749.796,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00074","chapter":"C004","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00198","start_s":700.557,"end_s":701.138,"video_s":750.557,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00074","chapter":"C004","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00199","start_s":701.158,"end_s":701.719,"video_s":751.158,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00074","chapter":"C004","text":"Passes 9-0.","fingerprint":"f7c37e75fd84","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00200","start_s":702.82,"end_s":704.822,"video_s":752.82,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00075","chapter":"C005","text":"Item 13 is a settlement of a claim.","fingerprint":"3c787ff22b24","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00201","start_s":704.842,"end_s":705.423,"video_s":754.842,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00075","chapter":"C005","text":"13?","fingerprint":"3fdba35f04dc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00202","start_s":705.443,"end_s":705.623,"video_s":755.443,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00075","chapter":"C005","text":"Okay.","fingerprint":"6a581ee90118","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00203","start_s":707.605,"end_s":713.172,"video_s":757.605,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00075","chapter":"C005","text":"Do we have a motion on item 13?","fingerprint":"ed8e5c0b142a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00204","start_s":713.573,"end_s":714.835,"video_s":763.573,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00076","chapter":"C005","text":"Motion to approve item number 13.","fingerprint":"8e34f425fb3a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00205","start_s":714.855,"end_s":716.397,"video_s":764.855,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00077","chapter":"C005","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00206","start_s":716.417,"end_s":717.138,"video_s":766.417,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00077","chapter":"C005","text":"Councilman Hernandez.","fingerprint":"3bb873cefabf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00207","start_s":718.159,"end_s":718.66,"video_s":768.159,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00077","chapter":"C005","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00208","start_s":718.68,"end_s":722.204,"video_s":768.68,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00077","chapter":"C005","text":"Just have a couple of questions for probably PD and staff.","fingerprint":"15aba1cb616e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00209","start_s":723.366,"end_s":731.056,"video_s":773.366,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00077","chapter":"C005","text":"This is a second settlement payout that has been brought to the council in the last few months related to Phoenix police officers driving behaviors.","fingerprint":"b3f70a11e8ae","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00210","start_s":731.337,"end_s":737.004,"video_s":781.337,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00077","chapter":"C005","text":"We had a speeding case where the officer hit the resident and the resident's leg was broken in the collision.","fingerprint":"5e1a28b49c2f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00211","start_s":737.024,"end_s":739.167,"video_s":787.024,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00077","chapter":"C005","text":"And now we have this one.","fingerprint":"d4c91870c9a4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00212","start_s":740.008,"end_s":742.872,"video_s":790.008,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00077","chapter":"C005","text":"So just have a couple of questions for the chief.","fingerprint":"4c9d83b99648","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00213","start_s":742.852,"end_s":745.458,"video_s":792.852,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00077","chapter":"C005","text":"in more general terms.","fingerprint":"d21b01b3b17f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00214","start_s":746.881,"end_s":748.845,"video_s":796.881,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00077","chapter":"C005","text":"Thank you, Chief, for joining us at the table.","fingerprint":"f5edc0f96b4f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00215","start_s":748.905,"end_s":755.359,"video_s":798.905,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00077","chapter":"C005","text":"When these incidents happen, what improvements are taken back to the overall department?","fingerprint":"0b0f036794c4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00216","start_s":757.567,"end_s":759.231,"video_s":807.567,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00078","chapter":"C005","text":"Mayor, members of council, councilor Hernandez.","fingerprint":"fd77d495062d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00217","start_s":759.852,"end_s":770.415,"video_s":809.852,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00078","chapter":"C005","text":"When something like this happens, we have a supervisor respond to the scene to do the initial investigation, take photographs, interview all the parties involved, and then we create a report, an internal investigation.","fingerprint":"3e326dfc40ab","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00218","start_s":770.475,"end_s":775.305,"video_s":820.475,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00078","chapter":"C005","text":"So the officer is served the notice of investigation, is interviewed about what occurred,","fingerprint":"ccae31c8ad09","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00219","start_s":775.285,"end_s":798.762,"video_s":825.285,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00078","chapter":"C005","text":"and then that that is taken and that is sent to our driving analysis committee it's a group of people that are in the traffic bureau and they look over all that information driving instructors as well are on that committee and they look for any ways we could have avoided that and that's how we look at future training future opportunities and if we notice any kind of patterns then we'll address those patterns with the entire department","fingerprint":"08f62adbbc9f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00220","start_s":798.978,"end_s":800.28,"video_s":848.978,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00079","chapter":"C005","text":"Okay, thank you so much for that.","fingerprint":"ff286f2acee8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00221","start_s":801.501,"end_s":803.103,"video_s":851.501,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00079","chapter":"C005","text":"You kind of delved a little bit into that.","fingerprint":"ae0e34b90b84","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00222","start_s":803.243,"end_s":810.913,"video_s":853.243,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00079","chapter":"C005","text":"My next question was gonna be, how are we learning from these mistakes and improving officer driving behavior across the whole department?","fingerprint":"7970977f2418","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00223","start_s":810.973,"end_s":812.856,"video_s":860.973,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00079","chapter":"C005","text":"So can you elaborate a little bit more on that?","fingerprint":"0bdeb64c1fbb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00224","start_s":814.017,"end_s":820.125,"video_s":864.017,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00079","chapter":"C005","text":"Do you just share, like once you have those, you just mentioned in future training opportunities, so that goes department-wide?","fingerprint":"cb6fa6558f24","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00225","start_s":820.426,"end_s":821.127,"video_s":870.426,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00080","chapter":"C005","text":"It does.","fingerprint":"386ef68e8efd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00226","start_s":821.287,"end_s":825.855,"video_s":871.287,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00080","chapter":"C005","text":"We look at trends, we look at issues, and we look at our training to make sure they align.","fingerprint":"729682bfff86","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00227","start_s":826.176,"end_s":835.231,"video_s":876.176,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00080","chapter":"C005","text":"That makes sure our training is teaching officers how to drive safely, be cautious, and if we see trends trending one way where there's an issue, then we'll address those through additional training.","fingerprint":"5ae277502204","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00228","start_s":835.251,"end_s":836.252,"video_s":885.251,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00081","chapter":"C005","text":"Okay, thank you.","fingerprint":"21d63267fca8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00229","start_s":836.673,"end_s":845.067,"video_s":886.673,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00081","chapter":"C005","text":"And specifically for the officers that are involved in car accidents like this, before they return to driving,","fingerprint":"693d830e2b85","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00230","start_s":845.587,"end_s":848.75,"video_s":895.587,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00081","chapter":"C005","text":"It sounds like you kind of partially answered my next question.","fingerprint":"c6329b7cdbfc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00231","start_s":849.151,"end_s":851.413,"video_s":899.151,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00081","chapter":"C005","text":"What training do they have to participate in?","fingerprint":"7a81a344a96f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00232","start_s":851.493,"end_s":856.018,"video_s":901.493,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00081","chapter":"C005","text":"So would they go through this new training again or before they get back on the road?","fingerprint":"1da14f6b2aec","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00233","start_s":859.461,"end_s":861.243,"video_s":909.461,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00082","chapter":"C005","text":"Mayor, members of council, councilor Hernandez, yes.","fingerprint":"29d30a79e892","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00234","start_s":861.483,"end_s":865.347,"video_s":911.483,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00082","chapter":"C005","text":"What we do is we do training as a whole for departments.","fingerprint":"e17107434c45","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00235","start_s":865.367,"end_s":874.817,"video_s":915.367,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00082","chapter":"C005","text":"So we do basic training at the beginning when officers are in the academy, and then we try to do additional advanced officer training throughout the lifetime of an officer's career.","fingerprint":"bb7f4cf28ba5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00236","start_s":874.797,"end_s":901.581,"video_s":924.797,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00082","chapter":"C005","text":"if we did notice that someone had an issue with say was backing say they they backed into a pole accidents happen that's what they're called accidents but if there's a reason for that or we think they have a deficiency in a skill set we would look to bring them out to the academy and have them work with an individual instructor so we do look at the totality of the actual collision in general okay thank you thank you chief and um just my final question can um uh","fingerprint":"6978b37b0df4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00237","start_s":902.405,"end_s":906.392,"video_s":952.405,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00083","chapter":"C005","text":"I mean, how are officers held accountable for their roles in this?","fingerprint":"bd3d38c135d6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00238","start_s":906.432,"end_s":915.609,"video_s":956.432,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00083","chapter":"C005","text":"It sounds like you've already spoke a little bit to that, that you look at the totality of the events, you go back and look, you have the investigators on the scene that respond.","fingerprint":"dc576ab7490c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00239","start_s":916.27,"end_s":919.215,"video_s":966.27,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00083","chapter":"C005","text":"Is that just, am I missing anything there?","fingerprint":"68a5372b81cf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00240","start_s":919.195,"end_s":946.418,"video_s":969.195,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00084","chapter":"C005","text":"no the investigation is fully vetted fully fully investigated it goes to our driving analysis committee who decides whether the action of the officer was in policy or out of policy if they're out of policy then discipline normally follows in this case it was a supervisory counseling okay thank you so much um and i think you already walked through the disciplinary process but i'm not sure um can you is there anything you can add on the disciplinary process for driving violations","fingerprint":"40330173103f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00241","start_s":946.853,"end_s":949.057,"video_s":996.853,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00084","chapter":"C005","text":"It's no different than any other violation.","fingerprint":"4572a7887c54","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00242","start_s":949.458,"end_s":959.555,"video_s":999.458,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00084","chapter":"C005","text":"It would just go to whatever the misconduct or the violation of policy would be and what that accordingly is set forth in our policy for discipline.","fingerprint":"01b4b59aeb69","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00243","start_s":960.517,"end_s":965.385,"video_s":1010.517,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00084","chapter":"C005","text":"This was the first offense, traffic violation, so it was supervisory counseling.","fingerprint":"852b72245c65","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00244","start_s":965.365,"end_s":966.786,"video_s":1015.365,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C005","text":"Okay, thank you so much, Chief.","fingerprint":"6ca74d23c6ec","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00245","start_s":967.027,"end_s":968.068,"video_s":1017.027,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C005","text":"Those are all my questions.","fingerprint":"6fe70016e41a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00246","start_s":969.129,"end_s":975.475,"video_s":1019.129,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C005","text":"It's important for me that we work to assure that these type of accidents stop happening.","fingerprint":"b58d923f7264","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00247","start_s":976.055,"end_s":982.822,"video_s":1026.055,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C005","text":"We have to hold our officers to a high driving standard because we do give them license to use their vehicles differently.","fingerprint":"27b6426d8459","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00248","start_s":983.282,"end_s":990.449,"video_s":1033.282,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C005","text":"And we need to improve our trust with the community by clearly illustrating changes in behavior among our officers.","fingerprint":"16e87465fd8d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00249","start_s":990.769,"end_s":993.552,"video_s":1040.769,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C005","text":"So ultimately, this goes further than lawsuit payouts.","fingerprint":"233be26a9352","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00250","start_s":993.572,"end_s":994.933,"video_s":1043.572,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C005","text":"It's just really important about","fingerprint":"48ea8764d180","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00251","start_s":994.913,"end_s":998.137,"video_s":1044.913,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00085","chapter":"C005","text":"Thank you so much for answering my questions.","fingerprint":"6f2047711e23","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00252","start_s":998.398,"end_s":998.798,"video_s":1048.398,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00086","chapter":"C005","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00253","start_s":1000.0,"end_s":1000.42,"video_s":1050.0,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00086","chapter":"C005","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00254","start_s":1001.262,"end_s":1001.642,"video_s":1051.262,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00086","chapter":"C005","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00255","start_s":1002.183,"end_s":1002.644,"video_s":1052.183,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00086","chapter":"C005","text":"Guardado?","fingerprint":"0344b48c3f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00256","start_s":1003.004,"end_s":1003.785,"video_s":1053.004,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00087","chapter":"C005","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00257","start_s":1003.805,"end_s":1004.146,"video_s":1053.805,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00087","chapter":"C005","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00258","start_s":1004.346,"end_s":1005.027,"video_s":1054.346,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00087","chapter":"C005","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00259","start_s":1005.047,"end_s":1005.467,"video_s":1055.047,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00088","chapter":"C005","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00260","start_s":1005.648,"end_s":1005.908,"video_s":1055.648,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00089","chapter":"C005","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00261","start_s":1006.349,"end_s":1006.749,"video_s":1056.349,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00090","chapter":"C005","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00262","start_s":1006.989,"end_s":1007.61,"video_s":1056.989,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00090","chapter":"C005","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00263","start_s":1007.63,"end_s":1008.131,"video_s":1057.63,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00090","chapter":"C005","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00264","start_s":1008.311,"end_s":1008.532,"video_s":1058.311,"speaker":"v06","turn":"T00091","chapter":"C005","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00265","start_s":1009.052,"end_s":1009.393,"video_s":1059.052,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00092","chapter":"C005","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00266","start_s":1009.613,"end_s":1010.294,"video_s":1059.613,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00092","chapter":"C005","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00267","start_s":1010.314,"end_s":1010.634,"video_s":1060.314,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00092","chapter":"C005","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00268","start_s":1011.476,"end_s":1011.556,"video_s":1061.476,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00092","chapter":"C005","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00269","start_s":1011.576,"end_s":1012.197,"video_s":1061.576,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00092","chapter":"C005","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00270","start_s":1012.517,"end_s":1012.777,"video_s":1062.517,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00092","chapter":"C005","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00271","start_s":1013.178,"end_s":1013.618,"video_s":1063.178,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00093","chapter":"C005","text":"Vallejo?","fingerprint":"45ef290b4044","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00272","start_s":1013.799,"end_s":1014.339,"video_s":1063.799,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00094","chapter":"C005","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00273","start_s":1014.359,"end_s":1015.521,"video_s":1064.359,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00094","chapter":"C005","text":"Passes 9-0.","fingerprint":"f7c37e75fd84","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00274","start_s":1016.142,"end_s":1020.63,"video_s":1066.142,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00095","chapter":"C006","text":"Item 15 is a public hearing for the proposed 19th Avenue and Alameda Road annexation.","fingerprint":"a9142a60825c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00275","start_s":1021.331,"end_s":1022.473,"video_s":1071.331,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00095","chapter":"C006","text":"We will open the public hearing.","fingerprint":"6cf432452aa5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00276","start_s":1022.493,"end_s":1030.627,"video_s":1072.493,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00095","chapter":"C006","text":"We do not have any members of the public to comment during the hearing, so I will close the hearing.","fingerprint":"856a2668acf7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00277","start_s":1032.27,"end_s":1033.592,"video_s":1082.27,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00095","chapter":"C006","text":"There's no vote required today.","fingerprint":"fbc1f44d350b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00278","start_s":1033.632,"end_s":1035.315,"video_s":1083.632,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00095","chapter":"C006","text":"Do any council members have a comment?","fingerprint":"785f5fb78b96","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00279","start_s":1036.291,"end_s":1042.086,"video_s":1086.291,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00095","chapter":"C006","text":"All right, seeing none, I will go on to 19, which is Camelback and 15th Avenue.","fingerprint":"21afa47b6a67","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00280","start_s":1042.126,"end_s":1044.713,"video_s":1092.126,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00095","chapter":"C006","text":"It's property acquisition for our streets department.","fingerprint":"ab7d5b1d3bb8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00281","start_s":1045.074,"end_s":1045.716,"video_s":1095.074,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00095","chapter":"C006","text":"Do we have a motion?","fingerprint":"ea97412996cb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00282","start_s":1046.518,"end_s":1047.942,"video_s":1096.518,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00096","chapter":"C006","text":"Motion to approve item 19.","fingerprint":"035aa1bf9637","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00283","start_s":1048.383,"end_s":1048.925,"video_s":1098.383,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00096","chapter":"C006","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00284","start_s":1048.945,"end_s":1049.707,"video_s":1098.945,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00097","chapter":"C006","text":"Motion and a second.","fingerprint":"9b5eb76aa224","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00285","start_s":1049.747,"end_s":1051.752,"video_s":1099.747,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00097","chapter":"C006","text":"Blue Crowley is here to provide comment.","fingerprint":"b062e0405395","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00286","start_s":1064.962,"end_s":1067.605,"video_s":1114.962,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00098","chapter":"C006","text":"Give you a little history on that area.","fingerprint":"471bf26d8c74","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00287","start_s":1067.626,"end_s":1072.592,"video_s":1117.626,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00098","chapter":"C006","text":"I was an Alhambra Village Planning Committee member and it's right in the heart of Alhambra Village.","fingerprint":"2180de9e785c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00288","start_s":1072.672,"end_s":1088.994,"video_s":1122.672,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00098","chapter":"C006","text":"And I want to thank Laura that in your district we are looking at and adjusting some of the discrepancies on the ADA and making sure we've got curb cuts and cut arounds that in that area.","fingerprint":"0b49fab4b687","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00289","start_s":1089.054,"end_s":1090.936,"video_s":1139.054,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00098","chapter":"C006","text":"How long ago should it have been done?","fingerprint":"f0e90d452420","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00290","start_s":1091.317,"end_s":1093.72,"video_s":1141.317,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00098","chapter":"C006","text":"Well, we'll just leave that on the table.","fingerprint":"7fe0e8fba31e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00291","start_s":1094.628,"end_s":1105.907,"video_s":1144.628,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00098","chapter":"C006","text":"but I also look at that area and all of the different transit options and one of the ones is there's a bus on 15th Avenue.","fingerprint":"0cbebc0688d7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00292","start_s":1107.91,"end_s":1110.355,"video_s":1157.91,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00098","chapter":"C006","text":"Is the infrastructure also there?","fingerprint":"7a4b7d125113","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00293","start_s":1111.597,"end_s":1117.286,"video_s":1161.597,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00098","chapter":"C006","text":"How many bus stops aren't up to status quo?","fingerprint":"ba5d3d2e83d9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00294","start_s":1118.609,"end_s":1120.652,"video_s":1168.609,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00098","chapter":"C006","text":"Just a thought, y'all.","fingerprint":"b0fcb69092c3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00295","start_s":1121.088,"end_s":1135.467,"video_s":1171.088,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00098","chapter":"C006","text":"and if that is that there have to be 36 individuals stopping there to get an actual bus and shelter, that's BS because what we need to do is get the system out there.","fingerprint":"ba84606f0505","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00296","start_s":1136.048,"end_s":1149.947,"video_s":1186.048,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00098","chapter":"C006","text":"So when I see the total discrepancy in the amount of bus acquisitions that are supposed to be going on as in with the mag prop, what is it, 469,","fingerprint":"6e0c84be67d2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00297","start_s":1150.568,"end_s":1155.092,"video_s":1200.568,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00098","chapter":"C006","text":"that states that light rail gets how much?","fingerprint":"f8bc63cf5c18","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00298","start_s":1156.513,"end_s":1158.776,"video_s":1206.513,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00098","chapter":"C006","text":"And how much is supposed to go to the bus?","fingerprint":"023084729cec","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00299","start_s":1160.357,"end_s":1172.008,"video_s":1210.357,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00098","chapter":"C006","text":"Well, in the past, with the leadership of Ed over there, rail got most of all the monies that were over there at the RPTA.","fingerprint":"e4d23d68451c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00300","start_s":1173.429,"end_s":1178.113,"video_s":1223.429,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00098","chapter":"C006","text":"And continuously, I asked, where's the buses?","fingerprint":"45c94822f2e8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00301","start_s":1178.694,"end_s":1180.035,"video_s":1228.694,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00098","chapter":"C006","text":"Where's the buses?","fingerprint":"30563ef408c4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00302","start_s":1180.319,"end_s":1183.544,"video_s":1230.319,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00098","chapter":"C006","text":"Why couldn't you do it according to what was supposed to be done?","fingerprint":"fadb48c1725a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00303","start_s":1184.065,"end_s":1187.511,"video_s":1234.065,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00098","chapter":"C006","text":"And that way we've got buses and the bus stops.","fingerprint":"d9b0338bcb76","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00304","start_s":1188.252,"end_s":1188.713,"video_s":1238.252,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00098","chapter":"C006","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00305","start_s":1190.476,"end_s":1191.237,"video_s":1240.476,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00099","chapter":"C006","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00306","start_s":1192.359,"end_s":1193.701,"video_s":1242.359,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00100","chapter":"C006","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00307","start_s":1193.721,"end_s":1194.362,"video_s":1243.721,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00100","chapter":"C006","text":"Guardado?","fingerprint":"0344b48c3f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00308","start_s":1194.382,"end_s":1195.123,"video_s":1244.382,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00100","chapter":"C006","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00309","start_s":1195.143,"end_s":1195.944,"video_s":1245.143,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00100","chapter":"C006","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00310","start_s":1195.964,"end_s":1196.165,"video_s":1245.964,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00100","chapter":"C006","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00311","start_s":1196.605,"end_s":1197.006,"video_s":1246.605,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00100","chapter":"C006","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00312","start_s":1197.246,"end_s":1197.407,"video_s":1247.246,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00100","chapter":"C006","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00313","start_s":1198.008,"end_s":1198.428,"video_s":1248.008,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00100","chapter":"C006","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00314","start_s":1198.649,"end_s":1199.41,"video_s":1248.649,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00101","chapter":"C006","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00315","start_s":1199.43,"end_s":1199.911,"video_s":1249.43,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00102","chapter":"C006","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00316","start_s":1200.051,"end_s":1200.291,"video_s":1250.051,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00103","chapter":"C006","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00317","start_s":1200.872,"end_s":1201.433,"video_s":1250.872,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00104","chapter":"C006","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00318","start_s":1201.453,"end_s":1202.335,"video_s":1251.453,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00104","chapter":"C006","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00319","start_s":1202.355,"end_s":1202.695,"video_s":1252.355,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00104","chapter":"C006","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00320","start_s":1203.537,"end_s":1203.617,"video_s":1253.537,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00104","chapter":"C006","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00321","start_s":1203.637,"end_s":1204.298,"video_s":1253.637,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00104","chapter":"C006","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00322","start_s":1204.498,"end_s":1204.759,"video_s":1254.498,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00104","chapter":"C006","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00323","start_s":1205.219,"end_s":1206.041,"video_s":1255.219,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00104","chapter":"C006","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00324","start_s":1206.061,"end_s":1206.522,"video_s":1256.061,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00104","chapter":"C006","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00325","start_s":1206.542,"end_s":1207.423,"video_s":1256.542,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00104","chapter":"C006","text":"Passes 9-0.","fingerprint":"f7c37e75fd84","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00326","start_s":1209.479,"end_s":1221.398,"video_s":1259.479,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00105","chapter":"C007","text":"Item 21 is amendments to our city's combined classification pay ordinance and the 2026.05 recommendations.","fingerprint":"c305bb22cb51","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00327","start_s":1221.538,"end_s":1222.219,"video_s":1271.538,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00105","chapter":"C007","text":"Do we have a motion?","fingerprint":"ea97412996cb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00328","start_s":1222.8,"end_s":1223.922,"video_s":1272.8,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00106","chapter":"C007","text":"Motion to approve item 21.","fingerprint":"944d69c0cb13","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00329","start_s":1224.042,"end_s":1225.625,"video_s":1274.042,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00106","chapter":"C007","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00330","start_s":1225.645,"end_s":1226.967,"video_s":1275.645,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00107","chapter":"C007","text":"We have a motion and a second.","fingerprint":"7451ba811637","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00331","start_s":1227.007,"end_s":1231.154,"video_s":1277.007,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00107","chapter":"C007","text":"So this would allow increased compensation for certain employees.","fingerprint":"33fd76bba1af","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00332","start_s":1231.194,"end_s":1233.337,"video_s":1281.194,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00107","chapter":"C007","text":"We do have one comment on this.","fingerprint":"bb16c602a875","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00333","start_s":1233.437,"end_s":1235.2,"video_s":1283.437,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00107","chapter":"C007","text":"Tyler Smith, the floor is yours.","fingerprint":"2b965da623fb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00334","start_s":1242.368,"end_s":1245.994,"video_s":1292.368,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C007","text":"Good afternoon, Mayor, Vice Mayor, and Council Members.","fingerprint":"b0138f3bdd26","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00335","start_s":1246.856,"end_s":1253.186,"video_s":1296.856,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C007","text":"My name is Tyler Smith and I serve as a Senior Program Supervisor 1 with the City of Phoenix Human Services Department.","fingerprint":"e300ffb3b8ae","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00336","start_s":1253.988,"end_s":1259.136,"video_s":1303.988,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C007","text":"Myself and my colleagues have taken our personal time to be here today to discuss this matter.","fingerprint":"e5bd876823bb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00337","start_s":1259.898,"end_s":1267.11,"video_s":1309.898,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C007","text":"Some of you also may know me as the President of the City of Phoenix LGBTQ Employee Alliance and Allies Employee Resource Group.","fingerprint":"feefec004588","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00338","start_s":1267.09,"end_s":1277.37,"video_s":1317.09,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C007","text":"I'm here today speaking on behalf of the eight senior program supervisors who are present with me and representing all 15 senior program supervisors who serve residents across the city of Phoenix.","fingerprint":"448f7147df1a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00339","start_s":1277.772,"end_s":1282.378,"video_s":1327.772,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C007","text":"We are here because we deeply care about the work we do and about the residents we serve.","fingerprint":"23dac7a4320d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00340","start_s":1282.879,"end_s":1286.263,"video_s":1332.879,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C007","text":"Every day we manage city facilities that serve thousands of older adults.","fingerprint":"6a3706ccf832","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00341","start_s":1286.644,"end_s":1291.069,"video_s":1336.644,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C007","text":"For many of our members, our senior centers are not just recreation sites, they are lifelines.","fingerprint":"d4d48075c067","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00342","start_s":1291.63,"end_s":1299.24,"video_s":1341.63,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C007","text":"They are places where seniors receive meals, social connection, health resources, and support during some of the most vulnerable stages of their lives.","fingerprint":"25d1c62e7270","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00343","start_s":1299.22,"end_s":1301.782,"video_s":1349.22,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C007","text":"Our role goes far beyond programming activities.","fingerprint":"eb83344500a9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00344","start_s":1302.243,"end_s":1303.964,"video_s":1352.243,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C007","text":"We supervise staff and volunteers.","fingerprint":"40f3841936b4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00345","start_s":1304.024,"end_s":1306.567,"video_s":1354.024,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C007","text":"We manage public budgets and ensure fiscal accountability.","fingerprint":"605ca53c3579","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00346","start_s":1306.627,"end_s":1309.59,"video_s":1356.627,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C007","text":"We oversee facility safety and ADA compliance.","fingerprint":"2ba3365179c6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00347","start_s":1310.05,"end_s":1312.512,"video_s":1360.05,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C007","text":"We provide case management to our seniors.","fingerprint":"af566a4f23e0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00348","start_s":1312.613,"end_s":1315.175,"video_s":1362.613,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C007","text":"We coordinate with community partners and outside agencies.","fingerprint":"adcb3bb268a0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00349","start_s":1315.715,"end_s":1319.499,"video_s":1365.715,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C007","text":"And we also implement monthly and weekly special events with hundreds of members in attendance.","fingerprint":"696b2c639dad","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00350","start_s":1320.14,"end_s":1324.043,"video_s":1370.14,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C007","text":"But we also carry specialized responsibilities that are unique and deeply personal.","fingerprint":"ac821df4e10e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00351","start_s":1324.564,"end_s":1328.147,"video_s":1374.564,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C007","text":"All senior program supervisors are dementia-friendly certified.","fingerprint":"4a1a7eda298d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00352","start_s":1328.33,"end_s":1339.643,"video_s":1378.33,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C007","text":"That means we receive specific training to work effectively with individuals living with Alzheimer's and dementia and to support their caregivers who are often overwhelmed and searching for help.","fingerprint":"ddcbe6cacdca","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00353","start_s":1339.663,"end_s":1344.588,"video_s":1389.663,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C007","text":"We facilitate monthly memory cafe programs to create safe, welcoming spaces for those families.","fingerprint":"0068350bea12","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00354","start_s":1345.069,"end_s":1353.038,"video_s":1395.069,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C007","text":"We also maintain food manager certifications to oversee congregate meal programs, ensuring health code compliance and safe food service for hundreds of seniors each day.","fingerprint":"810cd76982b6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00355","start_s":1353.743,"end_s":1355.545,"video_s":1403.743,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C007","text":"These are not small responsibilities.","fingerprint":"9251dfbe0b01","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00356","start_s":1356.025,"end_s":1359.289,"video_s":1406.025,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C007","text":"They require leadership, training, regulatory knowledge, and compassion.","fingerprint":"125a538ac34c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00357","start_s":1359.689,"end_s":1363.113,"video_s":1409.689,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C007","text":"Despite this, our position remains classified at pay grade 059.","fingerprint":"8ba82aad7081","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00358","start_s":1364.094,"end_s":1364.214,"video_s":1414.094,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C007","text":"Sorry.","fingerprint":"484aab2f2cd0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00359","start_s":1364.995,"end_s":1365.355,"video_s":1414.995,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00108","chapter":"C007","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00360","start_s":1366.576,"end_s":1371.462,"video_s":1416.576,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00109","chapter":"C007","text":"Thank you so much for your important work on behalf of the city, and thank you to all of your colleagues.","fingerprint":"ffec16af6859","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00361","start_s":1371.482,"end_s":1372.182,"video_s":1421.482,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00109","chapter":"C007","text":"Councilman Hernandez.","fingerprint":"3bb873cefabf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00362","start_s":1372.783,"end_s":1373.263,"video_s":1422.783,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00110","chapter":"C007","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00363","start_s":1373.424,"end_s":1374.565,"video_s":1423.424,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00110","chapter":"C007","text":"Just have a quick question, Tyler.","fingerprint":"970b781f1221","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00364","start_s":1374.965,"end_s":1376.667,"video_s":1424.965,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00110","chapter":"C007","text":"Are you supportive of the agenda item?","fingerprint":"2f51bc1d5797","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00365","start_s":1376.927,"end_s":1377.608,"video_s":1426.927,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00110","chapter":"C007","text":"I think...","fingerprint":"7d94a03eaf31","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00366","start_s":1377.858,"end_s":1380.605,"video_s":1427.858,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00110","chapter":"C007","text":"You might have been getting to that point at the end of your testimony.","fingerprint":"cba8ce872d3e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00367","start_s":1381.046,"end_s":1383.854,"video_s":1431.046,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00110","chapter":"C007","text":"Are you supportive of the agenda item?","fingerprint":"2f51bc1d5797","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00368","start_s":1383.874,"end_s":1386.08,"video_s":1433.874,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00111","chapter":"C007","text":"We're opposing the suggested pay grade at 052.","fingerprint":"eef198c3cc1d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00369","start_s":1386.761,"end_s":1389.007,"video_s":1436.761,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00111","chapter":"C007","text":"We're advocating for a higher pay grade.","fingerprint":"55a8f8ba8073","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00370","start_s":1389.629,"end_s":1390.03,"video_s":1439.629,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00111","chapter":"C007","text":"Okay, thank you.","fingerprint":"21d63267fca8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00371","start_s":1390.471,"end_s":1390.872,"video_s":1440.471,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00111","chapter":"C007","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00372","start_s":1393.957,"end_s":1395.139,"video_s":1443.957,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00112","chapter":"C007","text":"Councilman Pastor.","fingerprint":"0191e87b0f41","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00373","start_s":1395.88,"end_s":1396.0,"video_s":1445.88,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00113","chapter":"C007","text":"Hi.","fingerprint":"8f434346648f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00374","start_s":1397.241,"end_s":1397.802,"video_s":1447.241,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00113","chapter":"C007","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00375","start_s":1397.822,"end_s":1408.256,"video_s":1447.822,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00113","chapter":"C007","text":"I first want to recognize our HRC committees or those that serve our seniors.","fingerprint":"1377a4433576","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00376","start_s":1408.476,"end_s":1414.885,"video_s":1458.476,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00113","chapter":"C007","text":"I have witnessed, at least at Adam Diaz and at the Chinese Cultural Center,","fingerprint":"3de5f47e2043","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00377","start_s":1415.168,"end_s":1425.136,"video_s":1465.168,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00113","chapter":"C007","text":"The care that happens to our seniors and how they are guided, especially those that are, need a little extra hand and help.","fingerprint":"7d26edaffd77","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00378","start_s":1425.156,"end_s":1428.586,"video_s":1475.156,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00113","chapter":"C007","text":"So I wanna acknowledge and thank you for that.","fingerprint":"b49ef16de411","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00379","start_s":1429.829,"end_s":1430.832,"video_s":1479.829,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00113","chapter":"C007","text":"Secondly,","fingerprint":"8b21dd5073ed","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00380","start_s":1431.79,"end_s":1441.141,"video_s":1481.79,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00113","chapter":"C007","text":"I wanna ask, we have done this several times of classification paid ordinances over maybe the last several months.","fingerprint":"bc177e57ed95","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00381","start_s":1442.463,"end_s":1456.92,"video_s":1492.463,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00113","chapter":"C007","text":"My question is when these areas are reclassified and they have a range, at what point do those employees in the reclassification","fingerprint":"d85dca53d836","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00382","start_s":1457.407,"end_s":1461.974,"video_s":1507.407,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00113","chapter":"C007","text":"are reclassified and start receiving the money, or who determines that?","fingerprint":"075f2e876f95","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00383","start_s":1467.102,"end_s":1467.403,"video_s":1517.102,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00114","chapter":"C007","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00384","start_s":1467.423,"end_s":1468.865,"video_s":1517.423,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00114","chapter":"C007","text":"Good afternoon, Mayor, members of council.","fingerprint":"28509dcc3c1f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00385","start_s":1469.306,"end_s":1480.884,"video_s":1519.306,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00114","chapter":"C007","text":"Councilwoman Pastore, if I understand your question, you're asking with regard to specific employees' pay grades that have been regraded, who then determines whether or not they move up into the new grade, is that correct?","fingerprint":"a3c9af8dbd73","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00386","start_s":1481.325,"end_s":1481.966,"video_s":1531.325,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00114","chapter":"C007","text":"Correct.","fingerprint":"15a596e3c98c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00387","start_s":1481.986,"end_s":1484.73,"video_s":1531.986,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00114","chapter":"C007","text":"Well, the incumbents would automatically move up along","fingerprint":"f384196d9e8e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00388","start_s":1485.014,"end_s":1486.897,"video_s":1535.014,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00114","chapter":"C007","text":"with the new pay grade increase.","fingerprint":"62e4756590ce","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00389","start_s":1487.117,"end_s":1498.712,"video_s":1537.117,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00114","chapter":"C007","text":"And because this increase is one of an odd number of steps, the way that our step plans are designed, this would equate to approximately 2.5% increase for each of these individuals.","fingerprint":"4180a26e3198","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00390","start_s":1500.315,"end_s":1508.946,"video_s":1550.315,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00115","chapter":"C007","text":"But when we pass these items, does HR go in and say, okay, your grade is, I'm gonna make up a grade.","fingerprint":"ee6a49fdf8ba","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00391","start_s":1509.707,"end_s":1514.734,"video_s":1559.707,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00115","chapter":"C007","text":"Your grade currently is 12, but the reclassification moved to 14,","fingerprint":"fe1cb5ac9601","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00392","start_s":1515.136,"end_s":1518.7,"video_s":1565.136,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00115","chapter":"C007","text":"and now we're gonna reclassify from a 12 to a 14.","fingerprint":"b015e04b2558","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00393","start_s":1518.74,"end_s":1523.987,"video_s":1568.74,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00115","chapter":"C007","text":"Does HR automatically do that or does a director determine that?","fingerprint":"2d37a20834e6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00394","start_s":1524.087,"end_s":1525.268,"video_s":1574.087,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00115","chapter":"C007","text":"How does this play out?","fingerprint":"ea59aba40dcc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00395","start_s":1526.169,"end_s":1530.895,"video_s":1576.169,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00116","chapter":"C007","text":"So the pay grade itself is attached to the specific classifications.","fingerprint":"96849b468deb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00396","start_s":1531.176,"end_s":1535.501,"video_s":1581.176,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00116","chapter":"C007","text":"So when that classification is regraded then it would be automatic.","fingerprint":"8dea877c5278","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00397","start_s":1535.561,"end_s":1541.368,"video_s":1585.561,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00116","chapter":"C007","text":"It wouldn't be up to an individual director or somebody to say these people will move in, others will not.","fingerprint":"b1929b6efca5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00398","start_s":1541.488,"end_s":1543.05,"video_s":1591.488,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00116","chapter":"C007","text":"It would be everybody in that classification.","fingerprint":"4db01711fe39","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00399","start_s":1543.807,"end_s":1547.492,"video_s":1593.807,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00117","chapter":"C007","text":"Okay, so everybody in that classification will automatically be.","fingerprint":"f1e3e483098c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00400","start_s":1548.814,"end_s":1550.937,"video_s":1598.814,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00117","chapter":"C007","text":"And then sometimes we do it in a range.","fingerprint":"696761705421","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00401","start_s":1551.938,"end_s":1563.914,"video_s":1601.938,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00117","chapter":"C007","text":"Classification 15, say, is 20, 20, and we have now voted on a reclassification of a range from maybe 20 to 60.","fingerprint":"8ce7cf59aa31","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00402","start_s":1565.096,"end_s":1566.878,"video_s":1615.096,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00117","chapter":"C007","text":"Then who determines that?","fingerprint":"bc18e8725dbc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00403","start_s":1569.271,"end_s":1576.122,"video_s":1619.271,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00118","chapter":"C007","text":"So our system is actually a system of step increases, as you're aware, with approximately 5% between each step.","fingerprint":"6611aeb9c883","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00404","start_s":1576.403,"end_s":1590.165,"video_s":1626.403,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00118","chapter":"C007","text":"So when you see the beginning and the end of that range, if you will, it is actually the lowest step and the highest step, and each individual would move along in those steps with their normal increase.","fingerprint":"a6d53a8347ec","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00405","start_s":1592.862,"end_s":1605.58,"video_s":1642.862,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00118","chapter":"C007","text":"Oh, so for the open ranges, those classifications, that's determined by employees' individual MAPS scores, which is an annual process handled by the city manager's office.","fingerprint":"6583b1023553","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00406","start_s":1607.002,"end_s":1614.132,"video_s":1657.002,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00119","chapter":"C007","text":"Okay, so it's determined, when that happens, it's determined by their MAPS scores, which I'm assuming that's their evaluation?","fingerprint":"a329e8f974c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00407","start_s":1614.833,"end_s":1616.175,"video_s":1664.833,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00120","chapter":"C007","text":"That's correct, that's their annual evaluation.","fingerprint":"d970e5182a14","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00408","start_s":1616.195,"end_s":1621.502,"video_s":1666.195,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00121","chapter":"C007","text":"Okay, so it's determined by their evaluation and what's on their evaluation, and then it's determined by the city manager?","fingerprint":"84ed9747600a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00409","start_s":1621.87,"end_s":1624.214,"video_s":1671.87,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00122","chapter":"C007","text":"City Manager has the final authority on that.","fingerprint":"bec10d329e9a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00410","start_s":1624.274,"end_s":1624.435,"video_s":1674.274,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00123","chapter":"C007","text":"Okay.","fingerprint":"6a581ee90118","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00411","start_s":1624.775,"end_s":1624.976,"video_s":1674.775,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00123","chapter":"C007","text":"All right.","fingerprint":"dfbdd9492bec","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00412","start_s":1625.236,"end_s":1625.597,"video_s":1675.236,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00123","chapter":"C007","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00413","start_s":1630.486,"end_s":1631.288,"video_s":1680.486,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00124","chapter":"C007","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00414","start_s":1631.448,"end_s":1632.249,"video_s":1681.448,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00124","chapter":"C007","text":"Councilwoman Stark.","fingerprint":"f15b3cd9b019","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00415","start_s":1635.014,"end_s":1638.501,"video_s":1685.014,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00125","chapter":"C007","text":"Can Tyler come back up for a minute?","fingerprint":"2ef63cb7d9f5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00416","start_s":1638.521,"end_s":1638.801,"video_s":1688.521,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00125","chapter":"C007","text":"I'm sorry.","fingerprint":"308815590952","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00417","start_s":1638.822,"end_s":1640.244,"video_s":1688.822,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00125","chapter":"C007","text":"I should have asked this when he was up here.","fingerprint":"61d4a795f203","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00418","start_s":1640.264,"end_s":1641.246,"video_s":1690.264,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00125","chapter":"C007","text":"I apologize.","fingerprint":"2c77a47f05b2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00419","start_s":1644.736,"end_s":1648.143,"video_s":1694.736,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00125","chapter":"C007","text":"So first off, for the record, I know Tyler quite well.","fingerprint":"2190ad6b2b32","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00420","start_s":1648.684,"end_s":1653.934,"video_s":1698.684,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00125","chapter":"C007","text":"And he is beloved by the senior center in my district.","fingerprint":"ea193ac5b508","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00421","start_s":1654.135,"end_s":1660.087,"video_s":1704.135,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00125","chapter":"C007","text":"And I think he did an excellent speech in explaining what they do.","fingerprint":"ecdbe9d9f5a3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00422","start_s":1660.127,"end_s":1661.51,"video_s":1710.127,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00125","chapter":"C007","text":"They have a very important role.","fingerprint":"7d418da5a5f0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00423","start_s":1661.91,"end_s":1663.273,"video_s":1711.91,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00125","chapter":"C007","text":"So I want to just turn to you.","fingerprint":"08ee89976a96","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00424","start_s":1663.293,"end_s":1666.66,"video_s":1713.293,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00125","chapter":"C007","text":"And Tyler, what do you feel your grades should be?","fingerprint":"37acb57975ed","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00425","start_s":1668.783,"end_s":1671.067,"video_s":1718.783,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00125","chapter":"C007","text":"Not to put you on the spot, but I'm sure you've thought about this.","fingerprint":"abe76894f393","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00426","start_s":1671.667,"end_s":1672.789,"video_s":1721.667,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00126","chapter":"C007","text":"Thank you, Councilwoman.","fingerprint":"a418fa2d089e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00427","start_s":1673.55,"end_s":1682.144,"video_s":1723.55,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00126","chapter":"C007","text":"Yes, so we, as a collective, as a senior program, Supervisor Ones, feel we should be at the pay grade in the range of 059 to 061.","fingerprint":"fa2dd39c8a61","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00428","start_s":1682.424,"end_s":1694.082,"video_s":1732.424,"speaker":"v08","turn":"T00126","chapter":"C007","text":"That's just because of the comparison positions, such as caseworker threes and recreation coordinator threes that are very similar to what we do in our positions.","fingerprint":"0e04da152286","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00429","start_s":1698.517,"end_s":1701.903,"video_s":1748.517,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00127","chapter":"C007","text":"So I guess I'm prejudiced here.","fingerprint":"1a9d785c5998","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00430","start_s":1701.923,"end_s":1703.707,"video_s":1751.923,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00127","chapter":"C007","text":"I agree with Tyler.","fingerprint":"04d87f50f5f3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00431","start_s":1703.807,"end_s":1713.265,"video_s":1753.807,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00127","chapter":"C007","text":"I spend a lot of time at Shadow Mountain, and the amount of work that happens in the youth center is really critical.","fingerprint":"98601f48840a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00432","start_s":1713.445,"end_s":1715.249,"video_s":1763.445,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00127","chapter":"C007","text":"It is a lifeline to our seniors.","fingerprint":"677e89b04020","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00433","start_s":1715.609,"end_s":1720.238,"video_s":1765.609,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00127","chapter":"C007","text":"I mean, I'm in my 70s, and I sense...","fingerprint":"cf37b28c866c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00434","start_s":1720.218,"end_s":1725.758,"video_s":1770.218,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00127","chapter":"C007","text":"There's times that I should be at that center and you should be helping me with my balance and a lot of things.","fingerprint":"f4f5c48f0d7b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00435","start_s":1726.26,"end_s":1732.0,"video_s":1776.26,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00127","chapter":"C007","text":"But I know you do such terrific work, especially for people that don't have anyone","fingerprint":"5762eff3c40a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00436","start_s":1732.722,"end_s":1736.927,"video_s":1782.722,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00127","chapter":"C007","text":"that live in the city and really all they have is our senior center.","fingerprint":"a2ad07ed17e9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00437","start_s":1737.889,"end_s":1742.154,"video_s":1787.889,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00127","chapter":"C007","text":"So I'm inclined to say I would like to revisit their classification.","fingerprint":"0b93e232a38e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00438","start_s":1743.095,"end_s":1748.883,"video_s":1793.095,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00127","chapter":"C007","text":"And I don't know what that process would be, but I don't want to hold you up from getting at least a raise now.","fingerprint":"21147700f5d9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00439","start_s":1748.923,"end_s":1755.051,"video_s":1798.923,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00127","chapter":"C007","text":"Is there a way that we could revisit or I mean, what would be the logical process?","fingerprint":"09453c553fab","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00440","start_s":1756.178,"end_s":1757.199,"video_s":1806.178,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00128","chapter":"C007","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00441","start_s":1757.279,"end_s":1759.121,"video_s":1807.279,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00128","chapter":"C007","text":"Members of Council, Councilwoman Stark.","fingerprint":"a0f0f42642fd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00442","start_s":1760.002,"end_s":1763.765,"video_s":1810.002,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00128","chapter":"C007","text":"So we completely understand the concerns and we can revisit this.","fingerprint":"d2dfe726902c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00443","start_s":1764.206,"end_s":1766.288,"video_s":1814.206,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00128","chapter":"C007","text":"Like you said, this provides for an increase now.","fingerprint":"ba4aa71120fc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00444","start_s":1767.169,"end_s":1776.057,"video_s":1817.169,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00128","chapter":"C007","text":"The compensation analysis includes both the local labor market data for comparable positions as well as internal equity.","fingerprint":"1bca1cfff191","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00445","start_s":1776.077,"end_s":1784.886,"video_s":1826.077,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00128","chapter":"C007","text":"So with this recommendation, we are providing for both an increase while maintaining that internal alignment and equity across the greater organization.","fingerprint":"37961325c453","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00446","start_s":1788.292,"end_s":1796.385,"video_s":1838.292,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00129","chapter":"C007","text":"Okay, I just, I wanna make sure that you guys get compensated now, but I do think we should probably revisit.","fingerprint":"1a2c11b6b718","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00447","start_s":1796.726,"end_s":1799.791,"video_s":1846.726,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00129","chapter":"C007","text":"So I don't know, I don't know how others feel.","fingerprint":"ced7988056c8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00448","start_s":1799.951,"end_s":1804.658,"video_s":1849.951,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00129","chapter":"C007","text":"I feel pretty strongly about the senior centers, but that may be because I'm a senior.","fingerprint":"748620dd515c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00449","start_s":1804.859,"end_s":1810.047,"video_s":1854.859,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00129","chapter":"C007","text":"I mean, I'm sorry, but I understand the important work you do.","fingerprint":"853663290c0f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00450","start_s":1810.027,"end_s":1820.004,"video_s":1860.027,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00130","chapter":"C007","text":"Mayor, Councilman Stark, I think the option would be sort of what the Councilman suggested, which is if you approve it now, then we don't hold up anybody's increase.","fingerprint":"826bcbd3ee4f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00451","start_s":1820.024,"end_s":1828.659,"video_s":1870.024,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00130","chapter":"C007","text":"And understanding this direction, we can have the HR team go back and take another look at it and come back and explain to the Council whatever those findings are.","fingerprint":"f3866eeb6703","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00452","start_s":1830.001,"end_s":1831.123,"video_s":1880.001,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00130","chapter":"C007","text":"But I think to your point,","fingerprint":"d683097f4401","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00453","start_s":1831.795,"end_s":1835.502,"video_s":1881.795,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00130","chapter":"C007","text":"There's an immediate increase that's on the table here.","fingerprint":"345450d2f279","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00454","start_s":1835.542,"end_s":1839.368,"video_s":1885.542,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00130","chapter":"C007","text":"We can do that and then come back and revisit that.","fingerprint":"7141d0be435d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00455","start_s":1839.789,"end_s":1841.192,"video_s":1889.789,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00130","chapter":"C007","text":"That's what the council would like to do.","fingerprint":"d936586d9257","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00456","start_s":1845.399,"end_s":1847.343,"video_s":1895.399,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00131","chapter":"C007","text":"But I can't speak for everybody.","fingerprint":"8e2db38c201a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00457","start_s":1848.605,"end_s":1851.189,"video_s":1898.605,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00132","chapter":"C007","text":"I mean, I agree that maybe we move.","fingerprint":"da9be69053e2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00458","start_s":1851.55,"end_s":1853.854,"video_s":1901.55,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00132","chapter":"C007","text":"I don't want to hold anyone back either.","fingerprint":"685c30f810f4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00459","start_s":1854.307,"end_s":1857.012,"video_s":1904.307,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00132","chapter":"C007","text":"from getting the races that are already in here.","fingerprint":"8cb81b9e524b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00460","start_s":1857.513,"end_s":1876.77,"video_s":1907.513,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00132","chapter":"C007","text":"But I would like to make an amendment to the motion to say we move forward with the motion, but we go back and we revisit these classifications and really have a meeting with the individuals and for HR to figure out what is something, maybe somewhere in the middle that we can get and bring that back to the council.","fingerprint":"e529ae3b5e89","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00461","start_s":1878.64,"end_s":1881.046,"video_s":1928.64,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00133","chapter":"C007","text":"and I think the Vice Mayor was the maker of the motion.","fingerprint":"0122a34c767d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00462","start_s":1881.066,"end_s":1882.23,"video_s":1931.066,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00134","chapter":"C007","text":"Yeah, I made the motion.","fingerprint":"c6ad9518bb97","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00463","start_s":1882.25,"end_s":1886.762,"video_s":1932.25,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00134","chapter":"C007","text":"So if I may, Mayor.","fingerprint":"756bcb2449ee","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00464","start_s":1887.263,"end_s":1888.807,"video_s":1937.263,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00134","chapter":"C007","text":"Yeah, Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"d05b363b493b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00465","start_s":1889.108,"end_s":1894.843,"video_s":1939.108,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00134","chapter":"C007","text":"I understand the concerns that are being raised and I don't want to minimize the work that is being done.","fingerprint":"795a1ecad804","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00466","start_s":1894.823,"end_s":1910.188,"video_s":1944.823,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00134","chapter":"C007","text":"I think what is probably more appropriate is that we have a mechanism in which any unit can determine how to request an adjustment so that they're not forced to come here to counsel to advocate on behalf.","fingerprint":"675e2ddf1272","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00467","start_s":1910.929,"end_s":1915.937,"video_s":1960.929,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00134","chapter":"C007","text":"I would like to see a more formal process be instilled as to if there's any classification that","fingerprint":"1799aa1551b5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00468","start_s":1915.917,"end_s":1922.788,"video_s":1965.917,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00134","chapter":"C007","text":"It feels like they want to be reconsidered that we have a process and it's not that they have to come to council to do that and us move forward.","fingerprint":"3003eecf2a4f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00469","start_s":1922.948,"end_s":1937.031,"video_s":1972.948,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00134","chapter":"C007","text":"So my inclination was that we continue to move forward as presented in the motion, allow our human resource department to come up with a process in which this can be rolled through so that we can move forward.","fingerprint":"da3f1ba39aab","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00470","start_s":1937.011,"end_s":1954.097,"video_s":1987.011,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00134","chapter":"C007","text":"So I'm not I don't want to limit our action to just this department because I do not I am not sure if we have others that may feel the same way and we are now saying that the proper course is for you to come to council when this is being brought up and this is the time for you to raise it.","fingerprint":"8f560b5ffeae","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00471","start_s":1954.778,"end_s":1956.42,"video_s":2004.778,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00134","chapter":"C007","text":"I just would like to see a more formal process.","fingerprint":"2d068eb5c03f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00472","start_s":1957.295,"end_s":1971.67,"video_s":2007.295,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00135","chapter":"C007","text":"I would say one other thing we could also do is just to give you a presentation on the process itself as it stands today that may also give you a sense of what goes into that, how the HR staff and the HRC work through that.","fingerprint":"40a209acb3b9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00473","start_s":1972.232,"end_s":1975.219,"video_s":2022.232,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00135","chapter":"C007","text":"That may give you more of a sense of how that works.","fingerprint":"eb5f425fbaed","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00474","start_s":1976.65,"end_s":1986.884,"video_s":2026.65,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00136","chapter":"C007","text":"And vice mayor and members of council, we do have formal processes in place, and each unit is capable of bringing forward the classifications that they would like us to study, and they do quite frequently.","fingerprint":"3c04a1a4f258","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00475","start_s":1986.964,"end_s":1988.185,"video_s":2036.964,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00136","chapter":"C007","text":"Directors do the same thing.","fingerprint":"f316d1002a28","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00476","start_s":1988.205,"end_s":1994.434,"video_s":2038.205,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00136","chapter":"C007","text":"So there are processes in place, and this is part of a months-long study, including desk audits as well.","fingerprint":"347e661b31a8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00477","start_s":1994.454,"end_s":1999.941,"video_s":2044.454,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00136","chapter":"C007","text":"So there was a lot of work that did go into this, again, with needing to maintain that internal alignment and equity.","fingerprint":"7a18940a8f8f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00478","start_s":2001.625,"end_s":2019.931,"video_s":2051.625,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00137","chapter":"C007","text":"Wonderful, we have learned at the council when you adjust compensation in one area, you gotta adjust it in a whole lot of others and so we should do it in a methodical way because that's the most fair way and probably making compensation decisions from the podium is about as, that would become a difficult precedent.","fingerprint":"2ae94d8927ae","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00479","start_s":2020.772,"end_s":2022.194,"video_s":2070.772,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00138","chapter":"C007","text":"Mayor.","fingerprint":"dd51a825d06a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00480","start_s":2022.214,"end_s":2022.374,"video_s":2072.214,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00138","chapter":"C007","text":"Correct.","fingerprint":"15a596e3c98c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00481","start_s":2022.394,"end_s":2023.416,"video_s":2072.394,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00138","chapter":"C007","text":"I just have another question.","fingerprint":"273c5faf5880","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00482","start_s":2023.456,"end_s":2024.237,"video_s":2073.456,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00138","chapter":"C007","text":"Councilman Guardado.","fingerprint":"aa00302728d8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00483","start_s":2024.257,"end_s":2024.658,"video_s":2074.257,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00138","chapter":"C007","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00484","start_s":2025.178,"end_s":2031.227,"video_s":2075.178,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00138","chapter":"C007","text":"I guess, Jason, my question is, had these concerns have been brought up to you before?","fingerprint":"ffb869b64b7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00485","start_s":2031.882,"end_s":2038.379,"video_s":2081.882,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00138","chapter":"C007","text":"about them not being comfortable with the pay range that was being offered to them?","fingerprint":"bf7c94bfbb19","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00486","start_s":2038.8,"end_s":2046.94,"video_s":2088.8,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00139","chapter":"C007","text":"So the employees do come forward often with concerns, but again, we have to balance a lot of different factors, which is what occurred here as well.","fingerprint":"33c8512c7c1f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00487","start_s":2046.961,"end_s":2047.562,"video_s":2096.961,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00140","chapter":"C007","text":"Got it.","fingerprint":"fcd783c70e45","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00488","start_s":2048.032,"end_s":2050.316,"video_s":2098.032,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00140","chapter":"C007","text":"Okay, I just think, I think it's true.","fingerprint":"af627a79a01e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00489","start_s":2050.336,"end_s":2057.771,"video_s":2100.336,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00140","chapter":"C007","text":"I agree that we need a more streamlined process, especially for workers that are not being represented by a labor union.","fingerprint":"a386c60b8121","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00490","start_s":2057.951,"end_s":2063.762,"video_s":2107.951,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00140","chapter":"C007","text":"I think it's a little bit more difficult maybe sometimes for that process, so I do agree.","fingerprint":"77db115bd5d9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00491","start_s":2063.742,"end_s":2070.648,"video_s":2113.742,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00140","chapter":"C007","text":"that we need to streamline it to making sure that we are listening.","fingerprint":"3d315ea446c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00492","start_s":2071.009,"end_s":2075.733,"video_s":2121.009,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00140","chapter":"C007","text":"I know that sometimes it might be difficult and we're looking at different things.","fingerprint":"28ec38b6819c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00493","start_s":2075.893,"end_s":2086.103,"video_s":2125.893,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00140","chapter":"C007","text":"And when I see that somebody is making $31,000 a year, it's not something that I feel very comfortable with, but I get it that it's a process.","fingerprint":"9e91dc91d654","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00494","start_s":2086.163,"end_s":2090.627,"video_s":2136.163,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00140","chapter":"C007","text":"So if we can look at that and figure out how do we really streamline that","fingerprint":"3bdac28139d6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00495","start_s":2090.607,"end_s":2095.652,"video_s":2140.607,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00140","chapter":"C007","text":"in a way where everyone feels that they're being heard, I think I would really appreciate that.","fingerprint":"e40d59465207","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00496","start_s":2095.873,"end_s":2098.996,"video_s":2145.873,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00140","chapter":"C007","text":"And if you can just brief us on what that's gonna look like.","fingerprint":"3ebd49dcb243","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00497","start_s":2099.897,"end_s":2100.318,"video_s":2149.897,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00140","chapter":"C007","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00498","start_s":2100.338,"end_s":2101.078,"video_s":2150.338,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00140","chapter":"C007","text":"Yes, happy to do so.","fingerprint":"ccafaed3b1a1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00499","start_s":2101.098,"end_s":2101.359,"video_s":2151.098,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00141","chapter":"C007","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00500","start_s":2101.379,"end_s":2103.541,"video_s":2151.379,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00141","chapter":"C007","text":"We'll go to Councilman Pastor and then return to Councilman Hernandez.","fingerprint":"fadb678f8dd6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00501","start_s":2106.044,"end_s":2106.184,"video_s":2156.044,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00142","chapter":"C007","text":"Hi.","fingerprint":"8f434346648f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00502","start_s":2108.186,"end_s":2113.192,"video_s":2158.186,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00142","chapter":"C007","text":"Just wanna follow up with the fact that there is a process.","fingerprint":"34b422761415","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00503","start_s":2114.733,"end_s":2117.256,"video_s":2164.733,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00142","chapter":"C007","text":"There is a process that goes all the way up.","fingerprint":"f89dc23791d6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00504","start_s":2117.523,"end_s":2138.265,"video_s":2167.523,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00142","chapter":"C007","text":"and then the final process is to come to council to say we are not, we don't feel like that's the right reclassification and employees have the ability to come to us and we govern.","fingerprint":"4f0dcf2eb8d0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00505","start_s":2139.68,"end_s":2143.926,"video_s":2189.68,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00142","chapter":"C007","text":"and I just wanna be clear that there is a process.","fingerprint":"a1a4545c9576","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00506","start_s":2145.248,"end_s":2158.989,"video_s":2195.248,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00142","chapter":"C007","text":"The other piece is what I just heard was, and you may have to help me on this, was there's a classification that is very similar or equal to what you do.","fingerprint":"5a8ed52a7146","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00507","start_s":2160.651,"end_s":2167.662,"video_s":2210.651,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00142","chapter":"C007","text":"And so I think that's what they're asking for is to look at that classification","fingerprint":"9f0feab51551","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00508","start_s":2168.401,"end_s":2183.963,"video_s":2218.401,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00142","chapter":"C007","text":"and if it checks all the boxes, then it is probably very similar, maybe called differently, but they're doing the same thing and that's what's fair.","fingerprint":"778ca72d34a5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00509","start_s":2184.112,"end_s":2202.275,"video_s":2234.112,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00142","chapter":"C007","text":"and I'm only coming from my community college side of the HR and reclassification and what happens with us and how we have and the city has merged several classifications with similar duties but in different areas.","fingerprint":"dfd8f64646a8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00510","start_s":2202.896,"end_s":2206.901,"video_s":2252.896,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00142","chapter":"C007","text":"And so I think that's really what the concern is along with the pay.","fingerprint":"4a43a0aab609","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00511","start_s":2208.082,"end_s":2209.444,"video_s":2258.082,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00142","chapter":"C007","text":"Could you elaborate on that?","fingerprint":"c3f9691461bd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00512","start_s":2209.829,"end_s":2212.352,"video_s":2259.829,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00143","chapter":"C007","text":"Thank you, Councilman Pastor.","fingerprint":"14d442ed831d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00513","start_s":2212.433,"end_s":2217.96,"video_s":2262.433,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00143","chapter":"C007","text":"I do understand that concern, and the team did review the other classifications out there.","fingerprint":"1b8797a9e722","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00514","start_s":2218.04,"end_s":2221.605,"video_s":2268.04,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00143","chapter":"C007","text":"So there's often a great deal of nuance in each of these classifications.","fingerprint":"9a009b53a3c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00515","start_s":2222.306,"end_s":2236.005,"video_s":2272.306,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00143","chapter":"C007","text":"And I believe that, again, that where they landed with this initial recommendation, the recommendation that's before you today, is what they felt aligned best with the classification as it exists and the other classifications within the city.","fingerprint":"6bfea77ee1ad","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00516","start_s":2236.576,"end_s":2247.307,"video_s":2286.576,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00144","chapter":"C007","text":"Okay, but they're here and so we are asking, and it has to be in a motion because I learned this on something else last week.","fingerprint":"1930fbfa8b38","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00517","start_s":2248.067,"end_s":2262.702,"video_s":2298.067,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00144","chapter":"C007","text":"It has to be in motion, it has to be a directive to staff in order for us to even have them look and explore in this space and so","fingerprint":"113eeefc2feb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00518","start_s":2262.985,"end_s":2273.857,"video_s":2312.985,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00144","chapter":"C007","text":"I'm trying to clear that up because it has to be an emotion and for them to go ask to re-evaluate, look at it, and come back to us.","fingerprint":"9f032ec2cc6a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00519","start_s":2275.599,"end_s":2277.241,"video_s":2325.599,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00144","chapter":"C007","text":"And so I want to add clarity to that.","fingerprint":"d3a98e958f62","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00520","start_s":2277.361,"end_s":2280.205,"video_s":2327.361,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00144","chapter":"C007","text":"Am I correct, Ed, or Julie, or whoever?","fingerprint":"2b40e9219fda","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00521","start_s":2280.225,"end_s":2283.088,"video_s":2330.225,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00145","chapter":"C007","text":"I think you have it right.","fingerprint":"601141f21d2f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00522","start_s":2283.528,"end_s":2289.235,"video_s":2333.528,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00145","chapter":"C007","text":"If the desire of the council is for us to go back and look at this again, we do need that in the form of a motion.","fingerprint":"906ab0c1bb5f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00523","start_s":2289.936,"end_s":2291.377,"video_s":2339.936,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00145","chapter":"C007","text":"That's correct, Councilwoman.","fingerprint":"53f76f94e6d8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00524","start_s":2291.397,"end_s":2292.739,"video_s":2341.397,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00146","chapter":"C007","text":"I just wanted to be clear on that.","fingerprint":"510aaa066041","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00525","start_s":2294.727,"end_s":2295.489,"video_s":2344.727,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00146","chapter":"C007","text":"Councilwoman Hernandez.","fingerprint":"be943e39201c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00526","start_s":2296.291,"end_s":2296.832,"video_s":2346.291,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00147","chapter":"C007","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00527","start_s":2297.333,"end_s":2301.342,"video_s":2347.333,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00147","chapter":"C007","text":"Sorry, just have a follow-up question because I do agree with Councilwoman Pastor.","fingerprint":"242e9e38222e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00528","start_s":2302.565,"end_s":2311.926,"video_s":2352.565,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00147","chapter":"C007","text":"In my previous line of work, when we were doing reclassifications, and if there's two similar roles, I mean, I would be supportive of","fingerprint":"ac787fc84bc3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00529","start_s":2311.906,"end_s":2317.639,"video_s":2361.906,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00147","chapter":"C007","text":"a motion to re-look at these two particular ones to see if they can be merged.","fingerprint":"a57b6f0aa32b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00530","start_s":2318.04,"end_s":2323.372,"video_s":2368.04,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00147","chapter":"C007","text":"But Jason, I know you mentioned that there is a formal process in how we are doing reclassifications.","fingerprint":"15ea81057952","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00531","start_s":2323.833,"end_s":2326.238,"video_s":2373.833,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00147","chapter":"C007","text":"At what point do we do those?","fingerprint":"b1f7925f3ea7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00532","start_s":2326.258,"end_s":2328.062,"video_s":2376.258,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00147","chapter":"C007","text":"Is that going to be an ongoing situation?","fingerprint":"b48e0408d552","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00533","start_s":2328.103,"end_s":2329.846,"video_s":2378.103,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00147","chapter":"C007","text":"Do we do those one time a year?","fingerprint":"13a9cb38ca34","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00534","start_s":2330.207,"end_s":2331.45,"video_s":2380.207,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00147","chapter":"C007","text":"Can you give me the time frame?","fingerprint":"a4fe72ab07ce","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00535","start_s":2332.493,"end_s":2333.374,"video_s":2382.493,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00148","chapter":"C007","text":"Yes, absolutely.","fingerprint":"d154a97d0b67","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00536","start_s":2333.414,"end_s":2336.378,"video_s":2383.414,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00148","chapter":"C007","text":"So, Council Member Hernandez, it's actually an ongoing process.","fingerprint":"7f0573eb9b45","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00537","start_s":2336.538,"end_s":2341.243,"video_s":2386.538,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00148","chapter":"C007","text":"And just to be clear, it's more than just what you would call reclassification.","fingerprint":"208692a06afd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00538","start_s":2341.263,"end_s":2346.39,"video_s":2391.263,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00148","chapter":"C007","text":"We're really looking at the pay and compensation, so pay grade and what is appropriate for a particular classification.","fingerprint":"174d7d2e852d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00539","start_s":2346.81,"end_s":2353.418,"video_s":2396.81,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00148","chapter":"C007","text":"But those are ongoing and those go to the HRC Committee, the Human Resources Committee, for the final recommendation as you see today.","fingerprint":"6a16a1ddb51c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00540","start_s":2353.458,"end_s":2355.16,"video_s":2403.458,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00148","chapter":"C007","text":"So that is all part of that process.","fingerprint":"0a41ed8acef5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00541","start_s":2355.14,"end_s":2355.841,"video_s":2405.14,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00149","chapter":"C007","text":"Okay, thank you.","fingerprint":"21d63267fca8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00542","start_s":2355.961,"end_s":2373.508,"video_s":2405.961,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00149","chapter":"C007","text":"Because I also don't want to hold up from us being able to do the four that we have here before us, but I am hearing the concerns that the employees feel like they should be at the same pay grade as a different role.","fingerprint":"aa7644fe716e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00543","start_s":2373.569,"end_s":2375.592,"video_s":2423.569,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00149","chapter":"C007","text":"That seems like they're very similar.","fingerprint":"d1aeefa87182","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00544","start_s":2375.632,"end_s":2377.755,"video_s":2425.632,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00149","chapter":"C007","text":"So, yeah, I mean...","fingerprint":"520d8b1701e6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00545","start_s":2378.225,"end_s":2392.244,"video_s":2428.225,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00149","chapter":"C007","text":"open to how we move forward, but I would like us to look at that piece if there's room to do that.","fingerprint":"8ecf548d3f32","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00546","start_s":2392.264,"end_s":2393.989,"video_s":2442.264,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00150","chapter":"C007","text":"Vice Mayor, thank you so much.","fingerprint":"68178895b2e7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00547","start_s":2395.403,"end_s":2400.675,"video_s":2445.403,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00150","chapter":"C007","text":"So as I stated before, my concern was making sure there's some level of consistency in how we move this forward.","fingerprint":"8105edeaf99f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00548","start_s":2401.296,"end_s":2410.797,"video_s":2451.296,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00150","chapter":"C007","text":"Absent the employees coming to council here today, I had no idea that this was an issue, meaning that we weren't","fingerprint":"bd530fd6f3da","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00549","start_s":2411.047,"end_s":2416.894,"video_s":2461.047,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00150","chapter":"C007","text":"I didn't feel like I wasn't adequately briefed on this discussion and coming from a place of knowledge.","fingerprint":"8f4375128e0f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00550","start_s":2417.134,"end_s":2431.992,"video_s":2467.134,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00150","chapter":"C007","text":"How could we fix this to make sure that, one, when we do know that there's a reclassification, the employee group's position is stated in the material so that we have some level of","fingerprint":"abb10a781786","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00551","start_s":2431.972,"end_s":2456.713,"video_s":2481.972,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00150","chapter":"C007","text":"so that we can find out more information before we come to council because I presume that there was some level of determination made after this objection or was raised by the employee groups as to the classification and there was some further discussion or hopefully there was some further discussion or research done into this and maybe that would have been helpful for us to have seen ahead of time.","fingerprint":"778ad3ac8f03","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00552","start_s":2456.693,"end_s":2485.384,"video_s":2506.693,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00150","chapter":"C007","text":"So I am still in favor of us, I wanna make sure I'm climbing in favor of us moving forward with the reclassification as it stands, but how do we, what is your proposal on how we can get this standardized and know about all of the other outstanding, if there are other outstanding similar reclassification that have objection from the employee group so that we can be properly briefed and make decisions with full information?","fingerprint":"c3d22937feab","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00553","start_s":2486.225,"end_s":2487.327,"video_s":2536.225,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00151","chapter":"C007","text":"Thank you, Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"8ac1fd1753f1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00554","start_s":2487.347,"end_s":2503.308,"video_s":2537.347,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00151","chapter":"C007","text":"So we can certainly take a look and come back with recommendations with regard to how HRC can communicate so that, you know, there is opportunities to be heard at the HRC end of this and we can come back with recommendations as far as communication to council on that.","fingerprint":"6a65369de081","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00555","start_s":2507.174,"end_s":2509.617,"video_s":2557.174,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00152","chapter":"C007","text":"Councilwoman Guardado and then Hernandez.","fingerprint":"ef58988a7cd4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00556","start_s":2509.9,"end_s":2516.749,"video_s":2559.9,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00153","chapter":"C007","text":"I mean, I agree that we need a process, but I still insist on the amendment.","fingerprint":"99e6c4443da1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00557","start_s":2517.39,"end_s":2528.405,"video_s":2567.39,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00153","chapter":"C007","text":"And just because these workers are not represented by a union, and I know that this is, hopefully this is the last time that this happens, where workers come in and ask for something on the dais.","fingerprint":"d4f8aad91a53","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00558","start_s":2528.865,"end_s":2531.309,"video_s":2578.865,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00153","chapter":"C007","text":"I also agree that it should be done differently.","fingerprint":"c6ff17c06f99","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00559","start_s":2531.349,"end_s":2535.975,"video_s":2581.349,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00153","chapter":"C007","text":"But I also, you know, I also,","fingerprint":"48024c7fed74","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00560","start_s":2536.36,"end_s":2558.824,"video_s":2586.36,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00153","chapter":"C007","text":"Thank you so much for joining us.","fingerprint":"945bc1e42037","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00561","start_s":2559.125,"end_s":2570.497,"video_s":2609.125,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00153","chapter":"C007","text":"and I understand there's some times where there's disagreements and hearing that there's two classifications that are very similar and some are getting paid more than others.","fingerprint":"9a703105cd5b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00562","start_s":2571.057,"end_s":2583.09,"video_s":2621.057,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00153","chapter":"C007","text":"I would still, I'm hoping, Vice Mayor, that we can make the amendment just for this one time, you know, just because I, and then after that, being able to streamline the process.","fingerprint":"db1ce7bbcba4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00563","start_s":2584.049,"end_s":2585.591,"video_s":2634.049,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00154","chapter":"C007","text":"Thank you, members of council.","fingerprint":"c2ee126b1e05","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00564","start_s":2585.631,"end_s":2589.274,"video_s":2635.631,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00154","chapter":"C007","text":"And just for a point of clarification, these positions are represented positions.","fingerprint":"19a2f130c423","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00565","start_s":2589.295,"end_s":2592.418,"video_s":2639.295,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00154","chapter":"C007","text":"These are members of a bargaining unit association.","fingerprint":"0e58e14a3b3f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00566","start_s":2593.939,"end_s":2596.582,"video_s":2643.939,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00155","chapter":"C007","text":"Aspitea.","fingerprint":"1db6536f0dc8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00567","start_s":2601.407,"end_s":2605.752,"video_s":2651.407,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00156","chapter":"C007","text":"I think we'll go to Councilwoman O'Brien since she hasn't had a chance yet, and then we'll go to Councilwoman Hernandez.","fingerprint":"097e5faf8c21","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00568","start_s":2605.772,"end_s":2607.013,"video_s":2655.772,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00157","chapter":"C007","text":"I really just have a quick question, sorry.","fingerprint":"e807d87a4ab5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00569","start_s":2607.053,"end_s":2610.817,"video_s":2657.053,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00157","chapter":"C007","text":"Which unit are they represented by?","fingerprint":"1484992037cd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00570","start_s":2610.917,"end_s":2611.918,"video_s":2660.917,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00157","chapter":"C007","text":"I couldn't hear you.","fingerprint":"9e3193e49d97","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00571","start_s":2611.938,"end_s":2613.6,"video_s":2661.938,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00158","chapter":"C007","text":"I'm sorry, Unit 7, Aspitea.","fingerprint":"7149e3536cd4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00572","start_s":2614.188,"end_s":2616.47,"video_s":2664.188,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00159","chapter":"C007","text":"Okay, thank you, I just needed to hear that.","fingerprint":"3a289204ab1c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00573","start_s":2616.49,"end_s":2617.211,"video_s":2666.49,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00160","chapter":"C007","text":"Councilman Hernandez.","fingerprint":"3bb873cefabf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00574","start_s":2619.753,"end_s":2621.114,"video_s":2669.753,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00161","chapter":"C007","text":"I think I will hold my question.","fingerprint":"a56613888d65","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00575","start_s":2625.618,"end_s":2625.718,"video_s":2675.618,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00161","chapter":"C007","text":"Okay.","fingerprint":"6a581ee90118","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00576","start_s":2625.738,"end_s":2626.739,"video_s":2675.738,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00162","chapter":"C007","text":"Councilman Pastor.","fingerprint":"0191e87b0f41","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00577","start_s":2628.701,"end_s":2635.026,"video_s":2678.701,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00163","chapter":"C007","text":"I actually would like to make an exception, but my question is to Julie.","fingerprint":"04629ff7da66","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00578","start_s":2636.227,"end_s":2643.013,"video_s":2686.227,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00163","chapter":"C007","text":"Make an exception as to look at the two classifications.","fingerprint":"c3d579fa7973","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00579","start_s":2644.529,"end_s":2646.212,"video_s":2694.529,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00164","chapter":"C007","text":"and mayor members of council.","fingerprint":"64036f1464f2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00580","start_s":2646.272,"end_s":2648.597,"video_s":2696.272,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00164","chapter":"C007","text":"So are you making a substitute motion?","fingerprint":"e7b6e1228e04","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00581","start_s":2649.459,"end_s":2652.765,"video_s":2699.459,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00165","chapter":"C007","text":"No, I'm having a, what I'm saying, we're having a dialogue.","fingerprint":"dcd16dcca20d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00582","start_s":2652.825,"end_s":2664.509,"video_s":2702.825,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00165","chapter":"C007","text":"So what I'm saying is I would like in the motion if the vice mayor is willing to make an exception to look at these, the two classifications that they are speaking of.","fingerprint":"0cad4a159eda","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00583","start_s":2664.849,"end_s":2666.773,"video_s":2714.849,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00165","chapter":"C007","text":"If not, I can make a substitute motion.","fingerprint":"0184a2b34fb2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00584","start_s":2668.07,"end_s":2684.847,"video_s":2718.07,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00166","chapter":"C007","text":"Mayor, members of council, if the maker of the, so there is a motion on the table, if the maker of the motion doesn't agree to a friendly amendment, which should be a minor modification, then it would be a substitute amendment and needs a second, or a substitute motion which needs a second.","fingerprint":"52c8c92afd84","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00585","start_s":2686.379,"end_s":2693.754,"video_s":2736.379,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00167","chapter":"C007","text":"So for clarification, because we've had some conversation back and forth, I want to make sure I understand the motion, I'm sorry, the amendment as proposed.","fingerprint":"98849e6fd58b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00586","start_s":2693.774,"end_s":2694.856,"video_s":2743.774,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00167","chapter":"C007","text":"The amendment, can you repeat?","fingerprint":"8026cdf69fbe","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00587","start_s":2694.876,"end_s":2699.325,"video_s":2744.876,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00168","chapter":"C007","text":"The amendment is to bring this classification for staff to go back","fingerprint":"c01fd85d0d97","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00588","start_s":2699.879,"end_s":2710.578,"video_s":2749.879,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00168","chapter":"C007","text":"look at it, speak with the individuals that are affected by this, look at the two classifications and come back just for that classification with a new proposal.","fingerprint":"f91e23635932","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00589","start_s":2711.099,"end_s":2715.227,"video_s":2761.099,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00169","chapter":"C007","text":"And I think we need to be clear as to which classification we're talking about just so the record is clear.","fingerprint":"4ed5e5f03634","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00590","start_s":2715.247,"end_s":2721.959,"video_s":2765.247,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00169","chapter":"C007","text":"I presume we're talking about both the classification for senior center assistant and senior program supervisor.","fingerprint":"3a97e0e4ddb1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00591","start_s":2722.44,"end_s":2722.68,"video_s":2772.44,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00170","chapter":"C007","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00592","start_s":2724.517,"end_s":2730.025,"video_s":2774.517,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00171","chapter":"C007","text":"With that clarification as to what the motion is, I will accept the friendly amendment.","fingerprint":"75c252861db9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00593","start_s":2730.045,"end_s":2730.446,"video_s":2780.045,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00171","chapter":"C007","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00594","start_s":2732.109,"end_s":2734.693,"video_s":2782.109,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00172","chapter":"C007","text":"And then Councilman O'Brien was the second?","fingerprint":"8e1394bb1542","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00595","start_s":2734.793,"end_s":2735.213,"video_s":2784.793,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00172","chapter":"C007","text":"Councilwoman?","fingerprint":"6362e4737814","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00596","start_s":2735.854,"end_s":2738.739,"video_s":2785.854,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00173","chapter":"C007","text":"Before I make that judgment, can I ask a couple questions?","fingerprint":"ee381b131af6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00597","start_s":2738.759,"end_s":2738.999,"video_s":2788.759,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00173","chapter":"C007","text":"Please.","fingerprint":"56ccc4dcfc96","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00598","start_s":2739.64,"end_s":2740.001,"video_s":2789.64,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00173","chapter":"C007","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00599","start_s":2741.863,"end_s":2751.418,"video_s":2791.863,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00173","chapter":"C007","text":"Jason, can you explain the process you go through to make this determination and get here and make this recommendation?","fingerprint":"83803d5968b4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00600","start_s":2755.921,"end_s":2759.15,"video_s":2805.921,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00174","chapter":"C007","text":"Mayor, members of council, I'm actually gonna call Greg Carmichael up.","fingerprint":"2e61d98de60f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00601","start_s":2759.17,"end_s":2763.381,"video_s":2809.17,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00174","chapter":"C007","text":"He's our assistant director over class and comp, so he can walk you through the actual process.","fingerprint":"fb8406deb210","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00602","start_s":2764.584,"end_s":2765.627,"video_s":2814.584,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00175","chapter":"C007","text":"Okay, thank you.","fingerprint":"21d63267fca8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00603","start_s":2790.447,"end_s":2792.205,"video_s":2840.447,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00176","chapter":"C007","text":"Can you repeat the question for me again, please?","fingerprint":"4abee69cfa19","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00604","start_s":2792.827,"end_s":2805.804,"video_s":2842.827,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00177","chapter":"C007","text":"So can you, when we, obviously the city went through a large comprehensive class and comp review and we made many changes to pay classifications.","fingerprint":"bc039a830425","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00605","start_s":2806.344,"end_s":2814.895,"video_s":2856.344,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00177","chapter":"C007","text":"And so we have been refining because as we learned when we did that, occasionally there, we didn't get it quite right, right?","fingerprint":"6c949e09c197","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00606","start_s":2814.955,"end_s":2816.197,"video_s":2864.955,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00177","chapter":"C007","text":"We're not perfect.","fingerprint":"7f0b252cd70e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00607","start_s":2816.317,"end_s":2821.804,"video_s":2866.317,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00177","chapter":"C007","text":"And so we have been here as Councilwoman Pastor mentioned a few times before,","fingerprint":"4c1512b73655","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00608","start_s":2821.784,"end_s":2823.446,"video_s":2871.784,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00177","chapter":"C007","text":"to make modifications.","fingerprint":"364baaaed4b6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00609","start_s":2824.067,"end_s":2840.291,"video_s":2874.067,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00177","chapter":"C007","text":"What process do you go through when you are looking at these additional adjustments to our class and comp where we feel like it got out of sorts even though we did a whole great big class and comp redo?","fingerprint":"d7cd2349d323","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00610","start_s":2842.214,"end_s":2844.197,"video_s":2892.214,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00178","chapter":"C007","text":"Mayor, Councilwoman O'Brien,","fingerprint":"3f3bbe4dd8b5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00611","start_s":2845.527,"end_s":2853.377,"video_s":2895.527,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00178","chapter":"C007","text":"Requests come into our office, generally either through labor groups or through department heads.","fingerprint":"6e5e48218282","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00612","start_s":2853.762,"end_s":2867.116,"video_s":2903.762,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00178","chapter":"C007","text":"and employees, if an employee wants to raise an issue, generally they run that up their chain of command until it comes to a department head and they come across to the HR department and ask us to look at a classification or a market study.","fingerprint":"1a7633cc30d5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00613","start_s":2867.816,"end_s":2880.83,"video_s":2917.816,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00178","chapter":"C007","text":"When we get those requests, we review primarily, our first engagement is to look at the local labor market and assess our competitive position against other cities.","fingerprint":"4ea8ba3bf847","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00614","start_s":2881.17,"end_s":2882.892,"video_s":2931.17,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00178","chapter":"C007","text":"Mayor, or...","fingerprint":"1560b05130b7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00615","start_s":2882.872,"end_s":2885.154,"video_s":2932.872,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00178","chapter":"C007","text":"Mesa, Scottsdale, Tempe, et cetera.","fingerprint":"299412cc7589","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00616","start_s":2885.875,"end_s":2893.403,"video_s":2935.875,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00178","chapter":"C007","text":"And so as a result of that, our first and primary consideration is are we competitive with the local labor market?","fingerprint":"e7eef09ce452","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00617","start_s":2894.144,"end_s":2906.837,"video_s":2944.144,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00178","chapter":"C007","text":"Secondarily, we're also looking internally to see if a regrade or reclassification will disrupt a job family or a career pass or any other internal alignment within the city.","fingerprint":"f6041e998ff2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00618","start_s":2907.644,"end_s":2912.272,"video_s":2957.644,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00178","chapter":"C007","text":"Combining those two elements, we come up with our best recommendation as to a potential regrade.","fingerprint":"3753a55890eb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00619","start_s":2912.793,"end_s":2923.333,"video_s":2962.793,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00178","chapter":"C007","text":"And if we think that's warranted, we will work with the labor union and the department head and gain concurrence on a strategy moving forward.","fingerprint":"250861195942","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00620","start_s":2923.433,"end_s":2926.378,"video_s":2973.433,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00178","chapter":"C007","text":"And then that will come to this body to make a final determination.","fingerprint":"c4699f830f87","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00621","start_s":2928.788,"end_s":2944.988,"video_s":2978.788,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00179","chapter":"C007","text":"So the data you use, if I understood correctly, is a market study from the local region and evaluating us against our, I'm not gonna say comparable cities, but surrounding cities to ensure that we are competitive.","fingerprint":"4a39ca4ecb9b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00622","start_s":2946.129,"end_s":2946.55,"video_s":2996.129,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00179","chapter":"C007","text":"That's correct.","fingerprint":"b09e054ee29f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00623","start_s":2947.03,"end_s":2949.714,"video_s":2997.03,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00179","chapter":"C007","text":"And so did this study show that we weren't competitive?","fingerprint":"dcf1388b4288","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00624","start_s":2950.935,"end_s":2955.741,"video_s":3000.935,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00180","chapter":"C007","text":"We found we were generally competitive with the local labor market for this type of work.","fingerprint":"b268922ef1ec","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00625","start_s":2957.037,"end_s":2966.001,"video_s":3007.037,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00181","chapter":"C007","text":"and so even though we were generally competitive, you are bringing to us an increase for this particular pay grade that we're talking about.","fingerprint":"fdbea6d89d8a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00626","start_s":2966.2,"end_s":2996.055,"video_s":3016.2,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00182","chapter":"C007","text":"that's correct because in addition to the competitive nature externally we were also looking internally and in the review of this classification we felt it compared closely with a recreation coordinator and so we were aligning this body of work with a recreation coordinator and we worked with those departments to assess similar jobs not the same jobs but similar jobs and that's how we ended up with the final determination that we're bringing forward today","fingerprint":"b15dc71d155c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00627","start_s":2997.993,"end_s":3021.79,"video_s":3047.993,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00183","chapter":"C007","text":"So even though we were competitive in pay to our neighboring cities, the reason you brought forth a pay increase is because comparatively speaking to other jobs within the city that seemed similar enough, is that a fair way to describe it, you still felt like a pay increase was needed.","fingerprint":"b99c0c1db099","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00628","start_s":3021.77,"end_s":3024.333,"video_s":3071.77,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00183","chapter":"C007","text":"and is that yet correct?","fingerprint":"6d30783599ca","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00629","start_s":3025.395,"end_s":3025.755,"video_s":3075.395,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00184","chapter":"C007","text":"Correct.","fingerprint":"15a596e3c98c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00630","start_s":3026.516,"end_s":3034.306,"video_s":3076.516,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00185","chapter":"C007","text":"Okay and was this presented to the Aspatia right is that the correct?","fingerprint":"3f5eef0bd3b0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00631","start_s":3036.449,"end_s":3039.693,"video_s":3086.449,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00186","chapter":"C007","text":"It was Aspatia was involved in this correct.","fingerprint":"8471de201b67","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00632","start_s":3039.713,"end_s":3043.137,"video_s":3089.713,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00187","chapter":"C007","text":"Okay and were there others that disagreed with this?","fingerprint":"5f74cbacbdf1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00633","start_s":3045.783,"end_s":3047.385,"video_s":3095.783,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00188","chapter":"C007","text":"I can't speak to the number who disagreed.","fingerprint":"6de7ec511030","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00634","start_s":3047.405,"end_s":3049.429,"video_s":3097.405,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00189","chapter":"C007","text":"I'm not right off the top of my head.","fingerprint":"608282f7debc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00635","start_s":3049.449,"end_s":3052.113,"video_s":3099.449,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00189","chapter":"C007","text":"Okay, so Tyler is here, obviously.","fingerprint":"363a4e596bf1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00636","start_s":3052.153,"end_s":3053.975,"video_s":3102.153,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00190","chapter":"C007","text":"And poor Tyler, you can sit down.","fingerprint":"f27f99d452ef","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00637","start_s":3054.015,"end_s":3055.578,"video_s":3104.015,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00191","chapter":"C007","text":"Sorry, Tyler.","fingerprint":"67c4c9baed04","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00638","start_s":3057.06,"end_s":3063.69,"video_s":3107.06,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00191","chapter":"C007","text":"So in the process of working with the association and employees, tell me more about that then when you present that.","fingerprint":"ca7c3980f3d5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00639","start_s":3069.374,"end_s":3075.984,"video_s":3119.374,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00191","chapter":"C007","text":"I guess when you present it to, I'm presuming an employee group asked for this to be reviewed.","fingerprint":"72ed7c6a1db1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00640","start_s":3076.726,"end_s":3077.787,"video_s":3126.726,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00191","chapter":"C007","text":"Is that correct?","fingerprint":"bad86010d563","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00641","start_s":3077.968,"end_s":3078.408,"video_s":3127.968,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00191","chapter":"C007","text":"That is correct.","fingerprint":"a388af4f4e99","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00642","start_s":3078.428,"end_s":3079.67,"video_s":3128.428,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00191","chapter":"C007","text":"Okay, a correct assumption on my part.","fingerprint":"a503ba1d73a7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00643","start_s":3080.111,"end_s":3093.452,"video_s":3130.111,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00191","chapter":"C007","text":"So when you go back to that group of employees or employee, do you present this information and the data by which you've come to your recommendation for the city council?","fingerprint":"62f28f1b73e8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00644","start_s":3093.793,"end_s":3096.597,"video_s":3143.793,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00191","chapter":"C007","text":"Or do you just come to city council without going back to them?","fingerprint":"1008f34de414","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00645","start_s":3096.779,"end_s":3108.03,"video_s":3146.779,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C007","text":"No, we worked, Mayor, Council Ryan, we worked extensively with Aspatia leadership and discussed all of the factors that we're considering.","fingerprint":"8db8e73a6730","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00646","start_s":3108.07,"end_s":3115.218,"video_s":3158.07,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C007","text":"External competitiveness, internal alignment, ramifications of ripple effects.","fingerprint":"2bab080092d5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00647","start_s":3115.298,"end_s":3119.722,"video_s":3165.298,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C007","text":"If we change one job classification, what does that affect other classifications across the city?","fingerprint":"db166f183254","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00648","start_s":3120.243,"end_s":3125.368,"video_s":3170.243,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C007","text":"We felt like we had a solid proposal that Aspatia leadership would support.","fingerprint":"ab82dd54fe3e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00649","start_s":3125.348,"end_s":3128.014,"video_s":3175.348,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C007","text":"and the department leadership would support.","fingerprint":"e03b7fedb467","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00650","start_s":3128.595,"end_s":3133.485,"video_s":3178.595,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00192","chapter":"C007","text":"We presented that to the Human Resources Committee and we're bringing it forward to this body today.","fingerprint":"26f051589e7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00651","start_s":3134.568,"end_s":3134.748,"video_s":3184.568,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00193","chapter":"C007","text":"Okay.","fingerprint":"6a581ee90118","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00652","start_s":3135.309,"end_s":3144.268,"video_s":3185.309,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00193","chapter":"C007","text":"Given the request for an amendment to the motion, what steps would you take then from here were that to pass?","fingerprint":"edfdd1db3f4e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00653","start_s":3146.932,"end_s":3172.385,"video_s":3196.932,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00194","chapter":"C007","text":"Councilwoman O'Brien, if you're asking if the amendment passes, in other words, I believe the amendment right now is to review this classification again, this classification family, we would, the class and comp would have to go through the process as just described again, including, and they have a lot of the data, so they can go back, look at the data, but again, it would have to be reviewed in that internal alignment that Greg spoke about as well.","fingerprint":"aef0d3337b10","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00654","start_s":3172.786,"end_s":3176.23,"video_s":3222.786,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00194","chapter":"C007","text":"But we can certainly take that back and do another look at it.","fingerprint":"7e4d8fee7581","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00655","start_s":3176.665,"end_s":3181.176,"video_s":3226.665,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00195","chapter":"C007","text":"And you would go back to the Human Resources Commission, is that, sorry?","fingerprint":"ca99f4f825f9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00656","start_s":3181.316,"end_s":3183.722,"video_s":3231.316,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00196","chapter":"C007","text":"The Human Resources Committee, yes, the HRC as well.","fingerprint":"9c0b2d5634f6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00657","start_s":3183.782,"end_s":3188.634,"video_s":3233.782,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00197","chapter":"C007","text":"HRC, before you were to make a recommendation to the City Council.","fingerprint":"a25e6c91b5cd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00658","start_s":3189.295,"end_s":3192.042,"video_s":3239.295,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00198","chapter":"C007","text":"That's correct, it would have to go through HRC, correct.","fingerprint":"aac27f79ab51","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00659","start_s":3192.022,"end_s":3201.498,"video_s":3242.022,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00199","chapter":"C007","text":"Okay, and I want to just ensure that is that what you're asking for Councilwoman Guardado is for that to go back through the process.","fingerprint":"1d242be52b83","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00660","start_s":3201.518,"end_s":3210.793,"video_s":3251.518,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00199","chapter":"C007","text":"And if what I would ask you now is if they go back and review this and the assessment is that this is the correct pay grade.","fingerprint":"8f5680ddca5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00661","start_s":3210.813,"end_s":3215.942,"video_s":3260.813,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00200","chapter":"C007","text":"Yeah, I mean, I'm hopeful that they will come around.","fingerprint":"282deb107bb0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00662","start_s":3216.002,"end_s":3217.945,"video_s":3266.002,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00200","chapter":"C007","text":"I'm sure Jason will come around and brief us.","fingerprint":"e2c14b447d64","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00663","start_s":3218.448,"end_s":3224.544,"video_s":3268.448,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00200","chapter":"C007","text":"and before it comes to the dais, I'm sure there'll be consensus on the council on how we're moving forward.","fingerprint":"5b0c136fd05a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00664","start_s":3230.5,"end_s":3235.292,"video_s":3280.5,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00201","chapter":"C007","text":"So Mayor, Councilman O'Brien, my understanding of the motion would be","fingerprint":"ed8b1f5d7c9d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00665","start_s":3236.926,"end_s":3245.165,"video_s":3286.926,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00201","chapter":"C007","text":"that you're moving to approve this item as it is so that no one's increase, because there's others on here, are held up.","fingerprint":"8bce6bee0d35","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00666","start_s":3245.947,"end_s":3254.867,"video_s":3295.947,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00201","chapter":"C007","text":"We would then, as staff, go back, re-examine all the steps we took, re-consult with the labor groups, talk with the employees,","fingerprint":"52d7ab10c12e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00667","start_s":3254.948,"end_s":3260.116,"video_s":3304.948,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00201","chapter":"C007","text":"and then come back with, if there were any changes that came out of that process, we would bring those back.","fingerprint":"49fed0d603c2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00668","start_s":3260.457,"end_s":3265.004,"video_s":3310.457,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00201","chapter":"C007","text":"It is possible that after doing all that, they would still come to the same conclusion, possible.","fingerprint":"e47af46e9a36","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00669","start_s":3265.364,"end_s":3270.072,"video_s":3315.364,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00201","chapter":"C007","text":"It's also possible that they might come with a different conclusion, but they would lay all that out very clearly.","fingerprint":"0b4cdee5c9d0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00670","start_s":3270.452,"end_s":3279.066,"video_s":3320.452,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00201","chapter":"C007","text":"And as you said, we'd be able to brief council members beforehand with that, as well as I think to the vice mayor's question,","fingerprint":"7d0e2ded55f7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00671","start_s":3279.046,"end_s":3283.511,"video_s":3329.046,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00201","chapter":"C007","text":"more fully lay out the process so you understand all those steps that go into it as well.","fingerprint":"20915f2bfa41","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00672","start_s":3283.531,"end_s":3285.293,"video_s":3333.531,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00201","chapter":"C007","text":"Does that capture what you're seeking?","fingerprint":"32f0b0d2225f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00673","start_s":3285.333,"end_s":3287.976,"video_s":3335.333,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00202","chapter":"C007","text":"Okay.","fingerprint":"6a581ee90118","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00674","start_s":3287.996,"end_s":3301.951,"video_s":3337.996,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00202","chapter":"C007","text":"Mayor, can I just very quickly, and I would implore you to at least go out to the senior centers and observe what they do and see the level of work and responsibility they take on because it is pretty important.","fingerprint":"1eb2631e99da","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00675","start_s":3302.652,"end_s":3305.475,"video_s":3352.652,"speaker":"debra-stark","turn":"T00202","chapter":"C007","text":"I think that would help maybe with the reassessment.","fingerprint":"ca4b281fd04e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00676","start_s":3306.772,"end_s":3310.876,"video_s":3356.772,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00203","chapter":"C007","text":"and thank you, and Councilwoman O'Brien still has the floor.","fingerprint":"9c84ea08cfc9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00677","start_s":3311.716,"end_s":3335.918,"video_s":3361.716,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00204","chapter":"C007","text":"Thank you, Ed, for the further clarification, but I guess what I want to, or what I feel like is missing is that we need to see the data, because this isn't just a, how do I wanna say, the process is not just a conversation with the employees and what we're looking at data,","fingerprint":"681c58d0d0b0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00678","start_s":3335.898,"end_s":3339.342,"video_s":3385.898,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00204","chapter":"C007","text":"and job descriptions and pay.","fingerprint":"76dda7ca7040","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00679","start_s":3339.803,"end_s":3341.605,"video_s":3389.803,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00204","chapter":"C007","text":"And then I'm gonna ask one more question.","fingerprint":"ec0970aa523c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00680","start_s":3341.625,"end_s":3357.525,"video_s":3391.625,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00204","chapter":"C007","text":"When we do do these reviews and talk to our neighboring cities, is it just about pay alone or do we also look at the compensation part, sorry, the rest of the package, which is benefits, thank you.","fingerprint":"c04e4ab206f2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00681","start_s":3358.907,"end_s":3363.593,"video_s":3408.907,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00204","chapter":"C007","text":"Because when I was on school board,","fingerprint":"a0ab151bff11","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00682","start_s":3363.573,"end_s":3388.5,"video_s":3413.573,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00204","chapter":"C007","text":"folks would talk about pay but they would forget about the benefit side of their package and when you compare both that was a bigger package for our employees than our neighboring school districts but they they wanted more pay but they didn't want to give up the benefit side of it so is that a consideration when we talk about this","fingerprint":"694cd9db60c2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00683","start_s":3394.876,"end_s":3409.628,"video_s":3444.876,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00205","chapter":"C007","text":"For Mayor, Councillor O'Brien, for these kinds of studies when they're specific to a classification or a job family and we're comparing to the local labour market, we're primarily looking at the base compensation.","fingerprint":"d63db7dce4d5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00684","start_s":3411.397,"end_s":3439.345,"video_s":3461.397,"speaker":"v10","turn":"T00205","chapter":"C007","text":"We fully recognize that when we're comparing with the private sector, the total compensation is probably a more robust package for us to review, but for most of our classifications within the city, especially those that are in the STEP system, comparing to other public sector municipalities, our base compensation is a reasonable proximity to gauge a competitive position for our jobs.","fingerprint":"adbb916b41d1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00685","start_s":3439.797,"end_s":3443.566,"video_s":3489.797,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00206","chapter":"C007","text":"So our benefits packages, we don't compare those to our neighboring cities?","fingerprint":"d0a29edee51a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00686","start_s":3446.954,"end_s":3452.808,"video_s":3496.954,"speaker":"v09","turn":"T00207","chapter":"C007","text":"Mayor, members of council, Councilwoman O'Brien, for the purposes of these studies, it is the base wage that class and compensation looks at.","fingerprint":"e4f6a9ce197e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00687","start_s":3455.715,"end_s":3456.777,"video_s":3505.715,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00208","chapter":"C007","text":"Okay, that...","fingerprint":"d53fa8b21e3a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00688","start_s":3457.448,"end_s":3463.4,"video_s":3507.448,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00208","chapter":"C007","text":"And I would tell you, I would ask that as we start going forward, that that be a consideration.","fingerprint":"d5df37f6c9a7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00689","start_s":3463.42,"end_s":3478.309,"video_s":3513.42,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00208","chapter":"C007","text":"I understand the base wage concept, but I also, I mean, not knowing what that is, I mean, and clearly we don't look at it, I think it is not a best practice to not evaluate that as well because","fingerprint":"513545e165b2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00690","start_s":3478.289,"end_s":3480.313,"video_s":3528.289,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00208","chapter":"C007","text":"Benefits are a big deal.","fingerprint":"82a5fe399b20","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00691","start_s":3480.414,"end_s":3495.707,"video_s":3530.414,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00208","chapter":"C007","text":"I mean, we might be making the same base wage, whether it's 30,000, 50,000, or 100,000, but if my benefits package is worth 40,000 in Phoenix and it's worth 10,000 in another city, I won't name any,","fingerprint":"46319cd6870a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00692","start_s":3495.687,"end_s":3500.616,"video_s":3545.687,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00208","chapter":"C007","text":"because I don't want to get in trouble, then that is a discrepancy.","fingerprint":"992c5d797c8f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00693","start_s":3500.776,"end_s":3504.864,"video_s":3550.776,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00208","chapter":"C007","text":"And there is more value depending on what matters to you.","fingerprint":"7afe904c00ea","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00694","start_s":3504.984,"end_s":3516.345,"video_s":3554.984,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00208","chapter":"C007","text":"And if benefits don't matter to you, like somebody who is married and has kids, the health benefit package might be more important than if you don't have that in a different city.","fingerprint":"beb47d3859b3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00695","start_s":3517.54,"end_s":3523.287,"video_s":3567.54,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00208","chapter":"C007","text":"I don't think we're doing ourselves a good service to not look at that.","fingerprint":"a0668e8033fd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00696","start_s":3524.408,"end_s":3525.53,"video_s":3574.408,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00208","chapter":"C007","text":"It is a whole package.","fingerprint":"dfef33bab45e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00697","start_s":3525.55,"end_s":3527.772,"video_s":3575.55,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00208","chapter":"C007","text":"I do want to take care of our employees.","fingerprint":"d98bc4fd7229","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00698","start_s":3528.473,"end_s":3540.628,"video_s":3578.473,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00208","chapter":"C007","text":"What I don't want to do, which is what makes me a little nervous about this motion, is to mandate that they come back to or that we mandate that they make a change and go to the","fingerprint":"bd1751a4e52c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00699","start_s":3540.608,"end_s":3543.711,"video_s":3590.608,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00208","chapter":"C007","text":"and the Human Resources Committee.","fingerprint":"ea27fba219c6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00700","start_s":3544.272,"end_s":3553.982,"video_s":3594.272,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00208","chapter":"C007","text":"It's that they're going to evaluate it and that if they don't make, if there's not a recommendation to change, then it stops there.","fingerprint":"4723193ff2dd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00701","start_s":3554.002,"end_s":3555.263,"video_s":3604.002,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00208","chapter":"C007","text":"Is that fair?","fingerprint":"113bff90e947","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00702","start_s":3555.283,"end_s":3560.309,"video_s":3605.283,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00209","chapter":"C007","text":"Mayor, Council Member O'Brien, yes, that was the intention of what I stated was we would do that.","fingerprint":"2b1034696554","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00703","start_s":3560.369,"end_s":3564.473,"video_s":3610.369,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00209","chapter":"C007","text":"And I think you said something important which is,","fingerprint":"b71ca48aeb66","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00704","start_s":3564.689,"end_s":3566.471,"video_s":3614.689,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00209","chapter":"C007","text":"that we should come back and show the data.","fingerprint":"bb7948e574dc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00705","start_s":3566.491,"end_s":3581.948,"video_s":3616.491,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00209","chapter":"C007","text":"So I think what this does is gives staff the opportunity with this as a test, not a test, but an example to really come back and walk through with each of you what steps to go through, what data fed into the assessment.","fingerprint":"e9f551067166","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00706","start_s":3581.968,"end_s":3586.773,"video_s":3631.968,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00209","chapter":"C007","text":"And if as we go back and we assess that it should be higher because of factors, we'll lay all that out.","fingerprint":"a7e7457fc665","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00707","start_s":3586.873,"end_s":3589.836,"video_s":3636.873,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00209","chapter":"C007","text":"If not, we'll lay all that out in either direction.","fingerprint":"52f942ab9dc4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00708","start_s":3589.816,"end_s":3605.175,"video_s":3639.816,"speaker":"ed-zuercher","turn":"T00209","chapter":"C007","text":"but it'll give an opportunity for you to fully understand the reclassification and HRC process and we can take the time to do that and you can understand every step of that and the evaluation that has gone into the recommendation that we're bringing you.","fingerprint":"a625f37d2484","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00709","start_s":3605.678,"end_s":3611.929,"video_s":3655.678,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00210","chapter":"C007","text":"With that clarification, Mayor, I'm willing to accept the friendly amendment.","fingerprint":"4e3b7d544e61","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00710","start_s":3612.13,"end_s":3625.374,"video_s":3662.13,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00210","chapter":"C007","text":"And then I would just ask that going forward, I would hope with the support of my colleagues that we would start looking at the entire compensation package, not just the base pay when we're evaluating this.","fingerprint":"e719092a1d78","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00711","start_s":3625.575,"end_s":3625.935,"video_s":3675.575,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00210","chapter":"C007","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00712","start_s":3626.416,"end_s":3626.636,"video_s":3676.416,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00211","chapter":"C007","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00713","start_s":3626.657,"end_s":3629.121,"video_s":3676.657,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00211","chapter":"C007","text":"And I think that was consistent with the Vice Mayor's","fingerprint":"b5606e078713","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00714","start_s":3629.455,"end_s":3633.1,"video_s":3679.455,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C007","text":"That was consistent, but I wanted to clarify on something else.","fingerprint":"f2f192558454","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00715","start_s":3633.16,"end_s":3638.146,"video_s":3683.16,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C007","text":"So Councilwoman Stark, for example, talked about going out to the center and observing them.","fingerprint":"59ee3d7e6da0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00716","start_s":3638.206,"end_s":3645.255,"video_s":3688.206,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C007","text":"While I understand her motivation for that, again, this comes back to my idea that we need to be consistent.","fingerprint":"44cecc6f8d13","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00717","start_s":3645.436,"end_s":3651.003,"video_s":3695.436,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C007","text":"If that's not what we do for every classification as we reclassify, I don't think it's appropriate.","fingerprint":"cc4b55f2a369","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00718","start_s":3651.023,"end_s":3652.645,"video_s":3701.023,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C007","text":"But if we do it for all of them,","fingerprint":"7ff37267a2c6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00719","start_s":3652.625,"end_s":3653.809,"video_s":3702.625,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C007","text":"I think it's appropriate.","fingerprint":"1185b2901350","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00720","start_s":3653.849,"end_s":3662.095,"video_s":3703.849,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C007","text":"And I think that's why I would like to make sure that it's clear that this motion is to, for lack of a better word, begin the process","fingerprint":"aeaada20e416","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00721","start_s":3663.07,"end_s":3677.433,"video_s":3713.07,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C007","text":"over for these two positions, these two classified positions, in light of the arguments that were articulated and comparing it to the other classification they think they're aligned with.","fingerprint":"934c45237a9e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00722","start_s":3677.453,"end_s":3690.073,"video_s":3727.453,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C007","text":"I don't view the motion as asking you to go beyond what already exists in term of framework, and then you would provide a briefing to us as council members as to what the results of that are.","fingerprint":"fb595e9007a3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00723","start_s":3690.053,"end_s":3691.515,"video_s":3740.053,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C007","text":"specific review was.","fingerprint":"9dfeadd11e2e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00724","start_s":3692.116,"end_s":3694.199,"video_s":3742.116,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C007","text":"That's my hope of the motion.","fingerprint":"705bfa0fdfea","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00725","start_s":3694.639,"end_s":3696.262,"video_s":3744.639,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C007","text":"Is that incorrect?","fingerprint":"945d7a46423c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00726","start_s":3696.282,"end_s":3696.842,"video_s":3746.282,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00212","chapter":"C007","text":"Okay thank you.","fingerprint":"21d63267fca8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00727","start_s":3697.263,"end_s":3699.787,"video_s":3747.263,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00213","chapter":"C007","text":"Thank you and I want to agree with Councilman O'Brien.","fingerprint":"fc0bbff3481d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00728","start_s":3700.207,"end_s":3702.11,"video_s":3750.207,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00213","chapter":"C007","text":"To me total compensation really matters.","fingerprint":"6e778636439e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00729","start_s":3702.15,"end_s":3707.217,"video_s":3752.15,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00213","chapter":"C007","text":"We have excellent benefits including many that peer cities don't offer and that matters.","fingerprint":"05568644d203","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00730","start_s":3707.557,"end_s":3714.767,"video_s":3757.557,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00213","chapter":"C007","text":"I also think we should take in account the merit system and it's something like 80 percent of our employees could get something like a five percent raise.","fingerprint":"9b7b7cbb85a3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00731","start_s":3715.368,"end_s":3718.052,"video_s":3765.368,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00213","chapter":"C007","text":"That's incredible and our peer cities don't offer that and if","fingerprint":"4caf56c1b5ca","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00732","start_s":3719.348,"end_s":3724.716,"video_s":3769.348,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00213","chapter":"C007","text":"If almost everyone in a class is likely to get it, that is also fair to consider.","fingerprint":"5064997cfff0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00733","start_s":3724.776,"end_s":3730.025,"video_s":3774.776,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00213","chapter":"C007","text":"We really, I think, would be well served by looking at total compensation.","fingerprint":"f147f5b90a3e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00734","start_s":3730.065,"end_s":3737.897,"video_s":3780.065,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00213","chapter":"C007","text":"And if people don't value total compensation, then we should just put everything into base wage and forget with those benefits.","fingerprint":"c4ee85d848c8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00735","start_s":3738.687,"end_s":3750.017,"video_s":3788.687,"speaker":"lori-bays","turn":"T00214","chapter":"C007","text":"And Mayor, if I may just add to that point, we do publish each year for each employee a personalized summary of their total compensation.","fingerprint":"1814c911b88b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00736","start_s":3750.097,"end_s":3753.827,"video_s":3800.097,"speaker":"lori-bays","turn":"T00214","chapter":"C007","text":"So it includes everything that they receive from","fingerprint":"d6ee2403ee24","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00737","start_s":3753.807,"end_s":3776.49,"video_s":3803.807,"speaker":"lori-bays","turn":"T00214","chapter":"C007","text":"All of those things summarized in a document for them to be able to review exactly how much they get to the penny for each of those items, and it includes their total compensation package.","fingerprint":"e6a87cf2d7ba","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00738","start_s":3776.47,"end_s":3777.972,"video_s":3826.47,"speaker":"lori-bays","turn":"T00214","chapter":"C007","text":"and so on.","fingerprint":"9066644a9341","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00739","start_s":3780.636,"end_s":3786.304,"video_s":3830.636,"speaker":"lori-bays","turn":"T00214","chapter":"C007","text":"So I do want to point that out.","fingerprint":"5a4c9cc868b3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00740","start_s":3786.685,"end_s":3799.002,"video_s":3836.685,"speaker":"lori-bays","turn":"T00214","chapter":"C007","text":"Some employees may not realize that that's available to them in ECRIS and so I would encourage all employees to review that because it does give a very good summary of everything that we provide to our employees and it is a very, very rich benefit package.","fingerprint":"08b5bd734ebd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00741","start_s":3799.066,"end_s":3799.447,"video_s":3849.066,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00215","chapter":"C007","text":"Wonderful.","fingerprint":"ee04228c5c6d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00742","start_s":3799.467,"end_s":3803.095,"video_s":3849.467,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00215","chapter":"C007","text":"I used to work at an employer that would mail it to each of us and then you'd read.","fingerprint":"56c0c8912aa3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00743","start_s":3803.255,"end_s":3805.2,"video_s":3853.255,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00215","chapter":"C007","text":"And it felt good to see your total compensation.","fingerprint":"5ebc278467fc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00744","start_s":3805.44,"end_s":3808.768,"video_s":3855.44,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00215","chapter":"C007","text":"So we spent an enormous amount of time on electrician pay a few years ago.","fingerprint":"6211966e8c31","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00745","start_s":3809.57,"end_s":3813.518,"video_s":3859.57,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00215","chapter":"C007","text":"Some electricians have wonderful pensions outside the city, including private sector.","fingerprint":"1bed346a019f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00746","start_s":3813.839,"end_s":3814.601,"video_s":3863.839,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00215","chapter":"C007","text":"Some do not.","fingerprint":"dabd430ba6f7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00747","start_s":3815.543,"end_s":3816.906,"video_s":3865.543,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00215","chapter":"C007","text":"Did we just do base pay?","fingerprint":"0b9829ebdda9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00748","start_s":3818.928,"end_s":3834.49,"video_s":3868.928,"speaker":"lori-bays","turn":"T00216","chapter":"C007","text":"So, Mayor, members of the Council, the reality is in the job market that we've been in, and things have recently started to slow down, but by and large, the job market over the last several years has been highly competitive, and we have had to compete both at base pay alone and","fingerprint":"6d0031f540b9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00749","start_s":3834.47,"end_s":3835.911,"video_s":3884.47,"speaker":"lori-bays","turn":"T00216","chapter":"C007","text":"at Total Compensation.","fingerprint":"99810ea22ce4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00750","start_s":3836.312,"end_s":3839.715,"video_s":3886.312,"speaker":"lori-bays","turn":"T00216","chapter":"C007","text":"So we've really been trying to focus on both at the same time.","fingerprint":"ef1318dbf4bb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00751","start_s":3839.775,"end_s":3853.287,"video_s":3889.775,"speaker":"lori-bays","turn":"T00216","chapter":"C007","text":"Now that things are slowing down in the labor market, we can definitely focus a little bit more on looking at that Total Compensation package and advertising what we're doing with regard to benefits and other pays outside of base pay.","fingerprint":"1f9965fac9e0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00752","start_s":3854.128,"end_s":3860.354,"video_s":3904.128,"speaker":"lori-bays","turn":"T00216","chapter":"C007","text":"But it is really important right now and has been for the last several years that we also focus on base pay.","fingerprint":"919b274cc715","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00753","start_s":3860.394,"end_s":3861.895,"video_s":3910.394,"speaker":"lori-bays","turn":"T00216","chapter":"C007","text":"So I don't think that we can","fingerprint":"0a60445db769","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00754","start_s":3861.875,"end_s":3866.363,"video_s":3911.875,"speaker":"lori-bays","turn":"T00216","chapter":"C007","text":"take our foot off the gas of focusing on base pay if we're going to remain competitive in the labor market.","fingerprint":"53c78b526adf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00755","start_s":3866.724,"end_s":3873.435,"video_s":3916.724,"speaker":"lori-bays","turn":"T00216","chapter":"C007","text":"But we do have to also, to your points, point out what we have in total compensation and how wonderful of a benefit package we offer.","fingerprint":"10a13e4cd043","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00756","start_s":3874.097,"end_s":3874.317,"video_s":3924.097,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00217","chapter":"C007","text":"Mayor.","fingerprint":"dd51a825d06a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00757","start_s":3874.998,"end_s":3875.78,"video_s":3924.998,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00217","chapter":"C007","text":"Councilwoman O'Brien.","fingerprint":"003ed429bc6f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00758","start_s":3876.401,"end_s":3880.508,"video_s":3926.401,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00218","chapter":"C007","text":"And I don't want my comments to be mistaken that we shouldn't","fingerprint":"6f1c40434fb5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00759","start_s":3880.673,"end_s":3884.619,"video_s":3930.673,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00218","chapter":"C007","text":"have base pay as something that we look at.","fingerprint":"d8f8c9eb8adf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00760","start_s":3884.679,"end_s":3888.104,"video_s":3934.679,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00218","chapter":"C007","text":"I don't know if you want to call it the focus, but that's the primary.","fingerprint":"0bee21cf20b5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00761","start_s":3888.164,"end_s":3897.637,"video_s":3938.164,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00218","chapter":"C007","text":"But to not do this part, I'm glad that we look at that, that it's available, but it is important to, I think, not just have it available, but to be able to compare.","fingerprint":"7964b13c78ec","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00762","start_s":3898.238,"end_s":3908.453,"video_s":3948.238,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00218","chapter":"C007","text":"So I do understand it's been a very tight job market and continues to be, you're right, it's nice that it's lightening up a little bit, but please, yeah.","fingerprint":"e9d585c2c3d1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00763","start_s":3908.433,"end_s":3910.738,"video_s":3958.433,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00218","chapter":"C007","text":"to make sure we're able to compare all of it.","fingerprint":"2fdc1f4bdbfe","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00764","start_s":3911.299,"end_s":3911.58,"video_s":3961.299,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00219","chapter":"C007","text":"Mayor?","fingerprint":"dd51a825d06a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00765","start_s":3912.602,"end_s":3915.187,"video_s":3962.602,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00220","chapter":"C007","text":"I think I saw Councilman Hernandez first and then Councilman Guardado.","fingerprint":"39a7ba782209","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00766","start_s":3915.327,"end_s":3916.109,"video_s":3965.327,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00220","chapter":"C007","text":"Councilman Guardado.","fingerprint":"aa00302728d8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00767","start_s":3916.61,"end_s":3916.951,"video_s":3966.61,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C007","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00768","start_s":3917.392,"end_s":3927.994,"video_s":3967.392,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C007","text":"I mean, I think, yes, I think we should be looking at the two packages, but at least one of the things that I continue to hear is that,","fingerprint":"73938a9804cf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00769","start_s":3927.974,"end_s":3947.788,"video_s":3977.974,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C007","text":"Thank you all for joining us.","fingerprint":"1b7dec27c4c8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00770","start_s":3947.768,"end_s":3952.957,"video_s":3997.768,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C007","text":"because they know that there's a lot of people because they have the option of paying for health care or not paying for health care.","fingerprint":"5fc42ec78884","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00771","start_s":3953.739,"end_s":3971.751,"video_s":4003.739,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C007","text":"To me, that's a dangerous zone to only look at the whole package just because I do feel there's a lot of departments where there is still a lot of turnover because they're more focused on being able to feed families instead of having the whole package because there's a lot of","fingerprint":"69cb0c495842","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00772","start_s":3971.731,"end_s":3973.974,"video_s":4021.731,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C007","text":"folks that still qualify for access.","fingerprint":"ea2160309b97","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00773","start_s":3974.815,"end_s":3989.715,"video_s":4024.815,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C007","text":"So I would like to see if there's a way to get a breakdown on how many people are taking the full package and paying for health insurance and paying for dental and paying for everything that we offer.","fingerprint":"4f4cbe94d2cc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00774","start_s":3989.755,"end_s":3990.856,"video_s":4039.755,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C007","text":"It's an amazing package.","fingerprint":"02384d301f94","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00775","start_s":3990.876,"end_s":3996.143,"video_s":4040.876,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C007","text":"I think for people that have been working here for 10 plus years, I think it's a great thing.","fingerprint":"652a6cb93424","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00776","start_s":3996.604,"end_s":4000.489,"video_s":4046.604,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C007","text":"Folks that are thinking about retirement and need health insurance more than ever.","fingerprint":"3a176be376c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00777","start_s":4000.469,"end_s":4027.388,"video_s":4050.469,"speaker":"betty-guardado","turn":"T00221","chapter":"C007","text":"but I think in order to attract people I think the way we attract people is by the the base rate and I think that's how we've been able to change things but like I'm curious to be able to see that and see what that looks like and if it's true that you know our young people that were that we're hiring that we're hopeful will be here in 20 years are are taking that package at the moment thank you thank you Lori thank you everybody","fingerprint":"446930fe438d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00778","start_s":4027.688,"end_s":4040.986,"video_s":4077.688,"speaker":"lori-bays","turn":"T00222","chapter":"C007","text":"Mayor, Councilman Guardado, we can pull that information for you, and I think that underscores the point that I was making about how we have to really look at both competitiveness at base wage alone as well as with total compensation.","fingerprint":"2805c7457811","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00779","start_s":4041.006,"end_s":4041.427,"video_s":4091.006,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C007","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00780","start_s":4042.588,"end_s":4044.11,"video_s":4092.588,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00223","chapter":"C007","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00781","start_s":4044.13,"end_s":4044.551,"video_s":4094.13,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00224","chapter":"C007","text":"Guardado?","fingerprint":"0344b48c3f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00782","start_s":4044.791,"end_s":4045.572,"video_s":4094.791,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00224","chapter":"C007","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00783","start_s":4045.592,"end_s":4046.193,"video_s":4095.592,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00224","chapter":"C007","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00784","start_s":4046.213,"end_s":4046.434,"video_s":4096.213,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00224","chapter":"C007","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00785","start_s":4047.014,"end_s":4047.395,"video_s":4097.014,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00224","chapter":"C007","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00786","start_s":4047.435,"end_s":4047.735,"video_s":4097.435,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00224","chapter":"C007","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00787","start_s":4048.316,"end_s":4048.737,"video_s":4098.316,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00224","chapter":"C007","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00788","start_s":4049.037,"end_s":4050.299,"video_s":4099.037,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00225","chapter":"C007","text":"Can I explain my vote?","fingerprint":"e881d2afa8f3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00789","start_s":4050.319,"end_s":4050.779,"video_s":4100.319,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00225","chapter":"C007","text":"Please do.","fingerprint":"a549bac1fc15","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00790","start_s":4052.161,"end_s":4057.088,"video_s":4102.161,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00225","chapter":"C007","text":"I'm voting yes, and I want to thank the employees for advocating for yourselves.","fingerprint":"e3ecaf900402","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00791","start_s":4057.186,"end_s":4084.628,"video_s":4107.186,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00225","chapter":"C007","text":"this was the final stop as you can see we are going back and forth but what I want to say is you are actually helping us improve the system and this is a way we improve the system and in a way in the future for policy if we need to so I just want to thank you yes Robinson yes Stark yes Waring Hodge Washington yes Gallego yes passes 9-0","fingerprint":"e31a1b4c24fd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00792","start_s":4089.097,"end_s":4089.497,"video_s":4139.097,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00226","chapter":"C007","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00793","start_s":4090.038,"end_s":4097.988,"video_s":4140.038,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00227","chapter":"C008","text":"Next, we go to item 24, which is to accept a gift from the Carnegie Corporation of New York to the Phoenix Public Library, Vice Mayor.","fingerprint":"15b67e33f78b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00794","start_s":4098.509,"end_s":4099.67,"video_s":4148.509,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00228","chapter":"C008","text":"Motion to approve item 24.","fingerprint":"8b49ea99a227","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00795","start_s":4100.191,"end_s":4100.611,"video_s":4150.191,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00228","chapter":"C008","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00796","start_s":4101.432,"end_s":4102.634,"video_s":4151.432,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00229","chapter":"C008","text":"We have a motion and a second.","fingerprint":"7451ba811637","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00797","start_s":4103.034,"end_s":4112.826,"video_s":4153.034,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00229","chapter":"C008","text":"This gift comes as part of the America 250 celebration, an incredible milestone for our country, and it will help our Carnegie Library location","fingerprint":"350158e47b80","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00798","start_s":4112.806,"end_s":4115.531,"video_s":4162.806,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00229","chapter":"C008","text":"celebrate this historic milestone.","fingerprint":"e6bcb184ea0f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00799","start_s":4115.551,"end_s":4119.779,"video_s":4165.551,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00229","chapter":"C008","text":"Our library was opened in 1908 and was among the first libraries to serve our city.","fingerprint":"ec0acf8543de","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00800","start_s":4120.48,"end_s":4129.316,"video_s":4170.48,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00229","chapter":"C008","text":"It's one of many ways that we and the state of Arizona are marking the America 250 milestone and really looking forward to supporting this item.","fingerprint":"f7f9baf95b66","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00801","start_s":4129.957,"end_s":4130.258,"video_s":4179.957,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00229","chapter":"C008","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00802","start_s":4131.318,"end_s":4131.839,"video_s":4181.318,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00229","chapter":"C008","text":"Guardado?","fingerprint":"0344b48c3f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00803","start_s":4132.039,"end_s":4132.239,"video_s":4182.039,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00230","chapter":"C008","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00804","start_s":4132.82,"end_s":4133.321,"video_s":4182.82,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00230","chapter":"C008","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00805","start_s":4133.341,"end_s":4133.982,"video_s":4183.341,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00230","chapter":"C008","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00806","start_s":4134.002,"end_s":4134.422,"video_s":4184.002,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00230","chapter":"C008","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00807","start_s":4134.803,"end_s":4135.363,"video_s":4184.803,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00230","chapter":"C008","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00808","start_s":4135.383,"end_s":4135.804,"video_s":4185.383,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00230","chapter":"C008","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00809","start_s":4135.944,"end_s":4136.144,"video_s":4185.944,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00230","chapter":"C008","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00810","start_s":4136.565,"end_s":4137.066,"video_s":4186.565,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00230","chapter":"C008","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00811","start_s":4137.106,"end_s":4137.346,"video_s":4187.106,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00230","chapter":"C008","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00812","start_s":4137.767,"end_s":4138.127,"video_s":4187.767,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00230","chapter":"C008","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00813","start_s":4138.327,"end_s":4139.008,"video_s":4188.327,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00230","chapter":"C008","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00814","start_s":4139.028,"end_s":4139.389,"video_s":4189.028,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00230","chapter":"C008","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00815","start_s":4140.21,"end_s":4140.29,"video_s":4190.21,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00230","chapter":"C008","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00816","start_s":4140.31,"end_s":4140.911,"video_s":4190.31,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00230","chapter":"C008","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00817","start_s":4141.131,"end_s":4141.371,"video_s":4191.131,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00230","chapter":"C008","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00818","start_s":4141.792,"end_s":4142.373,"video_s":4191.792,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00230","chapter":"C008","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00819","start_s":4142.393,"end_s":4142.893,"video_s":4192.393,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00230","chapter":"C008","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00820","start_s":4142.913,"end_s":4143.494,"video_s":4192.913,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00230","chapter":"C008","text":"Passes 9-0.","fingerprint":"f7c37e75fd84","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00821","start_s":4145.136,"end_s":4148.981,"video_s":4195.136,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00231","chapter":"C009","text":"Item 26 is related to Sueño Park Public Art.","fingerprint":"4406df285ab5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00822","start_s":4149.001,"end_s":4149.542,"video_s":4199.001,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00231","chapter":"C009","text":"Do we have a motion?","fingerprint":"ea97412996cb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00823","start_s":4150.143,"end_s":4151.264,"video_s":4200.143,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00231","chapter":"C009","text":"Motion to approve item 26.","fingerprint":"62d4dfef47f0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00824","start_s":4151.324,"end_s":4153.247,"video_s":4201.324,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00231","chapter":"C009","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00825","start_s":4153.267,"end_s":4154.869,"video_s":4203.267,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00231","chapter":"C009","text":"We have a motion and a second.","fingerprint":"7451ba811637","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00826","start_s":4156.011,"end_s":4157.072,"video_s":4206.011,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00231","chapter":"C009","text":"Councilwoman Pastor.","fingerprint":"dbcef12e9415","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00827","start_s":4157.288,"end_s":4159.993,"video_s":4207.288,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00232","chapter":"C009","text":"Yes, I want to talk about Suanyo Park.","fingerprint":"dda9318870c6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00828","start_s":4161.075,"end_s":4169.091,"video_s":4211.075,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00232","chapter":"C009","text":"Suanyo Park is an important community space in the heart of Maryville, and I'm very excited to see this investment coming to District 4's west side.","fingerprint":"95db7ea548ca","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00829","start_s":4169.953,"end_s":4177.187,"video_s":4219.953,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00232","chapter":"C009","text":"Maryville is a vibrant community where families rely heavily on our parks as a gathering space.","fingerprint":"e92ba55b2f70","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00830","start_s":4177.167,"end_s":4184.179,"video_s":4227.167,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00232","chapter":"C009","text":"Projects like this help ensure that art and culture investments reach every part of the city, not just our central core.","fingerprint":"fed2182767c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00831","start_s":4184.74,"end_s":4193.235,"video_s":4234.74,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00232","chapter":"C009","text":"The installation will also include a functional element like shade or seating, which directly improves the park experiences","fingerprint":"ff37c908be55","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00832","start_s":4193.317,"end_s":4196.7,"video_s":4243.317,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00232","chapter":"C009","text":"for resident and families who use the space every day.","fingerprint":"96cb630e69ae","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00833","start_s":4196.76,"end_s":4200.324,"video_s":4246.76,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00232","chapter":"C009","text":"I wanna recognize the selected artist, Joe Ray.","fingerprint":"f8079fe9cf61","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00834","start_s":4200.344,"end_s":4203.607,"video_s":4250.344,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00232","chapter":"C009","text":"He is part of the Sombra Collaborative.","fingerprint":"c3655d8719fa","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00835","start_s":4204.168,"end_s":4209.694,"video_s":4254.168,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00232","chapter":"C009","text":"His past work across Phoenix has focused on colorful and community-centered installations.","fingerprint":"8e0469baf688","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00836","start_s":4210.394,"end_s":4221.045,"video_s":4260.394,"speaker":"laura-pastor","turn":"T00232","chapter":"C009","text":"I just wanna thank the Office of Arts and Culture and everyone involved in the community-based selection process to ensure this project reflects the neighborhood it serves, thank you.","fingerprint":"6106e93487cb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00837","start_s":4222.713,"end_s":4223.174,"video_s":4272.713,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00233","chapter":"C009","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00838","start_s":4224.015,"end_s":4224.716,"video_s":4274.015,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00233","chapter":"C009","text":"Guardado?","fingerprint":"0344b48c3f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00839","start_s":4224.736,"end_s":4225.617,"video_s":4274.736,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00233","chapter":"C009","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00840","start_s":4225.637,"end_s":4226.018,"video_s":4275.637,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00233","chapter":"C009","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00841","start_s":4226.238,"end_s":4226.458,"video_s":4276.238,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00234","chapter":"C009","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00842","start_s":4226.959,"end_s":4227.38,"video_s":4276.959,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00235","chapter":"C009","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00843","start_s":4227.96,"end_s":4228.221,"video_s":4277.96,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00236","chapter":"C009","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00844","start_s":4228.621,"end_s":4229.062,"video_s":4278.621,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00237","chapter":"C009","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00845","start_s":4229.342,"end_s":4229.543,"video_s":4279.342,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00238","chapter":"C009","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00846","start_s":4229.963,"end_s":4230.464,"video_s":4279.963,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00239","chapter":"C009","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00847","start_s":4230.724,"end_s":4230.925,"video_s":4280.724,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00240","chapter":"C009","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00848","start_s":4231.425,"end_s":4231.766,"video_s":4281.425,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00241","chapter":"C009","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00849","start_s":4232.006,"end_s":4232.727,"video_s":4282.006,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00242","chapter":"C009","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00850","start_s":4232.747,"end_s":4233.068,"video_s":4282.747,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00243","chapter":"C009","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00851","start_s":4233.889,"end_s":4233.969,"video_s":4283.889,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00243","chapter":"C009","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00852","start_s":4233.989,"end_s":4234.67,"video_s":4283.989,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00243","chapter":"C009","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00853","start_s":4234.87,"end_s":4235.471,"video_s":4284.87,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00243","chapter":"C009","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00854","start_s":4235.491,"end_s":4235.972,"video_s":4285.491,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00243","chapter":"C009","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00855","start_s":4236.152,"end_s":4236.372,"video_s":4286.152,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00244","chapter":"C009","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00856","start_s":4236.813,"end_s":4237.354,"video_s":4286.813,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00245","chapter":"C009","text":"Passes 9-0.","fingerprint":"f7c37e75fd84","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00857","start_s":4238.956,"end_s":4242.421,"video_s":4288.956,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00246","chapter":"C010","text":"Item 30 is related to pilot simulator training contract.","fingerprint":"7d3ee3cf7712","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00858","start_s":4242.702,"end_s":4244.624,"video_s":4292.702,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00246","chapter":"C010","text":"We'll turn to our Public Safety Chairman for a motion.","fingerprint":"fc6e47dc5778","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00859","start_s":4246.187,"end_s":4246.787,"video_s":4296.187,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00247","chapter":"C010","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00860","start_s":4247.729,"end_s":4251.454,"video_s":4297.729,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00247","chapter":"C010","text":"I see the Commander and Assistant Chief are coming to the table.","fingerprint":"713fde7bf545","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00861","start_s":4254.117,"end_s":4259.426,"video_s":4304.117,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00247","chapter":"C010","text":"Chief Lee and Commander Riggin just had a quick question for you before I make a motion.","fingerprint":"b38ba53c50c6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00862","start_s":4259.446,"end_s":4260.769,"video_s":4309.446,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00247","chapter":"C010","text":"A couple of quick questions.","fingerprint":"e378751a13b5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00863","start_s":4261.45,"end_s":4274.954,"video_s":4311.45,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00247","chapter":"C010","text":"The simulated training, I think it's important to ask just a really general question and let you guys elaborate on it, but why is this training important?","fingerprint":"13174ca27f2c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00864","start_s":4275.014,"end_s":4276.817,"video_s":4325.014,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00247","chapter":"C010","text":"Why do you think it's necessary?","fingerprint":"31c227ba30d5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00865","start_s":4278.805,"end_s":4281.55,"video_s":4328.805,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00248","chapter":"C010","text":"Vice Mayor, members of City Council, Councilman Robinson.","fingerprint":"b1d49c409b89","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00866","start_s":4282.231,"end_s":4297.216,"video_s":4332.231,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00248","chapter":"C010","text":"So the use of simulator training in flight avionics has been used for decades and it has also been recognized as a national best practice for providing not only basic training but advanced as well as intermediate and emergency training.","fingerprint":"c3451207383d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00867","start_s":4297.877,"end_s":4300.341,"video_s":4347.877,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00248","chapter":"C010","text":"It helps the pilots be able to adjust to different","fingerprint":"7584a3d9a9a6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00868","start_s":4300.507,"end_s":4301.809,"video_s":4350.507,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00248","chapter":"C010","text":"types of aircraft.","fingerprint":"272c8d181697","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00869","start_s":4301.889,"end_s":4305.654,"video_s":4351.889,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00248","chapter":"C010","text":"It gives them scenarios that they're able to work through in a controlled environment.","fingerprint":"22090ad99b59","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00870","start_s":4306.635,"end_s":4321.536,"video_s":4356.635,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00248","chapter":"C010","text":"Some of the emergency procedures that these pilots are presented with in the form of a scenario are items that are emergent in nature and would typically put not only the pilot at risk, but also put the aircraft itself and the airframe under severe duress.","fingerprint":"68a192a99728","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00871","start_s":4321.516,"end_s":4333.635,"video_s":4371.516,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00248","chapter":"C010","text":"So the ability for us to utilize continued simulator training provides a cost-effective, safe environment for our folks to be able to learn the skill sets required to operate these million-dollar pieces of equipment.","fingerprint":"db78e6eaca7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00872","start_s":4335.725,"end_s":4357.561,"video_s":4385.725,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00249","chapter":"C010","text":"Thank you for that excuse me I have to admit I've spent a little bit of time up the air support unit lately and the amount of work that is being done by this particular unit and it's been some time I had the the pleasure of being in Chief Lee's position but it was 20 years ago when I had the air support unit and things have changed drastically.","fingerprint":"dbdbe9c1d014","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00873","start_s":4358.222,"end_s":4359.825,"video_s":4408.222,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00249","chapter":"C010","text":"Commander Riggin if you could","fingerprint":"566673454e3e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00874","start_s":4360.43,"end_s":4380.109,"video_s":4410.43,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00249","chapter":"C010","text":"Give us an idea of the types of things that you guys are doing nowadays, because I think it's really important, besides the training that is being done, the work that you are able to do with these types of aircraft, the platforms that we have up there, and how far reaching they are, and what it actually does for us in general.","fingerprint":"52ff5b0ac0ab","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00875","start_s":4380.663,"end_s":4382.828,"video_s":4430.663,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00250","chapter":"C010","text":"Yes, thank you, Mayor, Council, Councilman Robinson.","fingerprint":"e53a149a59b9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00876","start_s":4383.41,"end_s":4387.901,"video_s":4433.41,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00250","chapter":"C010","text":"The men and women of the air support units provides support to the patrol function in the city of Phoenix.","fingerprint":"12d0ca47bcbf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00877","start_s":4388.342,"end_s":4391.75,"video_s":4438.342,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00250","chapter":"C010","text":"They do that via surveillance missions that they do to identify targeted offenders.","fingerprint":"a2f480d863bb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00878","start_s":4391.951,"end_s":4396.883,"video_s":4441.951,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00250","chapter":"C010","text":"Traditionally, they are violent ones in nature, homicide suspects, armed robbery.","fingerprint":"1b44a776f514","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00879","start_s":4396.863,"end_s":4404.213,"video_s":4446.863,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00250","chapter":"C010","text":"And what they do is they provide an opportunity to maintain observation of that suspect until an appropriate time is done.","fingerprint":"87b8d93e3e80","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00880","start_s":4404.253,"end_s":4412.303,"video_s":4454.253,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00250","chapter":"C010","text":"We look at venue, environment, location for the appropriate time that traditionally our SWAT team or our crime impact unit is taking those dangerous felons off the street.","fingerprint":"8689d7ef1a18","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00881","start_s":4413.225,"end_s":4414.967,"video_s":4463.225,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00250","chapter":"C010","text":"They also perform transport missions.","fingerprint":"4810b899c179","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00882","start_s":4415.167,"end_s":4423.258,"video_s":4465.167,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00250","chapter":"C010","text":"So if one of our detectives needs to go to a neighboring state because a suspect was just as arrested, then they can provide that very timely service over there.","fingerprint":"5215074bdd3c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00883","start_s":4423.66,"end_s":4426.683,"video_s":4473.66,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00250","chapter":"C010","text":"and then in some cases have actually been able to keep the chain of custody.","fingerprint":"69fe5943bc0d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00884","start_s":4426.723,"end_s":4432.428,"video_s":4476.723,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00250","chapter":"C010","text":"They took a seat out of a vehicle one time, were able to put it inside of the airplane, transport it back.","fingerprint":"3d58b93059f1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00885","start_s":4432.488,"end_s":4443.979,"video_s":4482.488,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00250","chapter":"C010","text":"Those are valuable pieces of evidence that result in successful prosecution of crimes and then that's something that's always done for those transport missions depending upon if there is evidence related and they also do a cost analysis.","fingerprint":"b2d6907698ec","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00886","start_s":4443.999,"end_s":4450.866,"video_s":4493.999,"speaker":"v12","turn":"T00250","chapter":"C010","text":"So depending on how far it is, the number of people involved, if it's cheaper to use commercial aircraft, we'll do that and if it's cheaper to use our own, then we do that.","fingerprint":"494814244570","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00887","start_s":4452.483,"end_s":4453.845,"video_s":4502.483,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00251","chapter":"C010","text":"Okay, thank you very much for that.","fingerprint":"5de28eea6e30","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00888","start_s":4453.946,"end_s":4461.719,"video_s":4503.946,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00251","chapter":"C010","text":"And I wanted to get those points out because we were talking about training or this particular item deals with training, simulation training.","fingerprint":"d858b2a48ada","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00889","start_s":4462.12,"end_s":4469.954,"video_s":4512.12,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00251","chapter":"C010","text":"But I think it's important for everyone to understand the totality of why we do the training and the totality of what the mission happens to be.","fingerprint":"57d733cf2032","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00890","start_s":4470.415,"end_s":4471.597,"video_s":4520.415,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00251","chapter":"C010","text":"It's tremendous.","fingerprint":"12919d84030b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00891","start_s":4471.617,"end_s":4474.963,"video_s":4521.617,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00251","chapter":"C010","text":"And for anybody who has not had an opportunity to sit down","fingerprint":"fe177e865eac","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00892","start_s":4474.943,"end_s":4475.484,"video_s":4524.943,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00251","chapter":"C010","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00893","start_s":4476.345,"end_s":4495.45,"video_s":4526.345,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00251","chapter":"C010","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00894","start_s":4495.43,"end_s":4497.953,"video_s":4545.43,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00251","chapter":"C010","text":"I don't know anybody who would dispute that.","fingerprint":"a4bc24211ef6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00895","start_s":4498.334,"end_s":4504.422,"video_s":4548.334,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00251","chapter":"C010","text":"And so I think this is a really good move, excuse me, a good item and move in the right direction.","fingerprint":"f59886e96797","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00896","start_s":4504.442,"end_s":4507.906,"video_s":4554.442,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00251","chapter":"C010","text":"And like I said, I've had the opportunity to spend some time with the Air Support Unit.","fingerprint":"fbb628a06982","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00897","start_s":4508.227,"end_s":4511.071,"video_s":4558.227,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00251","chapter":"C010","text":"I thank you guys all for your hospitality and all that you've done up there.","fingerprint":"2e849975fe06","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00898","start_s":4511.692,"end_s":4515.056,"video_s":4561.692,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00251","chapter":"C010","text":"And clearly we are moving in the right direction for a lot of different things.","fingerprint":"ac97af7db4f2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00899","start_s":4515.637,"end_s":4519.782,"video_s":4565.637,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00251","chapter":"C010","text":"And for that reason, Mayor, I'd like to move approval of item number 30.","fingerprint":"8dd5a06630fc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00900","start_s":4519.802,"end_s":4520.163,"video_s":4569.802,"speaker":"kevin-robinson","turn":"T00251","chapter":"C010","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00901","start_s":4520.303,"end_s":4523.026,"video_s":4570.303,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00252","chapter":"C010","text":"We have a motion and a second.","fingerprint":"7451ba811637","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00902","start_s":4523.047,"end_s":4524.188,"video_s":4573.047,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00252","chapter":"C010","text":"Councilwoman Hernandez.","fingerprint":"be943e39201c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00903","start_s":4524.387,"end_s":4524.889,"video_s":4574.387,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00253","chapter":"C010","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00904","start_s":4524.909,"end_s":4526.494,"video_s":4574.909,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00253","chapter":"C010","text":"I just have a couple questions.","fingerprint":"312af7dae8ba","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00905","start_s":4526.554,"end_s":4529.524,"video_s":4576.554,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00253","chapter":"C010","text":"And apologies first if you've already answered them.","fingerprint":"082ac69e656f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00906","start_s":4530.005,"end_s":4532.473,"video_s":4580.005,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00253","chapter":"C010","text":"I got a little lost there.","fingerprint":"418e01fcee1a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00907","start_s":4532.74,"end_s":4541.609,"video_s":4582.74,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00253","chapter":"C010","text":"I know that these planes came up in our last formal meeting where I had a few questions around the number of planes, the department has a cost of upkeep and deployment.","fingerprint":"46538dbc4b36","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00908","start_s":4542.47,"end_s":4550.077,"video_s":4592.47,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00253","chapter":"C010","text":"But you know, as with everything, every day we learn something new about all kinds of things, including the training costs and how we actually use the planes.","fingerprint":"7626ba6539d4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00909","start_s":4551.378,"end_s":4561.228,"video_s":4601.378,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00253","chapter":"C010","text":"So my understanding is the department is seeking council approval to pay for the flight simulator for the department pilots, correct?","fingerprint":"d51466ef813e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00910","start_s":4562.896,"end_s":4565.582,"video_s":4612.896,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00254","chapter":"C010","text":"Mayor, Vice Mayor, Members of Council, and Councilwoman Hernandez.","fingerprint":"ec597e474e38","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00911","start_s":4565.933,"end_s":4571.318,"video_s":4615.933,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00254","chapter":"C010","text":"This particular request is specifically for funding in order to do simulator training.","fingerprint":"dffb6a09d9ad","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00912","start_s":4571.759,"end_s":4573.56,"video_s":4621.759,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00254","chapter":"C010","text":"We are not purchasing the training.","fingerprint":"58f6b86dfa1a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00913","start_s":4574.021,"end_s":4575.582,"video_s":4624.021,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00254","chapter":"C010","text":"I mean, we are not purchasing the simulator.","fingerprint":"35aaa6f9f1a1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00914","start_s":4575.602,"end_s":4580.968,"video_s":4625.602,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00254","chapter":"C010","text":"We are only asking for the funding to cover the cost of the training, which is provided by Simcoe Aviation.","fingerprint":"6c1d950d7c40","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00915","start_s":4580.988,"end_s":4581.949,"video_s":4630.988,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00255","chapter":"C010","text":"Okay, thank you.","fingerprint":"21d63267fca8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00916","start_s":4582.669,"end_s":4583.53,"video_s":4632.669,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00255","chapter":"C010","text":"Just wanted to clarify that.","fingerprint":"a338b1752a85","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00917","start_s":4583.91,"end_s":4589.035,"video_s":4633.91,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00255","chapter":"C010","text":"And then, sorry, and this might be where, it might be repetitive, but I'm gonna go ahead and proceed anyways.","fingerprint":"8b1691df2d08","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00918","start_s":4589.676,"end_s":4595.822,"video_s":4639.676,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00255","chapter":"C010","text":"What aircraft that the department owns will the simulator training be appropriate for?","fingerprint":"905ef5951b2c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00919","start_s":4598.013,"end_s":4600.438,"video_s":4648.013,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00256","chapter":"C010","text":"Mayor and Vice Mayor, Members of Council, Councilwoman Hernandez.","fingerprint":"f2ac8849621d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00920","start_s":4600.859,"end_s":4606.209,"video_s":4650.859,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00256","chapter":"C010","text":"So the two aircraft that this particular training is specific to is the Pilatus PC-12.","fingerprint":"65d6b448d231","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00921","start_s":4606.73,"end_s":4608.173,"video_s":4656.73,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00256","chapter":"C010","text":"That is the turboprop engine.","fingerprint":"1b7a0538984d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00922","start_s":4608.193,"end_s":4612.521,"video_s":4658.193,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00256","chapter":"C010","text":"It also is a cargo vessel that we can use for flying as well.","fingerprint":"f718d6769ffc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00923","start_s":4613.223,"end_s":4617.591,"video_s":4663.223,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00256","chapter":"C010","text":"This particular training, this is the simulator training specific to that platform.","fingerprint":"2de56fab8a82","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00924","start_s":4618.077,"end_s":4618.638,"video_s":4668.077,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00257","chapter":"C010","text":"Okay, thank you.","fingerprint":"21d63267fca8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00925","start_s":4618.678,"end_s":4628.069,"video_s":4668.678,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00257","chapter":"C010","text":"And I think I did hear what uses that aircraft is for in Councilwoman Robinson's question.","fingerprint":"2c1bb86c614c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00926","start_s":4628.77,"end_s":4631.813,"video_s":4678.77,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00257","chapter":"C010","text":"Anything else you can add to what you have already stated?","fingerprint":"7d35cb386798","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00927","start_s":4631.833,"end_s":4644.709,"video_s":4681.833,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C010","text":"I think it's important, Councilwoman Hernandez, just to note that depending on the mission that the air unit is asked to perform will dictate the type of aircraft that is actually selected for use.","fingerprint":"72140aeed969","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00928","start_s":4645.269,"end_s":4647.392,"video_s":4695.269,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C010","text":"So as Commander Riggin had mentioned,","fingerprint":"0a601b80e49b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00929","start_s":4647.524,"end_s":4657.135,"video_s":4697.524,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C010","text":"depending on if they're having to transport folks or evidence or whatever the case may be from one state over a long distance, it makes more sense to use a fixed wing aircraft.","fingerprint":"a70b13609fa8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00930","start_s":4657.596,"end_s":4667.527,"video_s":4707.596,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C010","text":"If it is something where we're actively overhead of a scene and we're monitoring something, that's where our patrol helicopters, the H125s that we use are typically the platform of choice.","fingerprint":"de17bf35bdd9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00931","start_s":4667.567,"end_s":4671.952,"video_s":4717.567,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C010","text":"That's what we use every single day to cover the patrol related functions.","fingerprint":"d570f82c22f4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00932","start_s":4672.072,"end_s":4674.595,"video_s":4722.072,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00258","chapter":"C010","text":"So it just depends on what the mission is.","fingerprint":"1d122ee4ae6b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00933","start_s":4674.575,"end_s":4675.476,"video_s":4724.575,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00259","chapter":"C010","text":"Okay, thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f3e96a907f4b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00934","start_s":4676.117,"end_s":4683.764,"video_s":4726.117,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00259","chapter":"C010","text":"And then my last question, I recently had my where a constituent asked, and I told him that I would come back and ask this question.","fingerprint":"c2f0fa6d70e3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00935","start_s":4683.804,"end_s":4686.707,"video_s":4733.804,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00259","chapter":"C010","text":"But he brought up a question around drones.","fingerprint":"b02f06d84a32","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00936","start_s":4687.868,"end_s":4694.015,"video_s":4737.868,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00259","chapter":"C010","text":"You know, and the question he asked was, have we considered using drones instead of piloted airplanes?","fingerprint":"9aaff9a09898","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00937","start_s":4694.475,"end_s":4699.921,"video_s":4744.475,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00259","chapter":"C010","text":"And would there be a cost savings if we replaced piloted airplanes with drones?","fingerprint":"40a1d82b5e5e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00938","start_s":4700.561,"end_s":4702.303,"video_s":4750.561,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00259","chapter":"C010","text":"And what would that cost savings be?","fingerprint":"c0d0dcfd0e23","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00939","start_s":4703.195,"end_s":4715.399,"video_s":4753.195,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00260","chapter":"C010","text":"So Mayor, Vice Mayor, Members of Council, Councilwoman Hernandez, that's an excellent question and it's one that we were asked several times over the last three or four years as we developed the Phoenix unmanned aerial system program.","fingerprint":"33ead8180696","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00940","start_s":4715.98,"end_s":4723.414,"video_s":4765.98,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00260","chapter":"C010","text":"I had the pleasure of actually being directly involved in that and one of the misconceptions that came out of the implementation of our policy","fingerprint":"ed53cf856095","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00941","start_s":4723.394,"end_s":4751.459,"video_s":4773.394,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00260","chapter":"C010","text":"The primary use of the drones, we use them in three different areas.","fingerprint":"231afb39b956","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00942","start_s":4751.499,"end_s":4753.401,"video_s":4801.499,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00260","chapter":"C010","text":"We use them for investigative support.","fingerprint":"6f7d55b3a248","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00943","start_s":4753.786,"end_s":4757.792,"video_s":4803.786,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00260","chapter":"C010","text":"We use them to manage special events and we use them for tactical support.","fingerprint":"72b622c8fb45","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00944","start_s":4758.113,"end_s":4767.828,"video_s":4808.113,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00260","chapter":"C010","text":"So instead of having to put a tactical operator and our SAU team in front of a door or a window, we can actually utilize a drone to be able to see what's there before we put somebody in peril.","fingerprint":"88aaf030da04","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00945","start_s":4768.609,"end_s":4773.837,"video_s":4818.609,"speaker":"v11","turn":"T00260","chapter":"C010","text":"So we do not have a situation where the helicopters would replace the drones or vice versa.","fingerprint":"a89e1864ec05","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00946","start_s":4774.171,"end_s":4774.992,"video_s":4824.171,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00261","chapter":"C010","text":"Okay, thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f3e96a907f4b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00947","start_s":4775.212,"end_s":4786.869,"video_s":4825.212,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00261","chapter":"C010","text":"And sorry, just as a follow-up for future, can you get me, not now, but can you follow up with my office on the cost breakdown for our entire air support units we have?","fingerprint":"65c135aae35b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00948","start_s":4787.63,"end_s":4797.243,"video_s":4837.63,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00261","chapter":"C010","text":"Cost breakdown, like cost to maintain, what they cost to purchase, and what it costs per hour to have these out deployed.","fingerprint":"468b798a6451","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00949","start_s":4798.265,"end_s":4799.567,"video_s":4848.265,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00261","chapter":"C010","text":"Councilwoman Hernandez, absolutely.","fingerprint":"109b092ccf62","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00950","start_s":4799.687,"end_s":4800.448,"video_s":4849.687,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00261","chapter":"C010","text":"Okay, thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f3e96a907f4b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00951","start_s":4800.768,"end_s":4801.309,"video_s":4850.768,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00261","chapter":"C010","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00952","start_s":4803.955,"end_s":4804.636,"video_s":4853.955,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C010","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00953","start_s":4804.756,"end_s":4805.216,"video_s":4854.756,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00262","chapter":"C010","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00954","start_s":4806.778,"end_s":4806.958,"video_s":4856.778,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00263","chapter":"C010","text":"Guardado?","fingerprint":"0344b48c3f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00955","start_s":4807.199,"end_s":4807.419,"video_s":4857.199,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00263","chapter":"C010","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00956","start_s":4807.96,"end_s":4808.72,"video_s":4857.96,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00263","chapter":"C010","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00957","start_s":4808.74,"end_s":4810.162,"video_s":4858.74,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00263","chapter":"C010","text":"May I explain my vote?","fingerprint":"26d5f810396a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00958","start_s":4810.382,"end_s":4810.743,"video_s":4860.382,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00263","chapter":"C010","text":"Please do.","fingerprint":"a549bac1fc15","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00959","start_s":4811.123,"end_s":4811.483,"video_s":4861.123,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00263","chapter":"C010","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00960","start_s":4811.524,"end_s":4815.408,"video_s":4861.524,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00263","chapter":"C010","text":"The question before us is not whether pilots should be trained safely.","fingerprint":"e03966aa7d9c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00961","start_s":4815.448,"end_s":4820.253,"video_s":4865.448,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00263","chapter":"C010","text":"We can all agree that if we are going to have an Air Force, our pilots should be trained properly.","fingerprint":"9e6a949f9005","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00962","start_s":4820.293,"end_s":4826.2,"video_s":4870.293,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00263","chapter":"C010","text":"The deeper question really is why our police department continues to operate and expand aerial surveillance.","fingerprint":"1999f3e0fbf1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00963","start_s":4826.18,"end_s":4835.074,"video_s":4876.18,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00263","chapter":"C010","text":"and more like tactical aviation capacity at all, especially in a city facing crises in housing, heat resilience, behavioral health access and youth opportunity.","fingerprint":"103ac7e30526","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00964","start_s":4835.555,"end_s":4841.904,"video_s":4885.555,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00263","chapter":"C010","text":"The reality is that we are being asked to normalize and fund Phoenix Police Department behavior that should give us pause.","fingerprint":"784d1848729d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00965","start_s":4842.405,"end_s":4849.977,"video_s":4892.405,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00263","chapter":"C010","text":"We continue to militarize Phoenix Police at the same time our city struggles to fund the very services that prevent harm in the first place.","fingerprint":"935d2646ed34","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00966","start_s":4849.957,"end_s":4854.782,"video_s":4899.957,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00263","chapter":"C010","text":"Let us be courageous enough to question the premise and the normalization of this.","fingerprint":"499a084c2500","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00967","start_s":4855.243,"end_s":4859.988,"video_s":4905.243,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00263","chapter":"C010","text":"Let us remember that true safety is built from the ground up, not enforced from the sky.","fingerprint":"f9426a6b50d5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00968","start_s":4860.028,"end_s":4868.077,"video_s":4910.028,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00263","chapter":"C010","text":"I will continue to raise these issues because I believe in investing in real solutions that truly create community safety.","fingerprint":"bacf7d46ecdd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00969","start_s":4868.457,"end_s":4873.683,"video_s":4918.457,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00263","chapter":"C010","text":"I do not believe that our air fleet creates safety, and I do not believe that that is a good financial investment for our city.","fingerprint":"262c6e8391d1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00970","start_s":4874.244,"end_s":4875.045,"video_s":4924.244,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00263","chapter":"C010","text":"And with that, I vote no.","fingerprint":"3ff45318c18f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00971","start_s":4875.725,"end_s":4876.026,"video_s":4925.725,"speaker":"anna-hernandez","turn":"T00263","chapter":"C010","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00972","start_s":4876.546,"end_s":4876.907,"video_s":4926.546,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00264","chapter":"C010","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00973","start_s":4877.367,"end_s":4877.607,"video_s":4927.367,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00264","chapter":"C010","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00974","start_s":4878.088,"end_s":4878.488,"video_s":4928.088,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00264","chapter":"C010","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00975","start_s":4878.629,"end_s":4879.349,"video_s":4928.629,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00264","chapter":"C010","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00976","start_s":4879.369,"end_s":4879.93,"video_s":4929.369,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00264","chapter":"C010","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00977","start_s":4880.264,"end_s":4880.624,"video_s":4930.264,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00265","chapter":"C010","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00978","start_s":4881.105,"end_s":4881.465,"video_s":4931.105,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C010","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00979","start_s":4882.026,"end_s":4882.707,"video_s":4932.026,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C010","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00980","start_s":4882.727,"end_s":4883.027,"video_s":4932.727,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C010","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00981","start_s":4883.848,"end_s":4883.928,"video_s":4933.848,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C010","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00982","start_s":4883.948,"end_s":4884.629,"video_s":4933.948,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C010","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00983","start_s":4884.849,"end_s":4885.109,"video_s":4934.849,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C010","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00984","start_s":4885.49,"end_s":4885.89,"video_s":4935.49,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00266","chapter":"C010","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00985","start_s":4886.771,"end_s":4887.011,"video_s":4936.771,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00267","chapter":"C010","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00986","start_s":4887.272,"end_s":4888.052,"video_s":4937.272,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00268","chapter":"C010","text":"Passes 8-1.","fingerprint":"a7b3afc7a8da","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00987","start_s":4891.276,"end_s":4891.937,"video_s":4941.276,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00269","chapter":"C010","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00988","start_s":4893.959,"end_s":4900.466,"video_s":4943.959,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00270","chapter":"C011","text":"We next go to item 36, which is related to public transit department and the aviation buying bus.","fingerprint":"9c912754c466","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00989","start_s":4900.586,"end_s":4901.327,"video_s":4950.586,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00270","chapter":"C011","text":"Do we have a motion?","fingerprint":"ea97412996cb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00990","start_s":4902.047,"end_s":4903.269,"video_s":4952.047,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00271","chapter":"C011","text":"Motion to approve item 36.","fingerprint":"d56167974fd8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00991","start_s":4903.309,"end_s":4904.11,"video_s":4953.309,"speaker":"kesha-hodge-washington","turn":"T00271","chapter":"C011","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00992","start_s":4904.871,"end_s":4906.072,"video_s":4954.871,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00272","chapter":"C011","text":"A motion and a second.","fingerprint":"ed26edd34e26","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00993","start_s":4906.132,"end_s":4908.094,"video_s":4956.132,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00272","chapter":"C011","text":"Diane Barker is here to provide testimony.","fingerprint":"ea29b7333801","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00994","start_s":4909.323,"end_s":4910.265,"video_s":4959.323,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00272","chapter":"C011","text":"followed by Blue.","fingerprint":"abf4d8feec9d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00995","start_s":4916.56,"end_s":4918.244,"video_s":4966.56,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00273","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you, Mayor and City Council.","fingerprint":"a9c3c975681b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00996","start_s":4918.264,"end_s":4919.788,"video_s":4968.264,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00273","chapter":"C011","text":"I'm in District","fingerprint":"8486653f7894","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00997","start_s":4920.443,"end_s":4925.069,"video_s":4970.443,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00273","chapter":"C011","text":"seven and I do support this issue.","fingerprint":"b020f0321497","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00998","start_s":4925.089,"end_s":4940.187,"video_s":4975.089,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00273","chapter":"C011","text":"I had been a terminal driver out at Phoenix Sky Harbor and we made transition into the cleaner burning of vehicles and I applaud the city of Phoenix for continuing that.","fingerprint":"2ed5d260a4dc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L00999","start_s":4940.768,"end_s":4948.577,"video_s":4990.768,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00273","chapter":"C011","text":"I guess we're leading to electric but we still have a large amount of compressed natural gas and all I can say is","fingerprint":"b7c002123a3c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01000","start_s":4948.557,"end_s":4956.615,"video_s":4998.557,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00273","chapter":"C011","text":"If you want to bring the political divide together and Trump's drill baby drill, just have him drill lighter.","fingerprint":"ace527467e53","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01001","start_s":4956.635,"end_s":4959.021,"video_s":5006.635,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00273","chapter":"C011","text":"That's compressed natural gas.","fingerprint":"5cf5856935b2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01002","start_s":4959.341,"end_s":4959.823,"video_s":5009.341,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00273","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01003","start_s":4962.168,"end_s":4964.473,"video_s":5012.168,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00274","chapter":"C011","text":"Blue will be our final speaker on this item.","fingerprint":"6e78c9c6d203","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01004","start_s":4980.721,"end_s":4982.563,"video_s":5030.721,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00275","chapter":"C011","text":"Boy, do I wanna have fun with this one.","fingerprint":"8935b3082086","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01005","start_s":4983.143,"end_s":4986.846,"video_s":5033.143,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00275","chapter":"C011","text":"Eight buses for $12 million, you ordered them in 23.","fingerprint":"3144c709fb92","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01006","start_s":4988.248,"end_s":4997.736,"video_s":5038.248,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00275","chapter":"C011","text":"At that same time, over there at the RPTA, you canceled, what was it, 27 buses?","fingerprint":"4e35c7a1e3c5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01007","start_s":4998.797,"end_s":5010.627,"video_s":5048.797,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00275","chapter":"C011","text":"Because you weren't going to be instituting the routes that had been originally dealt with and that you cut back","fingerprint":"16bbd99c3884","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01008","start_s":5012.058,"end_s":5014.461,"video_s":5062.058,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00275","chapter":"C011","text":"one of them being Litchfield.","fingerprint":"ca32f1ffe209","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01009","start_s":5014.502,"end_s":5028.301,"video_s":5064.502,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00275","chapter":"C011","text":"But what I'm looking at here is it says eight buses for 12 million, but it's a contingency out of 229,882,861 dollars.","fingerprint":"0d2f10afea1e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01010","start_s":5029.082,"end_s":5032.307,"video_s":5079.082,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00275","chapter":"C011","text":"Well, is that gonna be going for buses and such?","fingerprint":"cb7ec77a68ce","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01011","start_s":5032.588,"end_s":5037.795,"video_s":5082.588,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00275","chapter":"C011","text":"Because with the monies that you got from that Prop 400,","fingerprint":"d9741ba3c641","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01012","start_s":5038.889,"end_s":5043.195,"video_s":5088.889,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00275","chapter":"C011","text":"Where are all the bus stops that are inadequate?","fingerprint":"25a66ffe99cb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01013","start_s":5043.435,"end_s":5044.496,"video_s":5093.435,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00275","chapter":"C011","text":"Where are all the buses?","fingerprint":"0569ee3715d7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01014","start_s":5045.417,"end_s":5052.847,"video_s":5095.417,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00276","chapter":"C011","text":"On Camelback, you have- In blue, this is whether the airport should buy, this is not Prop 479, so should the airport have buses?","fingerprint":"5f6a7accf3d9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01015","start_s":5052.867,"end_s":5057.193,"video_s":5102.867,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00277","chapter":"C011","text":"Right, right, and they're being made a part of the whole system.","fingerprint":"e60f0744ed13","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01016","start_s":5058.174,"end_s":5061.738,"video_s":5108.174,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00277","chapter":"C011","text":"Are they gonna have bike racks?","fingerprint":"88e7cdbc5874","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01017","start_s":5062.059,"end_s":5066.905,"video_s":5112.059,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00277","chapter":"C011","text":"If it's gonna be put back into the system, that's something I got put on.","fingerprint":"8692e6b96e3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01018","start_s":5066.935,"end_s":5089.382,"video_s":5116.935,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00277","chapter":"C011","text":"that it's system-wide when you bought these is are they going to have the bike racks and what I was trying to point out is that with the amount of expenditures you haven't done on buses and infrastructure that you have continuously put towards light rail","fingerprint":"b62d0494509b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01019","start_s":5090.29,"end_s":5094.02,"video_s":5140.29,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00277","chapter":"C011","text":"I need you not to be funding 52% on rail.","fingerprint":"ff62e45c9dbf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01020","start_s":5094.201,"end_s":5104.047,"video_s":5144.201,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00277","chapter":"C011","text":"I need you to get back to what it is, and that's creating a bus system, not for a medium-sized city, but with the fifth largest city in the country.","fingerprint":"4eca1a37352b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01021","start_s":5105.461,"end_s":5106.082,"video_s":5155.461,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00278","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01022","start_s":5106.363,"end_s":5111.616,"video_s":5156.363,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00278","chapter":"C011","text":"And just to be clear, this is not for the public transit system, Valley Metro system.","fingerprint":"ae3019f6ec10","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01023","start_s":5112.057,"end_s":5120.517,"video_s":5162.057,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00278","chapter":"C011","text":"This is for the airport, but it will use the same contract to buy buses that the public transit department uses.","fingerprint":"726835037f4d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01024","start_s":5120.497,"end_s":5121.918,"video_s":5170.497,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00278","chapter":"C011","text":"and it really is exciting today.","fingerprint":"3f447b6dfbfc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01025","start_s":5121.978,"end_s":5125.582,"video_s":5171.978,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00278","chapter":"C011","text":"We had one of these electric buses out in front of City Hall.","fingerprint":"bfa2a72879a2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01026","start_s":5125.642,"end_s":5129.665,"video_s":5175.642,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00278","chapter":"C011","text":"I got to visit and it was on but so incredibly quiet.","fingerprint":"44fc7965a842","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01027","start_s":5129.685,"end_s":5133.729,"video_s":5179.685,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00278","chapter":"C011","text":"It's gonna be such a great experience for our riders, more sustainable.","fingerprint":"10740f3b40aa","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01028","start_s":5134.07,"end_s":5140.395,"video_s":5184.07,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00278","chapter":"C011","text":"So we'll be reducing tailpipe emissions and the driver said it's a really responsive vehicle that will be great to drive.","fingerprint":"4b70ee7103e1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01029","start_s":5140.495,"end_s":5142.738,"video_s":5190.495,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00278","chapter":"C011","text":"So I'm excited that the airport will have this option.","fingerprint":"3c797c00e7e3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01030","start_s":5143.318,"end_s":5149.744,"video_s":5193.318,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00278","chapter":"C011","text":"The SkyTrain will still be our workforce but it's good to be able to have options including","fingerprint":"bdb20e6628e3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01031","start_s":5149.724,"end_s":5151.706,"video_s":5199.724,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00278","chapter":"C011","text":"for continuity of operations.","fingerprint":"7e3b6b4a9133","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01032","start_s":5151.726,"end_s":5155.109,"video_s":5201.726,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00278","chapter":"C011","text":"Should there be a challenge with the SkyTrain?","fingerprint":"5a3e63239bb0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01033","start_s":5155.71,"end_s":5156.991,"video_s":5205.71,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00278","chapter":"C011","text":"Roll call.","fingerprint":"b072d9d01909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01034","start_s":5157.011,"end_s":5157.471,"video_s":5207.011,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00279","chapter":"C011","text":"Guardado?","fingerprint":"0344b48c3f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01035","start_s":5157.752,"end_s":5158.012,"video_s":5207.752,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00279","chapter":"C011","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01036","start_s":5158.592,"end_s":5158.993,"video_s":5208.592,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00279","chapter":"C011","text":"Hernandez?","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01037","start_s":5159.173,"end_s":5159.914,"video_s":5209.173,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00279","chapter":"C011","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01038","start_s":5159.934,"end_s":5160.354,"video_s":5209.934,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00279","chapter":"C011","text":"O'Brien?","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01039","start_s":5160.454,"end_s":5160.734,"video_s":5210.454,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00279","chapter":"C011","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01040","start_s":5161.215,"end_s":5161.655,"video_s":5211.215,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00279","chapter":"C011","text":"Pastor?","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01041","start_s":5161.836,"end_s":5162.516,"video_s":5211.836,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00279","chapter":"C011","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01042","start_s":5162.536,"end_s":5163.077,"video_s":5212.536,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00279","chapter":"C011","text":"Robinson?","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01043","start_s":5163.097,"end_s":5163.357,"video_s":5213.097,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00279","chapter":"C011","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01044","start_s":5163.817,"end_s":5164.058,"video_s":5213.817,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00279","chapter":"C011","text":"Stark?","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01045","start_s":5164.078,"end_s":5164.158,"video_s":5214.078,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00279","chapter":"C011","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01046","start_s":5165.139,"end_s":5165.499,"video_s":5215.139,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00279","chapter":"C011","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01047","start_s":5166.22,"end_s":5166.3,"video_s":5216.22,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00279","chapter":"C011","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01048","start_s":5166.32,"end_s":5167.0,"video_s":5216.32,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00279","chapter":"C011","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01049","start_s":5167.201,"end_s":5167.841,"video_s":5217.201,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00279","chapter":"C011","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01050","start_s":5167.861,"end_s":5168.282,"video_s":5217.861,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00279","chapter":"C011","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01051","start_s":5168.922,"end_s":5169.183,"video_s":5218.922,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00279","chapter":"C011","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01052","start_s":5169.483,"end_s":5170.063,"video_s":5219.483,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00279","chapter":"C011","text":"Passes 9-0.","fingerprint":"f7c37e75fd84","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01053","start_s":5172.105,"end_s":5172.486,"video_s":5222.105,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00280","chapter":"C011","text":"All right.","fingerprint":"dfbdd9492bec","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01054","start_s":5173.867,"end_s":5175.789,"video_s":5223.867,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00280","chapter":"C011","text":"Councilman Waring, you've been working on this for so long.","fingerprint":"5b0ab8d90417","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01055","start_s":5175.809,"end_s":5178.111,"video_s":5225.809,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00280","chapter":"C011","text":"Did you want to make a motion on item 37?","fingerprint":"07546c5283f4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01056","start_s":5179.93,"end_s":5180.451,"video_s":5229.93,"speaker":"ann-o-brien","turn":"T00281","chapter":"C011","text":"Second.","fingerprint":"16367aacb67a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01057","start_s":5182.233,"end_s":5185.719,"video_s":5232.233,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00282","chapter":"C011","text":"We have a motion and a second, and we will welcome back Diana Blue.","fingerprint":"c71de60d83aa","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01058","start_s":5197.456,"end_s":5197.897,"video_s":5247.456,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00283","chapter":"C011","text":"I love it.","fingerprint":"898a8c802384","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01059","start_s":5198.158,"end_s":5205.128,"video_s":5248.158,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00283","chapter":"C011","text":"You think that that shuttle service is really important, but then when I look at your district, if I wrote a black","fingerprint":"c54e98aeb0be","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01060","start_s":5205.732,"end_s":5210.16,"video_s":5255.732,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00283","chapter":"C011","text":"out all the area that doesn't have transit.","fingerprint":"cdf1682214cb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01061","start_s":5210.982,"end_s":5216.131,"video_s":5260.982,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00283","chapter":"C011","text":"I know, it's a shuttle service between ASU and Mayo.","fingerprint":"2bb7d5174e74","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01062","start_s":5216.412,"end_s":5218.376,"video_s":5266.412,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00283","chapter":"C011","text":"It runs for a mile and a half.","fingerprint":"cf44dfc284ea","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01063","start_s":5218.396,"end_s":5228.314,"video_s":5268.396,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00283","chapter":"C011","text":"I'm just saying that his district is one of the transit deserts of the city, and I'm glad that you're getting that part.","fingerprint":"4b5b2afc389d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01064","start_s":5228.598,"end_s":5231.141,"video_s":5278.598,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00283","chapter":"C011","text":"but why aren't you filling the rest of it in?","fingerprint":"cce99a005c9d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01065","start_s":5231.701,"end_s":5234.084,"video_s":5281.701,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00283","chapter":"C011","text":"It's a grid out for the whole city.","fingerprint":"0261e44d1318","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01066","start_s":5234.664,"end_s":5238.649,"video_s":5284.664,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00283","chapter":"C011","text":"Where are the buses on your major arterials out there?","fingerprint":"7d731c08335c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01067","start_s":5240.15,"end_s":5245.716,"video_s":5290.15,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00283","chapter":"C011","text":"Is it because you don't feel that the density is right for a bus?","fingerprint":"cd0ee9a15d4d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01068","start_s":5245.756,"end_s":5254.065,"video_s":5295.756,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00283","chapter":"C011","text":"Well, it's not the density, it's the whole of the city and the grid being maximized for a bus.","fingerprint":"15df1203a5be","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01069","start_s":5254.737,"end_s":5275.682,"video_s":5304.737,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00283","chapter":"C011","text":"Like I said, I appreciate that you guys have put together a little shuttle service and the amount of money that's gonna go to it, but in the overall gestalt of the whole system, when it comes to your district, sir, there's a hole, like I said, a transit desert.","fingerprint":"558cd8bca750","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01070","start_s":5281.737,"end_s":5283.199,"video_s":5331.737,"speaker":"v13","turn":"T00284","chapter":"C011","text":"Mayor, I guess I'll just say this.","fingerprint":"3c9b3e1988de","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01071","start_s":5284.12,"end_s":5300.083,"video_s":5334.12,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00285","chapter":"C011","text":"I appreciate all input, but this is the first I've heard of the transit desert, and I don't know that Blue is a resident of District 2, so he might not be the best person to decide how things are going in District 2.","fingerprint":"009f76dc97e4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01072","start_s":5301.645,"end_s":5305.11,"video_s":5351.645,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00285","chapter":"C011","text":"But this is fantastic, and I appreciate you letting me make the motion.","fingerprint":"9a0f10665ed9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01073","start_s":5305.39,"end_s":5306.091,"video_s":5355.39,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00285","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01074","start_s":5308.822,"end_s":5322.581,"video_s":5358.822,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00286","chapter":"C011","text":"Okay, Diane Barker again, and I'm supportive of infrastructure that will be for flexible transit, and it is leading to a sustainable community.","fingerprint":"7b6138dd2bad","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01075","start_s":5322.621,"end_s":5329.53,"video_s":5372.621,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00286","chapter":"C011","text":"Mary, you're wanting electricity, but electric has its admissions at the source.","fingerprint":"75751d4476ae","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01076","start_s":5332.801,"end_s":5338.333,"video_s":5382.801,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00287","chapter":"C011","text":"and just to be clear, this is a very exciting project, but it is infrastructure.","fingerprint":"a9e9ba27c01a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01077","start_s":5338.374,"end_s":5342.162,"video_s":5388.374,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00287","chapter":"C011","text":"This is applying for a federal grant, a build grant in the Mayo area.","fingerprint":"317785699c67","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01078","start_s":5342.242,"end_s":5345.49,"video_s":5392.242,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00287","chapter":"C011","text":"It would let Mayo be able to expand.","fingerprint":"ba6122117f10","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01079","start_s":5345.55,"end_s":5347.013,"video_s":5395.55,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00287","chapter":"C011","text":"They're doing incredible work.","fingerprint":"d50cf41d0fd4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01080","start_s":5348.174,"end_s":5350.938,"video_s":5398.174,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00287","chapter":"C011","text":"in our city and really providing life-saving care.","fingerprint":"81fea9ba2b38","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01081","start_s":5351.418,"end_s":5359.79,"video_s":5401.418,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00287","chapter":"C011","text":"ASU is also expanding and has helped bring in very cool companies, one of which was recognized this morning by Forbes 30 Under 30.","fingerprint":"6916fae992c9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01082","start_s":5360.17,"end_s":5365.438,"video_s":5410.17,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00287","chapter":"C011","text":"Jacob Lester with My Health got recognized on our Phoenix Forbes 30 Under 30.","fingerprint":"bb14642e16d5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01083","start_s":5365.478,"end_s":5368.922,"video_s":5415.478,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00287","chapter":"C011","text":"So these are great entrepreneurs under the age of 30.","fingerprint":"01b74990ed5e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01084","start_s":5368.942,"end_s":5371.566,"video_s":5418.942,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00287","chapter":"C011","text":"And we want more of that in 2020.","fingerprint":"7ee7fb570ef9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01085","start_s":5371.732,"end_s":5374.677,"video_s":5421.732,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00287","chapter":"C011","text":"North Phoenix, so we're very hopeful the federal government will partner with us.","fingerprint":"b7a61483e7d8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01086","start_s":5375.077,"end_s":5379.925,"video_s":5425.077,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00287","chapter":"C011","text":"The infrastructure is quite expensive in this area, but this is a Jim Waring project.","fingerprint":"71ab9bb60b0c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01087","start_s":5379.985,"end_s":5389.82,"video_s":5429.985,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00287","chapter":"C011","text":"It is a public-private partnership, so ASU's gonna pay for some of it, Mayo's gonna pay for it, and the public sector, we hope, USDOT and we will all contribute.","fingerprint":"b81897c281b0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01088","start_s":5389.86,"end_s":5399.595,"video_s":5439.86,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00287","chapter":"C011","text":"So really trying to leverage a lot of money to improve street road infrastructure in that area, and very optimistic that USDOT may wanna","fingerprint":"fc7723851578","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01089","start_s":5399.575,"end_s":5401.559,"video_s":5449.575,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00287","chapter":"C011","text":"partner with us on this one.","fingerprint":"94abaa376881","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01090","start_s":5402.24,"end_s":5412.461,"video_s":5452.24,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00288","chapter":"C011","text":"Mayor, I'll just say, you know, the Mayo expansion during my years in the council, not because of me, I don't want anybody to misinterpret, has been incredible.","fingerprint":"6071700c5937","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01091","start_s":5412.722,"end_s":5416.369,"video_s":5462.722,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00288","chapter":"C011","text":"I think the $1.9 billion investment","fingerprint":"ce616ca8fc42","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01092","start_s":5417.26,"end_s":5418.902,"video_s":5467.26,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00288","chapter":"C011","text":"did, I can't remember now.","fingerprint":"2431e1949119","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01093","start_s":5418.942,"end_s":5420.283,"video_s":5468.942,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00289","chapter":"C011","text":"That's just what they announced last year.","fingerprint":"ffdd74cf6f6a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01094","start_s":5420.383,"end_s":5421.645,"video_s":5470.383,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00290","chapter":"C011","text":"I mean, it's fantastic.","fingerprint":"a3f8dbc97996","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01095","start_s":5423.246,"end_s":5429.473,"video_s":5473.246,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00290","chapter":"C011","text":"But the expansion, I believe that campus is going to be bigger than their one in Rochester by the time it's all done.","fingerprint":"84c7d4718b81","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01096","start_s":5429.493,"end_s":5436.981,"video_s":5479.493,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00290","chapter":"C011","text":"I don't know, it just speaks to people wanting to come to Phoenix and the market that we've created here.","fingerprint":"a73b82371ef0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01097","start_s":5437.882,"end_s":5442.246,"video_s":5487.882,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00290","chapter":"C011","text":"And I can't wait to see more progress in the years ahead.","fingerprint":"a99846f423a8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01098","start_s":5442.266,"end_s":5443.167,"video_s":5492.266,"speaker":"jim-waring","turn":"T00290","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01099","start_s":5443.433,"end_s":5448.14,"video_s":5493.433,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00291","chapter":"C011","text":"and the councilman has spent an enormous amount of time on this flood plain and the streets in this area.","fingerprint":"fc3c2c15caed","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01100","start_s":5448.2,"end_s":5454.93,"video_s":5498.2,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00291","chapter":"C011","text":"So here's to hoping we, thanks for reminding me.","fingerprint":"be96c8fdb51e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01101","start_s":5455.831,"end_s":5457.754,"video_s":5505.831,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00291","chapter":"C011","text":"Well, it's moving forward motion.","fingerprint":"687e302cea1c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01102","start_s":5457.854,"end_s":5463.422,"video_s":5507.854,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00291","chapter":"C011","text":"Forward motion is some days you went out right, some days you just make progress.","fingerprint":"39bd159c9e1f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01103","start_s":5463.843,"end_s":5465.786,"video_s":5513.843,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00291","chapter":"C011","text":"All right, roll call.","fingerprint":"5d88818c1d17","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01104","start_s":5465.806,"end_s":5466.046,"video_s":5515.806,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C011","text":"Guardado.","fingerprint":"0344b48c3f7d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01105","start_s":5466.407,"end_s":5467.148,"video_s":5516.407,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C011","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01106","start_s":5467.228,"end_s":5467.548,"video_s":5517.228,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C011","text":"Hernandez.","fingerprint":"cffdd87c9d5a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01107","start_s":5467.729,"end_s":5468.59,"video_s":5517.729,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C011","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01108","start_s":5468.61,"end_s":5469.01,"video_s":5518.61,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C011","text":"O'Brien.","fingerprint":"65b87174be3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01109","start_s":5469.03,"end_s":5469.311,"video_s":5519.03,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C011","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01110","start_s":5469.732,"end_s":5470.152,"video_s":5519.732,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C011","text":"Pastor.","fingerprint":"e2e48a7c6792","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01111","start_s":5470.332,"end_s":5471.013,"video_s":5520.332,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C011","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01112","start_s":5471.033,"end_s":5471.554,"video_s":5521.033,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C011","text":"Robinson.","fingerprint":"c2665ea3e125","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01113","start_s":5471.594,"end_s":5471.855,"video_s":5521.594,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C011","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01114","start_s":5472.476,"end_s":5472.816,"video_s":5522.476,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C011","text":"Stark.","fingerprint":"7e7d8c699ee5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01115","start_s":5474.112,"end_s":5474.492,"video_s":5524.112,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C011","text":"Waring?","fingerprint":"89e23f85fa7c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01116","start_s":5475.534,"end_s":5476.274,"video_s":5525.534,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C011","text":"Hodge Washington?","fingerprint":"562c6370e968","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01117","start_s":5476.495,"end_s":5476.735,"video_s":5526.495,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C011","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01118","start_s":5477.236,"end_s":5478.797,"video_s":5527.236,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C011","text":"Gallego?","fingerprint":"3597c8ba66c7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01119","start_s":5478.817,"end_s":5479.078,"video_s":5528.817,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C011","text":"Yes.","fingerprint":"8a798890fe93","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01120","start_s":5479.498,"end_s":5480.159,"video_s":5529.498,"speaker":"denise-archibald","turn":"T00292","chapter":"C011","text":"Passes 9-0.","fingerprint":"f7c37e75fd84","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01121","start_s":5481.58,"end_s":5482.001,"video_s":5531.58,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00293","chapter":"C011","text":"Excellent.","fingerprint":"6d785acc7d4c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01122","start_s":5482.301,"end_s":5484.684,"video_s":5532.301,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00293","chapter":"C011","text":"Wishing everyone on our team luck with this one.","fingerprint":"236b9286956e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01123","start_s":5485.845,"end_s":5495.376,"video_s":5535.845,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00293","chapter":"C011","text":"That concludes our agendized meeting, and so we will now go to public comment, and I'll turn to the city attorney to explain this portion of the meeting.","fingerprint":"e739311a7e80","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01124","start_s":5496.177,"end_s":5496.838,"video_s":5546.177,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00294","chapter":"C011","text":"Thank you, Mayor.","fingerprint":"d83b2fd3c775","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01125","start_s":5497.038,"end_s":5503.225,"video_s":5547.038,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00295","chapter":"C012","text":"During citizen comment, members of the public may speak to the city council for up to three minutes on issues of interest or concern.","fingerprint":"4d4713206cdf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01126","start_s":5503.66,"end_s":5510.651,"video_s":5553.66,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00295","chapter":"C012","text":"However, the matters addressed must be within the jurisdiction of the Phoenix City Council and on which the council has the authority to act.","fingerprint":"604f59ebdbba","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01127","start_s":5511.111,"end_s":5513.835,"video_s":5561.111,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00295","chapter":"C012","text":"The citizen comment session is limited to 30 minutes.","fingerprint":"4b4641b48602","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01128","start_s":5514.276,"end_s":5522.188,"video_s":5564.276,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00295","chapter":"C012","text":"The Arizona Open Meeting Law allows the city council to listen to comments, but prohibits council members from discussing or acting on the issues presented.","fingerprint":"8a816930936b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01129","start_s":5522.629,"end_s":5524.972,"video_s":5572.629,"speaker":"julie-kriegh","turn":"T00295","chapter":"C012","text":"However, council members may respond to criticism.","fingerprint":"73272def6458","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01130","start_s":5528.357,"end_s":5528.557,"video_s":5578.357,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00296","chapter":"C012","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01131","start_s":5528.577,"end_s":5529.218,"video_s":5578.577,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00296","chapter":"C012","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01132","start_s":5529.319,"end_s":5532.283,"video_s":5579.319,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00296","chapter":"C012","text":"And we will begin with Blue Crowley.","fingerprint":"5b2f6490facc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01133","start_s":5534.879,"end_s":5535.86,"video_s":5584.879,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00296","chapter":"C012","text":"followed by Dan Barker.","fingerprint":"9719b7089fc7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01134","start_s":5537.001,"end_s":5539.944,"video_s":5587.001,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00296","chapter":"C012","text":"I'm sorry, but blue will be followed by mahogany.","fingerprint":"6c901123b983","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01135","start_s":5543.247,"end_s":5554.517,"video_s":5593.247,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00297","chapter":"C012","text":"To pick up where I left off, a transit desert is when you don't have a bus on any major arterial and all the major arterials in your area, most of them don't have buses.","fingerprint":"d9c2b3111258","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01136","start_s":5554.817,"end_s":5556.759,"video_s":5604.817,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00297","chapter":"C012","text":"That would make it a transit desert.","fingerprint":"b8d5d667eaeb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01137","start_s":5558.08,"end_s":5564.886,"video_s":5608.08,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00297","chapter":"C012","text":"I have here stuff from the RPTA when you were chair and","fingerprint":"164fc6abdb9d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01138","start_s":5565.743,"end_s":5572.473,"video_s":5615.743,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00297","chapter":"C012","text":"Mr. Zucker was chairman of the management committee.","fingerprint":"03609a4c7449","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01139","start_s":5573.594,"end_s":5589.878,"video_s":5623.594,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00297","chapter":"C012","text":"At that time, if you remember, I pointed out to you that all the funding that you were pushing towards light rail was restricted, but","fingerprint":"d0507bfaff3b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01140","start_s":5590.685,"end_s":5594.672,"video_s":5640.685,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00297","chapter":"C012","text":"One of the things that you've been talking about is that West Side expansion.","fingerprint":"14da9bf70909","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01141","start_s":5595.393,"end_s":5616.068,"video_s":5645.393,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00297","chapter":"C012","text":"This is from 2023, when you, Your Honor, put forth an extension of a contract for $30 million for planning and such for that area.","fingerprint":"66d45aa74648","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01142","start_s":5617.634,"end_s":5631.914,"video_s":5667.634,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00297","chapter":"C012","text":"and the estimated two year, one year expenditures for 2025 through 2027, $28 million and a 10% on contingency.","fingerprint":"ae827766bb26","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01143","start_s":5633.837,"end_s":5635.279,"video_s":5683.837,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00297","chapter":"C012","text":"Where's that money coming from?","fingerprint":"30f3c1cfc205","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01144","start_s":5635.319,"end_s":5643.731,"video_s":5685.319,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00297","chapter":"C012","text":"Because if you're using RPTA funds for that contract, you're not supposed to.","fingerprint":"a5a62b3d59ef","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01145","start_s":5643.871,"end_s":5646.595,"video_s":5693.871,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00297","chapter":"C012","text":"It's something I pointed out more than once already.","fingerprint":"5846f899f4ab","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01146","start_s":5647.081,"end_s":5674.911,"video_s":5697.081,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00297","chapter":"C012","text":"and when I look at what we put forth back in the 1980s that you finally agreed to in the 90s that went to a vote in the aughts that you cut one-third of it out saying that you don't have the funding and as I pointed out over the last five years hey you need to re-establish and get it done what is your","fingerprint":"5e589c8d92fb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01147","start_s":5675.549,"end_s":5680.013,"video_s":5725.549,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00297","chapter":"C012","text":"Our PTA plan for the next year.","fingerprint":"5cc37d319fcb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01148","start_s":5680.074,"end_s":5682.216,"video_s":5730.074,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00297","chapter":"C012","text":"And where are the buses?","fingerprint":"f7f88cbcf028","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01149","start_s":5682.596,"end_s":5684.178,"video_s":5732.596,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00297","chapter":"C012","text":"Where are the bus stops?","fingerprint":"9b3b40a1411d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01150","start_s":5684.798,"end_s":5689.143,"video_s":5734.798,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00297","chapter":"C012","text":"Because all I see you doing is wanting to get the rail done.","fingerprint":"ebd7f726d399","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01151","start_s":5690.063,"end_s":5699.473,"video_s":5740.063,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00297","chapter":"C012","text":"And it'd be nice if those things worked, but I look at Camelback between Central and 19th.","fingerprint":"c63c8955ae13","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01152","start_s":5700.414,"end_s":5704.678,"video_s":5750.414,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00297","chapter":"C012","text":"There are six rail that go through there","fingerprint":"6b33178b354f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01153","start_s":5705.148,"end_s":5706.489,"video_s":5755.148,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00297","chapter":"C012","text":"during rush hour.","fingerprint":"ab22d6876164","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01154","start_s":5707.01,"end_s":5707.83,"video_s":5757.01,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00297","chapter":"C012","text":"How many buses?","fingerprint":"0d9c1240f179","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01155","start_s":5709.552,"end_s":5710.012,"video_s":5759.552,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00297","chapter":"C012","text":"Do you know?","fingerprint":"0264b378c3f3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01156","start_s":5711.414,"end_s":5711.674,"video_s":5761.414,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00297","chapter":"C012","text":"Two.","fingerprint":"3fc4ccfe7458","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01157","start_s":5713.596,"end_s":5715.397,"video_s":5763.596,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00297","chapter":"C012","text":"How is that a transit system?","fingerprint":"b19c677985cb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01158","start_s":5716.218,"end_s":5726.307,"video_s":5766.218,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00297","chapter":"C012","text":"And when you brag and tap your shoulders about, well, we're a really good medium-sized system, well, that would be for like Glendale or Mesa.","fingerprint":"3619050aa3b7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01159","start_s":5727.288,"end_s":5729.651,"video_s":5777.288,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00297","chapter":"C012","text":"You're the city of Phoenix, seven million people.","fingerprint":"0c6b7cb7dcee","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01160","start_s":5730.111,"end_s":5732.353,"video_s":5780.111,"speaker":"v07","turn":"T00297","chapter":"C012","text":"You're not a medium, you're a large.","fingerprint":"5981f5ffdd1e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01161","start_s":5733.683,"end_s":5735.914,"video_s":5783.683,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00298","chapter":"C012","text":"Mahogany will be next followed by Diane.","fingerprint":"f9f72fefc08d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01162","start_s":5752.347,"end_s":5755.495,"video_s":5802.347,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C012","text":"Good evening, Mayor and members of City Council.","fingerprint":"623ca03ff660","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01163","start_s":5755.796,"end_s":5763.875,"video_s":5805.796,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C012","text":"My name is Mahogany Sevier, and I am a resident of Phoenix for ten years.","fingerprint":"b6709a37f827","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01164","start_s":5764.637,"end_s":5768.567,"video_s":5814.637,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C012","text":"I am here tonight to speak on homelessness strategy.","fingerprint":"0787ae9e7b1a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01165","start_s":5768.547,"end_s":5785.662,"video_s":5818.547,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C012","text":"While I share the community's frustration with seeing our public spaces, parks, and sidewalks becoming heavily impacted by encampments, I firmly believe that the current solely enforcement-based approach is not working.","fingerprint":"7a899e750cf1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01166","start_s":5785.642,"end_s":5796.52,"video_s":5835.642,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C012","text":"Sweeping encampments without providing immediate viable alternatives only move the problem from one block to another or worsen.","fingerprint":"f6922c6b18c4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01167","start_s":5797.401,"end_s":5808.78,"video_s":5847.401,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C012","text":"Break the fragile trust between our unhoused neighbors and service providers is not just a nuisance, it's a human crisis.","fingerprint":"d450423c55eb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01168","start_s":5808.76,"end_s":5825.784,"video_s":5858.76,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C012","text":"We know that a safe, stable place to live in the first steps of addressing the root causes of homelessness, which are mental health crisis, addiction, and extreme poverty.","fingerprint":"bdb194632a12","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01169","start_s":5826.425,"end_s":5830.992,"video_s":5876.425,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C012","text":"I urge the council to pivot towards the housing first approach.","fingerprint":"5663d8ca4a62","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01170","start_s":5831.933,"end_s":5836.219,"video_s":5881.933,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C012","text":"Specifically, I am asking you to fund more","fingerprint":"84f12548aaf7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01171","start_s":5836.199,"end_s":5864.822,"video_s":5886.199,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C012","text":"Not less immediate low barriers and non-congress shelters prove the expansion of mental health outreach teams to work alongside in places of law enforcement, invest in permanent supportive housing solutions rather than temporary high cost cleanup operations that do not solve the roots issue.","fingerprint":"e2a262f88655","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01172","start_s":5865.477,"end_s":5872.405,"video_s":5915.477,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C012","text":"The unhoused are not a separate moral category.","fingerprint":"a80ab0105a9d","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01173","start_s":5872.445,"end_s":5873.526,"video_s":5922.445,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C012","text":"They are neighbors.","fingerprint":"afbf2d9900b1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01174","start_s":5875.548,"end_s":5883.257,"video_s":5925.548,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C012","text":"Often people dealing with health crisis, losing their homes due to economical hardship.","fingerprint":"6475e84e09ec","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01175","start_s":5883.277,"end_s":5889.504,"video_s":5933.277,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C012","text":"They deserve dignity and we deserve a city that works for everyone.","fingerprint":"87bd1dbdb1d3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01176","start_s":5889.544,"end_s":5890.725,"video_s":5939.544,"speaker":"v14","turn":"T00299","chapter":"C012","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01177","start_s":5893.27,"end_s":5894.051,"video_s":5943.27,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00300","chapter":"C012","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01178","start_s":5894.171,"end_s":5898.695,"video_s":5944.171,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00300","chapter":"C012","text":"Diane is next, followed by Lee Ellis.","fingerprint":"8607bcd25fba","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01179","start_s":5899.395,"end_s":5901.317,"video_s":5949.395,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00301","chapter":"C012","text":"Thank you, Mayor, City Council.","fingerprint":"8e59ebae7076","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01180","start_s":5902.058,"end_s":5921.354,"video_s":5952.058,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00301","chapter":"C012","text":"I had an opportunity to be greeted well by my councilwoman, Anna Hernandez, and I just said, I remember being in LA and being on the freeway, and they had a platform, and the fast bus led us off there, and we connected with the local.","fingerprint":"cb832b4c5bf5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01181","start_s":5921.435,"end_s":5923.176,"video_s":5971.435,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00301","chapter":"C012","text":"I said, you know, I love taking","fingerprint":"7cab0c658c17","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01182","start_s":5923.156,"end_s":5934.687,"video_s":5973.156,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00301","chapter":"C012","text":"The transit over in LA, about 15% of the people, we think of it all cars over there, but they do have a big percentage taking transit.","fingerprint":"f13bc709140f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01183","start_s":5935.088,"end_s":5938.296,"video_s":5985.088,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00301","chapter":"C012","text":"I think that I'm a user of transit.","fingerprint":"b9ad45fd05d9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01184","start_s":5938.276,"end_s":5940.198,"video_s":5988.276,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00301","chapter":"C012","text":"I've made it work for me.","fingerprint":"e396555e6e21","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01185","start_s":5940.399,"end_s":5949.129,"video_s":5990.399,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00301","chapter":"C012","text":"What we have, I think that this area basically suffers from the lack of inspiration and education.","fingerprint":"662a6d6f848e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01186","start_s":5949.89,"end_s":5961.904,"video_s":5999.89,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00301","chapter":"C012","text":"In appreciating what we have, I see that TransDeaf, who's been with us in some other names for 50 years, got a contract, Ed would know about this, back in","fingerprint":"4fe32a518614","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01187","start_s":5961.884,"end_s":5971.157,"video_s":6011.884,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00301","chapter":"C012","text":"July, for the next five years, they operate out of not only the north and south, but 30% in the West Valley.","fingerprint":"97012298be00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01188","start_s":5971.177,"end_s":5980.67,"video_s":6021.177,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00301","chapter":"C012","text":"And this is where all you folks, we had 10 hours of talking about taking the light rail up there on Indian School.","fingerprint":"9f6ac590f240","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01189","start_s":5980.771,"end_s":5983.314,"video_s":6030.771,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00301","chapter":"C012","text":"But we have new buses.","fingerprint":"65f83e70030c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01190","start_s":5983.434,"end_s":5985.317,"video_s":6033.434,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00301","chapter":"C012","text":"Talk about electric.","fingerprint":"1ec50e7e2b3f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01191","start_s":5985.357,"end_s":5988.001,"video_s":6035.357,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00301","chapter":"C012","text":"We seem to be headed towards electric.","fingerprint":"566b8bb7eb7a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01192","start_s":5988.041,"end_s":5989.663,"video_s":6038.041,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00301","chapter":"C012","text":"The light rail is electric.","fingerprint":"90a7d7d1eb28","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01193","start_s":5989.643,"end_s":5994.331,"video_s":6039.643,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00301","chapter":"C012","text":"But if you think it's going to be zero emission, it has.","fingerprint":"70670681a5fc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01194","start_s":5994.492,"end_s":5996.556,"video_s":6044.492,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00301","chapter":"C012","text":"Pollution, as I stated earlier.","fingerprint":"28feef47a431","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01195","start_s":5997.157,"end_s":5998.78,"video_s":6047.157,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00301","chapter":"C012","text":"It'd be interesting to see.","fingerprint":"a48bfc8a1425","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01196","start_s":5998.86,"end_s":6005.392,"video_s":6048.86,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00301","chapter":"C012","text":"The city has been remarkable in making renewable energy for some years.","fingerprint":"adc9f10f3570","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01197","start_s":6005.512,"end_s":6010.741,"video_s":6055.512,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00301","chapter":"C012","text":"And we should be applauded across the United States for the CNG we've had.","fingerprint":"c66aa9cbfd98","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01198","start_s":6010.841,"end_s":6013.947,"video_s":6060.841,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00301","chapter":"C012","text":"I've driven those buses out at the airport.","fingerprint":"59673a92d027","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01199","start_s":6013.927,"end_s":6016.95,"video_s":6063.927,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00301","chapter":"C012","text":"and maybe we really should measure the emission.","fingerprint":"a49119c15045","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01200","start_s":6016.99,"end_s":6017.791,"video_s":6066.99,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00301","chapter":"C012","text":"Well, we should.","fingerprint":"96b34719f3c4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01201","start_s":6017.851,"end_s":6026.78,"video_s":6067.851,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00301","chapter":"C012","text":"And all of the components that MAG lets be exempt from pollution, transit, we need to measure it.","fingerprint":"91a967393947","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01202","start_s":6027.101,"end_s":6039.934,"video_s":6077.101,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00301","chapter":"C012","text":"We can't have a light rail accident for three days down on a major intersection, Indian School and Central caused by what happens","fingerprint":"e9cb7ee14ef7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01203","start_s":6039.914,"end_s":6046.147,"video_s":6089.914,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00301","chapter":"C012","text":"all the time, accidents from people making left-hand turns into the train.","fingerprint":"6cdec95fda95","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01204","start_s":6046.628,"end_s":6051.078,"video_s":6096.628,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00301","chapter":"C012","text":"And that happened six weeks ago or so.","fingerprint":"5ad3069f2c2c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01205","start_s":6051.098,"end_s":6052.881,"video_s":6101.098,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00301","chapter":"C012","text":"It was terrible.","fingerprint":"1de522768022","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01206","start_s":6052.902,"end_s":6055.166,"video_s":6102.902,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00301","chapter":"C012","text":"The driver in the truck was killed.","fingerprint":"37598b3d8a58","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01207","start_s":6055.246,"end_s":6057.872,"video_s":6105.246,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00301","chapter":"C012","text":"The whole train went off of the track.","fingerprint":"8f0cfb002d6a","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01208","start_s":6057.852,"end_s":6070.471,"video_s":6107.852,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00301","chapter":"C012","text":"and then I sit and listen to you wanting to make the preferred alternative to go on Indian School with more light rail that's at grade and it's dangerous.","fingerprint":"8f5468e3c108","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01209","start_s":6070.711,"end_s":6075.218,"video_s":6120.711,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00301","chapter":"C012","text":"Actually Central Avenue in the future and this would help out small businesses.","fingerprint":"3d4f042f2bfe","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01210","start_s":6075.778,"end_s":6085.092,"video_s":6125.778,"speaker":"v02","turn":"T00301","chapter":"C012","text":"We should have small businesses on Central and get the traffic off of that Central Avenue.","fingerprint":"bda4a767ccf6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01211","start_s":6087.89,"end_s":6088.591,"video_s":6137.89,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00302","chapter":"C012","text":"Thank you so much.","fingerprint":"f35b24cbbbe7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01212","start_s":6088.631,"end_s":6090.153,"video_s":6138.631,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00302","chapter":"C012","text":"Lee is next, followed by David.","fingerprint":"0f5b7d4a5322","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01213","start_s":6090.173,"end_s":6094.82,"video_s":6140.173,"speaker":"v13","turn":"T00303","chapter":"C012","text":"Thank you for your time.","fingerprint":"28036d909db6","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01214","start_s":6095.662,"end_s":6098.185,"video_s":6145.662,"speaker":"v13","turn":"T00303","chapter":"C012","text":"Since we last spoke, I was speaking on behalf of SOS.","fingerprint":"7328b89d2efe","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01215","start_s":6098.306,"end_s":6099.828,"video_s":6148.306,"speaker":"v13","turn":"T00303","chapter":"C012","text":"They have made a lot of good improvements.","fingerprint":"669331e51462","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01216","start_s":6101.03,"end_s":6101.731,"video_s":6151.03,"speaker":"v13","turn":"T00303","chapter":"C012","text":"They are stepping up.","fingerprint":"ca3890afcc22","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01217","start_s":6101.751,"end_s":6104.675,"video_s":6151.751,"speaker":"v13","turn":"T00303","chapter":"C012","text":"We do still need some more disabled bathrooms in there.","fingerprint":"abbe496de675","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01218","start_s":6105.837,"end_s":6109.122,"video_s":6155.837,"speaker":"v13","turn":"T00303","chapter":"C012","text":"There are showers in there they're going to need some work onto as well.","fingerprint":"4f1d9dcf54dc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01219","start_s":6109.663,"end_s":6113.308,"video_s":6159.663,"speaker":"v13","turn":"T00303","chapter":"C012","text":"But thank you for your time and all your guys' hard effort.","fingerprint":"321e66066896","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01220","start_s":6113.909,"end_s":6114.69,"video_s":6163.909,"speaker":"v13","turn":"T00303","chapter":"C012","text":"We appreciate you.","fingerprint":"4b4cb38d2cf2","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01221","start_s":6118.163,"end_s":6118.683,"video_s":6168.163,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00304","chapter":"C012","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01222","start_s":6118.944,"end_s":6120.345,"video_s":6168.944,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00304","chapter":"C012","text":"David is next, followed by Elizabeth.","fingerprint":"c93c717db2a4","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01223","start_s":6126.511,"end_s":6129.734,"video_s":6176.511,"speaker":"v15","turn":"T00305","chapter":"C012","text":"Yeah, I wanted to say thank you to all of you in the council.","fingerprint":"bb063a80ccda","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01224","start_s":6130.855,"end_s":6134.478,"video_s":6180.855,"speaker":"v15","turn":"T00305","chapter":"C012","text":"Everything has been going way better than we could have ever thought possible.","fingerprint":"f81ffee768bc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01225","start_s":6135.879,"end_s":6137.901,"video_s":6185.879,"speaker":"v15","turn":"T00305","chapter":"C012","text":"There's a lot of good works that are going on.","fingerprint":"ac63656ca9cf","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01226","start_s":6137.981,"end_s":6139.783,"video_s":6187.981,"speaker":"v15","turn":"T00305","chapter":"C012","text":"We just had our first town hall today.","fingerprint":"8079dab16a7b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01227","start_s":6140.564,"end_s":6144.107,"video_s":6190.564,"speaker":"v15","turn":"T00305","chapter":"C012","text":"I was able to speak there, so pardon me, my voice is gone.","fingerprint":"c967bd4beafa","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01228","start_s":6144.787,"end_s":6147.63,"video_s":6194.787,"speaker":"v15","turn":"T00305","chapter":"C012","text":"But anyway, I just wanted to say thank you for hearing us.","fingerprint":"69cd7425e973","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01229","start_s":6148.859,"end_s":6153.715,"video_s":6198.859,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00306","chapter":"C012","text":"Elizabeth is next, followed by Teresa.","fingerprint":"a46e856c26e0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01230","start_s":6158.893,"end_s":6159.274,"video_s":6208.893,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00307","chapter":"C012","text":"Okay.","fingerprint":"6a581ee90118","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01231","start_s":6161.026,"end_s":6169.259,"video_s":6211.026,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00307","chapter":"C012","text":"Okay, so basically I wanted to tell you a little bit about my back story and my disability.","fingerprint":"870cfb176481","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01232","start_s":6170.361,"end_s":6178.534,"video_s":6220.361,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00307","chapter":"C012","text":"Just because I feel like there's not enough education regarding mental health that comes from people that experience severe psychiatric conditions.","fingerprint":"4cc6557cccef","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01233","start_s":6179.435,"end_s":6184.283,"video_s":6229.435,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00307","chapter":"C012","text":"Because people face a lot of stigma in talking in public about it.","fingerprint":"01a10d6019f0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01234","start_s":6184.263,"end_s":6188.128,"video_s":6234.263,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00307","chapter":"C012","text":"but I have a disorder that's called schizoaffective disorder.","fingerprint":"0560147de9d9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01235","start_s":6188.168,"end_s":6192.634,"video_s":6238.168,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00307","chapter":"C012","text":"It's very difficult to medicate because it has a wide variety of symptoms.","fingerprint":"7755a97cba80","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01236","start_s":6193.375,"end_s":6200.124,"video_s":6243.375,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00307","chapter":"C012","text":"Basically I have like all the mental health disorders at like one time, which is super fun, right?","fingerprint":"d5b186e34c20","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01237","start_s":6201.025,"end_s":6202.988,"video_s":6251.025,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00307","chapter":"C012","text":"Oh no.","fingerprint":"0efea166568e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01238","start_s":6203.969,"end_s":6207.754,"video_s":6253.969,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00307","chapter":"C012","text":"But anyways, I wanted to tell you a little bit about how it operates.","fingerprint":"0206659ff6c9","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01239","start_s":6207.874,"end_s":6211.519,"video_s":6257.874,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00307","chapter":"C012","text":"I had come before and told you about how I have a glandular problem.","fingerprint":"d0d51ec05e95","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01240","start_s":6211.499,"end_s":6237.692,"video_s":6261.499,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00307","chapter":"C012","text":"which causes a hormone to be elevated which counteracts vitamin D and it causes like lesions on the brain and I have psoriasis and and it causes a wide variety like kidney failure and like a wide variety of symptoms and the average life expectancy is I believe","fingerprint":"e2ce05adae00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01241","start_s":6237.672,"end_s":6262.532,"video_s":6287.672,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00307","chapter":"C012","text":"around age 40 so I'm doing good on the average but it makes it so that your calcium is too high and also the lesions you know don't help but makes it so your calcium is too high because you don't have enough vitamin D right and I'm only explaining this because I don't I feel like it's a mechanical thing to me right um","fingerprint":"faf645bbc334","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01242","start_s":6262.512,"end_s":6292.401,"video_s":6312.512,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00307","chapter":"C012","text":"you know the calcium gets too high and it just regulates basically everything in this cell right so you have things that work on large molecules going in and out of membranes and they're triggered by like a potential like an action potential so like if you have a certain amount of calcium on one side it's going to want to move across through active transport and so it interferes with energy processing so metabolism","fingerprint":"910837d50923","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01243","start_s":6292.381,"end_s":6297.894,"video_s":6342.381,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00307","chapter":"C012","text":"and it also interferes with neurotransmitters going in and out.","fingerprint":"3ed56dae4d92","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01244","start_s":6297.934,"end_s":6299.958,"video_s":6347.934,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00307","chapter":"C012","text":"It might even stop them entirely.","fingerprint":"fbf00493bc8f","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01245","start_s":6299.998,"end_s":6309.2,"video_s":6349.998,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00307","chapter":"C012","text":"And so from my experience, I just don't feel like people have an idea that this is a sort of mechanical thing that occurs within my body.","fingerprint":"5758c0cd6a68","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01246","start_s":6309.56,"end_s":6311.605,"video_s":6359.56,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00307","chapter":"C012","text":"It's not necessarily a choice.","fingerprint":"551e8853aff8","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01247","start_s":6311.585,"end_s":6333.209,"video_s":6361.585,"speaker":"v16","turn":"T00307","chapter":"C012","text":"but it's very difficult to kind of deal with ramifications and that's part of why I want to be transparent about being an advocate that has these disorder because I feel like a lot of people don't understand how it works and that's about it.","fingerprint":"8528ea4b0700","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01248","start_s":6335.552,"end_s":6337.514,"video_s":6385.552,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00308","chapter":"C012","text":"Thank you so much for that important testimony.","fingerprint":"b0d711a28bcd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01249","start_s":6337.774,"end_s":6340.157,"video_s":6387.774,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00308","chapter":"C012","text":"Theresa Hill is next followed by Nanika","fingerprint":"a03cceda21a0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01250","start_s":6342.55,"end_s":6362.179,"video_s":6392.55,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00309","chapter":"C012","text":"Mayor and City Council, I want to take this opportunity to say thank you to the police officers, the families, and that you approve the visits that the officers made.","fingerprint":"de426673f183","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01251","start_s":6363.29,"end_s":6383.931,"video_s":6413.29,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00309","chapter":"C012","text":"In just a few months, there have been a number of family citizen apps showing on our neighborhood for the calls of the police for fighting, for yelling, theft at Walgreens and Circle K.","fingerprint":"fa38907b16d5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01252","start_s":6383.911,"end_s":6389.859,"video_s":6433.911,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00309","chapter":"C012","text":"that I can't feel safe in going to from stabbings to bonfires.","fingerprint":"5e60c069e12b","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01253","start_s":6390.24,"end_s":6398.271,"video_s":6440.24,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00309","chapter":"C012","text":"These are just a few, including exposure of people in the park.","fingerprint":"2da484666742","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01254","start_s":6398.852,"end_s":6401.736,"video_s":6448.852,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00309","chapter":"C012","text":"And so I just want to say thank you to the police officers.","fingerprint":"22a0dcc232bd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01255","start_s":6401.796,"end_s":6404.4,"video_s":6451.796,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00309","chapter":"C012","text":"They're handling a lot of calls.","fingerprint":"ff208fd53190","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01256","start_s":6405.578,"end_s":6407.54,"video_s":6455.578,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00309","chapter":"C012","text":"I do care for the homeless.","fingerprint":"75688fa85514","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01257","start_s":6408.141,"end_s":6410.204,"video_s":6458.141,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00309","chapter":"C012","text":"I support all the city is doing.","fingerprint":"7c76a4aedea5","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01258","start_s":6411.045,"end_s":6416.692,"video_s":6461.045,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00309","chapter":"C012","text":"But I hear over and over again that we're criminalizing people for being homeless.","fingerprint":"7371c08674bd","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01259","start_s":6419.155,"end_s":6421.658,"video_s":6469.155,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00309","chapter":"C012","text":"We are here to enforce the laws.","fingerprint":"4acfa56d5658","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01260","start_s":6422.198,"end_s":6428.346,"video_s":6472.198,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00309","chapter":"C012","text":"And if homeless are getting arrested, they're getting arrested for breaking the law.","fingerprint":"485b8ef11de0","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01261","start_s":6429.946,"end_s":6437.558,"video_s":6479.946,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00309","chapter":"C012","text":"I have seen personally people stealing even in the grocery stores that are homeless.","fingerprint":"9a30db4b0dde","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01262","start_s":6439.04,"end_s":6447.113,"video_s":6489.04,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00309","chapter":"C012","text":"I've had homeless people tell me it doesn't matter because the police won't touch me because I'm homeless.","fingerprint":"04a22d93c1d3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01263","start_s":6447.874,"end_s":6450.979,"video_s":6497.874,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00309","chapter":"C012","text":"That means to be under control.","fingerprint":"7071efc617c3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01264","start_s":6452.081,"end_s":6454.845,"video_s":6502.081,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00309","chapter":"C012","text":"And our parks are not campsites.","fingerprint":"da8459a15132","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01265","start_s":6455.326,"end_s":6457.489,"video_s":6505.326,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00309","chapter":"C012","text":"They're not medical centers.","fingerprint":"519c51abbac7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01266","start_s":6458.363,"end_s":6463.228,"video_s":6508.363,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00309","chapter":"C012","text":"We have lots of money we've spent and we need to spend on these shelters.","fingerprint":"83937a695fc7","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01267","start_s":6463.788,"end_s":6473.918,"video_s":6513.788,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00309","chapter":"C012","text":"I know a few people who have gone through the program, have gotten an apartment, have gotten a job, and they don't go to work.","fingerprint":"9f231a937257","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01268","start_s":6473.938,"end_s":6477.261,"video_s":6523.938,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00309","chapter":"C012","text":"They're in the system until they get evicted.","fingerprint":"a5797b05a1dc","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01269","start_s":6477.281,"end_s":6480.404,"video_s":6527.281,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00309","chapter":"C012","text":"Then the landlords, out they go.","fingerprint":"e121f6237a69","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01270","start_s":6480.444,"end_s":6486.21,"video_s":6530.444,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00309","chapter":"C012","text":"And we wonder why they are not wanting to accept our vouchers.","fingerprint":"5c9105724d35","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01271","start_s":6486.798,"end_s":6492.204,"video_s":6536.798,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00309","chapter":"C012","text":"So housing first doesn't work when I see so many people.","fingerprint":"2fed3dcbaa8c","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01272","start_s":6493.946,"end_s":6499.392,"video_s":6543.946,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00309","chapter":"C012","text":"We need to drop the catch-all phrase, criminalizing homeless.","fingerprint":"a97cabb55450","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01273","start_s":6500.393,"end_s":6502.095,"video_s":6550.393,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00309","chapter":"C012","text":"We need to look at the whole picture.","fingerprint":"80bae77ab7ee","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01274","start_s":6502.496,"end_s":6503.897,"video_s":6552.496,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00309","chapter":"C012","text":"And I'll end with this.","fingerprint":"b5199d40e8f3","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01275","start_s":6505.179,"end_s":6506.52,"video_s":6555.179,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00309","chapter":"C012","text":"Where is the balance?","fingerprint":"2b8063e436c1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01276","start_s":6509.964,"end_s":6515.37,"video_s":6559.964,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00309","chapter":"C012","text":"Where did we lose our right to have a safe city?","fingerprint":"6f1d92eed6ee","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01277","start_s":6517.072,"end_s":6518.794,"video_s":6567.072,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00309","chapter":"C012","text":"and thank you guys for listening.","fingerprint":"25e1226e6e4e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01278","start_s":6518.855,"end_s":6523.101,"video_s":6568.855,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00309","chapter":"C012","text":"You're hearing us that are actually throughout the valley.","fingerprint":"a78b9b19a467","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01279","start_s":6523.141,"end_s":6528.248,"video_s":6573.141,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00309","chapter":"C012","text":"These problems aren't in just one district, they're citywide.","fingerprint":"d40d57930ed1","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01280","start_s":6529.69,"end_s":6530.371,"video_s":6579.69,"speaker":"v05","turn":"T00309","chapter":"C012","text":"Thank you again.","fingerprint":"bf18a457cabb","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01281","start_s":6530.391,"end_s":6531.292,"video_s":6580.391,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00310","chapter":"C012","text":"Thank you.","fingerprint":"844347e54f00","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01282","start_s":6531.673,"end_s":6534.557,"video_s":6581.673,"speaker":"kate-gallego","turn":"T00310","chapter":"C012","text":"With that, our final speaker is no longer online, so we are adjourned.","fingerprint":"0f6145ad2b85","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]},{"id":"L01283","start_s":6550.417,"end_s":6563.413,"video_s":6600.417,"speaker":"v01","turn":"T00311","chapter":"C012","text":"I also want, before I welcome Rich to the podium, I want to say, I mean, we have talked about the deal-making of New Orleans, and it was a very tough deal to do because we had a compressed timeline.","fingerprint":"be60f1d6096e","evidence":[],"suggestions":[]}],"items":[{"event_item_id":62862,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"If viewing this packet electronically in PDF, open and use bookmarks to navigate easily from one item to another.\r\n\r\nOPTIONS TO ACCESS THIS MEETING\r\n\r\nVirtual Request to speak at a meeting: \r\n\r\n- Register online by visiting the City Council Meetings page on phoenix.gov at least 2 hours prior to the start of this meeting. Then, click on this link at the time of the meeting and join the Webex to speak: \r\nhttps://phoenixcitycouncil.webex.com/phoenixcitycouncil/j.php?MTID=md15fbc68aa288098bb3a1821d6a94bef\r\n\r\n- Register via telephone at 602-262-6001 at least 2 hours prior to the start of this meeting, noting the item number. Then, use the Call-in phone number and Meeting ID listed below at the time of the meeting to call-in and speak. \r\n\r\nIn-Person Requests to speak at a meeting:\r\n\r\n- Register in person at a kiosk located at the City Council Chambers, 200 W. Jefferson St., Phoenix, Arizona, 85003. Arrive 1 hour prior to the start of this meeting. Depending on seating availability, residents will attend and speak from the Upper Chambers, Lower Chambers or City Hall location.\r\n\r\n- Individuals should arrive early, 1 hour prior to the start of the meeting to submit an in-person request to speak before the item is called. After the item is called, requests to speak for that item will not be accepted.\r\n\r\nAt the time of the meeting:\r\n\r\n- Watch the meeting live streamed on phoenix.gov or Phoenix Channel 11 on Cox Cable, or using the Webex link provided above.\r\n\r\n- Call-in to listen to the meeting. Dial 602-666-0783 and Enter Meeting ID 2555 597 6128# (for English) or 2556 096 2175# (for Spanish). Press # again when prompted for attendee ID.\r\n\r\n- Watch the meeting in-person from the Upper Chambers, Lower Chambers or City Hall depending on seating availability.\r\n\r\n- Members of the public may attend this meeting in person. Physical access to the meeting location will be available starting 1 hour prior to the meeting.\r\n\r\nPara nuestros residentes de habla hispana:\t\r\n\r\n- Para registrarse para hablar en español, llame al 602-262-6001 al menos 2 horas antes del inicio de esta reunión e indique el número del tema. El día de la reunión, llame al 602-666-0783 e ingrese el número de identificación de la reunión 2556 096 2175#. El intérprete le indicará cuando sea su turno de hablar. \r\n\r\n- Para solamente escuchar la reunión en español, llame a este mismo número el día de la reunión (602-666-0783; ingrese el número de identificación de la reunión 2556 096 2175#). Se proporciona interpretación simultánea para nuestros residentes durante todas las reuniones.\r\n\r\n- Para asistir a la reunión en persona, vaya a las Cámaras del Concejo Municipal de Phoenix ubicadas en 200 W. Jefferson Street, Phoenix, AZ 85003. Llegue 1 hora antes del comienzo de la reunión. Si desea hablar, regístrese electrónicamente en uno de los quioscos, antes de que comience el tema. Una vez que se comience a discutir el tema, no se aceptarán nuevas solicitudes para hablar. Dependiendo de cuantos asientos haya disponibles, usted podría ser sentado en la parte superior de las cámaras, en el piso de abajo de las cámaras, o en el edificio municipal.\r\n\r\n- Miembros del público pueden asistir a esta reunión en persona. El acceso físico al lugar de la reunión estará disponible comenzando una hora antes de la reunión.","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":63412,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":"The Phoenix City Council convened in formal session on Wednesday, February 18, 2026 at 2:39 p.m. in the Council Chambers.","votes":[],"roll_call":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Present"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Present"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Present"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Present"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Present"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Present"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Present"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Present"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Present"}]},{"event_item_id":62800,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Present"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Present"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Present"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Present"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Present"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Present"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Present"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Present"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Present"}]},{"event_item_id":63563,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":"Prior to the Call to Order, a moment of silence was held in memory of Phoenix Municipal Court Hearing Officer Susan Hawkins, who passed in the line of duty.\n\nCouncilwoman Pastor temporarily left and returned to the voting body during discussion of Item 36.\n\nMayor Gallego acknowledged the presence of Mario Barajas and Elsie Duarte, Spanish interpreters. In Spanish, Mr. Barajas announced their availability to the audience.\n\nThe City Clerk confirmed copies of the titles of Ordinances G-7471; S-52517 and S-52595 through S-52626 were available to the public in the Office of the City Clerk at least 24 hours prior to this Council meeting and, therefore, may be read by title or agenda item only pursuant to the City Code.\n\nReferences to attachments in these minutes relate to documents that were attached to the agenda.\n\nCity Attorney Julie Kriegh stated members of the public may speak for up to two minutes on agenda items and gave direction on appropriate decorum when providing comments.","votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62802,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"BOARDS AND COMMISSIONS","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62803,"agenda_number":"1","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Mayor and Council Appointments to Boards and Commissions","matter_file":"26-0358","matter_type":"Board & Commission","action":"approved","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"The following individuals were recommended for appointment by Mayor Gallego and Councilwoman Stark.\n\nNorth Mountain Village Planning Committee\nAppoint Reuben Nach, filling a vacancy, for a term to expire February 18, 2028, as recommended by Councilwoman Stark.\n\nPhoenix Business and Workforce Development Board\nAppoint Brenda Sipe, replacing Raghu Santanam, for a partial term to expire June 30, 2027, as recommended by Mayor Gallego.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":63414,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":"Mayor Gallego administered the oath of office to the following appointee:\n-Reuben Nach, North Mountain Village Planning Committee-\n\nMayor Gallego invited the appointee to approach the dais so Council could extend their appreciation.","votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62804,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"LIQUOR LICENSES, BINGO, AND OFF-TRACK BETTING LICENSE APPLICATIONS","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62872,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":"approved and/or adopted as part of an omnibus motion","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":"Mayor Gallego requested a motion on liquor license items. A motion was made, as appears below.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62805,"agenda_number":"2","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Nadu - District 2","matter_file":"25-2592","matter_type":"License - Liquor","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62807,"agenda_number":"3","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Life Time - Paradise Valley - District 3","matter_file":"26-0034","matter_type":"License - Liquor","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62813,"agenda_number":"4","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Special Event - Brophy College Preparatory - District 4","matter_file":"26-0110","matter_type":"License - Special Event","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62815,"agenda_number":"5","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Special Event - McDowell Mountain Music Festival, Inc. - District 4","matter_file":"26-0178","matter_type":"License - Special Event","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62811,"agenda_number":"6","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Special Event - Windsor Square Special Planning District - District 4","matter_file":"26-0098","matter_type":"License - Special Event","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62814,"agenda_number":"7","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Special Event - Stacy Fuson Foundation - District 6","matter_file":"26-0176","matter_type":"License - Special Event","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62806,"agenda_number":"8","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Char 3333 - District 6","matter_file":"25-2594","matter_type":"License - Liquor","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62809,"agenda_number":"9","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Urban Market - District 7","matter_file":"26-0128","matter_type":"License - Liquor","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62808,"agenda_number":"10","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Walter Studios - District 7","matter_file":"26-0122","matter_type":"License - Liquor","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62810,"agenda_number":"11","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - Special Event - Hungarian Cultural Association of Phoenix - District 8","matter_file":"26-0016","matter_type":"License - Special Event","action":"recommended for approval","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62861,"agenda_number":"12","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Liquor License - 27th Ave Market - District 1","matter_file":"26-0136","matter_type":"License - Liquor","action":"forwarded without recommendation","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\nMayor Gallego introduced this item and reported it was within Council District 1.\n\nCouncilwoman O'Brien reported she would like to hear from the applicant before making a motion.\n\nIsmail Abushanab stated he was the applicant for the series-10 liquor license application. He said the location has had a valid series-9 liquor license since 1983, which has allowed Circle K to sell hard liquor to date. Mr. Abushanab opined keeping the location vacant would be detrimental for the community as the building has suffered damage from vandalism that has required significant investment and spoke about meeting with community leaders, neighborhood groups, residents and law enforcement, and the creation of a neighborhood agreement focused on safety. He advocated for Council to recommend approval of this liquor license.\n\nMayor Gallego noted Reuben Nach, newly appointed member of the North Mountain Village Planning Committee, had signed up to speak if necessary and declared his support for this application.\n\nCouncilwoman O'Brien thanked Mr. Abushanab for his work with the community.\n\nNOTE: One electronic comment was submitted for the record in support for this item.\n\nCouncilwoman O'Brien made a motion seconded my Councilwoman Pastor, as appears below.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62818,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"ORDINANCES, RESOLUTIONS, AND NEW BUSINESS","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62820,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"ADMINISTRATION","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62873,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":"approved and/or adopted as part of an omnibus motion","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":"Mayor Gallego requested a motion on the remaining agenda items. A motion was made, as appears below.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":63562,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":"Item 13, Ordinance S-52595 was a request to authorize the City Controller to disburse funds, up to amounts indicated on item 13, for the purpose of paying vendors, contractors, claimants and others, and providing additional payment authority under certain existing city contracts. This section also requested continuing payment authority, up to amounts indicated below, for the following contracts, contract extensions and/or bids awarded. As indicated below, some items below require payment pursuant to Phoenix City Code section 42-13.","votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62822,"agenda_number":"14","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Proposed Rancho Grande Annexation (Ordinance S-52611) - District 7","matter_file":"26-0029","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62827,"agenda_number":"16","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Acceptance and Dedication of Deeds and Easements for Roadway, Public Utility and Sidewalk Purposes (Ordinance S-52607) - Districts 2, 3 & 4","matter_file":"25-2807","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62825,"agenda_number":"17","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Acquisition of Real Property for Improvements of Booster Pump Station 4SA-B2 Located near 48th Street and Elliot (Ordinance S-52598) - District 6","matter_file":"25-2550","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62826,"agenda_number":"18","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Acquisition of Real Property for Full Replacement of Booster Pump Station 7J-B1 Located Near E. Quartz Mountain Road and N. Cheney Drive in Paradise Valley (Ordinance S-52602) - Out of City","matter_file":"25-2741","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62829,"agenda_number":"20","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"LinkedIn Recruiting Services Contract - RFA 26-0092 - Request for Award (Ordinance S-52610) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0026","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62857,"agenda_number":"22","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Request to Amend the Intergovernmental Agreement with Arizona State University for Opioid Response Planning (Ordinance S-52623) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0190","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62831,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"COMMUNITY SERVICES","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62832,"agenda_number":"23","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Amend Ordinance S-51554 for the Central and Columbus Development Project (Ordinance S-52619) - District 4","matter_file":"26-0114","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62866,"agenda_number":"25","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Artist Design, Fabrication, and Installation Contract for the General Obligation Bond Public Art Projects, Proposition 1: Fire Stations (Ordinance S-52624) - Districts 1, 3, 5 & 6","matter_file":"26-0146","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62835,"agenda_number":"27","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Performance Entertainment Coordination Services - PKS-RFQU-24-0427 - Request for Award (Ordinance S-52599) - Citywide","matter_file":"25-2597","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62837,"agenda_number":"28","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Amend Ordinance S-49260 and Development Agreement with Halle Properties LLC. (Ordinance S-52596) - District 2","matter_file":"25-2271","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62838,"agenda_number":"29","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Authorization to Amend Development Agreement with Grand Canyon University (City Contract 142412) (Ordinance S-52622) - District 5","matter_file":"26-0277","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62823,"agenda_number":"31","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"(CONTINUED FROM JANUARY 7 AND FEBRUARY 4, 2026) - Request Authorization to Enter Into a Private Stormwater Pipe License with Envision Dobbins, LLC (Ordinance S-52517) - District 7","matter_file":"26-0329","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62864,"agenda_number":"32","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Voluntary Acquisition of Improved Real Property Located at the Southeast Corner of E. Madison Street and S. 30th Street for Phoenix Sky Harbor International Airport (Ordinance S-52626) - District 8","matter_file":"26-0038","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62836,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62842,"agenda_number":"33","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Phoenix Sky Harbor International Airport Terminal 3 Garage Expansion Joints and Bearing Pads and Terminal 4 Garage Seals and Expansion Joints on Levels 4 through 9 - Professional Services - AV13000007 and AV21000117 (Ordinance S-52597) - District 8","matter_file":"25-2302","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62843,"agenda_number":"34","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Painting Services - IFB 24-FMD-004 - Amendment (Ordinance S-52603) - Citywide","matter_file":"25-2774","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62844,"agenda_number":"35","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Paint and Rubber Removal from Pavement Surfaces Contract IFB 24-0075 (Ordinance S-52612) - Districts 1, 8 & Out of City","matter_file":"26-0030","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62839,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"PUBLIC SAFETY","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62846,"agenda_number":"38","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Apply for Arizona State Parks & Trails Land and Water Conservation Fund Grant for Federal Fiscal Year 2026 (Ordinance S-52606) - Districts 7 & 8","matter_file":"25-2806","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62847,"agenda_number":"39","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Global Navigation Satellite System Receivers and Related Equipment Contract - COOP 26-0039 - Request for Award  (Ordinance S-52609) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0006","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62841,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"TRANSPORTATION AND INFRASTRUCTURE","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62848,"agenda_number":"40","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"35th Avenue: Interstate 10 to Camelback Road (BUILD) - Engineering Services Amendment - ST89340634 (Ordinance S-52614) - Districts 4 & 5","matter_file":"26-0040","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62849,"agenda_number":"41","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Bypass Spools and Tailpieces Contract - IFB-26-0112 Request for Award (Ordinance S-52600) - Citywide","matter_file":"25-2685","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62850,"agenda_number":"42","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Chlorine IFB-26-0153 Request for Award (Ordinance S-52601) - Citywide","matter_file":"25-2736","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62851,"agenda_number":"43","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Water Loss Audit Contract - RTO-2526-WRD-704 -  Request for Award (Ordinance S-52604) - Citywide","matter_file":"25-2790","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62852,"agenda_number":"44","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Rotork Actuators Contract - IFB-26-0140 Request for Award (Ordinance S-52613) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0032","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62853,"agenda_number":"45","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Request to Amend the Intergovernmental Agreement Between the City of Phoenix and Town of Cave Creek for Water Service Infrastructure (Ordinance S-52615) - Out of City","matter_file":"26-0044","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62854,"agenda_number":"46","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Water Resources Technical Strategy Development Requirements Contract - Amendment (Ordinance S-52617) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0066","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62821,"agenda_number":"47","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"(CONTINUED FROM JANUARY 7 AND FEBRUARY 4, 2026) - Amend City Code - Ordinance Adoption - Rezoning Application PHO-1-25--Z-SP-9-22-7 - Southwest Corner of 35th Avenue and Broadway Road (Ordinance G-7471) - District 7","matter_file":"26-0330","matter_type":"Ordinance-G","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62863,"agenda_number":"48","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"(CONTINUED FROM JANUARY 7 AND FEBRUARY 4, 2026) - Modification of Stipulation Request for Ratification of November 19, 2025, Planning Hearing Officer Action - PHO-1-25--Z-131-99-7 - Southeast Corner of 59th Avenue and Lower Buckeye Road - District 7","matter_file":"26-0331","matter_type":"Zoning Modification of Stipulations","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":true,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62819,"agenda_number":"13","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Settlement of Claim(s) Perez v. City of Phoenix","matter_file":"26-0323","matter_type":"Payment Ordinance","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\nMayor Gallego introduced this item.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington made a motion to approve Item 13. Councilwoman Pastor seconded the motion.\n\nCouncilwoman Hernandez spoke about this being the second settlement brought to the Council within the last few months regarding police officers driving behavior. She questioned what improvements were considered by the Police Department when incidents like this happened.\n\nPolice Chief Matthew Giordano responded when an incident occurs, a supervisor responds to conduct a initial investigation and create an internal report, the officer involved receives a notice of investigation and is interviewed. He stated all the information gathered is then sent to the Driving Analysis Committee within the Driving Bureau, who reviews the case to identify whether the incident could have been avoided and to improve future training and if the Committee identifies patterns, they are addressed with the entire department.\n\nCouncilwoman Hernandez asked Chief Giordano to explain how were driving behaviors addressed across the whole department.\n\nChief Giordano explained they look for trends, issues as well as training to ensure officers are trained to drive safely and cautiously.\n\nCouncilwoman Hernandez asked Chief Giordano to explain what is done specifically for the officers that are involved in vehicular accidents before their return to driving duty.\n\nChief Giordano explained the department provides basic training at the police academy as well as ongoing advanced training throughout an officer's career and if an officer showed a specific issue, that officer may receive individualized instruction at the academy. Chief Giordano restated each collision is reviewed in its entirety to understand what happened and to determine whether additional training is needed.\n\nCouncilwoman Hernandez asked how are officers held accountable when they were involved in a traffic incident.\n\nChief Giordano responded the investigation is fully vetted, goes to the department's driving analysis committee who decides whether the action of the officer was within policy, and if the action was determined to be out of policy discipline normally follows. Chief Giordano stated in this case a supervisory council was conducted.\n\nCouncilwoman Hernandez asked clarification on the disciplinary process for driving violations.\n\nChief Giordano reiterated a driving violation was not different than any other violation and it would follow the misconduct or violation of policy like any other one according to the policy for discipline. He restated in this case a supervisory council was conducted since this was the first offense traffic violation.\n\nCouncilwoman Hernandez emphasized the importance to prevent future accidents by holding officers to high driving standards and improving community trust requires demonstrating clear changes in officer behavior and ensuring safety for residents. She thanked Chief Giordano for his answers.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62817,"agenda_number":"15","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Proposed 9th Avenue and Alameda Road Annexation - Public Hearing - District 1","matter_file":"26-0046","matter_type":"Public Hearing (Non-Zoning)","action":"hearing held","passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\nMayor Gallego introduced this item.\n\nMayor Gallego declared the public hearing open. Noting there were no members of the public wishing to speak, she closed the public hearing.","votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62828,"agenda_number":"19","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Acquisition of Real Property for Roadway Improvements Along 15th Avenue North of Camelback Road (Ordinance S-52608) - District 4","matter_file":"25-2809","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\nMayor Gallego introduced this item.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington made a motion to approve Item 19. Councilwoman O'Brien seconded the motion.\n\nBlue Crowley spoke about the importance of public transit and the necessary infrastructure needed to support the transit system.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62830,"agenda_number":"21","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Amendments to the City's Combined Classification and Pay Ordinance (S-51144) in Accordance with Human Resources Committees (HRCs) 2026-004 and 2026-005 Recommendations (Ordinance S-52621) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0177","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted as amended","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\nMayor Gallego introduced this item.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington made a motion to approve Item 21. Councilwoman O'Brien seconded the motion.\n\nTyler Smith communicated he was a Senior Program Supervisor I with the City's Human Services Department and had taken personal leave to attend this meeting. Mr. Smith spoke about the duties and responsibilities of his position and advocated for a higher classification pay grade than the one proposed in today's agenda.\n\nCouncilwoman Hernandez asked if Mr. Smith was in support of this item.\n\nMr. Smith answered he and his colleagues were opposing the suggested pay grade.\n\nCouncilwoman Pastor recognized those who serve the City's senior residents and spoke about the care and guidance provided to them by City staff. She recalled Council has acted on several classification pay ordinances in the near past and asked about the process to determine when and how a position pay grade was reclassified.\n\nHuman Resources Director Jason Perkiser answered when a position was regraded, the incumbents automatically move up along the new pay grade increase and explained how the City's step plan are designed.\n\nCouncilwoman Pastor asked who determined these regrades.\n\nMr. Perkiser answered all employees within a specific classification regrade would automatically be moved to the new pay grade.\n\nCouncilwoman Pastor asked Mr. Perkiser to explain the difference between a position classification with pay step and one with pay ranges.\n\nMr. Perkiser explained the City uses a step-increase pay system and the pay range shown for a position reflected the lowest and highest step, with employees moving through those steps with normal progression. He further explained that for open-range classifications, placement within the range was determined by the employee's annual management achievement plan (MAP) evaluation score and in these cases, the City Manager has final authority to determine the employee's salary increase.\n\nCouncilwoman Stark reported she knew Mr. Smith well and the fact that the seniors who attend the senior center in her district adore him. She commended him for speaking at the meeting today to explain what they do. Councilwoman Stark asked Mr. Smith what he thought his classification grade should be.\n\nMr. Smith opined that collectively, a Senior Program Supervisor I, should be at the same pay grade as Case Worker III and Recreation Coordinator III, which performed comparable duties.\n\nCouncilwoman Stark spoke about her experience at Shadow Mountain Senior Center and how senior centers are important and a lifeline to the City's senior population. She stated this item would give the Senior Program Supervisor I a raise but she would like to revisit this classification and asked about the process to do so.\n\nMr. Perkiser acknowledged the concerns raised and affirmed the City could revisit this classification. He noted the recommendation did provide an increase and explained the compensation analysis incorporated both local labor market data for similar roles and internal equity considerations, which resulted in an increase while still maintaining internal alignment and equity across the broader organization.\n\nCouncilwoman Stark affirmed the Senior Program Supervisor Is should be compensated now and expressed the need to revisit this classification as she understood the important work they do.\n\nCity Manager Ed Zuercher stated the Human Resources Department (HR) team could reassess this classification and return to Council with their findings. He noted there was an immediate increase available and the Council could choose to move forward with that now. Mr. Zuercher expressed the need to make an amendment to the motion approving the current recommendation while directing HR to review the classification, meet with the affected staff and identify a potential middle ground to return to Council.\n\nCouncilwoman Guardado stated she did not wish to hold the currently proposed raises and that she was prepared to make a friendly amendment to the motion.\n\nCouncilwoman Guardado made a friendly amendment to the motion that the Council move forward with the motion on the floor, but also revisit these classifications, have a meeting with the employees and for HR to identify a potential middle ground to bring back to Council.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington expressed she understood the concerns raised and the fact she did not want to minimize the work that was being done. She opined it would be more appropriate to have a formal process so any classification seeking reconsideration could do so through an established procedure rather than through a Council meeting. Vice Mayor Hodge Washington stated her inclination to proceed with the motion as presented and direct HR to develop a formal process for reviewing and addressing such requests. She said this ensured progress while allowing HR to create a consistent method applicable across all departments.\n\nMr. Zuercher stated staff could provide the Council with a presentation of the current process and how it works.\n\nMr. Perkiser stated the City does have a formal process in place and each unit, as well as department directors, were capable of bringing forward the classifications they would like HR to study. He briefly spoke about the process and work done in this case.\n\nMayor Gallego stated we have learned that adjusting compensation in one area often means adjustments across several others and to ensure fairness, these changes should be made in a methodical and deliberate process. She opined making compensation decisions from the podium would set a challenging and difficult precedent.\n\nCouncilwoman Guardado asked if these classification pay range concerns had been brought up to HR by the employees.\n\nMr. Perkiser answered employees often did come forward with concerns, but HR had to balance several different factors, which occurred in this case.\n\nCouncilwoman Guardado expressed the need for a more streamlined process, specially for workers not represented by a labor union, with a goal that everyone feels they are being heard and brief the Council on what that would entail.\n\nCouncilwoman Pastor stated the reclassification process was not arbitrary as there was a formal reclassification process that employees could follow to request a review if they believed their current classification did not reflect the work they actually performed, they could move through the steps in the process and the final appeal was the Council, which ensured transparency and governance. She further stated the second point was about equity in the job duties as it appeared the employees believed there were existing classifications elsewhere in the City that already mirrored the work they performed. Councilwoman Pastor said if that classification truly aligned, same responsibilities, skill level and scope of work, it would make sense to consider whether their jobs should be placed in that category. She spoke about her experience with HR and reclassification, particularly in the community college arena, where similar roles were often consolidated or aligned across departments to avoid inconsistencies in duties, titles, or pay. Councilwoman Pastor opined the concern was the employees believe there were existing classifications that were similar, called differently, but performed the same job duties. She asked Mr. Perkiser to speak to that.\n\nMr. Perkiser said he understood the concern. He stated the team did review the other classifications, there are numerous nuances in each of these classifications, and the proposal before the Council today is what the team felt aligned best with the classification as it exists and with other classifications within the City.\n\nCouncilwoman Pastor stated what the classification incumbents were asking needed to be included in a motion with direction to staff in order to for the City to even reevaluate and explore the request and return to Council with the findings. She asked for confirmation that a motion was needed.\n\nMr. Zuercher confirmed Councilwoman Pastor was correct and if the desire of the Council was for the City to revisit this classification again, a motion was needed.\n\nCouncilwoman Hernandez expressed her agreement with Councilwoman Pastor and briefly spoke about her experience with reclassifications. She stated her support to reevaluate these two particular classifications. Councilwoman Hernandez asked clarification on the current formal process.\n\nMr. Perkiser clarified the formal process was an ongoing progress that evaluated not only the re-classification but also the pay grade and compensation for what was appropriate for a particular classification. He said all recommendations go to the Human Resources Committee (HRC) for the final recommendation to Council.\n\nCouncilwoman Hernandez opined she did not wish to place the current proposals on hold, but she heard the employees concerns raised today and she also would like to revisit this reclassification.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington restated the need for consistency in how the Council moves this forward and absent the employees coming before the Council today, she had no knowledge, nor was she briefed, this was an issue. She asked how this could be corrected in order to provide councilmembers insight as to the employee group's positions, research done by HR as well as discussions held regarding a reclassification prior to a Council meeting. Vice Mayor Hodge Washington stated willingness to move forward with the proposed reclassification as it stood today and asked Mr. Perkiser what was his proposal for a standardized process and communication on any other outstanding similar reclassification that have objections from an employee group in order for Council to make a decision based on the full information.\n\nMr. Perkiser answered staff would develop a plan on how HRC could communicate to Council about the work they do and come back to Council with recommendations.\n\nCouncilwoman Guardado expressed her agreement regarding the need for a process and also insisted on the need for the amendment to the motion. She stated the affected employees were not represented by a union and they should not need to come to Council for a resolution. Councilwoman Guardado expressed her understanding of what the employees were asking and it was her hope this would not become a necessity for workers that were not represented by a union and briefly spoke about the fact that the City was in the middle of labor negotiations with employee unions and groups. Councilwoman Guardado reiterated the need to make the amendment for this time as staff streamlined the process.\n\nMr. Perkiser clarified these positions were represented by a bargaining unit association.\n\nCouncilwoman O'Brien asked which bargaining unit were these employees represented by.\n\nMr. Perkiser answered they were represented by Unit 7 - Administrative, Supervisory, Professional & Technical Employee Association (ASPTEA).\n\nCouncilwoman Pastor made an exception to look at the two classifications.\n\nCity Attorney Julie Kriegh asked if Councilwoman Pastor wished to make a substitute motion.\n\nCouncilwoman Pastor stated she would like to make an exception to look at these two classifications as part of the motion if Vice Mayor Hodge Washington would be willing to accept, and if not, she was prepared to make a substitute motion.\n\nCity Attorney Kriegh advised if the maker of the motion on the table did not accept the amendment, which needs a second, a substitute motion would be necessary.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington asked for clarification on the language of the amendment to her motion.\n\nCouncilwomen Guardado stated the amendment is to bring this classification for staff to go back, look at it, speak with the individuals that are affected by this, look at the two classifications and come back just that classification with a new proposal.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington stated the need to identify which classification was being discussed and for the record, the classification was both the classification for senior center assistant and senior program supervisor.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington accepted the friendly amendment.\n\nCouncilwoman O'Brien asked Mr. Perkiser to explain the process the City go through to a determine and recommend a position reclassification.\n\nMr. Perkiser introduced HR Assistant Director Greg Carmichael who oversees classification and compensation.\n\nCouncilwoman O'Brien recalled the City completed a major, comprehensive classification and compensation study that led to many changes and since then, HR has been refining and adjusting certain classifications that needed some level of correction and a recommendation was brought to Council for approval. She asked what process HR goes through when looking at these additional classification adjustments.\n\nMr. Carmichael explained HR receives requests to review classifications or conduct market studies from labor groups, department directors, or employees through their chain of command and after receiving these requests, HR first analyzes other local cities' labor market to determine whether the City is competitive and then reviews internal alignment to ensure any regrade or reclassification will not disrupt job families, career paths, or internal structures. He said after combining the external market data and the internal alignment, HR develops a recommended adjustment if warranted as well as coordinates with the respective labor union and department leadership to reach an agreement on the proposed strategy, and then present that recommendation to the City Council for final determination.\n\nCouncilwoman O'Brien asked for confirmation that the data used was a market study from surrounding cities to ensure the City was competitive.\n\nMr. Carmichael answered that was correct.\n\nCouncilwoman O'Brien asked if the market study in this case showed the City was not competitive.\n\nMr. Carmichael answered HR found the City was generally competitive with the local labor market for this type of work.\n\nCouncilwoman O'Brien asked even though the City was generally competitive, staff was bringing an increase for this particular pay grade.\n\nMr. Carmichael responded Councilwoman O'Brien was correct. He stated the study showed the City was generally competitive in nature with local labor market, but HR identified the classification in question closely matched the responsibilities of a recreation coordinator, thus requiring an adjustment to the pay grade to better align similar job types within the City, which is the recommendation brought to Council today.\n\nCouncilwoman O'Brien asked for confirmation that even though the City's pay was competitive compared to local cities, the pay increase was proposed because the classification did not seam to align with other similar jobs within the City. She asked if it was accurate to say a pay increase was still considered necessary for internal equity.\n\nMr. Perkiser answered yes.\n\nCouncilwoman O'Brien asked if this proposal was presented to ASPTEA.\n\nMr. Perkiser answered yes, ASPTEA was involved in the process.\n\nCouncilwoman O'Brien asked if there were others that have disagreed with this proposal.\n\nMr. Perkiser answered he could not speak on the numbers who have disagreed as he did not have that information readily available.\n\nCouncilwoman O'Brien asked if it was part of the process to provide the HR data to Council. She further asked if she was correct in assuming an employee group had asked for this particular review.\n\nMr. Carmichael answered staff worked extensively with ASPTEA leadership to discuss all the factors being considered, including external competitiveness, internal alignment, and ramifications of the change. He stated staff felt this was a strong proposal that ASPTEA leadership as well as the department leadership would support and added the proposal was presented to the HRC before today's recommendation.\n\nCouncilwoman O'Brien asked what steps staff would take moving forward given the amendment to the motion on the floor.\n\nMr. Perkiser answered staff at the HR Classification and Compensation would have to go through the process described, and relook at the data collected including the internal alignment.\n\nCouncilwoman O'Brien asked if staff would go back to HRC as well before making a recommendation to Council.\n\nMr. Perkiser answered yes.\n\nCouncilwoman O'Brien asked Councilwoman Guardado if the intent of her amendment was to have staff go back to through the process, and what was her direction if after the review the assessment confirms this is the correct pay grade.\n\nCouncilwoman Guardado stated staff would brief Councilmembers before a proposal is brought back to the dais with the intention to reach a consensus among Councilmembers on how to move forward.\n\nMr. Zuercher stated his understanding the motion would be to approve this item as recommended in order for the increases to not be held up and begin a new assessment process with the intention to present the data to the Council at a future date. He said it was possible that staff would come to the same conclusion or reach a different one, but the information would be very clearly presented and Councilmembers would be briefed beforehand and a more fully layout of the process would be presented as well.\n\nCouncilwoman Guardado answered yes.\n\nCouncilwoman Stark urged staff to go to the senior centers and observe the level of work and responsibility the position takes on and opined it would help with the reassessment.\n\nCouncilwoman O'Brien thanked Mr. Zuercher for the clarification. She stated Council needed to see the data as this was more than just a conversation with employees. She asked if staff looked at total compensation or just pay when comparing the City with other local jurisdictions.\n\nMr. Carmichael answered for studies that were specific to a classification or job family, staff primarily looked at base compensation when comparing to other municipalities. He stated when comparing with the private sector total compensation was a more robust package to review.\n\nCouncilwoman O'Brien asked if the City's benefit packages were not compared with those of other municipalities.\n\nMr. Perkiser answered for the purpose of these studies, staff looked at the base wage only.\n\nCouncilwoman O'Brien stated her understanding that base wages was the current metric used for compensation studies, but opined relying only on base wage was not sufficient. She emphasized benefits could vary greatly between municipalities and could significantly impact overall value of a compensation package. Councilwoman O'Brien reported concerns about a motion that would mandate changes or forced the issue before the HRC. She stated her preference was for HR to reevaluate, and if there are no changes to the recommendation, the process should simply end there.\n\nMr. Zuercher confirmed the intention of his statement was for HR to reevaluate, and if there are no changes to the recommendation, the reevaluation process would end there. He stated this will allow staff the opportunity to return with the necessary data and walk Council through each step of the assessment, show what information was used, how it was evaluated, whether any factors supported or not a higher classification, and all factors will be clearly laid out. He said the goal is to give Council a full understanding of the reclassification and HR process, including how the final recommendation was developed.\n\nCouncilwoman O'Brien stated with that clarification she was prepared to accept the friendly amendment.\n\nCouncilwoman O'Brien accepted the friendly amendment to the motion.\n\nCouncilwoman O'Brien asked that moving forward, and with the support of her colleagues, staff start looking at the entire compensation package, not just base pay, when reevaluating a job classification.\n\nMayor Gallego opined Councilwoman O'Brien's statement was consistent with Vice Mayor Hodge Washington comments.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington clarified that Councilwoman Stark's suggestion to observe employees at their work sites might be well intended, but it would be appropriate only if it is done as a consistent part of the process for all classifications. She emphasized the goal of the motion was to simply restart the review process for the two specific positions based on the arguments presented and how the duties of those positions compared to similar classifications. Vice Mayor Hodge Washington stressed the motion does not ask HR to go beyond the existing procedures, and after the review is completed, HR would brief the Council on the results.\n\nMayor Gallego expressed her agreement with Councilwoman O'Brien as to total compensation matters, as the City has excellent benefits including many peer cities do not offer. She stated the City should also take into account the merit system, which many peer cities also do not offer.\n\nAssistant City Manager Lori Bays stated the City publishes an annual summarized document for each and every employee listing their total compensation package, including salary, one-time payments, overtime, benefits, pension payments that were paid by the City, and health insurance payments that were paid on their behalf. She said some employees may not realize that information is available to them and encouraged all employees to review the document.\n\nMayor Gallego reported she worked with an employer that would mail that information to employees. She recalled a few years ago, Council spent a lot of time discussing electrician pay and asked if the City had just considered base pay.\n\nMs. Bays explained the job market has been highly competitive in the last several years and the City has had to compete with both base pay as well as total compensation. She stated currently, the job market has slowed down and the City could focus more on looking at the total compensation package and advertising what the benefits are outside the base pay. Ms. Bays opined the City still needed to focus on base pay to remain competitive in the labor market, but also needed to point out the total compensation packet it offered.\n\nCouncilwoman O'Brien clarified she did not say the City should not have base pay as the focus, but total compensation was available and was an important comparison point.\n\nCouncilwoman Guardado opined both base wage and benefits should be considered, but warned that focusing only on the full benefits package could be misleading. She noted that many younger employees focused on higher base pay to support their families and not always prioritized benefits and asked for data on how newly hired employees were actually enrolling in the full benefits package. Councilwoman Guardado commented long tenured employees may value the comprehensive benefit package more, but attracting new employees often depended on offering competitive base wages and she stated she was curious to see the breakdown to better understand what newer employees were choosing as well as if the benefits aligned with their needs.\n\nMs. Bays stated staff would gather that information. She restated the need to look at both base wage as well as total compensation.\n\nPrior to her vote, Councilwoman Pastor stated she was voting yes, and thanked the employees for advocating for themselves. She noted the back-and-forth discussion was valuable and helped improve the system.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62833,"agenda_number":"24","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Authorization to Accept Carnegie Corporation of New York $10,000 Commemorative Gift to Phoenix Public Library (Ordinance S-52616) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0052","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\nMayor Gallego introduced this item.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington made a motion to approve Item 24. Councilwoman O'Brien seconded the motion.\n\nMayor Gallego stated this gift was part of the America 250 celebration and will support the Carnegie Library's participation in this national milestone. She noted the library opened in 1908 and was among the City's earliest libraries and this was one of several ways the City and the state were marking America 250.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62834,"agenda_number":"26","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Artist Design, Fabrication, and Installation Contract for The Sueño Park Public Art Project (Ordinance S-52620) - District 4","matter_file":"26-0117","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\nMayor Gallego introduced this item.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington made a motion to approve Item 26. Councilwoman Pastor seconded the motion.\n\nCouncilwoman Pastor stated Sueno Park was a important gathering space in the community and expressed her excitement to see the new investment in west side of District 4 and this project ensured art and culture investments reached all parts of the City, not just the central core. She said the installation would include features like shade or seating to enhance the daily experience for families and residents. Councilwoman Pastor indicated her appreciation for the selected artist, Joe Ray of the Sombra Collaborative, who is known for colorful, community-focused work. She also thanked the Office of Arts and Culture and everyone involved in the community-driven selection process, ensuring the project reflects the neighborhood it serves.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62840,"agenda_number":"30","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Pilot Simulator Training Contract - RFA 24-0390 - Request for Award (Ordinance S-52618) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0085","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\nMayor Gallego introduced this item.\n\nCouncilman Robinson noted Assistant Police Chief Brian Lee and Commander Brian Riggan were coming to the table. He opined the pilot simulator training was important and asked Chief Lee to elaborate on why the simulator training was important and necessary.\n\nAssistant Police Chief Lee stated the use of simulator training and flight avionics has been used for decades and it has also been recognized as a national best practice that allows pilots to practice basic, advanced, and intermediate emergency procedures safely and in a cost effectively way. He added it offered controlled environments to work through high risk scenarios that could endanger both pilots and aircraft in real life as well as it helped pilots adapt to different aircraft and maintain critical skills for operating expensive equipment\n\nCouncilman Robinson communicated he has spent time with the Air Support Unit and highlighted how dramatically the unit's capabilities have expanded over the years and stressed the ongoing training was a direct investment in safety. He encouraged others to also spend time with the Air Support Unit to fully appreciate its mission and contributions. Councilman Robinson asked Commander Riggan to provide a brief overview of what the Air Support Unit did beyond the simulator training, the platforms that were available to them and how far reaching they were and what it actually did in general.\n\nCommander Riggan explained the unit conducted surveillance missions to track violent offenders, supported coordinated arrests with specialized teams, performed transport missions for detectives and evidence, and sometimes preserved crucial evidence by flying it directly to maintain chain of custody. He stated they evaluated each mission for cost efficiency and choose either department aircraft or commercial travel as appropriate. He added their aircrafts provided far reaching support to patrol operations across the City, enhancing safety, response capability, and investigative effectiveness.\n\nCouncilman Robinson stressed the importance of this information to understand the full mission of the Air Support Unit and why training is critical. He stated the unit's work was extensive and the time he spent with them offered a deeper appreciation for their capabilities and accomplishments. Councilman Robinson noted training was fundamentally an investment in safety, and no one would disagree with its value. He further expressed gratitude for the unit's hospitality during his visit and reaffirmed the department was moving forward in a positive direction on many fronts.\n\nCouncilman Robinson made a motion to approve Item 30. Councilwoman O'Brien seconded the motion.\n\nCouncilwoman Hernandez communicated during previous formal meetings she has learned more about how the aircrafts are used, the upkeep costs, how they are deployed, and what their training entails. She expressed her understanding the department was requesting Council approval to fund a flight simulator for its pilots.\n\nAssistant Police Chief Lee confirmed Councilwoman Hernandez understanding was correct. He stated the request today was to fund the purchase of simulator training, which was provided by Simcoe Aviation.\n\nCouncilwoman Hernandez asked about the aircrafts the department owned and what the training be appropriate for.\n\nAssistant Police Chief Lee answered the department owned two aircrafts that this particular simulation training was specific to.\n\nCouncilwoman Hernandez questioned if there was any other relevant information to share.\n\nAssistant Police Chief Lee explained the Air Support Unit selected which aircraft to use based entirely on the mission’s requirements. He stated for long distance transportation of people or evidence, a fixed wing aircraft was the practical choice and when continuous monitoring over an active scene was needed, the patrol helicopters were used, as they were the daily workhorses for patrol related operations.\n\nCouncilwoman Hernandez reported she had a constituent ask her if the Police Department considered the use of drones instead of piloted airplanes and would there be a cost saving for doing so.\n\nAssistant Police Chief Lee explained that during development of Phoenix’s Unmanned Aerial System program, a common misconception was that drones would replace helicopters, and in reality, they serve different purposes. He stated drones operate at low altitudes, can hold stationary positions for long periods at significantly lower cost, and are used for investigative support, special event management, and tactical support operations. He added drones allow officers to assess dangerous situations before placing personnel at risk. He said helicopters and drones complement each other, and neither is intended to replace the other.\n\nCouncilwoman Hernandez asked if Assistant Police Chief Lee could provide the cost breakdown for the entire Air Support Unit to her office, to include the cost to purchase, maintain, and the per hour cost to have these aircrafts deployed.\n\nAssistant Police Chief Lee answered yes.\n\nPrior to her vote, Councilwoman Hernandez opined investing in Police aviation diverted resources from critical community needs. Councilwoman Hernandez further explained her reasons for why she was voting no.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"No"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62865,"agenda_number":"36","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Gillig, LLC - PTD22-001 - Amendment - Public Transit Department and Aviation Department (Ordinance S-52625) - Citywide","matter_file":"26-0324","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\nMayor Gallego introduced this item.\n\nVice Mayor Hodge Washington made a motion to approve Item 36. Councilwoman O'Brien seconded the motion.\n\nNOTE: Councilwoman Pastor temporarily left the voting body.\n\nDianne Barker spoke in support of this item.\n\nNOTE: Councilwoman Pastor returned to the voting body.\n\nBlue Crowley spoke about public transit in the City of Phoenix.\n\nMayor Gallego advised Mr. Crowley this item was whether or not to purchase buses for the airport.\n\nMayor Gallego explained that even though this item was to purchase buses for the airport, it would use the same contract the Public Transit Department used to buy buses. She expressed excitement to introduce electric buses and noted one was displayed at City Hall today. Mayor Gallego noted these buses were quiet, more sustainable, pleasant to drive, reduced emission, and improved rider experience which made them a strong option for airport operations. She clarified the SkyTrain remained the primary system, but by having electric buses provided valuable flexibility and continuity if any challenges arose with the SkyTrain.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62845,"agenda_number":"37","agenda_number_source":"field","title":"Apply for U.S. Department of Transportation Better Utilizing Investments to Leverage Development Grant Opportunity for Federal Fiscal Year 2025-26 - Federal Bipartisan Infrastructure Law Funding (Ordinance S-52605) - District 2","matter_file":"25-2792","matter_type":"Ordinance-S","action":"adopted","passed":"Pass","consent":false,"minutes_note":"Discussion\nMayor Gallego introduced this item.\n\nCouncilman Waring made a motion to approve Item 37. Councilwoman O'Brien seconded the motion.\n\nBlue Crowley spoke about the public transit system around the north Phoenix area.\n\nMayor Gallego advised Mr. Crowley this item was whether or not to build a bridge at Mayo.\n\nCouncilman Waring expressed his appreciation for all input and opined this was the first time he heard about a transit desert. He stated this item was fantastic improvement to District 2.\n\nDianne Barker spoke in support of transit infrastructure.\n\nMayor Gallego stated this project involved applying for a federal BUILD grant to support costly infrastructure improvements in the Mayo Hospital area and this investment would enable the continuance of its major expansion, which has already brought life-saving care and significant economic growth to Phoenix. She noted Arizona State University (ASU) was also expanding in the region and attracting innovative companies. Mayor Gallego reported this was a public-private partnership led by Councilman Waring, ASU, Mayo, and hopefully the federal government. She stated the partnership would contribute to the infrastructure cost, and City leaders were optimistic the United States Department of Transportation (USDOT) would also partner become a partner in this project.\n\nCouncilman Waring stated Mayo's expansion has been remarkable, potentially making the Phoenix campus even bigger than the one in Rochester, MN. He said the progress reflected the strong market and momentum in north Phoenix.\n\nMayor Gallego recognized Councilman Waring for the extensive work he has done on floodplain and street improvements in the area.","votes":[{"person":"Betty Guardado","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Anna Hernandez","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kesha Hodge Washington","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Laura Pastor","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kevin Robinson","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Debra Stark","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Jim Waring","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Ann O'Brien","value":"Yes"},{"person":"Kate Gallego","value":"Yes"}],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62855,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"PLANNING AND ZONING MATTERS","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":null,"votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62858,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"REPORTS FROM CITY MANAGER, COMMITTEES OR CITY OFFICIALS","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":"None.","votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62859,"agenda_number":"000","agenda_number_source":"title-rule","title":"000 CITIZEN COMMENTS","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":"City Attorney Julie Kriegh stated during Citizen Comment, members of the public may address the City Council for up to three minutes on issues of interest or concern to them. She advised the Arizona Open Meeting Law permits the City Council to listen to the comment, but prohibits council members from discussing or acting on the matters presented.\n\nBlue Crowley spoke about bus deserts, regional public transportation and light-rail expenditures, and the bus system in Phoenix.\n\nMohagany Seveira spoke about the unsheltered and the City's homelessness strategy.\n\nDianne Barker spoke about the transit and light-rail systems.\n\nLee Ellis II thanked the City for the improvements at the Safe Outdoor Space campus and reported additional improvements were still needed.\n\nDavid Morgan thanked the City for the work being done to assist the homeless population.\n\nElizabeth Venable provided testimony regarding her mental health disorder in a effort for people to better understand mental health and reduce the stigma that comes with it.\n\nTeresa Hill thanked the Police Department for its efforts to reduce crimes in her neighborhood and spoke about the homeless situation Citywide.","votes":[],"roll_call":[]},{"event_item_id":62860,"agenda_number":null,"agenda_number_source":"none","title":"ADJOURN","matter_file":null,"matter_type":null,"action":null,"passed":null,"consent":false,"minutes_note":"There being no further business to come before the Council, Mayor Gallego declared the meeting adjourned at 4:26 p.m.\n\n___________________________\nMAYOR\n\nATTEST:\n\n__________________________\nCITY CLERK\n\nMW\n\nCERTIFICATION\n\nI hereby certify that the foregoing minutes are a true and correct copy of the minutes of the formal session of the City Council of the City of Phoenix held on the 18th day of February, 2026. I further certify that the meeting was duly called and held and that a quorum was present.\n\nDated this [NUMBER]th day of [MONTH], [YEAR].\n\n__________________________\nCITY CLERK","votes":[],"roll_call":[]}],"coverage":{"lines":1283,"speaking_seconds":6133.1,"seconds_by_role":{"member":2917.5,"staff":534.2,"official":48.1,"public":933.9,"unclassified":1699.3},"named_seconds":3499.8,"named_share":0.5707,"chapters_found":9,"agenda_items_acted_on":49},"build":{"builder_version":"0.1.0","built_at":"2026-10-20T19:26:09Z","problems":[],"inputs":{"recordings":[{"source_ref":"part 1 of 1","content_sha256":"d73937f720f815608825c400bb8a4b476f54fc06e0298f52406f2bec0d6f6324"}],"agenda_file_sha256":"50d7436a661471179f6e17f70959c358401b331795c9d330e685a9d1158ae7cb","config_pack_sha256":"5056771490d823a6d33bdb79169e991d17ffc31da27d800ac79d9d7b7a82bfeb"},"checks":{"chapter_announcements_skipped":0,"roll_call_suggestions":8,"name_suggestions_from_minutes":0,"captions":{"source":"City of Phoenix captions, Granicus clip 693","cues":326,"anchors":5,"median_shift_s":null,"unaligned":983,"sha256":"b1cbd32f4a137186425448f83be1ab02ddd196b7b9330ee85269b8a50df22f4c"},"lines_flagged_language":3,"video_offset_check":{"source":"the video's own captions","shift_s":49.95,"anchors":11397,"spread_s":0.11,"recorded_offset_s":50.0,"difference_s":-0.05,"agrees":true}},"freeze":{"approved_by":"jthacker 2026-10-20","frozen_at":"2026-10-20T19:27:02Z","previous_version":null}},"publication":{"exported_at":"2026-10-22T05:49:15Z","from_version":1,"from_sha256":"5b2e9775b7079de957a996399ef0ff0a1bf2f35cb24d0023a8a381f169014475","fixes_applied":8}}